One of the pioneers of investigative journalism aka Muckraking, this compilation of articles written by Ida Tarbell for McClure, shredding Standard Oil Company and John Rockefeller's monopolistic business practice is a magnificent work.
By the beginning of 20th century, the anti-competitive practices of businesses across various industries had already started drawing flak from the nation and Government authorities. A definitive push came in the form of series of the articles written by Ida Tarbell, which was a prominent contributing factor in the eventual dissolution of the Standard Oil trust in 1911. The articles completed the transformation of public image of John Rockefeller as a national villain.
On closer perusal of the articles it becomes evident that Ida Tarbell did not write the articles to demonize Rockefeller. Her work is based on detailed research, court transcripts and personal interviews. It would be in incorrect to say that the author presented her views with a prejudice since the due credit has been accorded to Standard Oil for its business acumen and reprimand to producers association for their continued lack of good judgment.
At the hindsight, we now know that Standard Oil was the monopoly which worked among several other attempted combinations of various sorts which did not work due to greed and lesser acumen of its participants. It is interesting to read how the role of railways in unfair business practices was downplayed, while all the focus of hatred was channelized to Standard Oil.
Ida Tarbell has brilliantly argued that the object does not justify the means, that just by saying "it is business" does not write off all immoral, unlawful, anti-competitive and unfair activities to earn profits. All the rationale for the activities purported to be for the good of oil industry, price stability, foreign market and everything else does not account for the wrongs inflicted on countless number of small competitors driven out of the business.
We will never know what would have been the state of oil industry without the monopolistic years of Standard Oil. History has shown us that such huge amount untethered power always leads to promotion of self-interest at the expense of others. We will also never know what would have become of the Standard Oil if the trust was not dissolved. We do know that the off-springs of the slain dragon, continue to breathe fire to this day in form of Exxon, Mobil, Chevron and others.
This book gives a good view of the early years of the oil industry in US but does not go beyond that for obvious reasons. The story of oil, with or without Standard Oil trust, continues to be full of turmoil. It is good supplement to get a holistic view of the study of oil and energy. For readers interested in Oil, I would strongly recommend the truly seminal work by Daniel Yergin in his book the Prize.