What do you think?
Rate this book
Gideon Green - Das Leben ist nicht schwarz-weiß
Eigentlich hat Gideon seine Karriere als Detektiv ja längst an den Nagel gehängt. Damals, nach den Vorkommnissen auf dem Schuldach. Doch dann steht plötzlich Lily vor der Tür, die mal sowas wie seine beste Freundin war. Sie ist da einer Sache auf der Spur und dafür braucht sie Gideons Hilfe. Und weil eben niemand so ein gutes Gespür hat für Verbrechen wie Gideon, kann er quasi nicht Nein sagen. Aber mit wem haben sie sich da angelegt? Als es schließlich um einen echten Mord geht und Gideon eine Verschwörung bis in die höchsten Kreise der Stadt wittert, muss er feststellen, dass das Leben so gar nichts mit einem Film noir zu tun hat.
383 pages, Hardcover
First published May 17, 2022
20 people are currently reading
3265 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 148 reviews
Read
November 20, 2021Hi! I’m Katie, I wrote this book (releasing 5/17/22, available for request on Edelweiss/Netgalley now) and I’m reviewing it because Goodreads allows me to do that!
FAQs (THAT NO ONE HAS ACTUALLY ASKED ME YET):
Q: What is this book about?
A: This book is about Gideon Green, former child detective, who comes out of retirement to help his ex-best friend and solve a brand new case. It features many things I love, including film noir, school newspapers, and In-N-Out Burger. But most of all, this is a story about stories: their power, their limitations, and the infinite possibilities in writing yourself a new one.
Q: Is it a mystery, or is it a comedy?
A: Both!
Q: Was writing this book a vital lifeline for you during the pandemic, or a cause of greater despair?
A: Also both!
Q: How many 1940s film references will I, the reader, be subjected to?
A: Countless!
And since no book is complete without a shiny sticker that you can’t peel off without ruining the dust jacket, I’ve created this one just for you, Goodreads friends:
FAQs (THAT NO ONE HAS ACTUALLY ASKED ME YET):
Q: What is this book about?
A: This book is about Gideon Green, former child detective, who comes out of retirement to help his ex-best friend and solve a brand new case. It features many things I love, including film noir, school newspapers, and In-N-Out Burger. But most of all, this is a story about stories: their power, their limitations, and the infinite possibilities in writing yourself a new one.
Q: Is it a mystery, or is it a comedy?
A: Both!
Q: Was writing this book a vital lifeline for you during the pandemic, or a cause of greater despair?
A: Also both!
Q: How many 1940s film references will I, the reader, be subjected to?
A: Countless!
And since no book is complete without a shiny sticker that you can’t peel off without ruining the dust jacket, I’ve created this one just for you, Goodreads friends:
April 6, 2022
What an absolute five star gem of a book - “Gideon Green in Black and White” was, it literally knocked my socks off, I was so blown away with it. I loved the sound of the premise and within a couple of pages of being introduced to Gideon Green, I just knew I’d picked up the right book to read.
Sixteen year old, Gideon Green’s short-lived run as the locally famous boy detective, ended when middle school started and his best friend along with everyone else moved on. Now, officially ‘retired’ he still loves watching his collection of film noirs and wearing his trench coat and fedora. However, his unique behaviour and attitude, often leaves him sitting alone at school at the mercy of bullies. Until one day, Lily turns up on his doorstep needing his help. Unable to turn down a case, Gideon goes ‘undercover’ with Lily, working on the Herald - the school newspaper. However, when he meets Tess the editor in chief, he starts to have feelings he hasn’t experienced before and realises he might not want to spend his life alone. As Lily and Gideon discover the case is bigger than they could have anticipated, Gideon decides to take a few risks and it often ends with Gideon being taken back to his dad by the police. Forced to not pursue the ‘investigation’ any further, how long is it before Gideon can no longer sit in his bedroom and not strive for truth?
I just loved how Gideon and Lily worked together, often having different opinions but still enjoying being back together as best friends. Gideon with his idiosyncrasies is a truly wonderful character and his little interludes of how scenes would be, if his life was a film noir were adorable. This book is as much mystery as comedy and the author Katie Henry, has done really well incorporating a well thought out mystery mixed with comedy, in an exceptional character driven novel, which also focuses on family, friendship and love.
I actually feel at a bit of a loss now I’ve finished the book, I genuinely felt a part of the story and I’m actually missing Gideon very much!
Katie Henry is the American author of several novels and she writes for and about her favourite demographic of people: teenagers. As an adult, I found the book entertaining for any aged reader and hope beyond hope we see more of Gideon in the future!
#GideonGreenInBlackAndWhite - 5 stars
Sixteen year old, Gideon Green’s short-lived run as the locally famous boy detective, ended when middle school started and his best friend along with everyone else moved on. Now, officially ‘retired’ he still loves watching his collection of film noirs and wearing his trench coat and fedora. However, his unique behaviour and attitude, often leaves him sitting alone at school at the mercy of bullies. Until one day, Lily turns up on his doorstep needing his help. Unable to turn down a case, Gideon goes ‘undercover’ with Lily, working on the Herald - the school newspaper. However, when he meets Tess the editor in chief, he starts to have feelings he hasn’t experienced before and realises he might not want to spend his life alone. As Lily and Gideon discover the case is bigger than they could have anticipated, Gideon decides to take a few risks and it often ends with Gideon being taken back to his dad by the police. Forced to not pursue the ‘investigation’ any further, how long is it before Gideon can no longer sit in his bedroom and not strive for truth?
I just loved how Gideon and Lily worked together, often having different opinions but still enjoying being back together as best friends. Gideon with his idiosyncrasies is a truly wonderful character and his little interludes of how scenes would be, if his life was a film noir were adorable. This book is as much mystery as comedy and the author Katie Henry, has done really well incorporating a well thought out mystery mixed with comedy, in an exceptional character driven novel, which also focuses on family, friendship and love.
I actually feel at a bit of a loss now I’ve finished the book, I genuinely felt a part of the story and I’m actually missing Gideon very much!
Katie Henry is the American author of several novels and she writes for and about her favourite demographic of people: teenagers. As an adult, I found the book entertaining for any aged reader and hope beyond hope we see more of Gideon in the future!
#GideonGreenInBlackAndWhite - 5 stars
March 25, 2023
J’ai kiffééé ! C’était hyper addictif, l’ambiance est incroyable et les personnages très attachants. Il y a un côté à la Veronica Mars que j’ai évidemment adoré et ça se dévore, vraiment : à lire !
March 31, 2023
Gideon gets on your nerves slightly but that didn't stop me from finishing this book. Great plot and I was drawn in from the first couple of pages.
May 26, 2022
3.25 stars
I liked the main story of Gideon and Lily investigating an uptick in crime and stumbling upon a murder. Teen sleuths are one of my favorite plot points, especially when they figure out things that authorities don't. Gideon is great at noticing details and remembers everything he sees. Watching him put together clues was fun and something I wish I could do.
Gideon himself wasn't always likeable and got on my nerves. I don't understand how he can be so smart at some things and completely clueless in others. He can rude, makes leaps without double checking his facts, and thinks he's always the victim. I did feel bad that his relationship with his dad wasn't great and wanted to see that repaired, especially since his mom is gone.
I also thought the romance lacked chemistry and I didn't really care if it was there or not. Gideon and Tessa seemed to get together quickly and it just kind of faded into the background.
I would read another Gideon Green story if the author decides on a sequel. Maybe he'll be a bit more mature in the future?
I liked the main story of Gideon and Lily investigating an uptick in crime and stumbling upon a murder. Teen sleuths are one of my favorite plot points, especially when they figure out things that authorities don't. Gideon is great at noticing details and remembers everything he sees. Watching him put together clues was fun and something I wish I could do.
Gideon himself wasn't always likeable and got on my nerves. I don't understand how he can be so smart at some things and completely clueless in others. He can rude, makes leaps without double checking his facts, and thinks he's always the victim. I did feel bad that his relationship with his dad wasn't great and wanted to see that repaired, especially since his mom is gone.
I also thought the romance lacked chemistry and I didn't really care if it was there or not. Gideon and Tessa seemed to get together quickly and it just kind of faded into the background.
I would read another Gideon Green story if the author decides on a sequel. Maybe he'll be a bit more mature in the future?
July 24, 2023
This book was such a good read for what it was, a simple, fun and lighthearted read. There are complex aspects touched upon but they are never explored in a any deep way which work for the story and the plot. I had fun reading this book and I was able to read the whole thing in just one day. If you are looking for a light read and something that will keep you entertained for a couple of hours and if you are into noir films then this is the book for you.
March 3, 2022
I’m so incredibly grateful to Katie Henry for sending me an ARC.
Heretics Anonymous, Henry’s debut novel, has been my favorite of hers up until this point. Now I’m not so sure if Gideon Green may have dethroned it, but I refuse to decide. They can both live happily as my top two picks from her so far.
Gideon Green in Black and White features a main character who is very passionate about film noir and getting to the truth. In this book, we follow Gideon while he attempts to get to the truth of a mystery as well as uncover some truths within his family.
Something KH does so well is nuance. Her books are full of it. This one had such a great message about telling your own story as well as the truth not always being a black and white thing.
KH is also fantastic at writing relatable characters. Each of her novels contains something I can relate to. In GG, I related SO MUCH to both Gideon and his dad. In regards to Gideon, I can totally understand feeling like everything you say and do is going to be criticized or shot down. In regards to his father, I understand realizing you’re too hard on your child and fearing they hate you. I’m ALSO the parent of a very Gideon-like child, so all of this had such an emotional impact on me when the two characters were forced to talk about their challenges. I like that KH’s characters aren’t perfect, but they’re given opportunities to grow and learn and change.
The mystery aspect of this novel was very well done as well. I never would’ve pegged Henry as a mystery writer, but it was incredibly well thought-out and managed to take some very surprising twists and turns.
Admittedly, it took me about halfway through the book to feel invested, but once I was there, there was no going back. Like I said, I refuse to decide if this is my favorite by her or not, but it’s definitely in the top two. KH could never write anything that I wouldn’t drop every thing to read.
Heretics Anonymous, Henry’s debut novel, has been my favorite of hers up until this point. Now I’m not so sure if Gideon Green may have dethroned it, but I refuse to decide. They can both live happily as my top two picks from her so far.
Gideon Green in Black and White features a main character who is very passionate about film noir and getting to the truth. In this book, we follow Gideon while he attempts to get to the truth of a mystery as well as uncover some truths within his family.
Something KH does so well is nuance. Her books are full of it. This one had such a great message about telling your own story as well as the truth not always being a black and white thing.
KH is also fantastic at writing relatable characters. Each of her novels contains something I can relate to. In GG, I related SO MUCH to both Gideon and his dad. In regards to Gideon, I can totally understand feeling like everything you say and do is going to be criticized or shot down. In regards to his father, I understand realizing you’re too hard on your child and fearing they hate you. I’m ALSO the parent of a very Gideon-like child, so all of this had such an emotional impact on me when the two characters were forced to talk about their challenges. I like that KH’s characters aren’t perfect, but they’re given opportunities to grow and learn and change.
The mystery aspect of this novel was very well done as well. I never would’ve pegged Henry as a mystery writer, but it was incredibly well thought-out and managed to take some very surprising twists and turns.
Admittedly, it took me about halfway through the book to feel invested, but once I was there, there was no going back. Like I said, I refuse to decide if this is my favorite by her or not, but it’s definitely in the top two. KH could never write anything that I wouldn’t drop every thing to read.
May 22, 2022
Katie Henry has become a really solid go-to author for me, so I was super excited to see that she had a new book coming out! Gideon Green was wonderfully unique, and I found Gideon himself to be a truly one-of-a-kind character whose story I found myself really enjoying.
Gideon is.... he's not your typical teenage boy. He's high key obsessed with old noir movies from the '30s and '40s, he wears a trench coat, and he's pretty cool with being alone pretty much always. In an interesting turn of events, his former best friend Lily asks him for help, which he finds himself agreeing to. In doing so, he has to join the school paper. This not only appeases Lily, but Gideon's dad who has insisted he find something to do other than sitting in his room watching century old movies.
Gideon fancies himself a bit of a detective, like those he spends his time watching. He even had solved a case as a kid. Thing is, Gideon is really smart, and a great detective... but he isn't so great at knowing when to shut up or slow down. So, as you can imagine, things won't exactly go smoothly in this case, either. The case, for me personally, took a backstage to Gideon's personal story. I loved Gideon getting out and rekindling friendships and making new ones, seeing him giving the school paper his all. I also loved Gideon's relationship with his father, and how both men were trying so hard to navigate their bond. It was clear that they loved each other deeply, they just didn't know how to do it for a while. The development of that relationship was kind of perfect.
I also loved Gideon finally figuring out more about himself. He wallowed, for a really long time, about some embarrassing situations years ago. Instead of facing them, he retreated into himself, and I think Lily bringing him into the school paper was the best thing that ever happened to him. Sure, he made some mistakes. Okay fine, he made loads of mistakes. But as the story went along, Gideon's motivations became more altruistic, and he really learned and grew as a person, gaining a much better understanding of who he is and how he treats the people around him.
And while the book tackled some more serious issues (and some crime), it was so very funny and clever, that I really enjoyed reading the story, even if I wasn't quite as invested on the outcome of the investigation. I was wholly invested in Gideon.
Bottom Line: Gideon Green definitely delivered with the author's usual blend of unique subject matter combined with really heartfelt characters and a ton of humor.
You can find the full review and all the fancy and/or randomness that accompanies it at It Starts at Midnight
Gideon is.... he's not your typical teenage boy. He's high key obsessed with old noir movies from the '30s and '40s, he wears a trench coat, and he's pretty cool with being alone pretty much always. In an interesting turn of events, his former best friend Lily asks him for help, which he finds himself agreeing to. In doing so, he has to join the school paper. This not only appeases Lily, but Gideon's dad who has insisted he find something to do other than sitting in his room watching century old movies.
Gideon fancies himself a bit of a detective, like those he spends his time watching. He even had solved a case as a kid. Thing is, Gideon is really smart, and a great detective... but he isn't so great at knowing when to shut up or slow down. So, as you can imagine, things won't exactly go smoothly in this case, either. The case, for me personally, took a backstage to Gideon's personal story. I loved Gideon getting out and rekindling friendships and making new ones, seeing him giving the school paper his all. I also loved Gideon's relationship with his father, and how both men were trying so hard to navigate their bond. It was clear that they loved each other deeply, they just didn't know how to do it for a while. The development of that relationship was kind of perfect.
I also loved Gideon finally figuring out more about himself. He wallowed, for a really long time, about some embarrassing situations years ago. Instead of facing them, he retreated into himself, and I think Lily bringing him into the school paper was the best thing that ever happened to him. Sure, he made some mistakes. Okay fine, he made loads of mistakes. But as the story went along, Gideon's motivations became more altruistic, and he really learned and grew as a person, gaining a much better understanding of who he is and how he treats the people around him.
And while the book tackled some more serious issues (and some crime), it was so very funny and clever, that I really enjoyed reading the story, even if I wasn't quite as invested on the outcome of the investigation. I was wholly invested in Gideon.
Bottom Line: Gideon Green definitely delivered with the author's usual blend of unique subject matter combined with really heartfelt characters and a ton of humor.
You can find the full review and all the fancy and/or randomness that accompanies it at It Starts at Midnight
May 31, 2022
This book was an interesting mix. I really enjoyed the mystery aspect, but I hate the hard push on including LGBTQ in YA books. I felt like it didn’t add much to the story and was essentially a distraction.
March 13, 2024
Hi Again,
My bookcases have arrived and we are slowly assembling them and moving all the books over. With that comes an unhaul. I have been slowly looking over all my books as I pull them from my shelves and making unhaul piles as well as donation piles. While I work on this I am trying to listen to audiobooks, one of the audiobooks that I currently have on my Libby is Gideon Green in Black and White. I went into this audiobook having little to no idea what I got myself into and I ended up having a great time!
SPOILERS AHEAD
Gideon was a genius boy detective, with his best friend at his side, they solved a bunch of local crimes. Flash forward several years and now they are teenagers, no longer solving crimes and no longer friends. But one day his ex-best friend (Lily) shows up needing Gideon’s help with a mystery and even though he is angry with her for moving on from their friendship, he wants to help. So Gideon and Lily get back up to sleuthing. However, Gideon also has to join a school activity, and sleuthing with Lily does not count, so he joins the school paper with her. Now they are back to spending a ton of time together and trying to solve the mystery but they quickly find that this mystery is a much bigger case.
I absolutely loved Gideon Green! I really had no idea what I was expecting from this book but it was absolutely wonderful. I devoured this book in nearly one sitting when I got away from my PC, I listened on my phone and then moved to my physical copy of the book. This was a fun story of mystery, suspense, friendship, and family relationships with a splash of potential romance. Katie Henry did an amazing job with this book and I am incredibly excited to read whatever she writes next (although I would not complain if we got to see Gideon again very soon).
Goodreads Rating: 5 Stars
My bookcases have arrived and we are slowly assembling them and moving all the books over. With that comes an unhaul. I have been slowly looking over all my books as I pull them from my shelves and making unhaul piles as well as donation piles. While I work on this I am trying to listen to audiobooks, one of the audiobooks that I currently have on my Libby is Gideon Green in Black and White. I went into this audiobook having little to no idea what I got myself into and I ended up having a great time!
SPOILERS AHEAD
Gideon was a genius boy detective, with his best friend at his side, they solved a bunch of local crimes. Flash forward several years and now they are teenagers, no longer solving crimes and no longer friends. But one day his ex-best friend (Lily) shows up needing Gideon’s help with a mystery and even though he is angry with her for moving on from their friendship, he wants to help. So Gideon and Lily get back up to sleuthing. However, Gideon also has to join a school activity, and sleuthing with Lily does not count, so he joins the school paper with her. Now they are back to spending a ton of time together and trying to solve the mystery but they quickly find that this mystery is a much bigger case.
I absolutely loved Gideon Green! I really had no idea what I was expecting from this book but it was absolutely wonderful. I devoured this book in nearly one sitting when I got away from my PC, I listened on my phone and then moved to my physical copy of the book. This was a fun story of mystery, suspense, friendship, and family relationships with a splash of potential romance. Katie Henry did an amazing job with this book and I am incredibly excited to read whatever she writes next (although I would not complain if we got to see Gideon again very soon).
Goodreads Rating: 5 Stars
September 3, 2022
Thank you to @epicreads and @harperaudio for the gifted copies.
Gideon Green is not your typical teenage boy. He’s obsessed with old noir films and pretty much keeps to himself.
Gideon was once a private detective but those days are gone, until and old friend Lily shows up at his door asking for help.
I love me a good YA mystery. Gideon is one of those teenage sleuths that we all love.
This book was also hilarious! Gideon is such an interesting character, you can’t help but love him.
The supporting characters were also fantastic!
This was my first book by this author and I can definitely say I will be reading more.
Overall this was a fun story and I recommend if you enjoy YA mysteries, old noir films, and humor.
I also listened to the audiobook and absolutely loved it!
May 23, 2022
I absolutely LOVED this book!! It was definitely a book that caught me by surprise because it wasn’t even on my radar until I read a sample of it on Libby. It made me laugh out loud a bunch and I also loved the mystery and how creative Gideon (the MC) was. He made me think of Shawn Spencer, from the TV show Psych. I loved Gideon’s character arc and growth, as well as his best friend Lily’s. I found myself hurrying to turn the pages because I HAD to know what happened next. This is a book I would definitely recommend to people, especially if you love mysteries and humorous/sarcastic MCs.
February 28, 2023
katie henry!!!!!! i thank all that is good that silly little 2019 me read heretics anonymous because some booktuber she liked wouldn’t stop raving about it. gideon green in black and white is unapologetically katie henry. like so you’re saying that all i need to do to be happy is solve a crime conspiracy, date the editor and chief of my highschool paper, and repair my relationship with my father? done done and done!
okay jokes aside, henry never fails to tug at my heart strings with the simple, heartfelt reflections from her young protagonists. she’s got me jumping up and down in my room after something exciting happens and updating my friend (has never heard of henry lol) on this book’s happenings.
you cant go wrong with sweet coming of age stories 🫶 and free therapy lol
okay jokes aside, henry never fails to tug at my heart strings with the simple, heartfelt reflections from her young protagonists. she’s got me jumping up and down in my room after something exciting happens and updating my friend (has never heard of henry lol) on this book’s happenings.
you cant go wrong with sweet coming of age stories 🫶 and free therapy lol
April 5, 2024
3,5 Punkte. Ist eigentlich ganz witzig und Gideon ein toller Charakter. Bei mir ist das Krimi-Thema ein bisschen zu wirr und nicht spannend genug. Aber da ich eh kein Krimileser bin, kann das auch an mir liegen.
May 21, 2022
This books lives in the delightful intersection of so many of my favorite things:
Veronica Mars
Sal & Gabby
The Extraordinaries
Humor, heart, friendship, and straight up fiercely being yourself because that's all you can be.
***
GR Personal Rating System:
★★★★★ 5 Stars ~ LOVED
★★★★☆ 4 Stars ~ ENJOYED
★★★☆☆ 3 Stars ~ LIKED
★★☆☆☆ 2 Stars ~ MEH
★☆☆☆☆ 1 Star ~ NOPE
Veronica Mars
Sal & Gabby
The Extraordinaries
Humor, heart, friendship, and straight up fiercely being yourself because that's all you can be.
***
GR Personal Rating System:
★★★★★ 5 Stars ~ LOVED
★★★★☆ 4 Stars ~ ENJOYED
★★★☆☆ 3 Stars ~ LIKED
★★☆☆☆ 2 Stars ~ MEH
★☆☆☆☆ 1 Star ~ NOPE
June 18, 2022
This review is for the audio version read by Ramon de Ocampo.
I enjoyed this quite a bit! I think one of the main reasons why is that unlike a lot of modern YA, this felt like it was actually written for teens instead of for adults who like YA. I also enjoyed the mix of mystery, humor, and heartwarming moments.
Gideon's obsession with 1940's noir films feels like one of those quirky anachronisms that book characters have but real people don't, but the author managed to build on it in such a way as to make it believable. I think it helps that as the book goes on, the noir obsession isn't played up quite as much - she doesn't keep mentioning the trenchcoat and fedora outfit, or pepper in an excessive amount of references to old films (there are a couple but they're not distracting).
Gideon's and Lily's shenanigans would definitely get them into serious trouble if they happened for real (to say nothing of what would happen if they were nonwhite), but this book doesn't deal with all the serious social issues that a lot of other YA books tackle these days, which gives it a slightly more lighthearted tone even when things like
Another thing that appeals to me is that I think Gideon is quite possibly neurodivergent, although this is never explicit. However, Gideon hyper-fixates on his interests, has trouble understanding and relating to other people, and sometimes upsets people he cares about without understanding why or even realizing that they're upset sometimes. Like I said, at no point does the book say that Gideon is autistic or neurodivergent or anything, and I'm not sure whether it's intended or if it's something I'm reading into the character, but I think it's at least a plausible interpretation and if so I think it was fairly well done.
I don't think this will be an all-time classic book that I'll read again and again or even remember too strongly five years from now, but I enjoyed it a lot and found it a refreshing change of pace.
I enjoyed this quite a bit! I think one of the main reasons why is that unlike a lot of modern YA, this felt like it was actually written for teens instead of for adults who like YA. I also enjoyed the mix of mystery, humor, and heartwarming moments.
Gideon's obsession with 1940's noir films feels like one of those quirky anachronisms that book characters have but real people don't, but the author managed to build on it in such a way as to make it believable. I think it helps that as the book goes on, the noir obsession isn't played up quite as much - she doesn't keep mentioning the trenchcoat and fedora outfit, or pepper in an excessive amount of references to old films (there are a couple but they're not distracting).
Gideon's and Lily's shenanigans would definitely get them into serious trouble if they happened for real (to say nothing of what would happen if they were nonwhite), but this book doesn't deal with all the serious social issues that a lot of other YA books tackle these days, which gives it a slightly more lighthearted tone even when things like
Another thing that appeals to me is that I think Gideon is quite possibly neurodivergent, although this is never explicit. However, Gideon hyper-fixates on his interests, has trouble understanding and relating to other people, and sometimes upsets people he cares about without understanding why or even realizing that they're upset sometimes. Like I said, at no point does the book say that Gideon is autistic or neurodivergent or anything, and I'm not sure whether it's intended or if it's something I'm reading into the character, but I think it's at least a plausible interpretation and if so I think it was fairly well done.
I don't think this will be an all-time classic book that I'll read again and again or even remember too strongly five years from now, but I enjoyed it a lot and found it a refreshing change of pace.
March 8, 2023
With his trench coat, fedora, and love of film noir, Gideon Green has always known he was born to be a hard-boiled detective. The problem is that his career has already peaked - when he was 10. But then he gets a visit from a femme fatale (aka his ex-best friend Lilly) begging for help investigating a story she's working on for the student newspaper, and he knows that if can just crack this case, his "career" will be back on track! But when a dead body turns up and the police place him at the scene of the crime, Gideon realizes that maybe the 1940's detective movies he loves may not have prepared him very well for real life!
Super cute mystery with some romance, friendship, and father-son issues thrown in. I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 though b/c I had to suspend A LOT of disbelief at the things the kids were doing in their "investigation" and how much their status as "reporters" at the high school newspaper would protect them and print their investigative piece. ;)
Satisfies #3 of the #the52bookclub2023 challenge: Title Starts With the Letter "G"
Tie-ins: mystery, detective, film noir, Hispanic, Mexican-American, LGBTQIA characters (girl has 2 moms), newspaper, reporter, journalist, journalism, investigation
Super cute mystery with some romance, friendship, and father-son issues thrown in. I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 though b/c I had to suspend A LOT of disbelief at the things the kids were doing in their "investigation" and how much their status as "reporters" at the high school newspaper would protect them and print their investigative piece. ;)
Satisfies #3 of the #the52bookclub2023 challenge: Title Starts With the Letter "G"
Tie-ins: mystery, detective, film noir, Hispanic, Mexican-American, LGBTQIA characters (girl has 2 moms), newspaper, reporter, journalist, journalism, investigation
December 11, 2021
I was fortunate enough to receive an ARC from the author.
Gideon Green. Where to start? He’s a deeply lonely, hurt kid. He’s unwilling to sacrifice his interests and what makes him special, which was so relatable that that fact alone would have made me cry. But there was the aftermath of a bad friend breakup and the examination of being the family disappointment… many tears were shed.
Katie Henry has this beautiful way of balancing snappy humor with gut punching emotion. I’ve always been able to relate to her protagonists in some way, but Gideon… Gideon is on a deeper level.
The writing is voicey and clever, and there is plenty of LGBT+ and BIPOC representation to go around. And there’s also Toast. Trust me, you’ll love Toast.
Gideon Green. Where to start? He’s a deeply lonely, hurt kid. He’s unwilling to sacrifice his interests and what makes him special, which was so relatable that that fact alone would have made me cry. But there was the aftermath of a bad friend breakup and the examination of being the family disappointment… many tears were shed.
Katie Henry has this beautiful way of balancing snappy humor with gut punching emotion. I’ve always been able to relate to her protagonists in some way, but Gideon… Gideon is on a deeper level.
The writing is voicey and clever, and there is plenty of LGBT+ and BIPOC representation to go around. And there’s also Toast. Trust me, you’ll love Toast.
Read
August 28, 2023I picked up Gideon Green in Black and White on a whim, and I quite enjoyed it.
Gideon's very much the sort of kid who doesn't do well in high school. He's obsessed with film noir and wears a trench coat all the time. Beyond standing out visually, he also has little understanding of or interest in social cues, meaning he spends a lot of time alone but doesn't mind it. He's the definition of an awkward loner.
But when his childhood best friend who left him to be popular shows up in his life again with a mystery, he cannot resist the lure of a mystery. What's really nice about all of this is that Gideon does change through the course of the book, but not in some basal way. He keeps his trench coat and his interests, but he does try to learn how to understand people better and communicate better. This is a book that celebrates individuality and owning who you are.
So far as the mystery goes, it's fun. As an adult, I obviously spent a lot of time thinking "dear god, get an adult," but I think it very much fits the genre.
Gideon's very much the sort of kid who doesn't do well in high school. He's obsessed with film noir and wears a trench coat all the time. Beyond standing out visually, he also has little understanding of or interest in social cues, meaning he spends a lot of time alone but doesn't mind it. He's the definition of an awkward loner.
But when his childhood best friend who left him to be popular shows up in his life again with a mystery, he cannot resist the lure of a mystery. What's really nice about all of this is that Gideon does change through the course of the book, but not in some basal way. He keeps his trench coat and his interests, but he does try to learn how to understand people better and communicate better. This is a book that celebrates individuality and owning who you are.
So far as the mystery goes, it's fun. As an adult, I obviously spent a lot of time thinking "dear god, get an adult," but I think it very much fits the genre.
December 20, 2022
I really loved that this was both a mystery with amateur (or not so) sleuths solving the crime, and a slightly humorous reflection on being the oddball kid in school. Mixed in are some important lessons on family, friendship, and learning that there is space between "honest" truths and lying where you can tell truths, but still be kind.
Overall this was a really fun read, I enjoyed that our protagonist has a treasured film noir collection, and that even though he's the "kid that solves crimes adults can't", that he still makes mistakes and jumps to conclusions (so he's not a super genius that is always correct, Henry allows Gideon to be an observant person that also happens to be a kid). I'd love to know what Gideon gets up to next!
Ramón de Ocampo does a good job with the audiobook narration, though I wish there had been more distinction between the character voices to make it easier to know who the dialogue was coming from at parts.
Overall this was a really fun read, I enjoyed that our protagonist has a treasured film noir collection, and that even though he's the "kid that solves crimes adults can't", that he still makes mistakes and jumps to conclusions (so he's not a super genius that is always correct, Henry allows Gideon to be an observant person that also happens to be a kid). I'd love to know what Gideon gets up to next!
Ramón de Ocampo does a good job with the audiobook narration, though I wish there had been more distinction between the character voices to make it easier to know who the dialogue was coming from at parts.
January 31, 2024
Le concept de ce roman est hyper original. On suit Gideon Green, un ado avec une bien vieille âme, solitaire, mais avec une intelligence des plus affûtée! Il a même mis sur pied sa petite agence d'enquêtes.
Agrémenté de ses réflexions de style "film en noir et blanc", c'est franchement sympathique!
Guideon accorde une importance majeure au sens des mots (on se rejoint là-dessus mon cher!) et n'hésite pas à reformuler et reprendre ses interlocuteurs. Ça frôle parfois le sarcasme et l'insolence, mais l'attitude et le ton qu'il adopte ne le rendent que plus attachant. Après tout, les gens n'ont qu'à bien s'exprimer n'est-ce pas?🤭
Lorsque Lily se présente chez lui pour demander son aide pour investiguer sur une histoire douteuse, il est loin de s'imaginer la tournure que prendront les évènements...
J'ai aimé Guideon, Lily et Tess. J'ai aimé l'enquête et le coté "retro" de Guideon.
Sans être un coup de coeur, au final, ce roman m'a fait passer un bien agréable moment!
Agrémenté de ses réflexions de style "film en noir et blanc", c'est franchement sympathique!
Guideon accorde une importance majeure au sens des mots (on se rejoint là-dessus mon cher!) et n'hésite pas à reformuler et reprendre ses interlocuteurs. Ça frôle parfois le sarcasme et l'insolence, mais l'attitude et le ton qu'il adopte ne le rendent que plus attachant. Après tout, les gens n'ont qu'à bien s'exprimer n'est-ce pas?🤭
Lorsque Lily se présente chez lui pour demander son aide pour investiguer sur une histoire douteuse, il est loin de s'imaginer la tournure que prendront les évènements...
J'ai aimé Guideon, Lily et Tess. J'ai aimé l'enquête et le coté "retro" de Guideon.
Sans être un coup de coeur, au final, ce roman m'a fait passer un bien agréable moment!
March 30, 2023
Une très très bonne découverte ✨
Je ne me serais pas laissé tenter par ce roman si PKJ ne me l'avait pas envoyé, et je réalise aujourd'hui l'erreur que ça aurait été. Cette histoire a été une bouffée de fraîcheur que je compte cultiver longtemps !
L'écriture est topissime et la psychologie des personnages surprenante. Pour un roman Young adult qui parle d'enquête et d'ego, j'ai trouvé toute l'histoire très humaine et les évolutions des personnages menées avec brio. J'ai adoré Gideon dès la première page, et je l'aime encore plus maintenant que le livre est fini. J'aime Tess de tout mon coeur, elle est vraiment LA figure du roman pour moi. Coup de coeur pour Garcia et le papa de Gideon qui sont vraiment attendrissant dans leurs rôles respectifs.
Je n'ai pas accroché avec Lily, et j'ai trouvé que peut-être son personnage manquait par moment de cohérence surtout à la fin. Mais ce n'est pas grave : on ne peut pas aimer tout le monde et ça n'a pas du vraiment gêné ma lecture.
L'intrigue policière m'a un peu perdu et c'est pour cela que je ne mets que 4 étoiles malgré mon coup de coeur pour l'histoire. Elle est bien amenée, bien conclue, mais les nuances m'ont échappé pendant tout le livre. Je n'ai pas compris comment ils arrivaient à de telles conclusions, peut-être parce que j'étais fatiguée, peut-être parce que c'était maladroit... Je dirais que c'est le poing faible du roman.
Mais cette histoire est vraiment une superbe découverte ❤️
Je ne me serais pas laissé tenter par ce roman si PKJ ne me l'avait pas envoyé, et je réalise aujourd'hui l'erreur que ça aurait été. Cette histoire a été une bouffée de fraîcheur que je compte cultiver longtemps !
L'écriture est topissime et la psychologie des personnages surprenante. Pour un roman Young adult qui parle d'enquête et d'ego, j'ai trouvé toute l'histoire très humaine et les évolutions des personnages menées avec brio. J'ai adoré Gideon dès la première page, et je l'aime encore plus maintenant que le livre est fini. J'aime Tess de tout mon coeur, elle est vraiment LA figure du roman pour moi. Coup de coeur pour Garcia et le papa de Gideon qui sont vraiment attendrissant dans leurs rôles respectifs.
Je n'ai pas accroché avec Lily, et j'ai trouvé que peut-être son personnage manquait par moment de cohérence surtout à la fin. Mais ce n'est pas grave : on ne peut pas aimer tout le monde et ça n'a pas du vraiment gêné ma lecture.
L'intrigue policière m'a un peu perdu et c'est pour cela que je ne mets que 4 étoiles malgré mon coup de coeur pour l'histoire. Elle est bien amenée, bien conclue, mais les nuances m'ont échappé pendant tout le livre. Je n'ai pas compris comment ils arrivaient à de telles conclusions, peut-être parce que j'étais fatiguée, peut-être parce que c'était maladroit... Je dirais que c'est le poing faible du roman.
Mais cette histoire est vraiment une superbe découverte ❤️
March 2, 2022
I'm always down for a Katie Henry book and I was frickin stocked for this one. She always comes up with the most inventive concepts and this one was no different. Gideon as our main character was so interesting and I loved following him. He's not exactly the most likeable protagonist and he definitely has his flaws but I think that's what makes him such a dynamic main character. The side characters were also great and helped to build up the story. The focus on friendship and Gideon's relationship with Lily was one of my absolute favorite aspects of the novel As for the mystery aspect, it wasn't exactly my favorite. I felt like it was quite predictable at times and I generally don't care about any sort of involvement of organized crime (without giving spoilers). However, I did find the mystery fun to read and was excited to find out more about it.
March 2, 2023
Okay, I didn't finish this book because I physically, PHYSICALLY COULDN'T.
The writing is so bad, the characters are EXTREMELY ONE DIMENSIONAL and have absolutely no redeeming qualities whatsoever.
The main character, Gideon, is the most cringy piece of crap I've ever heard of. Man literally wears a TRENCH COAT in the summer. To top it all off, he stays in his room all day, makes snarky, really out of pocket responses to everyone and is just overall a badly written character. Bro thinks he's in some sort of film, which would be interesting if HE WAS 7. BUT NO, THIS KID IS IN HIS MID TEENS AND STILL ACTS LIKE A FICTIONAL CHARACTER.
The dialogue for this book is extremely unnatural, very painful to read. The entire cast of this book sounds like npcs from GTA it's really bad.
If I could give this book 0 stars I would.
The writing is so bad, the characters are EXTREMELY ONE DIMENSIONAL and have absolutely no redeeming qualities whatsoever.
The main character, Gideon, is the most cringy piece of crap I've ever heard of. Man literally wears a TRENCH COAT in the summer. To top it all off, he stays in his room all day, makes snarky, really out of pocket responses to everyone and is just overall a badly written character. Bro thinks he's in some sort of film, which would be interesting if HE WAS 7. BUT NO, THIS KID IS IN HIS MID TEENS AND STILL ACTS LIKE A FICTIONAL CHARACTER.
The dialogue for this book is extremely unnatural, very painful to read. The entire cast of this book sounds like npcs from GTA it's really bad.
If I could give this book 0 stars I would.
July 26, 2023
Gideon Green in Black and White deals with some heavy topics, but at the same time it’s incredibly funny. The detective work is solid and makes sense. I recommend this book to teens and up, especially those who just didn’t fit in.
March 10, 2023
Katie Henry, man. She does that writing thing dang good.
December 25, 2023
3.5, some parts 4
Read
December 7, 2021Katie Henry has gifted us with a cleverly-crafted mystery absolutely brimming with humor and heart. Gideon Green is the rare kind of character you’ll find impossible to forget.
April 17, 2022
When you laugh at the dedication and then snort laugh and fist pump at the end of the first chapter you know you are going to love the book and laugh a lot. Which is exactly how it went down reading Gideon Green in Black and White. Looking at the author, who is the author of some of my all time favourite and go-to humour novels, it’s no surprise that this book is funny. Like really, unexpectedly, dry-humour funny. But what was surprising was the mystery (very cool), sleuthing, totally platonic male-female best friend relationship (finally, yes!!) and cute but not attention demanding, just perfect romance.
I love it when you finish a book and just flick the last page (ebook) and sit and take a moment to soak in just how fantastic that story was. How completely it sucked you in. In my case my next task is to then add it straight to my library’s order list, though I’m not too sure if I will be putting it in my mystery collection or humour. It really could go both ways and will appeal to readers wanting either genre or even just readers who love a book with great characters and dynamic relationships.
There is so much to love about this book.
Gideon himself. He’s not afraid to note how different he is and how this makes him extraordinary. He’s good at noticing details, at putting these clues together. It’s what made him a great detective as a kid and what makes him the perfect guy for the job his ex-best friend Lily has for him. Gideon is our narrator and his dry wit and unique, detail-observing perspective makes him an hilarious narrator. While a label is never given, what makes him so great at detective work can make relationships a little tricky, like connecting with his dad. Gideon’s relationship with his dad is one of the things I enjoyed the most in this book. They are different and they each struggle to understand the other. The love is there, though, and through all Gideon’s arrests (ah, yep, there are a few) and his dad’s harsh words, it is them learning to reach out to each other that is really powerful.
Then we have the mystery. I love YA mysteries that just make sense for teenagers to be investigating and Lily and Gideon working as journalists to uncover a trend Lily has noticed in the local crime rate is the perfect crime to solve, especially when things get interesting with a murder. It is intriguing.
The romance is the bonus extra in this book that is just the cherry on top of the ice cream sundae. Gideon and Tess just work and it’s great to see their relationship blossom, Gideon’s confidence grow and just how easy, sweet and authentic it is. Also without drama, which I totally adored.
Gideon Green in Black and White has to be one of my favourite books so far this year and one of my favourite mysteries. It’s unique (love the blend of humour and crime solving) and unputdownable. Can’t wait to add this one to our library shelves.
The publishers provided an advanced readers copy of this book for reviewing purposes. All opinions are my own.
Find more reviews, reading age guides, content advisory, and recommendations on my blog Madison's Library
I love it when you finish a book and just flick the last page (ebook) and sit and take a moment to soak in just how fantastic that story was. How completely it sucked you in. In my case my next task is to then add it straight to my library’s order list, though I’m not too sure if I will be putting it in my mystery collection or humour. It really could go both ways and will appeal to readers wanting either genre or even just readers who love a book with great characters and dynamic relationships.
There is so much to love about this book.
Gideon himself. He’s not afraid to note how different he is and how this makes him extraordinary. He’s good at noticing details, at putting these clues together. It’s what made him a great detective as a kid and what makes him the perfect guy for the job his ex-best friend Lily has for him. Gideon is our narrator and his dry wit and unique, detail-observing perspective makes him an hilarious narrator. While a label is never given, what makes him so great at detective work can make relationships a little tricky, like connecting with his dad. Gideon’s relationship with his dad is one of the things I enjoyed the most in this book. They are different and they each struggle to understand the other. The love is there, though, and through all Gideon’s arrests (ah, yep, there are a few) and his dad’s harsh words, it is them learning to reach out to each other that is really powerful.
Then we have the mystery. I love YA mysteries that just make sense for teenagers to be investigating and Lily and Gideon working as journalists to uncover a trend Lily has noticed in the local crime rate is the perfect crime to solve, especially when things get interesting with a murder. It is intriguing.
The romance is the bonus extra in this book that is just the cherry on top of the ice cream sundae. Gideon and Tess just work and it’s great to see their relationship blossom, Gideon’s confidence grow and just how easy, sweet and authentic it is. Also without drama, which I totally adored.
Gideon Green in Black and White has to be one of my favourite books so far this year and one of my favourite mysteries. It’s unique (love the blend of humour and crime solving) and unputdownable. Can’t wait to add this one to our library shelves.
The publishers provided an advanced readers copy of this book for reviewing purposes. All opinions are my own.
Find more reviews, reading age guides, content advisory, and recommendations on my blog Madison's Library
August 6, 2023
Beautiful combination of film noir and nearodiverse main character energy! The writing is done in a way to be able to see the world through Gideon’s eyes. Excellent read for mystery and suspense. (YA Novel)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 148 reviews