Thank you to NetGalley and Hillman Grad Books for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
DNF @ 60%
I was really excited to read this when I came across it on NetGalley. I love space operas, and I especially love those that are not in Western-focused settings, so I was really looking forward to reading a Korean-based setting.
However, I couldn't finish this. I got pretty far in, at just under 2/3, and what is described in the synopsis only just started to happen. What?! It's wild that I read 220 pages and yet it felt like there was hardly any plot, world building, or even real characterization. My main issue with this book is that there is zero intrigue. There is no overarching plot point in the first half of the novel that made me want to read on. It was just the characters going about their daily lives really, and I didn't find them very interesting.
Starting with the characters: our first introduction to Ocean, the MC, is her accusing her boyfriend of cheating on her with someone on his ship. This seemed like such an odd choice to me since 1. we don't know anything about their relationship together or these characters separately, 2. I don’t see it having any impact on anything later, and 3. it just made Ocean seem really dramatic and immature. So she got off to a bad start with me.
We slowly got introduced to other characters, and thankfully none of them were as dramatic, but I felt like the way they acted changed on a dime and made no sense. When we first meet the captain, she seemed very laissez-faire and chill, but the second the crew went on a mission, she completely flipped and went authoritarian and didn't care about anyone's feelings. When two of the narrating characters met for the first time, one was very prejudiced and straight-up mean to the other. But then a few chapters later, there was a hint of romance from both sides? What?! I know a lot of people love the enemies to lovers trope, and while that's personally not my thing, I don't think it was executed well at all. I felt blindsided by the sudden turnaround from borderline racism to tenderness, vulnerability, and attraction between the two that even other characters were noticing and pointing out!
And lastly, one of the major characters is a dude who is belongs to a family so rich that he can afford to pay for the meals of everyone at a very fancy restaurant without a single care. I'm tired of reading sci-fi with obscenely rich characters like this. It's hard to feel sympathy for someone so comfortable in their wealth at a level that can only be obtained through the exploitation of others.
As for the world building, I thought it was pretty interesting at first. I thought I knew a decent amount about Korean culture, but there are a lot of Korean words in this that I hadn't heard before. There is a handy glossary at the back, with funny commentary, though most words are understandable via context clues. I did start to wonder what language these characters are speaking in, because they use Korean words so often but are apparently speaking in another language with a non-Korean character. But one thing that really threw me is that 22% in, there is a reference to a real life Korean astronaut, which seems to imply that this book takes place in our world. In real life, Yi So-yeon went to space in 2008, and then the Korean space program ended. But in this book, Korea is the main power of the solar system (galaxy? unsure). How did that happen? How did the events after 2008 change the power balance of space travel so drastically to the point that the United States is not even worth mentioning and Russia is only brought up once in a throwaway reference? There wasn't any explanation 60% into the book, but perhaps the history is explained more later. This may not be important to many readers, but as a lover of history both real and alternate, I can't help but get distracted thinking about it.
In addition, there were some weird prose choices for a space opera. Like why does a spaceship have a clutch, gears, and pedals? It really felt more like a stick shift car than anything spaceworthy. There was also a moment where a character goes on a space walk, and the narrative says that some tools they drop start "spinning in the air" but there is no air in space...
And then for the plot... there really wasn't any until around 55% in. And at that point I cared so little about the characters and world that even that couldn't hook me. I feel like I gave this book quite a few chances, but if a book hasn't hooked me over halfway in, I really see no reason to finish.
And as someone who loves Becky Chambers, I don't think this book is in any way, shape, or form comparable to her work. You'd at least need compelling characters for that, and this world is nowhere near utopian either, so I wouldn't recommend for Chambers lovers. I'm not really sure who I would recommend this to. This author does have some interesting ideas though, so perhaps I will check out their work in the future.