What do you think?
Rate this book
魔法騎士レイアース [Magic Knight Rayearth] #3
Magic Knight Rayearth I, Vol. 3
The end of the adventure is at hand for Hikaru, Umi and Fuu, three schoolgirls from Tokyo who were transported to the magical realm of Cephiro to become the Magic Knights. They have unlocked their magic, powered up their weapons, and defeated Zagato's minions. But one test remains before they can confront the sinister Zagato himself, and release the imprisoned Princess Emeraude. They must don the three Mashin--powerful spirits that can only be wielded by Magic Knights. With the girls' magic fully charged, the final battle begins!
213 pages, Paperback
First published March 6, 1995
21 people are currently reading
516 people want to read
About the author
Clamp
1,194 books3,123 followersŌkawa Nanase 大川七瀬
[born: 2 May 1967; Ōsaka, bloodtype: A]
Mokona Apapa もこなあぱぱ
[born: 16 Jun 1968, Kyōto; bloodtype: A]
Nekoi Mick 猫井みっく
[born: 21 Jan 1969, Kyōto; bloodtype: O]
Igarashi Satsuki 五十嵐さつき
[born: 8 Feb 1969, Kyōto; bloodtype: A]
CLAMP originally began in 1989 as a twelve-member dōjinshi circle, but by 1990, the circle had diminished from twelve to seven. Of the remaining seven, Tamayo Akiyama, Sei Nanao, and Leeza Sei left the group during the production of the RG Veda manga. Other former members of CLAMP also included Soushi Hishika, O-Kyon, Kazue Nakamori, Yuzuru Inoue and Shinya Ōmi. Currently, there are four members in the group.
In 2004, CLAMP's 15th anniversary as a mangaka group, the members changed their names from Nanase Ohkawa, Mokona Apapa, Mick Nekoi, and Satsuki Igarashi to Ageha Ohkawa, Mokona, Tsubaki Nekoi and Satsuki Igarashi (her name is pronounced the same, but written with different characters) respectively. The August 2004 issue of Newtype USA, a magazine specializing in events of the anime and manga subcultures, reported that the members of CLAMP simply wanted to try out new names. In a later interview with Ohkawa, it was revealed that initially Mokona wanted to drop her surname because it sounded too immature for her liking, while Nekoi disliked people commenting that her name was the same as Mick Jagger's. Ohkawa and Igarashi, wanting to go with the flow of Nekoi's and Mokona's name changes, changed their names as well.
In 2006, they made their first USA public debut at Anime Expo in Anaheim, California. They were well received at the convention, with 6,000 fans in attendance at their panel.
[born: 2 May 1967; Ōsaka, bloodtype: A]
Mokona Apapa もこなあぱぱ
[born: 16 Jun 1968, Kyōto; bloodtype: A]
Nekoi Mick 猫井みっく
[born: 21 Jan 1969, Kyōto; bloodtype: O]
Igarashi Satsuki 五十嵐さつき
[born: 8 Feb 1969, Kyōto; bloodtype: A]
CLAMP originally began in 1989 as a twelve-member dōjinshi circle, but by 1990, the circle had diminished from twelve to seven. Of the remaining seven, Tamayo Akiyama, Sei Nanao, and Leeza Sei left the group during the production of the RG Veda manga. Other former members of CLAMP also included Soushi Hishika, O-Kyon, Kazue Nakamori, Yuzuru Inoue and Shinya Ōmi. Currently, there are four members in the group.
In 2004, CLAMP's 15th anniversary as a mangaka group, the members changed their names from Nanase Ohkawa, Mokona Apapa, Mick Nekoi, and Satsuki Igarashi to Ageha Ohkawa, Mokona, Tsubaki Nekoi and Satsuki Igarashi (her name is pronounced the same, but written with different characters) respectively. The August 2004 issue of Newtype USA, a magazine specializing in events of the anime and manga subcultures, reported that the members of CLAMP simply wanted to try out new names. In a later interview with Ohkawa, it was revealed that initially Mokona wanted to drop her surname because it sounded too immature for her liking, while Nekoi disliked people commenting that her name was the same as Mick Jagger's. Ohkawa and Igarashi, wanting to go with the flow of Nekoi's and Mokona's name changes, changed their names as well.
In 2006, they made their first USA public debut at Anime Expo in Anaheim, California. They were well received at the convention, with 6,000 fans in attendance at their panel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 137 reviews
January 15, 2019
Così felice di averlo ritrovato e ricomprato (il terzo è esaurito ora nella mia fume) e in seguito riletto. Ora sarà perfettamente conservato in una scatola a prova di umidità.
March 7, 2018
That was one hell of a final plot twist 😱
October 25, 2020
Llegamos a la recta final de la primera parte de Las Guerreras Mágicas y debo admitir que todavía no sé si me gusta o no. Por una parte, me encanta que la magia esté relacionada directamente con el poder del alma y la voluntad de cada ser. Los poderes de las chicas han evolucionado junto con sus espadas y armaduras. Y tras varias pruebas, cada una consigue trabajar junto a un genio elemental (de agua, viento y fuego).
Sin embargo, hay recursos que me hacen rodar los ojos o en su peor caso, llegan a molestarme. Por ejemplo, los supuestos villanos no lo son realmente y no son más que personas que no tenían otra opción. Así mismo, el final queda tan abierto que quién sabe si en algún momento la editorial decida retomar la historia y completar los otros 3 volúmenes que hacen falta.
Si bien tiene emocionantes escenas de acción, buen crecimiento de personajes y fluidez para contar la historia y que no resulte agobiante, lo cierto es que está lejos de ser perfecta. Eso sí, me agrada mucho la interacción que tienen las chicas y con todo y que en la línea de tiempo no han de pasar muchos días, se nota que se preocupan por las demás y que arriesgarían su vida con tal de protegerlas.
Espero que Hikaru, Umi y Fuu tengan una mejor conclusión a su historia.
REVIEWS ANTERIORES:
Volumen 1 | Volumen 2
Sin embargo, hay recursos que me hacen rodar los ojos o en su peor caso, llegan a molestarme. Por ejemplo, los supuestos villanos no lo son realmente y no son más que personas que no tenían otra opción. Así mismo, el final queda tan abierto que quién sabe si en algún momento la editorial decida retomar la historia y completar los otros 3 volúmenes que hacen falta.
Si bien tiene emocionantes escenas de acción, buen crecimiento de personajes y fluidez para contar la historia y que no resulte agobiante, lo cierto es que está lejos de ser perfecta. Eso sí, me agrada mucho la interacción que tienen las chicas y con todo y que en la línea de tiempo no han de pasar muchos días, se nota que se preocupan por las demás y que arriesgarían su vida con tal de protegerlas.
Espero que Hikaru, Umi y Fuu tengan una mejor conclusión a su historia.
REVIEWS ANTERIORES:
Volumen 1 | Volumen 2
January 26, 2020
5+
Fabuloso el giro del final, que hace que necesites leer el siguiente. La historia de Zagato con Emeraude me recuerda un poquito a , me encantó. Creo que aunque la historia hubiera quedado acá me fascinaría igual.
Las armaduras finales son geniales *_* qué buen manga.
Fabuloso el giro del final, que hace que necesites leer el siguiente. La historia de Zagato con Emeraude me recuerda un poquito a , me encantó. Creo que aunque la historia hubiera quedado acá me fascinaría igual.
Las armaduras finales son geniales *_* qué buen manga.
June 26, 2021
Tercer volumen y tenemos que hablar de los increíbles Mayin!! Los Mayin (o genios) son seres mágicos protectores de Cefiro. Ceres, Windom y Rayearth se mantienen dormidos esperando que las Guerreras Mágicas de la profecía los despierten cuando los necesiten para salvar al mundo (en su modo batalla son robots gigantes que pueden ser pilotados).
Hikaru, Umi y Fuu tendrán que ir a cada uno de los santuarios de los Mayin y demostrar que son dignas de ellos.
Los esbirros de Zagato estarán a la orden del día para hacerles su misión imposible. Me encanta que cada uno de los que se presenta tiene razones muy distintas por las que trabajan con Zagato, y nuestras guerreras saben como tratar con cada uno de ellos demostrando no solo fuerza, sino también astucia.
Las ilustraciones me siguieron encantando a lo largo de todos los volúmenes, aún más al ver como las armaduras de nuestras chicas van evolucionando. La representación de los Mayin en forma espiritual es magnífica, pero en forma robot se hace un poco demasiado y difícil de entender en la página. Una pena que no se puedan disfrutar esos detalles.
La batalla final sucede en este volumen, con un plot twist que solo veía venir porque lo recordaba del anime, pero que me resulta asombroso.
La verdad que la última página se me hizo un poco abrupta y me hace desear que los volúmenes del siguiente arco se consiguieron en Argentina para al menos poder ver que es de la vida de nuestras heroínas en el futuro.
De todas formas, una historia muy bella que me llena de nostalgia. Llena de acción, una atmósfera fantástica excepcional y con un mensaje hermoso en el centro. Super recomendado!
Hikaru, Umi y Fuu tendrán que ir a cada uno de los santuarios de los Mayin y demostrar que son dignas de ellos.
Los esbirros de Zagato estarán a la orden del día para hacerles su misión imposible. Me encanta que cada uno de los que se presenta tiene razones muy distintas por las que trabajan con Zagato, y nuestras guerreras saben como tratar con cada uno de ellos demostrando no solo fuerza, sino también astucia.
Las ilustraciones me siguieron encantando a lo largo de todos los volúmenes, aún más al ver como las armaduras de nuestras chicas van evolucionando. La representación de los Mayin en forma espiritual es magnífica, pero en forma robot se hace un poco demasiado y difícil de entender en la página. Una pena que no se puedan disfrutar esos detalles.
La batalla final sucede en este volumen, con un plot twist que solo veía venir porque lo recordaba del anime, pero que me resulta asombroso.
La verdad que la última página se me hizo un poco abrupta y me hace desear que los volúmenes del siguiente arco se consiguieron en Argentina para al menos poder ver que es de la vida de nuestras heroínas en el futuro.
De todas formas, una historia muy bella que me llena de nostalgia. Llena de acción, una atmósfera fantástica excepcional y con un mensaje hermoso en el centro. Super recomendado!
May 10, 2017
In this volume, the three girls are well on their way to becoming Legendary Magic Knights, but in order to reach their full power, they must awaken the three mysterious Mashin to aid them in their fight against evil Zagato. The girls must each prove themselves to be worthy of the Mashin, and show that their hearts are strong.
I wasn't really sure what happened at the end of this volume. The action panels are so busy and confusing, and then it ended so quickly. Well, it was certainly a surprising twist at the end that made up for how predictable the rest of the plot was.
I really loved the artwork of the Mashin, beautifully elegant and regal figures! And I loved how the girls' armor evolves and changes with their character development. But the girls are still very one-sided characters, and I wish they had more depth. The villain is a very boring character; no depth, no development, almost no dialogue. It makes the big battle at the end sort of a let-down.
But I'm glad that I read it! There were many parts of the story that I enjoyed!
I wasn't really sure what happened at the end of this volume. The action panels are so busy and confusing, and then it ended so quickly. Well, it was certainly a surprising twist at the end that made up for how predictable the rest of the plot was.
I really loved the artwork of the Mashin, beautifully elegant and regal figures! And I loved how the girls' armor evolves and changes with their character development. But the girls are still very one-sided characters, and I wish they had more depth. The villain is a very boring character; no depth, no development, almost no dialogue. It makes the big battle at the end sort of a let-down.
But I'm glad that I read it! There were many parts of the story that I enjoyed!
July 21, 2018
Review of vol. 1: here.
Review of vol. 2: here.
✵ I continue to be blown away by the moral of this story being about belief and friendship. I appreciate how the authors continue to bring attention to the fact that the girls barely know each other, but the girls fight back saying that it doesn't matter.
✵ I knew about the plot twist beforehand, which I think made me enjoy it and the story overall more. It's an out-of-the-box idea. I do have to mention that it can be triggering in regards to suicide and because of that it's not entirely perfect. It has to be read as a metaphor in order for it to work. I appreciate it as entertainment and also for the message it sends about not being able to live a happy life if you have to constantly care about others and never about yourself.
Review of vol. 2: here.
✵ I continue to be blown away by the moral of this story being about belief and friendship. I appreciate how the authors continue to bring attention to the fact that the girls barely know each other, but the girls fight back saying that it doesn't matter.
✵ I knew about the plot twist beforehand, which I think made me enjoy it and the story overall more. It's an out-of-the-box idea. I do have to mention that it can be triggering in regards to suicide and because of that it's not entirely perfect. It has to be read as a metaphor in order for it to work. I appreciate it as entertainment and also for the message it sends about not being able to live a happy life if you have to constantly care about others and never about yourself.
February 18, 2021
Those CLAMP ladies have the most unexpected endings.
August 11, 2020
El señor plot twist tiene este manga jajajajaja por dioooos! Que locura
March 13, 2021
¡Inche Kamite trae la siguiente parte de una trinche vez! 😭😭😭😭.
Había Olvidado que en el manga el Genio de Esmeralda es un Centauro Maligno 😈😍
Había Olvidado que en el manga el Genio de Esmeralda es un Centauro Maligno 😈😍
December 29, 2022
Même si j'ai moyennement aimé les 2 premiers, les révélations à la fin de ce tome c'était pépite ✨
October 22, 2015
The story ends with an interesting twist, I wish the rest of the plot had the same sort of surprises. The artwork is beautiful and is really where the manga shines.
Final word, Magic Knight Rayearth has a very cute and entertaining story, but ultimately it lacks the depth that would make it a enduring tale.
Final word, Magic Knight Rayearth has a very cute and entertaining story, but ultimately it lacks the depth that would make it a enduring tale.
March 3, 2021
Wow con este final... la primera vez que vi el anime lloré con este capítulo. No vi venir el final para nada.
April 6, 2024
When I first saw this book, I was surprised. I've never seen anything like this before! It was a shock and something new. I like. The book is fantastic! I recommend!
June 13, 2022
Umi, Fuu, and Hikaru each must have their hearts tested before they can do their destined Spirits, becoming true Magic Knights and saving Cephiro. Danger awaits them, for Zagato has sent an enemy to kill each of them at the chosen spirit shrines before this can happen. Not to mention Zagato himself is waiting for the girls, even if they succeed. Only is Zagato their true enemy?
This is so beautiful, the illustrations of the landscapes, the girls communing with their spirits in a surreal, dream-like ambience, transforming into the Magic Knights, Zagato in all his dark, melancholy moodiness, Emeraude’s true heart exposed, all becoming works of art which push the story forward. The twist at the end is so heartbreaking, the last panel never fails to make me cry. For nothing was what it seemed to these innocent, idealistic girls and as Magic Knights they learn this in a painful way. Amidst all the heavy drama along with the intense emotional and magical ordeals, Mokona’s antics, Gardina’s light-hearted adversity, and Fuu’s humourous observations were welcome moments when the reader could breathe and laugh. At the same time, there was an overall sweetness and beauty to this, which softened the flaws and repetitive moments in the story. For all of these qualities, I give this four stars.
This is so beautiful, the illustrations of the landscapes, the girls communing with their spirits in a surreal, dream-like ambience, transforming into the Magic Knights, Zagato in all his dark, melancholy moodiness, Emeraude’s true heart exposed, all becoming works of art which push the story forward. The twist at the end is so heartbreaking, the last panel never fails to make me cry. For nothing was what it seemed to these innocent, idealistic girls and as Magic Knights they learn this in a painful way. Amidst all the heavy drama along with the intense emotional and magical ordeals, Mokona’s antics, Gardina’s light-hearted adversity, and Fuu’s humourous observations were welcome moments when the reader could breathe and laugh. At the same time, there was an overall sweetness and beauty to this, which softened the flaws and repetitive moments in the story. For all of these qualities, I give this four stars.
March 27, 2019
¿¿Qué clase de final es ése??
December 6, 2019
3,5 stars
November 10, 2022
Amo las CLAMP son mis mangakas favoritas ❤️❤️❤️
August 16, 2024
Favorite manga ever! Love the story and beautiful artwork.
March 31, 2022
3.3 / 5
January 13, 2022
4.5 stars. I loved it.
August 2, 2021
In the spirit of “I get into a fandom 20 years too late,” I read the first 3 volumes of Rayearth, as it was all I could get a hold of in my library. I knew a little bit about the series, in that I could recognize the three main characters on sight. (As a blonde, bespectacled Sagittarius with short hair, type A blood, and a serious temperament, I relate a lot to Fuu, but man oh man that initial teasing of Hikaru being being short and looking like a kid even though she was 14 was brutal, CLAMP did not need to come at me like that.)
I was not expecting giant magic robots though, that was a twist. I thought it was more like Sailor Moon (which it was, but with giant mecha too.)
Wikipedia tells me there’s a Part 2 I will need to get my hands on somehow, and thank God because that ending was abrupt and low key unsatisfying.
Oh the big twist is that Emeraude essentially committed suicide by Magic Knight? (Admittedly it was a twist I did not expect.) And that when they did it they were sent back home to Tokyo as promised, but then it just…ends. Literally. No time to process or feel some closure, it ends with the three girls holding each other in fear and grief because they’d literally killed Emeraude like three seconds before. It feels incomplete so I am glad it is incomplete. My library and none of the nearest ones seem to have the Part 2, so this may take some time to see to it’s conclusion.
The whole thing with Emeraude seeming like a little girl in the “good” form and a grown up busty lady (which seems to be a trope with the female villains in this series) in the hate-filled form is…I don’t know how to parse it, just like I don’t quite know how to parse the fact that she’s in love with Zagato, and tells the girls such in her “good” child-like form. Maybe it’s best not to think about it.
Also, I don’t know about other translations, but I was not thrilled with some of TokyoPop’s font choices. I got used to the font they used for magic spells and Good Emeraude’s text; the font they used for Zagato’s speech looks like the one font I saw everyone use for “gothic” stuff in the early 2000s, but at least it was legible. Whatever they used for Evil Emeraude’s speech was barely legible and just not pleasing to the eye. Not everything needs a fancy font guys. (Unless it was like that in Japanese too—I don’t know.)
This also maybe because I’m on a graphic novel kick, so I’ve been reading Western ones as well as manga (or it could be a style thing) but I sometimes had a hard time figuring out what was going on. Manga tends to be more about action lines and emphasizing big feels rather than placing characters in a concrete location, so when you got to big fight scenes with lots of swirls and magic, and less on details, i had to reread some sections. There were also some scene cuts that seemed abrupt and I had no idea if I’d missed a page or what. (Ex: the end of the Gardenia fight where it abruptly transitions to Emeraude and Zagato). Again more a style thing and I enjoyed the story itself, but some panels had a lot going on.
Final thoughts: I liked how Ascot and Gardena were essentially defeated through talking, and also Gardena’s reason for quitting being “Zagato is not paying me enough for this, also you’re pretty cool,” is goals, Gardena was best underling, you work for your money, girl. Also Ascot’s outfit just seemed really really familiar—I think Li in Cardcaptor Sakura may have had a similar outfit? I couldn’t place my finger on it and it bugged me a little.
Also holy SHIT, Hikaru had balls there. Choosing to fight swords with swords instead of magic (probably because it was fair) and getting pummelled as a human shield for her friends was WAY MORE INTENSE than the other girls when it came to proving themselves to the Mashin.
Fuu’s sword didn’t power up so much as it just got longer, pretty sure that thing was twice her height by the end. Well, twice might be an exaggeration, but like, 1.5 Fuus at LEAST. I said “holy shit that’s a huge sword” multiple times
Anyway A+, I was entertained, debating if I should watch the anime or wait if and when I get my hands on the rest of the manga.
I was not expecting giant magic robots though, that was a twist. I thought it was more like Sailor Moon (which it was, but with giant mecha too.)
Wikipedia tells me there’s a Part 2 I will need to get my hands on somehow, and thank God because that ending was abrupt and low key unsatisfying.
Oh the big twist is that Emeraude essentially committed suicide by Magic Knight? (Admittedly it was a twist I did not expect.) And that when they did it they were sent back home to Tokyo as promised, but then it just…ends. Literally. No time to process or feel some closure, it ends with the three girls holding each other in fear and grief because they’d literally killed Emeraude like three seconds before. It feels incomplete so I am glad it is incomplete. My library and none of the nearest ones seem to have the Part 2, so this may take some time to see to it’s conclusion.
The whole thing with Emeraude seeming like a little girl in the “good” form and a grown up busty lady (which seems to be a trope with the female villains in this series) in the hate-filled form is…I don’t know how to parse it, just like I don’t quite know how to parse the fact that she’s in love with Zagato, and tells the girls such in her “good” child-like form. Maybe it’s best not to think about it.
Also, I don’t know about other translations, but I was not thrilled with some of TokyoPop’s font choices. I got used to the font they used for magic spells and Good Emeraude’s text; the font they used for Zagato’s speech looks like the one font I saw everyone use for “gothic” stuff in the early 2000s, but at least it was legible. Whatever they used for Evil Emeraude’s speech was barely legible and just not pleasing to the eye. Not everything needs a fancy font guys. (Unless it was like that in Japanese too—I don’t know.)
This also maybe because I’m on a graphic novel kick, so I’ve been reading Western ones as well as manga (or it could be a style thing) but I sometimes had a hard time figuring out what was going on. Manga tends to be more about action lines and emphasizing big feels rather than placing characters in a concrete location, so when you got to big fight scenes with lots of swirls and magic, and less on details, i had to reread some sections. There were also some scene cuts that seemed abrupt and I had no idea if I’d missed a page or what. (Ex: the end of the Gardenia fight where it abruptly transitions to Emeraude and Zagato). Again more a style thing and I enjoyed the story itself, but some panels had a lot going on.
Final thoughts: I liked how Ascot and Gardena were essentially defeated through talking, and also Gardena’s reason for quitting being “Zagato is not paying me enough for this, also you’re pretty cool,” is goals, Gardena was best underling, you work for your money, girl. Also Ascot’s outfit just seemed really really familiar—I think Li in Cardcaptor Sakura may have had a similar outfit? I couldn’t place my finger on it and it bugged me a little.
Also holy SHIT, Hikaru had balls there. Choosing to fight swords with swords instead of magic (probably because it was fair) and getting pummelled as a human shield for her friends was WAY MORE INTENSE than the other girls when it came to proving themselves to the Mashin.
Fuu’s sword didn’t power up so much as it just got longer, pretty sure that thing was twice her height by the end. Well, twice might be an exaggeration, but like, 1.5 Fuus at LEAST. I said “holy shit that’s a huge sword” multiple times
Anyway A+, I was entertained, debating if I should watch the anime or wait if and when I get my hands on the rest of the manga.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 30, 2019
Todo pasa muy rápido en este volumen y te quedas con un cliffhanger descomunal. Disfruté mucho las escenas de acción, el estilo de dibujo y los escenarios de cada batalla pero me quedó a deber un poco este último tomo de la primer parte.
January 1, 2023
Now equipped with Escudo weapons, the last stage of their quest awaits Hikaru, Umi and Fuu. To become to Magic Knights of legend, they must reawaken the powerful spirits known as "Mashin". Standing in their way are more of Zagatos minions, who keep tracking them down to fulfill Zagato's orders of killing the girls before they can reach the end of their journey. And what they learn about his motives when they finally face Zagato himself changes everything... Not matter how many times I read this, the conclusion of the first MKR trilogy, it never fails to break my heart.
June 15, 2020
The last book in the first "cour" of Magic Knight warriors. The plot twist is always nice, no matter how many times I revisit this awesome series. Again, in hindsight, many things seem rushed and too sudden because of page number restriction, but MKR, both in the idea itself and its aesthetic execution, is always worth more than lukewarm three stars. My longtime favorite.
August 5, 2019
that got dark and romantic and convoluted super-fast . . . but this is CLAMP, after all.
I can't say I didn't see this coming, just not exactly as it played out. that's some hot psychological mess at the end.
I can't say I didn't see this coming, just not exactly as it played out. that's some hot psychological mess at the end.
July 14, 2020
A stunning ending
I've read and watched Magic Knight Rayearth many times over the years, but the ending to the first act still stuns me every time. Utterly gorgeous.
I've read and watched Magic Knight Rayearth many times over the years, but the ending to the first act still stuns me every time. Utterly gorgeous.
April 29, 2021
The final installment of Magic Knight Rayearth was... okay.
I know I've harped in reviews of the previous two installments that this series suffers from an incredibly short page count. That problem is clearest and most damaging in the last installment. The final battle (Debonair) happens so quickly that it's hard to understand what is going on if you haven't read the summary or watched the anime. The art doesn't provide a lot of clarity here either since the Mashin Rune Gods are so new and we haven't yet had time to learn how to tell them apart. This means it's impossible to determine who does what in the battle. If I didn't know from watching the anime 15 years ago who actually defeats whom, I wouldn't have a clue now.
The final twist also comes with little build up or explanation and I think it would actually be more effective if it hadn't come out of the blue with no warning. Foreshadowing can be powerful, but this series didn't create room for that kind of build up. That means the twist doesn't feel earned to me and feels more like it's just something for shock value.
The last page is also very frustrating for me as a reader. We don't get to see how these three girls deal with what they've just lived through. Their task wasn't what they thought it was and I'd love to see how the trio, especially Hikaru, deal with the weight of what they've actually done - what it means for them and for Cephiro. Instead, we just get "the end".
This is where the allegory of Emaurade's task as the Pillar falls flat. She alone is responsible for the safety and security of Cephiro. This really could have led into an exploration of suffering versus responsibility, and agency versus powerlessness. With a person's will being the strongest force in Cephiro, it seemed like the series was really building up to exploring each person's responsibility to their own selves and also to the world around them. This allegory had so much potential, but it is barely explored in this final volume. Instead, this is all about in your face PLOT. Everything suffers to get the rest of this story on the page as quickly as possible.
Everything suffered in this ending volume - art, characters, allegory, relationships, empathy, even plot itself. This felt rushed and unfortunately ends the series as a bit of a hot mess instead of what it truly could have been.
Even though the plot is different, I recommend the anime after reading to get some decent closure on the story of this series.
I know I've harped in reviews of the previous two installments that this series suffers from an incredibly short page count. That problem is clearest and most damaging in the last installment. The final battle (Debonair) happens so quickly that it's hard to understand what is going on if you haven't read the summary or watched the anime. The art doesn't provide a lot of clarity here either since the Mashin Rune Gods are so new and we haven't yet had time to learn how to tell them apart. This means it's impossible to determine who does what in the battle. If I didn't know from watching the anime 15 years ago who actually defeats whom, I wouldn't have a clue now.
The final twist also comes with little build up or explanation and I think it would actually be more effective if it hadn't come out of the blue with no warning. Foreshadowing can be powerful, but this series didn't create room for that kind of build up. That means the twist doesn't feel earned to me and feels more like it's just something for shock value.
The last page is also very frustrating for me as a reader. We don't get to see how these three girls deal with what they've just lived through. Their task wasn't what they thought it was and I'd love to see how the trio, especially Hikaru, deal with the weight of what they've actually done - what it means for them and for Cephiro. Instead, we just get "the end".
This is where the allegory of Emaurade's task as the Pillar falls flat. She alone is responsible for the safety and security of Cephiro. This really could have led into an exploration of suffering versus responsibility, and agency versus powerlessness. With a person's will being the strongest force in Cephiro, it seemed like the series was really building up to exploring each person's responsibility to their own selves and also to the world around them. This allegory had so much potential, but it is barely explored in this final volume. Instead, this is all about in your face PLOT. Everything suffers to get the rest of this story on the page as quickly as possible.
Everything suffered in this ending volume - art, characters, allegory, relationships, empathy, even plot itself. This felt rushed and unfortunately ends the series as a bit of a hot mess instead of what it truly could have been.
Even though the plot is different, I recommend the anime after reading to get some decent closure on the story of this series.
July 10, 2024
3.5 ★
---
"Magic Knight Rayearth" es un manga entretenido y de rápida lectura.
El arte y el diseño de personajes son el punto alto, a medida que avanzan los tomos hay unas puestas en página muy bonitas y muy dinámicas.
Lo cual es bueno porque la historia es bastante básica y, a partir del segundo tomo, repetitiva. Así que es el arte el que va llevando el ritmo.
Fue una decepción que no haya construcción del mundo, incluso se siente vacío. Y, si bien lo compararn con un RPG -y es una comparativa acertada-, no quita que sea un problema. Las protagonistas van avanzando de a poco, enfrentando a villanos, aprendiendo algo nuevo de su magia y llegan al jefe final. Relamente no hay conflicto.
Y hablando del villano, Zagato, me dejó con gusto a poco. Me gustan sus motivaciones, pero termina cediendo su lugar a otro personaje. Y si bien el plot twist es bueno, no fue construido correctamente.
Debo ser de la minoría pero el final abrupto y abierto me dejó conforme, en gran parte porque lo poco que conocí de Céfiro no alcanza para preocuparme por su bienestar.
En general, es un manga con buenas ideas, pero con un ritmo que no le ayuda a desarrollarlas. La nostalgia hace mucho por la historia y el afecto que uno pueda tenerle. Es una lectura rápida ideal para aquellos que amamos el género de chicas mágicas.
CW: Mención de suicidio
---
"Magic Knight Rayearth" is a quick-read.
The art and character design are the high point, it has some beautiful and very dynamic layouts. Which is good because the story is quite simple and repetitive. So it's the art the element that keeps it interesting.
I was disappointed by the lack of world building, it even feels empty. I dn't know why should I care for this world.
The plot became boring fast, the MCs are doing the same things all the time. There is really no conflict. I kown that Zagato is the "final boss", but he is defeated so quickly that I have no time to enjoy the battle. And while the plot twist is good, it was not built correctly.
That being said, I must be in the minority but the abrupt and open ending left me satisfied, largely because the little I knew about Céfiro is not enough to worry about his well-being.
In general, it is a manga with good ideas, but has no time to develop them. Nostalgia does a lot for history. Still, it's a quick read for those of us who love the magical girl genre.
CW: Mention of suicide
---
"Magic Knight Rayearth" es un manga entretenido y de rápida lectura.
El arte y el diseño de personajes son el punto alto, a medida que avanzan los tomos hay unas puestas en página muy bonitas y muy dinámicas.
Lo cual es bueno porque la historia es bastante básica y, a partir del segundo tomo, repetitiva. Así que es el arte el que va llevando el ritmo.
Fue una decepción que no haya construcción del mundo, incluso se siente vacío. Y, si bien lo compararn con un RPG -y es una comparativa acertada-, no quita que sea un problema. Las protagonistas van avanzando de a poco, enfrentando a villanos, aprendiendo algo nuevo de su magia y llegan al jefe final. Relamente no hay conflicto.
Y hablando del villano, Zagato, me dejó con gusto a poco. Me gustan sus motivaciones, pero termina cediendo su lugar a otro personaje. Y si bien el plot twist es bueno, no fue construido correctamente.
Debo ser de la minoría pero el final abrupto y abierto me dejó conforme, en gran parte porque lo poco que conocí de Céfiro no alcanza para preocuparme por su bienestar.
En general, es un manga con buenas ideas, pero con un ritmo que no le ayuda a desarrollarlas. La nostalgia hace mucho por la historia y el afecto que uno pueda tenerle. Es una lectura rápida ideal para aquellos que amamos el género de chicas mágicas.
CW: Mención de suicidio
---
"Magic Knight Rayearth" is a quick-read.
The art and character design are the high point, it has some beautiful and very dynamic layouts. Which is good because the story is quite simple and repetitive. So it's the art the element that keeps it interesting.
I was disappointed by the lack of world building, it even feels empty. I dn't know why should I care for this world.
The plot became boring fast, the MCs are doing the same things all the time. There is really no conflict. I kown that Zagato is the "final boss", but he is defeated so quickly that I have no time to enjoy the battle. And while the plot twist is good, it was not built correctly.
That being said, I must be in the minority but the abrupt and open ending left me satisfied, largely because the little I knew about Céfiro is not enough to worry about his well-being.
In general, it is a manga with good ideas, but has no time to develop them. Nostalgia does a lot for history. Still, it's a quick read for those of us who love the magical girl genre.
CW: Mention of suicide
Displaying 1 - 30 of 137 reviews