First off let me say that I am an H.P. Lovecraft fanatic. No other author, save maybe Dean Koontz, has had more of an impact on my love of horror and directed my tendencies in the written word. And so, when I discovered the Arkham Horror collection of books, short stories, board games, and other forms of entertainment I have been on the look out for all things Arkham. This is my first experience with an Arkham Horror short story collection, and I must say, I was very happy with the majority of this collection. I have broken down the four stories below, but if you are looking for an overall review, I highly recommend this collection for any fan of cosmic and occult horror, especially for the Lovecraft fan. The one protentional downside for those uninitiated in H.P. Lovecraft and his mythos is the lack of explanation on some things. Especially the various gods, entities, creatures, and basic previous events. You are expected to have read and be able to recall a lot of information from various Lovecraft stories. For someone like me it was actually very refreshing and appreciated. But for those who haven’t read a lot of Lovecraft I suggest you start with the most popular stories (The Shadow Over Innsmouth, The Call of Cthulhu, The Dunwich Horror, and others) so you can go into these stories with more knowledge, and you will be able to appreciate at a deeper level.
Hour Of The Huntress: Being the first story in this collection I was looking forward to a strong start deep in Lovecraft mythos, cosmic horror, 1920s atmosphere, and creeping terror. But unfortunately, that is not the case. This story focuses on a young woman who has come to Arkham looking to reunite with her sister whom she abandoned to an unhealthy family life when they were younger. Even though physically she is described in the traditional “flapper” style her behavior and mannerisms are more akin to a modern feminist and it can become grating and overbearing at times. I found myself rooting against her from time to time and that is not something that I want in my protagonist. Her attitude and way of speaking to the more criminal types would have probably ended much worse for her if this was more of an accurate depiction of the time. When it comes to the supporting characters that is where this story shines. I found them to be much more interesting than the main character and I actually cared about their endings. As for the horror elements this was another area that lacked in my opinion. The threat was very short lived and while it was physically threatening and mildly hinted at greater things it was just too easy in all aspects. From summoning, control, and destruction it was something that didn’t seem like it would have required much research into forbidden and arcane knowledge (a Lovecraft staple) and could have been achieved by a trip to any local high school library. Overall, not a terrible story but I feel that it did fall short when you try and shoehorn it into the Lovecraft mythos.
The Dirge Of Reason: Coming off of the previous story I was not sure what to expect with the second selection. Thankfully I was presented with a much stronger entry that I feel connects itself to the mythos expertly. A somewhat disgruntled federal agent with a past (I love my classic 20’s style grumpy gumshoe) is charged with trying to discover why a large orchestra was completely destroyed along with a portion of a mansion just outside of Arkham. Between a standoffish police force, warring bootlegger groups, a wealthy powerful and arrogant woman, a nosy reporter, and the hidden cosmic horror this all comes together to create a very interesting story and investigation for our protagonist. Just like something straight from Lovecraft himself this story includes a completely unholy and unearthly horror that, while a terrible force on its own, is really just an insignificant taste of the true horror that lay beyond our stars and dimensions. The ending also leaves things open for a continuation and I for one would be thrilled to see a series with this protagonist and the various lurking terrors hidden within the boundaries of Arkham.
Ire Of The Void: I found this story to be a slight dip in quality. Starting out it did have me interested and I was really curious to see where we were headed. The main character (a depressed, isolated, and obsessed professor of astronomy) is well fleshed out and I did find him to be interesting. When he starts to accompany a fellow, and world renowned, scientist on a mission to try and find abnormalities in physical space, things picked up even more for me. I was really interested in the explanations of the disturbances, the backstories of the locations, and how this was all building to a dark and terrible explanation. Add to that the violent and bloody first encounter with the entities and I was all in. Unfortunately, after that the story takes a pretty steady downward slide into questionable and uninteresting events and descriptions. Even when there is dimensional travel, hostile plains of existence, and deadly pursuit it all felt dull. I felt that these events and settings could have been revised into something that really gave a sense of terror and foreboding that would bring up a sense of dread in the reader. But what I feel we got instead was just some strange environments that didn’t inspire fear, but more a feeling of awkwardness and uninterest. A sliver lining is the two distinct entities in this story. Running into either of these creatures would be sure to drive any human mad, but at least it would be short lived as they certainly would not live long enough realize their growing insanity.
The Deep Gate: The final story in this collection is exactly what I was looking for. I can not speak highly enough about how well it builds tension, unease, and fits so perfectly into the Lovecraft mythos. A story in direct connection to Lovecraft’s The Shadow Over Innsmouth, it improves on the original but it also does nothing to alter or lessen the events and world created previously. From the very start I found the protagonist to be someone I could connect with and understand. He is a haunted old sailor who’s family history is one of lets say questionable aspect. If you are familiar with the Innsmouth story you will certainly understand what he is going though when you find out his full name. I will let you discover that for yourself. He becomes tangled up with a young woman who has discovered a tome in her library that appears to be counting down to Armageddon. When he discovers the location the prediction is directing them towards is one that ties into his past, and the overwhelming dread he has been feeling, he knows that he has to be the one to try and stop the end times. With scenes of underwater horror, terrifying creatures, and even a portal to a cyclopean city of cosmic horror and death, I found that I was always looking forward to the next stage in the story. The ending also is fantastic, in my opinion. It screams Lovecraft in how it leaves the reader knowing that even though the day maybe won, you are still powerless to the real immense evil that in the blink of an eye can end everything and everyone in existence.