What do you think?
Rate this book
Canary #1
When a horrific shooting disturbs the peace of a sleepy town in the Old West, Marshal Holt is called upon to investigate. But as Holt digs deeper, he discovers that evil may just run to the core, and it all seems to stem from a place called CANARY. From writer SCOTT SNYDER and artist DAN PANOSIAN come a western tale that's make your blood run cold...
Part of the Comixology Originals line of exclusive digital content only available on Comixology and Kindle. Read for free as part of your subscription to Comixology Unlimited, Kindle Unlimited or Amazon Prime. Also available for purchase via Comixology, Kindle and in print via Dark Horse Books.
Part of the Comixology Originals line of exclusive digital content only available on Comixology and Kindle. Read for free as part of your subscription to Comixology Unlimited, Kindle Unlimited or Amazon Prime. Also available for purchase via Comixology, Kindle and in print via Dark Horse Books.
29 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 19, 2022
233 people are currently reading
159 people want to read
About the author
Scott Snyder
1,781 books5,134 followersScott Snyder is the Eisner and Harvey Award winning writer on DC Comics Batman, Swamp Thing, and his original series for Vertigo, American Vampire. He is also the author of the short story collection, Voodoo Heart, published by the Dial Press in 2006. The paperback version was published in the summer of 2007.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
February 24, 2024
The wild west meets something sinister.
William Holt, a celebrity cowboy with dime store novels written about him, is sent in by the US Marshals to solve a string of bizarre murders.
He confronts the family of a creepy kid who slit a woman's throat because he was supposedly upset by her use of a lizard egg in a presentation about statehood. It makes no sense, so what's actually going on?
There is a veiled reference to something that happened to him when he tracked down the man who made him famous, and you see a bit of what happened but I'm holding out judgment for now.
An overall Mulder & Scully meet Walker Texas Ranger vibe - if you like that kind of thing.
I'm actually kinda interested.
William Holt, a celebrity cowboy with dime store novels written about him, is sent in by the US Marshals to solve a string of bizarre murders.
He confronts the family of a creepy kid who slit a woman's throat because he was supposedly upset by her use of a lizard egg in a presentation about statehood. It makes no sense, so what's actually going on?
There is a veiled reference to something that happened to him when he tracked down the man who made him famous, and you see a bit of what happened but I'm holding out judgment for now.
An overall Mulder & Scully meet Walker Texas Ranger vibe - if you like that kind of thing.
I'm actually kinda interested.
August 1, 2022
A kid cutting his schoolteacher’s throat with a knife is just the latest in a string of bizarre incidents in and around 1890s Utah. A theory is floated that it’s due to the water coming from the old Canary Mine in the mountains and Marshal Azrael Holt is dispatched to join a geologist in investigating the alleged source. But the Marshal’s bloody past ain’t done with him jest yet…
Scott Snyder and Dan Panosian’s Canary #1 is… shockingly half decent. The Comixology Original label always makes me expect the worst. It’s not an amazing comic but it’s a solid western/horror blend that’s sometimes entertaining.
It’s rare to see Panosian drawing comics these days and he remains a very skilled cartoonist. I particularly liked his colouring choices, giving us orange and yellow skies - I get that it underlines the autumnal setting but it also lends the comic an otherworldly atmosphere that complements the supernatural aspects well. I didn’t think the Marshal’s mask design was very good though - it looks confusing more than anything (it’s meant to be a coffin, or an upside-down cross, or teeth, or…?).
I liked Holt’s ornery dialogue with all and sundry, and his don’t-give-no-fucks attitude is amusing. The Family Apple shootout is textbook western though and the “cop with one month to go before retirement” angle is such a cliche. Johnny Apple himself is an effectively creepy kid but the killer in the flashback was more boring than disturbing. Get this: he eats a fish, raw! Hmm.
Still, Canary #1 is a promising start and I’ll stick around to see how it all pans out - it’s worth a look if you’ve got a Prime or Comixology Unlimited subscription as it’s included. Two solid Scott Snyder/Comixology Originals in one year? Lord a’mercy, we certainly are living in the end times!
Scott Snyder and Dan Panosian’s Canary #1 is… shockingly half decent. The Comixology Original label always makes me expect the worst. It’s not an amazing comic but it’s a solid western/horror blend that’s sometimes entertaining.
It’s rare to see Panosian drawing comics these days and he remains a very skilled cartoonist. I particularly liked his colouring choices, giving us orange and yellow skies - I get that it underlines the autumnal setting but it also lends the comic an otherworldly atmosphere that complements the supernatural aspects well. I didn’t think the Marshal’s mask design was very good though - it looks confusing more than anything (it’s meant to be a coffin, or an upside-down cross, or teeth, or…?).
I liked Holt’s ornery dialogue with all and sundry, and his don’t-give-no-fucks attitude is amusing. The Family Apple shootout is textbook western though and the “cop with one month to go before retirement” angle is such a cliche. Johnny Apple himself is an effectively creepy kid but the killer in the flashback was more boring than disturbing. Get this: he eats a fish, raw! Hmm.
Still, Canary #1 is a promising start and I’ll stick around to see how it all pans out - it’s worth a look if you’ve got a Prime or Comixology Unlimited subscription as it’s included. Two solid Scott Snyder/Comixology Originals in one year? Lord a’mercy, we certainly are living in the end times!
February 27, 2024
Dark and deep
The woods are lovely dark and deep and Snyder's story culls the sleep.
This is a dark outing with a blend of the western and horror.
Book starts the series and looks quite enticing.
Too short to form a solid judgement but enough wow to follow on in the series.
This creepy story has us deep in Utah where strange happenings bring Marshal into the mix to investigate the cases. The clues seemed to point to the Canary mines and the waters emerging out from it which were causing the problems in the community. The violence is brutal.
The story seems to take a leaf out of the American Vampire series by Scott and Stephen King which was also set in the wild west.
This explores a more obscure subject and the art is in sync with the story.
The series catches on fast.
The woods are lovely dark and deep and Snyder's story culls the sleep.
This is a dark outing with a blend of the western and horror.
Book starts the series and looks quite enticing.
Too short to form a solid judgement but enough wow to follow on in the series.
This creepy story has us deep in Utah where strange happenings bring Marshal into the mix to investigate the cases. The clues seemed to point to the Canary mines and the waters emerging out from it which were causing the problems in the community. The violence is brutal.
The story seems to take a leaf out of the American Vampire series by Scott and Stephen King which was also set in the wild west.
This explores a more obscure subject and the art is in sync with the story.
The series catches on fast.
January 5, 2023
Amazon art
Dark story telling
Badass protagonist
Eerie settings
Wild wild west
And some good old comic style
Would recommend
Dark story telling
Badass protagonist
Eerie settings
Wild wild west
And some good old comic style
Would recommend
January 12, 2024
Could have been good. Improbable characters using improbable theatrical prose and a poor excuse of an ending killed it. And Panosian’s art didn’t impress me one bit though I kinda liked his weird colours.
October 27, 2022
Interesting Western
Monsters in the old West? Demonic possession? Evil incarnate? All possibilities from this first chapter n Scott Snyder's "Canary". Snyder's writing is, as always, too notch. A master storyteller. Love the artwork throughout the book too. Daniel is great at drawing the beauty of the West as well as the ugliness of what this story deals with. Definitely recommend checking out "Canary"!
Monsters in the old West? Demonic possession? Evil incarnate? All possibilities from this first chapter n Scott Snyder's "Canary". Snyder's writing is, as always, too notch. A master storyteller. Love the artwork throughout the book too. Daniel is great at drawing the beauty of the West as well as the ugliness of what this story deals with. Definitely recommend checking out "Canary"!
January 2, 2023
"Of course. Sorry, it just... happened so fast. She was using them different eggs there to argue that the future of the territory is up to us. How it still can become anything, good, bad. There's a quail egg, a tortoise, a rattler. One is missing, I think, it might be a… right, right. She was midsentence when the boy, he just walked up, pulled out a straight razor, and cut her throat. Half the goddamned town was watching."
Once again Comixology have teamed up with Scott Snyder to produce a new original series. I couldn't resist giving it a go having enjoyed Clear (Comixology Originals) #1, Night of the Ghoul (comiXology Originals) #1 and We Have Demons (comiXology Originals) #1.
This time we go back to the old-west, around the time of the formation of the Union. When a horrific killing of a teacher occurs, the infamous Marshal Holt is called in to investigate the crime. When the clues point to a church going young boy the mystery deepens and Holt has to ride out to the family's ranch to confront the boy.
Right up my street, with a horror feel and a possible supernatural edge brewing, this gets 5 stars.
Once again Comixology have teamed up with Scott Snyder to produce a new original series. I couldn't resist giving it a go having enjoyed Clear (Comixology Originals) #1, Night of the Ghoul (comiXology Originals) #1 and We Have Demons (comiXology Originals) #1.
This time we go back to the old-west, around the time of the formation of the Union. When a horrific killing of a teacher occurs, the infamous Marshal Holt is called in to investigate the crime. When the clues point to a church going young boy the mystery deepens and Holt has to ride out to the family's ranch to confront the boy.
Right up my street, with a horror feel and a possible supernatural edge brewing, this gets 5 stars.
January 11, 2024
Love westerns and add in some creepy mysticism and you have a great diversion :)
January 15, 2024
3.5 stars—-
I wish there was an Omnibus entry for these 6 volumes, but I’m just gonna rate all of them as 1 entry here.
I wish there was an Omnibus entry for these 6 volumes, but I’m just gonna rate all of them as 1 entry here.
March 27, 2023
Old West. Mystery egg. Creepy kid. Badass Marshal (who sometimes wears a mask). Oh and last but certainly not least - Scott Snyder.
What's not to like?
I'm definitely intrigued enough to continue. Plus these are free with Amazon Prime.
3.5 Stars Rounded to 3
What's not to like?
I'm definitely intrigued enough to continue. Plus these are free with Amazon Prime.
3.5 Stars Rounded to 3
December 26, 2023
A solid start to this Western Horror series.
I particularly love the Graphic Artists colour choices, the red sky and the reflections are so gorgeous.
Excited to read more in this series, nice perk that it’s free on Amazon Prime Reading also.
I particularly love the Graphic Artists colour choices, the red sky and the reflections are so gorgeous.
Excited to read more in this series, nice perk that it’s free on Amazon Prime Reading also.
June 5, 2023
Amazing!!
July 7, 2023
The story is decent and the art is great, but the writing is somewhat amateur and reeks of poor editing. There are strange mistakes such as parentheses used in speech bubbles, odd word orders in sentences, and overuse/misuse of commas. It's unclear whether or not the author is aware of the existence of the hyphen.
This series was recommended to me on reddit, which led me to read the first book for free via Prime. Honestly until I came here to write this review I was assuming that the author was an up-and-comer or self-publisher taking a crack at their first comic. I must say I'm a bit surprised to learn that this author is by no means a beginner and is in fact quite well-established.
Again, the story is solid but the writing quality is quite immersion-breaking for me so I will not be continuing the series. A good editor could solve all of the issues quite easily.
This series was recommended to me on reddit, which led me to read the first book for free via Prime. Honestly until I came here to write this review I was assuming that the author was an up-and-comer or self-publisher taking a crack at their first comic. I must say I'm a bit surprised to learn that this author is by no means a beginner and is in fact quite well-established.
Again, the story is solid but the writing quality is quite immersion-breaking for me so I will not be continuing the series. A good editor could solve all of the issues quite easily.
July 10, 2024
Unexpected horror masterpiece
I wasn't sure what this story was about, as I had never heard of it before. The covers are what attracted me (hats off to the excellent interior artwork as well. It almost tells the story without the need for words), but the story is what kept me turning the page. More cinematic than most actual cinema these days. Characters feel real, and fleshed out, without much exposition actually given. Shocking and horrific, and not overly predictable. Highly recommended for fans of westerns and horror stories. A great start, I'm looking forward to continuing this journey.
I wasn't sure what this story was about, as I had never heard of it before. The covers are what attracted me (hats off to the excellent interior artwork as well. It almost tells the story without the need for words), but the story is what kept me turning the page. More cinematic than most actual cinema these days. Characters feel real, and fleshed out, without much exposition actually given. Shocking and horrific, and not overly predictable. Highly recommended for fans of westerns and horror stories. A great start, I'm looking forward to continuing this journey.
Read
February 28, 2023Snyder does it again
Snyder does it yet again. This is a stunning first issue that pulls you along with a constant sense of intrigue that is permanently shifting from one point to the next. I don't think there's a genre that this man can't turn his hand to.
It goes without saying that the art here is jaw dropping. The use of colour and brush strokes has you feeling constantly on edge.
Snyder does it yet again. This is a stunning first issue that pulls you along with a constant sense of intrigue that is permanently shifting from one point to the next. I don't think there's a genre that this man can't turn his hand to.
It goes without saying that the art here is jaw dropping. The use of colour and brush strokes has you feeling constantly on edge.
April 7, 2023
Curious Build up
This comixology original starts well and builds up the mystery without dropping any clues whatsoever. The story introduces us to the lead protagonist and shows us a world where violence is on the rise. The catch being that this violence is coming unexpectedly from common folks.
The artwork has its very distinctive feel which bodes well with the wild wild west setting of the story so far.
Overall, a decent attempt
This comixology original starts well and builds up the mystery without dropping any clues whatsoever. The story introduces us to the lead protagonist and shows us a world where violence is on the rise. The catch being that this violence is coming unexpectedly from common folks.
The artwork has its very distinctive feel which bodes well with the wild wild west setting of the story so far.
Overall, a decent attempt
Read
July 15, 2023Canary in a gold mine
This is the first book outside the mainstream Marvel/DC world apart from Captain Canuck which I recommend. It's dark and gritty, this can easily be a movie/series.
I was initially fazed by the artwork but I got used to it as I read on.
I chose a 4/5 because it was an introduction to the world and characters.
This is the first book outside the mainstream Marvel/DC world apart from Captain Canuck which I recommend. It's dark and gritty, this can easily be a movie/series.
I was initially fazed by the artwork but I got used to it as I read on.
I chose a 4/5 because it was an introduction to the world and characters.
December 31, 2023
A horror/western tale about strange deaths and a marshal who must find out what's going on. The coloration and the drawing reminded me of old western book. The narration cuts like a knife but is more strange than really helpful to the plot. Murderers? Possesses? The finale with the original target leaves the ending open to all these interpretations.
December 10, 2022
I just read this one all random like on Comixology. It's about a series of crazy murders in the old west and a marshall with a mask trying to deal with the problem. Seems like a kind of horror western--the first issue was pretty interesting, with good art and some creepy visuals.
December 12, 2022
Great First Issue
It very nicely sets the stage without telegraphing where the story is going. The art is impeccable, too. Reminds me of a Belgian or French comic book, Blueberry. Looking forward to the next issue.
It very nicely sets the stage without telegraphing where the story is going. The art is impeccable, too. Reminds me of a Belgian or French comic book, Blueberry. Looking forward to the next issue.
December 18, 2022
Ace storytelling and visuals
The storytelling, character building, and visuals in this first issue of Canary are all ace. A few pages, and you’ve dived right in, and can’t wait to see this story unfold.
The storytelling, character building, and visuals in this first issue of Canary are all ace. A few pages, and you’ve dived right in, and can’t wait to see this story unfold.
May 11, 2023
Love the fact that this is a weird western, and the main character is pretty cool, but the big draw here is the artwork. These comixology originals are a mixed-bag but this one seems like it could be pretty decent.
July 31, 2022
Great art. Pretty good introduction to the story, but doesn’t move it very far along. The other two issues will have to move the story along very quickly. Worth reading.
August 2, 2022
Wild West Mystery
Looking good so far, I like the illustrative style & this looks like being a promising mystery, complete with a tough no nonsense badass US Marshall …
Looking good so far, I like the illustrative style & this looks like being a promising mystery, complete with a tough no nonsense badass US Marshall …
September 7, 2022
Spooky, mysterious and adventurous
October 26, 2022
intro
Meh. Not exactly withering to read the next graphic novel. Do like Snyder tho. But we’ll see. Yes we will see.
Meh. Not exactly withering to read the next graphic novel. Do like Snyder tho. But we’ll see. Yes we will see.
November 7, 2022
something different
great comic. not myusual style, but glad I found it! I am glad it wasrecommend on the app. also short read.
great comic. not myusual style, but glad I found it! I am glad it wasrecommend on the app. also short read.
Read
November 29, 2022Great start
Interesting story, seems to be a lot under the hood. But typical westerm hero bullet proof, nice read, will comtinue reading,
Interesting story, seems to be a lot under the hood. But typical westerm hero bullet proof, nice read, will comtinue reading,
December 28, 2022
A bit confused throughout, felt like parts of the story were missing but the concept is interesting enough and I don't usually read westerns so I'll give it a try. The art is nice as well.
December 31, 2022
Cawpile: 5.07 3*
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews