What do you think?
Rate this book
Kindred #2
Shiloh
Award-winning author Lori Benton delivers a rich historical novel of faith, hope, and second chances.
December 1795
A year has passed since Ian Cameron reluctantly sent his uncle’s former slave Seona and their son, Gabriel, north to his kin in Boston. Determined to fully release them, Ian strives to make a life at Mountain Laurel, his inherited plantation, along with Judith, the wife he’s vowed to love and cherish. But when tragedy leaves him alone with his daughter, Mandy, and his three remaining slaves, he decides to return north. An act of kindness on the journey provides Ian the chance to obtain land near the frontier settlement of Shiloh, New York. Perhaps even the hope for a new life with those he still holds dear.
In Boston, Seona has taken her first tentative steps as a free woman, while trying to banish Ian from her heart. The Cameron family thinks she and Gabriel should remain under their protection. Seona’s mother, Lily, thinks it’s time they strike out on their own. Then Ian arrives, offering a second chance Seona hadn’t dared imagine. But the wide-open frontier of Shiloh feels as boundless and terrifying as her newfound freedom―a place of new friends and new enemies, where deep bonds are renewed but old hurts stand ready to rear their heads. It will take every ounce of faith and courage Ian and Seona can muster to fight for their family and their future . . . together.
December 1795
A year has passed since Ian Cameron reluctantly sent his uncle’s former slave Seona and their son, Gabriel, north to his kin in Boston. Determined to fully release them, Ian strives to make a life at Mountain Laurel, his inherited plantation, along with Judith, the wife he’s vowed to love and cherish. But when tragedy leaves him alone with his daughter, Mandy, and his three remaining slaves, he decides to return north. An act of kindness on the journey provides Ian the chance to obtain land near the frontier settlement of Shiloh, New York. Perhaps even the hope for a new life with those he still holds dear.
In Boston, Seona has taken her first tentative steps as a free woman, while trying to banish Ian from her heart. The Cameron family thinks she and Gabriel should remain under their protection. Seona’s mother, Lily, thinks it’s time they strike out on their own. Then Ian arrives, offering a second chance Seona hadn’t dared imagine. But the wide-open frontier of Shiloh feels as boundless and terrifying as her newfound freedom―a place of new friends and new enemies, where deep bonds are renewed but old hurts stand ready to rear their heads. It will take every ounce of faith and courage Ian and Seona can muster to fight for their family and their future . . . together.
446 pages, Paperback
Published September 8, 2021
24 people are currently reading
378 people want to read
About the author
Lori Benton
18 books985 followersLori Benton was born and raised east of the Appalachian Mountains, surrounded by early American and family history going back to the 1600s. Her novels transport readers to the 18th century, where she brings to life the Colonial and early Federal periods of American history, creating a melting pot of characters drawn from both sides of a turbulent and shifting frontier, brought together in the bonds of God's transforming grace.
When she isn’t writing, reading, or researching 18th century history, Lori enjoys exploring the mountains with her husband.
Burning Sky, Lori's debut novel, was a finalist for the ECPA 2014 Christian Book Award, and winner of the 2014 Christy Award for First Novel, Historical, and Book of the Year.
When she isn’t writing, reading, or researching 18th century history, Lori enjoys exploring the mountains with her husband.
Burning Sky, Lori's debut novel, was a finalist for the ECPA 2014 Christian Book Award, and winner of the 2014 Christy Award for First Novel, Historical, and Book of the Year.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
May 3, 2021
An absolute triumph! With nuance and sensitivity, this tale explores the complexities of life after freedom from bondage. It’s a landscape of hope, fear, choices, love, surrender, and ultimately, victory over that which ensnares. The writing is as lush as the frontier world it portrays. Shiloh is so powerful, and the characters so richly drawn, it could only have come from master storyteller Lori Benton’s pen.
That was my official endorsement, above. But for the rest of you, I'll add this. Shiloh would work as a stand-alone but would be even better if you've read Mountain Laurel, the first in the Kindred duology. And it would be EVEN BETTER if you have also read her 2013 debut novel, Burning Sky, which is one of my favorite books of all time, so don't hesitate to read that if you haven't already.
That was my official endorsement, above. But for the rest of you, I'll add this. Shiloh would work as a stand-alone but would be even better if you've read Mountain Laurel, the first in the Kindred duology. And it would be EVEN BETTER if you have also read her 2013 debut novel, Burning Sky, which is one of my favorite books of all time, so don't hesitate to read that if you haven't already.
Read
October 11, 2021𝘔𝘰𝘶𝘯𝘵𝘢𝘪𝘯 𝘓𝘢𝘶𝘳𝘦𝘭 was one of the most tangled loved stories I've ever read so I felt compelled to see how Lori Benton would tease out a happy ending for Ian and Seona. As with book #1 in the series, 𝘚𝘩𝘪𝘭𝘰𝘩 has a rather complex plot. This, coupled with its large cast (including characters from Benton's previous novels), makes it a story that should be read slowly and thoughtfully.
My Favorite Quote: "Your heart is a garden and His word the seed. It'll grow there if ye sow it."
My Favorite Quote: "Your heart is a garden and His word the seed. It'll grow there if ye sow it."
October 7, 2021
3.5
If you enjoy a good historical, Lori Benton is an absolute must read! Her research is impeccable and her writing stunning. Her descriptions are so vivid, you feel as if you are there. I thoroughly enjoy her work and recommend it.
My thanks to Tyndale House for a copy of this book via Net Galley. The opinion here is my own.
If you enjoy a good historical, Lori Benton is an absolute must read! Her research is impeccable and her writing stunning. Her descriptions are so vivid, you feel as if you are there. I thoroughly enjoy her work and recommend it.
My thanks to Tyndale House for a copy of this book via Net Galley. The opinion here is my own.
October 24, 2022
1795-1797 New York
Why did I wait so long to read the conclusion to the Kindred Series? Will Ian and Seona finally find happiness?
As is the author's strength, she beautifully brings the time and location to life.
Why did I wait so long to read the conclusion to the Kindred Series? Will Ian and Seona finally find happiness?
As is the author's strength, she beautifully brings the time and location to life.
April 15, 2022
I love when authors do some world building. As mentioned in the author's note at the end of the book, 'Shiloh' is a sequel, not only to the first 'Kindred' novel ('Mountain Laurel'), but to her first novel, 'Burning Sky'. I would highly recommend that you read both of those novels before reading this one, though I don't know that it necessarily matters if you read Burning Sky before Mountain Laurel.
My heart broke for Ian, Seona, and Judith at the close of Mountain Laurel, and I wanted to know what would happen for each of them next. This novel answered those questions in a very poignant manner.
While I loved reacquainting myself with not only the Cameron clan, but the MacGregors, what really shone for me was the theme of this novel: trusting in the Lord. Once again, sweet Malcom reminded both Seona and Ian of where they needed to put their trust, no matter the fear that they were facing.
I think I spent the last 5 chapters or so of this book in near constant tears at the reminders of God's perfect grace, even when things (or perhaps ESPECIALLY! when things) are going wrong at every turn.
My heart broke for Ian, Seona, and Judith at the close of Mountain Laurel, and I wanted to know what would happen for each of them next. This novel answered those questions in a very poignant manner.
While I loved reacquainting myself with not only the Cameron clan, but the MacGregors, what really shone for me was the theme of this novel: trusting in the Lord. Once again, sweet Malcom reminded both Seona and Ian of where they needed to put their trust, no matter the fear that they were facing.
I think I spent the last 5 chapters or so of this book in near constant tears at the reminders of God's perfect grace, even when things (or perhaps ESPECIALLY! when things) are going wrong at every turn.
December 1, 2021
A wonderfully complex and heartfelt story. I made sure to read it slowly so I could savor the beautiful writing. After reading Mountain Laurel, I couldn't wait for Shiloh to release so I could find out how Lori Benton would bring a satisfying ending to these characters' stories. It didn't disappoint! And seeing characters I remembered from Burning Sky felt like catching up with old friends.
February 4, 2022
This book was worth the agonizing wait that came from reading the first book an entire year before this second one's publication. It was so good to reunite with characters from across the pages of all of Lori Benton's books, especially Joseph Tames-His-Horse. I wish we could have seen more of his story firsthand, rather than hearing it related after the fact by others, nevertheless I was touched and grinning over the long-awaited finale to his story! A very satisfying read rich in detail, gritty in truth, and sweeping in scope. I'm sad to say goodbye. Super impressed with the author's ability to weave so many of her books together!
January 31, 2022
Can’t say enough good things about this latest novel by author Lori Benton. Absolutely excellent in every way. The messages she shares through this story couldn’t be more perfect for the troubling and uncertain days we're living in. Guaranteed to encourage, strengthen, and refresh your spirit. What a gift from this amazing author. And if I may say so, a gift from God. Highly recommend!
*I would read Mountain Laurel first to get the very most from this story. Both written with such skill and mastery, I don’t want you to miss a speck of the goodness in store. Bravo, Lori Benton!
*I would read Mountain Laurel first to get the very most from this story. Both written with such skill and mastery, I don’t want you to miss a speck of the goodness in store. Bravo, Lori Benton!
December 6, 2021
" . . . but we ask for Your protection in this place we've come to settle .. . . that Ye'd be the rock this man choose to build his house upon. Give him courage to go where Ye lead and do what Ye tell him to do."
Ian Cameron's life desperately needed a sure foundation. Having been rooted, uprooted, grieved and loved, he was once again following God's voice into places unknown. Intending to make a life for himself and his expanding family in Mountain Laurel, while struggling to come to terms with the absence of those he still loved, unforeseen circumstances provide a tenuous path forward, northward, offering a glimmer of hope that grace can indeed be enough. However, there is one question lingering in the forefront of his mind, what will Seona want?
Seona's life as a freewoman has been an adjustment at best, but she, along with her mother and young son, have considered living under the Cameron family roof in Boston over the past months a blessing, although recently they have broached the topic of striking out on their own. When Ian arrives unannounced with his young daughter in tow, along with plans that have the potential to forever separate or join them together again, will Seona muster up the courage to choose faith over fear? One thing is for certain, neither choice is easy.
A glorious love story tucked neatly into the rarity of a great story! Every . . . . single . . . word has been scripted carefully, strategically and beautifully into just the right place at just the right time. What a privilege to spend time again with most beloved characters, not only from the first book in this series, but also from a previous stand-alone. Carved with precision, the story line not only offers keen insights into God's Word, but illustrates its many applications, for I daresay each of us has at one time or another put too much faith in the created, rather than the Creator, nearly drowning us in fear.
" There will always be fears, Seona, for as long as we live in a fallen world. They stalk us. They roar. Make it hard to hear the Almighty, see His hand at work. But ye've the power to refuse fear a welcome into your heart."
Ian Cameron's life desperately needed a sure foundation. Having been rooted, uprooted, grieved and loved, he was once again following God's voice into places unknown. Intending to make a life for himself and his expanding family in Mountain Laurel, while struggling to come to terms with the absence of those he still loved, unforeseen circumstances provide a tenuous path forward, northward, offering a glimmer of hope that grace can indeed be enough. However, there is one question lingering in the forefront of his mind, what will Seona want?
Seona's life as a freewoman has been an adjustment at best, but she, along with her mother and young son, have considered living under the Cameron family roof in Boston over the past months a blessing, although recently they have broached the topic of striking out on their own. When Ian arrives unannounced with his young daughter in tow, along with plans that have the potential to forever separate or join them together again, will Seona muster up the courage to choose faith over fear? One thing is for certain, neither choice is easy.
A glorious love story tucked neatly into the rarity of a great story! Every . . . . single . . . word has been scripted carefully, strategically and beautifully into just the right place at just the right time. What a privilege to spend time again with most beloved characters, not only from the first book in this series, but also from a previous stand-alone. Carved with precision, the story line not only offers keen insights into God's Word, but illustrates its many applications, for I daresay each of us has at one time or another put too much faith in the created, rather than the Creator, nearly drowning us in fear.
" There will always be fears, Seona, for as long as we live in a fallen world. They stalk us. They roar. Make it hard to hear the Almighty, see His hand at work. But ye've the power to refuse fear a welcome into your heart."
September 8, 2021
With her typical flare for bringing frontier history and romance onto the page and holding readers in a grip until the end, Lori Benton continues her story of redemption and love begun in Mountain Laurel. While Ian and Seona rediscover love and carve a new beginning in the wilderness through faults and stumbles, other characters' stories come to life too. I also loved how this story intertwined some of the authors earlier works (while not being a sequel to them in itself). Especially enthralling to me was the return of characters from her novel Burning Sky. (Oh, how I loved that story!) I've always imagined a happy ending for one particular character from that book. (Can you guess who I mean?) Anyone else who has loved that story will enjoy finding that and other happily-ever-afters in Shiloh. Adventure, danger, suspense, along with second chances and new beginnings--you'll discover them all in Lori Benton's rich, new historical.
I received and ARC from Netgalley. This review expresses my honest opinion.
I received and ARC from Netgalley. This review expresses my honest opinion.
September 1, 2021
A compelling conclusion to the series begun in Mountain Laurel.
Seamlessly adding characters from other books to join Ian and Seona's journey, made this feel like one epic family saga. The index of names for reference in the introduction looks rather daunting, but it wasn't hard to follow the storyline. Highly recommend reading Mountain Laurel first (and Burning Sky also) to avoid spoilers.
Well written, pulling on every emotion, this author never fails to create a masterful novel full of historical detail and human struggle, but leaves a path of hope and faith to follow to the end. The elements of parenting, rocky romantic relationships, and the pull of family ties were something I could latch onto and identify with. Added adventure with danger, and bravery shown from many characters, brought exciting parts towards the end. There are so many lovely lines to savor, especially the wisdom and faith of Malcolm. Watching Ian and Seona struggle and grow in faith was inspirational; genuine faith in action.
"Be strong and of a good courage, fear not, nor be afraid of them; for the Lord thy God, he it is that doth go with thee; he will not fail thee, nor forsake thee."
Highly recommend for historical fiction fans who enjoy epic early American frontier stories, with faith and romance.
4.5 stars
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
Seamlessly adding characters from other books to join Ian and Seona's journey, made this feel like one epic family saga. The index of names for reference in the introduction looks rather daunting, but it wasn't hard to follow the storyline. Highly recommend reading Mountain Laurel first (and Burning Sky also) to avoid spoilers.
Well written, pulling on every emotion, this author never fails to create a masterful novel full of historical detail and human struggle, but leaves a path of hope and faith to follow to the end. The elements of parenting, rocky romantic relationships, and the pull of family ties were something I could latch onto and identify with. Added adventure with danger, and bravery shown from many characters, brought exciting parts towards the end. There are so many lovely lines to savor, especially the wisdom and faith of Malcolm. Watching Ian and Seona struggle and grow in faith was inspirational; genuine faith in action.
"Be strong and of a good courage, fear not, nor be afraid of them; for the Lord thy God, he it is that doth go with thee; he will not fail thee, nor forsake thee."
Highly recommend for historical fiction fans who enjoy epic early American frontier stories, with faith and romance.
4.5 stars
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
January 6, 2022
This is a tremendous story.
This is one of those books that I almost don't even know where to start to share a review.
I loved the book. It's a satisfying conclusion to this captivating series by Lori Benton.
The beloved characters are back. The storyline follows both Ian and Seona, and the choices they must make regarding their lives.
Well written, well thought-out, deep and realistic characters. Charming, detailed setting.
All around, this is an amazing story.
(It definitely requires being read after Mountain Laurel, but that is another book not-to-be-missed)
Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review, and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255
This is one of those books that I almost don't even know where to start to share a review.
I loved the book. It's a satisfying conclusion to this captivating series by Lori Benton.
The beloved characters are back. The storyline follows both Ian and Seona, and the choices they must make regarding their lives.
Well written, well thought-out, deep and realistic characters. Charming, detailed setting.
All around, this is an amazing story.
(It definitely requires being read after Mountain Laurel, but that is another book not-to-be-missed)
Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review, and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255
October 28, 2021
Shiloh was a great sequel to Mountain Laurel. The first book was such a complicated story and didn't really leave you with a "happily ever after", so I was hopeful this one would have a happy ending.
This story yet again pulled on the emotions. I felt like the characters were real and enjoyed following them along on their journey. The story has some really intense moments where I didn't know if something bad was going to happen - and I enjoyed that element of suspense.
All in all, Shiloh was a very good read and I thought the ending was good. I do look forward to reading the next book when it releases.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
This story yet again pulled on the emotions. I felt like the characters were real and enjoyed following them along on their journey. The story has some really intense moments where I didn't know if something bad was going to happen - and I enjoyed that element of suspense.
All in all, Shiloh was a very good read and I thought the ending was good. I do look forward to reading the next book when it releases.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
September 30, 2022
Though it was a little slower, this book was a deep, tender, and satisfying conclusion to Mountain Laurel.
July 6, 2022
I think if I were to go back and read this one and it's prequel and sequel, I might give it 4 stars altogether. I know that doesn't add up, but you'll just have to trust me on that haha. Overall, this series could really be a study on the human... His life, temperament, situation, experiences, emotions, growth in spiritual life etc etc... It would probably be a good book (series) for a book club discussion. I was impressed how Lori weaved together so many of her main characters from her other books into this series! Quite ingenious actually. This one was very good in the beginning and the end, but really crawled through the middle.
August 21, 2021
I loved this story. The 18th century frontier is one of my favorite time periods and settings. This book brings a complex and emotional story to a truly satisfying end. Not only does the book continue the story of Ian Cameron, a young man with a complex past, whose life continues to get complicated even further when his wife dies in childbirth leaving him with Mandy, his toddler daughter, to raise on his own, but it brings back to life some of my favorite people from a past novel.
Ian eventually sells the ailing plantation he inherited in North Carolina to his neighbor and sets out toward Boston with his remaining three slaves whom he has freed, each of whom have their own issues. The other half of the tangle of his life awaits him in Boston in the form of Seona, a beautiful young woman who was his Uncle’s former slave, and their son, Gabriel. When Ian stops to help a stranger along the way, his help is repaid with a ticket to his future, an opportunity to settle in upstate New York.
As Ian strives to reconcile his wants and needs with those of his children and the woman he hopes will eventually become his wife, he must learn to exercise patience and faith. With the help of his neighbors, the MacGregors, Ian begins to carve a life for himself and all the people under his care. When a shady character from the past starts roaming around Shiloh, it takes an old friend of the MacGregors, Joseph Tames-His-Horse, to put an end to the turmoil created.
A beautiful ending to a story filled with good people, complex people, community, second choices, redemption, and faith! Join Ian and Seona, the MacGregors, and the community of Shiloh in this beautiful journey! I strongly recommend that you read Mountain Laurel prior to reading Shiloh. Both are perfect read for lovers of historical fiction!
This complimentary ARC copy was received from Tyndale House Publishers and NetGalley. The above thoughts and opinions are wholly my own.
Ian eventually sells the ailing plantation he inherited in North Carolina to his neighbor and sets out toward Boston with his remaining three slaves whom he has freed, each of whom have their own issues. The other half of the tangle of his life awaits him in Boston in the form of Seona, a beautiful young woman who was his Uncle’s former slave, and their son, Gabriel. When Ian stops to help a stranger along the way, his help is repaid with a ticket to his future, an opportunity to settle in upstate New York.
As Ian strives to reconcile his wants and needs with those of his children and the woman he hopes will eventually become his wife, he must learn to exercise patience and faith. With the help of his neighbors, the MacGregors, Ian begins to carve a life for himself and all the people under his care. When a shady character from the past starts roaming around Shiloh, it takes an old friend of the MacGregors, Joseph Tames-His-Horse, to put an end to the turmoil created.
A beautiful ending to a story filled with good people, complex people, community, second choices, redemption, and faith! Join Ian and Seona, the MacGregors, and the community of Shiloh in this beautiful journey! I strongly recommend that you read Mountain Laurel prior to reading Shiloh. Both are perfect read for lovers of historical fiction!
This complimentary ARC copy was received from Tyndale House Publishers and NetGalley. The above thoughts and opinions are wholly my own.
June 9, 2021
Most of the time I love Lori Benton's writings. Her early American novels are well-thought out and well-researched, and they give an accurate glimpse into the history and events of the era. Shiloh does all this, but it does so with a slow-moving plot--almost as slow as molasses in January.
Ian Carmichael has watched his wife and son die during childbirth, and has made the decision to move back to Boston, where his son and his "hand-fasted" wife live with his parents. He wants to make a family with Seona, the mother of his son. He has to overcome the animosity of his brother, as well as Seona's reservations toward him. Every movement Ian makes is explained in excruciating detail, which makes the reading a slog through mud.
Lori has included the good guys, the bad guys, the hurting guys, and the not entirely good or bad guys. She has included a couple of romances happening in unexpected places, a kidnapping to make tension in the plot, and a welcome return home. But, the reading is slow, and I found myself finding excuses not to read the book. This is not to say that Lori has lost her touch in writing, rather, it is to say that this didn't fit my reading mood. I just didn't enjoy it as much as I had reading her other books. Three Stars.
I do want to say that this won't be the last book by Lori Benton I will read. Tyndale House and NetGalley.com provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed are solely my own.
Ian Carmichael has watched his wife and son die during childbirth, and has made the decision to move back to Boston, where his son and his "hand-fasted" wife live with his parents. He wants to make a family with Seona, the mother of his son. He has to overcome the animosity of his brother, as well as Seona's reservations toward him. Every movement Ian makes is explained in excruciating detail, which makes the reading a slog through mud.
Lori has included the good guys, the bad guys, the hurting guys, and the not entirely good or bad guys. She has included a couple of romances happening in unexpected places, a kidnapping to make tension in the plot, and a welcome return home. But, the reading is slow, and I found myself finding excuses not to read the book. This is not to say that Lori has lost her touch in writing, rather, it is to say that this didn't fit my reading mood. I just didn't enjoy it as much as I had reading her other books. Three Stars.
I do want to say that this won't be the last book by Lori Benton I will read. Tyndale House and NetGalley.com provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed are solely my own.
October 1, 2021
I love Lori Benton's books. She is one of my favorite authors for historical fiction,. This series is a bit different but that's what I enjoyed most. Her descriptions in this book made me feel like I was there and I did not want to return to the present. There were some scenes that I liked and others I didn't much like. My favorite character was Seona. I loved her from Mountain Laurel. I feel that the author has really rounded out this individual perfectly. She's got the determination for excelling at whatever life decides to throw at her. I'm still not sure about Ian though. He comes off to me as a caring man but somewhat flighty. Overall, I liked the book very much so much so that I stayed up late to finish it. I do know that I didn't want to return to the present. I didn't want to say goodbye to Seona. My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review.
Don't forget! Come back to your Review on the pub date, 05 Oct 2021, to post to these retailers.
Don't forget! Come back to your Review on the pub date, 05 Oct 2021, to post to these retailers.
November 1, 2021
North Carolina, 1795. Over a year ago, Ian Cameron sent Seona and their son Gabriel to live with his family in Boston. Seona was formerly enslaved to Ian’s uncle but has now been freed. Ian is wed to Judith due to cruel manipulation on the part of Judith’s mother but has vowed to make their marriage work. Then tragedy strikes, and Ian finds himself alone with Mandy, his daughter with Judith. He decides to head north and has a chance to obtain land in Shiloh, New York. Seona is in Boston, trying to decide whether to stay with Ian’s family or go out on her own with her mother. Then Ian arrives, promising a future in Shiloh. But is that what Seona wants? When evil creeps into their midst, will their faith see them through?
Benton has taken on the daunting task of creating a sequel to two of her books at once. Shiloh is the sequel to Mountain Laurel but also brings in characters from her first published novel, Burning Sky. The characters are interwoven seamlessly, and the story is filled with historical details, adventure, love, doubt, and fear. As Ian embarks on a journey back to Seona, he is also on a spiritual journey of learning to trust God and become a better man. Seona and her mother, Lily, are each experiencing the ranging emotions of an enslaved person who has been freed, and both think of choosing a different path. The Christian themes of trusting God and each other abound in this book, but the results of greed are also explored through the character of Aram Crane. Shiloh, above all, is a journey of faith and a lesson that as faith grows, love grows along with it.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher via Historical Novels Review Magazine.
Benton has taken on the daunting task of creating a sequel to two of her books at once. Shiloh is the sequel to Mountain Laurel but also brings in characters from her first published novel, Burning Sky. The characters are interwoven seamlessly, and the story is filled with historical details, adventure, love, doubt, and fear. As Ian embarks on a journey back to Seona, he is also on a spiritual journey of learning to trust God and become a better man. Seona and her mother, Lily, are each experiencing the ranging emotions of an enslaved person who has been freed, and both think of choosing a different path. The Christian themes of trusting God and each other abound in this book, but the results of greed are also explored through the character of Aram Crane. Shiloh, above all, is a journey of faith and a lesson that as faith grows, love grows along with it.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher via Historical Novels Review Magazine.
October 12, 2021
I have been waiting on this book since I finished Mountain Laurel a year ago. I couldn't wait to see how Ian and Seona's story turned out. I enjoyed this book although it seemed to move at a very slow pace. I understand that Seona needed to learn how to live as a free woman and that Ian needed to mourn Judith. I also loved how Benton took Seona and Ian on a journey to show them that the only Savior is Jesus, not each other or themselves. Malcolm was by far my favorite character in this book as he imparts his wisdom and humility to all of those around him. He is the gentle reminder to all believers that reading God's word daily and keeping it close to our hearts is the way to peace and freedom. I also enjoyed getting to see the characters from Burning Sky and admire how seamlessly Benton wove the storylines together. Altogether a great story that brings three books full circle.
December 28, 2024
After so enjoying the first book as well as Burning Sky (not in this series, but the characters and town from Burning Sky become part of this story)I felt a bit let down with Shiloh. The problem seemed to stem from too many characters, my brain kept snagging on who had said what. The dynamic between Ian and Seona was so angst ridden that it was unenjoyable. Personally this book would have gotten 4 stars if it had been 10 chapters shorter. It felt like the author put a lot of unnecessary filler in and it took f-o-r-e-v-e-r to get to the crux of the issue between Seona and Ian. In a word, it became a tedious read, but I was only 10 chapters from the ending, so I persevered.
October 30, 2021
When you read a Lori Benton book, you expect a beautifully written book. This book lived up to that expectation. This was definitely a unique story line and love story. Hardships abounded. Grace and forgiveness were needed. We follow Ian from North Carolina to Boston and New York. As he yearns to be reunited with Seona and his son Gabriel. Gold and greed threaten Ian. A story filled with danger, trials, joys and resolution. I listened to the story on audio. The narrator did a good job drawing me into the story and each character. I also received a copy of this book from NetGalley. All views stated are my own.
November 6, 2021
What an AMAZING story! It perfectly continues the story of Ian and Seona from Mountain Laurel and includes beloved characters from Burning Sky, too! I have so many feelings concerning this story, but mostly I am impressed and encouraged by the theme of GRACE twining it all together.
February 17, 2023
I've been a Lori Benton fangirl since reading an ARC of Burning Sky many years ago, so any book of hers is almost an automatic 5+++ stars for me ... and I rarely take the time to write reviews, but had to for this one. It wrecked me in the BEST way--so many beautiful story threads, some reaching back to that first book in print, woven together. The Kindred duology was a hard read in many ways, especially Mountain Laurel, but soooo worthwhile. ❤ Thank you, Lori, for another beautiful story!
September 21, 2021
This is essentially the second half of the story begun in Mountain Laurel, but at the same time, it's also a sequel to Burning Sky. It was a surprise how closely the characters of Burning Sky are entwined with the characters introduced in Mountain Laurel, and how some unfinished business from Burning Sky has come to haunt them all. I think the story summarizes events from the related novels well enough, but I'd highly recommend reading both before reading Shiloh.
I'm glad that there is, at last, a happy ending. There's a part of me that felt like it should have come a lot sooner--doors opened quickly enough for it--but Benton takes a slow, realistic approach. Seona is now a free woman, but she doesn't know how to be free. She has never been forced to make choices before, since as a slave, she'd had none. She'd been hurt badly when Ian broke his promise and married Judith while handfasted to her. Now she has the chance to marry Ian in the eyes of the law, but she's weighed down with fear. He can't keep his promises of safety. As she is reminded, as a savior, Ian will always disappoint. But there is a Savior who won't.
I did like Ian more in this book; he's much steadier, with a faith that now sustains him. But he has a rough go of trying to woo Seona back to him while making sure that she is choosing him, not just doing what she's told. We get to know Ian's family much better, with all their heavy undercurrents, and even see what comes of Joseph Tames-His-Horse a decade after Burning Sky. It was good; slow, for the majority of the book, but good.
Thank you, Tyndale House and NetGalley for the complimentary e-book. I was not required to write a positive review, and all opinions are my own.
I'm glad that there is, at last, a happy ending. There's a part of me that felt like it should have come a lot sooner--doors opened quickly enough for it--but Benton takes a slow, realistic approach. Seona is now a free woman, but she doesn't know how to be free. She has never been forced to make choices before, since as a slave, she'd had none. She'd been hurt badly when Ian broke his promise and married Judith while handfasted to her. Now she has the chance to marry Ian in the eyes of the law, but she's weighed down with fear. He can't keep his promises of safety. As she is reminded, as a savior, Ian will always disappoint. But there is a Savior who won't.
I did like Ian more in this book; he's much steadier, with a faith that now sustains him. But he has a rough go of trying to woo Seona back to him while making sure that she is choosing him, not just doing what she's told. We get to know Ian's family much better, with all their heavy undercurrents, and even see what comes of Joseph Tames-His-Horse a decade after Burning Sky. It was good; slow, for the majority of the book, but good.
Thank you, Tyndale House and NetGalley for the complimentary e-book. I was not required to write a positive review, and all opinions are my own.
September 13, 2021
Not realizing Shiloh was a part of a family series, I might have thought it a complicated book. Crowded with a large cast of characters, making up the many and varied branches of the family tree. Complicated by Scottish, slave and Indian language, traditions and cultures there were many times when I needed a translation, but the spiritual faith and revelations were universal.
This book was a bit slow at times and overall long. I think it could have benefitted from a sharp and critical editor making for a crisper and better paced telling.
It was, however, a well researched and solidly written work revealing what to me was a piece of little known historical fiction.
Thank you NetGalley for this ARC and the chance to offer my review.
This book was a bit slow at times and overall long. I think it could have benefitted from a sharp and critical editor making for a crisper and better paced telling.
It was, however, a well researched and solidly written work revealing what to me was a piece of little known historical fiction.
Thank you NetGalley for this ARC and the chance to offer my review.
October 20, 2021
Lori Benton has done an amazing job writing a sequel to two of her previous books. Once again her writing shines. With a great balance between characters from both books, Benton told an epic satisfying story. She created a beautiful community truly meant to support one another. Her characters faced many changes as well as struggles from within and an enemy opposing them. This book just made me want to read more of her writing!
October 21, 2021
Author Lori Benton continues to be one of my favorite historical authors. She brings the American frontier to life in such a vivid, incandescent way I feel like I'm right there in the story with the characters.
Ian and Seona's story expands from the first book in the Kindred series, Mountain Laurel, to add in many interesting, loveable (and some not so loveable) characters. The plot and relationships are layered and richly-detailed, almost to the point I had to reread or read slower to make sure I caught them all. And the book builds to a mighty climax. I couldn't put it down, and once again Lori delivers not only a great story but a spiritual arc that resonated within my heart.
Authentic and filled with nuggets of spiritual wisdom, Shiloh is a love letter to America's frontier and the strength and diversity of those who settled it. It was also a pleasure reuniting with the cast of Burning Sky again (Neil and Willa!), and glimpsing the happily-ever-after of a beloved character from that story.
Lori Benton is a gifted storyteller. Sometimes her books are hard to read, but life is hard. And grace is found in human mistakes as well as successes. She covers all of that, and more, with her lyrical words. If you enjoy inspirational historical fiction with threads of romance and redemption, check out Mountain Laurel and then Shiloh.
Ian and Seona's story expands from the first book in the Kindred series, Mountain Laurel, to add in many interesting, loveable (and some not so loveable) characters. The plot and relationships are layered and richly-detailed, almost to the point I had to reread or read slower to make sure I caught them all. And the book builds to a mighty climax. I couldn't put it down, and once again Lori delivers not only a great story but a spiritual arc that resonated within my heart.
Authentic and filled with nuggets of spiritual wisdom, Shiloh is a love letter to America's frontier and the strength and diversity of those who settled it. It was also a pleasure reuniting with the cast of Burning Sky again (Neil and Willa!), and glimpsing the happily-ever-after of a beloved character from that story.
Lori Benton is a gifted storyteller. Sometimes her books are hard to read, but life is hard. And grace is found in human mistakes as well as successes. She covers all of that, and more, with her lyrical words. If you enjoy inspirational historical fiction with threads of romance and redemption, check out Mountain Laurel and then Shiloh.
August 17, 2021
I truly think I could just sit and read Lori Benton’s books and be content. There is something so unforced and natural about her writing that calls me to just settle in and stay.
I along with everyone else (who has read Mountain Laurel) I’m sure was more than ready to follow Seona and Ian to their happy ending.
This book is Seona’s journey physical and emotionally from Mountain Laurel to Boston to Shiloh. There were so many complexities here for Seona and all the characters in this story. The Indian, whites and slaves all came from different viewpoints and many of them overlapped. Untangling feelings was a huge task.
Some things I loved about this story: the other romance stories that you may not see coming, the fact that Judith was in story throughout and all the scriptures that led the way for the characters to become whole.
I really feel that The Burning Sky and Shiloh should be read before you read this book.
I recommend it.
Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read this book. The opinions are entirely my own.
I along with everyone else (who has read Mountain Laurel) I’m sure was more than ready to follow Seona and Ian to their happy ending.
This book is Seona’s journey physical and emotionally from Mountain Laurel to Boston to Shiloh. There were so many complexities here for Seona and all the characters in this story. The Indian, whites and slaves all came from different viewpoints and many of them overlapped. Untangling feelings was a huge task.
Some things I loved about this story: the other romance stories that you may not see coming, the fact that Judith was in story throughout and all the scriptures that led the way for the characters to become whole.
I really feel that The Burning Sky and Shiloh should be read before you read this book.
I recommend it.
Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read this book. The opinions are entirely my own.
June 25, 2022
"Your heart is a garden and His Word is the seed. It'll grow there if ye sow it."
~Macolm Cameron, Shiloh
Shiloh, book two in Lori Benton's Kindred Series, begins a year after the conclusion of Mountain Laurel. Ian has remained at his plantation, choosing to honor his commits to his uncle and embrace his family. Yet, Ian is haunted by his past, yearning for freedom from the memories he has tried to hide away. When tragedy comes to Moutain Laurel, Ian decides to make a new path for his life and those in his care.
Seona, along with Lily, her mother, and Gabriel, her son, has begun to make a life for herself in Boston. She realizes her newly found freedom doesn't give the joy and comfort she expected. Ian arrives and offers her the chance to start anew and to redeem himself in her eyes.
Is a new life possible for them after all the hurt and betrayal?
Shiloh delves into the difficult process of learning a new way of life, of freedom, when bondage is all one has known: the bondage of slavery, bondage of fear, bondage of mistrust. In Boston, Seona began the long processing of healing. That processing was hindered when she placed her trust and faith in men and not in God. Afraid to feel again, to be hurt again, she constructs an iron clad wall around her heart, creating a bondage of her own making. She will never truly heal or live until she realizes that her faith must rest in God, not imperfect man.
Shiloh was a wonderful conclusion to Mountain Laurel, filled with beautiful characters and encouraging scriptures. It depicts the trials and triumphs of a people finding their way through a world filled prejudice, sorrow, fear, hope and love.
There were a couple of things that made this story even more spectacular. First, if you have read Burning Sky, you are in for a real treat! I love learning what has become of beloved characters from another outstanding book, especially when they get their happy endings. Secondly, I was totally geeking out when Lori introduced James Fenimore Cooper into the story...The Last of the Mohicans is a favorite of mine.
~Macolm Cameron, Shiloh
Shiloh, book two in Lori Benton's Kindred Series, begins a year after the conclusion of Mountain Laurel. Ian has remained at his plantation, choosing to honor his commits to his uncle and embrace his family. Yet, Ian is haunted by his past, yearning for freedom from the memories he has tried to hide away. When tragedy comes to Moutain Laurel, Ian decides to make a new path for his life and those in his care.
Seona, along with Lily, her mother, and Gabriel, her son, has begun to make a life for herself in Boston. She realizes her newly found freedom doesn't give the joy and comfort she expected. Ian arrives and offers her the chance to start anew and to redeem himself in her eyes.
Is a new life possible for them after all the hurt and betrayal?
Shiloh delves into the difficult process of learning a new way of life, of freedom, when bondage is all one has known: the bondage of slavery, bondage of fear, bondage of mistrust. In Boston, Seona began the long processing of healing. That processing was hindered when she placed her trust and faith in men and not in God. Afraid to feel again, to be hurt again, she constructs an iron clad wall around her heart, creating a bondage of her own making. She will never truly heal or live until she realizes that her faith must rest in God, not imperfect man.
Shiloh was a wonderful conclusion to Mountain Laurel, filled with beautiful characters and encouraging scriptures. It depicts the trials and triumphs of a people finding their way through a world filled prejudice, sorrow, fear, hope and love.
There were a couple of things that made this story even more spectacular. First, if you have read Burning Sky, you are in for a real treat! I love learning what has become of beloved characters from another outstanding book, especially when they get their happy endings. Secondly, I was totally geeking out when Lori introduced James Fenimore Cooper into the story...The Last of the Mohicans is a favorite of mine.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews