I appreciate what living without plastic: More than 100 Easy Swaps for Home, Travel, Dining, Holidays, and Beyond by Brigette Allen and Christine Wong is trying to do. It was a really wise choice to focus on suggestions for cutting down single-use plastics with the awareness that plastic has its place in vehicles, computers, and medical equipment. There are a wide range of ideas for swaps.
I've been trying to reduce my plastic use for years, so I had heard of some of these ideas before. Some have worked for me, like switching to reusable bags, water bottles, and straws. Those are oldies but goodies. Others things I attempted did not work for me, like composting, giving up shampoo, using natural deodorant, and driving 20 minutes to the closest grocery store with a bulk section to fill my own containers. I've been through some disasters!
Many of the ideas in this book are new to me. Here are some new ones I don't think I'll try: carrying a glass jar of homemade moisturizer made of coconut oil with me "on the go," hefting around a steel cooler to picnics, and bringing my own popcorn to the movies (the movie theaters near me don't allow outside food or drink). I wouldn't consider those easy swaps. On the other hand, I thought these were great new ideas: making bags out of old T-shirts, making reusable gift wrap from old bedsheets, making confetti out of dry leaves, recycling broken Stasher bags and old gift cards, and finding a chewing gum brand that doesn't contain plastic. So, maybe there's an idea for everyone.
At times, the tone was fear-mongering. For example, "Most mattresses are made of polyurethane foam (PU; RIC #7). Because this material is highly flammable, it's necessary for the manufacturers to add highly toxic flame retardants so the bed won't burst into flames." This statement is phrased in a dramatic way. It's not that the bed is going to burst spontaneously into flames without flame retardants. That's silly. It's that if, God forbid, there's a house fire, flame retardants will keep the bed from burning up as fast. Personally, I'd prefer taking the long-term risk of breathing them in if it could save my life in a fire. The amount we breathe in on a daily basis is clearly not immediately deadly or "highly toxic."
The 30-Day Plastic Detox Plan isn't so useful to me. As a personal preference, I want something concrete to write on each day of a calendar. Instead, the steps for each day of the challenge aren't linear, but interconnected. For example, Day 8 is "Hydrate Naturally" (meaning carry a reusable water bottle) and Day 18 is "Be beautiful from the inside out" (meaning drink plenty of water). Some of them are too much to do all in one day, like Day 14, "Feed the earth" (compost your food waste). Many of them have to do with eating out, traveling, and going to amusement parks/conventions/food festivals, which are special occasions that don't make sense for the author to schedule for me as part of a 30-day challenge.
Despite any shortcomings, the book is a wakeup call about how prevalent plastic is in every area of my life. It'll help me choose non-plastic options when I'm shopping in the future.