I was looking forward to reading Helen Creighton's Bluenose Ghosts (originally published in 1957) as I do enjoy Maritime provinces of Canada ghost stories, mysteries, folklore etc. And I guess because I was expecting a both interesting and also readable account of Nova Scotia "true" stories of spiritual manifestations, of the supernatural (after very much enjoying Creighton's Songs and Ballads of Nova Scotia), well and truly, my disappointment and my lack of reading pleasure regarding Creighton's presented text for Bluenose Ghosts has been and continues to be pronounced, rather all encompassing and for a number of different but in my opinion more than justified reasons.
For one and first and foremost, how Helen Creighton writes about her collected, her listened to (and supposedly authentic and having actually occurred) tales is (at least to and for me personally) majorly distracting and thus also hugely annoying, with Creighton trying to verbally stuff so many accounts into each of her eleven chapters that the amount of detail being provided tends to get massively tedious, exaggerated and that there is also an annoying lack of textual organisation present in Bluenose Ghosts, so that what could (and even should) be interesting kind of just ends up feeling like Helen Creighton is just majorly information dropping and in my opinion making her stories mesh into a gigantic and messily rendered verbal ball of intertwined and ridiculously all over the place words and also instances of annoying and headache producing verbal diarrhoea. And while there are most definitely interesting bits and pieces to be encountered in Bluenose Ghosts (supernatural signs that warn humans of impending death, ghosts disturbing the living after they themselves have been either on purpose or inadvertently disturbed, ghosts who guard buried treasure, regarding second sight both towards the future and also into the past, on devils/angels, phantom ships and other sea mysteries, how ghosts can both help and harm, wandering female spirits, ghosts that appear as either animals or as lights and of course also accounts concerning haunted houses and poltergeists), trying to locate those intriguing, engaging and also believable nuggets within Creighton's jumbled and lacking organisation writing style and narration is a bit like searching for needles in haystacks and has definitely not made Bluenose Ghosts an enjoyable and a to be recommended book. For two, because many the stories found in Bluenose ghosts feel so pretty far-fetched that they sound more like campfire horror tales, I manages to become very bored with Bluenose Ghosts after about page fifty and for the remaining pages was both skimming through and also wanting Helen Creighton to finally write more believable and more realistic sounding Nova Scotia Ghost stories in Bluenose Ghosts (but which never did happen, alas). And for three, I also rather consider it majorly frustrating (and intellectually lacking) that Creighton does not provide a separate bibliography at the back of Bluenose Ghosts, and that yes, considering that the majority if not even all of the tales being presented are first-person accounts, all of this should be acknowledged by Helen Creighton with detailed footnotes and be not simply alluded to rather sparingly within the text of Bluenose Ghosts (and just to say in conclusion that I have definitely not at all enjoyed this book, have major issues with Helen Creighton's writing, with her narration and textual presentation and in fact also kind of think that my two star rating for Bluenose Ghosts is actually rather generous on my part).