So, this review ended up being rather negative, despite the fact that overall the book was all right. I was actually really invested in the climax, and enjoyed some of the new characters immensely. I wanted, like with Janette Oak's writing, simply /more/ of what we got - more friendship scenes, more character building, more one on one scenes, more scenes with side characters. A book that leaves you interested enough to want more has its merit.
Now. On to some of the stuff I had issues with.
I am once again startled by the use of skin color in this. I have...questions. Glimpses are described as pale skinned, whiter than the already white protags. In fact, white people look 'dark skinned' next to glimpses. So...Is there no skin-colored ethnicity in the Realm? Are all black people's glimpse-twins pale skinned? If so, that's an...uh...odd choice to make. Also, seems odd that 'twin' is used to describe the human/glimpse stuff. Wouldn't 'clone' or 'doppleganger' or 'soul sharer' be more accurate? Nock and Bolt are twins, Antoinette and Gwanne are not. But Batson doesn't seem to have a good idea of how twins act irl anyways, so whatever. (A flaw in all twin-having media I've found is a weird, almost unnatural idea of how twins 'work'. It's not just Batson's writing.) Also, again, using 'dark-skin' for an insult is just a really....bad...choice. What if the skin was described as translucent instead, since it was already described as that at one point? Lean heavily into that, make black/brown human counterparts/glimpses have translucent skin instead of pale skin, call humans 'solid-skins' and bam, problem solved.
Another...tasteless choice was using the word 'braves' for 'skilled bowmen of the Yewman country'. Like...who let this happen? That term is extremely racially loaded and throwing around racially loaded terms with no regard for if they fit or not leaves a really bad taste in my mouth. I think that the racially loaded terms in this book were put in with little to no thought, and aren't malevolent. I don't have a reason to believe any sort of intentional harm, so I don't have a problem with it beyond finding it ill thought out.
I find the whole hinted at romance between Antionette and Aidan, and their respective glimpses, to just be kinda weird considering how little the idea of glimpse/human counterparts are explored beyond 'weird that I have another twin I'll never meet!' But I do appreciate how the romance isn't explicate. Aside from a few comments about physical attraction to each other, focus is in other places, and I am so thankful for that.
Apart from that, meh. There were parts that were good. Again, the climax had me involved and was excellently written. But the overuse of explanation marks and talking tags made stuff like yelling seem less important, as it does. And, idk, again, just because it's a kids book doesn't mean it gets a pass for being poorly written in parts. I do think it's better than the first book, and if Batson improves a little with each book he writes, good for him!! I'm hoping his third one will be even better.
There were...a lot of sword fights in this book. I didn't like it, I'm not here for violence, but if you like that sort of thing, you might like it.
Now, a good thing! Some interesting theological concepts were introduced that did impress me, like scholars disagreeing on when rapture stuff happens. It's a neat way to introduce kids to the concepts. I did appreciate that. If I had kids, this would be on their bookshelves, just because there's some really solid use of theology and Christian ideas in this.
I do think that storywise, the character roster suffers due to needing a group of twelve, but having killed off a bunch of them in the first book, and then immediately dumping a bunch of new characters on the reader at the start of the second book. I'd be way, way more invested in these characters if they didn't feel like a way to show off Batson's various character ideas. There are cool concepts, like Farix, but we just...don't see enough of them because, again, there's twelve, and there's not enough carry over characters from the previous one. So we're subjected to all these character building scenes of new characters instead of more character building scenes of characters we already know a bit about. The books are focused on the plot, and not so much the characters. Character interactions rarely happen unless it's to push the plot along.
The result ends up being we know a little about a lot of characters. If Bolt had been replaced Merewen, and everyone else had remained the same, there wouldn't have been very much difference in the story. Orrr, a couple of the characters introduced in this book could've replaced the characters on the kill count of the previous one. I can't even remember anyone who was killed off in the first book, aside from Bolt and Ascriot, and the grandpa glimpse. It just kinda sucks because I want to love these characters, but I don't have enough time with them.
At the end of the day, despite the weird glimpse stuff and massive, shallow character list, it's a much better book than the first, and I hope the third is even better. I'm looking forward to reading it.