What do you think?
Rate this book
Belmont Mansion #3
O melodie necântată
O melodie necantata. Seria Conacul Belmont. Volumul 3
Violonista de exceptie, cu studii muzicale la Viena, Rebekah Carrington reuseste sa obtina o auditie cu dirijorul noii filarmonici din Nashville. Insa femeile sunt „mult prea gingase si delicate” pentru rigorile unei orchestre,
iar sperantele lui Rebekah sunt iute spulberate, intrucat maestrul, hotarat sa-si lase amprenta asupra lumii muzicii clasice, se conformeaza randuielilor sociale ale vremii. Iar, pentru a inrautati si mai mult lucrurile, Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, baroana de la Belmont si cea care nu de mult i-a oferit o slujba lui Rebekah, este intru totul de acord cu el.
Muzicianul de renume national, Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb, este noul dirijor al orchestrei. In ciuda lipsei de inspiratie – si a unei sacaitoare dureri de cap, ce nu se da dusa –, trebuie sa termine de scris simfonia la care lucreaza inainte de marea deschidere a cladirii operei. Chiar mai mult, motivul si mai important din spatele acestei dorinte este omul care i-a insuflat pentru prima oara dragostea de muzica, si anume tatal sau, care acum se afla pe patul de moarte. Pe masura ce starea de sanatate a lui Nathaniel se inrautateste, dirijorul e tot mai convins ca Rebekah este singura persoana care ar putea sa-l ajute sa termine simfonia. Dar cum poti recastiga increderea unei femei, dupa ce i-ai calcat visele in picioare?
Dupa cum muzica ne misca pana la lacrimi, dar ne si inalta sufletele, O melodie necantata capteaza splendorile muzicii clasice intr-o vreme in care contributiile feminine, cu greu castigate, in toate aspectele culturii au schimbat nu doar istoria lumii, ci si inimile barbatilor.
Violonista de exceptie, cu studii muzicale la Viena, Rebekah Carrington reuseste sa obtina o auditie cu dirijorul noii filarmonici din Nashville. Insa femeile sunt „mult prea gingase si delicate” pentru rigorile unei orchestre,
iar sperantele lui Rebekah sunt iute spulberate, intrucat maestrul, hotarat sa-si lase amprenta asupra lumii muzicii clasice, se conformeaza randuielilor sociale ale vremii. Iar, pentru a inrautati si mai mult lucrurile, Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, baroana de la Belmont si cea care nu de mult i-a oferit o slujba lui Rebekah, este intru totul de acord cu el.
Muzicianul de renume national, Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb, este noul dirijor al orchestrei. In ciuda lipsei de inspiratie – si a unei sacaitoare dureri de cap, ce nu se da dusa –, trebuie sa termine de scris simfonia la care lucreaza inainte de marea deschidere a cladirii operei. Chiar mai mult, motivul si mai important din spatele acestei dorinte este omul care i-a insuflat pentru prima oara dragostea de muzica, si anume tatal sau, care acum se afla pe patul de moarte. Pe masura ce starea de sanatate a lui Nathaniel se inrautateste, dirijorul e tot mai convins ca Rebekah este singura persoana care ar putea sa-l ajute sa termine simfonia. Dar cum poti recastiga increderea unei femei, dupa ce i-ai calcat visele in picioare?
Dupa cum muzica ne misca pana la lacrimi, dar ne si inalta sufletele, O melodie necantata capteaza splendorile muzicii clasice intr-o vreme in care contributiile feminine, cu greu castigate, in toate aspectele culturii au schimbat nu doar istoria lumii, ci si inimile barbatilor.
464 pages, Paperback
First published January 31, 2017
202 people are currently reading
2378 people want to read
About the author
Tamera Alexander
36 books3,240 followersTamera Alexander is a USA Today bestselling novelist and one of today's most beloved authors of inspirational historical romance and women’s contemporary fiction. While being Gram Tam is her current favorite role, she’ll never turn down a stroll through an old cemetery or browsing through antique shops.
Her books have been awarded numerous industry-leading honors—among them the Christy Award, the RITA Award, the Carol Award, Library Journal's top honors—and have earned the distinction of Publisher's Weekly Starred Reviews. In 2020 she was inducted into the Christy Award Hall of Fame which recognizes authors for their legacy and contribution to Christian fiction. Her deeply drawn characters and thought-provoking plots have earned her devoted readers worldwide.
Tamera and her husband love living in Nashville, Tennessee, and treasure the time spent with their grown children and grandchildren. They live a short distance from the Southern mansions that serve as the backdrop for many of her critically-acclaimed novels. Tamera views her writing as a way to grow closer to the Lord Jesus Christ—and her deepest desire is that those who read her novels will take steps closer to Him as well.
Her books have been awarded numerous industry-leading honors—among them the Christy Award, the RITA Award, the Carol Award, Library Journal's top honors—and have earned the distinction of Publisher's Weekly Starred Reviews. In 2020 she was inducted into the Christy Award Hall of Fame which recognizes authors for their legacy and contribution to Christian fiction. Her deeply drawn characters and thought-provoking plots have earned her devoted readers worldwide.
Tamera and her husband love living in Nashville, Tennessee, and treasure the time spent with their grown children and grandchildren. They live a short distance from the Southern mansions that serve as the backdrop for many of her critically-acclaimed novels. Tamera views her writing as a way to grow closer to the Lord Jesus Christ—and her deepest desire is that those who read her novels will take steps closer to Him as well.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 424 reviews
March 5, 2017
Sometimes, the most enjoyed and appreciated books are the hardest ones to write a review for. Its kind of like viewing a spectacular mountain range, and you take a picture of its awesomeness, yet the picture just doesn't capture the authentic beauty of it. In a similar essence, I lack the ability to fully describe the beauty of Tamera's books when I finish one of her novels. A Note Yet Unsung was written with heart. It caused my emotions to soar with the musical quality of writing. I wish I could thank Tamera Alexander in person, and tell her how gifted of a writer she really is and how proud I am of her for fully using her gift to edify and glorify God with her words.
My only negative comment, which could also be read as a compliment, is that I wish her stories where at least another 100 pages. Unfortunately, I know the majority of readers are always looking for less pages, quicker reads, but Alexander has a quality to her writing that not many authors can do well, and that is... penning a novel that could easily cruise into the 600 and 700 pages range with never a moment of dullness. I crave to read more of her characters, to have her stories even more fully fledged out.
Other than applauding and yelling, "Bravissimo!" I cant fully review the splendor of this inspiring novel. Read it. You will be blessed.
My only negative comment, which could also be read as a compliment, is that I wish her stories where at least another 100 pages. Unfortunately, I know the majority of readers are always looking for less pages, quicker reads, but Alexander has a quality to her writing that not many authors can do well, and that is... penning a novel that could easily cruise into the 600 and 700 pages range with never a moment of dullness. I crave to read more of her characters, to have her stories even more fully fledged out.
Other than applauding and yelling, "Bravissimo!" I cant fully review the splendor of this inspiring novel. Read it. You will be blessed.
April 12, 2018
I enjoyed this novel on so very many levels. The love story flowed so easily and naturally from sparks of dislike into sparks of love. There were beautiful lessons to be learned within these pages too. Highly recommended.
March 12, 2019
Re-Read Feb/March 2019:
I lovelovelove this book, but unfortunately, it took me over a month to read it and I wasn't in the mood. *sighs* I hate when I don't feel like reading books I love.
Still, this is one of my favorites and I will hopefully be more in the mood next time! Highly recommend you read my previous reviews for my "actual opinion." ;)
Re-Read March 2018 //
Can I just say . . . this book was even better the second time?
I love this book. SO FREAKING MUCH. The world and the characters come alive. It's been over a year since I've read this so I actually found that I'd forgotten things. It was like I was reading it for the first time, except this time 'round I had some fond memories to make it even better.
This story means so much to me. ALL OF IT. It's about the power of music & using your gifts to honor the Giver & overcoming prejudice & making a difference & the intricacies of love & SO MANY OTHER THINGS. It means the world to me, this book.
The characters and themes in this book will stick with me forever. I can't recommend this book enough. <3
Revised Content Note: There is a bit more kissing/physical contact than I remembered. A brief description of a partially-nude statue, a mention of a woman breastfeeding her child, a really despicable stepfather who attempts to rape one of the characters in the past. Also some kissing, longing, etc. Nothing I personally felt too uncomfortable with but I probably would recommend this to those 15 or 16+, for these reasons and for interest level.
5 stars!
/ / /
WOW. This book was SO good! When I started reading it, I wasn't entirely in the mood for it. However, once I got past the first 60 pages or so, I was so immersed in the story that it was painful to put the book down.
Since lists are so much fun, let's go ahead and divide my thoughts into a list, shall we?
Things I Liked:
// Look, somebody has to say it...TATEEEEE. Oh my goodness, Tate Whitcomb was by far the best part of the book! I absolutely fell in love with him. <3 He can be short-tempered and irritable at times, but he's really a great guy overall. He just has a lot of problems weighing on his mind, including composing an ENTIRE symphony, dealing with the stresses of being the new, young conductor of an orchestra, and lots of personal issues (which shall not be named because spoilers). POOR THING. I just want to hug him throughout the entire book. Because the way he treats Rebekah?? Suffice it to say, the two of them are darling together. I just love how sweet he is with her (um, most of the time...hehe).
// Tate's family was wonderful. I just loved his family so much! It was amusing seeing how adorably awkward Tate was when introducing them to Rebekah. XD And the genuine love they had for each other is just so heartwarming.
// All the violin and music-related stuff! I'm a violinist myself so I really appreciated all the music in this book. Rebekah and Tate both play the violin, and I love that. I'm not sure if non-musicians would enjoy it as much? Maybe it just appeals to me because I deal with music all the time anyway. But yes, all the music was splendid! (And I love that the author actually has a playlist of all the songs mentioned in the book on her website. :D)
// The setting! I really liked the "refined southern feel" of this book. It takes place in Nashville in 1871, where there are mansions and concert halls and even donut shops (where Tate takes Rebekah <3). It has a very charming feel to it overall. ^_^
// The writing style was so gorgeous! I positively adored Tamera Alexander's writing style! Too often the writer is either too descriptive or not descriptive enough. But this author struck the perfect balance. The writing was rich and evocative, yet engaging enough that I didn't get sucked into a black hole of descriptions. (That has happened before. XD)
// Rebekah. I can't believe I haven't mentioned her yet! She was SUCH a great character! It's not often that I find myself rooting for both main characters so much. She was a good blend of gentle and sassy. I loved her determination and strong will, combined with a gentleness of spirit. I think that female characters often end up on either side of the spectrum, which aggravates me. But Rebekah broke the mold, being an independent young woman who still knew how to be a lady.
TATE AND REBEKAH. Have I conveyed how much I love them??? EEP. They were the most darling couple! You don't know how much I wanted them to just GET TOGETHER. (I'm not telling you if it happens or not...you'll have to read the book to find out. ;))
// Alllll the cookies and donuts and cakes. YUM.
// THE ENDING. The last few chapters were so darn good. I cried happy tears during one scene. :')
Oh, and I almost forgot to mention this! I loved that Tate and Rebekah's relationship was not based on physical attraction so much. Sure, looks had a part to play in it, but I appreciated that they each wanted the other person to achieve their goals. They were genuinely attracted to their personalities and character, rather than just their physical appearance.
Things I Didn't Like:
// Some of the dialect got a little old...there's only so much of that I can take in a book.
// Not enough time in the donut shop. Yes, this is a legitimate concern. XD
// I honestly can't think of much else. It was a really wonderful book!
Overall, I LOVED this book! Even though it was the third book in the series, I didn't at all feel disconnected or confused. The series is written in such a way that it seems reading them out of order works fine. That being said, I enjoyed this book so much that I just have to read the other ones now. :)
And content-wise, it was very clean! There were a couple kisses exchanged, and I believe one or two of them may have been described more than some people would like. But I thought most of them were sweet. Rebekah's stepfather clearly has...ahem, a thing for Rebekah. It's not dwelt on very much, but yes, it's worth mentioning for sensitive readers. I definitely would recommend it to older teens, probably fourteen and fifteen on up.
I received a free copy of this book from Bethany House Publishers in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
4.5 stars!
I lovelovelove this book, but unfortunately, it took me over a month to read it and I wasn't in the mood. *sighs* I hate when I don't feel like reading books I love.
Still, this is one of my favorites and I will hopefully be more in the mood next time! Highly recommend you read my previous reviews for my "actual opinion." ;)
Re-Read March 2018 //
Can I just say . . . this book was even better the second time?
I love this book. SO FREAKING MUCH. The world and the characters come alive. It's been over a year since I've read this so I actually found that I'd forgotten things. It was like I was reading it for the first time, except this time 'round I had some fond memories to make it even better.
This story means so much to me. ALL OF IT. It's about the power of music & using your gifts to honor the Giver & overcoming prejudice & making a difference & the intricacies of love & SO MANY OTHER THINGS. It means the world to me, this book.
The characters and themes in this book will stick with me forever. I can't recommend this book enough. <3
Revised Content Note: There is a bit more kissing/physical contact than I remembered. A brief description of a partially-nude statue, a mention of a woman breastfeeding her child, a really despicable stepfather who attempts to rape one of the characters in the past. Also some kissing, longing, etc. Nothing I personally felt too uncomfortable with but I probably would recommend this to those 15 or 16+, for these reasons and for interest level.
5 stars!
/ / /
WOW. This book was SO good! When I started reading it, I wasn't entirely in the mood for it. However, once I got past the first 60 pages or so, I was so immersed in the story that it was painful to put the book down.
Since lists are so much fun, let's go ahead and divide my thoughts into a list, shall we?
Things I Liked:
// Look, somebody has to say it...TATEEEEE. Oh my goodness, Tate Whitcomb was by far the best part of the book! I absolutely fell in love with him. <3 He can be short-tempered and irritable at times, but he's really a great guy overall. He just has a lot of problems weighing on his mind, including composing an ENTIRE symphony, dealing with the stresses of being the new, young conductor of an orchestra, and lots of personal issues (which shall not be named because spoilers). POOR THING. I just want to hug him throughout the entire book. Because the way he treats Rebekah?? Suffice it to say, the two of them are darling together. I just love how sweet he is with her (um, most of the time...hehe).
// Tate's family was wonderful. I just loved his family so much! It was amusing seeing how adorably awkward Tate was when introducing them to Rebekah. XD And the genuine love they had for each other is just so heartwarming.
// All the violin and music-related stuff! I'm a violinist myself so I really appreciated all the music in this book. Rebekah and Tate both play the violin, and I love that. I'm not sure if non-musicians would enjoy it as much? Maybe it just appeals to me because I deal with music all the time anyway. But yes, all the music was splendid! (And I love that the author actually has a playlist of all the songs mentioned in the book on her website. :D)
// The setting! I really liked the "refined southern feel" of this book. It takes place in Nashville in 1871, where there are mansions and concert halls and even donut shops (where Tate takes Rebekah <3). It has a very charming feel to it overall. ^_^
// The writing style was so gorgeous! I positively adored Tamera Alexander's writing style! Too often the writer is either too descriptive or not descriptive enough. But this author struck the perfect balance. The writing was rich and evocative, yet engaging enough that I didn't get sucked into a black hole of descriptions. (That has happened before. XD)
// Rebekah. I can't believe I haven't mentioned her yet! She was SUCH a great character! It's not often that I find myself rooting for both main characters so much. She was a good blend of gentle and sassy. I loved her determination and strong will, combined with a gentleness of spirit. I think that female characters often end up on either side of the spectrum, which aggravates me. But Rebekah broke the mold, being an independent young woman who still knew how to be a lady.
TATE AND REBEKAH. Have I conveyed how much I love them??? EEP. They were the most darling couple! You don't know how much I wanted them to just GET TOGETHER. (I'm not telling you if it happens or not...you'll have to read the book to find out. ;))
// Alllll the cookies and donuts and cakes. YUM.
// THE ENDING. The last few chapters were so darn good. I cried happy tears during one scene. :')
Oh, and I almost forgot to mention this! I loved that Tate and Rebekah's relationship was not based on physical attraction so much. Sure, looks had a part to play in it, but I appreciated that they each wanted the other person to achieve their goals. They were genuinely attracted to their personalities and character, rather than just their physical appearance.
Things I Didn't Like:
// Some of the dialect got a little old...there's only so much of that I can take in a book.
// Not enough time in the donut shop. Yes, this is a legitimate concern. XD
// I honestly can't think of much else. It was a really wonderful book!
Overall, I LOVED this book! Even though it was the third book in the series, I didn't at all feel disconnected or confused. The series is written in such a way that it seems reading them out of order works fine. That being said, I enjoyed this book so much that I just have to read the other ones now. :)
And content-wise, it was very clean! There were a couple kisses exchanged, and I believe one or two of them may have been described more than some people would like. But I thought most of them were sweet. Rebekah's stepfather clearly has...ahem, a thing for Rebekah. It's not dwelt on very much, but yes, it's worth mentioning for sensitive readers. I definitely would recommend it to older teens, probably fourteen and fifteen on up.
I received a free copy of this book from Bethany House Publishers in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
4.5 stars!
April 21, 2017
There's a unique quality to Tamera Alexander's storytelling that stays with me after I finish her books. The narrative is not fast-paced, but the descriptions steadily develop the setting and characters until I feel immersed. The world of music and composing in the 1800's was fascinating and I loved the historical details that brought the story to life. Rebekah and Nate have an interesting dynamic, although I didn't quite feel the chemistry between them. They are both strong personalities that don't back down, so they had to find a good working balance as they collaborated on Nate's symphony. The secondary cast was quite varied, from Rebekah's estranged family, to her extraordinarily wealthy employer, to Nate's warm and loving mountain family. There is a real sense of Rebekah's frustration as she seeks to fulfill her dreams only to be held back by society's restrictions against her gender. It makes me more appreciative of the freedoms we enjoy today because of the determination of women who worked for change.
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
February 7, 2017
A lovely conclusion to the Belmont Masion Series. I love how the author used three of Adelicia Acklen's favorite things: art, nature and music as the motivation behind each book in the series.
In 1871 Nashville it wasn't acceptable for a female to be part of a symphony. And yet, this is exactly the heart's desire of Rebekah Carrington. Initially, the local symphony's maestro, Tate Whitcomb is not kind to her or the idea of a female musician on stage.
Both Rebekah and Tate have difficult circumstances surrounding them that add depth to the novel. While the novel isn't awash in history, the author does a nice job of helping the reader feel the time period and geography.
The entire Belmont Mansion Series is wonderful.
In 1871 Nashville it wasn't acceptable for a female to be part of a symphony. And yet, this is exactly the heart's desire of Rebekah Carrington. Initially, the local symphony's maestro, Tate Whitcomb is not kind to her or the idea of a female musician on stage.
Both Rebekah and Tate have difficult circumstances surrounding them that add depth to the novel. While the novel isn't awash in history, the author does a nice job of helping the reader feel the time period and geography.
The entire Belmont Mansion Series is wonderful.
February 8, 2017
Full review on Faithfully Bookish http://wp.me/p7ngfE-z2
Music lover or not, A Note Unsung will capture your heart, reader friends because the story is about much more than the wonderful music! Reconstruction Era Nashville, as well as the struggles and triumphs of her residents, is brought to life once again by talented storyteller and bonafide southern belle, Tamera Alexander. The tenacious dreams and complex lives of the main characters will keep readers riveted to the pages.
I requested the opportunity to read and review this title through NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own.
Music lover or not, A Note Unsung will capture your heart, reader friends because the story is about much more than the wonderful music! Reconstruction Era Nashville, as well as the struggles and triumphs of her residents, is brought to life once again by talented storyteller and bonafide southern belle, Tamera Alexander. The tenacious dreams and complex lives of the main characters will keep readers riveted to the pages.
I requested the opportunity to read and review this title through NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own.
May 6, 2023
Well I remember adoring this book the first time I read it but I don't remember it making me sob!! This is definitely my fav out of all of Tamera Alexander's books I've read... probably because I relate so much to Nathaniel and adore music with my whole heart. What a story! What a fun time re-reading this trilogy.
Read
February 14, 2017From the beloved USA Today bestselling author of Rekindled, To Whisper Her Name, and A Lasting Impression comes the final novel in the sweeping Southern Belmont Mansion series.
A master violinist trained in Vienna, Rebekah Carrington manages to wheedle her way into an audition with the maestro at the newly-formed Nashville Philharmonic. But women are "far too fragile and frail" for rigors of an orchestra, and Rebekah's hopes are swiftly dashed because the conductor—determined to leave his mark on the world of classical music—bows to public opinion. To make matters worse, Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, mistress of Belmont Mansion and Rebekah's new employer, agrees with him.
Nationally acclaimed conductor Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb is Nashville's new orchestra leader. And despite a reluctant muse—and a strange buzzing and recurring pain in his head—he must finish composing his symphony before the grand opening of the city's new opera hall. But far more pressing, he must finish it for the one who first inspired his love of music—his father, who is dying. As Tate's ailment worsens, he believes Rebekah can help him finish his symphony. But how do you win back a woman's trust when you've robbed her of her dream?
As music moves us to tears yet makes our hearts soar, A Note Yet Unsung captures the splendor of classical music at a time when women's hard-won strides in cultural issues changed not only world history—but the hearts of men.
A master violinist trained in Vienna, Rebekah Carrington manages to wheedle her way into an audition with the maestro at the newly-formed Nashville Philharmonic. But women are "far too fragile and frail" for rigors of an orchestra, and Rebekah's hopes are swiftly dashed because the conductor—determined to leave his mark on the world of classical music—bows to public opinion. To make matters worse, Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, mistress of Belmont Mansion and Rebekah's new employer, agrees with him.
Nationally acclaimed conductor Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb is Nashville's new orchestra leader. And despite a reluctant muse—and a strange buzzing and recurring pain in his head—he must finish composing his symphony before the grand opening of the city's new opera hall. But far more pressing, he must finish it for the one who first inspired his love of music—his father, who is dying. As Tate's ailment worsens, he believes Rebekah can help him finish his symphony. But how do you win back a woman's trust when you've robbed her of her dream?
As music moves us to tears yet makes our hearts soar, A Note Yet Unsung captures the splendor of classical music at a time when women's hard-won strides in cultural issues changed not only world history—but the hearts of men.
July 25, 2021
I must admit, I had my reservations about Tamera Alexander. My first impression of her was that she was a bit too wordy and emotional in her writing. In the beginning, I sometimes wanted to scan the page to 'get to the point'. My mom had recommended this book to me (Tamera is her favorite author). When I 'complained' about my first impressions she said 'stick with it' and she was right! I cannot, not give this book five stars. Tamera won me over! What a BEAUTIFUL story with so many meaningful truths both spiritually and relationally among the characters. I'm not one to become emotional when reading a story but this one got to me! I got choked up at the end. I loved the relationship that developed between Rebekah and Tate and all the additional characters. I definitely became emotionally attached to this entire story and everyone in it. I want to know how they're doing now! I wish it was longer. I wish I could be their friend! Haha. I am not musically inclined at all but while reading, I became enamored with all of the beautiful instruments in an orchestra. You can even listen to the music described if you go to Tamera's website! How cool?! I love the historical accuracy she weaves into the book. It's fun to read a fictional twist on real life people!
March 5, 2017
Tamera writes amazing southern fiction set in Nashville in the Reconstruction years. In A Note Yet Unsung, Rebekah is a professional violinist in an era that doesn't allow women to do such scandalous things like perform with an orchestra. She's a woman who doesn't fit and can't got home. But she can't leave either. This book will suck you into the time period, the setting, and a story that won't let go. This book has a depth to the challenges facing the characters that adds such richness to the story. I will thinking about this book for weeks if not months to come.
June 13, 2022
A great book and a lovely ending to the series. I've loved every book in the Belmont series.
March 7, 2017
After living in Austria for several years, Rebekah Carrington returns home to Nashville. Desperate to find somewhere to live other than her family home, she auditions for the Nashville Philharmonic Symphony, only to be turned down because of her gender. So Rebekah takes the next best job she can find—tutoring the daughter of Adelicia Acklen, owner of the Bellmont Mansion and one of the symphony’s most influential supporters. But how will Rebekah achieve her dreams of playing professionally when her employer, the conductor, and society refuse to allow women the opportunity?
A Note Yet Unsung by Tamera Alexander continues the line of questioning brought up in the other books in the series: If a woman possesses the ability to perform art at a high level, shouldn’t she be allowed to do so? But the post-Civil War era is one that only begins to open up these opportunities to skilled women. A Note Yet Unsung (and the other books in the series) demonstrates what it would be like to be a woman in this time period, trying to influence the culture to allow women equal opportunities to men.
The other major theme in this novel is the romance between Rebekah and the symphony conductor, Nathaniel Whitcomb. Their story begins with a rocky relationship that quickly shows them to be the perfect match. They have many hurdles to overcome, but their romance is sweet and romantic. However, the details of their engagement and their plans following the major symphony performance at the end was not shown in very much detail.
A Note Yet Unsung also contains a little danger and mystery which were solved satisfactorily. This book is Christian, as shown in the prayers and hymns of the characters, yet is not preachy or clear on the definition of salvation. While this book was not my all-time favorite, I enjoyed it very much and have very few negative comments for it.
I recommend A Note Yet Unsung to readers of inspirational romance and historical fiction.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and Bethany House Publisher’s Blogger Reviewer Program. All opinions are expressly my own.
A Note Yet Unsung by Tamera Alexander continues the line of questioning brought up in the other books in the series: If a woman possesses the ability to perform art at a high level, shouldn’t she be allowed to do so? But the post-Civil War era is one that only begins to open up these opportunities to skilled women. A Note Yet Unsung (and the other books in the series) demonstrates what it would be like to be a woman in this time period, trying to influence the culture to allow women equal opportunities to men.
The other major theme in this novel is the romance between Rebekah and the symphony conductor, Nathaniel Whitcomb. Their story begins with a rocky relationship that quickly shows them to be the perfect match. They have many hurdles to overcome, but their romance is sweet and romantic. However, the details of their engagement and their plans following the major symphony performance at the end was not shown in very much detail.
A Note Yet Unsung also contains a little danger and mystery which were solved satisfactorily. This book is Christian, as shown in the prayers and hymns of the characters, yet is not preachy or clear on the definition of salvation. While this book was not my all-time favorite, I enjoyed it very much and have very few negative comments for it.
I recommend A Note Yet Unsung to readers of inspirational romance and historical fiction.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and Bethany House Publisher’s Blogger Reviewer Program. All opinions are expressly my own.
February 27, 2018
A Note Yet Unsung by Tamera Alexander is a wonderful Christian historical romance. It is the final book in the Belmont Mansion series but can be read as a stand-alone.
Once again Tamera Alexander has woven fact and fiction to produce a first class story. The world is changing. Women are no longer content to sit demurely in the background. The novel features strong modern women who know what they want and set out to achieve their goals. They are also kind women who give others chances and notice the marginalised.
God gives each one of us a gift. "God gifted her with the desire and the ability to play." It is up to us what we do with that gift.
The novel is about breaking down the traditional boundaries. Just because something has always been done that way does not make it necessarily right.
This theme leads into the theme of slavery which had been abolished by the time of the novel, 1871. Some characters treat everyone they meet with kindness and compassion. They see the state of their heart and not the colour of their skin.
There are some beautiful bonds within the novel. Family are those who love and encourage us to follow our dreams and to soar.
Blood ties do not always mean love ties. There is one close knit family though who are wonderful.
Fathers are important. The love of a father lasts beyond death. The love of our Father god is perfect. "His motivation always stems from love." He will never let us down.
Taking care of the widows and orphans is another theme.
Great love equates to great grief. "Grief was a strange thing. You could try to avoid it... but...grief... always returned." Grief hurts even when we know the eternal destination of our loved ones.
Music soothes. It bridges the class and age divide. Music alters our world and can bring peace to our soul. If music is our gift, we owe it to others to share it.
A Note Yet Unsung is a perfectly wonderful read that educates as it entertains. The reader is left with a heart that soars and a smile on their face.
Just perfect.
Once again Tamera Alexander has woven fact and fiction to produce a first class story. The world is changing. Women are no longer content to sit demurely in the background. The novel features strong modern women who know what they want and set out to achieve their goals. They are also kind women who give others chances and notice the marginalised.
God gives each one of us a gift. "God gifted her with the desire and the ability to play." It is up to us what we do with that gift.
The novel is about breaking down the traditional boundaries. Just because something has always been done that way does not make it necessarily right.
This theme leads into the theme of slavery which had been abolished by the time of the novel, 1871. Some characters treat everyone they meet with kindness and compassion. They see the state of their heart and not the colour of their skin.
There are some beautiful bonds within the novel. Family are those who love and encourage us to follow our dreams and to soar.
Blood ties do not always mean love ties. There is one close knit family though who are wonderful.
Fathers are important. The love of a father lasts beyond death. The love of our Father god is perfect. "His motivation always stems from love." He will never let us down.
Taking care of the widows and orphans is another theme.
Great love equates to great grief. "Grief was a strange thing. You could try to avoid it... but...grief... always returned." Grief hurts even when we know the eternal destination of our loved ones.
Music soothes. It bridges the class and age divide. Music alters our world and can bring peace to our soul. If music is our gift, we owe it to others to share it.
A Note Yet Unsung is a perfectly wonderful read that educates as it entertains. The reader is left with a heart that soars and a smile on their face.
Just perfect.
February 7, 2017
There are so many ways that I could go with this review, but I'm just going to be completely up front and honest. I cried with this book. You made me cry, Tamera Alexander. It was so breathtaking. The rhythm of it all flowed together to produce a beautiful, symphonic harmony.
Every book I've ever read by Tamera Alexander has held me completely spellbound; A Note Yet Unsung was no different.
Rebekah Carrington was sent abroad at a very tender age. Her grandmother sent her away so that she could escape her abusive step-father. Rebekah comes home at her mother's insistence when her grandmother dies. Rebekah decides she cannot live in the house with her stepfather and attempts to secure a job with the symphony. She is refused, because she is a woman.
The Maestro is not what she expected at all, and as life would have it she is found to be working closely with him.
I'm not going to ruin the story for anyone, because I loved it so much. This is definitely one of those books that you could read over and over again and it would get better each time you read it.
A Note Yet Unsung is about finding out who your true friends are, being loyal, and taking chances.
I would recommend this book to anyone! Just don't get it and expect to be a quick read. It was something that I couldn't put down, it was that good. It didn't have explicit content, or any cringe moments.
The cover is also exquisite. It makes you want to just delve right into the story.
Five star review for this masterpiece. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.
I was given a copy of this book by NetGalley for a complete and honest review
Every book I've ever read by Tamera Alexander has held me completely spellbound; A Note Yet Unsung was no different.
Rebekah Carrington was sent abroad at a very tender age. Her grandmother sent her away so that she could escape her abusive step-father. Rebekah comes home at her mother's insistence when her grandmother dies. Rebekah decides she cannot live in the house with her stepfather and attempts to secure a job with the symphony. She is refused, because she is a woman.
The Maestro is not what she expected at all, and as life would have it she is found to be working closely with him.
I'm not going to ruin the story for anyone, because I loved it so much. This is definitely one of those books that you could read over and over again and it would get better each time you read it.
A Note Yet Unsung is about finding out who your true friends are, being loyal, and taking chances.
I would recommend this book to anyone! Just don't get it and expect to be a quick read. It was something that I couldn't put down, it was that good. It didn't have explicit content, or any cringe moments.
The cover is also exquisite. It makes you want to just delve right into the story.
Five star review for this masterpiece. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.
I was given a copy of this book by NetGalley for a complete and honest review
December 5, 2017
I listened to the audio version of this story, and I can see why A Note Yet Unsung won a Christy Award! Step back in time to Nashville in the mid 1800's and into the world of music. I was captivated by the characters and plot. Well done!
March 4, 2017
Despite her training as a master violinist, Rebekah Carrington was denied entry into the Nashville Philharmonic by young conductor Nathaniel Whitcomb, who bowed to public opinion. Now, with a reluctant muse and a recurring pain in his head, he needs her help to finish his symphony. But how can he win back her trust when he's robbed her of her dream?
This was my absolute favorite in the 3 book Belmont Mansion series, and had such a wow factor that it made my 2017 favorites list. The combination of symphonic music, the music of the hills of Tennessee, and old fashioned hymns really resonated with me. Tate and Rebekah both were affected by difficult circumstances, yet they never gave up on their faith or their love for music.
My favorite part of the entire book was Rebekah's first visit to Tate's home. The love, support and closeness of Tate's family, the sharing of their simple pleasures in music and food, and their strong faith was so tender and sweet. The poem the grandfather wrote will be one I will copy and hold on to forever.
One of Tamera Alexander's best! I highly recommend this entire series and have to say she left the best for last.
Favorite Quotes: "But you must trust that the Lord has your best interest at the center of His heart, and whatever His plans are for your life, for this talent He has given you, He will bring them to fruition in time."
"Seek His desires..above all, no matter what you will have to surrender. And you WILL have to surrender. We all do. It's part of the soul's refinement. ....Then when we surrender...or when He takes something from us, His motivation always stems from love."
This was my absolute favorite in the 3 book Belmont Mansion series, and had such a wow factor that it made my 2017 favorites list. The combination of symphonic music, the music of the hills of Tennessee, and old fashioned hymns really resonated with me. Tate and Rebekah both were affected by difficult circumstances, yet they never gave up on their faith or their love for music.
My favorite part of the entire book was Rebekah's first visit to Tate's home. The love, support and closeness of Tate's family, the sharing of their simple pleasures in music and food, and their strong faith was so tender and sweet. The poem the grandfather wrote will be one I will copy and hold on to forever.
One of Tamera Alexander's best! I highly recommend this entire series and have to say she left the best for last.
Favorite Quotes: "But you must trust that the Lord has your best interest at the center of His heart, and whatever His plans are for your life, for this talent He has given you, He will bring them to fruition in time."
"Seek His desires..above all, no matter what you will have to surrender. And you WILL have to surrender. We all do. It's part of the soul's refinement. ....Then when we surrender...or when He takes something from us, His motivation always stems from love."
March 8, 2023
What a satisfying conclusion to this series! I love how there were three distinct themes present in each book - art, nature, and music - and having long been interested in music (even some classical scores), I soaked in every moment of this last story. I want to share so much about it in a review, yet don't want to share anything at all except to say - it is a MUST READ!
Even though I don't want to share too much, I will share just a few things...
If you are a fan of Southern history, you'll love the fact that the Belmont mansion in Nashville and its owner are an integral part of A Note Yet Unsung. Having visited the mansion in person after reading the first book, I could still visualize many of the rooms mentioned and even that glorious staircase! I imagined the moment that Rebekah played the violin from its second story landing, and the notes of her song permeating the entire house. So exquisite!
Christian themes are definitely present in this story, but a little different than what you'd expect. The message of running the race that has been set before us is the prevailing theme, and it's perfectly woven throughout as Tate is composing his symphony.
If romance is your jam, then this book checks ALL the boxes! My word, the chemistry between these two is palpable! Expect all the goosebumps, stomach flutters, and swoony feelings to capture you as you read!
With a whole host of great reviews from other readers available online, it's clear that this story is another masterpiece from Tamera Alexander. I wanted it to go on for at least another 100 pages or more because these characters feel as real as you can possibly imagine. Ahhhhh, it's so sad to leave them, and now I might be on a book hangover for a long while... *sobs*
Even though I don't want to share too much, I will share just a few things...
If you are a fan of Southern history, you'll love the fact that the Belmont mansion in Nashville and its owner are an integral part of A Note Yet Unsung. Having visited the mansion in person after reading the first book, I could still visualize many of the rooms mentioned and even that glorious staircase! I imagined the moment that Rebekah played the violin from its second story landing, and the notes of her song permeating the entire house. So exquisite!
Christian themes are definitely present in this story, but a little different than what you'd expect. The message of running the race that has been set before us is the prevailing theme, and it's perfectly woven throughout as Tate is composing his symphony.
If romance is your jam, then this book checks ALL the boxes! My word, the chemistry between these two is palpable! Expect all the goosebumps, stomach flutters, and swoony feelings to capture you as you read!
With a whole host of great reviews from other readers available online, it's clear that this story is another masterpiece from Tamera Alexander. I wanted it to go on for at least another 100 pages or more because these characters feel as real as you can possibly imagine. Ahhhhh, it's so sad to leave them, and now I might be on a book hangover for a long while... *sobs*
October 11, 2017
The writing of this book is absolutely gorgeous. I feel as if I've listened to the symphonies described even though I was listening to words instead of music.
At first, I didn't think I was going to like the main guy Tate. He can be harsh, mean, prideful, oblivious, and did I mention arrogant? Yet the author still managed to write him in a way that I was hoping he'd wake up and change, which he does in a very slow but adorable way until I couldn't help but be totally won over by him in the end (his family might have helped in that regard. Characters with big families, especially brothers, are one of my soft spots).
The main girl Rebecca is a good foil for him. She's strong and sassy enough not to take any of his guff, which is exactly what he needed.
The end of the book did seem to wrap things up perhaps a little two quickly, but that was one of my very few complaints. But that was mostly because I was sorry to see the last of Belmont Mansion in these books!
This book also had a few cameo appearances from both sets of characters from the previous books in the Belmont Mansion series and even answered one of the questions left unanswered at the end of A Beauty so Rare (what happened with the building of the new opera house). There was even a few interactions with Marcus that had such an inside joke referencing A Beauty So Rare that I was in stitches laughing at it. So very well done.
At first, I didn't think I was going to like the main guy Tate. He can be harsh, mean, prideful, oblivious, and did I mention arrogant? Yet the author still managed to write him in a way that I was hoping he'd wake up and change, which he does in a very slow but adorable way until I couldn't help but be totally won over by him in the end (his family might have helped in that regard. Characters with big families, especially brothers, are one of my soft spots).
The main girl Rebecca is a good foil for him. She's strong and sassy enough not to take any of his guff, which is exactly what he needed.
The end of the book did seem to wrap things up perhaps a little two quickly, but that was one of my very few complaints. But that was mostly because I was sorry to see the last of Belmont Mansion in these books!
This book also had a few cameo appearances from both sets of characters from the previous books in the Belmont Mansion series and even answered one of the questions left unanswered at the end of A Beauty so Rare (what happened with the building of the new opera house). There was even a few interactions with Marcus that had such an inside joke referencing A Beauty So Rare that I was in stitches laughing at it. So very well done.
February 5, 2017
Grr!!!! This book was SOOOOO close to being an amazing, 5-star read!!! I was completely swept away until the final chapters, when the sumptuous storytelling I'd been blissfully lost in for hours suddenly leapt forward at a frantic gallop to bring the book -- and the series -- to a close... with half the plot too rushed, and the other half left too vague. I wanted to see more! I needed just a few more answers! I also found the character of Billy rather pointless, but then I also did not read the previous book in the series, so perhaps there was some larger reason for his presence that I was simply unaware of. But on the whole, this book was a lavish, literary feast that belongs on every historical fiction lover's keeper shelf!
October 22, 2017
An amazing, heartachingly beautiful tale rich with whimsy and romance. Two gifted musicians who are facing some of life's greatest struggles come together and find love in a most unexpected way...a must-read!
Read
April 14, 2018Thoroughly enjoyed this novel! The history was fascinating, and the characters well-rounded and endearing. It's challenging to portray music with mere words, but Tamera Alexander did a wonderful job. I can't wait to read more from her.
April 9, 2017
***4.5 stars***
Oh my goodness! What a wonderful story. This book has cemented Tamera Alexander as one of my favorite authors.
One thing that I love about historical fiction is when I learn something interesting. I did not know that at one time women were not encouraged to play the violin. It was considered a manly instrument and men were allowed to perform on stage. Really? Wow! I am so grateful for the women who paved the way for me to have had the experience of playing the violin on stage in an orchestra.
The love story between Tate and Rebekah begins on a "sour note." (Pun intended.) Really it was a miscommunication of intent, but I loved Rebekah's gumption and willingness to put herself in uncomfortable situations to go after her dream.
The way their past unfolds and their secrets revealed was well written. This story is great from start to end. This is the third book in a series. Characters from the previous two are mentioned, but this book can be read as a stand alone.
The book contains Christian themes, non-graphic violence, non-graphic sexual assault, and kissing.
Source: I received a complimentary copy of the book from Bethany House to review.
Oh my goodness! What a wonderful story. This book has cemented Tamera Alexander as one of my favorite authors.
One thing that I love about historical fiction is when I learn something interesting. I did not know that at one time women were not encouraged to play the violin. It was considered a manly instrument and men were allowed to perform on stage. Really? Wow! I am so grateful for the women who paved the way for me to have had the experience of playing the violin on stage in an orchestra.
The love story between Tate and Rebekah begins on a "sour note." (Pun intended.) Really it was a miscommunication of intent, but I loved Rebekah's gumption and willingness to put herself in uncomfortable situations to go after her dream.
The way their past unfolds and their secrets revealed was well written. This story is great from start to end. This is the third book in a series. Characters from the previous two are mentioned, but this book can be read as a stand alone.
The book contains Christian themes, non-graphic violence, non-graphic sexual assault, and kissing.
Source: I received a complimentary copy of the book from Bethany House to review.
May 27, 2017
5/26--Full review!
First. Of. All. Let me just say that I truly appreciate Tamera Alexander's attention to detail. Her rich setting and "little things" that her character do make her books so easy to just completely entrench oneself into the story. You're just THERE.
*Ahem* Going on. These characters, y'all. They will worm their way into your heart. To be perfectly honest, I actually didn't care for Rebekah too much at first. She seemed a little too egotistical, a trait that I have mentioned in reviews before to be abhorrent. Fortunately, she much improved as the story progressed, and I was quite proud of her in the end. And ohhhhhh, Tate. Maddening man, that. And absolutely, positively one of the most fleshed out, beautifully written characters I've had the joy of knowing. Not only did it sound like he was well put together on the outside, but his essence was so wonderfully done. His past, present, and future. TA, much applause.
STO-ree. So good. Well weaved with history, this book shows the stark contrast of different areas of the US in the post Civil War era. I've always known that the dichotomy was striking, but TA takes it to an even higher level. The love story was beautiful, as was the plot of the symphony. I thoroughly enjoyed both plots, but I have to say that my favorite aspect of the entire novel wasn't the plush Belmont, the rich music history, the opulent opera house, or sweet romance. It was Tate's family. Get ready to fall into absolute adoration. I hesitate to say more because spoilers, but I just couldn't NOT mention them.
AT ANY RATE. I loved this book. I was honored to receive it as a part of GoodReads Giveaways, and thoroughly enjoyed it. Every opinion here would have been stated verbatim had I bought the book myself.
First. Of. All. Let me just say that I truly appreciate Tamera Alexander's attention to detail. Her rich setting and "little things" that her character do make her books so easy to just completely entrench oneself into the story. You're just THERE.
*Ahem* Going on. These characters, y'all. They will worm their way into your heart. To be perfectly honest, I actually didn't care for Rebekah too much at first. She seemed a little too egotistical, a trait that I have mentioned in reviews before to be abhorrent. Fortunately, she much improved as the story progressed, and I was quite proud of her in the end. And ohhhhhh, Tate. Maddening man, that. And absolutely, positively one of the most fleshed out, beautifully written characters I've had the joy of knowing. Not only did it sound like he was well put together on the outside, but his essence was so wonderfully done. His past, present, and future. TA, much applause.
STO-ree. So good. Well weaved with history, this book shows the stark contrast of different areas of the US in the post Civil War era. I've always known that the dichotomy was striking, but TA takes it to an even higher level. The love story was beautiful, as was the plot of the symphony. I thoroughly enjoyed both plots, but I have to say that my favorite aspect of the entire novel wasn't the plush Belmont, the rich music history, the opulent opera house, or sweet romance. It was Tate's family. Get ready to fall into absolute adoration. I hesitate to say more because spoilers, but I just couldn't NOT mention them.
AT ANY RATE. I loved this book. I was honored to receive it as a part of GoodReads Giveaways, and thoroughly enjoyed it. Every opinion here would have been stated verbatim had I bought the book myself.
February 7, 2017
First off, this will definitely be in my library of paperbacks. I love Tamera Alexander's novels. They keep you engaged and connected with the characters. This is the third installment of the Belmont Mansion series, although they are all stand alone. I love the banter between Rebekah and Tate! They argue and get each other! One of my favorite scenes:
Tate took her in his arms and kissed her, his lips gentle at first. Then slowly, deliberately, as he wove his hands into her hair, his kiss grew more insistent, his breath quickening as did hers. Rebekah had thought the moment they shared behind the ticket office had robbed her of composure, but this- She felt herself melting into him, keenly aware of where she ended and he began, but her desire for him begged her to lesson that distance. She wrapped her arms around his neck to make certain she stayed upright.
"Rebekah," he whispered against her mouth. He tasted of mint and something else sweet.
"What," she said softly.
"Are we still arguing?"
"Yes..." She grinned. "And I'm winning."
He laughed. "If this is how we argue..." He kissed her again."Then I'll let you win every time."
I had the hardest time putting it down for "real life"cause I wanted to find out what would happen next. Each ending was like that, cliffhanger to the next chapter. There are moments of tears of joy and sadness and it was worth every moment. I also enjoyed catching up with previous characters in the series. 4.5 stars
Tate took her in his arms and kissed her, his lips gentle at first. Then slowly, deliberately, as he wove his hands into her hair, his kiss grew more insistent, his breath quickening as did hers. Rebekah had thought the moment they shared behind the ticket office had robbed her of composure, but this- She felt herself melting into him, keenly aware of where she ended and he began, but her desire for him begged her to lesson that distance. She wrapped her arms around his neck to make certain she stayed upright.
"Rebekah," he whispered against her mouth. He tasted of mint and something else sweet.
"What," she said softly.
"Are we still arguing?"
"Yes..." She grinned. "And I'm winning."
He laughed. "If this is how we argue..." He kissed her again."Then I'll let you win every time."
I had the hardest time putting it down for "real life"cause I wanted to find out what would happen next. Each ending was like that, cliffhanger to the next chapter. There are moments of tears of joy and sadness and it was worth every moment. I also enjoyed catching up with previous characters in the series. 4.5 stars
July 21, 2023
Another awesome book by the talented Tamera Alexander! Historical fiction set in the very real setting of the Belmont Mansion in Nashville, Tennessee, this third book of the series stars Rebekah Carrington, a violinist trained in Vienna who has returned to her hometown hoping to audition for the new Nashville Philharmonic. But when she actually gets into the director's office, he immediately dismisses her as "only a woman." Women are not allowed to be in orchestras no matter how talented. But he will accept her valuable help in writing his upcoming symphony debut to be the first concert in the new opera house. As they work side-by-side, they begin to appreciate each others' gifts, until the unthinkable happens to the conductor.
A master novel by a master storyteller. She simply draws you in and doesn't let you go. And the characters allow their faith to mold their choices and responses. Highly recommended for Christian historical fiction readers!
A master novel by a master storyteller. She simply draws you in and doesn't let you go. And the characters allow their faith to mold their choices and responses. Highly recommended for Christian historical fiction readers!
March 1, 2017
Oh, my word! People have been telling me to read Tamera Alexander's books for years, but this is my first one. Now I'm going to have to go back and get the rest of her titles. She's THAT good. I was sucked in by this story from the first page and it didn't let go until the end. Actually, I'm not sure it even let go then because I'm still thinking about it. A keeper!
October 24, 2017
A Note Yet Unsung by Tamera Alexander
Year: 1871
Location: Nashville, TN
Main Characters:
Rebekah Carrington
Adelicia Cheatham, Wealthy patron of the arts, Rebekah’s employer
Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb, Nashville Philharmonic maestro
Barton Ledbetter, Rebecca’s evil step-father
Delphia, Ledbetter housekeeper, sister to Demetrius
Demetrius, ex-slave, inspired and taught Rebecca on the violin
Sigh.
I've read a lot of really good books over the last couple months, but this one was amazing.
This is the last of the Belmont Mansion novels, and in my opinion, the best. Oh, really, they were all good, but this one was so “sigh-worthy”.
There is such depth to this book. Just as you think you know what's going to happen, Ms. Alexander designs several subplots to catch your attention and make you wonder what's going to happen with them. Very little of it was predictable, which is such a rare find. Even up to the end you will get at least three surprises.
Synopsis:
I ran a gamut of emotions throughout the whole book, ending with a nice tear-jerker of a story in the author's notes at the end. Wow!
I can recommend this book to anyone. Clean, wonderful, and a satisfying faith theme throughout the book.
March 13, 2017
About this book:
“A master violinist trained in Vienna, Rebekah Carrington manages to wheedle her way into an audition with the maestro at the newly-formed Nashville Philharmonic. But women are "far too fragile and frail" for the rigors of an orchestra, and Rebekah's hopes are swiftly dashed because the conductor--determined to leave his mark on the world of classical music--bows to public opinion. To make matters worse, Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, mistress of Belmont Mansion and Rebekah's new employer, agrees with him.
Nationally acclaimed conductor Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb is Nashville's new orchestra leader. And despite a reluctant muse--and a strange buzzing and recurring pain in his head--he must finish composing his symphony before the grand opening of the city's new opera hall. But far more pressing, he must finish it for the one who first inspired his love of music--his father, who is dying. As Tate's ailment worsens, he believes Rebekah can help him finish his symphony. But how do you win back a woman's trust when you've robbed her of her dream?”
Series: The last book in the “Belmont Mansion” series. Read reviews of Book #1 Here! & Book #2 Here!
Spiritual Content- Proverbs 5:21 at the beginning; Scriptures are quoted, referenced, read & talked about; A Hymn is played, sung & talked about many times; A song about going to see God is sung; Prayers & a Blessing over food; A bit of being witnessed to; Talks about God, His voice & gifts; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God (expect three aren’t); Rebekah isn’t sure God is patient & generous-hearted as her father always said, but starts praying; Many mentions of God, His plans & gifts from God; Mentions of prayers & praying; Mentions of churches, church going, services & songs; Mentions of Bibles; A few mentions of a missionary; A few mentions of blessings & blessing someone; A few mentions of Heaven; A mention of a cathedral;
*Note: A mention of a man looking like Adonis in the flesh.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blasted’, a ‘dumb’, a ‘n*gger’, and two forms of ‘idiot’; Sarcasm; Mentions of curses (said, not written); Pain (up to semi-detailed); Stabbing someone with a knife (self-defense, barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of deaths, murders, beatings & blood (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a death & wondering if it was murder; Mentions of the war, slaves, slavery, soldiers, deaths & killings; Mentions of mine accidents, deaths, injuries & violence (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of pain & bad headaches & illnesses; Mentions of alcohol, wine, drinking & a drunk; Mentions of moonshine, blood feuds, shooting someone & a slit throat (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of cigars, tobacco & smoking; Mentions of addictions, morphine, laudanum & opium dens; Mentions of a whipping & pain; Mentions of debts; Mentions of lying & lies; Mentions of throwing up; Mentions of squirrel hunting, skinning them & making stew out of them (barely-above-not-detailed); A few mentions of roasted a pig & a young girl feeling sad for him; A few mentions of jealousy & envy; A couple mentions of a poker game; A mention of a hog killing; A mention of a sound like a polecat begging to die.
Sexual Content- two finger-to-lips touches (up to semi-detailed), two almost kisses, a palm kiss, seven hand kisses, a cheek kiss, three forehead kisses, four barely-above-not-detailed kisses, two semi-detailed kisses, and three detailed kisses; Remembering kisses (semi-detailed); Wanting to & Thinking about touch/ing & kiss/ing someone (up to semi-detailed); Wanting to be kissed & desires (barely-above-not-detailed); Touches, Unwanted touches, Embraces & Warmth (up to semi-detailed); Noticing, Staring at lips, Smelling & Nearness (semi-detailed); Remembering touches & warmth (barely-above-not-detailed); Remembering & many mentions of when she was thirteen, Rebekah’s stepfather tried to rape her (semi-detailed, no true details but mentions of him being pulled off her & her bodice ripped); *Spoiler**End of Spoiler*; Mentions of kisses, kissing & thinking about kissing someone (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of touches (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of reasons a man would be out late at night (none of them respectable); Mentions of noticing & staring; Mentions of flirting & a flirt; A few mentions of a married couple sharing or not sharing a bed (Rebekah also mentions that if she marries she’d want to share her husband’s bed); A few mentions of debauchery; A few mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of blushes; A couple mentions of gentlemen’s clubs & the women there; A couple mentions of young couples sparking mischief; A couple mentions of a stealing a kiss or two from a woman; A couple mentions of reputations & compromising someone; Love, falling in love & the emotions.
*Note: A few mentions of the painting of Beatrice Cenci & her story of being raped by family members (no details); A few mentions of a fifteen-year-old mother pulling a breast out of her shirt & nursing her infant; A couple mentions of a man’s crude comment about how a woman got a spot in an orchestra; A couple mentions of young women flaunting their womanly charms & then becoming warm-natured as they talked with Tate; A couple mentions of a woman arranging her bodice to show more of her décolletage & men staring at her plentiful assets; A couple mentions of a statue of a woman’s robe falling and showing a breast; A couple mentions of noticing Tate noticing Rebekah’s womanly curves; A couple mentions of the prostitute in the Bible; A mention of a woman’s curves; A mention of an ad for attractive female servers, but nothing on what they would be doing.
-Rebekah Carrington, age 23
-Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb, age 32
P.O.V. switches between them
Set in 1871
425 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- Two Stars
My personal Rating- Two Stars
I was very hesitate over reviewing this novel due to the author’s last book having so much sexual content. However, I did highly enjoy the previous two books in this series. Add in that the orchestra and violin music was a large factor of this novel’s plot, I decided to take a chance and read it.
Before I go any further, I should say that I’m very weak for anything with a violin. It’s been my favorite instrument for longer than I can remember. {One reason I loved the quote on page 92, “There are places in the heart where only the violin can reach.”, on which I very much agree.}
I’ve seen other reviewers mention feeling that this book was slow, and while I can understand that, I didn’t feel that way. But, then again, I really do love classical music and orchestra details. Those who don’t feel the same, though, would most likely find all those parts in this story not as interesting as another part. The author also added to the novel by linking the pieces the characters would play in the book on her website so the reader can listen along. I truly appreciate that. :)
There were parts and things I didn’t like, though. And unfortunately those scenes reflect on my ratings. We see many flashbacks and mentions of when Rebekah’s stepfather tried to rape her when she was young. He later tries to corner her again. As Tate & Rebekah’s relationship grows their kisses lead to a few detailed kisses. (A detailed kiss is a kiss that is described in three or more sentences.)
I honestly would have been thrilled to give this novel a three- or four-star rating, but because of some of the content, I cannot even though I enjoyed quite a bit of this book and seeing Eleanor & Marcus and Claire & Edward again those few times.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Bethany House) for this honest review.
“A master violinist trained in Vienna, Rebekah Carrington manages to wheedle her way into an audition with the maestro at the newly-formed Nashville Philharmonic. But women are "far too fragile and frail" for the rigors of an orchestra, and Rebekah's hopes are swiftly dashed because the conductor--determined to leave his mark on the world of classical music--bows to public opinion. To make matters worse, Adelicia Acklen Cheatham, mistress of Belmont Mansion and Rebekah's new employer, agrees with him.
Nationally acclaimed conductor Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb is Nashville's new orchestra leader. And despite a reluctant muse--and a strange buzzing and recurring pain in his head--he must finish composing his symphony before the grand opening of the city's new opera hall. But far more pressing, he must finish it for the one who first inspired his love of music--his father, who is dying. As Tate's ailment worsens, he believes Rebekah can help him finish his symphony. But how do you win back a woman's trust when you've robbed her of her dream?”
Series: The last book in the “Belmont Mansion” series. Read reviews of Book #1 Here! & Book #2 Here!
Spiritual Content- Proverbs 5:21 at the beginning; Scriptures are quoted, referenced, read & talked about; A Hymn is played, sung & talked about many times; A song about going to see God is sung; Prayers & a Blessing over food; A bit of being witnessed to; Talks about God, His voice & gifts; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God (expect three aren’t); Rebekah isn’t sure God is patient & generous-hearted as her father always said, but starts praying; Many mentions of God, His plans & gifts from God; Mentions of prayers & praying; Mentions of churches, church going, services & songs; Mentions of Bibles; A few mentions of a missionary; A few mentions of blessings & blessing someone; A few mentions of Heaven; A mention of a cathedral;
*Note: A mention of a man looking like Adonis in the flesh.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blasted’, a ‘dumb’, a ‘n*gger’, and two forms of ‘idiot’; Sarcasm; Mentions of curses (said, not written); Pain (up to semi-detailed); Stabbing someone with a knife (self-defense, barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of deaths, murders, beatings & blood (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a death & wondering if it was murder; Mentions of the war, slaves, slavery, soldiers, deaths & killings; Mentions of mine accidents, deaths, injuries & violence (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of pain & bad headaches & illnesses; Mentions of alcohol, wine, drinking & a drunk; Mentions of moonshine, blood feuds, shooting someone & a slit throat (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of cigars, tobacco & smoking; Mentions of addictions, morphine, laudanum & opium dens; Mentions of a whipping & pain; Mentions of debts; Mentions of lying & lies; Mentions of throwing up; Mentions of squirrel hunting, skinning them & making stew out of them (barely-above-not-detailed); A few mentions of roasted a pig & a young girl feeling sad for him; A few mentions of jealousy & envy; A couple mentions of a poker game; A mention of a hog killing; A mention of a sound like a polecat begging to die.
Sexual Content- two finger-to-lips touches (up to semi-detailed), two almost kisses, a palm kiss, seven hand kisses, a cheek kiss, three forehead kisses, four barely-above-not-detailed kisses, two semi-detailed kisses, and three detailed kisses; Remembering kisses (semi-detailed); Wanting to & Thinking about touch/ing & kiss/ing someone (up to semi-detailed); Wanting to be kissed & desires (barely-above-not-detailed); Touches, Unwanted touches, Embraces & Warmth (up to semi-detailed); Noticing, Staring at lips, Smelling & Nearness (semi-detailed); Remembering touches & warmth (barely-above-not-detailed); Remembering & many mentions of when she was thirteen, Rebekah’s stepfather tried to rape her (semi-detailed, no true details but mentions of him being pulled off her & her bodice ripped); *Spoiler**End of Spoiler*; Mentions of kisses, kissing & thinking about kissing someone (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of touches (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of reasons a man would be out late at night (none of them respectable); Mentions of noticing & staring; Mentions of flirting & a flirt; A few mentions of a married couple sharing or not sharing a bed (Rebekah also mentions that if she marries she’d want to share her husband’s bed); A few mentions of debauchery; A few mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of blushes; A couple mentions of gentlemen’s clubs & the women there; A couple mentions of young couples sparking mischief; A couple mentions of a stealing a kiss or two from a woman; A couple mentions of reputations & compromising someone; Love, falling in love & the emotions.
*Note: A few mentions of the painting of Beatrice Cenci & her story of being raped by family members (no details); A few mentions of a fifteen-year-old mother pulling a breast out of her shirt & nursing her infant; A couple mentions of a man’s crude comment about how a woman got a spot in an orchestra; A couple mentions of young women flaunting their womanly charms & then becoming warm-natured as they talked with Tate; A couple mentions of a woman arranging her bodice to show more of her décolletage & men staring at her plentiful assets; A couple mentions of a statue of a woman’s robe falling and showing a breast; A couple mentions of noticing Tate noticing Rebekah’s womanly curves; A couple mentions of the prostitute in the Bible; A mention of a woman’s curves; A mention of an ad for attractive female servers, but nothing on what they would be doing.
-Rebekah Carrington, age 23
-Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb, age 32
P.O.V. switches between them
Set in 1871
425 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- Two Stars
My personal Rating- Two Stars
I was very hesitate over reviewing this novel due to the author’s last book having so much sexual content. However, I did highly enjoy the previous two books in this series. Add in that the orchestra and violin music was a large factor of this novel’s plot, I decided to take a chance and read it.
Before I go any further, I should say that I’m very weak for anything with a violin. It’s been my favorite instrument for longer than I can remember. {One reason I loved the quote on page 92, “There are places in the heart where only the violin can reach.”, on which I very much agree.}
I’ve seen other reviewers mention feeling that this book was slow, and while I can understand that, I didn’t feel that way. But, then again, I really do love classical music and orchestra details. Those who don’t feel the same, though, would most likely find all those parts in this story not as interesting as another part. The author also added to the novel by linking the pieces the characters would play in the book on her website so the reader can listen along. I truly appreciate that. :)
There were parts and things I didn’t like, though. And unfortunately those scenes reflect on my ratings. We see many flashbacks and mentions of when Rebekah’s stepfather tried to rape her when she was young. He later tries to corner her again. As Tate & Rebekah’s relationship grows their kisses lead to a few detailed kisses. (A detailed kiss is a kiss that is described in three or more sentences.)
I honestly would have been thrilled to give this novel a three- or four-star rating, but because of some of the content, I cannot even though I enjoyed quite a bit of this book and seeing Eleanor & Marcus and Claire & Edward again those few times.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Bethany House) for this honest review.
May 30, 2017
Stunningly beautiful. Alexander's words washed over me and soaked into the very fiber of my being. This story is illusive and magical and all-consuming. I couldn't stop reading but I wanted to put on the brakes because I dreaded it being over too soon.
Rich in character and setting and delicious details that make the plot zing. I loved it all -- Tate's family, Rebekah's connection with her grandmother, her villainous step-father and ineffectual mother. Sweet Opal and repugnant Darrow Fulton. The solid threads of faith and family that jar with the cutthroat life in the orchestra world.
This story left me breathless. I'm still enthralled, replaying favourite scenes, rewriting other ones and allowing my imagination free reign on a happily-ever-after expansion.
Tate is a hero I needed to warm up to. I love the way the author slowly reveals intriguing tidbits from his past. Suddenly I was seeing Tate in a whole new light. There's unexpected depth in the taciturn, ambitious, often autocratic maestro! And though it took some time, when I fell for him, I fell hard!
Much like Rebekah. A brilliant, passionate musician who can't follow her destiny because of the ridiculous rules of 'proper' society. Women too delicate and fragile for the rigors of playing in an orchestra! Pshaw! Loved the historical details -- even when they infuriated me.
And I also love the unabashed way Tamera Alexander weaves faith and God into the heart of her story. Uplifting and unforgettable. Definitely one for the keeper shelf!
Rich in character and setting and delicious details that make the plot zing. I loved it all -- Tate's family, Rebekah's connection with her grandmother, her villainous step-father and ineffectual mother. Sweet Opal and repugnant Darrow Fulton. The solid threads of faith and family that jar with the cutthroat life in the orchestra world.
This story left me breathless. I'm still enthralled, replaying favourite scenes, rewriting other ones and allowing my imagination free reign on a happily-ever-after expansion.
Tate is a hero I needed to warm up to. I love the way the author slowly reveals intriguing tidbits from his past. Suddenly I was seeing Tate in a whole new light. There's unexpected depth in the taciturn, ambitious, often autocratic maestro! And though it took some time, when I fell for him, I fell hard!
Much like Rebekah. A brilliant, passionate musician who can't follow her destiny because of the ridiculous rules of 'proper' society. Women too delicate and fragile for the rigors of playing in an orchestra! Pshaw! Loved the historical details -- even when they infuriated me.
And I also love the unabashed way Tamera Alexander weaves faith and God into the heart of her story. Uplifting and unforgettable. Definitely one for the keeper shelf!
June 6, 2017
This one is probably my favorite in this "series" (I say series because the books are loosely connected with some of the same characters, but really they are standalones). I really, really liked the main character Rebekah and the way music was handled in this book - from the symphony orchestra, to the old fashioned hymms to the late night playing to get others to sleep was just beautiful. I do not play music but am a fan of it and the way it enhanced and enriched the story was well done. I also liked the way the main character Tate was written. At the beginning of the book I didn't like him, thought he was too proud, too arrogant but then as the story develops and he is fleshed out and we get the chance to know him, my feelings changed. I probably liked him better than Rebekah in the end. Probably my only quibble with this book is the way Rebekah's stepfather was written, he was too villainy and obviously evil and I couldn't understand why others did not see it. But other than that, this book was great. I think Adelicia Cheatham really stood out in this book more than the others (though its been years since I've read the first two books). If someone ever wrote a book on her life I'd read it. She is such an interesting person!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 424 reviews