4 twinkling-though-threatened stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐
A tale as dark as it is light. A man-made Western community – Emerson Pass – riddled with its “dark undercurrents” of bigotry; an America that is a “contradiction of ideals and actual practices”, and merely sheds hazy glimpses of its Dream. A woman, and a man, whose boldness of character knows no end; a prevailing sentiment of Merriness that defies convention and defeat, and humbly celebrates its triumph.
❄️❄️❄️
QUOTE:
"I was a young man when I first came to America. So young, in fact, that I hadn’t yet considered the consequences of my choices. I wanted only to have adventures. The idea of doing what was expected of me seemed like a death sentence. I’d read of the western frontier and the men and women who had braved rough terrain and wild animals to better their circumstances. This idea was so very American to me and stirred my blood. I gave up the inheritance and the title, leaving it all to my younger brother who was so much better suited for it all. I was free and that’s all I wanted. Now, all these years later, I understood what a romantic fantasy the wild west had been. In those tales of conquering heroes, there was no mention of the American government’s manipulation of white settlers or the atrocities done to tribal nations. The government had promised rich, fertile soil in Indian Territory to anyone willing to bet on a homestead. They’d lured them out west with outright lies for the sole purpose of expansion and destroyed Native American life.
All this said, I had no regrets. I’d made the life for myself that I’d dream of as a boy. All on my own terms and in my own ways."
- Alexander Barnes, on his journey to the west and the myth of the American dream.
THE STORY:
Alexander Barnes landed on Emerson Pass and made (fictional) history. He feels one with his land, and thrives on its prosperity. Following the tragic death of his mentally ill wife (think of Mr Rochester) three years prior to the narrative's incipit, Lord Barnes poured all his energies into sowing love and affection in the hearts of his five precious children, Fiona (3), Cymbeline (6), twins Theo and Flynn (9) and Josephine (13). His mission to provide a wholesome life to the residents of Emerson Pass urges him to set up a school 🏫 and appoint a schoolmistress 👩🏫, thereby providing free education to the young population. Yet on the momentous night of Miss Quinn Cooper's arrival, much goes amiss and actions that cannot be undone open up wounds and cracks deep-etched within the fabric of this community. Alexander's neighbour and village friend, Samuel Cole, gets shot to his death while Harley is escorting Miss Cooper to her accommodation; she falls off the sleigh 🛷 and loses consciousness, only to return to it in Lord Barnes' library, surrounded by angels...The rest, as they say, is history, and yet, much revolves around the dark mystery of Cole's death: a good, tough, and hard-working man who illegally brings home a black wife, Rachel, and lovingly sets up a family with her. Is she the reason he is dead❓
COMMENTS:
Much of the narration revolves around this troubling occurrence, and casts shadows over Miss Cooper's teaching appointment. Like Lord Barnes, she has no intention of excluding Rachel's children from her classroom, yet the air is tension-ridden, and she must brave dangers, and undergo many a test if she is to fight for what she believes in. The history of the land comes to the reader in snippets, such that the historical framework of this story constitutes more of a backdrop rather than its central focus and nucleus, that palpitates with emotion and romance. As per novel title, Miss Quinn's role as revolutionising schoolmistress and teacher is indeed put at the forefront, by way of underlining the reigning status of love, courage, and education over riches and roughness of heart. With her matter-of-fact practicality, courage, transparency and independence, Quinn's character is strikingly reminiscent of Jane Eyre, though curiously mingled with governess Maria from The Sound of Music, in the way she instructs, inspires and lovingly cares for the Barnes children, but also in the unconventional nature of her burgeoning love story with Lord Barnes.
The narration is pleasantly eventful and fast-paced, with the exception of a few chapters towards the middle of the story that lacked freshness or interest. In this sense, narrative drive owes much to the children's naïve plea - blurted out early on in the story - that Miss Quinn ought to become their mother. Much like the Von Trapp children, they shrewdly conspire against their unloving nannies and run out of them faster than the effort it takes to appoint one, given the children's willful wildness and the land's unforgiving winters.
I could hardly do the story justice without the mention of the formidable staff at Barnes estate: principally, the quintessentially British, upright butler, Jasper, who is eternally bent on preserving a level of formality and adhering to old-fashioned principles. There is something about the role of a butler that is to my mind irresistible; a feeling possibly immortalised by the place butler Stevens (from The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro) holds in my heart ❤️. Between Quinn's homesickness for her mother and sister Annabelle, Lizzie's lifelong devotion to the Barnes family and Lord Barnes' Jesus-like helping-hand within the community, a profound sense of family permeates the pages of this story and infuses heat and warmth into the otherwise snowy, freezing, and tempestuous landscape of winters in Emerson Pass.
❄️❄️❄️
Describing The School Mistress, my first of Tess Thompson, as a cosy and heart-warming read is an understatement. Its overall effect is fizzy and cheerful, culminating in a triple wedding and happily-ever-after for all members of the extended Barnes family 💍🥂🍾. You see, Thompson summons a vast repertoire of feel-good elements in this one: one could say that she pulls out all the stops!
A read to sneakily squeeze into one's bursting TBR list!
FAVOURITE QUOTE 🌹:
"The world was a hard place and courage our only map."
***Special thanks to Goodreads friend Mary-Lisa on whose profile I found this book! ♥️📘***