From the moment I read the very first paragraph, I knew that I would like this book. There was humor, a strong and likable heroine (who was not drop-dead-gorgeous to boot!), an equally strong and tortured hero (who unfortunately? was gorgeous - and an utter fool), and secondary characters I wanted to get to know better (such as Marcus).
What I liked best about this book would probably be the heroine. For once, I felt as if I got a heroine who was not particularly skilled at anything, and yet was capable enough to save her love not once, but twice. This is such a marvel to me that it almost compensates for the tiny ways in which the book did not work for me.
The plot was predictable. The hero is a spy for England - kind of. He is one of the four who are responsible for the safety of the Prince Regent. Of course he has a problem that prevents him from trusting women. Of course that problem gets him in trouble. And yet, seen through Lady Olivia's eyes, he became a likable enough character. It is just that I wished to bash him over the head for his blindness, pretty much what his friends and the Prince Regent probably wanted to do when he doubted his wife. Also, amazingly enough, he was a virgin. Can you believe that? What a delight! That's probably why I had put this book on my To-Be-Read pile in the first place; I had forgotten. But of course he had to be fantastic in bed his first time around...
I had mentioned secondary characters. I liked Marcus. He seemed nice and caring. He is Lord Dane's good friend - and likely successor. Through Olivia's eyes, he became the sweet brother she had loved and lost. Granted, he didn't particularly care for the comparison to her deceased brother, but since she was his best friend's wife, he could accept the role - and hope for his own HEA.
And then there is Olivia's brother. Hmm...what can I say that won't give much away? Not much so I'll leave it at that. I do wish I had a brother who was as good and loving to me as Olivia's brother had been to her. Instead, I must make do with two younger sisters.
Lord Traitor makes an appearance. Apparently he has had his own book. I will have to seek it out, Surrender to a Wicked Spy being my first exposure (I think) to Celeste Bradley (or at least to this particular series).
What did I not like about this book, aside from the parents from hell and how Dane treated his wife during the party? How very contemporary the voices of the character and the narrative seemed to be. Strip away the historical trappings and you get a modern day romance. I am not very partial to contemporary romance. I do not demand stringent historical accuracies. Indeed, I have little knowledge of them. However, in some cases, the inaccuracies cross the point to obviousness, in which case, they do bother me. Luckily, Celeste Bradley has a particularly humorous style of writing that enabled me to enjoy this book despite the contemporary style of writing. If only, now, that she had refrained from constant references of Viking gods, their ginormous anatomy, and the ridiculous training idea. What a laugh. But then again, that was probably the whole point.