What do you think?
Joy and Fear: The Beatles, Chicago and the 1960s
A riveting look at the polarizing nature of the Beatles phenomenon, and how it transformed a generation, through the lens of a singular city in the center of America.
For many, the Beatles offered a delightful alternative to the dull and the staid, while for others, the mop-top haircuts, the unsettling music, and the hysterical girls that greeted the British imports wherever they went were a symbol of unwelcome social and cultural change. This opposition to the group—more widespread and deeper rooted in Chicago than in any other major American city—increased as the decade wore on, especially when the Beatles adopted more extreme countercultural values.
At the center of this book is a cast of characters engulfed by the whirlwind of Beatlemania, including the unyielding figure of Mayor Richard J. Daley who deemed the Beatles a threat to the well-being of his city; the Chicago Tribune editor who first warned the nation about the Beatle menace; George Harrison’s sister, Louise, who became a regular presence on Chicago radio; the socialist revolutionary who staged all of the Beatles’ concerts in the city and used much of the profits from the shows to fund left-wing causes; the African-American girl who braved an intimidating environment to see the Beatles in concert; a fan club founder who disbelievingly found herself occupying a room opposite her heroes when they stayed at her father’s hotel; the University of Chicago medical student who spent his summer vacation playing in a group that opened for the Beatles’ on their last tour; and the suburban record store owner who opened a teen club modeled on the Cavern in Liverpool that hosted some of the biggest bands in the world.
Drawing on historical and contemporary accounts, Joy and Fear brings to life the frenzied excitement of Beatlemania in 1960s Chicago, while also illustrating the deep-seated hostility from the establishment toward the Beatles.
For many, the Beatles offered a delightful alternative to the dull and the staid, while for others, the mop-top haircuts, the unsettling music, and the hysterical girls that greeted the British imports wherever they went were a symbol of unwelcome social and cultural change. This opposition to the group—more widespread and deeper rooted in Chicago than in any other major American city—increased as the decade wore on, especially when the Beatles adopted more extreme countercultural values.
At the center of this book is a cast of characters engulfed by the whirlwind of Beatlemania, including the unyielding figure of Mayor Richard J. Daley who deemed the Beatles a threat to the well-being of his city; the Chicago Tribune editor who first warned the nation about the Beatle menace; George Harrison’s sister, Louise, who became a regular presence on Chicago radio; the socialist revolutionary who staged all of the Beatles’ concerts in the city and used much of the profits from the shows to fund left-wing causes; the African-American girl who braved an intimidating environment to see the Beatles in concert; a fan club founder who disbelievingly found herself occupying a room opposite her heroes when they stayed at her father’s hotel; the University of Chicago medical student who spent his summer vacation playing in a group that opened for the Beatles’ on their last tour; and the suburban record store owner who opened a teen club modeled on the Cavern in Liverpool that hosted some of the biggest bands in the world.
Drawing on historical and contemporary accounts, Joy and Fear brings to life the frenzied excitement of Beatlemania in 1960s Chicago, while also illustrating the deep-seated hostility from the establishment toward the Beatles.
- GenresMusicNonfictionHistory
368 pages, Paperback
Published March 2, 2021
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
February 3, 2022
This is an entertaining book despite the fact that it sounds at times, like a college sociology report. However, knowing that the infamous "Bigger than Christ" press conference took place in the city, I was interested to see if there were any interesting stories to be had.
For instance, I did not realize the Beatles first Chicago appearance was smack dab in the middle of the Stock Yards district. Nor did I realize that many Chicagoans first heard the Beatles on the black radio stations. It seems there was a bit of a misunderstanding because the Vee Jay label (which released the first Beatles lp in the U.S.) was known for for signing black artists. Listeners who remember it were confused because the group clearly did not sound black, though some actually enjoyed the music.
The city's press seemed much more antagonistic to the band than in places like New York. And Mayor Daley really did try to ban them from staying in the city limits in 1964, as if the city would be destroyed by riots. They were escorted out of town as soon as they finished playing and spent the night in Detroit.
Perhaps my favorite chapter was the one on all the local garage bands that formed in the Beatles' wake such as, The Shadows of Knight, The Buckinghams, The Durty Wurds, The Saturday's Children, The Ides of March, and The Cryan Shames (whose guitarist had a hook for a hand, just like in Wild in the Streets. Coincidence? I think not).
The Beatles in 1966 encountered trouble everywhere, but there were race riots on the day they arrived in Chicago to play what became their final tour. As the decade wore on, Chicagoans, more than the fans in other cities, were repelled by the Beatles' new image as bearded hippies. [Everywhere except Old Town which was the city's answer to Haight Ashbury]. Elsewhere, guys with long hair were hassled well after 1966, while the average citizen applauded the police brutality on display at the 1968 Convention. And everyone hated Yoko.
Thus, to contemporaries, the Beatles breakup was not big news, and they just faded away. As someone who did not have a clear picture of who they were until after they broke up, this is not too surprising. The "Mop Top" image was long gone and by 1970, there were a lot of new bands to pick up the slack.
For instance, I did not realize the Beatles first Chicago appearance was smack dab in the middle of the Stock Yards district. Nor did I realize that many Chicagoans first heard the Beatles on the black radio stations. It seems there was a bit of a misunderstanding because the Vee Jay label (which released the first Beatles lp in the U.S.) was known for for signing black artists. Listeners who remember it were confused because the group clearly did not sound black, though some actually enjoyed the music.
The city's press seemed much more antagonistic to the band than in places like New York. And Mayor Daley really did try to ban them from staying in the city limits in 1964, as if the city would be destroyed by riots. They were escorted out of town as soon as they finished playing and spent the night in Detroit.
Perhaps my favorite chapter was the one on all the local garage bands that formed in the Beatles' wake such as, The Shadows of Knight, The Buckinghams, The Durty Wurds, The Saturday's Children, The Ides of March, and The Cryan Shames (whose guitarist had a hook for a hand, just like in Wild in the Streets. Coincidence? I think not).
The Beatles in 1966 encountered trouble everywhere, but there were race riots on the day they arrived in Chicago to play what became their final tour. As the decade wore on, Chicagoans, more than the fans in other cities, were repelled by the Beatles' new image as bearded hippies. [Everywhere except Old Town which was the city's answer to Haight Ashbury]. Elsewhere, guys with long hair were hassled well after 1966, while the average citizen applauded the police brutality on display at the 1968 Convention. And everyone hated Yoko.
Thus, to contemporaries, the Beatles breakup was not big news, and they just faded away. As someone who did not have a clear picture of who they were until after they broke up, this is not too surprising. The "Mop Top" image was long gone and by 1970, there were a lot of new bands to pick up the slack.
February 10, 2022
John F. Lyons' book "Joy and Fear" looks at the career of the Beatles through the lens of Chicago, IL. That city was a regular stop on the Beatles' tours and was seen as a microcosm of Midwestern USA's reaction to the British Invasion and the Swinging Sixties. With Mayor Richard Daley in charge, Chicago was not an easy town to let your freak flag fly, and the Beatles were seen as pretty freaky.
The book collates the various Chicagoan reactions to the Beatles as described by fans, detractors, editorialists, politicians and musicians. Those reactions range from disgust to ecstasy and evolve along with the music and fashion of the times. For readers who only know how the "coastal elitists" responded to the Fab Four, some of the negative commentary is eye-opening. For a city run by a Democrat, there was a lot of extreme right conservatism in the mainstream. It took a long time for young people to feel safe wearing "hippie" styles in public. Even the KKK was in on the action.
Still, the Beatles gave birth to a lot of garage bands in Chicago and some of those musicians went on to fame. Chicago is also a regular host city to the Annual Fest for Beatles Fans which only shows that the power of the Beatles can outlast their most fervent detractors.
The book collates the various Chicagoan reactions to the Beatles as described by fans, detractors, editorialists, politicians and musicians. Those reactions range from disgust to ecstasy and evolve along with the music and fashion of the times. For readers who only know how the "coastal elitists" responded to the Fab Four, some of the negative commentary is eye-opening. For a city run by a Democrat, there was a lot of extreme right conservatism in the mainstream. It took a long time for young people to feel safe wearing "hippie" styles in public. Even the KKK was in on the action.
Still, the Beatles gave birth to a lot of garage bands in Chicago and some of those musicians went on to fame. Chicago is also a regular host city to the Annual Fest for Beatles Fans which only shows that the power of the Beatles can outlast their most fervent detractors.
May 21, 2021
The genre for this month in my 2021 reading challenge was History and Biography. I struggled in choosing a book to satisfy the challenge but then stumbled upon this one. The Beatles coming to America isn’t exactly the first thing that comes to mind when you think of a history book but technically it fits the bill. There’s been plenty written on The Beatles, their careers, and their lasting impact but I’ve never seen a book as specific as this one, studying the effect they had on a particular city - in this case, Chicago. It was interesting to see how they were received in this city vs the large cities on the East or West coast. A lot of it - like the Beatlemania craze - could be generalized but the lukewarm reception they received from city officials was unique to Chicago.
Looking through the lens of living in 2020 and knowing how outrageous and edgy a lot of musicians are today, it’s funny to think that people frowned upon The Beatles because they had shaggy hair and wore tight-fitting suits. Times sure have changed and yet, at the same time, a lot of the social issues that were covered in the book are still prevalent in today’s society.
It was interesting to revisit the path of The Beatles’ career. When you really look at it, they weren’t together for very long at all, they only toured for a few years and broke up a few years after that. Yet, the impact they had, and continue to have, on music ever since is like nothing this world’s ever seen before (or will likely ever see again). By the time I came to be a Beatles fan as a kid they were already firmly cemented as music legends but while reading this, I wonder what I would have thought had I been a teenager in the 60s when they first came to America. I bet I would have been swept up in Beatlemania but would I have stuck with them through their later years? It’s hard to say but all in all, this was an interesting read and gave me a lot to think about!
Looking through the lens of living in 2020 and knowing how outrageous and edgy a lot of musicians are today, it’s funny to think that people frowned upon The Beatles because they had shaggy hair and wore tight-fitting suits. Times sure have changed and yet, at the same time, a lot of the social issues that were covered in the book are still prevalent in today’s society.
It was interesting to revisit the path of The Beatles’ career. When you really look at it, they weren’t together for very long at all, they only toured for a few years and broke up a few years after that. Yet, the impact they had, and continue to have, on music ever since is like nothing this world’s ever seen before (or will likely ever see again). By the time I came to be a Beatles fan as a kid they were already firmly cemented as music legends but while reading this, I wonder what I would have thought had I been a teenager in the 60s when they first came to America. I bet I would have been swept up in Beatlemania but would I have stuck with them through their later years? It’s hard to say but all in all, this was an interesting read and gave me a lot to think about!
May 21, 2021
I first saw the Beatles on my black and white TV in London in the 1960s when I was a small child. Their music and energy brought excitement and escapism into my life. I became a fan. They played at my local cinema in 1963 and I can still remember the buzz and excitement, that was around the area at the time although I was too young to go to the concerts. For the length of time they were together, they crammed in so many appearances and released so many records.
This book looks at the impact the Beatles had on Chicago through their visits and performances and is a great read for those of us who are interested in the culture and history of the times.
This book looks at the impact the Beatles had on Chicago through their visits and performances and is a great read for those of us who are interested in the culture and history of the times.
January 18, 2023
An interesting observational standpoint for this book, where Chicago takes the centre stage, and how the Beatles continually bumped up against the city.
Lyons does a good job of painting the main players who interacted, or fawned over, or disliked, or outright ignored the Beatles and their influences.
While I got some great insight into their impact on Chicago and its citizens, my only real complaint is, no doubt stemming from the fact that the author is a Professor of History, that it often comes across a touch dry and academic.
But it's worth the read, for sure.
Lyons does a good job of painting the main players who interacted, or fawned over, or disliked, or outright ignored the Beatles and their influences.
While I got some great insight into their impact on Chicago and its citizens, my only real complaint is, no doubt stemming from the fact that the author is a Professor of History, that it often comes across a touch dry and academic.
But it's worth the read, for sure.
April 8, 2021
An absolutely fantastic read about the Beatles impact in America, through a Chicago lens. Full of quotes and anecdotes that you won't find in any of the other Beatles books out there (and there are so many!) As a Canadian, this was very eye-opening about the public perception of the group and the individuals towards the end of the 60's. Would recommend this book to anybody who wants to read about lesser explored areas of the history of the fabulous foursome.
March 10, 2024
Meticulously researched -- almost to a fault. Great details about the rise and fall of the Beatles in Chicago and the political and religious forces that were involved.
Great look at the music scene in Chicago and the bands that did and did not succeed.
You won't marvel at the writing in the book because it tends to be overwritten in places and kind of dry in others. If you read for a retrospective look at an interesting time in Chicago pop culture, you'll enjoy it.
Great look at the music scene in Chicago and the bands that did and did not succeed.
You won't marvel at the writing in the book because it tends to be overwritten in places and kind of dry in others. If you read for a retrospective look at an interesting time in Chicago pop culture, you'll enjoy it.
July 18, 2024
This book is a refreshingly honest portrait of the Beatles and their impact on the U.S, specifically the midwest, in the mid-60s. It also serves as an account of their insane touring schedule and life on the road. The author avoids the nauseating "Beatles invented music"esque cliches of most critics/authors and instead pulls from unexpected/forgotten interviews and firsthand accounts.
April 25, 2021
I loved this book! If you're interested in the Beatles or Chicago it's perfect for you. I learned so much!
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews