Oh BOY. This book was interesting.
I'll be honest with you and say that I picked this book up for three main reasons: .
1. I love me a good fairy tale retelling.
2. I love the gays.
3. I was hoping that maybe some borderline inappropriate things would happen based on the title.
Now, there were fairy tales and there gays, but as for inappropriate goings on, well...the most we got was some references to nocturnal activities and then, uh, some throupling happened in the last story. Yeah. Yeah it did.
Overall, I really enjoyed this collection. Some of the stories were retellings, while others were original stories based on some traditional fairy tale tropes. I liked the characters in most of the stories and was invested in the majority of them.
My main complaint is that the stories all felt too short. They ended quite suddenly without a lot of resolution and often after the characters kissed for the first time. I would have loved to see some of the stories receive novel treatment because it often felt like they were just getting started when they would suddenly resolve and end. There was also some inconsistency in the writing, including some dates that were confusing and didn't match up, so some revision and editing is definitely needed.
Some personal favorites from the collection are:
"Brightleaf": This tells the story of a village healer who helps a goblin save his human brother. The characters felt well developed in this particular story, and I appreciated the backstories given. It also has a sequel later on in the collected called "The Troll," and while I liked that one, I thought "Brightleaf" was better.
"Wolf-Given"/"Seventh Son": This was an interesting story about a wolf and a man who was, at one point in his life, promised to marry another wolf. Sounds weird, but it works. These two stories could easily have been an entire novel. I enjoyed the world building and the characters and wanted to spend more time with them and understand them better.
"Rumors": This story is about a listless prince who meets the jester at the court that he is visiting. There was an interesting mystery involved, and I liked the delicate simplicity of the story. It was short, but enjoyable.
"The Toad Prince": This was another story that could have been so much more. It is about the bastard son of the regent who is beaten by his younger brothers and is in love with a man from a painting, the deceased cousin of his one and only friend. I really liked the twist in this story and wanted more.
I honestly really liked most of the stories. Some felt far too short, but then the characters would show up in another story and I liked the cyclical nature of that. I wish they could have been more involved, more complicated, and didn't feel so repetitive, but I really did enjoy reading this collection and would definitely recommend it!