Camille Di Maio is one of my favorite historical fiction authors, so I was so excited to read her new novel in advance!
To be completely honest, I didn’t love it as much as The Beautiful Strangers, because I didn’t feel as deeply connected with the characters as I was with that one and I wasn’t as much engaged in the love story, but nonetheless The First Emma was a wonderful book.
It isn’t even a real criticism, it’s just that I loved The Beautiful Strangers a little bit more, and if there is anyone here who hasn’t read it yet, I strongly recommend to do it as soon as possible!
The First Emma started off really great: Otto Koehler, a rich businessman famous for his brewing company and numerous investments, with a disabled wife and two mistresses, all of them named Emma, killed by one of his mistresses.
What’s not to like about an incipit like that?
Then the story switch to many years later, in 1942’s Baltimore, where young Mabel is alone and hopeless, at first working as a secretary but soon in need of a new job, eager for a change of luck and with not much left to lose.
When she reads the advertisement of an old woman looking for an aspiring writer to record her story, Mabel believes she may have found her chance.
So she leaves for San Antonio, where this old woman lives, and soon meets the memorable Emma Koehler.
Immensely rich, proud and determined, Emma is surrounded by nieces and nephews whom she welcomes generously in her house, while knowing that not all of them are moved by sincere affection for her, but more by the hope of receiving a bigger part of her inheritance.
She is confined to a wheelchair after a car accident and the two nurses employed to help her, petite blonde Emma Dumpke and fierce redhead Emma Burgemeister, both became her husband’s mistresses.
She is pushing eighties, but still strong-minded and ready to tell her story, how she moved from Germany to San Antonio with her husband Otto, who only lived for making money and was extraordinarily good at it, and slowly learned to make his world her own, becoming an essential part of his business.
Otto was unstoppable, always moving to the next achievement, while Emma was focused on maintaining their brewing company, Pearl, and making it grow.
I strongly disliked Otto and actually hated him with a passion from a certain point on.
He didn’t seem capable to love, at least not people, and he only truly cared for his damned investments.
I was furious with him, for how he mistreated Emma’s feelings, ignoring and hurting her with his coldness before the mistresses came into the scene and openly cheating on her after the accident, claiming that “a man has his needs”, yeah sure. He almost never gave a damn about Emma’s needs, so I nearly threw my Kindle when I read that. I would have very gladly killed him myself, if dear Emma Burgemeister didn’t see to it.
I adored and devoured the first half of this book on a plane, already anxious and sad about it having to end at some point too soon.
At first I was more engaged in Mabel’s story than in Emma’s tale, but in the second half of the novel I couldn’t wait to return to the past, eager to discover more details about the two other Emmas and Otto’s murder.
I was slightly disappointed at the end, because there wasn’t as much about the mistresses and the murder as I expected: the story revolved much more around the first Emma, as the title suggest, and her transformation from loving wife to wise and acute businesswoman both with and without Otto Koehler, especially during the Great Depression.
After reading the author’s note, I understood: there isn’t much information about Emma Koehler, despite Camille Di Maio’s admirable research, and she didn’t want to fictionalize her too much, a decision which I totally respect.
The romance was lovely and Mabel and Erik were both great characters, well-constructed, believable and each with a history and an identity of their own.
Even though I wasn’t as invested in them as I was with Kate and Sean in The Beautiful Strangers, I still liked them a great deal.
With this book, which will be out in May 2020 (and I can’t express how honored I was to read it so early!), Camille Di Maio confirms herself as a great writer of historical fiction, one who has definitely earned a special place among my favorite authors.
I highly recommend The First Emma to any lover of historical fiction and to everyone looking for a good, inspiring novel about a strong and clever woman with very much to teach about female dignity, potential, love and commitment.
A sincerely heartfelt thank you to NetGalley, Camille Di Maio and Wyatt-MacKenzie for the opportunity to read this wonderful book in advance!
I am already waiting for Camille’s next novel, sure that it won’t disappoint!