What do you think?
Rate this book
True Colors #6
The Green Dress
Fiction Based on Strange, But True, History
True, riveting stories of American criminal activity are explored through a unique stories of historical romantic suspense. Collect them all and be inspired by the hope that always finds its way even in the darkest of times.
In Boston, 1886, Harriet Peters commissions Sarah Jane Robinson to make her a new dress. Both widows are struggling to make ends meet, and they strike up a quick friendship. Harriet feels sorry for Sarah Jane, who has suffered so much loss in her life. But Harriet’s friend, Dr. Michael Wheaton, has concerns that death seems to follow Sarah Jane in mysterious ways Still, Harriet can’t imagine any deceit in her friend, who she comforts through the deaths of her daughter and nephew. Will Harriet’s trusting nature lead to her own demise as a persistent stomachache starts to plague her?
True, riveting stories of American criminal activity are explored through a unique stories of historical romantic suspense. Collect them all and be inspired by the hope that always finds its way even in the darkest of times.
In Boston, 1886, Harriet Peters commissions Sarah Jane Robinson to make her a new dress. Both widows are struggling to make ends meet, and they strike up a quick friendship. Harriet feels sorry for Sarah Jane, who has suffered so much loss in her life. But Harriet’s friend, Dr. Michael Wheaton, has concerns that death seems to follow Sarah Jane in mysterious ways Still, Harriet can’t imagine any deceit in her friend, who she comforts through the deaths of her daughter and nephew. Will Harriet’s trusting nature lead to her own demise as a persistent stomachache starts to plague her?
239 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 1, 2020
25 people are currently reading
1522 people want to read
About the author
Liz Tolsma
42 books1,779 followersLiz Tolsma is the author of several WWII novels, romantic suspense novels, prairie romance novellas, and an Amish romance. She is a popular speaker and an editor and resides next to a Wisconsin farm field with her husband and their youngest daughter. Her son is a U.S. Marine, and her oldest daughter is a recent college graduate. Liz enjoys reading, walking, working in her large perennial garden, kayaking, and camping. Please visit her website at www.liztolsma.com and follow her on Facebook, Twitter (@LizTolsma), Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest. She is also the host of the Christian Historical Fiction Talk podcast.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 248 reviews
June 15, 2020
I read this book in an hour and a half! It was honestly that suspenseful!
It's pretty clear that there's a poisoner in the story, and the body count here is staggering! I hoped the first one would be saved, hoped another would be saved...you get the idea. And there's not a single thing to tip off the police because it looks more like a family curse than a targeted poisoner. I couldn't stop flipping the pages as my suspect list dropped from three, to two...to one crazed individual who's lost all control and nearly all fear of getting caught. Who's going to survive that final rampage?
The heartbreaking thing was knowing that this crime actually happened, that these folks really did die from the poisoner's tricks. Tolsma did an excellent job building the suspense and really tapped into the emotion of the story. Well done!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
It's pretty clear that there's a poisoner in the story, and the body count here is staggering! I hoped the first one would be saved, hoped another would be saved...you get the idea. And there's not a single thing to tip off the police because it looks more like a family curse than a targeted poisoner. I couldn't stop flipping the pages as my suspect list dropped from three, to two...to one crazed individual who's lost all control and nearly all fear of getting caught. Who's going to survive that final rampage?
The heartbreaking thing was knowing that this crime actually happened, that these folks really did die from the poisoner's tricks. Tolsma did an excellent job building the suspense and really tapped into the emotion of the story. Well done!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
August 21, 2020
Thoughts soon. Excellent book.
Edit: update
I loved this story. True crime. The writing was wonderful and remained hopeful even in the dire circumstances. The book was clean with Christian leanings and I won it in a Goodreads giveaway.
I put in for it after one of my GR friends, Hannah, recommended it to me. She really knows what I will read, so when I saw the giveaway I leapt at it! I am so glad I read it!
This book is also haunting and creepy. It reveals the lack of humanity that can be under our very noses.
I put the others of this series called True Colors on my TBR too.
Edit: update
I loved this story. True crime. The writing was wonderful and remained hopeful even in the dire circumstances. The book was clean with Christian leanings and I won it in a Goodreads giveaway.
I put in for it after one of my GR friends, Hannah, recommended it to me. She really knows what I will read, so when I saw the giveaway I leapt at it! I am so glad I read it!
This book is also haunting and creepy. It reveals the lack of humanity that can be under our very noses.
I put the others of this series called True Colors on my TBR too.
August 24, 2020
What immediately stood out to me was the delightfully creepy, gothic vibe. There was this cloak of despondency, mystery, and tension hovering over the entire story, though there was a thread of hope throughout, which created this spine-tingling vibe that enhanced the gothic tone. I loved the mysterious phantom illness that plagued the entire family. This kept me invested throughout. The leading lady’s heart for children and the downtrodden was exquisite and beautiful. We need more folks with such rich depth in this world.
May 19, 2020
I have been reading through the True Colors series and truly each one is better than the last.
I really love trying to figure out " who done it and why".
I figured out who did it fairly quickly in on this one but the why had me stumped and I ended up staying up late reading til the end because I just could not sleep without knowing the "why".
Each story is based on a true crime case from historical past and it's fascinating to read about each case. The author also fills us in on the true facts of the case in the back of the book and I appreciate that.
I recommend this whole series.
Expected publication: June 1st 2020 by Barbour Books
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
I really love trying to figure out " who done it and why".
I figured out who did it fairly quickly in on this one but the why had me stumped and I ended up staying up late reading til the end because I just could not sleep without knowing the "why".
Each story is based on a true crime case from historical past and it's fascinating to read about each case. The author also fills us in on the true facts of the case in the back of the book and I appreciate that.
I recommend this whole series.
Expected publication: June 1st 2020 by Barbour Books
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
July 3, 2020
Disturbingly intriguing. That description best fits this book—or, rather, the Robinson family. I am always interested to know how much is history and how much is fiction. In this case, quite a bit of the story was based on fact. The deaths that happened in these pages really did happen, and that’s the disturbing part.
It is a dark story. Especially when you realize the magnitude of deaths (of all ages) were really murders. There isn’t really gore mentioned—descriptions of the pain each victim had before death was described, but it definitely wasn’t gory.
Some would find the killer disturbing beyond reason—which is true. In that sense, Liz Tolsma did a great job capturing the craze of a narcissist. What is sickening is how “the will of God” was blamed. But it was clearly portrayed as coming from a warped mind (by the time the whole story wrapped up).
With so much death, the emphasis on heave and being ready to die was brought out vividly. I appreciated the message that one is not “good enough” to go to heaven, but rather that one has to accept the price Jesus paid. It did at times seem to portray that everyone went to heaven, but I think that was more or less just the characters coping. I was specifically looking to see if the question of “earning heaven” was answered in a Biblical fashion, and I do think it was.
The romance was obvious, with hugs, desire to kiss, and noticing each others’ looks, but it didn’t feel overdone or overemotional until about 60% in. Then, a switch seemed to flip and they both leaned on each other more. Honestly, my main thought has nothing to do with impropriety, as it didn’t seem to go too deep, but more that the chemistry felt a little forced to me.
This could be handed to a teen solely based on how that particular teen can handle disturbing plots. As far as romance goes, I didn’t really find the romance too heavy personally. It was definitely way less of a focus than the mystery.
As far as storyline goes, I found it fascinating and one I’d like to reread sometime. I read it mainly on nights when I was both tired and editing my own writing, so overall I felt like the dialogue and chemistry was stiff and at times the characters felt a little stupid because it was super clear that the family was being poisoned and even who was doing it; but that could have totally been my brain working overtime.
*I received this book from the publisher and happily provided my honest review*
It is a dark story. Especially when you realize the magnitude of deaths (of all ages) were really murders. There isn’t really gore mentioned—descriptions of the pain each victim had before death was described, but it definitely wasn’t gory.
Some would find the killer disturbing beyond reason—which is true. In that sense, Liz Tolsma did a great job capturing the craze of a narcissist. What is sickening is how “the will of God” was blamed. But it was clearly portrayed as coming from a warped mind (by the time the whole story wrapped up).
With so much death, the emphasis on heave and being ready to die was brought out vividly. I appreciated the message that one is not “good enough” to go to heaven, but rather that one has to accept the price Jesus paid. It did at times seem to portray that everyone went to heaven, but I think that was more or less just the characters coping. I was specifically looking to see if the question of “earning heaven” was answered in a Biblical fashion, and I do think it was.
The romance was obvious, with hugs, desire to kiss, and noticing each others’ looks, but it didn’t feel overdone or overemotional until about 60% in. Then, a switch seemed to flip and they both leaned on each other more. Honestly, my main thought has nothing to do with impropriety, as it didn’t seem to go too deep, but more that the chemistry felt a little forced to me.
This could be handed to a teen solely based on how that particular teen can handle disturbing plots. As far as romance goes, I didn’t really find the romance too heavy personally. It was definitely way less of a focus than the mystery.
As far as storyline goes, I found it fascinating and one I’d like to reread sometime. I read it mainly on nights when I was both tired and editing my own writing, so overall I felt like the dialogue and chemistry was stiff and at times the characters felt a little stupid because it was super clear that the family was being poisoned and even who was doing it; but that could have totally been my brain working overtime.
*I received this book from the publisher and happily provided my honest review*
May 28, 2020
This is a wonderful addition to a series I have truly enjoyed.
Liz Tolsma has penned a suspenseful story of a serial killer in 1880's Boston. The book started a little slow for me, but the last half of the story had me glued to the page. Tolsma's skill of storytelling, combined with her flawless research is a recipe of success for mixing fact and fiction. While the story itself was suspenseful and at times dark, the faith thread was one of hope, lending the fictional heroine strength.
This story along with many of the crimes highlighted in Barbours True Colors: Historical stories of American Crime series were previously unknown to me. I love learning more of America's history, including some of its darker stories as well.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are mine.
Liz Tolsma has penned a suspenseful story of a serial killer in 1880's Boston. The book started a little slow for me, but the last half of the story had me glued to the page. Tolsma's skill of storytelling, combined with her flawless research is a recipe of success for mixing fact and fiction. While the story itself was suspenseful and at times dark, the faith thread was one of hope, lending the fictional heroine strength.
This story along with many of the crimes highlighted in Barbours True Colors: Historical stories of American Crime series were previously unknown to me. I love learning more of America's history, including some of its darker stories as well.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are mine.
May 15, 2020
The Green Dress by new to me author Liz Tolsma was a very well written and wonderful story. The story is seen through the eyes of Michael and Harriet Robinson and centers on a true crime tale. Although I am not a big fan of the sleuth genre, I have lately taken to reading mysteries that have very nice twists and turns and this story had plenty of them. I had a hard time figuring out who did the crime and when I thought I knew...the story took me somewhere else. My enjoyment of good historical fiction is what let me to want to read this story. Will I continue with the series, I am not sure at this point. Again, very nice story that will hold your attention.
Thank you Netgalley and Barbour Publishing, Inc. for this ARC in exchange for my fair and honest review. Opinions and thoughts expressed in this review are completely my own.
4-Stars
Thank you Netgalley and Barbour Publishing, Inc. for this ARC in exchange for my fair and honest review. Opinions and thoughts expressed in this review are completely my own.
4-Stars
May 22, 2020
This fiction based upon true crimes series has brought to light little known tragedies from the past. In The Green Dress, readers are taken to 1886 Boston and the home of the Robinson family. Mysteriously, multiple family members are dying months apart of unknown causes.
Family friend Harriet, a young woman that ran away from her own family, provides the point of view for the story. It was fascinating. Horrible, but fascinating.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
Family friend Harriet, a young woman that ran away from her own family, provides the point of view for the story. It was fascinating. Horrible, but fascinating.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
June 1, 2020
The first 30-40% was a bit slow, especially after it was clear after the first death who killer was and why they did it (though towards 70% I was wondering if someone else was also involved). But the last 60% was quite fast paced and suspenseful. There was a lot of heartache as well within these pages.
I loved Micheal as the hero. He had his own fears and worries to overcome but was a strong fighter for those who can't. Harriet was a compassionate, lovable character but I found her a bit naive quite a few times.
The last comment from the murder to Harriet was quite chilling and shown how truly evil this person was.
*I’ve received a complimentary copy from the publisher through Netgalley. All opinions expressed are my own.*
I loved Micheal as the hero. He had his own fears and worries to overcome but was a strong fighter for those who can't. Harriet was a compassionate, lovable character but I found her a bit naive quite a few times.
The last comment from the murder to Harriet was quite chilling and shown how truly evil this person was.
*I’ve received a complimentary copy from the publisher through Netgalley. All opinions expressed are my own.*
May 21, 2020
I like historical fiction because I always learn something. In The Green Dress, Liz Tolsma takes a disturbing real event and brings it to life. Robison family members are falling ill and dying. Ms. Tolsma adds two characters, Harriet Peters and Dr. Michael Wheaton to the story in order to recount the incident. Harriet is portrayed as Lizzy Robinson’s best friend and Michael is a local Doctor who helps Harriet make sense of the doom that surrounds the family. How could so many from one household suffer such horrible deaths.
It is hard to believe that this story is real. But the author has done a good job of fleshing out the story with engaging characters in Harriet, Michael and Gracie. Even though she gives us a glimpse into a depraved mind, the author also shows a faith thread that gives hope. Harriet and Michael are praying people who act out their Christian values and seek to save lives in a dangerous situation.
This is a great addition to the True Colors American Crime series from Barbour.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
It is hard to believe that this story is real. But the author has done a good job of fleshing out the story with engaging characters in Harriet, Michael and Gracie. Even though she gives us a glimpse into a depraved mind, the author also shows a faith thread that gives hope. Harriet and Michael are praying people who act out their Christian values and seek to save lives in a dangerous situation.
This is a great addition to the True Colors American Crime series from Barbour.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
March 18, 2025
Read for St. Pattys day because it has green in the title and the main character is Irish. Well written, but incredibly sad and morbid. Parts were very frustrating, and I wanted to yell at the characters. Features child death and an asylum. I didn't know that going in. Otherwise, I would have skipped it.
July 7, 2020
3 Top Reasons I Absolutely Loved The Green Dress
Whew. This won't be easy. But I'm going to do it. So here goes.
1. Nail-biting suspense.
Seriously, she nailed the pacing of The Green Dress. I really think Liz's best work comes in suspense, and you see it in certain parts of her WWII books and in these true crime novels. This one, in particular, is her best work yet. I was so impressed and so eager to turn that page, that I read it... FAST. And then some sections I reread again right away. One of the biggest strengths of the suspense in this book is that you know what's coming. You know every bit of it. This is suspense, not mystery. You know who did what and how (although she doesn't come right out and say it) and that gut-knowing is what keeps you riveted and screaming, "No! Don't! NO!!!"
2. Multi-layered plot
Don't mistake the simplicity of this story for it being simplisTIC. It is not. Instead, Liz layered the story at perfect intervals so that instead of knowing all and just seeing it unfold, you know what you know... and then learn some more, that reinforces what you knew and tells you what you'll discover next. As simple as it is (bad guy hurts people for selfish gain), it is also deeply complex.
3. Romance that didn't make me squirm.
Okay, so Liz is much more effusive in her romance than I will ever be. It seriously takes everything out of me to do romance, while she has characters who dance across the page with declarations of love worthy of Rogers and Hammerstein. And her readers love it. So, seeing the quiet reserve she gives the romance in this book (remember, compared to her others!) made the story richer for me. This fit the characters. What might have felt "over the top" in other books just feels reasonable and normal in this book. She kept it for situations it felt realistic and understandable.
Bonus reason that I loved The Green Dress? Because she nailed one theological issue that usually I want to throw the book when I see. YAY LIZ!
Barbour gave me an advance reading copy. I chose to review it and am so very glad I did.
Whew. This won't be easy. But I'm going to do it. So here goes.
1. Nail-biting suspense.
Seriously, she nailed the pacing of The Green Dress. I really think Liz's best work comes in suspense, and you see it in certain parts of her WWII books and in these true crime novels. This one, in particular, is her best work yet. I was so impressed and so eager to turn that page, that I read it... FAST. And then some sections I reread again right away. One of the biggest strengths of the suspense in this book is that you know what's coming. You know every bit of it. This is suspense, not mystery. You know who did what and how (although she doesn't come right out and say it) and that gut-knowing is what keeps you riveted and screaming, "No! Don't! NO!!!"
2. Multi-layered plot
Don't mistake the simplicity of this story for it being simplisTIC. It is not. Instead, Liz layered the story at perfect intervals so that instead of knowing all and just seeing it unfold, you know what you know... and then learn some more, that reinforces what you knew and tells you what you'll discover next. As simple as it is (bad guy hurts people for selfish gain), it is also deeply complex.
3. Romance that didn't make me squirm.
Okay, so Liz is much more effusive in her romance than I will ever be. It seriously takes everything out of me to do romance, while she has characters who dance across the page with declarations of love worthy of Rogers and Hammerstein. And her readers love it. So, seeing the quiet reserve she gives the romance in this book (remember, compared to her others!) made the story richer for me. This fit the characters. What might have felt "over the top" in other books just feels reasonable and normal in this book. She kept it for situations it felt realistic and understandable.
Bonus reason that I loved The Green Dress? Because she nailed one theological issue that usually I want to throw the book when I see. YAY LIZ!
Barbour gave me an advance reading copy. I chose to review it and am so very glad I did.
May 19, 2020
The Green Dress by Liz Tolsma is engrossing historical story. At times it was very heartbreaking and had my stomach in knots not sure what would happen since I knew it would was based on a true story. This true color series has been very interesting. Each book is based on a true story in history that is adapted into a fiction story. In this story Harriet is taken in by a family in the Boston area.
Eventually she and the local doctor notice that several members of their family are dying a painful death. Michael is a doctor in the area that suspects something is just not right. It just doesn’t line up.
I would highly recommend the book. It’s a great mystery because you’re not sure why they’re dying and if it’s at the hands of someone, and if so who. And the fact that it’s based on a true story makes it even more interesting. The author also includes additional information and in the back of the book so you know the true story and where she took liberties.
Sexual content – kissing
Violence – several painful deaths. Not sure if you call this violence, symptoms of a poisoning
I received this book from Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review.
You can see my full review at More Than a Review dot com where I rate the level of sex, violence, language and drug/alcohol use in books.
Eventually she and the local doctor notice that several members of their family are dying a painful death. Michael is a doctor in the area that suspects something is just not right. It just doesn’t line up.
I would highly recommend the book. It’s a great mystery because you’re not sure why they’re dying and if it’s at the hands of someone, and if so who. And the fact that it’s based on a true story makes it even more interesting. The author also includes additional information and in the back of the book so you know the true story and where she took liberties.
Sexual content – kissing
Violence – several painful deaths. Not sure if you call this violence, symptoms of a poisoning
I received this book from Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review.
You can see my full review at More Than a Review dot com where I rate the level of sex, violence, language and drug/alcohol use in books.
May 21, 2020
Me being a former medical student I guessed what was going on not even halfway through the book. But you know what? I'm still floored!y goodness!
This book is certainly an eye popper for sure that will keep you rooted in your spot to see what happens next!
I love this author very much! Her stories are fascinating!
I did learn a lot about Sarah Jane. In fact, I never knew she exsisted. She kind of creeped me out actually.
This story made me want to cry at times some of it was very sad.
I didn't like Dr. Beers at all! He gave me the creeps too!
I really really like these True Colors series. They're an interesting part of our history and I love how each author adds her own charm.
I will admit there were times when I felt the hairs stand up on the back of my neck that's for sure!
I give this book 5 stars because of the outstanding writing style Liz Tsolma has. Her stories are awesome!
This book is certainly an eye popper for sure that will keep you rooted in your spot to see what happens next!
I love this author very much! Her stories are fascinating!
I did learn a lot about Sarah Jane. In fact, I never knew she exsisted. She kind of creeped me out actually.
This story made me want to cry at times some of it was very sad.
I didn't like Dr. Beers at all! He gave me the creeps too!
I really really like these True Colors series. They're an interesting part of our history and I love how each author adds her own charm.
I will admit there were times when I felt the hairs stand up on the back of my neck that's for sure!
I give this book 5 stars because of the outstanding writing style Liz Tsolma has. Her stories are awesome!
May 17, 2020
Wow! What an interesting story! From the very beginning, I was drawn in to the mystery and suspense. What could be happening to these people? Why were there so many unexplained deaths? I wondered about the green dress and the importance of the garment. When I learned the reason for the green dress, I was totally surprised. A great read. I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
September 25, 2022
3.5stars
The Green Dress is book 6 in the True Colours Series, it is a series that takes real (and sometimes unheard of) historical events and turns them into a historical fiction story. They aren't long books, which given the theme of some is fine. Right now there are approximately 12 books in the series and so far I have only read The Pink Bonnet, which after finishing that heartbreaking story made me pause in this series. Each book is a standalone so they can be read in any order and they are also written by a variety of Christian authors.
The Green Dress is the story of Harriet Peters, taking place in 1882 Boston. Her best friend has died suddenly and what follows is a story of her family and a mysterious illness that appears to be following them.
Given that this is based on fact makes the story all the more sad and horrendous. What follows was an entertaining read as I watched Harriet not just on a journey to figure out what was going on but also one that showed her commitment, strength and determination. Though I kinda figured out what was going on, it was the why and other bits that surprised me. Harriet's faith journey also followed her through this process with a touch of romance.
The Green Dress released in June 2020 and is part of my Reading Off My Kindle Challenge
The Green Dress is book 6 in the True Colours Series, it is a series that takes real (and sometimes unheard of) historical events and turns them into a historical fiction story. They aren't long books, which given the theme of some is fine. Right now there are approximately 12 books in the series and so far I have only read The Pink Bonnet, which after finishing that heartbreaking story made me pause in this series. Each book is a standalone so they can be read in any order and they are also written by a variety of Christian authors.
The Green Dress is the story of Harriet Peters, taking place in 1882 Boston. Her best friend has died suddenly and what follows is a story of her family and a mysterious illness that appears to be following them.
Given that this is based on fact makes the story all the more sad and horrendous. What follows was an entertaining read as I watched Harriet not just on a journey to figure out what was going on but also one that showed her commitment, strength and determination. Though I kinda figured out what was going on, it was the why and other bits that surprised me. Harriet's faith journey also followed her through this process with a touch of romance.
The Green Dress released in June 2020 and is part of my Reading Off My Kindle Challenge
June 18, 2020
Another book from the True Colors that bases fiction on strange, but true, history. Harriet Peters left her home because of an arranged marriage to a much older gentleman and fled to Boston where she is taken in by the Robinson family when she is found wandering the streets and is treated like one of the family. But then family members begin, one at a time, to develop a strange debilitating stomach ailment that leads to their death.
Tolsma's development of the characters was well done, and I especially loved Harriet and her strong loyalty to the children. Michael Wheaton, a new doctor to the area haunted by a past, made a great partner for Harriet in both the sleuthing and romance. This is one of the shorter of the True Colors book, and I easily read it in a few hours. The pace of this book seemed to move more slowly than others in this series, and I basically had the culprit down to 2 people before I had read very far into the book as well as the probable cause.
A good addition to this series, and an easy enjoyable read.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
Tolsma's development of the characters was well done, and I especially loved Harriet and her strong loyalty to the children. Michael Wheaton, a new doctor to the area haunted by a past, made a great partner for Harriet in both the sleuthing and romance. This is one of the shorter of the True Colors book, and I easily read it in a few hours. The pace of this book seemed to move more slowly than others in this series, and I basically had the culprit down to 2 people before I had read very far into the book as well as the probable cause.
A good addition to this series, and an easy enjoyable read.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
July 6, 2020
I have read several of Liz Tolsma’s WWII books in the past and have enjoyed her ability to weave a beautiful story around tragic events. While this book is a departure from that particular era, I found this true crime novel to be not as far a leap as I thought; this story also deals with people’s cruelty and strange events that seem impossible yet remain based in truth.
Harriet is a likeable character for whom the reader is able to feel immediate sympathy. She has lost so much, and now stands to lose her best friend to a mysterious and painful illness. This brings her to Michael’s door, seeking help for Lizzie from the doctor just down the block from her own millinery shop. But the illness proves to be a different kind of danger than either is expecting.
The suspense ratchets up quickly, and having my own suspicions from the beginning, I couldn’t help but worry for Harriet and Michael both. Clues are hidden in plain sight, becoming clear as the tale continues, with a few instances of suspicion proving misplaced from early assumptions on my part. The author does a good job of giving enough information to keep the reader engaged, but without giving everything away from the outset.
I recommend this book for those who are interested in true crime stories but who don’t want foul language or gory details to be part of the content. This book does a good job of navigating a balance between reality and remaining clean, while still delivering a chilling story of suspense and man’s often inhumane treatment of others.
I received a copy of this book through Celebrate LIt but was under no obligation to post positive remarks. The opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
Harriet is a likeable character for whom the reader is able to feel immediate sympathy. She has lost so much, and now stands to lose her best friend to a mysterious and painful illness. This brings her to Michael’s door, seeking help for Lizzie from the doctor just down the block from her own millinery shop. But the illness proves to be a different kind of danger than either is expecting.
The suspense ratchets up quickly, and having my own suspicions from the beginning, I couldn’t help but worry for Harriet and Michael both. Clues are hidden in plain sight, becoming clear as the tale continues, with a few instances of suspicion proving misplaced from early assumptions on my part. The author does a good job of giving enough information to keep the reader engaged, but without giving everything away from the outset.
I recommend this book for those who are interested in true crime stories but who don’t want foul language or gory details to be part of the content. This book does a good job of navigating a balance between reality and remaining clean, while still delivering a chilling story of suspense and man’s often inhumane treatment of others.
I received a copy of this book through Celebrate LIt but was under no obligation to post positive remarks. The opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
June 2, 2020
I’m enjoying this series of books that are about true crimes in history. This story is one I had never heard before. The beginning I felt was a little slower but I really enjoyed the last half of the book and couldn’t put it down! I received this book from Net Galley in exchange for a honest review.
October 5, 2024
This was a bargain basement find that not only was large print but filled the "green" requirement for my Rainbow reading challenge. I had never heard of this author, but going forward, I will be seeking out other works by her. This is a true crime story from the late 1800's that she then creates a story using as many facts as possible that she has found recorded of the case.
This story dealt with a serial killer within a family. I don't want to give too much info on the story and ruin it for any potential readers.
This was a super quick and enjoyable read. I will definitely be reading more of the author soon.
This story dealt with a serial killer within a family. I don't want to give too much info on the story and ruin it for any potential readers.
This was a super quick and enjoyable read. I will definitely be reading more of the author soon.
March 12, 2020
A suspenseful mystery based on a real crime! Set in the late 1880's, in the town of Somerville, near Boston, Massachusetts, a sinister plot emerges around suspicious deaths, drawing the attention of a local doctor.
"None of us know what life is going to bring from day to day. We just live and walk in God’s grace through it all."
The tension builds as the danger grows, and the good doctor struggles to pinpoint the cause of the deadly illness. I could hardly wait for him to figure it out, as the situation worsened. Harriet seemed loyal to a fault, but sacrificial to keep her promise to look after her dying friend's young family members. I wanted her to take the kids and run! Dr. Wheaton made a good, strong hero with his own personal struggles to overcome. I was pulling for him from the start. There were some tender inspirational moments as they discussed their faith and heaven.
Historical mystery fans may enjoy this tale, with a bit of faith and romance.
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
"None of us know what life is going to bring from day to day. We just live and walk in God’s grace through it all."
The tension builds as the danger grows, and the good doctor struggles to pinpoint the cause of the deadly illness. I could hardly wait for him to figure it out, as the situation worsened. Harriet seemed loyal to a fault, but sacrificial to keep her promise to look after her dying friend's young family members. I wanted her to take the kids and run! Dr. Wheaton made a good, strong hero with his own personal struggles to overcome. I was pulling for him from the start. There were some tender inspirational moments as they discussed their faith and heaven.
Historical mystery fans may enjoy this tale, with a bit of faith and romance.
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
May 26, 2020
The Green Dress is about a woman who is staying with the Robinson family. There seem to be strange illnesses or deaths occur. It seems to be about a woman named Sarah Jane Robinson. What is going on in the house is strange.
Harriet seems to bring in a Dr. Weaton. She moved into the Robinson family household but things seem to happen more once Lizzie passes away. But we do not know who it is. As the story goes on and more death occurs. The suspicions rise. Who is killing the Robinson family members and why?
The author does a wonderful job of having you trying to figure out the culprit. You get a history of some of the members. What a way to show some true colors in some folks. This story has you wanting to turn the pages and rooting for the heroes to save the day. You are pulled in emotionally as well. I was guessing Dr. Beers or even Mrs. Robinson. Can Michael and Harriet save the Robinson family members or will it all go bad?
Harriet seems to bring in a Dr. Weaton. She moved into the Robinson family household but things seem to happen more once Lizzie passes away. But we do not know who it is. As the story goes on and more death occurs. The suspicions rise. Who is killing the Robinson family members and why?
The author does a wonderful job of having you trying to figure out the culprit. You get a history of some of the members. What a way to show some true colors in some folks. This story has you wanting to turn the pages and rooting for the heroes to save the day. You are pulled in emotionally as well. I was guessing Dr. Beers or even Mrs. Robinson. Can Michael and Harriet save the Robinson family members or will it all go bad?
June 2, 2020
3.5 stars
"Get out of the house. Get out while you can."
Harriet Peters is both grief-stricken and terrified, not only has her best friend succombed to a violet death, but others in her family have died in exactly the same manner. It's perplexing, to say the least. This is a family who has shown her nothing but kindness over the brief years of their acquaintance; taking her in and helping Harriet to establish her own millinery business; the Robinsons are hard workers and a God-fearing family, but something has gone terriby awry.
"Without evidence you can't get the warrant, but without the warrant, we can't get the evidence."
Dr. Michael Wheaton is beside himself with worry about the lovely hat shop owner. Harriet engaged his services when Lizzie Robinson was on her death bed, and he has every reason to suspect that something nefarious is going on within the household. He can't help but admire Harriet for her fierce dedication to her friends, but how can he find answers when no one will allow him entrance into the house?
"The Green Dress" is a tribute to this entire series; exposing heinous historical crimes, while mananging to thread them together with tender doses of spiritual depth and the sweetest of romances.
"Get out of the house. Get out while you can."
Harriet Peters is both grief-stricken and terrified, not only has her best friend succombed to a violet death, but others in her family have died in exactly the same manner. It's perplexing, to say the least. This is a family who has shown her nothing but kindness over the brief years of their acquaintance; taking her in and helping Harriet to establish her own millinery business; the Robinsons are hard workers and a God-fearing family, but something has gone terriby awry.
"Without evidence you can't get the warrant, but without the warrant, we can't get the evidence."
Dr. Michael Wheaton is beside himself with worry about the lovely hat shop owner. Harriet engaged his services when Lizzie Robinson was on her death bed, and he has every reason to suspect that something nefarious is going on within the household. He can't help but admire Harriet for her fierce dedication to her friends, but how can he find answers when no one will allow him entrance into the house?
"The Green Dress" is a tribute to this entire series; exposing heinous historical crimes, while mananging to thread them together with tender doses of spiritual depth and the sweetest of romances.
June 1, 2020
Get out of the house while you can....
Imagine hearing that statement inside your head - several times. Would you be inclined to act on it if it meant life or death? The True Colors series teaches us some rather bizarre history, some of which is almost impossible to believe. It seems, from the observational point, that those unfortunate folks who found themselves in these situations would be inclined to leave town as soon as possible. However, as life is, most of us would have trouble believing that such evil exists and thus would remain.
Harriet Peters arrives in Somerville, Massachusetts all alone. Finding a new family in the Robinsons, she slowly built her life in a new place. When members of her new family die of a mysterious illness, she looks to the new doctor in town to figure out what is killing them. Will their investigation bring further harm or can a diagnosis be found?
Once again I have learned that history can be hard to believe at times. This digital copy was received through Barbour Publishing and NetGalley. My comments and impressions were in no way solicited.
Imagine hearing that statement inside your head - several times. Would you be inclined to act on it if it meant life or death? The True Colors series teaches us some rather bizarre history, some of which is almost impossible to believe. It seems, from the observational point, that those unfortunate folks who found themselves in these situations would be inclined to leave town as soon as possible. However, as life is, most of us would have trouble believing that such evil exists and thus would remain.
Harriet Peters arrives in Somerville, Massachusetts all alone. Finding a new family in the Robinsons, she slowly built her life in a new place. When members of her new family die of a mysterious illness, she looks to the new doctor in town to figure out what is killing them. Will their investigation bring further harm or can a diagnosis be found?
Once again I have learned that history can be hard to believe at times. This digital copy was received through Barbour Publishing and NetGalley. My comments and impressions were in no way solicited.
October 3, 2021
I've been wary of the True Colors series whenever they show up in my giveaways, though I have no idea exactly why. Especially not after reading The Green Dress. I don't know if I've ever read a historical mystery that's not a regency or with so much romance it distracts from the plot. I've also never read a medical thriller, although after finishing this I'm seriously questioning why I haven't investigated the doctor-turned-detective genre a little more.
I'm glad I did have occasion to read this. Again, it is a genre I am hoping to explore more, and I really like how Liz Tolsma interpreted this historical story.
That's another thing. I vaguely knew that this was based on a true story, but it read so much like other thrillers I've read, not informational or even historical texts. I really enjoyed the two main characters, they worked together well and were written into the historical context perfectly. From my understanding, only the two main characters, Harriet and Michael, were complete fabrications in this story, and they added a lot to the novel in the way that they investigated from inside the home and as a doctor.
Another thing I liked about this book, which I'm sure was not the author's primary goal in writing this, was the blend of science and religion. Having had no real religion growing up, I often have trouble understanding how these two topics intersect. In this novel, we see patients trusting doctors and both patients and doctors trusting God, and I found this contrast really informative as to how faith informs medicine and scientific practices. I know a lot about medicine has changed in the years since this took place, but still being able to see the connections that the characters, especially Michael, made between religion and pure science was eye-opening.
I hope I get the opportunity to read more True Colors books in an attempt to look at more personal histories throughout the US and UK. It's this kind of thing that makes me want to read history and historical fiction, to learn more about the people history may have forgotten. I really enjoyed this.
Disclaimer:
I'm glad I did have occasion to read this. Again, it is a genre I am hoping to explore more, and I really like how Liz Tolsma interpreted this historical story.
That's another thing. I vaguely knew that this was based on a true story, but it read so much like other thrillers I've read, not informational or even historical texts. I really enjoyed the two main characters, they worked together well and were written into the historical context perfectly. From my understanding, only the two main characters, Harriet and Michael, were complete fabrications in this story, and they added a lot to the novel in the way that they investigated from inside the home and as a doctor.
Another thing I liked about this book, which I'm sure was not the author's primary goal in writing this, was the blend of science and religion. Having had no real religion growing up, I often have trouble understanding how these two topics intersect. In this novel, we see patients trusting doctors and both patients and doctors trusting God, and I found this contrast really informative as to how faith informs medicine and scientific practices. I know a lot about medicine has changed in the years since this took place, but still being able to see the connections that the characters, especially Michael, made between religion and pure science was eye-opening.
I hope I get the opportunity to read more True Colors books in an attempt to look at more personal histories throughout the US and UK. It's this kind of thing that makes me want to read history and historical fiction, to learn more about the people history may have forgotten. I really enjoyed this.
Disclaimer:
July 1, 2020
I have loved all the books in the True Colors series and I think that this one has been my favorite. This book showed the horror that this poor family went through with a mother that only thought of money. I like how Harriet and Michael were worked in to the story. This story made me sick in some ways to see how horrible some people really are. I could not put this story down. I received a copy of this book from Celebratelit for a fair and honest opinion that I gave of my own free will.
May 11, 2020
This book had me hooked from the very beginning! I ended up staying up too late reading this! I had kind of suspected what was going on and who was doing it. I have really enjoyed reading these true crime stories that are still Christian Fiction. I really enjoyed this book!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
September 1, 2021
As I read The Green Dress, I shook my head in disbelief. This is the story of Sarah Jane Robinson, known as The Boston Borgia, an Irish-born American serial killer who poisoned her family members and other people from 1881 to 1886, with the help of her accomplices Thomas R. Smith and Dr. Charles C. Beers. In this story, Harriet Peters has been taken in by the Robinson family after she runs from home refusing to marry the man her father has selected for her. She becomes friends with Lizzie, the daughter of Sarah Jane and when she becomes sick, she nurses her. Nothing they do save Lizzie and she dies a painful death, the same as other members of her family. The doctor, Charles Beers, can't figure out how the "toxin" is killing the family members. Harriet brings in another doctor to get a second opinion, Dr. Michael Wheaton, who has some suspicions about what is happening. Sarah Jane, wants him out of her home and to stay away from the family. When two more family members get sick, Dr. Wheaton goes to the police. He is in fear for Harriet's life, especially since he hasn't seen her for awhile. Throw in some insurance money and there is a lot to be suspicious of.
Once again, I was not aware of The Boston Borgia, so looked it up, as I couldn't believe it was possible. Liz Tolsma took the story and added some romance to move the story along in a positive and hopeful way. It was Harriet and Dr. Wheaton (Dr. White in the actual case) that began to suspect that these were not natural deaths. At first Harriet did not believe Michael, but eventually, when she became ill, she knew he was telling the truth. I liked how the relationship between Michael and Harriet developed. The writing was wonderful and remained hopeful even in the dire circumstances. The book was clean with Christian leanings, although not preachy. This was a very emotional story, and hearing about the pain the victims were in was very difficult. Liz Tolsma does a great job creating tension. The reader knows what is happening, the suspense is when she will be caught and who the next victim will be. There was definitely a creepy, gothic vibe permeating this story. I do recommend this series, as I really enjoy how true crime is taken and a fictional story is built around it, but not obscuring the actual events.
Once again, I was not aware of The Boston Borgia, so looked it up, as I couldn't believe it was possible. Liz Tolsma took the story and added some romance to move the story along in a positive and hopeful way. It was Harriet and Dr. Wheaton (Dr. White in the actual case) that began to suspect that these were not natural deaths. At first Harriet did not believe Michael, but eventually, when she became ill, she knew he was telling the truth. I liked how the relationship between Michael and Harriet developed. The writing was wonderful and remained hopeful even in the dire circumstances. The book was clean with Christian leanings, although not preachy. This was a very emotional story, and hearing about the pain the victims were in was very difficult. Liz Tolsma does a great job creating tension. The reader knows what is happening, the suspense is when she will be caught and who the next victim will be. There was definitely a creepy, gothic vibe permeating this story. I do recommend this series, as I really enjoy how true crime is taken and a fictional story is built around it, but not obscuring the actual events.
April 4, 2020
The Green Dress by Liz Tolsma is the latest installment of the exciting True Colors series. Based on the crime spree of female serial killer Sarah Jane Robinson, the novel focuses on Harriet Peter, the fictional best friend of Sarah Jane’s daughter, and fictional doctor Michael Wheaton. After the death of Harriet’s best friend, she moves in with the family to help. When more of the Robinson family becomes ill, Michael warns Harriet to get out of the house as soon as she can. But Harriet made a promise to her best friend. How can she keep that promise and stay alive?
Tolsma kicks off this romantic suspense by catapulting the reader into the poignant world of 1886 Boston. Lizzie’s sickness and eventual death (based on the true account of Lizzie Robinson) is well-researched and well-executed. Tolsma manages to use these scenes to not only introduce Harriet and Michael but also the character of Sarah Jane.
Harriet is a relatable character willing to do what she can for the family she’s made. Her background, with a difficult family situation, added to the story and made her motivation believable. I liked the way Tolsma weaved it in without doing a huge info-dump. Speaking of backstories, I also liked the way she weaved in Michael’s backstory. I found his history with his mother endearing, and it made me like him more.
The actual timeline of events, from Lizzie’s death to the last victim, serves as the structure of the novel. I appreciated that Tolsma stayed true to actual events, but I wasn’t as invested in the romance because of the time lapse that had to occur to move the story along. However, I do think she did a great job of developing the romance between Harriet and Michael considering the timeline she was given. The last third of the novel was my favorite part as far as their relationship and its development.
The historical notes at the end helped me to appreciate the research Tolsma put into this story. I thought she did an excellent job of fleshing out Sarah Jane Robinson and the manipulation she used. I think characters based on true historical characters would be the hardest to portray because of preconceived notions and the accuracy it requires. Tolsma did a great job of bringing these real people to life. Charley Robinson was my favorite. I almost wish he there could be a story about him. But she did do a great job of making me care about the characters and mourn their deaths with Harriet.
Overall, The Green Dress is a well-written romantic suspense. I highly recommend it to anyone who loves mystery, history, and romance.
(Review will go live on the blog May 22 at 5:00 PM)
Tolsma kicks off this romantic suspense by catapulting the reader into the poignant world of 1886 Boston. Lizzie’s sickness and eventual death (based on the true account of Lizzie Robinson) is well-researched and well-executed. Tolsma manages to use these scenes to not only introduce Harriet and Michael but also the character of Sarah Jane.
Harriet is a relatable character willing to do what she can for the family she’s made. Her background, with a difficult family situation, added to the story and made her motivation believable. I liked the way Tolsma weaved it in without doing a huge info-dump. Speaking of backstories, I also liked the way she weaved in Michael’s backstory. I found his history with his mother endearing, and it made me like him more.
The actual timeline of events, from Lizzie’s death to the last victim, serves as the structure of the novel. I appreciated that Tolsma stayed true to actual events, but I wasn’t as invested in the romance because of the time lapse that had to occur to move the story along. However, I do think she did a great job of developing the romance between Harriet and Michael considering the timeline she was given. The last third of the novel was my favorite part as far as their relationship and its development.
The historical notes at the end helped me to appreciate the research Tolsma put into this story. I thought she did an excellent job of fleshing out Sarah Jane Robinson and the manipulation she used. I think characters based on true historical characters would be the hardest to portray because of preconceived notions and the accuracy it requires. Tolsma did a great job of bringing these real people to life. Charley Robinson was my favorite. I almost wish he there could be a story about him. But she did do a great job of making me care about the characters and mourn their deaths with Harriet.
Overall, The Green Dress is a well-written romantic suspense. I highly recommend it to anyone who loves mystery, history, and romance.
(Review will go live on the blog May 22 at 5:00 PM)
June 30, 2020
The Green Dress by Liz Tolsma is a totally gripping Christian historical crime suspense and part of the True Colors series. It can be read as a stand-alone.
Liz Tolsma has taken a true life crime and woven her story around the facts. It is both mesmerising and horrifying as the reader knows that all that happens is true.
Crimes are committed. At first it seems like bad luck but as the body count rises so does the suspicion.
The characters are all well drawn. The young children’s mannerisms and innocence were perfectly captured. The leading lady has a kind heart, looking out for the innocent. She struggles with the concept of a good Father as her earthly father let her down. “Why did God have to do this to her?” God does not ‘let’ anything happen, it is man’s free will and His Holy Spirit grieves.
The novel has the theme of trust. Both the reader and the characters have to decide where to place their trust.
We see the question of grace arise as a character asks “Have I been good enough?’… ‘You aren’t asking the right question… Did He [God] love you enough to send His Son for you.’ “ We will never be ‘good enough’ in our own strength. It is not about what we do. It is about what Jesus has done.
I am loving this True Colors series. It is both fascinating and horrifying as all the stories are grounded in fact. The Green Dress, as with all the previous books, inspires me to delve deeper into the facts. Thank you Liz Tolsma for a marvellous read.
I received this book for free. A favourable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
Liz Tolsma has taken a true life crime and woven her story around the facts. It is both mesmerising and horrifying as the reader knows that all that happens is true.
Crimes are committed. At first it seems like bad luck but as the body count rises so does the suspicion.
The characters are all well drawn. The young children’s mannerisms and innocence were perfectly captured. The leading lady has a kind heart, looking out for the innocent. She struggles with the concept of a good Father as her earthly father let her down. “Why did God have to do this to her?” God does not ‘let’ anything happen, it is man’s free will and His Holy Spirit grieves.
The novel has the theme of trust. Both the reader and the characters have to decide where to place their trust.
We see the question of grace arise as a character asks “Have I been good enough?’… ‘You aren’t asking the right question… Did He [God] love you enough to send His Son for you.’ “ We will never be ‘good enough’ in our own strength. It is not about what we do. It is about what Jesus has done.
I am loving this True Colors series. It is both fascinating and horrifying as all the stories are grounded in fact. The Green Dress, as with all the previous books, inspires me to delve deeper into the facts. Thank you Liz Tolsma for a marvellous read.
I received this book for free. A favourable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 248 reviews