kristy is back home from her hawaiian vacation & staring down the barrel of another year attending the eighth grade at stoneybrook middle school. she is also anxious because abby was president of the babysitters club while kristy was away & kristy is very concerned that abby was a superior president somehow. (abby as president was the subplot of stacey's broken heart. i forgot to mention it in my review. basically, abby thinks kristy is too bossy & controlling, so she only charges dues every other week, doesn't make people write in the notebook, doesn't force people to be on time to meetings, etc. she organizes a mexican fiesta with the charges to show that she can hold a successful babysitting event without being a dictator about it, but all these things go wrong & she learns, i guess, that kristy may be bossy but she's good at getting shit done.)
anyway, kristy feels the need to prove that she is a good president, & what better way to prove it than to organize another event. she calls it that fall into fall festival block party. she plans to block off mclelland road (the road that wtson's mansion is on) & have all kinds of fun autumn-themed activities, like maple sugarding, cider making, apple picking, etc. the other babysitters are kind of shellshocked by this idea & weakly point out that there are no apple trees on mclelland road. kristy is all, "no problem, we'll hang some." she decides they will hang apples from trees for kids to pick, & use food processors to made cider, & build a fire pit for boiling sap into syrup, & she dispatches claudia to figure out a way to sculpt fallen leaves into statues.
the babysitters kind of idly go along with the plans for a little while, but eventually they're like, "um, kristy? we're all really busy with homework & stuff, & we're worn out from abby's mexican fiesta event, & also, your fall into fall festival ideas are totally batshit crazy." then jessi enrolls in an advanced dance class that meets on thursday afternoon, so she suggests re-scheduling friday babysitters club meetings for thursdays. & then mallory enrolls in a fiction class at the library that meets on wednesday afternoons, & she suggests rescheduling wednesday meetings for tuesdays. kristy completely loses her mind & i all, "i guess i'm the only one who really cares about the babysitters club, huh?" & then she suggests that they disband the club. & EVERYONE VOTES TO DISBAND. it's really weird.
so the babysitters club is kaput. they circulate their phone numbers to their clients & claudia kind of acts as a one-woman phone tree for people calling in for sitters. kristy is completely destroyed that the club is over, but no one else seems to be upset, so she keeps her feelings to herself. some other kids at SMS are taking sitting jobs, including cokie mason, who doesn't seem like a very good sitter. they tell kristy is the babysitters club had a monopoly on stoneybrook babysitting jobs, but now that the club is disbanded, everyone else can have a chance to learn how to change diapers & stuff.
eventually kristy can't take it anymore. she calls everyone to a meeting & asks if they want to re-form the club. stacey is the only one that is like, "i don't know if this is a good idea," but finally everyone votes yes. the end.
this book didn't really make any sense. i feel like shutting down the babysitters club is kind of a huge, disruptive decision & they seemed to make it on a lark. it's kind of hard to go back from something like that, but they do, with pretty much no repercussions at all. & pretty much the only reason they closed down the club in the first place is because kristy seriously went crazy. the scene in which mallory suggests switching wednesday meetings to tursday...holy shit. i would not have been surprised if kristy attacked mallory with a circular saw & then invited some of her regular clients over to dine on mallory's organs. i'd vote to shut the club down too, just to spare myself an hour & a half a week of being confined in a room with kristy the maniac.