I’m torn between giving it zero stars and 5 stars.
This book touches on everything one needs to do to heal from having grown up with a BPD mother - but it avoids the mammoth in the room.
It assumes “Your goal is to create a new relationship with your mother that’s healthier than the one you grew up in.”
I feel the whole book is saying cheerful versions of ‘when your mother grabs an axe and cuts off one of your limbs, make sure you have a good doctor - and remember to wash the blood of the carpet’’.
From ‘you’ll have to be patient with your mother’ to ‘you’ll have to work at not being codependent in future relationships’ to ‘you’ll have to fight off a tendency to depression, anxiety and addictions’, he is showing us how to heal from abuse… by keeping the abuser in our lives.
This is abhorrent to me. He never questions the presence of the mother in her children’s lives. We’re supposed to strive to make the relationship better.
Fuck that. It borders on manipulation and gaslighting.
When you have a BPD mother, any of these issues (absolutely no self-worth, depression, anxiety, addictions etc) can kill you. Definitely we must get better - it’s an almost overwhelming amount of work, I’ve literally achieved nothing else in my life but surviving my childhood - AND I HAVE TO MAKE NICE WITH MY ABUSER ON TOP OF IT??? I have to manage her, give her more chances, try to trust her again??? When my only reason for existing as a child was to manage her and make her happy??! Are you fucking kidding me??! When do I get to live???
In NO OTHER connection with an abuser do people tell you to suck it up/improve it. They tell you to leave, move, change your name and start from scratch. That’s how you survive. Survival is a lot messier than the author seems to think, with his neat little advice in neat little columns.
If I hadn’t moved across the world, gone NC (no contact), I never could have rebuilt myself. Never.
The fact the author keeps a ‘healthier relationship’ with the BPD breeder as the central thesis of his book makes it morally bankrupt.
If one manages to overlook that, the advice he gives is great, if a little glib.