MY RATING GUIDE: 3 Stars. Although I very much enjoy this series, this particular novella was grim & more brutally realistic than I prefer. TRIGGER WARNING BELOW.
1= dnf/What was that?; 2= Nope, not for me; 3= THIS WAS OKAY; 3.5= I enjoyed it; 4= I liked it a lot; 5= I Loved this; it was great! (I SELDOM give 5 Stars).
October 1793, London ~
Unknown to Bow Street Runner Constable Ned Woods, his future SIL Ginny, 14yrs old, has been violently assaulted & raped by a wealthy and privileged lodger while performing her duties as maid for the boardinghouse/inn where she works.
Ten years later, June, 1803 (also in the past), London ~ MMC Newly promoted Bow Street Runner Detective Stephen Lavender, just 24yrs old (here), with his trainer Constable Woods, accept their first murder case together not knowing the case will connect with terrible incidents from the past. The case will also resurrect a terrible past event for someone in Woods’ family and test Lavender’s character and his determination to apprehend and remove violent criminals from the streets.
Comments ~
1) DEATH OF IRISH KNELL, bk 5.5, published in 2019, is a quick reading novella from Detective Lavender’s past which leads into book 6, THE WILLOW MARSH MURDER. I don’t recommend reading DOIK as a standalone title as better understanding of the main characters is better understood when the books are read in order.
2) As mentioned above, I found this title more brutal and grim than previous books. I am hoping the next book - which is connected - provides better understanding and closure. )
3) The Lavender - Woods series is set in 1810+ England and features 2 Bow Street runners. The tone, details and period differ from other mysteries I read providing a slightly new perspective of English history.
4) Charlton is a fairly new-to-me author. I purchased a number of books & audiobooks in her Lavender/Woods series and am reading my way through them. I read a digital copy this time but Michael Page is wonderful depicting the various earthy characters and the overall tone (in the audiobook version).
5) Karen Charlton ends her books with author notes providing clarification of certain aspects of the period, setting, the particular cases and any historical characters. She provided such notes at the end of IRISH KNELL but I still found myself pondering how, if at all, such an ending to this novella (at the beginning of Lavender’s career) would affect him going forward. I still wonder.
6) The sad plight of the poor and lower classes (including many Bow Street families, laborers, immigrants, etc) resonates through this series as well as the widely prevalent unsanitary living conditions which gives me cause to wonder anew.
6) I recommend Charlton’s mysteries to readers who enjoy:
> Character-driven series.
> Seasoned characters.
> Classic, Historical and British Mysteries.
> Regency, Victorian novels with interesting facts and details from those periods.
> History.
> Police Procedural novels.
> Mysteries and books that are thought provoking.
> and enjoy a certain amount of earthy humor. ;)
READER CAUTION ~ *TRIGGER WARNING BELOW.
PROFANITY - PG-13. Limited strong language is used with occasional off-color jokes & earthy humor.
*VIOLENCE - PG. This is a murder mystery that includes rape, sexual assault & forced sodomy toward young girl(s) of 14 and up. The events are described from witnesses and either after the fact or interrupted with a “fade out.” The details are present but not dwelled upon but reported to the police.
SEXUAL SITUATIONS - None.