Reread/listened to the audiobook version May'2022:
This is a beautiful, poignant romance that tackles serious subject matter with honesty and grace. Still a big 5 star read for me!
Original rating/review Jan'2010:
5+ stars – Historical Romance
I loved this evocative story of two very different people from opposite social classes who form a deep, emotional connection and share an explosive passion that heals them both. It’s a poignant, romantic story with remarkable characters that stays with you long after you’ve finished reading it.
Notorious, devilishly wicked rogue Jack Dodger is the rich, powerful owner of London’s most famous, exclusive gentleman’s club, but no matter how much wealth he accumulates, he can’t escape the haunts of his tarnished, tortured past. Jack was orphaned to the rough streets of London’s dangerous rookeries as a boy of five and found refuge in a gang of child thieves under the tutelage of a man named Feagan. After living the life of a street urchin, enduring abuses and hardships, and engaging in numerous crimes, he eventually grew his fortune and has vowed to never let anyone harm him ever again, which also means never letting anyone past his hardened defenses or in his heart.
Olivia, Duchess of Lovingdon, is a lady bound by virtue, honor, and duty who has lived a stifled, strict existence, always in accordance with society’s rules and expectations, even at the sacrifice of her own will, desires, and happiness. Olivia is shocked to learn that her recently deceased (much older) husband has named debauched scoundrel Jack Dodger guardian of her five-year-old-son Henry and their estate. Now, the Duchess Olivia, a well-bred lady of upmost propriety, finds herself literally in the hands of a depraved scamp who holds no value in the rules of society.
The Duchess is appalled at having to share her home and the raising of her beloved son Henry with a deviant scoundrel like Jack, and he’s none too happy with the idea of having to tolerate and live with a stuffy, snobby, uptight, cold lady of society. But their mutual disdain doesn’t keep them from feeling a volatile, albeit unwanted and complicated, attraction that eventually evolves into cordial respect and something much deeper that neither expected and that has the potential for disaster, especially when devastating past secrets are revealed.
This story tackles some heavy, unpleasant, painful subjects, like child abuse, class differences, prejudice, and poverty, with an emotional honesty and intensity that’s heartbreaking, humbling, and inspiring. The story is affecting and brought tears to my eyes, but I didn’t feel like the author manipulated my emotions. There are just some harsh facts and realities of life that can’t be hidden or swept down the gutter. I think this story demonstrates beautifully that a person isn’t simply a product of their past or social position and how the choices we make in life can have irrevocable consequences.
This is the second book in the Scoundrels of St. James series, and although I enjoyed it immensely; I think I would have gotten even more out of it had I read the first book prior to this since there are some fairly significant plot points that carry on throughout the series.
Between the Devil and Desire is the type of story that stays with you long after it ends, and although there is a HEA, it’s more thought provoking and reflective, which I admired. I’m looking forward to reading the rest of this wonderful series.