I imagine I might be attacked for my low rating. If so, I won’t engage with you, so please don’t waste your time and mine. The author is young, sincere, and arrogant. She even admitted she does not listen to others particularly well. She thinks she knows it all and she doesn’t. Now, let me emphasize something: her basic point is 100% correct. BIPOC and the various other marginalized groups definitely have a more difficult time in many ways. But painting white straight males as the entire problem and the reason why institutional racism is still around isn’t fair. If you want allies, don’t antagonize them. She even admitted she did that with one white male friend and still hasn’t learnt the lesson.
Next, she isn’t much of a historian. On page 63 she writes “These schools (American residential schools for Indians) were the model for the residential schools in Australia and New Zealand. On the prior page she notes that Indian boarding schools started in 1860. Yet right after the quote on p. 63, she states “In 1814 they (residential schools) were set up by Christian churches and funded by the British government.” Let’s not automatically blame everything on American system of racism. American residential schools might have been influenced by British examples, but it certainly wasn’t the other way around, not unless the Brits had time travel and used it to see what the Americans would be doing in the future!
My problem with this book, is that she is young and has the arrogance of youth who KNOW they know it all. Her suggestions might have merit for other young adults who need to start examining the shocking news that they were brought up with many racist assumptions. It likely isn’t news to adults who have lived a while and read newspaper headlines as they matured, that the world they grew up in has changed drastically and their parents were wrong in certain things. Those adults who haven’t realized this are not likely to read this preachy book and if they do, are likely to be antagonized by the righteous attitude of the author. I was antagonized, and I agree with the basic premise that there is a lot of institutional racism that needs to be yanked out and redone.
Not recommended except for other young adults who are anxious to try to change their world. Good luck, but if you are young and reading my review, please remember that the world is not easily spilt up into right and wrong. It is various shades of both and it can be hard to distinguish what is indeed wrong and need to be redone from the ground up and what simply needs change of some degree, hopefully from within an organization, with input from outside pressure. Older adults might have suggestions that are valid.