Well, hello, wonderful Historical Romance with sassy ladies and a hero with a heavy burden. Why yes, I would like to read you!
So, this novel was a hard start for me. I wanted to read it but I just didn't know if I was feeling the premise. Girl is tired of the constrictions of her life and wants a night away, in breeches no less (gasp), and she ends up in a billiard battle for the privilege. It just seemed like a lot of work for her to have a night away.
Thankfully, this ended up being much less about that and more about 2 people getting over their previous misconceptions and coming together to make each other stronger and more free. Which is everything I want in a HR.
Betsy has been struggling under her self-imposed propriety of trying to out live her mother's scandalous affair from years earlier. She thinks she needs to marry and be as sexually inconspicuous as possible, lest she be overcome like her mother and run away with the first rouge she meets.
Jeremy is wounded warrior, staying with the Wildes for some R&R and trying not to relive all the horrors of losing his whole squad of men in the Colonies, of which he is the only survivor. He drinks, jokes, and mopes around the castle.
I wasn't a fan of Betsy's hang ups in this novel, however, Jeremy is very perspective and I loved that this conflict didn't get out of proportion or cause a huge rift between them as I have seen in other HRs I have read. They start this journey as friends, and through some gentle prodding of the people around them, realize they can have happiness, and steaminess without it being the problem they think it will be.
There was also the potential for a cheating troupe here, and I was VERY worried about that. I despise that troupe in any situation, and since Betsy is so horrified by her mother's infidelity, I was nervous we were going to continue that. However, though the novel begins with Betsy being proposed to by the Duke, and we are waiting for her to say NO, as the title implies, nothing more than a kiss or two happens before she makes up her mind, and since she never did promise to marry Thaddeus, said Duke, I didn't feel like that was an issue.
Thaddeus was a great option though, very dashing and kind, if not a bit dull and his mother is a hoot! The next novel in the series is called "Say Yes to the Duke", so hopefully he has a happy ending coming too.
Final fun things to mention.
-The "dressing like a boy" for freedom's sake didn't every really become a big of deal as it appeared, but it did lead to some fun situations.
-There is a meddling aunt and mother that were just delicious.
-The tension in this novel was on point for me.
-Great set up for the next novel as usual for Eloisa James
This became a 5 star for me with the upturning of troupes I was expecting and for the look into PTSD and how people treat the military. Its not too deep in here, but enough that I teared up a few times.
*I don't know how it happened, but this one pulled off a 5 star. Review to come