If I had to describe the trilogy in one word, I would say love. If I had two words: stupid love. The Dark Artifices delves deeper into the consequences of the cold war, following The Mortal Instruments. Clare’s Shadowhunter books have always been about love, however, this trilogy takes love to the next level and it is shown as very synonymous to lust in the books. The story is extremely well woven, with intricate societal systems, characters with deep emotions which are sometimes dark, realistic events, and a creative concept overall. If I were to rate the trilogy as a whole without worrying about the parts I did or did not like, I would give it a 10/10. Cassandra Clare writes in a captivating way and, for the most part, the books are very eventful. She brings in new concepts in these books including the Land of Faery, alternate dimensions, ancient and powerful magic, and much more. There are so many twists in the plot that for the most part, it is thrilling and there is no way one could predict all the big events that would happen.
The characters are also developed in such a way that the readers empathize with them and the plot becomes much more interesting because of that. Julian Blackthorn is arguably the most interesting character in the series. We see early on that Julian is secretive and there is “always more when it comes to Julian Blackthorn” (somewhere from the second book, I can’t remember the exact place). His political mind quickly makes readers fall in love with him. Julian has a dark side to him which is also a reason why he is more interesting. The other characters we learn more about in the series are Emma, Cristina, Mark, Livvy, Ty, Kit, Kieran, Diana, Drusilia, and a few others, and they do not fail to impress.
The only part I don’t enjoy about these books is how childishly “love” is displayed. It is hard to distinguish it from lust in these books. Everybody in the trilogy somehow, miraculously, finds their one true love. Spoiler alert (although, it isn’t too hard to figure this part out early on), Julian and Emma love each other because they can’t seem to keep their hands off of each other, Kit starts loving Ty, Mark, Cristina, and Kieran fall into a love triangle which makes no sense at all, and Diana also falls for Gwyn. Some of the love stories shown in the series are quite deep and possibly realistic, however, most characters who fall in love in these series start off with an obsessive desire for the other person. Moreover, it is very cringy when literally everybody finds somebody that they love. Real life clearly doesn't work that way and, in my opinion, this is what ruins the series, especially when everything else in the series is extremely well written and quite realistic (minus the fantasy part). It is, however, important to note that there are some couples that are actually good in the series. Diana and Gwyn start off pretty slowly and they are both very mature, so the development of their bond would make a great story. Another one is Ty and Kit; without even knowing for sure that they are both gay, they fall for each other. It is realistic because (spoiler alert) they have a lot of ups and downs in their relationship, mostly downs, including the part where Kit leaves at the end because he thinks Ty is mad at him. Diego and Cristina used to date before but they break up and that part is also well scripted. At the end, we also see more about Magnus and Alec’s relationship and that is by far the most authentic relationship in the entire Shadowhunter series.
Overall, the series would have been a little better if it didn’t feel like it was written from the perspective of a hopeless romantic. Yet, I would definitely recommend the series for all the good and exciting parts. If you enjoyed The Mortal Instruments and The Infernal Devices series, you will fall in love with The Dark Artifices, as it is the best amongst the three.