Okay, confession time. I read this book purely because of the gorgeous cover.
(Not exactly true, though. I also read it because I love fairytale retellings. Don't tell anyone, though. I'm supposed to be that girl who never touches fantasy with a 64-foot pole. 😜)
And honestly, I really, really wanted to like it. I loved a lot of the story—the mishmash of fairytale retellings, the characters, the world, and magic. I also really related to the main character's feelings of being forced into someone who wasn't really herself, longing like a bird to be free from her cage. The author's writing style fitted the tone of the story. And yes, Bristal's disguises and her "fairy godmother" role made me just a tad bit jealous. 😉
Oh, and Brack is an AMAZING character. Love him.
But in all, while there was a lot of fun and creative aspects of this story, there were a lot of things that I just couldn't quite get behind.
Some parts felt reminiscent of Disney movies. And for those who know me, I'm not a big—or even a little—fan of Disney, partly because I never could quite agree with the way they dealt with their themes. Specifically, in this book, there were SO many scenes where princes and princesses fell in love at first sight, based on appearance only. There was so much of "I love you because you're so beautiful" which just felt so wrong. That happened multiple times, not only between the princes and princesses Bristal was befriending/protecting, but also with Bristal herself.
The Bible specifically talks about this. Proverbs 31:30 states, "Charm is deceitful, and beauty is vain, but a woman who fears the LORD is to be praised."
Appearance should never be the guiding factor in ANY relationship, romantic or otherwise. I know it happens a lot in real life, but that's not how things SHOULD be. Such relationships are purely shallow, and probably not enduring like all good relationships should be. Like, seriously, can't we have an average (appearance-wise) female love interest?
Rant aside, I feel like there was a lot of romance that seemed to come out of nowhere in this book. And of course, there were weddings. None of the ships were ones I could get behind at all, because they were all so surface-level and based solely on appearance. None of the characters even started as friends, and I felt because of that, they didn't know each other very well. Which was just sad, because there was so much potential there.
There were also other things ... how stilted the dialogue felt, how some of the characters felt underdeveloped, and some believability issues I had, as well as questions worldbuilding-wise that never were explained.
But what I DID especially appreciate about this book was that the lines between good and evil were not crossed. There was a very clear evil character (that I really wanted to like, in the beginning) and her evil magic. The main and side characters used their good magic for healing, practical things, and bringing peace to the realm. Never once did they source from the dark magic.
So overall, I just feel this book wasn't my thing. But if you like dark fantasy with a lot of magical elements, fairytale retellings, and political subplots (that are specific to the world), you might enjoy this one.