Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Lily Singer Adventures #4

Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Legends

Rate this book
Alternate cover edition for B071H7K758

Legends exist in the past...until now. How very inconsiderate of them.

The battle has been won, but the war is far from over. With her greatest ally at death's door, it is up to Lily Singer to make things right. Troublemaking witch friend and talking cat in tow, she must pursue her father to England where he seeks an ancient evil to steal its power for himself. But when a queen of the fae gets involved and Sebastian's mistakes come back to haunt him, the three friends have to think fast and act faster to defeat legends that refuse to stay in the past.

Far from home and facing perilous odds, Lily fears she's not strong enough to keep her friends safe and win the day. Can she rise to the occasion or will this adventure be the end of them all?

Full of unexpected twists and snarky humor, Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Legends is the fourth book in the Lily Singer Adventures urban fantasy series. If you enjoy magic-filled adventures like Harry Potter and Supernatural then you'll love this delightful new series. Grab your copy today and discover why legends are so very hard to kill.

WARNING: This story has been known to cause loud snorts of laughter, inexplicable craving for tea, and loss of work productivity.

333 pages, ebook

First published April 28, 2017

553 people are currently reading
1100 people want to read

About the author

Lydia Sherrer

32 books587 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
807 (42%)
4 stars
769 (40%)
3 stars
274 (14%)
2 stars
28 (1%)
1 star
6 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 146 reviews
Profile Image for Siobhan.
5,041 reviews595 followers
May 15, 2017
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Legends is the fourth book in the Lily Singer Adventure series, and I cannot wait to get my hands on the future books in the series. I really do fear the wait will kill me. This is a series that is going from strength to strength, and my desire to know how everything comes together is at an all-time high. Honestly, it’s a wonderful series, a series that deserves so much more attention than it is getting. It’s a series I have only positive things to say about, it’s a series I’m going to follow until the end.

By book four, we all know what kind of magical story we are entering. We know that we’re going to be handed multi-layered story dressed up as a deceptively simple read. You enter thinking it will be a simple tale, and yet the deeper into the story you get the more intricate the story becomes. Never does it become overly complex, though. Everything comes together wonderfully, and you cannot help but adore the connections made.

Throughout the first three books, we’ve found ourselves with so many questions. These questions just keep piling and piling, slowly climbing higher until we fear we’re going to be buried under them all. The title of these books – the love, the lies, and the hocus pocus – truly are central throughout. We’ve been given magic from the very first chapter. We’ve been given more and more lies with every book. We’ve been given love in so many forms. This book takes these aspects and makes them even stronger. Whilst we finally get some answers to those big old questions we have, even more questions are added. It was a beautiful thing – whilst I could finally say ‘finally’ in regards to certain reveals, by the end I was asking ‘what if’ questions. Every time you think this series has brought about every possible twist, something more is added to the story.

Without a doubt, the development of this series is wonderful. As I’ve stated, the story keeps evolving. We go from one glorious thing to the next. Throughout, the characters are wonderful. I’ve said it in my review of book three that these characters have wiggled their way into my heart, but by this point I’m starting to believe they’re some of my favourite characters. I love the way they work off each other, I love how complex they are, and I love the way they continue to grow. This series has such a strong cast, and I cannot wait to see how everything comes together for each of the characters.

I really could say so much about this one, but I fear I’ll rant too much and slip into the realm of spoilers. Just know this book takes the series to all new heights. Questions are answered, new elements are added, and everything will leave you wanting more. I think it is safe to say that this is my favourite read in the series thus far – although I have no doubt the next book will blow my mind even more.

I’m now off to wallow in self-pity as I eagerly await the next book in the series. I have the short story to tide me over, but even that won’t be enough to calm my frazzled nerves. As always, if you’ve yet to start this series – do it.
Profile Image for Lola.
2,003 reviews276 followers
May 12, 2017
This series is so good and this book was no exception. Although I am sad that now the wait starts for the next book in the series. Legends was filled with all the things I've come to expect from this series, great characters, awesome magic, the snarky cat Sir Kipling and a good solid story. It also brings something new to this series. In this book they travel to the UK and they get to visit the Fae realm! And there's an exciting battle at the end and a bit of sadness as well. Some things get resolved, there are some interesting developments and at the end of the book I can't help but be curious what the next book will bring.

Throughout this series Lily is really growing into her own and she makes some important steps in that regard in this book as well. It's really great to see her change a bit and stand up for what she believes in. She is not compromising on some of her points, like how she wants to be both fashionable and wear adventure clothes, which was a fun touch of showing her personality. She acts so realistic and I liked how she hesitated to harm others even though they probably deserved.

On the topic of realism I was quite impressed by how the author wrote the battle scene towards the end, it all was over pretty quickly, but still you were able to follow what went on. It seemed realistic that battles with magic in this universe wouldn't drag on for long as that's basically not possible with the way magic works here.

The change in setting in this book was interesting. Instead of in the familiar setting in the US and the city and locations we already know there, the story took place in the UK in this book. It was fun seeing Lily her excitement about visiting the UK and Oxford and I thought it was interesting how she noted the differences between the two countries. Although for me it just illustrated how different the US is as the UK is a lot more similar to the Netherlands.

There is a bit of romance as a side plot line and I love seeing it develop and grow a bit in each book. The same is the case in this book and I liked were it left them at the end of this book and am curious to see it change even more in the next book. It was nice reading about both characters and how they slowly realize their feelings for the other. While the main part of the book is told from Lily's point fo view, there's an interlude in the middle from Sebastian's point of view, which is always one of my favorite parts of the books.

The reader meets some new characters and places in this book. There are some interesting new side characters, but mostly they serve to fill a bit of a role and they do play their part, but we don't get to know them as much as I would've liked. I did like the manservant in this book. I didn't really care for Yuki and her poking fun at Sir Kipling. I also didn't really care for the plot line with a certain legend being real, but it didn't diminish my enjoyment of the book. The main characters are still great to read about and we learn more about them in this book and Sir Kipling goes with them everywhere they go, so we see a lot more of the snarky cat, which was fun.

I especially liked how we learned a bit more about the Fae realm in this book. It's something the author only touched upon so far and in this book we get a nice chunk of information about the Fae. I still have a lot of questions and want to know more, but it was great to learn more about them here. I also really liked the scene where they visit the Fae realm. I loved how the realm was described, it looked so pretty in my head.

To summarize: I really enjoyed this book! It's just as good as the previous books and I liked how we get to read more about the characters I've grown fond of. The setting change was interesting too as they travel to the UK in this book. Lily develops more in this book again and I love seeing her grow into her own and finding her way. And she acts so realistically as well. The magic system is another thing that felt very realistic. Another part I really liked is how we learned more about the Fae and their realm in this book. And ofcourse seeing the romance develop was awesome too! I can't wait for the next book in this series as these books are just so fun!
Profile Image for Elinor Balensuela.
12 reviews
August 4, 2017
This book was everything that I wanted!! While some series begin to grow stale by Book 4, the Lily Singer Adventures is as fresh as they come! The new characters are wonderful foils for the existing ones without leaving you confused about who is who (although I am grateful for the Cast of Characters list in the front of the book).

We finally get answers to Sebastian's past and those answers are given gracefully and eloquently. I cannot even begin to describe how much I'd love to go to the Fae Realm and have a friend like Pip. Without overwhelming us all at once, Sheerer gives us plenty while still cleverly holding back some key points (like WHAT IN THE WORLD IS THIRIEL HOLDING OVER SEBASTIAN?!?! AND WHEN/HOW IS SHE GOING TO COLLECT?!).

I am absolutely in love with this series and cannot wait for the rest of the adventure!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Daphne.
1,302 reviews49 followers
January 26, 2019
These books are always fun. I really grew to like Lily and Sebastian and felt myself very invested in them and the relationship between them, which developed in this book. The world also expanded a lot in this book, which was very interesting. We learned more about the fae, which added a whole new element to the world. I loved that we got some more information about Sebastian's past as well.

All in all, it was a very satisfying book, much like the others have been. There are still some questions left unanswered, but not too many. I look forward to finding out the answers in the future! This series is a lot of fun, and I really like how unique the magic is in it. I'll definitely keep an eye out for news of future installments.
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
7 reviews
June 27, 2017
Lydia has grown in her writing with each book and this is no exception. It is an amazing book filled with adventure and a budding romance. The characters are well-rounded both emotionally and laughably. Their little quirks really bring the book together. You cannot help but root for the budding relationship between Sebastian and Lily, which is actually built on a solid foundation of friendship unlike other reads. Furthermore, you cannot help but love the adorable, loyal, good-natured, but often troublemaking, cat Sir Kipling. With a strong plot and strong characters, this book is extremely hard to put down once you start reading.

Additionally, unlike the other books, the protagonists' quest takes them to England. Far from falling short on explaining their new surroundings and its affects on the plot, Lydia excels as describing the new environment in such a way that it enhances the story and the readers understanding of the situations they face.

The only thing I am sad about with this book is the time I will have to wait until the next duo is available for purchase.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Lola.
2,003 reviews276 followers
October 7, 2019
Audiobook review

I've been re-reading these books in audio format and it's a lot of fun experiencing the story anew. While book 4 isn't my favorite book of the series, it's an important one in terms in story. My original review for this one sums up my thoughts pretty well I still didn't really care for Yuki, although the narration for him was spot on. And I liked the manservant and again forgot his name as soon as I sit down to write this review.

I liked the visit to the fae realm, the narrator did the fae voices so well, especially of Therriel (not sure if I write that correctly). She sounded regal and otherworldly, it was really impressive. On the topic of the narration, I really love the narrators style and how well she brought this series to live. She adds personality to the characters in the way she narrates them and I really liked how everyone had their own voice and I could recognize who's speaking just by voice.

I definitely would recommend this series and the audio versions are awesome.
Profile Image for Mike Jorgensen.
1,016 reviews20 followers
March 19, 2024
This series continues to be fun, this book was good, but not as great as book 3. It felt more Indiana Jones than Harry Potter, although it has great elements of both.

I can't quite figure out why I didn't enjoy this quite as much. Perhaps it was the exploration of the fae kingdom that felt a bit rushed in the interlude and led to expository dialogue (or inner monologue) that could have been avoided if the initial exploration were more exhaustive. I also had a bit of confusion as to why Lily was determined to get to Morgan LeFay other than the fact that John Faust wants to. Lily doesn't align with her and isn't likely to persuade her so why the effort?

This only got three stars from me, but I'll be starting book 5 later today so that should tell you where I stand on this series :)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
5 reviews
March 13, 2017
Lily Singer and her friend Sebastian are ready for another adventure. Along the way they pick up some new friends and some very unlikely allies.

This book can be read as a stand alone but is enhanced when read in order.

I received an advanced copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest and unbiased review.
Profile Image for Elena.
63 reviews2 followers
February 10, 2022
Lydia Sherrer, once again, does not disappoint. She has deepened the world that she opened in the first book of the series, and invited us to travel not just as mundanes but inhabitants. I have come to know and cheer Lily and Sebastian, and truly enjoy their adventures and their companions, both new and old. Cannot wait to read the next in the series…Brava!
Profile Image for Candy Laine.
Author 7 books8 followers
August 17, 2017
Even more fascinating characters enter the story universe in this book. Sebastian is reunited with his grandmother. A British setup shows a different kind of wizard. Lily heads to Oxford and finds bibliophile heaven. And of course a lot more trouble. Can't wait to read more.
725 reviews8 followers
October 9, 2017
Still good

This series is still good with lots of excitement in this one and the door left wide open for more in the series. As a lover of all things Arthurian, the trip to Tintagel and the connections with Morgana Le Fae suited me down to the ground.
54 reviews1 follower
October 18, 2018
5*

Great read, endearing characters and a great storyline made this series a firm favourite. Please write a 5th one!
*spoilers*

*

You can't leave it like that!? I'm dying to read their first kiss xxx
272 reviews2 followers
October 15, 2018
Excelent!

A true five rating. These books are in a separate class far exceeding the work of other authors with competing works. Wonderfully warm truly creative enchanting story. The kind of books that feeling disappointed that they are over when you've finished. I do hope there will be more books. This is almost a semi cliff hanger. Wonderfully memorable books, all four great reads, thank you
850 reviews4 followers
October 7, 2018
Legends is a wonderful 4th in this series!

I hate to blew it by including spoilers, but I am still crying over the little losses at the end of this story. I knew I was among friends while reading this charming story, but didn't know it was going to break my heart. Maybe you could add another story to this beautiful series??
Don't miss this delightful series and learn more about the Morgan's legend.
Profile Image for Mrs C E M Hicks.
73 reviews3 followers
June 11, 2018
Lov, Lies and Hocus Pocus book 4

I really enjoyed this book, it follows on from 1-3, so worth reading the previous ones to get to know the characters. I hope Sebastian & Lily return !
25 reviews
July 19, 2018
Fantastic Story Teller

I just finished the first four books in this series in a week and now I'm sad there aren't anymore out yet. Lydia is a fantastic story teller and I can't wait to see what's next!
Profile Image for Cameron.
38 reviews4 followers
September 4, 2023
I had an entire review written up on the app and then the whole app crashed so I've been unable to rewrite the whole thing but the bottom line is this...

This series was billed to me as an adult fantasy and it's just not. It's YA. There's nothing wrong with YA and I enjoy YA but there's something in this series that has really been bothering me. It's now been revealed that Lily's father has essentially drugged, r*ped, and impregnated like 20 different women. (I can't even remember exactly how many which is a problem.) This topic should either (a) only be included if it's going to be addressed and handled sensitively, or (b) not be included. In this case, the fact that I can't even remember how many victims there are is indicative of the fact that it's been really glossed over. The author hasn't even attempted to address it, I assume because this series is meant to be family friendly. If the series is written for a general audience including children, then this should NOT be a plot point.

There are still some things I like about this series, like the treatment of magic is interesting. Mostly, the writing is inexpert enough that it's distracting at times. But where I'm really getting lost is the plot with the father. I'm debating not finishing the series because it's so bad.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Eveie Hickman.
260 reviews1 follower
February 24, 2018
No time to savour this book had to read,so taken was I at the description of the fairy realm and the band of travellers wizards, witches cat and fox the the dynamics were for all to to see. Lily’s father as usual leaves it to lily to solve the mystery before taking the credit that being the misguided individual he was. But to overcome such odds and find love that is something else. I see another book in this series and I look forward to reading it.
Profile Image for Jolie.
642 reviews19 followers
April 24, 2018
Fun!!

These books are highly entertaining and (even better) not entirely predictable, which is rare. After a while most adventures seem to fall into patterns. I hope more of Lily and Sebastian's adventures are forthcoming! (Yes, Sir Kipling, yours as well.)
Profile Image for Lillian Mathews.
52 reviews1 follower
January 17, 2022
I liked the addition of the fae in this one but it seems to be dragging on with the "oh no they escaped again" plot. I get that is necessary for more books, but I wish there was another way the author could further the storyline.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Bonnie Dale Keck.
4,677 reviews58 followers
December 28, 2017
Kindle Unlimited A bit too well 'chick' for me personally here and there but reading them all so that speaks for itself or did when started reading them before 5 4 3 2 1 ratings.

Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: A Study In Mischief (A Lily Singer Adventures Novella) (The Lily Singer Adventures) {prequel, permafree?}}
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Beginnings (The Lily Singer Adventures, Book 1)
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Revelations (The Lily Singer Adventures, Book 2)
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Allies (The Lily Singer Adventures, Book 3)
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Legends (The Lily Singer Adventures, Book 4)

Suggest starting with prequel/book 0, then on to even more troubles between witches, wizards, and some that just can't stay out of trouble with 1 then on to this one with all that and she still just wants to read her book and sip her tea, but it's not going to happen, but then with this one you will see old friends, new friends, possible allies, and oh yeah a talking cat {obviously magical, and expert on jazz btw}. This third one the 'cutesy' ick factor started kicking in for me, not good; stick more to the story line and not so many side trips for different things, it's adding to the story length but not really the story line, especially the chick clothing talk that could have been condensed or totally almost left out other than a sentence or so, as it's supposed to be about the adventure not a day with chicks in the mall clothes shopping; get and/or use beta and arc readers, there are those issues plus the fae character being called that, by name, and 'it' so just no, don't be speciest and flip flopping back and forth in the timeline so bad either, the book could have been much tighter and much clearer and not as boring.

The last so far published and the last will ever read, as have been more and more redundant and repetitive, uninteresting, and what is up with the chick thing about clothes when supposedly the main character does not care about clothes {and doesn't own a pair of boots, as detailed in the last book but featured in this book's cover. although might have missed it in all the blah blah blah filler pages} and personally could care less about the chick 90210 angst going on. As to last minute plane tickets, out of Atlanta, not only would they have been expensive but as last minute buys they luggage would have not been prepaid so would have been minimum of $100 plus the overweight fee if they would even have accepted it on a flight going overseas. Regrading pets, for cats licensed veterinarian in the originating country must complete the non-commercial EU health certificate for England within 10 days of travel and must be accredited by the USDA and the non-commercial EU health certificate must be endorsed by the local USDA (United States) office unless the certificate is completed by a military Veterinary Corps Officer; forms must be endorsed by the government agency responsible for the import and export of animals, and you must sign Declaration of Non-Commercial Transport stating that your pet's transport does not involve the sale or transfer of ownership of your pet.And ahem saying that every few sentences is ahem annoying as is ah and uhm ad nauseum, and again get some beta or arc readers or listen to them. smf and it's really annoying to read how dim the inside is with one sentence then the next talk about huge windows everywhere, UH Huh? and doubly so for wondering why someone's grandmother would look older than someone's father, as they are all wizards but still duh as is libraries have rows and rows of books, some cases going up the ceiling. How can someone be said not to show emotion yet in no less than 3 or more places show emotion they never show, and how can epilogues be 1000+ pages. Yes, by the time this one was over, it was at 1.

The Lily Singer Adventures (4 Book Series), 4 set so can read back to back, and be less and less impressing and more and more bored.

Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: A Study In Mischief (A Lily Singer Adventures Novella) (The Lily Singer Adventures) {prequel, permafree?}}
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Beginnings (The Lily Singer Adventures, Book 1)
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Revelations (The Lily Singer Adventures, Book 2)
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Allies (The Lily Singer Adventures, Book 3)
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus: Legends (The Lily Singer Adventures, Book 4)
Profile Image for Steph Warren.
1,774 reviews39 followers
December 4, 2017
The stakes are up in this, the fourth installment of the adventures of Lily Singer (librarian wizard), Sebastian (rogue witch) and Sir Edgar Allen Kipling (talking cat and sarcastic supremo). Fans of previous novels will have seen the peril gradually increasing from localised hauntings and time slips, to the current full-on saving humanity from wizardly death or enslavement.

As the title suggests the enemy has also escalated, from generic curses and artefacts, through evil family members, to one of the most famous magic-users of legend. I was interested to see how Lydia Sherrer would handle Morgan le Fay in this series and this first introduction did not disappoint in terms of threat level or distinct personality.

Of course one of the main strengths in this series is the bonds between our main characters, and here also there is some nice development, along with even more lovable and/or unique side characters to add to the ever-growing cast of goodies (and even baddies) that I need to see more of.

I loved the development of the Fae side of the plot, with a bit more backstory about Sebastian and his magic. There is a lot of potential for further story in this enmeshment with the other realm, which I am quite excited about. Lily in England was fun too, as she was simultaneously out of her comfort zone, yet firmly amongst 'her people'!

To sum up, this is another great book for fans of light-hearted magical derring-do in a series that keeps getting better. Bring on Book 5!


Sebastian shrugged, giving her a silly grin. "Just excited, I suppose. I mean, come on, we're having an adventure. Anything could happen! Daring escapes from dastardly villains, life-and-death struggles with monstrous creatures, intrepid explorations of wild landscapes never before seen by the eyes of men__"

"You do realise we're going to England, right?" Lily asked dryly, smiling in spite of herself.

- Lydia Sherrer, Legends
Profile Image for Margie Martinson.
12 reviews2 followers
December 14, 2019
I honestly bought this book because I was in a Reading challenge at my public library and one of the challenges was to read a book set in your hometown. I was born in Atlanta and that is where Lily Singer, wizard and Library Archivist lives and works.
I read the book in two days and then over the next week finished the entire published series. And the next week finished the spinoff books.
The books are a simple and fun read and I am a pretty fast reader. The story is compelling and the the main characters are fun. What is a lot of fun is the dialogue between awkward Lily, charming Sebastian and Lily’s snarky talking cat (although he doesn’t start talking till book 2).
Having read all the books and the next one out in a month, I have done a reread and I’m busy developing my theories for Book 6. Clues are there and some red herrings. As I work on the theories, and check back though the books I have found more.
The books could be read stand alone, since explanations of the world are there, but that would only be half the fun.
I highly recommend. This series brings me back to the Harry Potter days of reading non stop, then going over the books with a fine toothed comb to figure out what was ahead, but in much shorter books.
I m so glad this was in my library challenge, since I most likely would not have bought the book to start with.
Profile Image for Jenn.
1,463 reviews26 followers
September 16, 2018
I want the next book yesterday

I guess my biggest complaint with this story and well the series is the lack of physical reminders. Like I know that Lily normally keeps her hair in a bun but not with sticks because she's afraid she'll hurt herself. What I don't remember because if it was mentioned it was never reiterated, is what color is Lily's hair? How long is it? What colors are their eyes? While I don't need the descriptions drilled into my mind the occasional reminder helps to keep the mental picture in my mind.

That said I've gotten used to the bookended point of view style of Sherrer's writing and appreciate that there are no longer massive time gaps between points of view. I love how she's finally brought us up close and personal with her leading characters as the series has progressed. I love how with each book the world continues to grow and include more characters but Sherrer takes the time to remind us of the older characters from other tales in the series by.mentioning them or including a small scene with them. Like with many series the danger was increased from the prior novel and this novels is even more of a page turner than the last. Definitely a great read.
Profile Image for Valerie.
1,392 reviews23 followers
January 16, 2021
I read this book for the ATY 2021 Reading Challenge Week 36: A book with 6 or more words in the title
I note that I have read two books for this challenge. Both are add-ons and both I read to calm my mind and my nerves. Escape fiction. Not deep philosophically challenging books that I am reading to improve my mind and understanding of the world, which is what the other books on my list are about. I even resolved that I would not add any new books until I had finished the books first put on the list. Oh well, I have to get up to 75 books read sometime.
I am enjoying this series. I like that it has magic and that wizards and witches can exist in a normal world with normal people and have normal problems. I like that there is a romance, but that the two people attracted to one another do not hop into bed and to pornography at the drop of a wand. BTW, there are no wands! In the third book, Lily and Sebastian are joined by more magical beings with the objective of finding the tomb and hibernating form of Morgan LeFay before Lily's dastardly father and his crew. Again, they win, but they aren't prepared for what happens next. And so we move on to another book. See you in a week or two, Lily!
Profile Image for Em.
20 reviews
August 28, 2024
I’m loving this series, this is a great one to have for rides to and from work and while you’re wrestling with your home chores (I’m talking about my nemesis, the litter box).
I’ve fallen in love with the characters and have been constantly engaged. I can get a bit distracted, so the author throwing in separate sections that show the characters side antics really amuse me.

Lily, the main character, is not the type of heroine I usually see in fantasy and magical realism books, and not who I think could be so badass. But oh boy, has she shown the different ways to be a boss ass bitch. And Sebastian is there too.

Would 10/10 recommend to a friend. Series starts out a lil boring, but gets intense and emotional. I miss these characters when I go back to real life.

Extra bonus points for not only a lovable, kitty sidekick, but a sassy kitty sidekick that talks.

My library only carries book 1-4 (booooooo!)
Profile Image for Kat Lebo.
858 reviews15 followers
August 6, 2020
Legends, Book #4 in the Love, Lies and Hocus Pocus series by Lydia Scherer.

Another rousing adventure for Lily Singer and her ever growing circle of friend, enemies, and freebies. Some issues are resolved; more are left wide open. Lily's relationship with Sebastian continues to evolve while her relationship with her father continues to devolve.

Pacing and flow are excellent. The plot is well crafted with lots of twists and turns. Characters, both new and old, are believable and relatable. I did find 3 proofing errors which, I believe we're all missing words. While the ending finds most of our heroes safe, it leaves too many issues unresolved, and seemed almost to end in the middle of the denouement, rather than a true end to the adventure. Not a cliffhanger, but too close for me.
Profile Image for Matthew McCready.
155 reviews
July 25, 2022
These books get better with each one. I don't like to give "book reports" where I recap the story, but instead prefer to give an overview and tell what it is like to a reader.

First and last, the romance grows. It is a funny romance, more like two 13 year olds. Strangely, however, Sebastian grows up more in this book.

The location is Oxford, England and the cliffs of Cornwall. Nice change, but it neither felt like the experience of a Brit or of a first time American Tourist. Parts of the adventure read more like a guide book or pamphlet.

Still, much more magic is revealed both higher more powerful magic and darker magic. None of it is unreasonable or quaint, however, like turning porcupines into pin cushions!

At the end of the day, the story isn't over. There is a lot left for several more books to answer.
Profile Image for Kate.
211 reviews9 followers
December 9, 2018
Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus is a series about Wizard Lily and her adventures to save the world with her frenemy-turned-best-friend-turned-possible-love-interest Witch Sebastian. I love the way these two interact and I flew through the 4 books.

I will say the little short stories that combine to make up the basis of Lily's magical experience were actually even more enjoyable than the later content that makes up the more defined plot. There was a brief section (I think in the middle of book 3? maybe book 4?) where the action slowed way down and there was some very detailed historically based background that was a little tough for me to get through - but the overall series was very much worth reading.
Profile Image for Beth Klein.
354 reviews1 follower
April 6, 2024
I enjoyed these books more as I went on to books 3&4. The characters and how Lily Singer grows and her relationships develop were enjoyable. Sir Edgar Allen Kipling the cat with magical talents may have been my favorite . Who doesn’t talk to their pets? If they made it into a movie /show I would watch. I love that there was a bit of “history” with King Arthur and his tales included and travel and books that take you along are always good . Altogether the first 4 books together I would give a 3.5 for fun.

. Perhaps written for a younger reader but it was a fun jaunt kind of like an old “Bewitched” episode. I would definitely recommend them for a preteen! I bought the first 4 books and 2 novellas as a package and I did read them all.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 146 reviews

Join the discussion

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.