When Evangeline is sent to live in a small mill town in Northern England as a schoolteacher in 1871, she finds herself struggling to fit in with an unfamiliar culture. Raised with the high-class Victorian values and ideals of a sophisticated upbringing, she is unprepared for the poverty she finds in the gritty factory town of Smeatley, where the locals speak with a hard-to-understand Yorkshire accent and struggle to thrive with few resources or opportunities.
Though she has no training as a teacher, she must prove herself successful before her grandfather will release her substantial inheritance to her and allow her to be reunited with her younger sister, the last remaining member of her family after a fever claimed the lives of her parents and brothers.
Evangeline's sudden change in circumstances is complicated when her aunt—a woman who values class distinctions more than her family relationships—forbids her from acknowledging any connection to her or to her grandfather, Mr. Farr—the man who owns nearly the entire town. For the first time in her life, Evangeline is truly alone.
Heartbroken, she turns to the one person in town who has shown her kindness—an Irish brick mason, Dermot, and his son, Ronan. Despite the difference in their classes and backgrounds, Evangeline and Dermot become friends, due in part to her ability to connect with Ronan, whose behavior requires special attention. The boy is uncomfortable around strangers and rarely even speaks to the other children in town. He often fixates on details other people ignore, and he adheres to specific, self-made rules that give his life order and structure; for example, Dermot's coat must be hung on a specific peg next to the door.
Evangeline attempts to prove herself a worthy teacher and earn the respect of her hard-to-understand students. Determined to find a way to introduce them to "proper English" while still honoring their unique language and culture, she enlists the help of a local family to write down familiar stories in the Yorkshire vernacular. Because of her efforts, the students and their families warm to Evangeline and she continues to look for ways to give the children a chance to become more than factory workers in the local cotton mill.
When the town learns of her upper-class status, Evangeline must work twice as hard to win back their trust--especially Dermot's. In the end, Evangeline and Dermot discover that, even though they come from different social spheres, together they can overcome social prejudices, make a positive difference in the lives of even the humblest people, and enjoy the strength that comes when two hearts find each other.
Ashes on the Moor is the inspiring love story of one Victorian woman's courage to fight against all odds, and the man whose quiet strength gives her the confidence to keep trying.
Ashes on the Moor is a great book for anyone who, like me, looooooves North and South, either the BBC production or the Elizabeth Gaskell novel it's based upon. I couldn't help picturing Dermot as Richard Armitage as I read. :) The setting, factory woes, even the emotion of the book...it all has echoes of North and South while also being its own original, heartwarming story, one I very much enjoyed. I especially appreciated Evangeline's character...watching her strengthen throughout the story and her resolve to do right by her students.
This book is evidence of just why I love this author's writing! Even though the tone in the beginning is despondent as Evangeline mourns her family and struggles with her new circumstances, it shows how much she grows and how time slowly heals. She does not seem particularly strong or skilled, but her compassion and newfound grit serve her well as she continues to make the best out of what she's been given. Dermot's surliness brings out her sassy side and I loved seeing their relationship develop from neighbors to unlikely friends to sweethearts. Each person in the wide cast of characters from the community are vibrant and easy to picture, and I especially enjoyed the Yorkshire way of speaking and their interesting phrases and names for things. The setting was very much a big part of the book and it felt a bit like one of my favorite movies, North and South. I liked that it was set in a smaller town though, which gave it a more cozy feel and less industrial. I have a soft spot for stories with teachers that care so much for their students, and Evangeline's determination to do the best for her students, despite her lack of training, is admirable and endearing. I was completely immersed from the get go and was happy that the initial mood of desperation slowly gave way to hope as Evangeline lifts herself with the help of Dermot and discovers her own fierce nature and strength.
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
.. This was a very heartbreaking Victorian era historical romance, set in England, written by Sarah M. Eden and narrated by Justine Eyre, Narrator. The heroine was a young lady who lost her entire family in one fell swoop. Her parents and brothers and died in an accident, leaving her and her sister alone. Her mother' sister invaded their lives and swept them away on the same day as their family's funeral, not allowing them to pack any personal items from their childhood home. All their personal and household items were stripped from them permanently.
The life of an impoverished schoolteacher is not one Evangeline Blake would have chosen for herself. Torn from her home and her beloved sister and sent to work in the gritty factory town of Smeatley, Evangeline must prove herself to her grandfather, a man who values self-reliance above all else, before he will grant her access to her inheritance. Raised to be a lady of refinement, she hasn't any of the skills necessary to manage on her own nor does she have the first idea how to be a teacher. But failure means never being with her sister again.
The aunt was a brute of a woman whose behavior was worse than the wicked witch of the west. She was a miserable excuse for a human being, bent on tormenting everyone around her, most especially her niece, Evangeline. She provided nothing physically, emotionally, or financially to help Evangeline when she banished her to the schoolhouse to become a teacher. Evangeline came from a loving, upper-crust family who suddenly finds herself having to walk while dragging her trunk of clothing to living quarters that were in deplorable condition and lacked essential items like a bed, food, and necessities.
Alone and overwhelmed, she turns to the one person in town who seems to know how she feels—Dermot McCormick, an Irish brick mason who is as far from home and as out of place as she is. Despite the difference in their classes and backgrounds, Evangeline and Dermot's tentative friendship deepens and grows. Her determination and compassion slowly earn her the faith and confidence of the skeptical residents of Smeatley, who become like the family she has lost.
Dermot McCormick's son has an emotional affliction very similar to one of Evangeline's deceased brothers. She is drawn to him and tutors him and he opens up to her like no one else, with the exception of his father. All the students make study progress, which helps raise her self-esteem.
This young woman worked tirelessly without any positive recognition from her Aunt, who constantly degraded and harassed her. She became a part of the community with the assistance of Dermot and worked with her students to accomplish great strides.
But when a secret from her past comes to light, Evangeline faces an impossible choice: seize the opportunity to reclaim her former life and rejoin her sister or fight for the new life she has struggled to build for herself—a life that includes Dermot.
Ashes on the Moor is the inspiring love story of one Victorian woman's courage to fight against all odds and the man whose quiet strength gives her the confidence to keep trying.
This is a clean and wholesome romance delivering an inspirational message of hope. Against all odds, a H.E.A. is built out of the Ashes on the Moor. .
I can't even imagine the amount of research that went into writing this one. Ms. Eden clearly spent a lot of time studying the time period and people and was able to write a story that easily transports you back to that time. As always, Ms. Eden is a great writer, is able to create well developed characters in compelling circumstances.
While it is a well written story, I just had a hard time connecting to it. I guess I prefer lighter novels, this was just too serious for me.
Which for a Sarah M Eden book is really really sad. I tend to love her books and trust that she'll give me a wonderful story, one that will make me laugh or make me cry. I've never had a book by her that wanted to make me tear my hair out with boredom until I encountered Ashes on the Moor. Makings of a great book, but for me, I not one I'd ever recommend. Such a shame.
This book is dreary, depressing, and dark. I honestly never connected with the main character, and never believed that she could overcome the challenges put against her. Her family was more than just mean or the villains; they had the control most of the time where the MC was just pawns in their hands. There was nothing positive about the first half of the book. I was bored and depressed. .
Until something happened, the grandfather appeared bringing light, something good for once in this melancholy novel. The clouds broke through the sky and there was hope. There was romance. There was challenges but I believed that the MC could overcome them again. It felt like I was reading a proper romance book, a book worthy of Eden's reputation. I enjoyed and consumed the latter half of the story. I give it 2.5 stars because it's not the worst book ever, there were elements I enjoyed, especially the last couple chapters. I
The first 200 pages are horrible monotonous drivel that left a reader hating every second. I quite literally did not want to read it. Why would I read something so droll, bleak, and disheartening? All I learned from this book was that working in a factory was something so terrifying, so hellish, that capitalism was of the devil and the drive of progress debilitating.
Eden's novel had the goal of education, of provoking thoughts and learning about them, like class distinctions and factory work conditions. The goal was missed. In fact, she shot the other direction. I learned that the dreary town hated everybody, the school teacher had no learning what so ever, nepotism ran amuck unchecked with detriment to the entire county. I even felt like the MC's sister was better off far away since the MC's life was so gloomy.
The MC's whole goal was to have her sister with her, yet I never felt that notion rang true. I was told it, rather than shown it. There was no memories with to share with the read of the two sisters, very little interaction with the character at the beginning. The plot would've been served better by establishing the grief of the loss of her family, rather than the rush of packing. It took me more than half the book to figure out what killed her family, a single word rushed past in the opening chapter, leading to confusion for the rest of the story.
Elements of reader-character connection lacked conviction, motifs were fumbled, and hard-hitting plot points overlooked. This felt like a first novel, with un-gleaned chances of exposition bumbled by an inexperienced author. It had the makings of an excellent book, with an underlying message of greed, inequality, and prejudice.
However, the mark was missed and instead the romance is barely there, the greed and inequality suffocates the reader, and prejudice runs foul of every character. This describes the first 200 something pages of exposition and rising action.
My largest complaint is that it never felt like a romance. A "proper romance" it proclaims on the cover. In fact, there was very little emotion from the Irishman, apathetic towards his so-called love interest. I would've taken a lot more hate and spitfire, than the shrugging half-hearted help. Their interactions held more of a student-teacher feel, than friendship or romance. There was no unresolved romantic/sexual tension until halfway through the book.
In short, the first 200 pages before the grandfather's visit need to be burned and rewritten because it is crap-tastic. The intent is there, but the execution left the reader with a foul taste, looking for something a little more lighthearted to wash out the mouth.
I really loved the atmospheric writing in this story. It tapped into much of the bleak mood associated with moors and life near them that's present in many classics, and that brought the late-Victorian feel of the story to life very effectively. Added to that, the heroine has just lost her family and everything she has ever known, getting dumped in a small country school to sink or swim as a gravely unqualified teacher.
I loved her pluck as she realizes she can't give up or give in, that she has to fight to gain a future. And before long she bonds with the local children, and she's ready to start fighting for them too.
I loved the banter between her and her neighbor, who's so clearly ready to take her down a notch or two but then ready also to help her learn how to survive.
The layers in the story kept me flipping pages and it was hard to put it aside to do anything else.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
It's always a happy day when a new book by Sarah Eden comes out. I am such a fan of her writing and her stories. She has a gift for weaving me right into her stories where I feel such a part of whatever emotion or activity that is going on and she does it so gently. I think that's one word I would always use to describe Sarah Eden's books. Gentle.
This story started off sad and a bit slow for me. It took me a bit to fall into the characters and feel like I was a part of them but it did happen about halfway through. By the end I was in love with Evangeline, Dermot and Ronan. I loved the glimpse into the history of the Yorkshire area, the struggles of the people and the very distinct Yorkshire accent. Evangeline, as a school teacher, kept saying that she didn't want to take their words away from them. I loved that too.
There was so much to love about this book. It was full and rich, gentle and endearing. Just what I would expect from Sarah Eden.
Content: clean
- I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.
This story is very inspiring as it progresses, but it definitely starts out somber. Right away, deep sympathy is felt for Evangeline and her situation. It's hard to imagine being thrust into an unfamiliar situation and expected to be successful, but she has good reasons to work hard and to figure out how to survive.
It's hard for me to picture how tough the times were for so many people during this time period. Eden paints a vivid portrayal of that. It's also tough to imagine families being so heartless.
Although this book is labeled as a romance, and a Proper Romance at that, the romance is very, very mild, gradual, and gentle. While the book does focus on some relationships, especially those of Evangeline and her Yorkshire students and of her and her Irish neighbor, Dermot, I thought most of the energy was concentrated on the language and teaching methods. This is a great historical fiction, especially for those who are interested in this area and time period.
The last line of the blurb sums this one up well--inspiring, courage, quiet strength, and confidence and all of those characteristics were gentle developed throughout the book.
Content: squeaky clean romance and content
*I received a copy from the publisher, which did not affect my opinion. All thoughts are my own.*
I couldn't wait this book to come out. I am a huge fan of Sarah Eden and I can't think of a book she's written that I didn't like. This one was no exception!
In Ashes on the Moor, we meet Evangeline Blake who has just lost her family. With only her sister left, she clings to her as they face an uncertain future with an aunt and uncle. But a cruel twist of fate separates them and throws Evangeline into circumstances that she's unprepared for. Forced to be the town's new schoolteacher and live in a humble home in need of a lot of care, Evangeline is lost and overwhelmed. The only person who shows her a bit of kindness is an Irishman named Dermot McCormick. He's also trying to figure out his place in the world since his heritage is looked down upon no matter what he does. But as Dermot and Evangeline build a friendship, stronger feelings flare and they must decide if love is worth fighting for.
I loved this book. It's not a light romance, but a look back in time when a woman had few choices and your birth and heritage could prevent you from having life's basic necessities. Ms. Eden has obviously done an incredible amount of research as the town of Smeatley with its Yorkshire residents comes to life, fairly jumping off the page. So many language, dress, and food details add to the amazing setting, giving the characters even more depth. Our heroine, Evangeline, will draw on all a reader's emotions as she deals with so many losses and has to keep picking herself up over and over. I wanted her to not only get her happily-ever-after, but to stand up and make a few people accountable for what they'd done! Dermot is also a character that will stay with you after the book is finished. He's suffered and risen above it, and all the while built a foundation of love and care for others, instead of bitterness as to his lot in life. He was the perfect match for Evangeline and their romance was a sweet, slow burn, that will give you all the feels. Definitely another one for my keeper shelf!
I think the best thing about Sarah Eden's books is that they aren't just stories, they are an experience. She pulls you into another time and place and takes you on an adventure that you won't soon forget!
This book suffered from a completely unbelievable plot. From the strange behavior of Mrs Barton to the unrealistic for the time period attitudes and ideas of Evangeline it just did not work for me. The characters were what ultimately made this work at all. Eden has a great ability to lead the reader to love and care for even less pleasant characters and really want everything to work out best for everyone.
I was so excited to get to read this new book by Sarah M. Eden. Firstly, I love the cover--it's gorgeous.
Evangeline and her 12 yr. old sister, Lucy, lost their parents and their brothers to a sudden illness. Right after the funeral they must leave the only home they've known to go to Yorkshire and are separated--Evangeline is to live in the small factory town of Smeatley as a schoolteacher and Lucy is sent to live with the grandfather they hardly know in Leeds. In order for Evangeline to have Lucy live with her she has to prove that she can keep a household (cleaning, cooking, manage money, etc) although she wasn't trained to do that as her family was quite well off. She also knows nothing of how to teach children.
The nearest neighbor to her is Dermot McCormick, an Irish brick mason who isn't quite accepted by all of the towns people. They have a rocky start but come to an arrangement of extra schooling for his son Ronan in exchange for cooking lessons for Evangeline. Their friendship grows slowly as they spend more time together. Evangeline is slowly accepted by the children she teaches and their parents until her relationship with her grandfather (Mr. Farr) and her Uncle and Aunt Barton comes to light. Then she has to decide if she wants to stay in Smeatley with Dermot and Ronan, or leave to live with Lucy and her grandfather in Leeds.
There are a lot of depressing scenes in the story because of the time period in which it's set--factory workers and those who lived off the land didn't have an easy life in the 1870's. They didn't have the safety precautions in the factories we have now, and illness or bad weather could wipe out a herd/flock or crop. But there are also instances of friendship and caring between neighbors as they helped each other in times of need or distress.
There were so many times I wanted to slap Aunt Barton and yell at her husband to do something instead of letting her trod all over him and have her way. The woman was miserable and made everyone around her miserable too, and I was so happy when he finally told her enough is enough. I can't imagine treating your sisters children the way Aunt Barton treated Evangeline and Lucy.
I felt so many things for Evangeline as she was left to drag/carry her trunk up to the schoolhouse by herself, find it in deplorable condition and attempt to get it ready for the children in just a few days time. She wasn't given the proper tools for cleaning and didn't even have a bed to sleep on. Luckily she had Dermot for a neighbor, who despite his prickliness, turned out to be a great blessing to her. Teaching her how to cook, and basically being the only friend she had for awhile.
I loved the scenes in the book with the children showing what they had learned even though Evangeline didn't teach them the way the school board supervisor said she should. She did what was best for her students to help them learn so they wouldn't have to work in the factory. I was relieved to find out why Aunt Barton was such a miserable woman--I wasn't satisfied with the answer but at least the author didn't leave me hanging wondering why she was so wretched a human being.
This is definitely a clean romance. Thanks to NetGalley for my eARC and the chance to review this book. All thoughts are my own and not influenced in any way.
Evangeline Blake's world is torn from her after the tragic death of her parents and brothers. She is forced to leave her home and accept the "benevolence" of her aunt and grandfather. Not all is as she was lead to believe it would be and her true character is tested as she is forced to deal with less than ideal circumstances.
I loved the growth of Evangeline in this book. She is compassionate, honorable, kind, and trustworthy. Her ultimate goal is to be reunited with her sister. To do that she must prove that she is capable. Fortunately, this lady of refinement meets an unlikely ally in the Irishman Dermot McCormick. He teaches her what she need to know to survive and they forge an alliance that helps them both.
I loved this glimpse into the impoverished life of the British countryside in 1871. The people try to survive everyday. Education has just been introduced for ever child to have access to. The divide between the wealthy and the poor is illustrated in stark contrast. In the middle of the story is a remarkable boy who we would now recognize as being on the autism spectrum. This is a wonderful story of a resilient people.
This is a clean book. I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
Evangeline has lost everyone in her immediate family except for her sister Lucy. But when their aunt comes to take them away from their upper class city home to a small factory town on the moor, she takes away even Lucy—who is sent off to boarding school. Evangeline is assigned the job of schoolmistress for a full class of students who have not had a day of education. And she, herself, has never taught a day in her life. Without her sister and with clear instructions not to tell anyone about her familial ties to her aunt and uncle, Evangeline is utterly on her own. And alone.
Except for her neighbor, Dermot, who is a working-class Irishman fighting to build his own future, raise an autistic boy on his own, and who tells her--on her very first day in town--that she is limited to one knock a day. Naturally, Evangeline knocks. She knocks because there is not so much as a blanket in her new quarters, and she knocks because she is hungry and because she does not know how to cook. And ultimately she knocks because Dermot’s son, Ronan, needs extra support and help with his studies. And, of course, she knocks because she wants to see Dermot.
Sarah M Eden’s Ashes on the Moor is a classic example of what I love about the author’s historical fiction. The novel and setting are well researched—the lives of the working class in a factory town depicted with their harshness, a strong sense of community, and humor. The dialogue is engaging. And the challenges Evangeline faces as a teacher, especially with regards to Ronan’s autism and to the challenge of helping her Welsh students learn to read “proper” English while also valuing their own native speech gives the book very real depth.
Ashes on the Moor is another beautiful story told by a brilliant author. I love Sarah Eden's books. She has an expert way of telling a story. The author created a perfectly subtle way of explaining the different dialects to the reader, all while keeping the story and characters flowing. The reader was learning Smeatley's way of speaking along with Evangeline. I appreciated that. I marveled at the detailed setting and the depth and growth of characters. Right away, the reader is caught up in the hardships of Evangeline and Lucy's sad beginning. I loved how Evangeline pulled herself up and did what had to be done. Dermot and Ronan were also delightful characters. Ronan had a special place in my heart. I absolutely loved this book.
This was so well done. This is not a light fluffy romance. There is so much depth to it.
I am a huge fan of the Hallmark Series When Calls the Heart. In many ways, this reminds me of that TV series but there are also many differences. Evangeline is not a teacher by choice and she has had everything taken away from her. She had no choice but to make the best of the hand life has dealt her. Times were not easy and everything seems stacked against her and Dermot but both of them have strong wills and are willing to fight for what they want. Through their trials and struggles, we see a beautiful relationship develop.
A wonderfully done historical romance that kept me engrossed in the story until the very last page.
Evangeline Black has lost everyone in her family except her younger sister Lucy. She has to prove that she worthy of her inheritance, but that means her sister is sent to Leeds. Evangeline is sent to Smeatley, in Yorkshire. She is supposed to teach the local children even though she has no prior experience, and show that she is able to win their acceptance through hard work, determination, and a willingness to learn their dialect which isn't easy at first.
I really enjoyed how Evangeline learned to stand up for herself though it wasn't easy, especially with her Aunt Barton. Her friendship with Dermot was sweet, and her understanding of his son because her brother George was similar, but she fostered a wonderful relationship with him. This was a really satisfying story.
Sarah Eden books are a bit of a mixed bag for me. But when she shines, man does she shine bright! This story was pitch perfect IMHO. It could be because the historical setting and situations are so spot-on true to history, it could be that I felt an even closer affinity to the FMC because my own grandmother experienced much of the same in her own life, and it is most definitely because of the rich emotional connection this author is able to establish with both the characters and the town they live in. The story absolutely grabs you, wrenches your heart, then heals it all in one lovely, touching read.
I loved this book! Though the plot is based on tragedy, it's a delight to read how Evangeline pulls through and stays strong despite the setbacks. And a very sweet romance as well!
If you’re looking for a Regency romance with complex characters, an intriguing story line, a well developed and inviting setting, and a happy ending, look no further! You will not only cheer for Evangeline and Dermot’s happy ending, but also root for them as they work together to overcome the obstacles life throws in their path. *happiest of sighs*
I've previously stated that I was done with this author. The works that I've read by her (with the exception of The Sheriffs of Savage Wells, which was wonderful) have been flops for me. However, I saw that she'd published a new book, the library system had it for me to borrow, and here we are. Again. Me having read a book by Ms. Eden and having yet another middling experience.
Now I'm not saying that there wasn't anything good about this book. Far from it! A 2.5 star rating from me means that this book was solidly in the "all right" category. There was a lot to like: both MCs who overcome some pretty dire circumstances, a sweet slow burn romance, and the subject of regional prejudice. There was very little mention of God, which I was fine with, because there was a chasteness and restraint that I appreciate, especially given the societal norm regarding physical intimacy nowadays. There was also the kindness shown to people, regardless of social class, that was nice.
However the beginning of this book was overwhelmingly sad to the point of depressing, and it was hard to dig my way out after that. The powerlessness of young, unmarried, and orphaned women during Victorian times was not something that I particularly enjoyed. And the villain(ess) of this story was too one dimensional to be believable.
Also, the way in which the author dealt with the issue of regional prejudice with her use of the Yorkshire dialect also detracted from the overall flow of the story. The dialect was not easy to read/understand, which may have been the author's entire point, but the constant thinking about learning the dialect, teaching around the dialect, embracing the dialect, was boring. Overall, I really do think I've read my last Sarah Eden novel this time. I love what she's trying to do, but the execution almost always falls short for me to entirely enjoy the experience.
I'm not sure how to express how much I adored this book! From a history lover's perspective, it was so well researched and the little details really suck you in to the time period. The author did such a phenomenal job with character development and you can't really help but cheer as the heroine finds her strength and independence. The hero is such a kind and caring gentleman that you can't help but fall in love with him either. Plus its all set against a brilliantly written back drop of class struggle, small town drama, and each character's failures and triumphs along the way. This book is everything a historical romance should be!
This story is very inspiring as it progresses, but it definitely starts out on the somber side. Right away, deep sympathy is felt for Evangeline and her situation. It's hard to imagine being thrust into an unfamiliar situation and expected to be successful, but she has good reasons to work hard and to figure out how to survive.
It's hard for me to picture how tough the times were for so many people during this time period. Eden paints a vivid and (what I consider to be) an accurate portrayal of that. It's also tough to imagine families being so heartless.
The romance is very, very mild, gradual, and gentle. While the book does focus on some relationships, especially those of Evangeline and her Yorkshire students and of her and her Irish neighbor, Dermot, there is a beautiful energy concentrated on the language and teaching methods. This is a fantastic historical fiction piece, especially for those who are interested in this area and time period.
The epilogue in this collector’s edition is everything. I was completely satisfied as everything tied together so well, including my emotions.
Content: very mild romance
*I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and were voluntarily given*
I so enjoy Eden's writing style. You get very complex situations. It's almost always like a fairytale where the characters are in deep sadness and bad situations and they find the strength to pull themselves out of it. She has two kinds of books, the light hearted and the tug your heartstrings out kind of books. This was a sadder beginning that turns out happy. The attention to detail and history in this book was very well done. You really feel like you are there and can almost smell it. The characters relationships with themselves and others grow slowly and take time. I also love that there is realism in the fairy-tale, not everything is tied up nicely with a bow at the end. These could have been real people. This is a PG book with no violence or content.
3.75 stars Audio version-Audible Plus selection narrator-Justine Eyre
My first book by Sarah M. Eden, known for her "clean" historical romances. I'll admit, I was initially drawn to the beautiful cover and the hint that it had elements of "North and South". I really did enjoy the book for the most part...very likable MC. However, I think it was the over the top, evil aunt that knocked this down a bit for me. A few other loose ends also affected my rating. That said, I will not hesitate to read more from Sarah Eden. Her books may be labeled clean, but they don't lack for romance and they are not preachy.
Well I listened to it in one day, stayed up until 1am...when I normally go to bed at 9 😂 This book hurt me but it was so good! Such good messages in it and of course the romance was sweet!
This why Sarah is one of my go to authors. She writes in a way to connect you with the characters and the storyline. I felt like I was in Yorkshire and feeling the frustration Evangeline dealt with. Her books definitely have earned a place on my bookshelf.
A young English lady is forced by her Aunt to take a teaching position in a small town to prove her ability to take care of herself so she can get custody of her younger sister. She comes from a family of wealth, but her grandfather has control of her inheritance so she must prove she is capable of caring for her. Romance comes along with a stonemason who helps her learn some of what will make her independent. Quick read and keeps your attention.
After the loss of nearly her entire family, Evangeline ends up teaching in a Yorkshire town where there has been no school for a long time. Although the author’s anchors in real time require that the book be set in the 1870s, there are clear echoes of Gaskell here, and the characters feel like they come from an earlier era. Our hero Dermot is an Irish transplant with an autistic son who, despite being grumpy, teaches the gently raised Evangeline to cook and dispenses philosophy as well, and to my mind is based on Brendan Bestillmyheart Coyle in North and South or Lark Rise to Candleford, he is quite likeable but a bit overly perfect.
The insta-teacher stuff bothering me wavered in the middle, with scenes more realistic like Evangeline’s students arguing about the necessity of learning and having tussles, or her concerns over whether she is teaching them very well since she’d never attended school herself. By the end, though, she was the miracle teacher with no training, guided by her deep love of “her children” and the ending seems like a veiled reference to school vouchers, startlingly. Evangeline is stated to have been raised to be a lady with lots of rules, so we can be affectionate for her despite Eden’s usual “women submit, men lead” plot - and here Evangeline differs by being unsubmissive by the end, and Dermot proud of her in a period-unlikely manner. The Horrible Aunt is given a backstory that seems unnecessary since her character is flat, and Evangeline’s grief for her family seems unrealistically quick to heal. Still three stars but I guess I shouldn’t read so many tame romances in a row, they invariably are based in moral and political universes I disagree with.
Yeah, I’ll still imagine Brendan Coyle as Dermot saying “Keep eyeing these, lads, I’ve a woman to greet, and I mean to do it well” though, and melt a little.
I am a huge fan of Sarah Eden's books! She has dozens of bestselling and award-winning titles and I've almost read all of them. This new book is another addition to the Proper Romance line and I couldn't wait to read it! The cover is absolutely stunning and Eden's words pulled me completely into northern England and the city of Yorkshire. This book quickly became a favorite because I was reminded of my own visit to northern England and the incredible town of Yorkshire twenty years ago. Isn't it wonderful that we can take a visit through the pages of a book?
Ashes on the Moor is set in Victorian England when factories were starting to change the landscape and socioeconomic paths of the English. The character of Evangeline is stoic, maddeningly ladylike, courageous, and romantic. I loved seeing the change that took place in Evangeline when she was forced to live on her own and do things she'd never attempted before--like cooking!
The romance that developed between Evangeline and Dermot was layered beautifully and grew slowly, yet at a satisfying pace. If you enjoy great writing, historical romance, clean romance, then you should definitely consider adding this book to your To-Read list!