Booklist March 1, 2004 (Vol. 100, No. 13)
K-Gr. 3. Irving and Muktuk, the nefarious polar bears last seen in Two Bad Bears (2001), have been sent to a zoo in Bayonne, New Jersey, as punishment for transgressions in their Alaskan town. At the zoo, they meet the resident polar bear, Roy, who has his own apartment and clocks out of the zoo every night after it closes. Since they aren't to be trusted, Irving and Muktuk have to stay in their apartment in the zoo, but they soon grow bored and escape, disguised as rakishly capped figures. Their objective is the nearby muffin factory (muffins are a passion), but they are discovered and forced back to the zoo. It is unlikely, however, given the looks on their faces on the final page, that they are on the way to muffin rehabilitation. The droll, understated text and Jill Pinkwater's simple, expressive, marker-and-ink illustrations perfectly capture the cheekiness of this story of bears gone bad and proud of it.
Horn Book Fall 2004
In the latest Irving and Muktuk installment, the muffin-loving polar bears are shipped to the Bayonne, New Jersey, zoo with a note that they aren't to be trusted. In this droll but unfocused story, the bears sneak off to visit a polar bear who leaves the zoo each night for his own apartment. The ink and felt-tip illustrations are agreeable if repetitive.
Kirkus Reviews February 15, 2004
Welcome back the Pinkwaters' Irving and Muktuk, two mischief-making polar bears with a muffin fixation. Here they're sent, in chains, to a zoo in New Jersey that happens to be adjacent to a muffin factory (karmic coincidence). Their mate in the zoo is Roy, a time-clock-punching polar bear with his own apartment. Irving and Muktuk, with their muffin-absconding rap sheet, aren't afforded such latitude. Not to mention, notes Roy, "they are afraid you might eat people." As if struck by lightning, they ask, "You can eat people?" Roy replies, "Don't even think about it." Loose cannons, Irving and Muktuk stage a zoo-break, joining a tour of the muffin factory to satisfy their craving. They're nabbed when found sleeping in the frozen-pea section of a nearby supermarket. The spare line drawings perfectly capture these strange, gratifying bears-two ursines who are always a step west of our expectations. (Picture book. 4-8)
Library Media Connection November/December 2004
Irving and Muktuk are on their way to the big city from Yellowtooth. Well, to the big city zoo. They arrive, not in a box or a crate, but rather they amble down the stairs with the other passengers. The zookeeper does not see them, even though they are rather large polar bears wearing handcuffs and chains. A letter from Officer Bunny of Yellowtooth accompanies the bears. He writes, "These bears are not to be trusted." They notice right away that next to the zoo is a very large muffin factory. Irving and Muktuk meet Roy, who shows them the ropes of living and working at the zoo. Roy doesn't live at the zoo; he has his own apartment. Roy tells them they can't have their own apartment because the zoo director thinks they are going to eat people. All they really want are more muffins. The zoo is closed on Mondays and Irving and Muktuk decide to escape. They manage to go on a tour of the muffin factory with some children. Only at the very end does anyone discover that they are bears (because they are eating all the muffins!) The illustrations are cheerful and happy, capturing the personality of the bears. Irving and Muktuk will appeal to all who love animal fun. Recommended. Ruie Chehak, Library Media Specialist, Sallie Jones Elementary School, Punta Gorda, Florida
Publishers Weekly February 16, 2004
Bad Bears in the Big City: An Irving and Muktuk Story by Daniel Pinkwater, illus. by Jill Pinkwater, finds the muffin-thieving polar bears sent in shackles from their home in Yellowtooth to the Bayonne, N.J., zoo. A note from Yellowtooth's Officer Bunny ("We hope you enjoy our bears. Remember, they are not to be trusted!") ensures that the bears are confined to the zoo, but the muffin factory next door provides too great a temptation. Copyright 2004 Reed Business Information.
School Library Journal April 1, 2004
PreS-Gr 3-In this zany sequel to the Pinkwaters' Irving and Muktuk: Two Bad Bears (Houghton, 2001), the incorrigible, muffin-loving polar bears are sent to a zoo in Bayonne, NJ, along with a letter stating that they are not to be trusted. Craving their favorite food, they make plans to break into the muffin factory next door. Using their pillows and blankets to make an ingenious disguise, they sneak into the building with a school tour group. When they are discovered, they run and hide in the freezer section of a local supermarket. Roy, a better-behaved polar bear, finds them and returns them to the zoo. This book mentions but does not explain the pair's muffin-stealing past and will make the most sense to readers who are familiar with its predecessor. The lighthearted cartoons reflect the mood of the humorous text. The pure white bears drawn with thin, free black outlines contrast with the backgrounds, which are often illustrated with bright complementary colors. Pinkwater's many fans will enjoy the further adventures of these mischievous creatures.-Donna Cardon, Provo City Library, UT Copyright 2004 Reed Business Information.