What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lacemaker
Lady Elisabeth "Liberty" Lawson has nearly everything a lady of her position could want. Daughter of the British lieutenant governor of the Virginia Colony and a darling of fine society in a rugged land, she is anticipating an advantageous marriage. That her betrothed is a rake and love is lacking is of little consequence—or so she tells herself.
Though her own life seems in order, colonial Williamsburg is a powder keg on the verge of exploding, and her fiancé's cousin Noble Rynallt carries the flame of revolution in his heart. Those with connections to the British nobility are suspected as spies, and Liberty soon finds herself left with a terrible choice. Will she stay true to her English roots? Or side with Noble and the radical revolutionaries?
Though her own life seems in order, colonial Williamsburg is a powder keg on the verge of exploding, and her fiancé's cousin Noble Rynallt carries the flame of revolution in his heart. Those with connections to the British nobility are suspected as spies, and Liberty soon finds herself left with a terrible choice. Will she stay true to her English roots? Or side with Noble and the radical revolutionaries?
413 pages, Paperback
First published January 2, 2018
708 people are currently reading
4508 people want to read
About the author
Laura Frantz
21 books2,762 followersLaura Frantz is passionate about all things historical, particularly the 18th-century, and writes her manuscripts in longhand first. Her stories often incorporate Scottish themes that reflect her family heritage. She is a direct descendant of George Hume, Wedderburn Castle, Berwickshire, Scotland, who was exiled to the American colonies for his role in the Jacobite Rebellion of 1715, settled in Virginia, and is credited with teaching George Washington surveying in the years 1748-1750. Frantz lives and writes in a log cabin in the heart of Kentucky.According to Publishers Weekly, "Frantz has done her historical homework." With her signature attention to historical detail and emotional depth, she is represented by Janet Kobobel Grant, Literary Agent & Founder, Books & Such Literary Agency of Santa Rosa, California.Readers can find Laura Frantz at www.laurafrantz.net.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 731 reviews
January 10, 2018
What drew you to this book? Was it the cover,the synopsis,the author,the reviews? For me it was all of them. Just when you say to yourself that you've read all of Laura Frantz's books and they were excellent and she couldn't possibly do it again she takes the Christian fiction world by storm and turns out another masterpiece! Lacemaker Lady Elisabeth "Liberty" Lawson has been making lace since she was five years old. Her world has been turned upside down with her fiance turning his back on her and she is suspected of being a spy for the British. She lives in colonial Williamsburg and the author created characters so lifelike I felt I was part of their life. I was not very familiar with the colonial time period but the author makes sure you get a wonderful historical dose of it and I learned so much. I love entertaining books like this that are historically factual but not dry and boring.
We are treated to swoonworthy Noble who comes to her aid. Don't you just love that name? He says Welsh endearments to her and she and her French maid eat Welsh food. Some of the recipes for this food are actually included too.
This is a definite reread book for sure!
Pub Date 02 Jan 2018
Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
We are treated to swoonworthy Noble who comes to her aid. Don't you just love that name? He says Welsh endearments to her and she and her French maid eat Welsh food. Some of the recipes for this food are actually included too.
This is a definite reread book for sure!
Pub Date 02 Jan 2018
Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
January 2, 2018
The Lacemaker by Laura Frantz brings to mind words that I don’t use in ordinary conversation – decadent, sumptuous, exhilarating – decadent romance, sumptuous historical detail, and exhilarating events captured my imagination with ease. In previous books, Frantz has proven that she has a strong knowledge of frontier life, with all the dangers and beauty that come with it. In this story, she takes on the time leading up to the American Revolution, bringing readers to colonial Williamsburg, Virginia, an exciting and tumultuous place for would-be patriots. As the daughter of the ousted British Governor, Lady Elisabeth Lawson, abandoned by both family and fiancé, knows that her ties with the British make her suspect to anyone who support revolution - everyone, that is, except for Noble Rynallt. Using her skills as a lacemaker to survive, she comes to realize that not taking a side could pose the greatest risk of all.
Liberty, as Elisabeth comes to call herself, is an endearing character. She feels like a lady of her time, however, as it was such a time of upheaval, she also rises to the occasion. Her actions still felt realistic and in keeping with the time period and what would have been an acceptable trade for a woman at that time. I appreciate the fact that she doesn’t feel like a modern woman placed in a historical setting. She feels organic and is firmly placed in the setting of colonial Virginia, which she clearly feels is her home.
Then there’s Noble Rynallt. Normally, such a name might give me pause, but it truly does fit him. He is both a gentleman and a Patriot, and I love how his character demonstrated the great sacrifice that they made for the revolution. It’s hard to envision men with families and homes, often very near the epicenter of their activities, and how this must have been such conflicting priorities for them. The fact that Welsh endearments are part of the story might also have a little something to do with his appeal. The fact that he and “Libby,” as he calls Elisabeth, both play roles in their sphere of the revolution is one of the most exciting parts of the story. Again, Liberty’s part in it feels realistic; her weapons and be silk dresses and upswept curls, but the consequences of discovery are just as dangerous for her as they would be for any Independence Man.
I truly did feel immersed in the world of this story. The historical details and the time period come to life. The plot is steady, pinpointed by moments of surprises both dangerous and delightful – once I hit the halfway mark, I could hardly put it down. I love how Frantz writes from the perspectives of both Liberty and Noble. It gives the story an added layer of complexity and made their relationship progression that much sweeter. Quietly steadfast and straightforward with his intentions, Noble Rynallt is everything a gentleman could be. Not to be overlooked, the faith element is never preachy but deeply rooted within the words and actions of the characters. Liberty’s decision to trust God no matter how dark the times may seem touched this reader’s heart. As this new year begins, I hope to remember Libby’s words in the face of adversity: “God goes with me. There’s no better escort.”
The Lacemaker is filled to the brim with history and romance and faith-affirming characters. It has earned a place on my favorites list, and I highly recommend it to fans of historical romance.
Liberty, as Elisabeth comes to call herself, is an endearing character. She feels like a lady of her time, however, as it was such a time of upheaval, she also rises to the occasion. Her actions still felt realistic and in keeping with the time period and what would have been an acceptable trade for a woman at that time. I appreciate the fact that she doesn’t feel like a modern woman placed in a historical setting. She feels organic and is firmly placed in the setting of colonial Virginia, which she clearly feels is her home.
Then there’s Noble Rynallt. Normally, such a name might give me pause, but it truly does fit him. He is both a gentleman and a Patriot, and I love how his character demonstrated the great sacrifice that they made for the revolution. It’s hard to envision men with families and homes, often very near the epicenter of their activities, and how this must have been such conflicting priorities for them. The fact that Welsh endearments are part of the story might also have a little something to do with his appeal. The fact that he and “Libby,” as he calls Elisabeth, both play roles in their sphere of the revolution is one of the most exciting parts of the story. Again, Liberty’s part in it feels realistic; her weapons and be silk dresses and upswept curls, but the consequences of discovery are just as dangerous for her as they would be for any Independence Man.
I truly did feel immersed in the world of this story. The historical details and the time period come to life. The plot is steady, pinpointed by moments of surprises both dangerous and delightful – once I hit the halfway mark, I could hardly put it down. I love how Frantz writes from the perspectives of both Liberty and Noble. It gives the story an added layer of complexity and made their relationship progression that much sweeter. Quietly steadfast and straightforward with his intentions, Noble Rynallt is everything a gentleman could be. Not to be overlooked, the faith element is never preachy but deeply rooted within the words and actions of the characters. Liberty’s decision to trust God no matter how dark the times may seem touched this reader’s heart. As this new year begins, I hope to remember Libby’s words in the face of adversity: “God goes with me. There’s no better escort.”
The Lacemaker is filled to the brim with history and romance and faith-affirming characters. It has earned a place on my favorites list, and I highly recommend it to fans of historical romance.
January 8, 2018
Could. not. stop. reading.
I loooooove Laura Frantz's writing and The Lacemaker reminded me why...it just so completely transports me. It's gorgeous and lilting and perfect. I loved watching Elisabeth / Liberty transform in this story. I found myself inwardly cheering for her as she grew in strength and resolve. And Noble...one of the best heroes I've read in a long time. The two things I loved most about him: How important hospitality, especially to people in need, is to him...and his sacrificial show of love. Yup I cried. Plus, I loved the pace of The Lacemaker...it clipped along so nicely, kept me turning page after page, and yet, it never rushed. Loved the history, loved the emotion, loved the whole thing!
I loooooove Laura Frantz's writing and The Lacemaker reminded me why...it just so completely transports me. It's gorgeous and lilting and perfect. I loved watching Elisabeth / Liberty transform in this story. I found myself inwardly cheering for her as she grew in strength and resolve. And Noble...one of the best heroes I've read in a long time. The two things I loved most about him: How important hospitality, especially to people in need, is to him...and his sacrificial show of love. Yup I cried. Plus, I loved the pace of The Lacemaker...it clipped along so nicely, kept me turning page after page, and yet, it never rushed. Loved the history, loved the emotion, loved the whole thing!
November 30, 2021
¿Se puede empezar una reseña con un ME HA ENCANTADO? ¿Es legitimo hacerlo? O, ¿es mejor dejarlo para el final?
🌸Si me hicieras estas preguntas a mí no sé qué te respondería, salvo quizá un "tal vez" o un "puede ser". Dos expresiones que me servirían para dar rienda suelta a todas aquellas sensaciones que me han embargado durante la lectura de esta maravillosa historia.
📍AMOR.
📍ALEGRÍA.
📍PASIÓN.
📍SUFRIMIENTO.
📍DESESPERACIÓN.
🌸Y, es que, seamos sinceros, cuando pasas la última página del libro que estás leyendo con una sensación de tristeza porque la historia ha llegado a su fin, es que te has enamorado de sus personajes y quieres más. Mucho más. Quieres volver a experimentar todas los sentimientos que aún perduran en tu interior: calidez, pasión, alegría... y enamorarte otra vez.
🌸Descubrir a esta autora ha sido una verdadera GOZADA en mayúsculas. Tanto que agradezco enormemente a @librosdesedaeditorial el envío del ejemplar y el haber podido así leer esta historia tan bonita y romántica.
🌸Si me hicieras estas preguntas a mí no sé qué te respondería, salvo quizá un "tal vez" o un "puede ser". Dos expresiones que me servirían para dar rienda suelta a todas aquellas sensaciones que me han embargado durante la lectura de esta maravillosa historia.
📍AMOR.
📍ALEGRÍA.
📍PASIÓN.
📍SUFRIMIENTO.
📍DESESPERACIÓN.
🌸Y, es que, seamos sinceros, cuando pasas la última página del libro que estás leyendo con una sensación de tristeza porque la historia ha llegado a su fin, es que te has enamorado de sus personajes y quieres más. Mucho más. Quieres volver a experimentar todas los sentimientos que aún perduran en tu interior: calidez, pasión, alegría... y enamorarte otra vez.
🌸Descubrir a esta autora ha sido una verdadera GOZADA en mayúsculas. Tanto que agradezco enormemente a @librosdesedaeditorial el envío del ejemplar y el haber podido así leer esta historia tan bonita y romántica.
March 5, 2022
Mixed feelings, y'all. I enjoyed most of this book; but the second half ran into the shallows and couldn't seem to get out. *sigh*
What I liked:
- A+++ worldbuilding. I seriously mean that. The author did a fantastic job making Revolution-era Williamsburg feel real and lush and tangible--which, let's be honest, I hardly ever feel when I read because most literary description leaves me cold. I'm infamously picky about this stuff :-P Trust me when I say this one was good. Sunsets, flowers, scents, clothing, tools, AND LET'S NOT FORGET THE FOOD--I could see/smell/taste alllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll of it. Beautifully done. I only wish more historical fiction writers could live up to this standard.
- The early stages of Noble and Liberty's romance had really strong & palpable tension, without going over-the-top, and that's not an easy balance to strike. They were adorable. I was shipping them HARD. Until . . .
What I Didn't Like:
- The romantic chemistry just . . . dropped off, suddenly, at about the 65-70% mark, and never recovered? And there's no excuse for that. ESPECIALLY NOT WHEN THE FIRST PART WAS SO VIVID. I know the author is capable of better than this because she SHOWED me better--so what's going on???
- More specifically: Liberty pulled a very sudden "Oh, I hardly know this man!" around the time of their wedding; causing me to facepalm with no little severity. Look, I get shyness & awkwardness & fear of intimacy and all that, except . . . it didn't make any sense in this case? Because they had ALREADY spent the lion's share of the book on a footing of considerable [not to mention historically-inaccurate-for-their-time-period-and-social-station] romantic intimacy! He literally came into her bedroom at one point when she was still asleep and called her Welsh terms of endearment, and then she woke up & smiled at him & was totally chill with it?!? You understand that is wildly inappropriate for a genteel Colonial unmarried couple, right--and yet you don't mind because "you trust him" or whatever--which is FINE, I guess, but then DON'T come at me with this "OH NO I'M MARRYING A MAN I BARELY KNOW" nonsense. 'Cause you ain't. You ain't marrying a man you barely know. Don't talk to me. I'm annoyed now. :-P
- I signed up for slightly steamy romance, not manufactured dumb angst. Give me what I signed up for, okay?
- Liberty and Noble both seemed slightly cookie-cutter-ish to me, in terms of personality and reactions and so on. Idk, I felt like I was reading about people I'd seen one too many times before.
She's the Dainty Lady Who Learns To Do Hard Things. He's the Responsible and Mature yet Brooding Hero With a Dark Past. [Which dark past wasn't really discussed, actually??? I expected him & Libby to at least talk about it once . . . they didn't? Why?] Also, she's small & blonde while he's tall & swarthy. Helpppppppppppppppppppp.
- Their names seriously irked me, okay??? "Noble" . . . I mean, even for a Puritan that'd be way too on-the-nose; and the guy's NOT a Puritan. He's a Welsh Presbyterian from a family with all-Celtic names. Why does he alone get to be "Noble"? And "Liberty"? That name was supposed to be a big sticking point between her Tory father and her Patriot-sympathizing mother . . . except that Liberty, by my calculation, was born in 1755, in the middle of the Seven Years' War, at the very height of colonial loyalty to Britain and well before any sort of agitation for independence. (I'm not a specialist in colonial history, so feel free to correct me if I'm wrong; but I don't think I'm wrong.)
- Liberty's spying operations didn't seem very well integrated into the plot . . . I expected her to discover something impactful & momentous which would create conflict and drive events; but it never happened.
- Two characters became rather important villains with basically NO development or explanation of "why." This bothered me.
- The climax left me cold. I know I was supposed to be super worried that they wouldn't make it out okay, but I just wasn't.
Overall? I have mad envy for this author's worldbuilding skills but I just wasn't satisfied by the romance. If you enjoy Colonial-era historical fiction in general, though, you might have fun with this book.
What I liked:
- A+++ worldbuilding. I seriously mean that. The author did a fantastic job making Revolution-era Williamsburg feel real and lush and tangible--which, let's be honest, I hardly ever feel when I read because most literary description leaves me cold. I'm infamously picky about this stuff :-P Trust me when I say this one was good. Sunsets, flowers, scents, clothing, tools, AND LET'S NOT FORGET THE FOOD--I could see/smell/taste alllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll of it. Beautifully done. I only wish more historical fiction writers could live up to this standard.
- The early stages of Noble and Liberty's romance had really strong & palpable tension, without going over-the-top, and that's not an easy balance to strike. They were adorable. I was shipping them HARD. Until . . .
What I Didn't Like:
- The romantic chemistry just . . . dropped off, suddenly, at about the 65-70% mark, and never recovered? And there's no excuse for that. ESPECIALLY NOT WHEN THE FIRST PART WAS SO VIVID. I know the author is capable of better than this because she SHOWED me better--so what's going on???
- More specifically: Liberty pulled a very sudden "Oh, I hardly know this man!" around the time of their wedding; causing me to facepalm with no little severity. Look, I get shyness & awkwardness & fear of intimacy and all that, except . . . it didn't make any sense in this case? Because they had ALREADY spent the lion's share of the book on a footing of considerable [not to mention historically-inaccurate-for-their-time-period-and-social-station] romantic intimacy! He literally came into her bedroom at one point when she was still asleep and called her Welsh terms of endearment, and then she woke up & smiled at him & was totally chill with it?!? You understand that is wildly inappropriate for a genteel Colonial unmarried couple, right--and yet you don't mind because "you trust him" or whatever--which is FINE, I guess, but then DON'T come at me with this "OH NO I'M MARRYING A MAN I BARELY KNOW" nonsense. 'Cause you ain't. You ain't marrying a man you barely know. Don't talk to me. I'm annoyed now. :-P
- I signed up for slightly steamy romance, not manufactured dumb angst. Give me what I signed up for, okay?
- Liberty and Noble both seemed slightly cookie-cutter-ish to me, in terms of personality and reactions and so on. Idk, I felt like I was reading about people I'd seen one too many times before.
She's the Dainty Lady Who Learns To Do Hard Things. He's the Responsible and Mature yet Brooding Hero With a Dark Past. [Which dark past wasn't really discussed, actually??? I expected him & Libby to at least talk about it once . . . they didn't? Why?] Also, she's small & blonde while he's tall & swarthy. Helpppppppppppppppppppp.
- Their names seriously irked me, okay??? "Noble" . . . I mean, even for a Puritan that'd be way too on-the-nose; and the guy's NOT a Puritan. He's a Welsh Presbyterian from a family with all-Celtic names. Why does he alone get to be "Noble"? And "Liberty"? That name was supposed to be a big sticking point between her Tory father and her Patriot-sympathizing mother . . . except that Liberty, by my calculation, was born in 1755, in the middle of the Seven Years' War, at the very height of colonial loyalty to Britain and well before any sort of agitation for independence. (I'm not a specialist in colonial history, so feel free to correct me if I'm wrong; but I don't think I'm wrong.)
- Liberty's spying operations didn't seem very well integrated into the plot . . . I expected her to discover something impactful & momentous which would create conflict and drive events; but it never happened.
- Two characters became rather important villains with basically NO development or explanation of "why." This bothered me.
- The climax left me cold. I know I was supposed to be super worried that they wouldn't make it out okay, but I just wasn't.
Overall? I have mad envy for this author's worldbuilding skills but I just wasn't satisfied by the romance. If you enjoy Colonial-era historical fiction in general, though, you might have fun with this book.
May 18, 2020
5/2020: I really don't recall much about this book except what annoyed me. Original rating 4 stars. Dropped to 3 stars "good" because of the sour memories.
Original review:
An absorbing and atmospheric story, set in colonial Williamsburg at the outset of the Revolution. The Tories are threatened by the Patriots, and emotions are running high. All Elisabeth Anne Lawson is supposed to be concentrating on is her imminently-approaching marriage to Miles, a local landowner, a trusted Tory.
But Elisabeth's heart is drawn to her homeland and the Patriots longing for freedom. The closer it gets to her wedding-day, the higher the emotions rise in the town, and the less she likes to think of her upcoming marriage. The political and social world is crumbling, as is Miles, her intended, who cannot keep away from the gaming-table.
I loved how so many of the events unfolded and was particularly drawn by Noble, the hero of the piece. He is a good strong man and one of faith and principle. I liked how he didn't use slaves to run his estate, and the Welsh angle was truly a lot of fun.
There were two major things that I didn't like.
#1. Profanity. Other than some instances of "blast" things were going pretty well until page 371, when a bad guy bursts out with "For G sake!" That late in the book? And is that somehow supposed to indicate he's not a good guy? Well, we already figured that out. Any profanity is always an offense to me in a Christian book. I am getting so tired of big publishers who seem to think it's okay to profane the Name of a holy God in their printed books.
#2. Patrick Henry. While doing her homework on all sorts of other delightful details, Frantz neglected to do her homework on this recurring true character. I'm not quite sure what sources she used for his character development, but the historical record is pretty clear. In this book, he is portrayed as a brash, plainspoken man who says what he thinks in plain and modern language, often punctuates it with "blast," is not very charitable in thought toward others, and always has a mug of ale in hand. The historical record differs massively. He was the premier orator of his day and a very successful lawyer, passionate about music and a dedicated Anglican. I found it odd that Noble should speak of playing his violin with Jefferson and Clark, but never with Henry, supposedly his nearest friend--and in real life a well-recognized violinist in his own right.
These two things prevented me from giving the book a full five-star rating.
Another pet peeve was a repeated anachronistic use of the word "honeymoon." I'm used to hearing it referred to as a "wedding trip" in older novels, so I looked it up to see how far outside the modern use it was. To my surprise, it began much earlier than I thought: 1791. Still a problem for a book set in 1776!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free review copy. A favorable review is not required.
Original review:
An absorbing and atmospheric story, set in colonial Williamsburg at the outset of the Revolution. The Tories are threatened by the Patriots, and emotions are running high. All Elisabeth Anne Lawson is supposed to be concentrating on is her imminently-approaching marriage to Miles, a local landowner, a trusted Tory.
But Elisabeth's heart is drawn to her homeland and the Patriots longing for freedom. The closer it gets to her wedding-day, the higher the emotions rise in the town, and the less she likes to think of her upcoming marriage. The political and social world is crumbling, as is Miles, her intended, who cannot keep away from the gaming-table.
I loved how so many of the events unfolded and was particularly drawn by Noble, the hero of the piece. He is a good strong man and one of faith and principle. I liked how he didn't use slaves to run his estate, and the Welsh angle was truly a lot of fun.
There were two major things that I didn't like.
#1. Profanity. Other than some instances of "blast" things were going pretty well until page 371, when a bad guy bursts out with "For G sake!" That late in the book? And is that somehow supposed to indicate he's not a good guy? Well, we already figured that out. Any profanity is always an offense to me in a Christian book. I am getting so tired of big publishers who seem to think it's okay to profane the Name of a holy God in their printed books.
#2. Patrick Henry. While doing her homework on all sorts of other delightful details, Frantz neglected to do her homework on this recurring true character. I'm not quite sure what sources she used for his character development, but the historical record is pretty clear. In this book, he is portrayed as a brash, plainspoken man who says what he thinks in plain and modern language, often punctuates it with "blast," is not very charitable in thought toward others, and always has a mug of ale in hand. The historical record differs massively. He was the premier orator of his day and a very successful lawyer, passionate about music and a dedicated Anglican. I found it odd that Noble should speak of playing his violin with Jefferson and Clark, but never with Henry, supposedly his nearest friend--and in real life a well-recognized violinist in his own right.
These two things prevented me from giving the book a full five-star rating.
Another pet peeve was a repeated anachronistic use of the word "honeymoon." I'm used to hearing it referred to as a "wedding trip" in older novels, so I looked it up to see how far outside the modern use it was. To my surprise, it began much earlier than I thought: 1791. Still a problem for a book set in 1776!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free review copy. A favorable review is not required.
January 16, 2018
Wow. This is a book that kept me thinking about it long after I finished. The pace is somewhat slow, but steady as the characters are developed and events occur that lead us to the heart of the story. The historical details are ones to savor as the world of Colonial Virginia is richly laid out and I felt like I could step right into the setting. It was fascinating to witness the shift Elizabeth experiences from opulence to desperate circumstances, although her faith prevented her from feeling truly desperate. I admired her fortitude in making her own way as seamstress and lacemaker, and the change of her name to Liberty marked an important transition in her life. The details of the turbulence and politics of the country as it heads into war made me apprehensive for Liberty and Noble and I worried for the upheaval that would inevitably disrupt their relationship. Their romance is as slow-building as the plot, being held back because of Noble's patriotic politics and Liberty's background as a Tory, but the anticipation builds and it is worth the wait! I loved their sweet moments together and the sacrifices they make for each other. I can't imagine the fullness of the courage and grit that these Patriots must have had to stay strong and hold to their convictions. This book made the revolution really come to life and made me ponder the gravity of what our forefathers (and foremothers) did to prepare the way for our country. It made me consider that the movers and shakers of the time were really just regular people in extraordinary circumstances, but there were also countless other regular citizens supporting the cause that aren't remembered by name but sacrificed as well. Highly recommend!
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
July 11, 2023
Transported. Enthralled. Delighted. What a new favorite epic romance. What a history nerd/ HEA chaser feast of a must-read.
It’s been a minute since I read a historical where I wasn’t just in total disbelief that these people weren’t real. Just so utterly vivid and threaded with actual peoples and places. There’s aptly named Noble, giving all the natural protector commanding presence with stoic honor just oozing from him (you know, the kind of hero that has a whole paragraph of wistful thoughts in his head but barely manages to blurt out a word or two, but then will devastate you with a Welsh endearment? Yep). And go ahead and give a warm welcome to our Lady Elizabeth a.k.a. Liberty girl to the Spine of Steel Heroine Hall of Fame. One ounce of her grit is all I ask for. Just stellar, stellar characterization and relationship progression.
We have a Welsh second son turned barrister/horsebreeder/landowner and Patriot/Independence Man becoming the unexpected rescuer of the daughter of the very Royalist lieutenant governor of Virginia Colony, now a “tarnished Tory” lacemaker. The tropes had me as giddy as Isabeau with a fresh-baked beignet. You’ve got your reversal of fortune class difference, your forced proximity, some caretaking. Shout out to what I like to call the Pemberley trope, as she simultaneously catches feels for the riverfront estate as for its master. *dreamy sigh* Also, what’s a name for when he’s been giving beyond-thoughtful romantic gestures way before his head has caught up with his heart? And then we get a marriage of convenience plus some epistolary? Tis too much *overwhelmed happy romance reader sniff*
Is the last 20% of every Laura Frantz book a cardiac endurance test of external conflict? I’ve only read two so far and have had to constantly remind my heart rate there will be HEA. Ah, but such glorious, well-earned resolution. In case stating the obvious is somehow necessary: I loved this book. If you love it too, you are correct. If you have not read it, this needs be rectified.
Content notes: kissing only, married couple fade to black scene, toxic parent, threat of war, some mild peril, kidnapping. Generous Christian faith content.
It’s been a minute since I read a historical where I wasn’t just in total disbelief that these people weren’t real. Just so utterly vivid and threaded with actual peoples and places. There’s aptly named Noble, giving all the natural protector commanding presence with stoic honor just oozing from him (you know, the kind of hero that has a whole paragraph of wistful thoughts in his head but barely manages to blurt out a word or two, but then will devastate you with a Welsh endearment? Yep). And go ahead and give a warm welcome to our Lady Elizabeth a.k.a. Liberty girl to the Spine of Steel Heroine Hall of Fame. One ounce of her grit is all I ask for. Just stellar, stellar characterization and relationship progression.
We have a Welsh second son turned barrister/horsebreeder/landowner and Patriot/Independence Man becoming the unexpected rescuer of the daughter of the very Royalist lieutenant governor of Virginia Colony, now a “tarnished Tory” lacemaker. The tropes had me as giddy as Isabeau with a fresh-baked beignet. You’ve got your reversal of fortune class difference, your forced proximity, some caretaking. Shout out to what I like to call the Pemberley trope, as she simultaneously catches feels for the riverfront estate as for its master. *dreamy sigh* Also, what’s a name for when he’s been giving beyond-thoughtful romantic gestures way before his head has caught up with his heart? And then we get a marriage of convenience plus some epistolary? Tis too much *overwhelmed happy romance reader sniff*
Is the last 20% of every Laura Frantz book a cardiac endurance test of external conflict? I’ve only read two so far and have had to constantly remind my heart rate there will be HEA. Ah, but such glorious, well-earned resolution. In case stating the obvious is somehow necessary: I loved this book. If you love it too, you are correct. If you have not read it, this needs be rectified.
Content notes: kissing only, married couple fade to black scene, toxic parent, threat of war, some mild peril, kidnapping. Generous Christian faith content.
March 17, 2019
Oh my ... A completely exquisite novel from Laura Frantz! I love this author's writing style, and I love stories set in colonial America. So getting my hands on a copy of The Lacemaker, a romantic tale set in 1770s Williamsburg, Virginia, was a treat! It was beautiful, gentle, exciting, and yet steadfast.
Elizabeth - Liberty - was a wonderful, feminine heroine. From genteel lady to working woman, she faces loss, illness, and danger as she struggles to find her place amidst the turmoil in Williamsburg. Loyalist or patriot? And who can she trust?
I'm convinced that Laura Frantz and I would have an absolutely lovely time talking together over tea. So many things about The Lacemaker made me think: "I would have written it exactly this way, too.". It actually reminded me of Courting Morrow Little in many ways; which happens to be my all-time favorite novel from Mrs. Frantz.
Love and loss. Danger and excitement. Sweet, tender moments that make my heart flutter as a woman. A gutsy female character with a quiet and gentle spirit. Hope and steadfast faith. Oh, this was a beautiful tale. It wasn't super fast-paced and dramatic, but it was thoughtful, lovely, and very satisfying.
I am very much looking forward to reading the newest release from this author, A Bound Heart.
Elizabeth - Liberty - was a wonderful, feminine heroine. From genteel lady to working woman, she faces loss, illness, and danger as she struggles to find her place amidst the turmoil in Williamsburg. Loyalist or patriot? And who can she trust?
I'm convinced that Laura Frantz and I would have an absolutely lovely time talking together over tea. So many things about The Lacemaker made me think: "I would have written it exactly this way, too.". It actually reminded me of Courting Morrow Little in many ways; which happens to be my all-time favorite novel from Mrs. Frantz.
Love and loss. Danger and excitement. Sweet, tender moments that make my heart flutter as a woman. A gutsy female character with a quiet and gentle spirit. Hope and steadfast faith. Oh, this was a beautiful tale. It wasn't super fast-paced and dramatic, but it was thoughtful, lovely, and very satisfying.
I am very much looking forward to reading the newest release from this author, A Bound Heart.
November 10, 2018
Laura Frantz has a beautiful writing style. Both main characters were lovely and noble. Reading The Lacemaker was a brief visit to colonial Williamsburg. The author does a great job of creating the mood or feel of the setting.
March 12, 2018
Wonderful story! I enjoyed this trip back to Virginia in the 1700s. Laura's research brings the world of Colonial Williamsburg to life. The characters are memorable and unique. Well done!
January 11, 2018
GUYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
For the love of freakin' turtles.
What do we even do with a book like this? Apparently, I can only just slosh a bunch of thoughts together with little cohesion, so settle in.
What I want to do is have the words at my disposal to give it douse it with the lauds and laurels it deserves. But it was such a whizbang of a finger-tip-tingling-exuberant experience that I don't know if I should try or just GUSH the HECK OUTTA IT !
So basically, here's the thing: EVERY TIME I READ A LAURA FRANTZ BOOK I AM LIKE: "THIS! THIS IS THE BEST LAURA FRANTZ BOOK IN THE HISTORY OF FRANTZ"
and then another one comes along--
The Lacemaker shows up and is all "hold my beer" (or in this case tepid Revolutionary cider in a pewter mug)
There is just so much that this book gets RIGHT!
Image result for the lacemaker frantzIt's almost like you never realized the limitations of other historical fiction until you read a book that is pretty much perfection. AND. THERE. ARE. FREAKIN. SPIES
spies. SPIES!
It's almost like you sing odes to the history of pen and paper and computers that allowed this to reach you. Thank you, Gutenburg! THANK YOU CAVEMEN WHO SCRAWLED IN CAVES...
Elisabeth "Liberty" Lawson is daughter to a Tory authoritarian just as rebels and revolutionaries are boiling under the surface and Williamsburg is a barrel of gunpowder that with the slightest flick of a wick could explode. When the pot boils over, Elisabeth is left abandoned by her father, her friends, the few Tory supporters remaining and even her would-be fiancee Miles.
It is Miles' cousin, Noble ( in any other book this would be an on-the-nose name, but I am giving it to Frantz because yah! take it! run with it into the sunset! more on Noble later ) who steps in (not for the first time) to prove stoically heroic and install Lady Elisabeth and her maid into his own estate.
Noble embodies the gift of hospitality. Go back to your Fruits of the Spirit in Sunday School. Look upward at that felt board with literal fruit with attributes in bold black marker--I bet, like in my class, Long Suffering IS ALWAYS the banana--- this is Noble. He is a hero of quiet strength whose sister's recent death left him even more bereft of his home and nationality. Ty Mawr, it seems, and the late Enid's care for it, embroider a lush picture of home: the first he truly had since emigrating from his beloved Wales. Noble's care for Elisabeth--beyond the realm of political affiliation and borne of pure Christian charity--- places him at odds with the kettle-boiling-over political world around him. His gentle tenacity to do the right thing, even for the enemy, will play out time and again throughout the mounting tension of the book until its gut-wrenching climax.
Now in historical romances, we often fall for the typified alpha guy! He is a cowboy! he is a gunslinger! he can wield a rifle and force those rapscallion Redcoats into their holes! But Frantz wants to provide the reader with a more intricate view of the many nuanced tenets of character. There is no witty banter, he is not out to be redeemed, he does not challenge the heroine ---he only surprises her with his unthinkable acts of hospitality: which benefit not only Liberty but her servants and family-- people on the other side of America's mounting conflict.
When is the last time we actually celebrated a romantic hero whose finest trait is in feeding and sheltering? When the latter part of the book arrives and Noble is thrust into a battle (both in the military arena and beyond), we are able to appreciate its effected counterbalance more. We have seen his true heart and now we can comprehend how a man of quiet conviction would take such drastic action. Frantz's delicate thesis is justified because she brings us clearly from point A of Noble's Awesomeness to Point B of Noble's awesomeness.
His heart and goodness and tiny smudges of grace--- escorting a lady home--- attending to her well being at a dance--- doesn't mean Noble can't lift a musket to his broad shoulder and fight alongside his comrades. That is not to say he doesn't frequent the Raleigh tavern and sound his conviction over pints with well-known historical figures (Wash and Jeff and John Laurens--- here's looking at you, Hamilton--play well at fitting into the pulse of the story without drawing attention from the central characters and conflict. Acting, instead, as pieces of the historical puzzle which deftly contribute to this elaborate world).
There is a lot of talk in the blogger and publisher world that divides heroes into two types: alpha (think Rhett Butler ) or Beta (think Peeta), Noble is the completely well-rounded male character that never once sifts into a category. He is, as most people are, at the intersection of a Venn diagram.
To add, Liberty is a strong woman whose strength often asserts itself in being intelligent enough to see beyond her own determination for agency to accept help. Her strength is her femininity. Her agency is found in an ultra feminine profession (lacemaking) and she is winsomely smart enough to recognize that the skill she fostered in a high social standing will find itself measured differently in a topsy turvy new world. Liberty is a passionate woman who is forced to stand on her own two feet, yes, but grateful for the help of others. She stumbles, she picks herself up, she navigates a new world but never with a boisterous or reckless spirit. Her calculated decisions are borne of a book's slowly mounting tension and realized with fabulous aplomb.
ANNNNDDDDD we need to talk about the fact that THANK ALL COOKIES IN THE JAR Frantz addresses the problematic tendency to confuse infatuation with love.
Liberty and Noble differentiate their growing attraction with love. Indeed, love only peeks up out of its gopher shell in true abiding form at a pivotal point of the story ( the gut wrenching you will DIE A THOUSAND DEATHS part)
This book is as exceptionally well-researched as every Frantz book and the plot spins at a beautiful pace, threaded with Frantz's lyrical description. Indeed, it put me in mind of the same heart-tug I felt reading the Mark of the King. Its faith threads are subtle and socio-cultural and very apt for the time--they are also explored through deft symbol and sacrifice.
And a rant, kittens, most of the time written dialect makes me scrunch up my nose and want to throw things. The insertion of "och aye bairn" unnerves me. There is a way to paint the accent instead in descriptors. But, Frantz, she can do it all. Trust her. Be it French, Welsh or Scotch, you are going to fall into the carefully meted timbre of dialogue. You know what, kitty cats, there is something about dialogue that suggests if you take ANY of it out of context and place it on stage, it would set a dimensional scene. That is the level of talent Frantz has--- she is just--- in a league of her own.
I also feel we need to thank Colonial Williamsburg because whomever has helped Frantz with her research has helped give the reader the fine-tuned extraordinarily detailed experience we have wandering through this world. Immersing yourself in The Lacemaker is as intricate a tour through Williamsburg during the Revolutionary wars as a youtube video mechanized to show us through the streets would be. If I didn't know Laura Frantz was alive and well and pinteresting her way through her beautiful life, I would swear this book was written years and years ago.
The best historical fiction takes time not only to narrate the past; but to inspire the reader to fall overwhelmingly into it. Verisimilitude. Dialogue intentions. Aura. World-building. Sight and scent and canvas. There is an ornate and startling poetry to the caresses her pen takes to a period she knows obviously as well as the one we live in.
The patriotism instilled in this book is one that is accessible beyond America. It is not all Mel-Gibson-Waving-a-Flag in The Patriot. This subtle humility toward better understanding of a still-flawed and frayed world-- as navigated by Liberty and Noble ( see the names? their every person representation as two of the pinnacles of any successful experiment--including the American one) stretches beyond run- of- the -mill jingoism, this instills the universal desire and need for fairness and equality.
Sometimes a talent is so arresting that you are so blessed that it exists. Sometimes art is so enriching that it makes you happy to be well and alive so that you can experience it. The Lacemaker is one such gift. It is a journey, a love letter, a tapestry. It is a book of resounding beauty at once still and shattering. It will move you to tears as a warm glow for the good of human nature and the advocacy of the best parts of humanity eke through you.
So I underlined a billion trillion lines in this book. A BILLION TRILLION! #nohyperbole --- but I have made the conscious decision to let this be part of the surprise and romance of unwrapping this word-gift. Let this be the slow moving peel back of startling words in perfect order.
Find yourself in this book, friends, and return to it again. It will enrich you as a reader, its goodness and heart shining through with a smartly lit radiance, slow burning with an ending SWOOSH of a boom.
LA! THIS BOOK IS THE BOMB, yo!
read it FOREVER
with gratitude forever and ever to Revell for making me stay up so late at night I was walking red-eyed zombie at work.
With gratitude forever to the makers of my favourite sauvignon blanc which helped me drown my BEST KIND OF DELICIOUS SORROW when this book ripped me apart.
For the love of freakin' turtles.
What do we even do with a book like this? Apparently, I can only just slosh a bunch of thoughts together with little cohesion, so settle in.
What I want to do is have the words at my disposal to give it douse it with the lauds and laurels it deserves. But it was such a whizbang of a finger-tip-tingling-exuberant experience that I don't know if I should try or just GUSH the HECK OUTTA IT !
So basically, here's the thing: EVERY TIME I READ A LAURA FRANTZ BOOK I AM LIKE: "THIS! THIS IS THE BEST LAURA FRANTZ BOOK IN THE HISTORY OF FRANTZ"
and then another one comes along--
The Lacemaker shows up and is all "hold my beer" (or in this case tepid Revolutionary cider in a pewter mug)
There is just so much that this book gets RIGHT!
Image result for the lacemaker frantzIt's almost like you never realized the limitations of other historical fiction until you read a book that is pretty much perfection. AND. THERE. ARE. FREAKIN. SPIES
spies. SPIES!
It's almost like you sing odes to the history of pen and paper and computers that allowed this to reach you. Thank you, Gutenburg! THANK YOU CAVEMEN WHO SCRAWLED IN CAVES...
Elisabeth "Liberty" Lawson is daughter to a Tory authoritarian just as rebels and revolutionaries are boiling under the surface and Williamsburg is a barrel of gunpowder that with the slightest flick of a wick could explode. When the pot boils over, Elisabeth is left abandoned by her father, her friends, the few Tory supporters remaining and even her would-be fiancee Miles.
It is Miles' cousin, Noble ( in any other book this would be an on-the-nose name, but I am giving it to Frantz because yah! take it! run with it into the sunset! more on Noble later ) who steps in (not for the first time) to prove stoically heroic and install Lady Elisabeth and her maid into his own estate.
Noble embodies the gift of hospitality. Go back to your Fruits of the Spirit in Sunday School. Look upward at that felt board with literal fruit with attributes in bold black marker--I bet, like in my class, Long Suffering IS ALWAYS the banana--- this is Noble. He is a hero of quiet strength whose sister's recent death left him even more bereft of his home and nationality. Ty Mawr, it seems, and the late Enid's care for it, embroider a lush picture of home: the first he truly had since emigrating from his beloved Wales. Noble's care for Elisabeth--beyond the realm of political affiliation and borne of pure Christian charity--- places him at odds with the kettle-boiling-over political world around him. His gentle tenacity to do the right thing, even for the enemy, will play out time and again throughout the mounting tension of the book until its gut-wrenching climax.
Now in historical romances, we often fall for the typified alpha guy! He is a cowboy! he is a gunslinger! he can wield a rifle and force those rapscallion Redcoats into their holes! But Frantz wants to provide the reader with a more intricate view of the many nuanced tenets of character. There is no witty banter, he is not out to be redeemed, he does not challenge the heroine ---he only surprises her with his unthinkable acts of hospitality: which benefit not only Liberty but her servants and family-- people on the other side of America's mounting conflict.
When is the last time we actually celebrated a romantic hero whose finest trait is in feeding and sheltering? When the latter part of the book arrives and Noble is thrust into a battle (both in the military arena and beyond), we are able to appreciate its effected counterbalance more. We have seen his true heart and now we can comprehend how a man of quiet conviction would take such drastic action. Frantz's delicate thesis is justified because she brings us clearly from point A of Noble's Awesomeness to Point B of Noble's awesomeness.
His heart and goodness and tiny smudges of grace--- escorting a lady home--- attending to her well being at a dance--- doesn't mean Noble can't lift a musket to his broad shoulder and fight alongside his comrades. That is not to say he doesn't frequent the Raleigh tavern and sound his conviction over pints with well-known historical figures (Wash and Jeff and John Laurens--- here's looking at you, Hamilton--play well at fitting into the pulse of the story without drawing attention from the central characters and conflict. Acting, instead, as pieces of the historical puzzle which deftly contribute to this elaborate world).
There is a lot of talk in the blogger and publisher world that divides heroes into two types: alpha (think Rhett Butler ) or Beta (think Peeta), Noble is the completely well-rounded male character that never once sifts into a category. He is, as most people are, at the intersection of a Venn diagram.
To add, Liberty is a strong woman whose strength often asserts itself in being intelligent enough to see beyond her own determination for agency to accept help. Her strength is her femininity. Her agency is found in an ultra feminine profession (lacemaking) and she is winsomely smart enough to recognize that the skill she fostered in a high social standing will find itself measured differently in a topsy turvy new world. Liberty is a passionate woman who is forced to stand on her own two feet, yes, but grateful for the help of others. She stumbles, she picks herself up, she navigates a new world but never with a boisterous or reckless spirit. Her calculated decisions are borne of a book's slowly mounting tension and realized with fabulous aplomb.
ANNNNDDDDD we need to talk about the fact that THANK ALL COOKIES IN THE JAR Frantz addresses the problematic tendency to confuse infatuation with love.
Liberty and Noble differentiate their growing attraction with love. Indeed, love only peeks up out of its gopher shell in true abiding form at a pivotal point of the story ( the gut wrenching you will DIE A THOUSAND DEATHS part)
This book is as exceptionally well-researched as every Frantz book and the plot spins at a beautiful pace, threaded with Frantz's lyrical description. Indeed, it put me in mind of the same heart-tug I felt reading the Mark of the King. Its faith threads are subtle and socio-cultural and very apt for the time--they are also explored through deft symbol and sacrifice.
And a rant, kittens, most of the time written dialect makes me scrunch up my nose and want to throw things. The insertion of "och aye bairn" unnerves me. There is a way to paint the accent instead in descriptors. But, Frantz, she can do it all. Trust her. Be it French, Welsh or Scotch, you are going to fall into the carefully meted timbre of dialogue. You know what, kitty cats, there is something about dialogue that suggests if you take ANY of it out of context and place it on stage, it would set a dimensional scene. That is the level of talent Frantz has--- she is just--- in a league of her own.
I also feel we need to thank Colonial Williamsburg because whomever has helped Frantz with her research has helped give the reader the fine-tuned extraordinarily detailed experience we have wandering through this world. Immersing yourself in The Lacemaker is as intricate a tour through Williamsburg during the Revolutionary wars as a youtube video mechanized to show us through the streets would be. If I didn't know Laura Frantz was alive and well and pinteresting her way through her beautiful life, I would swear this book was written years and years ago.
The best historical fiction takes time not only to narrate the past; but to inspire the reader to fall overwhelmingly into it. Verisimilitude. Dialogue intentions. Aura. World-building. Sight and scent and canvas. There is an ornate and startling poetry to the caresses her pen takes to a period she knows obviously as well as the one we live in.
The patriotism instilled in this book is one that is accessible beyond America. It is not all Mel-Gibson-Waving-a-Flag in The Patriot. This subtle humility toward better understanding of a still-flawed and frayed world-- as navigated by Liberty and Noble ( see the names? their every person representation as two of the pinnacles of any successful experiment--including the American one) stretches beyond run- of- the -mill jingoism, this instills the universal desire and need for fairness and equality.
Sometimes a talent is so arresting that you are so blessed that it exists. Sometimes art is so enriching that it makes you happy to be well and alive so that you can experience it. The Lacemaker is one such gift. It is a journey, a love letter, a tapestry. It is a book of resounding beauty at once still and shattering. It will move you to tears as a warm glow for the good of human nature and the advocacy of the best parts of humanity eke through you.
So I underlined a billion trillion lines in this book. A BILLION TRILLION! #nohyperbole --- but I have made the conscious decision to let this be part of the surprise and romance of unwrapping this word-gift. Let this be the slow moving peel back of startling words in perfect order.
Find yourself in this book, friends, and return to it again. It will enrich you as a reader, its goodness and heart shining through with a smartly lit radiance, slow burning with an ending SWOOSH of a boom.
LA! THIS BOOK IS THE BOMB, yo!
read it FOREVER
with gratitude forever and ever to Revell for making me stay up so late at night I was walking red-eyed zombie at work.
With gratitude forever to the makers of my favourite sauvignon blanc which helped me drown my BEST KIND OF DELICIOUS SORROW when this book ripped me apart.
May 17, 2020
I kinda feel bad for giving this beautiful book such a low rating (given that I was really hoping it'd be a 5-star book for me), but unfortunately I found it very underwhelming, and did not derive much pleasure in reading the last half or so.
But let's begin with the positive.
What makes The Lacemaker a good book:
* I don't care how many times I hear the "don't judge a book by its cover", I 100% do and a beautiful cover is always an incentive for me to pick up the book. Which is exactly what happened while I was browsing the library shelves one last time before quarantine, and chanced upon this loveliness when I checked the Laura Frantz section. This cover is GORGEOUS. I WANT THAT SLEEVE. I LOVE IT.
* The setting is quite simply amazing. When you read this book, you ARE in 1775 Virginia. Laura Frantz is reputedly one of the best Christian historical fiction authors out there for a reason. Because her books actually feel historical. In-depth research is evident, and the pre-Revolution atmosphere is perfectly captured, from brewing tension to outright raids. So yes. A far as history goes, this was great.
* Likewise, the attention to detail is astounding. Clothing descriptions are accurate and carefully sprinkled throughout for nice visuals, and the author also does an excellent job with surroundings and daily life happenings. I loved all the little details like the Welsh bread and the Independence Tea and the lack of dressmaking pins (the horror!). Everything was so well put together, and I love learning a thing or two after finishing a book. This novel had substance, and I appreciated that.
* There was good characterization, if we remove the characters from the plot, which I shall address in a second. Noble Rynallt, master of the great Ty Mawr, perfectly captured the essence of the tall-dark-handsome hero devoted to a Good Cause, and Liberty (Lady Elisabeth) encapsulated the beautiful, slender and flower-looking heroine who ends up having more backbone than it might seem. Sure, they were cliché, but they were done well. I liked them.
* This book had a lot of Poldark feels to it (kind of), which is one of my favourite TV shows, so I really enjoyed that.
Unfortunately, my list of good things pretty much stops here.
What Was Utterly Disappointing about The Lacemaker:
* Okay. You cannot, you absolutely CANNOT give me a book with a title like The Lacemaker AND NOT TALK ABOUT LACEMAKING. THIS WAS MY BIGGEST INCENTIVE TO READ THIS BOOK. I thought the heroine would, you know, ACTIVELY be making lace throughout the book, and that we'd get charming details of how it's made and used, etc. And right, to be fair, there obviously IS lacemaking in this book, to a certain extent. There are references now and again to bits of lace on sleeves or on cushions, and the heroine does try to take up lacemaking as a living for a hot minute in the middle of the plot, but that's pretty much it. THAT IS NOT ENOUGH LACE TO CALL A BOOK "THE LACEMAKER". *she says with her nose high in the air*
* The romance. Oh, my word. I have never witnessed a breathtakingly blooming romance plummet so dramatically into lukewarm waters IN MY LIFE. The beginning is SO DARN GOOD. You have the elegant Liberty (then Lady Elisabeth), a picture of perfection in her tightly-laced stays and rich gowns, playing the part of the poised and controlled Daughter of the House, and you have the dashing, ruggedly-handsome Independence man Rynallt, trying his best to make up for his cousin's neglect of his fiancée (being Lady Elisabeth). Amidst candlelit ballroom scenes, swishing skirts and powdered wigs, they slowly get to know each other, and the beginnings of the romance are deliciously slow and carefully measured.
BUT THEN. All of a sudden, with no warning whatsoever, all the chemistry, all the steam just evaporate like a neglected cup of tea. Pretty much every single romantic scene gets dampened by other pressing concerns that, granted, are important to consider in the grand scheme of the plot, but that so effectively interrupted the romance that it just...wasn't romantic anymore. I lost count of how many times Noble and Liberty would be in the middle of a cute scene before it was broken off with thoughts of impeding war, or important paperwork. I understand that your paperwork is important man, BUT STOP KILLING THE ROMANCE. This was all so disappointing after such a promising beginning.
* Likewise, the main plot. SO good in the beginning, so well thought-out, so much building tension. Historical characters are introduced, there is talk of spies and treason and prisoners and it promises to be so exciting. It's not. I'm still unsure of what actually should/did happen in this book. There are so many little random threads here and there. This was especially disappointing considering how good the setting was.
*There is SUCH a fuss made about Liberty's mother in the first half: when she's going to come back, what she'll do, etc, etc. And no sooner does she finally arrive than she LEAVES AGAIN.
*Lady Elisabeth's change of name to Liberty is rather very random, and quite unnecessary. You don't have to be named "Liberty" in order to believe in liberty.
*A lot of the secondary characters were rather flat and I did not understand some of their purposes. Several are mentioned and then never seen/heard of again.
*I can't begin to describe how utterly anti-climactic the last quarter of the book is. JUST WHAT. The main characters lost my sympathies because everything just felt so disconnected. I KNOW this author is capable of writing epic scenes and enthralling battles. Where were they? Every major plot point in this book happens off-stage. WHY. IT COULD HAVE BEEN SO GOOD. I was cheering for a happy ending so that we'd be spared further character musings and bemoaning of hard times and impeding war. Things still feel very unresolved by the end.
I just...I just don't know. I really wanted to love it, but between the romance deflating like a balloon with every passing chapter, and the plot that never seemed to progress, I slowly lost my enjoyment of this book and the story now feels very unmemorable to me. It's really too bad, because it had high potential, and Laura Frantz is a really gifted writer, but sadly this one just didn't quite work for me.
But let's begin with the positive.
What makes The Lacemaker a good book:
* I don't care how many times I hear the "don't judge a book by its cover", I 100% do and a beautiful cover is always an incentive for me to pick up the book. Which is exactly what happened while I was browsing the library shelves one last time before quarantine, and chanced upon this loveliness when I checked the Laura Frantz section. This cover is GORGEOUS. I WANT THAT SLEEVE. I LOVE IT.
* The setting is quite simply amazing. When you read this book, you ARE in 1775 Virginia. Laura Frantz is reputedly one of the best Christian historical fiction authors out there for a reason. Because her books actually feel historical. In-depth research is evident, and the pre-Revolution atmosphere is perfectly captured, from brewing tension to outright raids. So yes. A far as history goes, this was great.
* Likewise, the attention to detail is astounding. Clothing descriptions are accurate and carefully sprinkled throughout for nice visuals, and the author also does an excellent job with surroundings and daily life happenings. I loved all the little details like the Welsh bread and the Independence Tea and the lack of dressmaking pins (the horror!). Everything was so well put together, and I love learning a thing or two after finishing a book. This novel had substance, and I appreciated that.
* There was good characterization, if we remove the characters from the plot, which I shall address in a second. Noble Rynallt, master of the great Ty Mawr, perfectly captured the essence of the tall-dark-handsome hero devoted to a Good Cause, and Liberty (Lady Elisabeth) encapsulated the beautiful, slender and flower-looking heroine who ends up having more backbone than it might seem. Sure, they were cliché, but they were done well. I liked them.
* This book had a lot of Poldark feels to it (kind of), which is one of my favourite TV shows, so I really enjoyed that.
Unfortunately, my list of good things pretty much stops here.
What Was Utterly Disappointing about The Lacemaker:
* Okay. You cannot, you absolutely CANNOT give me a book with a title like The Lacemaker AND NOT TALK ABOUT LACEMAKING. THIS WAS MY BIGGEST INCENTIVE TO READ THIS BOOK. I thought the heroine would, you know, ACTIVELY be making lace throughout the book, and that we'd get charming details of how it's made and used, etc. And right, to be fair, there obviously IS lacemaking in this book, to a certain extent. There are references now and again to bits of lace on sleeves or on cushions, and the heroine does try to take up lacemaking as a living for a hot minute in the middle of the plot, but that's pretty much it. THAT IS NOT ENOUGH LACE TO CALL A BOOK "THE LACEMAKER". *she says with her nose high in the air*
* The romance. Oh, my word. I have never witnessed a breathtakingly blooming romance plummet so dramatically into lukewarm waters IN MY LIFE. The beginning is SO DARN GOOD. You have the elegant Liberty (then Lady Elisabeth), a picture of perfection in her tightly-laced stays and rich gowns, playing the part of the poised and controlled Daughter of the House, and you have the dashing, ruggedly-handsome Independence man Rynallt, trying his best to make up for his cousin's neglect of his fiancée (being Lady Elisabeth). Amidst candlelit ballroom scenes, swishing skirts and powdered wigs, they slowly get to know each other, and the beginnings of the romance are deliciously slow and carefully measured.
BUT THEN. All of a sudden, with no warning whatsoever, all the chemistry, all the steam just evaporate like a neglected cup of tea. Pretty much every single romantic scene gets dampened by other pressing concerns that, granted, are important to consider in the grand scheme of the plot, but that so effectively interrupted the romance that it just...wasn't romantic anymore. I lost count of how many times Noble and Liberty would be in the middle of a cute scene before it was broken off with thoughts of impeding war, or important paperwork. I understand that your paperwork is important man, BUT STOP KILLING THE ROMANCE. This was all so disappointing after such a promising beginning.
* Likewise, the main plot. SO good in the beginning, so well thought-out, so much building tension. Historical characters are introduced, there is talk of spies and treason and prisoners and it promises to be so exciting. It's not. I'm still unsure of what actually should/did happen in this book. There are so many little random threads here and there. This was especially disappointing considering how good the setting was.
*There is SUCH a fuss made about Liberty's mother in the first half: when she's going to come back, what she'll do, etc, etc. And no sooner does she finally arrive than she LEAVES AGAIN.
*Lady Elisabeth's change of name to Liberty is rather very random, and quite unnecessary. You don't have to be named "Liberty" in order to believe in liberty.
*A lot of the secondary characters were rather flat and I did not understand some of their purposes. Several are mentioned and then never seen/heard of again.
*I can't begin to describe how utterly anti-climactic the last quarter of the book is. JUST WHAT. The main characters lost my sympathies because everything just felt so disconnected. I KNOW this author is capable of writing epic scenes and enthralling battles. Where were they? Every major plot point in this book happens off-stage. WHY. IT COULD HAVE BEEN SO GOOD. I was cheering for a happy ending so that we'd be spared further character musings and bemoaning of hard times and impeding war. Things still feel very unresolved by the end.
I just...I just don't know. I really wanted to love it, but between the romance deflating like a balloon with every passing chapter, and the plot that never seemed to progress, I slowly lost my enjoyment of this book and the story now feels very unmemorable to me. It's really too bad, because it had high potential, and Laura Frantz is a really gifted writer, but sadly this one just didn't quite work for me.
October 27, 2021
Oh this was a GOOD one! I was really in the mood to read a story like this!! ♥️ Super romantic!!
Something I really appreciate about Laura Frantz’s writing and this book in particular, is the way she has her characters communicate. Rarely does she have a miscommunication or misunderstanding go unaddressed for too long. I was so glad/relieved when that didn’t occur in this story because it easily could have. To me, when authors create a story around misunderstandings it is uncreative and predictable. Instead, in this story there was lots of communicating and trust placed in the other person. The heroine was very sweet and I enjoyed watching her come into her own. I LOVED the hero. Such a self-less man of character. This man displayed love for his wife the way Christ loves the Church. Jesus did this (and more) for us; which leads me to my next reason for loving this story…the strong Spiritual theme. 💗
Something I really appreciate about Laura Frantz’s writing and this book in particular, is the way she has her characters communicate. Rarely does she have a miscommunication or misunderstanding go unaddressed for too long. I was so glad/relieved when that didn’t occur in this story because it easily could have. To me, when authors create a story around misunderstandings it is uncreative and predictable. Instead, in this story there was lots of communicating and trust placed in the other person. The heroine was very sweet and I enjoyed watching her come into her own. I LOVED the hero. Such a self-less man of character. This man displayed love for his wife the way Christ loves the Church. Jesus did this (and more) for us; which leads me to my next reason for loving this story…the strong Spiritual theme. 💗
January 29, 2018
It's hard to know where to even begin. There's a gentleness about this book-in the writing style, characters, and storyline.
I was hesitant about this book at first, because of the synopsis. I'm not a fan of bad father stories, so I was a little hesitant. Much to my relief, I found it written well. Yep, he was a bad father, but not just because he asked Liberty to do a couple things she didn't want to. I'm impressed with how deep the characters motives run. I was surprised with how the story progressed, especially halfway through.
I could write a whole review about Noble. He was such an honorable man, and I loved how even when he tried to avoid "her", he kept getting pulled back to her because his nobility and standing on what was right :) The Welsh phrases and his home were endearing as well. I loved his involvement with the Independence men, which is a big part of the story!
Liberty took me a little bit longer to really love, but she won me over. I loved how she took another name when her life hung in the balance...and I love how she went about making her decisions. I believe some of the decisions made in these times were particular for then, but there are still so many lessons to learn from it. Standing for the Lord when it is considered weak, or being bold when people would rather you be intolerant.
The romance was superb, and I loved how so much was centered in marriage, not outside out of it. There are a couple scenes that are leading to intimacy that may make some uncomfortable, but I thought they were written sweetly and not detailed at all. Still, I would recommend this book more for young adult readers because of it.
The spiritual content is woven throughout beautifully. First, very gentle, and then as the tension mounted, the characters sought the Lord more and there were a couple mentions to salvation. As a note there is some social drinking (mainly cider) in this book, as well as several visits to pubs.
I found the ending a little rushed, but at the same time everything came together and there wasn't much more to say. Besides, I can't complain too much with happy endings!
I can't wait to see what other books this author has in store for us!
*I received this book from Revell in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own."
I was hesitant about this book at first, because of the synopsis. I'm not a fan of bad father stories, so I was a little hesitant. Much to my relief, I found it written well. Yep, he was a bad father, but not just because he asked Liberty to do a couple things she didn't want to. I'm impressed with how deep the characters motives run. I was surprised with how the story progressed, especially halfway through.
I could write a whole review about Noble. He was such an honorable man, and I loved how even when he tried to avoid "her", he kept getting pulled back to her because his nobility and standing on what was right :) The Welsh phrases and his home were endearing as well. I loved his involvement with the Independence men, which is a big part of the story!
Liberty took me a little bit longer to really love, but she won me over. I loved how she took another name when her life hung in the balance...and I love how she went about making her decisions. I believe some of the decisions made in these times were particular for then, but there are still so many lessons to learn from it. Standing for the Lord when it is considered weak, or being bold when people would rather you be intolerant.
The romance was superb, and I loved how so much was centered in marriage, not outside out of it. There are a couple scenes that are leading to intimacy that may make some uncomfortable, but I thought they were written sweetly and not detailed at all. Still, I would recommend this book more for young adult readers because of it.
The spiritual content is woven throughout beautifully. First, very gentle, and then as the tension mounted, the characters sought the Lord more and there were a couple mentions to salvation. As a note there is some social drinking (mainly cider) in this book, as well as several visits to pubs.
I found the ending a little rushed, but at the same time everything came together and there wasn't much more to say. Besides, I can't complain too much with happy endings!
I can't wait to see what other books this author has in store for us!
*I received this book from Revell in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own."
February 25, 2018
Now this is what I call a beautiful Christian historical romance!!
Let me start with my personal challenges:
1. I'm not a big historical fiction fan. However I have decided to step out of my comfort zone this year. So as this book was on sale and a buddy group was reading, I thought I would give it go.
2. Not being a big fan of historical fiction the "'Twas" and the old language used was extremely difficult for me at first. So I started by reading a few chapters a day.
3. I had no previous knowledge of history from the 1700's.
However with all these challenges I have to say that I have finished this book 2 days earlier than planned with the BIGGEST smile on my face. I am grateful for book sales and buddy groups.
I am also happy that I pushed past my comfort zone, the unfamiliar old language and lack of history knowledge because I would have missed out finding a personal favourite for 2018. Soon as I hit half way I could not put this book down.
Laura Frantz you have taken me on a beautiful adventurous journey that I will not forget. Noble and Liberty's story was captivating. Noble a man who was VERY NOBLE by nature. Liberty the perfect example of a woman who is free internally and fights for external freedom. Both of there faith was extremely inspiring.
This book had it all! My personal favourites was that some parts were very funny (not sure if they were meant to be but I LOL many times) for example "the hat pin" I'm still laughing now! I also thought there were several SWOONY breath taking moments (My personal favourite was the covering prayer :), and I also really liked that this book was not predictable. It made several turns I was not expecting. And had me sitting in anticipation at times.
This book was my first by Laura Frantz but will not be my last.
I recommend for all those that want to be taken on a adventurous journey of history, romance and faith :)
Let me start with my personal challenges:
1. I'm not a big historical fiction fan. However I have decided to step out of my comfort zone this year. So as this book was on sale and a buddy group was reading, I thought I would give it go.
2. Not being a big fan of historical fiction the "'Twas" and the old language used was extremely difficult for me at first. So I started by reading a few chapters a day.
3. I had no previous knowledge of history from the 1700's.
However with all these challenges I have to say that I have finished this book 2 days earlier than planned with the BIGGEST smile on my face. I am grateful for book sales and buddy groups.
I am also happy that I pushed past my comfort zone, the unfamiliar old language and lack of history knowledge because I would have missed out finding a personal favourite for 2018. Soon as I hit half way I could not put this book down.
Laura Frantz you have taken me on a beautiful adventurous journey that I will not forget. Noble and Liberty's story was captivating. Noble a man who was VERY NOBLE by nature. Liberty the perfect example of a woman who is free internally and fights for external freedom. Both of there faith was extremely inspiring.
This book had it all! My personal favourites was that some parts were very funny (not sure if they were meant to be but I LOL many times) for example "the hat pin" I'm still laughing now! I also thought there were several SWOONY breath taking moments (My personal favourite was the covering prayer :), and I also really liked that this book was not predictable. It made several turns I was not expecting. And had me sitting in anticipation at times.
This book was my first by Laura Frantz but will not be my last.
I recommend for all those that want to be taken on a adventurous journey of history, romance and faith :)
November 20, 2017
RT Top Pick for January 2018
Frantz once again pens a novel so rich in historical detail that readers will become immersed in the setting and time period. The sights, sounds, smells and atmosphere of 1775 Colonial America are beautifully woven into a captivating romance story. And ah, the romance! The relationship development between Elisabeth (Liberty) and Noble causes both sighs and goosebumps as it progresses. There are many instances of peril, deceitful actions and surprises that keep the story moving rapidly and will invest readers in the outcome.
In 1775 Virginia, Lady Elisabeth "Liberty" Lawson is betrothed to a man who her father thinks will help further their Tory cause, as well as be a suitable husband for Elisabeth. However, she finds herself torn between what her family wants and the leanings of her mind and heart. Noble Rynallt is known as a generous man and a Patriot, and he takes care to be discreet about his political leanings in polite company. As Noble becomes acquainted with Elisabeth, he finds himself drawn to a woman promised to another. When things come to a head with the rebellion, Elisabeth must fend for herself, yet help comes from the most surprising of places.
https://www.rtbookreviews.com/book-re...
Frantz once again pens a novel so rich in historical detail that readers will become immersed in the setting and time period. The sights, sounds, smells and atmosphere of 1775 Colonial America are beautifully woven into a captivating romance story. And ah, the romance! The relationship development between Elisabeth (Liberty) and Noble causes both sighs and goosebumps as it progresses. There are many instances of peril, deceitful actions and surprises that keep the story moving rapidly and will invest readers in the outcome.
In 1775 Virginia, Lady Elisabeth "Liberty" Lawson is betrothed to a man who her father thinks will help further their Tory cause, as well as be a suitable husband for Elisabeth. However, she finds herself torn between what her family wants and the leanings of her mind and heart. Noble Rynallt is known as a generous man and a Patriot, and he takes care to be discreet about his political leanings in polite company. As Noble becomes acquainted with Elisabeth, he finds himself drawn to a woman promised to another. When things come to a head with the rebellion, Elisabeth must fend for herself, yet help comes from the most surprising of places.
https://www.rtbookreviews.com/book-re...
January 25, 2020
Noble is without a doubt, the BEST hero I’ve ever read in a book!
January 17, 2018
Wow, what a beautiful story! I just recently read my first Laura Frantz books and loved them (the first two books in the Ballantyne Legacy). So I had a feeling I would love this one as well, and I did—so very much!
Ms. Frantz has such a way of writing and describing detail that transports the reader to colonial Williamsburg. Her setting is so well written that it takes on a life of its own and almost becomes as important a part of the story as the characters. I don't typically prefer the setting of colonial Williamsburg, but I love it when Ms. Frantz writes about it! I could feel the tension of a Williamsburg that is on the dawn of Revolution. She has a way of writing about history so that you learn a lot and still enjoy an amazing story!
"The Lacemaker" also has characters that the reader will fall in love with. The two main characters are on opposite sides of the political spectrum when the story begins. It is fascinating reading from the two different political viewpoints. I never thought I'd feel sympathy for a Tory, yet I came to see that there are bad guys both among the Patriots and the Loyalists/Tories. Elizabeth (also called Liberty), is our heroine, who has a strong faith. Her example of continuing to pray and seek God, even when her world falls apart, is an inspiration to me. She is even able to find something to be thankful for and thanks God, when everyone has deserted her and she has lost her home. I also like the cameo appearances and references to men like Patrick Henry and George Washington.
Ms. Frantz writes an incredible story, one I wish I had had when I was first learning American history. She makes history come alive. I came to love the setting and the characters! This is a must read for lovers of historical fiction, American history and romance!
Content: I would give this book a PG rating for some minor content. Some examples of the content are: reference to a woman’s daring décolletage, talk of drinking and gambling, a man is drunk, there are almost naked slaves and a brief description of the brutal way they are treated when being auctioned, a reference to the pleasures of marriage as opposed to being celibate and men smoke tobacco.
Rating: I give this book 5 stars!
Genre: Christian Fiction; Historical; Romance.
I want to thank Laura Frantz, LibraryThing Early Reviewers and Revell for the complimentary copy of this book for review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I express in this review are my own. This is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR 16, Part 255.
Ms. Frantz has such a way of writing and describing detail that transports the reader to colonial Williamsburg. Her setting is so well written that it takes on a life of its own and almost becomes as important a part of the story as the characters. I don't typically prefer the setting of colonial Williamsburg, but I love it when Ms. Frantz writes about it! I could feel the tension of a Williamsburg that is on the dawn of Revolution. She has a way of writing about history so that you learn a lot and still enjoy an amazing story!
"The Lacemaker" also has characters that the reader will fall in love with. The two main characters are on opposite sides of the political spectrum when the story begins. It is fascinating reading from the two different political viewpoints. I never thought I'd feel sympathy for a Tory, yet I came to see that there are bad guys both among the Patriots and the Loyalists/Tories. Elizabeth (also called Liberty), is our heroine, who has a strong faith. Her example of continuing to pray and seek God, even when her world falls apart, is an inspiration to me. She is even able to find something to be thankful for and thanks God, when everyone has deserted her and she has lost her home. I also like the cameo appearances and references to men like Patrick Henry and George Washington.
Ms. Frantz writes an incredible story, one I wish I had had when I was first learning American history. She makes history come alive. I came to love the setting and the characters! This is a must read for lovers of historical fiction, American history and romance!
Content: I would give this book a PG rating for some minor content. Some examples of the content are: reference to a woman’s daring décolletage, talk of drinking and gambling, a man is drunk, there are almost naked slaves and a brief description of the brutal way they are treated when being auctioned, a reference to the pleasures of marriage as opposed to being celibate and men smoke tobacco.
Rating: I give this book 5 stars!
Genre: Christian Fiction; Historical; Romance.
I want to thank Laura Frantz, LibraryThing Early Reviewers and Revell for the complimentary copy of this book for review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I express in this review are my own. This is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR 16, Part 255.
February 18, 2018
This was a truly mesmerizing story. Lady Elizabeth Lawson is the daughter of one of the Lords of England who is part of the ruling Tory government of Virginia. Genteel and pampered, she has lived a life of ease and wealth spending her days sewing, lacemaking, and partying. Noble Rynallt is a Welsh descendent with a large Virginia estate who finds himself in league with the Patriot independence seekers and is compatriots with George Washington and Patrick Henry. When things being to explode between the Tories and the Patriots, Lady Elizabeth is caught between the two and must decide what her future will be.
Laura Frantz' historical novels always are deeply entrenched with rich detail of the time period and, in this case, the pre-Revolutionary War events. Her research brings this time period to life with vividness and accuracy.
The characters both major and minor were incredibly well written. Caught in the midst of deception and a self-serving, non-caring father, Libby aka Liberty is filled with courage and determination as she makes her way alone when her father deserts her. I loved her French maid, Isabeau, who even with her craziness stuck by her. Her father and her fiance were both men you love to hate as self-centered as possible. Noble showed how caring and honest he was in supporting Liberty no matter what others may say or write about her. Both Liberty and Noble showed their courage in different ways: Liberty as she played out her spy role, found a way to support herself, and stood up for herself to her father; and Noble as he stood up for Libby, was willing to give his life for her and fulfilled his military service even through he had not been trained for it.
I liked that the romance played a secondary role to the events that Noble and Liberty were caught up in so that the story of the Colonists fight again the Tory tyranny took prominence. Yet at the same time, the gradual development of the romance made their slowly growing feelings even more powerful. Frantz, once again, includes a faith thread that winds its way beautifully throughout the story.
Frantz has once again created a historical fiction novel that will take place among my favorites of this year. Definitely recommend it to all historical fiction readers especially those who love the Revolutionary War time period.
FAVORITE QUOTES: "Some contracts are made to be broken. Perhaps this is one of them. Providence spares us a great many pains we'd inflict on ourselves otherwise."
"Therein lies a lesson. Perhaps the Lord was showing her how brokenness could become abundance in the days to come. 'Twas a hope worth holding on to."
Laura Frantz' historical novels always are deeply entrenched with rich detail of the time period and, in this case, the pre-Revolutionary War events. Her research brings this time period to life with vividness and accuracy.
The characters both major and minor were incredibly well written. Caught in the midst of deception and a self-serving, non-caring father, Libby aka Liberty is filled with courage and determination as she makes her way alone when her father deserts her. I loved her French maid, Isabeau, who even with her craziness stuck by her. Her father and her fiance were both men you love to hate as self-centered as possible. Noble showed how caring and honest he was in supporting Liberty no matter what others may say or write about her. Both Liberty and Noble showed their courage in different ways: Liberty as she played out her spy role, found a way to support herself, and stood up for herself to her father; and Noble as he stood up for Libby, was willing to give his life for her and fulfilled his military service even through he had not been trained for it.
I liked that the romance played a secondary role to the events that Noble and Liberty were caught up in so that the story of the Colonists fight again the Tory tyranny took prominence. Yet at the same time, the gradual development of the romance made their slowly growing feelings even more powerful. Frantz, once again, includes a faith thread that winds its way beautifully throughout the story.
Frantz has once again created a historical fiction novel that will take place among my favorites of this year. Definitely recommend it to all historical fiction readers especially those who love the Revolutionary War time period.
FAVORITE QUOTES: "Some contracts are made to be broken. Perhaps this is one of them. Providence spares us a great many pains we'd inflict on ourselves otherwise."
"Therein lies a lesson. Perhaps the Lord was showing her how brokenness could become abundance in the days to come. 'Twas a hope worth holding on to."
December 16, 2017
I adore every book written by Laura Frantz. Much to my delight this lovely book arrived in the mail early! I have met Laura and after meeting her it makes me love her books all the more, she is the sweetest most down to earth lady! Anywho, this book is wonderful! I LOVE this time period of 1775 and the characters are very well written. Elisabeth is such a unique character, I am not sure how to explain but she is not what you would expect. Honestly, I felt pretty convicted after reading this book about how I worry too much. I feel like an underlying tone in the novel is that we need to take our worries to God and let Him handle it. Not to fret. The book is full of such great chunks of history and I need to read more about lace making, I couldn't imagine doing it myself! In classy Frantz style the romance is written perfectly. Basically as a history lover, this book has it all. I sat down to read it and didn't stop until the end. If you are new to Frantz books, you should read this book. If you have been reading Laura's books for awhile, this much anticipated read is one you will love!
Five stars.
"I received this book from Revell for free. All opinions are my own."
Five stars.
"I received this book from Revell for free. All opinions are my own."
May 15, 2018
The cover of this book grabbed my attention and when it was on sale I purchased a copy.
The historical facts in this story is detailed and very accurate. Top that with intriguing plots, characters you can love and some twists, and you have a great Historical fiction.
Why then the 3 stars? I struggled to get into the story for the first half of the book. It just went so slow for me. There was some references I didn't get with my limited historical knowledge, and after I googled that, it made a lot more sense. The second half grabbed my attention and made me want to turn the pages faster than I could read. The last 30% kept me on the edge of my seat and trying to guess what will happen.
I loved how Libby overcame her circumstances and Noble was just a sigh-worthy gentleman. There was parts of the book that left me in tears.
It really is a beautiful story, one of those who silently speaks to you but at the end made an impact. I would have liked it more if it grabbed my attention from the start, instead of more than halfway through.
The historical facts in this story is detailed and very accurate. Top that with intriguing plots, characters you can love and some twists, and you have a great Historical fiction.
Why then the 3 stars? I struggled to get into the story for the first half of the book. It just went so slow for me. There was some references I didn't get with my limited historical knowledge, and after I googled that, it made a lot more sense. The second half grabbed my attention and made me want to turn the pages faster than I could read. The last 30% kept me on the edge of my seat and trying to guess what will happen.
I loved how Libby overcame her circumstances and Noble was just a sigh-worthy gentleman. There was parts of the book that left me in tears.
It really is a beautiful story, one of those who silently speaks to you but at the end made an impact. I would have liked it more if it grabbed my attention from the start, instead of more than halfway through.
January 13, 2018
The Lacemaker is everything we've grown to love about Laura Frantz's books, with an extra dash of suspense, intrigue, and drama. I was swept from a fine English townhome in Williamsburg to a Welsh estate along the James River, to a colonial tavern, and even to a prison ship. This novel is full of heart and history, demonstrating a wonderful blend of both. Once again, Frantz proves herself to be a master storyteller, using words like a painter uses the brush: lovingly, skillfully, and for the rendering of vivid and complex work of art.
January 25, 2020
"Therefore my harp is turned to mourning and my flute to the sound of those who weep."
Daughter of the wealthy British lieutenant governor of Virginia, Lady Elisabeth Lawson has never truly known the meaning of the name her mother once loving bestowed upon her; "Liberty". Impending nuptials manage to consume nearly all of her attention, even though her groom has been noticeably absent; humiliating both of them by sending his cousin, Noble Rynallt, to escort Elisabeth to a lavish betrothal celebration.
When on the eve of her wedding, Lady Elisabeth's father flees his luxurious town home, leaving his daughter to experience the unbridled havoc of a patriot celebration in the streets of Williamsburg, she witnesses the ransack of her only home, shattering all hopes of a pleasant future. Once again it is the enigmatic Noble Rynallt, a well known Patriot leader, who demonstrates his honor and courage by offering the lady refuge. Trumped by Elisabeth's stubborn determination to support herself as a simple tradeswoman, a lace maker, Noble is forced to let her go.
"I want to protect you, but I do not know how. . . . . . I am not your husband nor your suitor, simply a concerned friend. . . . . . For all she knew he was her one true friend in all of Williamsburg."
It is impossible to ignore the author's lovely lilting way with words, or the courage ingrained deep within each of her characters, or the inspiring history saturating each chapter, for "The Lacemaker" is truly an exquisite display of talent.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions stated are entirely my own.
Daughter of the wealthy British lieutenant governor of Virginia, Lady Elisabeth Lawson has never truly known the meaning of the name her mother once loving bestowed upon her; "Liberty". Impending nuptials manage to consume nearly all of her attention, even though her groom has been noticeably absent; humiliating both of them by sending his cousin, Noble Rynallt, to escort Elisabeth to a lavish betrothal celebration.
When on the eve of her wedding, Lady Elisabeth's father flees his luxurious town home, leaving his daughter to experience the unbridled havoc of a patriot celebration in the streets of Williamsburg, she witnesses the ransack of her only home, shattering all hopes of a pleasant future. Once again it is the enigmatic Noble Rynallt, a well known Patriot leader, who demonstrates his honor and courage by offering the lady refuge. Trumped by Elisabeth's stubborn determination to support herself as a simple tradeswoman, a lace maker, Noble is forced to let her go.
"I want to protect you, but I do not know how. . . . . . I am not your husband nor your suitor, simply a concerned friend. . . . . . For all she knew he was her one true friend in all of Williamsburg."
It is impossible to ignore the author's lovely lilting way with words, or the courage ingrained deep within each of her characters, or the inspiring history saturating each chapter, for "The Lacemaker" is truly an exquisite display of talent.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions stated are entirely my own.
July 11, 2018
Every time I finish a Laura Frantz novel I immediately feel bereft. As if a visit with an old friend has come to an end and I’m sad to say ‘goodbye’. Whether you’re a long-time fan or first-time reader, Frantz does not disappoint. Historically rich and heart-tuggingly sweet, this story will weave its way around your heart and leave you with a bittersweet but satisfied sigh.
In 1775 colonial Williamsburg, Lady Elizabeth Lawson’s world has been turned upside down. The nation is wrought with divided loyalties and the rumblings of war and Elizabeth suddenly finds herself quite alone with no family or fiancé to turn to. True to his name, Independence man Noble Rynallt swoops in to offer his aid. He is quite the swoon-worthy hero with his swarthy good looks and unwavering patriotism.
In a day when uncertainties and fear reign, Noble and Elizabeth find strength and courage in their faith and in each other. A beautiful story set during a perilous period, rich in detail and laced with romance, history lovers and romance devotees alike will find something to enjoy in this book.
When it comes to early American history, Frantz is in a writing class all her own. I have yet to find an author her equal who can paint such a vivid and compelling story, page after page, book after book. I truly cannot get enough and so the Lacemaker will be added to the shelf along side its predecessors, to be read and reread over and over until the well-loved pages are wrinkled, worn and practically memorized.
Thank you Laura Frantz for yet another perfectly penned novel and thank you Revell for providing the book in exchange for an honest review.
In 1775 colonial Williamsburg, Lady Elizabeth Lawson’s world has been turned upside down. The nation is wrought with divided loyalties and the rumblings of war and Elizabeth suddenly finds herself quite alone with no family or fiancé to turn to. True to his name, Independence man Noble Rynallt swoops in to offer his aid. He is quite the swoon-worthy hero with his swarthy good looks and unwavering patriotism.
In a day when uncertainties and fear reign, Noble and Elizabeth find strength and courage in their faith and in each other. A beautiful story set during a perilous period, rich in detail and laced with romance, history lovers and romance devotees alike will find something to enjoy in this book.
When it comes to early American history, Frantz is in a writing class all her own. I have yet to find an author her equal who can paint such a vivid and compelling story, page after page, book after book. I truly cannot get enough and so the Lacemaker will be added to the shelf along side its predecessors, to be read and reread over and over until the well-loved pages are wrinkled, worn and practically memorized.
Thank you Laura Frantz for yet another perfectly penned novel and thank you Revell for providing the book in exchange for an honest review.
November 1, 2021
This was my Hidden Gem for the month of October. A book I requested and has been on my Kindle for far too long.
This is the story of Elizabeth Lawson (Liberty), the daughter of the Earl of Stirling. While her father (a Tory) abandons her on the night of their house being ransacked, her mother on her way back from England, Elizabeth is left to fend for herself - find lodging and a means to support herself. The only place that will hire her is The Raleigh, the meeting place of the high Patriots. One of those Patriots, Noble Rynallt, takes Liberty under his wing. With working at The Raleigh, Liberty hears certain things to relay to her father, but which side of the truth does she tell him?
I like this book very much. It was a little slow in the beginning learning all the characters, some I liked, some I didn't like. I liked the slow burn of the romance that built between Libby and Noble. In all a good read.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this advanced copy.
This is the story of Elizabeth Lawson (Liberty), the daughter of the Earl of Stirling. While her father (a Tory) abandons her on the night of their house being ransacked, her mother on her way back from England, Elizabeth is left to fend for herself - find lodging and a means to support herself. The only place that will hire her is The Raleigh, the meeting place of the high Patriots. One of those Patriots, Noble Rynallt, takes Liberty under his wing. With working at The Raleigh, Liberty hears certain things to relay to her father, but which side of the truth does she tell him?
I like this book very much. It was a little slow in the beginning learning all the characters, some I liked, some I didn't like. I liked the slow burn of the romance that built between Libby and Noble. In all a good read.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this advanced copy.
December 17, 2017
A sweeping tale with amazing historical detail! The beginning of the book started out a little slow for my taste, but layer upon layer was served up into a delicious story that leaves the reader satisfied. Noble was definitely a swoon-worthy hero in my eyes (I think I have a thing for heroes that use terms of endearment in another language) and Libby grew into a gentle strength that she wasn't aware she possessed at the beginning. I've always wanted to go to Colonial Williamsburg and that desire has only intensified ten-fold! A must read for those who love historical romances.
January 17, 2018
Warning: This book is going to hit you in the heart more times than you can count. Be prepared for giddiness, but also tears. I have warned you, so read at your own risk.
When colonial Williamsburg explodes like a powder keg on the eve of the American Revolution, Lady Elisabeth "Liberty" Lawson is abandoned by her fiancé and suspected of being a spy for the hated British. No one comes to her aid save the Patriot Noble Rynallt, a man with formidable enemies of his own. Liberty is left with a terrible choice. Will the Virginia belle turned lacemaker side with the radical revolutionaries, or stay true to her English roots? And at what cost?
Her life was perfect, Elizabeth, soon to be Liberty, was the bride of Williamsburg. Her fiancé was a rich, powerful man by the name of Miles Roth, her father was the British lieutenant governor of the Virginia Colony. She was as pampered and waited on as any woman of her status was. It wasn't until the "Liberty" men were starting to take over Williamsburg, that her life began to fall apart. Her father and close family friends left her to fend for herself on the eve of her wedding. Her fiancé did not come to her help, but rather his dashing, patriotic cousin, Noble Rynallt. He took her in and treated her as a guest, even though she was a Tory.
At crossroads, she decided that she would leave Ty Mawr and become a lacemaker in Williamsburg. Elizabeth, now Liberty, went from the pampered, prize of Williamsburg to a servant at Raleigh's, a popular gathering place for "Liberty" men like George Washington and Patrick Henry. A few months later, people started to go around with a rumor that Liberty was a spy for her father. After being confronted by Noble about this, she decided that she would instead spy on her father for the "Liberty" men.
As expected, sparks were flying in-between Liberty and Noble. They soon developed a relationship and it was so bitter sweet. I am not going to say anything more on their relationship for now, I don't want to spoil anything for you!
Ugh, this book was so good! There were so many great things in it, I just don't know where to start......
1. The story and plot line. When I first picked up this book, I did not expect to read what I ended up reading. This book had so many great plot twists that it keep me on my seat all 416 pages. It was a bit slow in some parts but for the most part it was a very well written book. Usually I am able to predict what is going to happen in books, but because this was so beautifully written, I just could not figure out what was happening next. If you are into adventure and crazy plot twists then this book is for you!
2. Romance. Noble and Liberty's relationship was so sweet! Their love for each other made me want to run around my house squealing! I loved how protective and caring Noble was for Libby, he even risked his life for her towards the end. If there was a book just about Noble and Liberty's love I would read it. Even though their relationship was just like any other Christian fiction romance, theirs’s seemed to be more special and dearer then others. Not saying that other Christian fiction couples don't have dear relationships theirs’s just has a special place in my heart.
3. Time period. I have read plenty of Revolutionary War themed books, but this one brought the war to a whole new light. Laura, told the story in both Noble's and Liberty's perspective, so we get the war in both a woman's and man's perspective. They both were very involved in the war. I really wish that this book was longer just so I could see how the rest of their lives played out.
4. Character Development. There was great character development in this book. This is one thing that this book was not lacking. I loved seeing Liberty go from a pampered high society woman, to a low servant in a matter of days. The best part was that she didn't even complain once about it.
5. Noble Rynallt. Noble was just a great male lead character. I could not have picked a better name for him. He was noble, dashing, caring, and loving to Liberty. Noble was always turning to God for guidance and praying. He would turn to God when he was in need and pain. He was always treating others as equals and not as trash. He was kind to everyone and helped the poor and needy. He was always willing to lend an extra hand to Liberty when she was in need of help. She could not have asked for a better man.
6. Liberty Lawson. Liberty is one of my favorite Christian fiction female leads. She was exactly the type of woman you would expect to find in colonial America. Even though, she grew up rich and pampered. She was not afraid to get her hands dirty. She was the type of woman that we need more of in this world. She did not complain about where God had placed her instead she embraced it and took it as well as she could. She prayed daily and was always turning to God in times of trouble and was trusting God through all her trials and tribulations.
7. This book was just so good overall. I highly recommend it, it was overall just a great historical fiction, romance read.
*I received this book from Revell Publishers in exchange for my honest review. All words are my own. *
http://www.harderfamilyadventures.com...
When colonial Williamsburg explodes like a powder keg on the eve of the American Revolution, Lady Elisabeth "Liberty" Lawson is abandoned by her fiancé and suspected of being a spy for the hated British. No one comes to her aid save the Patriot Noble Rynallt, a man with formidable enemies of his own. Liberty is left with a terrible choice. Will the Virginia belle turned lacemaker side with the radical revolutionaries, or stay true to her English roots? And at what cost?
Her life was perfect, Elizabeth, soon to be Liberty, was the bride of Williamsburg. Her fiancé was a rich, powerful man by the name of Miles Roth, her father was the British lieutenant governor of the Virginia Colony. She was as pampered and waited on as any woman of her status was. It wasn't until the "Liberty" men were starting to take over Williamsburg, that her life began to fall apart. Her father and close family friends left her to fend for herself on the eve of her wedding. Her fiancé did not come to her help, but rather his dashing, patriotic cousin, Noble Rynallt. He took her in and treated her as a guest, even though she was a Tory.
At crossroads, she decided that she would leave Ty Mawr and become a lacemaker in Williamsburg. Elizabeth, now Liberty, went from the pampered, prize of Williamsburg to a servant at Raleigh's, a popular gathering place for "Liberty" men like George Washington and Patrick Henry. A few months later, people started to go around with a rumor that Liberty was a spy for her father. After being confronted by Noble about this, she decided that she would instead spy on her father for the "Liberty" men.
As expected, sparks were flying in-between Liberty and Noble. They soon developed a relationship and it was so bitter sweet. I am not going to say anything more on their relationship for now, I don't want to spoil anything for you!
Ugh, this book was so good! There were so many great things in it, I just don't know where to start......
1. The story and plot line. When I first picked up this book, I did not expect to read what I ended up reading. This book had so many great plot twists that it keep me on my seat all 416 pages. It was a bit slow in some parts but for the most part it was a very well written book. Usually I am able to predict what is going to happen in books, but because this was so beautifully written, I just could not figure out what was happening next. If you are into adventure and crazy plot twists then this book is for you!
2. Romance. Noble and Liberty's relationship was so sweet! Their love for each other made me want to run around my house squealing! I loved how protective and caring Noble was for Libby, he even risked his life for her towards the end. If there was a book just about Noble and Liberty's love I would read it. Even though their relationship was just like any other Christian fiction romance, theirs’s seemed to be more special and dearer then others. Not saying that other Christian fiction couples don't have dear relationships theirs’s just has a special place in my heart.
3. Time period. I have read plenty of Revolutionary War themed books, but this one brought the war to a whole new light. Laura, told the story in both Noble's and Liberty's perspective, so we get the war in both a woman's and man's perspective. They both were very involved in the war. I really wish that this book was longer just so I could see how the rest of their lives played out.
4. Character Development. There was great character development in this book. This is one thing that this book was not lacking. I loved seeing Liberty go from a pampered high society woman, to a low servant in a matter of days. The best part was that she didn't even complain once about it.
5. Noble Rynallt. Noble was just a great male lead character. I could not have picked a better name for him. He was noble, dashing, caring, and loving to Liberty. Noble was always turning to God for guidance and praying. He would turn to God when he was in need and pain. He was always treating others as equals and not as trash. He was kind to everyone and helped the poor and needy. He was always willing to lend an extra hand to Liberty when she was in need of help. She could not have asked for a better man.
6. Liberty Lawson. Liberty is one of my favorite Christian fiction female leads. She was exactly the type of woman you would expect to find in colonial America. Even though, she grew up rich and pampered. She was not afraid to get her hands dirty. She was the type of woman that we need more of in this world. She did not complain about where God had placed her instead she embraced it and took it as well as she could. She prayed daily and was always turning to God in times of trouble and was trusting God through all her trials and tribulations.
7. This book was just so good overall. I highly recommend it, it was overall just a great historical fiction, romance read.
*I received this book from Revell Publishers in exchange for my honest review. All words are my own. *
http://www.harderfamilyadventures.com...
July 23, 2019
It look me a long time to get through this book cause of life but oh, what a joy it was to read!! Having had vacationed in Williamsburg last spring helped me really be able to imagine that time.🥰 The middle of the book slowed down a bit for me, but by heavens the later chapters really picked up pace! I loved the love story between Noble and Liberty and enjoyed watching their romance blossom. To no surprise, I absolutely love anything by Laura Frantz. Our mutual love for colonial America doesn’t hurt.💖
February 12, 2018
Noble Rynallt is just… perfect. Seriously, I can’t think of one area in which he lacks. Well, maybe one. He was a little slow starting the, um, honeymoon, but I’m sure that was for the benefit of the reader.
This isn’t the first time one of Laura Frantz’s heroes has ended up on my Book Boyfriend list, and I doubt it will be the last. As a matter of fact, I don’t believe I have given one of her novels below five stars. I love how she brings history alive.
This isn’t the first time one of Laura Frantz’s heroes has ended up on my Book Boyfriend list, and I doubt it will be the last. As a matter of fact, I don’t believe I have given one of her novels below five stars. I love how she brings history alive.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 731 reviews