Funny, Sly, Wise, and Big-Hearted
Not to get too gushy or to exaggerate but, "no brag. Just a fact", this is a nearly perfect middle grade book.
The set up appears simple enough. Steve and his two pals just barely make the school baseball team. At the beginning of the season one player gets his nose smashed by a pitch, and Steve, who watched it happen, develops Bean-O-Phobia. He now fears pitched balls. Since Steve spends most games on the bench he is called upon only infrequently to actually bat, but when he does bat he is frozen by fear and does terribly. Naturally, in the big end of the season championship game he is called upon to bat in a critical situation.
Seems pretty predictable, if not downright clichéd, right? Well wait. The author, Steve Moore, does everything right, never sounds a single false or off note, and does something fresh with the setup. (And even the drawings are smack on the money.)
First off, our hero Steve is a hoot. Moore pulls off the very difficult job of making the hero smart, funny and observant, as well as articulate and insightful, while still having him come across as a sometimes goofy and totally realistic and relatable middle grade kid. I've read a lot of books with middle grade heroes who think and speak like adults, and I've read even more books with middle grade heroes who are manic and oblivious, but it's awfully rare to get a hero who does double duty so well. With a kid like this at the center of a book, you are already halfway home. (Note the baseball metaphor there.)
On top of that we get some twists and turns in the story, (NO SPOILERS HERE), that confound one's expectations but lead to a happy, instructive and upbeat conclusion for everybody. The bench-sitting, the Bean-O-Phobia, the teasing from the jocks, the 0-for-100 batting, and the last inning hero challenge all get resolved in a satisfying, amusing, and right-feeling way.
But even if you put that aside, there's something else going on. This book excels at three other things that I very much admire, and that you don't find that often. First, the author slips in a lot of one and two sentence asides and throwaway lines that are just funny, observant or touching on their own and only tangentially related to the plot. Just odd bits of description or passing opinions. Second, the author is great at mini-scenes that contribute to the story but aren't necessary. Steve's discussion of Dad-fear, when Dads show up at games. Or Steve's description of how weird his school feels and sounds because all of the floors are carpeted. Or Steve's description of the odd behavior of the fans when he plays a team from a snooty private school. And so on. None of this is essential to the plot, but it adds depth, rhythm and richness to the book, (something often missing from middle grade sports humor). Finally, there is funny stuff that's totally over the head of any middle grade reader and is there for older kids and parents, (like the Muppet movies can be). For example, the names of the schools Steve's team plays are a riot.
So, I could go on, but the bottom line is that this is a sweet, funny, wryly observant and upbeat middle grade story of the first order, and a swell find. (Please note that I received a free advance ecopy of this book without a review requirement, or any influence regarding review content should I choose to post a review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)