What do you think?
Rate this book
Meryton Mystery #2
The Indomitable Miss Elizabeth
In a battle of wills between Lady Catherine and Mrs. Bennet, only one will come out alive… When a devastating secret is revealed, Elizabeth Bennet’s future happiness is pitted against the loyalty of the man she loves. Fitzwilliam Darcy is more determined than ever to win Elizabeth’s love—no matter what obstacles their families place between them. But then a killer strikes a fatal blow in the middle of a military parade. With a murderer on the loose and their hearts on the line, can Darcy and Elizabeth work together to solve another mystery? Or will the pressure break them apart forever? The Indomitable Miss Elizabeth is a fast-paced mystery interwoven with a sweet and wholesome Regency romance inspired by Jane Austen's timeless classic, Pride and Prejudice. It is the second novel in the A Meryton Mystery series.
362 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 14, 2017
150 people are currently reading
114 people want to read
About the author
Jennifer Joy
45 books209 followersWhen Jennifer isn’t busy dreaming up new adventures for her favorite characters, she is reading, baking, or chasing her twins around the park.
She believes in happy endings, sweet romance, and plenty of intrigue. She writes what she most enjoys reading, so expect lighthearted stories with happy endings and a few laughs.
Born on the beautiful Oregon coast, she traveled all around the world until she finally settled in the Andes Mountains of Ecuador with her husband and two kids.
She believes in happy endings, sweet romance, and plenty of intrigue. She writes what she most enjoys reading, so expect lighthearted stories with happy endings and a few laughs.
Born on the beautiful Oregon coast, she traveled all around the world until she finally settled in the Andes Mountains of Ecuador with her husband and two kids.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews
February 8, 2022
4.5 stars rounded up to 5 stars.
In this second of Jennifer Joy's mysteries, a matron well known in the Meryton Society, is found murdered. It seems to be the author's Modus Operandi to never leave a clue as to who the murderer might be. Even in knowing this from her first mystery and selecting the person in my mind who might fit this description...I was wrong. So good luck if you think you might have intuitive strength in solving crimes such as this.
Elizabeth and Darcy have not yet entered into an engagement after the first tale in which he was a suspect in the murder of Wickham. Both have insecurities and even reasons to think that the other might not actually want a marriage. And in this story, Lady Catherine shows up with her daughter. Now we find a second mystery which can be considered as part of canon. Just what is Anne de Bourgh's problem? Is there any medical man in Regency times who can diagnose such? And did you ever suspect that Lady Catwitch may have been a "jilt"?
But that is all just part of the overall story. Getting back to the other parts...what is this LAMB society? Why is it secret, who are its members & for what purpose do they meet? And furthermore why must membership be by invitation only. What a creative touch this author brings to the Hertfordshire history.
Darcy, AGAIN, seems to be at cross purposes with the words out of his mouth and those he carries in his heart. And Elizabeth: you know how so often she will put other person's needs before her own - even when such acts may doom her life to loneliness.
You should really have read the first book in this series as some parts may be a mystery in being able to understand everyone's part in this book. Tanner - big brother to who? The Colonel is sweet on which lady?
A new character, Lord Harvisham, is delightful in his views about marriage and in his handling of the case in his position as magistrate. An older gentleman who actually towers higher than Fitzwilliam Darcy, he brings a lot to the table as facts are considered and witnesses interviewed.
I stayed up late to finish this story so that is one reason to know that I enjoyed this book and that I look forward to the next in this series. Very imaginative and well written!
In this second of Jennifer Joy's mysteries, a matron well known in the Meryton Society, is found murdered. It seems to be the author's Modus Operandi to never leave a clue as to who the murderer might be. Even in knowing this from her first mystery and selecting the person in my mind who might fit this description...I was wrong. So good luck if you think you might have intuitive strength in solving crimes such as this.
Elizabeth and Darcy have not yet entered into an engagement after the first tale in which he was a suspect in the murder of Wickham. Both have insecurities and even reasons to think that the other might not actually want a marriage. And in this story, Lady Catherine shows up with her daughter. Now we find a second mystery which can be considered as part of canon. Just what is Anne de Bourgh's problem? Is there any medical man in Regency times who can diagnose such? And did you ever suspect that Lady Catwitch may have been a "jilt"?
But that is all just part of the overall story. Getting back to the other parts...what is this LAMB society? Why is it secret, who are its members & for what purpose do they meet? And furthermore why must membership be by invitation only. What a creative touch this author brings to the Hertfordshire history.
Darcy, AGAIN, seems to be at cross purposes with the words out of his mouth and those he carries in his heart. And Elizabeth: you know how so often she will put other person's needs before her own - even when such acts may doom her life to loneliness.
You should really have read the first book in this series as some parts may be a mystery in being able to understand everyone's part in this book. Tanner - big brother to who? The Colonel is sweet on which lady?
A new character, Lord Harvisham, is delightful in his views about marriage and in his handling of the case in his position as magistrate. An older gentleman who actually towers higher than Fitzwilliam Darcy, he brings a lot to the table as facts are considered and witnesses interviewed.
I stayed up late to finish this story so that is one reason to know that I enjoyed this book and that I look forward to the next in this series. Very imaginative and well written!
March 17, 2023
Victory attained by violence is tantamount to a defeat, for it is momentary. ~Gandhi
One of Meryton’s most prominent married women has been murdered.
All signs point to only one suspect – Lady Catherine De Bourgh.
But there must be other possibilities! Elizabeth Bennet is determined to discover the culprit.
So many questions to answer:
1. A regular gathering of some village ladies seems odd. What do these townspeople have in common with the Bingley sisters? And what is the significance of LAMB?
2. What is Anne De Bourgh’s mysterious illness? Why does it require her to be married so very soon? Could Darcy be involved in this illness?
3. When did Lady Lucas acquire a new clock? What happened to an inkwell that disappeared from the murder scene?
4. Why does Lady Catherine’s former suitor appear in Meryton? What does he have to do with justice for his one-time sweetheart?
Corn can't expect justice from a court composed of chickens. ~African Proverb
The murderer is ultimately discovered by that well-known detective, Mr. Collins … or was it?
“The Indomitable Miss Elizabeth” is a well-constructed murder mystery – a sequel to “The Honorable Mr. Darcy”. When I read sequels, I very often must go back to the previous book for a quick scan to get details in my mind before continuing. The original in this series was unique enough to stay in my memory and I didn’t need a re-read – high praise indeed.
Do you get to the end of a book you liked and wish it would continue?
Jennifer Joy has arranged two solutions:
(1) Subscribe to the author’s newsletter and receive a short prequel to this story and
(2) Watch for the third book in the series.
Can a village as small as Meryton have enough inhabitants for more murders? Cabot Cove, Maine had enough murderers for 264 episodes. Surely Meryton can support one more!
All violence is the result of people tricking themselves into believing that their pain derives from other people and that consequently those people deserve to be punished. ~Marshall Rosenberg
One of Meryton’s most prominent married women has been murdered.
All signs point to only one suspect – Lady Catherine De Bourgh.
But there must be other possibilities! Elizabeth Bennet is determined to discover the culprit.
So many questions to answer:
1. A regular gathering of some village ladies seems odd. What do these townspeople have in common with the Bingley sisters? And what is the significance of LAMB?
2. What is Anne De Bourgh’s mysterious illness? Why does it require her to be married so very soon? Could Darcy be involved in this illness?
3. When did Lady Lucas acquire a new clock? What happened to an inkwell that disappeared from the murder scene?
4. Why does Lady Catherine’s former suitor appear in Meryton? What does he have to do with justice for his one-time sweetheart?
Corn can't expect justice from a court composed of chickens. ~African Proverb
The murderer is ultimately discovered by that well-known detective, Mr. Collins … or was it?
“The Indomitable Miss Elizabeth” is a well-constructed murder mystery – a sequel to “The Honorable Mr. Darcy”. When I read sequels, I very often must go back to the previous book for a quick scan to get details in my mind before continuing. The original in this series was unique enough to stay in my memory and I didn’t need a re-read – high praise indeed.
Do you get to the end of a book you liked and wish it would continue?
Jennifer Joy has arranged two solutions:
(1) Subscribe to the author’s newsletter and receive a short prequel to this story and
(2) Watch for the third book in the series.
Can a village as small as Meryton have enough inhabitants for more murders? Cabot Cove, Maine had enough murderers for 264 episodes. Surely Meryton can support one more!
All violence is the result of people tricking themselves into believing that their pain derives from other people and that consequently those people deserve to be punished. ~Marshall Rosenberg
March 24, 2017
4.5 rounded up to 5 stars
I enjoyed this mystery even better than the first in this series. Ms. Joy does a wonderful job of meshing the Darcy/Elizabeth romance (and the Bingley/Jane romance) along with a murder mystery. The events in this story do follow sequentially after the previous book, though it can be read as a standalone. You may not fully appreciate the various references to what has previously happened, but they're not that important in order to follow and enjoy this entertaining story.
Once the murder takes place, there are numerous red herrings waved in front of the reader. Lady Catherine has recently barged into town with the usual blustering and bellowing. She seems to have the most obvious motive, and no one can vouch for her location at the time of the murder. But there's also a secret society in Meryton the Bennets have no prior knowledge of, and their purpose is related to the victim. Members of this society were observed in the vicinity at the time of the killing. Other suspects emerge as the local constable (Mr. Tanner, Darcy's half-brother), magistrate (Lord Harvisham, who has a shocking past with Lady Catherine) and Darcy work to gather clues. Is the murder weapon a mantel clock? Or was it something else? Was it perhaps an accident, with the victim hitting her head on the edge of a heavy table?
The plot thickens in fascinating ways. Mrs. Bennet, as usual, is insensitive, rude and relentless in her efforts to marry off her daughters. Lady Catherine is keeping a number of secrets, with one involving her daughter Anne and another involving her own health. Good ole Darcy is doing his best to help the Bennet family for Elizabeth's sake, but he's best at lodging his foot securely in his mouth and not even realizing it whenever he and his lady love converse. Colonel Fitzwilliam is on the case, too, and he pursues a romance in Meryton. Mr. Bennet's reaction to the death is somewhat surprising; one would not expect him to be so moved. By the book's end, it is nice to see him endeavoring to take a more active role as head of the family.
All of these elements are integrated perfectly, with interesting characters, nice romantic moments, and a mystery that will keep you guessing to the end. As other reviewers have commented, the pattern in this and the first book seems to be that an unlikely individual ends up as the culprit. Even with that knowledge, I couldn't pinpoint the right person. Once the murderer was identified, I did go back and reread some sections where that character appeared, and I could find some indications of the motivation for the killing, but the context was too benign for me to register them as such. Well done, Ms. Joy!
I enjoyed this mystery even better than the first in this series. Ms. Joy does a wonderful job of meshing the Darcy/Elizabeth romance (and the Bingley/Jane romance) along with a murder mystery. The events in this story do follow sequentially after the previous book, though it can be read as a standalone. You may not fully appreciate the various references to what has previously happened, but they're not that important in order to follow and enjoy this entertaining story.
Once the murder takes place, there are numerous red herrings waved in front of the reader. Lady Catherine has recently barged into town with the usual blustering and bellowing. She seems to have the most obvious motive, and no one can vouch for her location at the time of the murder. But there's also a secret society in Meryton the Bennets have no prior knowledge of, and their purpose is related to the victim. Members of this society were observed in the vicinity at the time of the killing. Other suspects emerge as the local constable (Mr. Tanner, Darcy's half-brother), magistrate (Lord Harvisham, who has a shocking past with Lady Catherine) and Darcy work to gather clues. Is the murder weapon a mantel clock? Or was it something else? Was it perhaps an accident, with the victim hitting her head on the edge of a heavy table?
The plot thickens in fascinating ways. Mrs. Bennet, as usual, is insensitive, rude and relentless in her efforts to marry off her daughters. Lady Catherine is keeping a number of secrets, with one involving her daughter Anne and another involving her own health. Good ole Darcy is doing his best to help the Bennet family for Elizabeth's sake, but he's best at lodging his foot securely in his mouth and not even realizing it whenever he and his lady love converse. Colonel Fitzwilliam is on the case, too, and he pursues a romance in Meryton. Mr. Bennet's reaction to the death is somewhat surprising; one would not expect him to be so moved. By the book's end, it is nice to see him endeavoring to take a more active role as head of the family.
All of these elements are integrated perfectly, with interesting characters, nice romantic moments, and a mystery that will keep you guessing to the end. As other reviewers have commented, the pattern in this and the first book seems to be that an unlikely individual ends up as the culprit. Even with that knowledge, I couldn't pinpoint the right person. Once the murderer was identified, I did go back and reread some sections where that character appeared, and I could find some indications of the motivation for the killing, but the context was too benign for me to register them as such. Well done, Ms. Joy!
November 14, 2022
My heart when the victim was revealed! Not expecting that one.
Loved the 2nd book in this series.
Lady C is in town making trouble for ODC and with the obnoxious behavior of Mrs B there were too many suspects to count.
Can't thank the author enough for making this audiobook available to us readers on YouTube.
Such generosity!!
Loved the 2nd book in this series.
Lady C is in town making trouble for ODC and with the obnoxious behavior of Mrs B there were too many suspects to count.
Can't thank the author enough for making this audiobook available to us readers on YouTube.
Such generosity!!
November 28, 2022
Another murder in Meryton! The victim was quite a shock and the killer was surprising. It was good in terms of the mystery but Elizabeth does a lot of willful misunderstanding when it comes to Darcy. He’s used to getting what he wants without explanation so Elizabeth always thinks the worst which was frustrating to read. Her inability to believe Darcy when he says he won’t marry his cousin Anne went on a little too long, but of course there is resolution at the end. Lady Catherine is a handful in this one, and at one point a suspect. She interferes with Darcy as much as possible and puts Caroline Bingley in her place. There are four engagements and a wedding by the end.
March 21, 2017
This is book two in the Meryton Mysteries series. I believe you MUST read the first book to keep from being completely, utterly, totally confused. I read the first book in October of 2016 and I was fairly confused until I recalled the details of that story. There are just enough changes to make you scratch your head frequently. I think the author should have included a brief synopsis of Book 1 in the beginning. It is sort of like watching The Empire strikes back before Star Wars: A New Hope.
Here's my version of the introductory scroll
Mr. Wickham is Dead
Darcy was exonerated, but wouldn't risk Miss Elizabeth's reputation to save his own.
Darcy has found a natural ½ brother living in Meryton
Miss Lucas isn't married to Mr. Collins
Kitty is engaged to Lt. Denny
Jane and Lizzy are waiting for their gentlemen to propose
Lizzy, despite her improved relationship with Mr. Darcy is worried about his consistency.
…...
When a beloved P&P character is murdered everyone is a suspect except the people who discovered the body. There is some sort of secret conspiracy a foot that includes Lady Lucas, the Bingley sisters and a few tradeswomen. Lady Catherine had threatened the victim and been threatened in return. Lady Catherine's former suitor coming to town as the magistrate can only make things worse for her. Anne de Bourgh has a secret in her illness, what could it be. (My guesses hermaphrodite or pregnancy – nope I was wrong). There are so many suspects yet the risk of naming on in a small town of 4 and twenty families keeps the investigators silent. When the murderer is revealed it will be quiet a surprise.
Pet peeves – this Lizzy is much too selfless when it comes to Darcy; absurdly so. I wouldn't give up a man I loved because his cousin was sickly and needy. In other aspects she is much too self-deprecating constantly feeling that she hasn't done enough or that she is cruel. This isn't classic Lizzy – she is kind but she isn't stupid or lacking self interest.
During many passages Lady Catherine is referred to only as Aunt. Only Darcy & Col. Fitzwilliam could call her Aunt and usually call her Lady Catherine. Using Aunt as a proper noun is confusing.
Here's my version of the introductory scroll
Mr. Wickham is Dead
Darcy was exonerated, but wouldn't risk Miss Elizabeth's reputation to save his own.
Darcy has found a natural ½ brother living in Meryton
Miss Lucas isn't married to Mr. Collins
Kitty is engaged to Lt. Denny
Jane and Lizzy are waiting for their gentlemen to propose
Lizzy, despite her improved relationship with Mr. Darcy is worried about his consistency.
…...
When a beloved P&P character is murdered everyone is a suspect except the people who discovered the body. There is some sort of secret conspiracy a foot that includes Lady Lucas, the Bingley sisters and a few tradeswomen. Lady Catherine had threatened the victim and been threatened in return. Lady Catherine's former suitor coming to town as the magistrate can only make things worse for her. Anne de Bourgh has a secret in her illness, what could it be. (My guesses hermaphrodite or pregnancy – nope I was wrong). There are so many suspects yet the risk of naming on in a small town of 4 and twenty families keeps the investigators silent. When the murderer is revealed it will be quiet a surprise.
Pet peeves – this Lizzy is much too selfless when it comes to Darcy; absurdly so. I wouldn't give up a man I loved because his cousin was sickly and needy. In other aspects she is much too self-deprecating constantly feeling that she hasn't done enough or that she is cruel. This isn't classic Lizzy – she is kind but she isn't stupid or lacking self interest.
During many passages Lady Catherine is referred to only as Aunt. Only Darcy & Col. Fitzwilliam could call her Aunt and usually call her Lady Catherine. Using Aunt as a proper noun is confusing.
March 20, 2017
Shocking! Another murder in Meryton! I can just see this being flashed across the front page of a newspaper if one existed in Meryton! The victim never saw it coming and there are no witnesses! This was a fast paced tightly woven tale with more than one mystery involved. Lady Catherine has also arrived in Meryton with her daughter, Anne, with the sole intent of getting Mr. Darcy to marry her! But why come all the way to Meryton? What dire circumstances would push Lady Catherine to this point? Miss Elizabeth is bound and determined to bring the murderer to justice but at what cost to herself. Will the truths uncovered cause a break between her and Mr. Darcy or will it bind them closer together.
I so enjoyed this tale. It was a mix of shock and awe with a touch of tongue-in-cheek and humor! Mrs. Bennet was brilliant standing up to Lady Catherine. Lord Harvisham, the magistrate, was definitely a worthy character that I would like to see more of! The back story between him and Lady Catherine was fascinating and you can read it if you sign up for Ms. Joy's newsletter! Mr. Tanner and Colonel Fitzwilliam were a constant sore in Darcy's side but he gave as good as he got!
I would love to offer more praise, but I fear giving away too much information! I will say I did determine the murderer right this time! However, I was wrong in what I thought was Anne de Bourgh's malady. I highly recommend this sequel to Meryton Mystery #1 The Honorable Mr. Darcy! I look forward with great anticipation to Meryton Mystery #3.
I so enjoyed this tale. It was a mix of shock and awe with a touch of tongue-in-cheek and humor! Mrs. Bennet was brilliant standing up to Lady Catherine. Lord Harvisham, the magistrate, was definitely a worthy character that I would like to see more of! The back story between him and Lady Catherine was fascinating and you can read it if you sign up for Ms. Joy's newsletter! Mr. Tanner and Colonel Fitzwilliam were a constant sore in Darcy's side but he gave as good as he got!
I would love to offer more praise, but I fear giving away too much information! I will say I did determine the murderer right this time! However, I was wrong in what I thought was Anne de Bourgh's malady. I highly recommend this sequel to Meryton Mystery #1 The Honorable Mr. Darcy! I look forward with great anticipation to Meryton Mystery #3.
January 18, 2023
Lovely audiobook!
4.5 ⭐
I wasn't expecting that person to be murdered but I was right with one of my suspects!
Lady C's past is a but surprising.
You can listen to it on: https://youtu.be/IZUzVWBFyyc
4.5 ⭐
I wasn't expecting that person to be murdered but I was right with one of my suspects!
Lady C's past is a but surprising.
You can listen to it on: https://youtu.be/IZUzVWBFyyc
January 24, 2024
What will happen if Mrs.Bennet and Lady Catherine compete for their daughters' groom? The murder victim was unexpected and the murderer a surprise. The many twists of the story are gery interesting.
March 18, 2017
Great mystery and romance
I loved Meryton Mystery Book 2 as much as Book 1. The plot is excellent, and the original characters are very well developed. I was proud of myself that I have guessed the identities of both the victim and the murderer correctly, as well as the nature of Anne's illness (no spoilers, you have to read it yourself.) The clues are there.
ODC wouldn't be themselves without their fair amount of misunderstandings and stubbornness. But as usual, they managed to move past them and learned to understand each other better.
My favorite original character was Lord Harvisham, and I especially enjoyed his interactions with Darcy, colonel Fitzwilliam and Tanner. And the good colonel got his HEA in one of my favorite alternative pairing.
Looking forward to the next book in the series.
I loved Meryton Mystery Book 2 as much as Book 1. The plot is excellent, and the original characters are very well developed. I was proud of myself that I have guessed the identities of both the victim and the murderer correctly, as well as the nature of Anne's illness (no spoilers, you have to read it yourself.) The clues are there.
ODC wouldn't be themselves without their fair amount of misunderstandings and stubbornness. But as usual, they managed to move past them and learned to understand each other better.
My favorite original character was Lord Harvisham, and I especially enjoyed his interactions with Darcy, colonel Fitzwilliam and Tanner. And the good colonel got his HEA in one of my favorite alternative pairing.
Looking forward to the next book in the series.
June 18, 2017
A Murder Mystery..
I don't want to give anything away, therefore, I'm just going to say that it kept me in suspense to the very end.
An overall, engaging read.
Nancy Peterson did well with the narration as usual.
Note:
"This audio book was provided by the author, narrator, or publisher at no
cost in exchange for an unbiased review."
March 28, 2017
I loved certain additional characters in this second book of the series but there was little dramatic tension for me and the villain was obvious. The lack of distress by the family of the murder victim was also off-putting.
September 25, 2017
After clearing his name of Wickham's murder in the first novel, Darcy and Elizabeth still have a long way to go before their happily ever after. The story begins with Mrs. Bennett and her five daughters shopping in Meryton. Lizzy meets Darcy as he enters the town, and perpetual matchmaker Mrs. Bennett convinces Darcy to escort Lizzy home. Lizzy hasn't seen Darcy in over two weeks and things are still uncertain between them. While Lizzy hasn't allowed herself to give her whole heart to Darcy, she has given him permission to court her. Darcy walks her home, and their wonderful flirtation over books gives him hope.
Returning to Meryton, Darcy and Col Fitzwilliam are dismayed to see Lady Catherine de Bourgh and Anne arrive to stay at the local inn. Anne is overtaken by a shocking illness, and the family struggles to keep it quiet. During the militia's parade a few days later, Elizabeth discovers the body of a person very dear to her. Overwhelmed with grief, she determines to find the murderer and bring them to justice.
Rather than being a rehash of the same events from the original Pride and Prejudice, this is a completely fresh plot. The introduction of new shopkeepers and other residents of Meryton expand the familiar circle of characters and keep the story fresh. There are a few characters introduced in the first book that appear in this one but it's easy to infer what their relationships are without lengthy explanations. This can truly be read as a standalone novel without spoiling the ending of the first book.
Darcy and Lizzy are portrayed perfectly in this version, and their interactions and conversations are so sweet. We get a glimpse of a new side to Mr. Bennett that I loved. A new father figure for Darcy is introduced, and I hope we see more of him in future novels.
Good luck guessing the identity of the killer! The murder plot is nicely done and there are well placed red herrings and clues throughout. There are a few twists and reveals that had me gasping and hitting the rewind button to make sure that I heard right. The mystery and the romance are given equal weight in the story and they don't detract from each other.
Nancy Peterson was the perfect narrator for this book. From the beginning I loved her voices for each character, especially Mrs. Bennett and Lady Catherine. They just seemed so authentic and sounded exactly like I pictured them. The narrator read the humorous bits with a pleasant smile in her voice like she's sharing the joke with us. She didn't overact or make the narration too dramatic, and her pace was perfect. It was the perfect combination of author and narrator.
Returning to Meryton, Darcy and Col Fitzwilliam are dismayed to see Lady Catherine de Bourgh and Anne arrive to stay at the local inn. Anne is overtaken by a shocking illness, and the family struggles to keep it quiet. During the militia's parade a few days later, Elizabeth discovers the body of a person very dear to her. Overwhelmed with grief, she determines to find the murderer and bring them to justice.
Rather than being a rehash of the same events from the original Pride and Prejudice, this is a completely fresh plot. The introduction of new shopkeepers and other residents of Meryton expand the familiar circle of characters and keep the story fresh. There are a few characters introduced in the first book that appear in this one but it's easy to infer what their relationships are without lengthy explanations. This can truly be read as a standalone novel without spoiling the ending of the first book.
Darcy and Lizzy are portrayed perfectly in this version, and their interactions and conversations are so sweet. We get a glimpse of a new side to Mr. Bennett that I loved. A new father figure for Darcy is introduced, and I hope we see more of him in future novels.
Good luck guessing the identity of the killer! The murder plot is nicely done and there are well placed red herrings and clues throughout. There are a few twists and reveals that had me gasping and hitting the rewind button to make sure that I heard right. The mystery and the romance are given equal weight in the story and they don't detract from each other.
Nancy Peterson was the perfect narrator for this book. From the beginning I loved her voices for each character, especially Mrs. Bennett and Lady Catherine. They just seemed so authentic and sounded exactly like I pictured them. The narrator read the humorous bits with a pleasant smile in her voice like she's sharing the joke with us. She didn't overact or make the narration too dramatic, and her pace was perfect. It was the perfect combination of author and narrator.
February 20, 2022
Entertaining
After the ordeal of the first book in the series, Darcy and Elizabeth are feeling pretty good about each other. Darcy is determined to win Elizabeth, now realizing that she had a very poor opinion of him. Elizabeth's attitude towards Darcy has undergone a dramatic change, but she still isn't completely sure. Lady Catherine shows up in Meryton after Mr Collins hints to her that Darcy and Elizabeth like each other. She visits Longbourn, and threatens Mrs Bennett in front of the whole family. Shortly thereafter, Mrs Bennett is found murdered, and Lady Catherine becomes a suspect. Darcy throws himself into the investigation, and of course Elizabeth is determined not to be left out of the action. Mr Tanner, introduced in the first book, is still the constable in Meryton. Colonel Fitzwilliam joins the effort, as well as a magistrate, Lord Harvisham, who has a prior connection with Lady Catherine. The investigation turns up a surprising number of people who didn't like Mrs Bennett.
The whodunit aspect of the story is wonderful, with lots of twists, turns, and surprises. The romantic aspect of the story is less satisfying. There is the pall cast by the death of Elizabeth's mother. Aside from that, I can only think that in this installment Elizabeth acts like a real ninny. In spite of Darcy's efforts to lay it on the line and constantly reassure her about his affections and his intentions, Elizabeth continues to waffle about her feelings, and seems to deliberately disregard and misunderstand Darcy's blatant reassurances. Her whininess and mistrust become tiresome, until I almost wished Darcy would just throw in the towel.
Then there's Jane and Bingley. Bingley isn't given much screen time, but what he is given isn't flattering. He's pretty spineless with his sisters and with Lady Catherine. His help in the murder investigation is given unwillingly, and he's not portrayed as a very manly man. I wished he'd been given a little more gumption.
The book is well written. Again, there are quite a few editing errors, but not enough to disrupt the flow of the story. I recommend this book for a spirited murder mystery.
After the ordeal of the first book in the series, Darcy and Elizabeth are feeling pretty good about each other. Darcy is determined to win Elizabeth, now realizing that she had a very poor opinion of him. Elizabeth's attitude towards Darcy has undergone a dramatic change, but she still isn't completely sure. Lady Catherine shows up in Meryton after Mr Collins hints to her that Darcy and Elizabeth like each other. She visits Longbourn, and threatens Mrs Bennett in front of the whole family. Shortly thereafter, Mrs Bennett is found murdered, and Lady Catherine becomes a suspect. Darcy throws himself into the investigation, and of course Elizabeth is determined not to be left out of the action. Mr Tanner, introduced in the first book, is still the constable in Meryton. Colonel Fitzwilliam joins the effort, as well as a magistrate, Lord Harvisham, who has a prior connection with Lady Catherine. The investigation turns up a surprising number of people who didn't like Mrs Bennett.
The whodunit aspect of the story is wonderful, with lots of twists, turns, and surprises. The romantic aspect of the story is less satisfying. There is the pall cast by the death of Elizabeth's mother. Aside from that, I can only think that in this installment Elizabeth acts like a real ninny. In spite of Darcy's efforts to lay it on the line and constantly reassure her about his affections and his intentions, Elizabeth continues to waffle about her feelings, and seems to deliberately disregard and misunderstand Darcy's blatant reassurances. Her whininess and mistrust become tiresome, until I almost wished Darcy would just throw in the towel.
Then there's Jane and Bingley. Bingley isn't given much screen time, but what he is given isn't flattering. He's pretty spineless with his sisters and with Lady Catherine. His help in the murder investigation is given unwillingly, and he's not portrayed as a very manly man. I wished he'd been given a little more gumption.
The book is well written. Again, there are quite a few editing errors, but not enough to disrupt the flow of the story. I recommend this book for a spirited murder mystery.
February 26, 2021
I enjoyed reading this and kept sneaking a few minutes here and there through out my day because I couldn't just sit down and finish the book. I like good JA fan fiction and have learned after reading many of them that there are some interpretations that I just cannot bear, some I don't like but will put up with and some I love. For example, I love when Miss de Bourgh gets a backbone and stands up to her mother. The one I don't really like is when Darcy's parents are portrayed as not good people. I always imagine them as kind and good if a little stern. I especially dislike his father being portrayed as having been philandering and not a good father. But I will overlook that and still read the book. I got both of those things in this story. But I can rejoice with the one and overlook the other.
While I'm enjoying reading Ms. Joy's mysteries I also find it difficult to have P&P characters get killed off. What? How can that person die? And then I'm terrified to find out who the guilty party is. Don't let it be someone I love!!! Anyway, it is just a little hard for me to read my beloved P&P characters in a different genre.
Still, I did enjoy reading this and getting my Darcy fix. I can never get too much Mr. Darcy. The mystery had some red herrings and while I had some suspects for who dunnit, I hadn't actually figured it out before the reveal. Ms. Joy doesn't give enough away to figure it all out way ahead of time thus keeping the intrigue going through the whole book. I always find her books to be well written and enjoy reading them.
No sex or language
Some violence - it is a murder mystery after all.
While I'm enjoying reading Ms. Joy's mysteries I also find it difficult to have P&P characters get killed off. What? How can that person die? And then I'm terrified to find out who the guilty party is. Don't let it be someone I love!!! Anyway, it is just a little hard for me to read my beloved P&P characters in a different genre.
Still, I did enjoy reading this and getting my Darcy fix. I can never get too much Mr. Darcy. The mystery had some red herrings and while I had some suspects for who dunnit, I hadn't actually figured it out before the reveal. Ms. Joy doesn't give enough away to figure it all out way ahead of time thus keeping the intrigue going through the whole book. I always find her books to be well written and enjoy reading them.
No sex or language
Some violence - it is a murder mystery after all.
February 26, 2020
I received this book for free. I am voluntarily posting this review and all opinions expressed herein are my own.
This is book two of the Meryton Mystery series and a variation of the "Pride and Prejudice" story. This is a standalone book and can be read without having read the first book in the series, "The Honorable Mr. Darcy." However, having said that, there are numerous references to events which occurred in the first book and due to events in the first book, some of the history of the characters has changed. The author does provide quick summaries of those events. I do recommend that you start with book one of this really enjoyable series, you won't regret it.
What a wonderful follow-up to "The Honorable Mr. Darcy." Ms. Joy does a great job in creating the P&P world and the characters who inhabit it. If you love these characters, you will absolutely enjoy them as they interact to solve a murder which has deeply affected Lizzie and her family. I love how Lizzie was able to subtly direct the investigation. Additionally, besides the murder investigation, the relationships between Bingley and Jane and, of course, Lizzie and Mr. Darcy are explored. New characters are introduced and a secret society [LAMB] is discovered. This book was such fun and any fan of P&P will certainly enjoy it.
The narrator, Nancy Peterson, is wonderful and compliments the written word with her narration.
This is book two of the Meryton Mystery series and a variation of the "Pride and Prejudice" story. This is a standalone book and can be read without having read the first book in the series, "The Honorable Mr. Darcy." However, having said that, there are numerous references to events which occurred in the first book and due to events in the first book, some of the history of the characters has changed. The author does provide quick summaries of those events. I do recommend that you start with book one of this really enjoyable series, you won't regret it.
What a wonderful follow-up to "The Honorable Mr. Darcy." Ms. Joy does a great job in creating the P&P world and the characters who inhabit it. If you love these characters, you will absolutely enjoy them as they interact to solve a murder which has deeply affected Lizzie and her family. I love how Lizzie was able to subtly direct the investigation. Additionally, besides the murder investigation, the relationships between Bingley and Jane and, of course, Lizzie and Mr. Darcy are explored. New characters are introduced and a secret society [LAMB] is discovered. This book was such fun and any fan of P&P will certainly enjoy it.
The narrator, Nancy Peterson, is wonderful and compliments the written word with her narration.
March 7, 2020
3.5-3.75. I did enjoy this one, but I thought the first book in the series was much better. This one didn't have me on pins and needles as The Honorable Mr. Darcy. I also struggle with the romance of the good Colonel. So many JAFF authors feel the need to pair him with either one of the Bennet girls or Charlotte. There are other women in the world outside of Meryton and Colonel F would have many opportunities to meet with all varieties of women. It's not that I don't like Charlotte, I really do, but liking her doesn't magically give her a bigger dowry, more beauty or anything else to offer that would've had her already married long before her 27th year. The Colonel also makes it very clear in canon that he must pay attention to money when searching for a bride which is something that, just like the Bennet girls, Charlotte does not have. If he openly stated he wouldn't consider courting Lizzy, who is younger and prettier, why would he pursue
Charlotte? Pardon the rant, this is a common Jaff that is one of my pet peeves. With that being said, the story did keep hold my interest and I look forward to the next book in the series.
Charlotte? Pardon the rant, this is a common Jaff that is one of my pet peeves. With that being said, the story did keep hold my interest and I look forward to the next book in the series.
February 25, 2019
This book was another murder mystery. I completely enjoyed watching Elizabeth and Darcy's feeling for each other grow. As much as I hate Aunt Catherine, I did like how she didn't just look down on Elizabeth how pretty much anyone but her precious Ann was worth Darcy. I usually hate when communication is an issue in books, but those books are get in a time when a man and a woman can be in the same room alone. I thought the communication issues between Elizabeth and Darcy were amusing. How he though he conveyed what he wanted to say, but it was misunderstood and then it took someone else pointing out to him what he did wrong. I did enjoy watching him grovel and maybe win Elizabeth in the process.
October 29, 2019
2.5 stars
A cozy mystery featuring the characters and setting of Pride & Prejudice. The author has changed some of the characters and a lot of the plot to make it work. Enjoyable but not terribly compelling.
Cover: Oh.... I am sooooo not a fan. The outlined type is heavy-handed. I don't like the woman hovering over the house. And if that's Elizabeth (and I'm sure it's supposed to be), she never EVER made that awful face. Ewwww. This is one of those situations where a non-designer thinks they can 'design' a cover because they have the right software. :(
Narrator: Just fine.
Hogwarts Sorting Hat: Have I ever sorted Elizabeth and Mr Darcy? In this case I'd put her in Ravenclaw and him in Gryffindor.
Themes: murder mystery, P&P re-telling, Regency/Napoleonic era
A cozy mystery featuring the characters and setting of Pride & Prejudice. The author has changed some of the characters and a lot of the plot to make it work. Enjoyable but not terribly compelling.
Cover: Oh.... I am sooooo not a fan. The outlined type is heavy-handed. I don't like the woman hovering over the house. And if that's Elizabeth (and I'm sure it's supposed to be), she never EVER made that awful face. Ewwww. This is one of those situations where a non-designer thinks they can 'design' a cover because they have the right software. :(
Narrator: Just fine.
Hogwarts Sorting Hat: Have I ever sorted Elizabeth and Mr Darcy? In this case I'd put her in Ravenclaw and him in Gryffindor.
Themes: murder mystery, P&P re-telling, Regency/Napoleonic era
August 19, 2017
A continuation of The Honourable Mr. Darcy, this mystery revolves around the murder of someone very close to Elizabeth, someone whom Lady Catherine threatened the day before the militia parade. Darcy must help Elizabeth through her grief and to solve the mystery before Elizabeth's life is again endangered by a murderer in Meryton.
I really enjoyed this second mystery in the series. I had read the first one before this summer, but the second volume of this series was new to me and very intriguing. When an author as talented as Jennifer Joy combines my love of mysteries with my love of all things Austen, I know I'm in for a treat!! :D
I really enjoyed this second mystery in the series. I had read the first one before this summer, but the second volume of this series was new to me and very intriguing. When an author as talented as Jennifer Joy combines my love of mysteries with my love of all things Austen, I know I'm in for a treat!! :D
June 29, 2017
A Fun Read
I enjoyed this second installment in the Meryton Mystery series. When another resident of the Meryton area is killed, there are lots of suspects, including Lady Catherine and Mrs. Lucas. Mr. Darcy has reasons for wanting the killer to be found and brought to justice. In the mean time, he and Lizzy struggle to understand one another. In the midst of the stress of trying to solve the murder, can they see eye to eye?
This was a great story which was hard to put down. I recommend it!
I enjoyed this second installment in the Meryton Mystery series. When another resident of the Meryton area is killed, there are lots of suspects, including Lady Catherine and Mrs. Lucas. Mr. Darcy has reasons for wanting the killer to be found and brought to justice. In the mean time, he and Lizzy struggle to understand one another. In the midst of the stress of trying to solve the murder, can they see eye to eye?
This was a great story which was hard to put down. I recommend it!
May 1, 2020
This was okay but not as good as its predecessor The Honorable Mr. Darcy. The tension between Elizabeth and Darcy was a bit forced as obstacles were thrown in their way unnecessarily. The mystery was okay, although I was sad to see who was murdered. I ended up skimming most of the book in order to find out what happens but I wouldn't read it again.
May 17, 2017
Another exciting romance/mystery
This is another fine, enjoyable Pride and Prejudice variation with more romance, more mystery and more of Elizabeth and Darcy.
Yes, there's another gruesome murder with too many suspects and not enough clues. Why were there no witnesses to the murder when so many people were nearby, and what is the meaning of the mysterious LAMB Club? What was the murder weapon and where is it now? All is made clear in The Indomitable Miss Elizabeth.
16
This is another fine, enjoyable Pride and Prejudice variation with more romance, more mystery and more of Elizabeth and Darcy.
Yes, there's another gruesome murder with too many suspects and not enough clues. Why were there no witnesses to the murder when so many people were nearby, and what is the meaning of the mysterious LAMB Club? What was the murder weapon and where is it now? All is made clear in The Indomitable Miss Elizabeth.
16
June 13, 2017
First off, I received this book for free in return for my unbiased review.
This was the first book in the series for me, and I was not sure if I would like this. Thankfully I was shocked at how much I really loved it.
Classic with a twist everything was so interesting. it grows on you and takes you to another world, its fun and mysterious, with a style that is at once familiar and yet all its own.
I would give this a try.
This was the first book in the series for me, and I was not sure if I would like this. Thankfully I was shocked at how much I really loved it.
Classic with a twist everything was so interesting. it grows on you and takes you to another world, its fun and mysterious, with a style that is at once familiar and yet all its own.
I would give this a try.
December 15, 2017
An engaging and highly enjoyable story! The slightly different character slants of the Bennett ( and D'Arcy ) family members are well worked out, as they were in the first story of the series. It was beneficial to have read that book previously, as the appearance of some characters was not fully explained in this one. The mystery and love story are nicely combined and keep the attention throughout. Definitely a recommended read and I am looking forward to reading the next books in the series.
May 23, 2021
Elizabeth has asked Mr. Darcy to give her some time to think about her feelings. So Darcy heads home for a gift for Elizabeth and a good fortnight for Lizzie to consider her feelings. By the time the two weeks is up, Elizabeth is ready to have him back and show him how much she cares for him. Unfortunately, someone is murdered and Elizabeth can’t move forward with an engagement until the murderer is found and brought to justice.
July 26, 2019
I am enjoying this series by Joy. It was not at all what I expected and I love the variation. Most P&P variations are so far from the characters that we know and love as well as changes that situation so much, this one does change the situation but not like others. I enjoy the mystery aspect as well. Very light and clean read.
March 20, 2017
Another great read from Jennifer Joy.
Her mysteries are a delight. Darcy and Elizabeth as crime solvers may be hard to imagine, but it has been done before. Jennifer Joy has a light, pleasing touch in her writing. Warning, it is shocking who is murdered.
Her mysteries are a delight. Darcy and Elizabeth as crime solvers may be hard to imagine, but it has been done before. Jennifer Joy has a light, pleasing touch in her writing. Warning, it is shocking who is murdered.
July 5, 2017
P&P And Agatha Christie Book2
Another superb murder mystery in Agatha Christie style. The Darcy Elizabeth romance is an added bonus. Though Elizabeth's constant doubts and misinterpretation of Darcy did get a little tiring by the end of the book
Another superb murder mystery in Agatha Christie style. The Darcy Elizabeth romance is an added bonus. Though Elizabeth's constant doubts and misinterpretation of Darcy did get a little tiring by the end of the book
December 16, 2017
Delightful!
There were some twists and turns that took me by surprise, and I wasn't sure I'd like (A death of a beloved character). But as I continued reading, I laughed and gasped and then I couldn't put it down. It's truly delightful.
There were some twists and turns that took me by surprise, and I wasn't sure I'd like (A death of a beloved character). But as I continued reading, I laughed and gasped and then I couldn't put it down. It's truly delightful.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews