The contents provided are not suitable for a book, but more for pamphlet(s) and implementation documents. In fact, it’s hard to consider this a book: if one were to write a high school essay using the font sizes and filler contained here, the teacher would either fail it, ask for a rewrite with more content, or some combination of both. Much of the content is also, hopefully, for any business or professional employed by one, already known—learned through experience or rehashed concepts taken from other sources.
There are quite a few anecdotes included about the successes and benefits of employing EOS, but no evidence to substantiate the claims. Given the emphasis on “traction” and its measurables (CH: 3) and “scorecard” or tracking weekly metrics (CH: 7), the lack of evidence provided of EOS’s effectiveness is unacceptable. The exclusion of evidence and measurables supporting the system is all the more damning when they include statements like, “More than 50,000 companies all over the world run on EOS” because that means they (EOS Worldwide) have quite a bit of data to analyze and share, especially if they are running EOS themselves. Most serious businesses these days are data driven in their decision making, and from this book I can’t say whether or not EOS respects that, which is particularly problematic here because it’ll cost money to implement EOS—a decision that should be made based on the data.
The last notable, negative issue of the book that I’ll discuss is the emphasis on “the Right People in the Right Seats.” First and foremost, EOS is a system designed for and implemented by a company’s leadership; subordinates merely need to know the basics of EOS, so they can more effectively participate in the system and do what’s asked of them. While, certainly, there could and probably are lower level employees that aren’t “the Right People in the Right Seats,” if your company is implementing EOS, especially if no organizational or management system was in place beforehand, then the people in the “wrong seats” are likely to be in the leadership.
Any manager that didn’t have a system of management, counseling, and/or performance tracking has a high likelihood of being in the wrong seat. Even more so, the person in position to hire and retain that manager, both department and/or team leaders and HR leadership, are likely to be in the wrong seat. You get the point: the person(s) responsible for hiring and retaining the aforementioned leadership are also highly likely in the wrong seat, so if you’re going to implement this system or something similar, make sure you do it honestly, else you’re wasting time and resources. Unfortunately, many implementations just won’t be as honest as they should be in order to get meaningful results, with certain leadership and officers primarily being interested in the bullet points that will go on their résumé.
If you’re an officer or in a high leadership position at a company that has implemented EOS, then I would give thought to providing the book to all employees. I myself, however, could not make that blanket recommendation, as just opening the book was like a disrespect to me—patronizing and a waste of time—due to the first two points mentioned above. Perhaps, depending on your employees, it might be better to use the Rockefeller Habits/Scaling Up system, which I’ve read goes into more detail and is a little more serious—it also appears that the founder of EOS was at one time a high ranking member of an organization created by the author of Scaling Up and that EOS is a striped down version what’s presented there.
I spent more time writing this review than it took me to read, comprehend, and contemplate the contents of this book. I’ll let you be the judge of whether or not that’s a good thing or a bad thing.