I received an Advanced Reader Copy so keep in mind that that I'm reading an earlier version without later edits:
Overall, an enjoyable, imaginative story set in a fictional medieval European country, focused on the lives of four young women and their families as an attack from a foreign nation threatens their home and livelihoods.
What I Liked:
I really enjoyed the setting and the introduction of some slightly-advanced technology into the medieval world, giving the primarily historical setting a dash of steampunk (medieval-punk?). This prompts a character, Laiken, to utter one of my favorite lines during the battle: "Just where in the blazes is everybody getting all these fancy props?" (As an unrelated aside, I kept picturing Chris Hemsworth in this role). The banter, particularly amongst the main characters' parents, was very enjoyable and felt real to me. I also enjoyed seeing the character Brendan grow and mature. I liked that he doesn't improbably become this amazing or skilled warrior, and that his growth felt more realistic and it was clear he still had a ways to go, but was on the right path.
Some other reviews remarked on the slow pace or it taking a while for the conflict to enter the picture. I personally didn't feel this way as I don't mind late-act conflicts. I felt that the history of the nation and its prior conflict with the Wolves was interweaved in the beginning of the narrative, so Kassim and the Wolves entering the picture later didn't feel jarring or out of place.
- I liked that at the end of the novel, it was clear that both the nation and the people still had healing and recovering to do; showing that war, even when you're the victor, still extracts great costs.
Some minor criticisms/nitpicks I had:
Once in a while throughout the course of the book, I felt there were some instances of "showing and not telling," particularly in regards to why a certain character performed a certain action or made a remark; just some moments that felt overly-explained when the motivation behind the act would have been clear just from describing the act and/or knowing the character's personality/motivation. I personally like some things left to be interpreted by the reader, or getting a feel for the character solely by the character's words/actions, so that may just be a personal nitpick, but they jumped out at me a little nonetheless. One example offhand (that I'm going to describe in vague terms to hopefully not spoil anything) would be a character performing a very simple yet sweet and innocent act, and the text describes why and what about the nature of the character's heart prompted her to do this, when I feel that can be divined by the description of the action itself.
I also have one extremely minor nitpick that I'm sure wouldn't bother most other readers, but I think I would preferred that, since Laudeland is fictional, that Armenia also be a fictional Eastern European country. It took me slightly out of the story trying to envision people from a real place intermixing with those of a fictional place, attempting to put it in a historical context when the novel is (mostly) fantasy, and puzzling over why "Kassim" is an Arabic name when he originates from Armenia (again, I understand this is a fantasy and isn't meant to be historically accurate, but combining real places with fictional places sort of forces my brain to do this and try to make everything make at least cultural sense if not historical sense). I realize many may disagree, and the author I'm sure had well thought-out reasons for mixing in real history (a lot of readers I'm sure enjoy that as well), but speaking personally, I think all of that could have been avoided by creating a fictional Eastern European/Middle Eastern country, maybe even in the same region.
Overall, I would still recommend this to readers who enjoy medieval fiction, low-fantasy, or even anyone who enjoys coming-of-age stories.