3.5. okay, so, the good: unlike the slayers podcast 90% of this season is 100% Buffy... from overall characters and especially to dialogue, humor, themes, pacing, even the jump cuts. and this makes sense, since this was headed by the fallen hero that was JW.
the less good: I think the shift in genre takes away from some buffy, and it's not all the illustration Style which is fine... tho somewhat inconsistent and not really my aesthetic. let's face it, while the makeup on Buffy was usually pretty tight, the other visual effects were usually B at best, and, while not at all few and far between, the big fantastical ones were limited by budget and the practical realities of live action sets. the CGI fantasy elements, outside of the most common stakings and vamp transitions, while of course Central to show, were also rather grounded in a sense of reality. with the leap to comics, all those bounds are taken away and the fantasy elements are ratcheted up by a good 75%. and while the themes are still totally buffy, I think this takes away from how really human and grounded the show was. additionally, the portrayal of a certain sex scene in season 8 looks like semi gross fanfic art that would not make it so explicitly to the show, and it is a challenge to capture the pacing in comic book form. it really succeeds in places, especially the smash cuts away on a character's punchline, and even reveals to me some things about the original.
on the whole, I prefer the show, and while I will likely read more seasons of this and the angel comic, despite their literally being produced by the creator, they don't really feel like canon to me. I don't care what anyone says, s7 deserved some criticism but was stronger than ppl say and s6 is peak Buffy, and (while I have critiques of how it got there) the ending to both series was perfect.
VAGUE SPOILER:
I'm especially annoyed by the way the forever teased and intended Buffy/Xander dynamic unfolds (partly the whole thing which I'm not behind, partly the pacing/reveal which doesn't convince me of its legitimacy, and also partly of the actual resolution which seems cheap... just, none of it feels earned on the page as we see it, esp after Renee...I was also skeptical of the Satsu storyline, but it was infinitely more grounded in believability and character choices we get to see).