What do you think?
Rate this book
Holidays With Jane #5
Holidays with Jane: Thankful Hearts
It’s time for crisp weather, colorful leaves, and a Thanksgiving feast. The authors of the Holidays with Jane series bring you Holidays with Jane: Thankful Hearts with six modern-day adaptations of Jane Austen’s novels. Join your favorite heroines around the fire with a cup of hot apple cider for heart-warming takes on these classic stories.
A Persuasive Visitor
by Cecilia Gray
Thanksgiving with your crazy family is hard enough without your rich and sexy ex-boyfriend, whom you were dumb enough to dump, showing up for the weekend. The only way it could be any worse would be if he started paying attention to another girl... which, of course, is exactly what happens to Anne Elliot. But the good thing about hitting rock bottom is that the only direction to go is up.
North by Northanger
by Jessica Grey
Kate Moore knows a lot about softball and sass...but she's clueless when it comes to guys. Especially smart, cute, worldly guys like Henry Taylor. When Henry invites her home for Thanksgiving, Kate is over the moon. But will her propensity for acting first and thinking later mess up her chances with Henry?
Second Time's the Charm
by Nancy Kelley
Marianne Dashwood has always believed in One True Love. But when her love isn’t true, Brandon Collins helps her pick up the pieces. Marianne dismissed her mother’s boring neighbor when they met, but his quiet personality hides depths that call to her as she gets to know him.
Will Marianne’s dedication to the ideal of One True Love leave her alone forever? Or will she find that with Brandon, the second time’s the charm?
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street
by Jennifer Becton
When vet student Harriet “Addy” Woodhouse returns home to Highbury, Georgia, for Thanksgiving, she longs to relax and spend time with her father, her sister Emma, and her best friend Martin. But Emma’s incessant meddling causes Addy to hatch her own cunning plan, which not only threatens to ruin the entire Thanksgiving celebration, but reveals the secret loves of both sisters’ hearts.
Melanie Perceived
by Rebecca M. Fleming
For as long as she can remember, Melanie Frances Price has loved Eddie. Growing up next door to the wealthy Bertrams, she is used to being his shadow - they are inseparable, the “Eddie & Frankie Show.” With post-college plans on the horizon, she hopes the friendship will (finally) develop into more. But when MaryJo Crawford waltzes onto the scene, changing everything, Melanie must decide what is really worth fighting for.
The Construction of a Heart
by Melissa Buell
Elizabeth Bennet credits the success of Bennet Homes to her close-knit family, however dysfunctional they might be. The Meryton Chamber of Commerce calls on local businesses to host the annual All-Town Thanksgiving Feast. Unfortunately, Elizabeth is paired up with pretentious businessman Will Darcy of Pemberley Estates, her main rival in the construction business. Will Elizabeth be able to fill up her Thankful Jar this year?
A Persuasive Visitor
by Cecilia Gray
Thanksgiving with your crazy family is hard enough without your rich and sexy ex-boyfriend, whom you were dumb enough to dump, showing up for the weekend. The only way it could be any worse would be if he started paying attention to another girl... which, of course, is exactly what happens to Anne Elliot. But the good thing about hitting rock bottom is that the only direction to go is up.
North by Northanger
by Jessica Grey
Kate Moore knows a lot about softball and sass...but she's clueless when it comes to guys. Especially smart, cute, worldly guys like Henry Taylor. When Henry invites her home for Thanksgiving, Kate is over the moon. But will her propensity for acting first and thinking later mess up her chances with Henry?
Second Time's the Charm
by Nancy Kelley
Marianne Dashwood has always believed in One True Love. But when her love isn’t true, Brandon Collins helps her pick up the pieces. Marianne dismissed her mother’s boring neighbor when they met, but his quiet personality hides depths that call to her as she gets to know him.
Will Marianne’s dedication to the ideal of One True Love leave her alone forever? Or will she find that with Brandon, the second time’s the charm?
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street
by Jennifer Becton
When vet student Harriet “Addy” Woodhouse returns home to Highbury, Georgia, for Thanksgiving, she longs to relax and spend time with her father, her sister Emma, and her best friend Martin. But Emma’s incessant meddling causes Addy to hatch her own cunning plan, which not only threatens to ruin the entire Thanksgiving celebration, but reveals the secret loves of both sisters’ hearts.
Melanie Perceived
by Rebecca M. Fleming
For as long as she can remember, Melanie Frances Price has loved Eddie. Growing up next door to the wealthy Bertrams, she is used to being his shadow - they are inseparable, the “Eddie & Frankie Show.” With post-college plans on the horizon, she hopes the friendship will (finally) develop into more. But when MaryJo Crawford waltzes onto the scene, changing everything, Melanie must decide what is really worth fighting for.
The Construction of a Heart
by Melissa Buell
Elizabeth Bennet credits the success of Bennet Homes to her close-knit family, however dysfunctional they might be. The Meryton Chamber of Commerce calls on local businesses to host the annual All-Town Thanksgiving Feast. Unfortunately, Elizabeth is paired up with pretentious businessman Will Darcy of Pemberley Estates, her main rival in the construction business. Will Elizabeth be able to fill up her Thankful Jar this year?
370 pages, ebook
Published October 1, 2016
11 people are currently reading
54 people want to read
About the author
Cecilia Gray
37 books142 followersCecilia Gray writes stories about first love, second chances, and forever friendships. She--much like her characters--resides in quite a few places.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews
November 22, 2017
As with the other "Holidays with Jane" collections, I loved most of the stories. A few great "curveballs" at least a couple of the stories. And as a card carrying member of Team Marianne, I was so very happy with the S&S story!
January 26, 2020
All these short stories happen around the Thanksgiving holidays in the USA in modern times. Mansfield Perk coffee shop makes cameo appearances in all.
A Persuasive Visitor by Cecilia Gray: Anne Elliot dropped Patrick Wentworth because she was entering medical school. Although she almost immediately regrets it and wants to change her mind she finds he has quickly moved on. Eight years later when her family (minus her father) gets together for Thanksgiving dinner, Patrick shows up with his friend, James, at the invitation of Anne’s brother-in-law. As Louisa makes a play for Patrick, Anne has a major decision to make about a job offer in research which would take her out of the field of front line medical practice. There are several flashbacks in which we read of their previous relationship and plans. The sexual chemistry is strong. The story is sweet.
@ 15% - North by Northanger by Jessica Grey: Kate Moore meets Henry Taylor at Abbey College and they strike up a very close relationship. Her parents decide to take a cruise over Thanksgiving holiday so Henry invites Kate home with him. His mother is running for political office and invites one of her campaign donors, a Mr. Kaplan, for dinner. Kate and Henry’s sister, Lana, are into watching mysteries on Investigation Discovery and are shocked to realize that the man responsible for the murder in the case they watch one night has a very strong resemblance to the man who came to dinner. They decide to look for evidence all on their lonesome!
@34% - Second Time’s the Charm by Nancy Kelley: Marianne Dashwood, a student at Delaford U., finds her boyfriend Will Hoffman cheating on her and believes since this was her one true love that she has missed out. During various times spent at her home, Delaford, her neighbor, Brandon Collins, a licensed therapist, talks her through her mixed emotions with more than one reason for doing so.
When he witnesses how she is pushing her sister, Elinor/Norrie at Edward, he has to counsel her to let them make their own way. It seems obvious that Norrie is attracted to Edward but why does he seems so uncomfortable in opposition to how he looks at her with longing in his eyes?
@51% - Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street: In true Emma style (according to canon) this young lady cannot resist matchmaking. When she attempts to match her adopted sister, Harriet (but everyone calls her Addy) with Frank Churchill, it is the final straw! Addy is studying to be a vet and has been friends since childhood with Martin Roberts, a neighbor who owns a farm…with many animals. So when Martin relates that another neighbor, Liam Knightley, has a soft spot for Emma, Addy asks Emma to fix her up with Liam…hoping Emma will realize how it feels to have someone mess with her emotions. Addy is pretty sure Emma will be jealous or will she?
@68% - Melanie Perceived – A Mansfield Park Story by Rebecca M. Fleming: In this story Melanie is also called Frankie by her childhood friend and neighbor, Eddie Bertram. They are best friends. Melanie is obsessed with photography and spends time going through photo files on her computer. Of special interest are those of the game in which Eddie’s ability as a receiver on the football team shown bright for the first time. When MaryJo and Hank Crawford move to town Eddie begins to act different, to not always be there, (to miss their every Wednesday night pizza) when Frankie wants to talk or hang out. It takes having the shoe on the other foot…Hank Crawford kissing Melanie AND Eddie realizing that he is not the only male MaryJo pays attention to…for Eddie to realize the value and true meaning of his relationship with Frankie.
@81% - The Construction of a Heart by Melissa Buell: Two construction companies competing for sales in Meryton: Bennet Homes and Pemberley Estates. Chase and Carla Bingley along with Will Darcy show up and, yes, we have an insult. As the story progresses both companies agree to host the annual Thanksgiving town dinner. Darcy and Elizabeth are forced to work together and soon we also have that insulting proposal with Darcy giving her the letter of explanation. Giovanni Wickham’s part of the story echoes canon.
In this short story the Gardiners are looking to buy some lakefront property, which just happens to be next to Darcy’s home. Their interaction shows a different side of Darcy to Elizabeth and she soon changes her mind about the man.
But then there is the Bingley and Jane matter and, of course, Lydia, to sort out. No colonel herein but there is Griffin Fitzwilliam who spills the beans about the former matter and who helped separate them.
I particularly liked the Thanksgiving jars into which townspeople put slips of water with words about what they were thankful for to be shared at the annual dinner.
These were all close to events in canon of JA's different stories but different enough to draw my attention in and keep me happy. I realize this is not the Thanksgiving season but I have had this on my Kindle and finally decided it was time to check it off books TBR.
A Persuasive Visitor by Cecilia Gray: Anne Elliot dropped Patrick Wentworth because she was entering medical school. Although she almost immediately regrets it and wants to change her mind she finds he has quickly moved on. Eight years later when her family (minus her father) gets together for Thanksgiving dinner, Patrick shows up with his friend, James, at the invitation of Anne’s brother-in-law. As Louisa makes a play for Patrick, Anne has a major decision to make about a job offer in research which would take her out of the field of front line medical practice. There are several flashbacks in which we read of their previous relationship and plans. The sexual chemistry is strong. The story is sweet.
@ 15% - North by Northanger by Jessica Grey: Kate Moore meets Henry Taylor at Abbey College and they strike up a very close relationship. Her parents decide to take a cruise over Thanksgiving holiday so Henry invites Kate home with him. His mother is running for political office and invites one of her campaign donors, a Mr. Kaplan, for dinner. Kate and Henry’s sister, Lana, are into watching mysteries on Investigation Discovery and are shocked to realize that the man responsible for the murder in the case they watch one night has a very strong resemblance to the man who came to dinner. They decide to look for evidence all on their lonesome!
@34% - Second Time’s the Charm by Nancy Kelley: Marianne Dashwood, a student at Delaford U., finds her boyfriend Will Hoffman cheating on her and believes since this was her one true love that she has missed out. During various times spent at her home, Delaford, her neighbor, Brandon Collins, a licensed therapist, talks her through her mixed emotions with more than one reason for doing so.
When he witnesses how she is pushing her sister, Elinor/Norrie at Edward, he has to counsel her to let them make their own way. It seems obvious that Norrie is attracted to Edward but why does he seems so uncomfortable in opposition to how he looks at her with longing in his eyes?
@51% - Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street: In true Emma style (according to canon) this young lady cannot resist matchmaking. When she attempts to match her adopted sister, Harriet (but everyone calls her Addy) with Frank Churchill, it is the final straw! Addy is studying to be a vet and has been friends since childhood with Martin Roberts, a neighbor who owns a farm…with many animals. So when Martin relates that another neighbor, Liam Knightley, has a soft spot for Emma, Addy asks Emma to fix her up with Liam…hoping Emma will realize how it feels to have someone mess with her emotions. Addy is pretty sure Emma will be jealous or will she?
@68% - Melanie Perceived – A Mansfield Park Story by Rebecca M. Fleming: In this story Melanie is also called Frankie by her childhood friend and neighbor, Eddie Bertram. They are best friends. Melanie is obsessed with photography and spends time going through photo files on her computer. Of special interest are those of the game in which Eddie’s ability as a receiver on the football team shown bright for the first time. When MaryJo and Hank Crawford move to town Eddie begins to act different, to not always be there, (to miss their every Wednesday night pizza) when Frankie wants to talk or hang out. It takes having the shoe on the other foot…Hank Crawford kissing Melanie AND Eddie realizing that he is not the only male MaryJo pays attention to…for Eddie to realize the value and true meaning of his relationship with Frankie.
@81% - The Construction of a Heart by Melissa Buell: Two construction companies competing for sales in Meryton: Bennet Homes and Pemberley Estates. Chase and Carla Bingley along with Will Darcy show up and, yes, we have an insult. As the story progresses both companies agree to host the annual Thanksgiving town dinner. Darcy and Elizabeth are forced to work together and soon we also have that insulting proposal with Darcy giving her the letter of explanation. Giovanni Wickham’s part of the story echoes canon.
In this short story the Gardiners are looking to buy some lakefront property, which just happens to be next to Darcy’s home. Their interaction shows a different side of Darcy to Elizabeth and she soon changes her mind about the man.
But then there is the Bingley and Jane matter and, of course, Lydia, to sort out. No colonel herein but there is Griffin Fitzwilliam who spills the beans about the former matter and who helped separate them.
I particularly liked the Thanksgiving jars into which townspeople put slips of water with words about what they were thankful for to be shared at the annual dinner.
These were all close to events in canon of JA's different stories but different enough to draw my attention in and keep me happy. I realize this is not the Thanksgiving season but I have had this on my Kindle and finally decided it was time to check it off books TBR.
January 5, 2018
6 Heartwarming Stories in this Bountiful Harvest!
I am so grateful that there is a Holidays with Jane anthology that celebrates Thanksgiving! What a great holiday to feature! There are six short stories in this anthology (one for each Jane Austen novel) and each story takes place in present-day. All things autumnal, cozy, and spiced are featured in this charming collection!
I hope you find this breakdown helpful!
A PERUASIVE VISITOR – Cecilia Gray
- The Premise: Dr. Anne Elliot has an important career decision to make during her Thanksgiving break. But her plans for quality time with her family are destroyed when she discovers an ex-boyfriend (that she terribly regrets breaking up with) is invited to her sister’s house for dinner!
- What I Loved: That Anne was at a crossroads similar to the one she experienced when dating Patrick before medical school. I also loved the flashbacks to Anne’s and Patrick’s steamy summer interlude and their palpable chemistry. However, I did wish the present-day story moved a little slower.
NORTH BY NORTHANGER – Jessica Grey
- The Premise: Kate is spending Thanksgiving Break with her…boyfriend? (not sure, no labels yet) and meeting his family the first time. But with the tense atmosphere and cold formality coming from Henry’s politician mother, Cate doesn’t experience the warmest of welcomes…
- What I Loved: That this story began right in the thick of it with Kate and Henry already a couple. I loved that Henry’s strict parent was a matriarch (and not patriarch) and that the whole “suspecting-the-parent-of-something-terrible” incident was refreshingly different! The flashbacks were lovely and Henry’s sweet banter with Kate gave me all sorts of warm fuzzies. One of my faves!
SECOND TIME’S THE CHARM – Nancy Kelley
- The Premise: Even after having her heart broken, Marianne vows that Will was her “once-in-a-lifetime-love.” But little does she know that her quiet next door neighbor Brandon Collins is hoping she will give him a chance…
- What I Loved: I <3 Marianne and Brandon stories! I enjoyed seeing a lot of Brandon’s thoughts throughout his encounters with Marianne. I love how Marianne was focused on matchmaking her sister with Edward (partly as a distraction from her own heartache), and how Brandon stepped in to give her some needed advice. Yay for Brandon!
THANKSGIVING ON HARTFIELD STREET – Jennifer Becton
- The Premise: Even though Harriet knows her sister Emma means well with her meddling and pushy ways, she has had enough. During her trip home for Thanksgiving this year, Harriet finally has the chance to turn the tables a little…
- What I Loved: It’s a Harriet/Robert Martin story – how unique!!! And what a unique switch to see Harriet as Emma’s adopted sister. I loved the friends-to-lovers evolution between Harriet and Martin, how Harriet only faked being ditzy, the clever enterprise Mr. Woodhouse co-owns with Dr. Perry, and, last but not least…GIANT JENGA! Yasssss! One of my faves!
MELANIE PERCEIVED – Rebecca M. Fleming
- The Premise: Melanie and Eddie have been neighbors and best-of-friends for over a decade. And while Melanie wished their relationship would develop into something more, it looks like Eddie has never thought of her in that way…
- What I Loved: College life, campus newspaper, photography, football – I really liked the theme and setting of this story. I appreciated how Melanie wasn’t timid and shy, and instead stood up for herself. Also, I loved Melanie’s relationship with the football-loving, kind-hearted ‘Grampa Jamie’.
THE CONSTRUCTION OF A HEART – Melissa Buell
- The Premise: Two rivaling construction businesses are asked to share the honor of hosting the annual All-Town Thanksgiving Feast. The teams from Bennet Homes and Pemberley Estates find it a little challenging to work together and blend their different styles…
- What I Loved: Witnessing all the planning sessions and menu preparations for the big day. It is heartwarming to see a community work like this to celebrate Thanksgiving together. I enjoyed how both Jane and Elizabeth are very involved with their family business, and also have dreams of other types of career paths. However, I thought the Lydia/Wickham incident felt a little implausible.
CONCLUSION:
I’m continuously amazed by all the unique and clever directions these authors take with Jane Austen’s characters, and how they can skillfully construct a fulfilling and satisfying tale into such a compact story. These Thanksgiving tales are as vibrant as the changing leaves, as warm as your favorite flannel, and as sweet as some hot apple pie! I highly recommend!
I am so grateful that there is a Holidays with Jane anthology that celebrates Thanksgiving! What a great holiday to feature! There are six short stories in this anthology (one for each Jane Austen novel) and each story takes place in present-day. All things autumnal, cozy, and spiced are featured in this charming collection!
I hope you find this breakdown helpful!
A PERUASIVE VISITOR – Cecilia Gray
- The Premise: Dr. Anne Elliot has an important career decision to make during her Thanksgiving break. But her plans for quality time with her family are destroyed when she discovers an ex-boyfriend (that she terribly regrets breaking up with) is invited to her sister’s house for dinner!
- What I Loved: That Anne was at a crossroads similar to the one she experienced when dating Patrick before medical school. I also loved the flashbacks to Anne’s and Patrick’s steamy summer interlude and their palpable chemistry. However, I did wish the present-day story moved a little slower.
NORTH BY NORTHANGER – Jessica Grey
- The Premise: Kate is spending Thanksgiving Break with her…boyfriend? (not sure, no labels yet) and meeting his family the first time. But with the tense atmosphere and cold formality coming from Henry’s politician mother, Cate doesn’t experience the warmest of welcomes…
- What I Loved: That this story began right in the thick of it with Kate and Henry already a couple. I loved that Henry’s strict parent was a matriarch (and not patriarch) and that the whole “suspecting-the-parent-of-something-terrible” incident was refreshingly different! The flashbacks were lovely and Henry’s sweet banter with Kate gave me all sorts of warm fuzzies. One of my faves!
SECOND TIME’S THE CHARM – Nancy Kelley
- The Premise: Even after having her heart broken, Marianne vows that Will was her “once-in-a-lifetime-love.” But little does she know that her quiet next door neighbor Brandon Collins is hoping she will give him a chance…
- What I Loved: I <3 Marianne and Brandon stories! I enjoyed seeing a lot of Brandon’s thoughts throughout his encounters with Marianne. I love how Marianne was focused on matchmaking her sister with Edward (partly as a distraction from her own heartache), and how Brandon stepped in to give her some needed advice. Yay for Brandon!
THANKSGIVING ON HARTFIELD STREET – Jennifer Becton
- The Premise: Even though Harriet knows her sister Emma means well with her meddling and pushy ways, she has had enough. During her trip home for Thanksgiving this year, Harriet finally has the chance to turn the tables a little…
- What I Loved: It’s a Harriet/Robert Martin story – how unique!!! And what a unique switch to see Harriet as Emma’s adopted sister. I loved the friends-to-lovers evolution between Harriet and Martin, how Harriet only faked being ditzy, the clever enterprise Mr. Woodhouse co-owns with Dr. Perry, and, last but not least…GIANT JENGA! Yasssss! One of my faves!
MELANIE PERCEIVED – Rebecca M. Fleming
- The Premise: Melanie and Eddie have been neighbors and best-of-friends for over a decade. And while Melanie wished their relationship would develop into something more, it looks like Eddie has never thought of her in that way…
- What I Loved: College life, campus newspaper, photography, football – I really liked the theme and setting of this story. I appreciated how Melanie wasn’t timid and shy, and instead stood up for herself. Also, I loved Melanie’s relationship with the football-loving, kind-hearted ‘Grampa Jamie’.
THE CONSTRUCTION OF A HEART – Melissa Buell
- The Premise: Two rivaling construction businesses are asked to share the honor of hosting the annual All-Town Thanksgiving Feast. The teams from Bennet Homes and Pemberley Estates find it a little challenging to work together and blend their different styles…
- What I Loved: Witnessing all the planning sessions and menu preparations for the big day. It is heartwarming to see a community work like this to celebrate Thanksgiving together. I enjoyed how both Jane and Elizabeth are very involved with their family business, and also have dreams of other types of career paths. However, I thought the Lydia/Wickham incident felt a little implausible.
CONCLUSION:
I’m continuously amazed by all the unique and clever directions these authors take with Jane Austen’s characters, and how they can skillfully construct a fulfilling and satisfying tale into such a compact story. These Thanksgiving tales are as vibrant as the changing leaves, as warm as your favorite flannel, and as sweet as some hot apple pie! I highly recommend!
November 9, 2017
“Let other pens dwell on guilt and misery.” Jane Austen
The book blurb did a great job in giving a quick synopsis of each of the stories. There is no need for me to do the same, so I will just share my thoughts. You have six JAFF [Jane Austen Fan Fiction] authors drawing straws… well, perhaps it didn’t happen exactly that way. They may not have drawn straws, but they did have to decide who would write which classic. Having decided that, our authors took Austen’s words, outline, and story line and created their own story using similar names in some cases, and modern references and situations in others.
1) A Persuasive Visitor: Celia Gray: [Rating: Moderate]: ends at 13%
“She had been forced into prudence in her youth, she learned romance as she grew older: the natural sequel of an unnatural beginning.” Jane Austen, Persuasion
Dr. Anne Elliot pediatric doctor took the advice of Dr. Russell, her adviser, mentor, division chief and ended her budding relationship with Patrick Wentworth. This story picks up eight years later where he works with the national park service as a firefighter or smoke-jumper, to be more precise. I really liked this story. It was steamy but it held true to the tone of Austen’s Persuasion.
2) North By Northanger: Jessica Grey: ends at 32%
“If adventures will not befall a young lady in her own village, she must seek them abroad.” Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey
Kate Moore came from a sports family. Her father was a coach, she had a softball scholarship at Abbey College, and her brother, James Moore, was a famous football star [quarterback for the NFL]. Henry Taylor, a theology student, invites her home for Thanksgiving. There she meets his mother, NY [2nd term] State Senator Bethany Taylor, and his sister Lana, who is 17-years old. This was a cute clean story that kept the character of Austen’s story and the HEA we expect. There are limitations as the characters are young… so, we really only have the early stages of their relationship.
3) Second Time’s the Charm: Nancy Kelley: ends at 50%
“The more I know of the world, the more I am convinced that I shall never see a man whom I can really love. I require so much.” Jane Austen, Sense and Sensibility
Marianne Dashwood believes in ‘One True Love.’ When Will Hoffman, [her one true love], turns out to be a dud, she is thrown into a tailspin. Neighbor and friend Brandon Collins comes to her rescue and tries to show her that not all is lost. I love the use of the names from canon in Allenham College and Delaford University. Characters remain true to Austen’s blueprint. We have the romantic Marianne, steadfast Elinor, conflicted Edward, and a Lucy Steele that is not averse to using modern technology to secure her man. This was so cute.
4) Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street: Jennifer Becton: ends at 66% [Rating: Steamy]
“It’s such a happiness when good people get together.” Jane Austen, Emma
Our author did something I’ve not seen before. This story is from the POV [point-of-view] of Harriet who is Emma’s adopted sister. She is Harriet [Addy] Smith Woodhouse, doctor of veterinary medicine. This switch was so cool.
Emma Woodhouse worked at a tiny local TV station [Channel Four] as a nightly news anchor. And like canon was a tiny bit meddlesome... OK… she was a lot meddlesome. She loved to meddle help others be the best they could be. She refuses to think that Martin Roberts [farmer/rancher] is good enough for her sister Addy. And Liam Knightley will help Emma adjust to her mistakes.
Philip Elton, attorney, is running for City Council and is trying to wheedle funds from the wealthy Mr. Woodhouse. August is his campaign manager. Yeah, right. Brick-House Gyms: partnership between Dr. Perry Brickman and Mr. Woodhouse... that was a cool twist. Frank Churchill [his stage name… yeah] works with Jane Fairfax: producer Channel Four… you can see where this is going. Cute story with a HEA that we just knew would happen.
5) Melanie Perceived: A Mansfield Park Story: Rebecca M. Fleming: ends at 79%
“We have all a better guide in ourselves, if we would attend to it, than any other person can be.” Jane Austen, Mansfield Park
College Campus News ‘The Lion’s Den’: Melanie Frances [Frankie] Price, Eddie Bertram: editor-in-chief. We have MaryJo Crawford and Hank Crawford: editor… I enjoyed the college feel to this. However, it didn’t grab me as Mansfield Park does, even though the author tried to remain true to the story line and characterization.
6) The Construction of a Heart: Melissa Buell: ends at 98%
“Vanity and pride are different things, though the words are often used synonymously. A person may be proud without being vain. Pride relates more to our opinion of ourselves, vanity to what we would have others think of us.” Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice
I loved this story because Pride & Prejudice is my favorite Austen story. Meryton Chamber of Commerce calls on local businesses to host the annual All-Town Thanksgiving Feast. This year’s hosts are Bennet Homes and Pemberley Estates… rivals in the construction and renovation business. I loved all our characters even with the slight name changes. I did not think it distracted from the story. Their characteristics remained true to canon and their behavior was consistent with their roles in P&P. I always love seeing how Darcy and Elizabeth get together.
The book blurb did a great job in giving a quick synopsis of each of the stories. There is no need for me to do the same, so I will just share my thoughts. You have six JAFF [Jane Austen Fan Fiction] authors drawing straws… well, perhaps it didn’t happen exactly that way. They may not have drawn straws, but they did have to decide who would write which classic. Having decided that, our authors took Austen’s words, outline, and story line and created their own story using similar names in some cases, and modern references and situations in others.
1) A Persuasive Visitor: Celia Gray: [Rating: Moderate]: ends at 13%
“She had been forced into prudence in her youth, she learned romance as she grew older: the natural sequel of an unnatural beginning.” Jane Austen, Persuasion
Dr. Anne Elliot pediatric doctor took the advice of Dr. Russell, her adviser, mentor, division chief and ended her budding relationship with Patrick Wentworth. This story picks up eight years later where he works with the national park service as a firefighter or smoke-jumper, to be more precise. I really liked this story. It was steamy but it held true to the tone of Austen’s Persuasion.
2) North By Northanger: Jessica Grey: ends at 32%
“If adventures will not befall a young lady in her own village, she must seek them abroad.” Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey
Kate Moore came from a sports family. Her father was a coach, she had a softball scholarship at Abbey College, and her brother, James Moore, was a famous football star [quarterback for the NFL]. Henry Taylor, a theology student, invites her home for Thanksgiving. There she meets his mother, NY [2nd term] State Senator Bethany Taylor, and his sister Lana, who is 17-years old. This was a cute clean story that kept the character of Austen’s story and the HEA we expect. There are limitations as the characters are young… so, we really only have the early stages of their relationship.
3) Second Time’s the Charm: Nancy Kelley: ends at 50%
“The more I know of the world, the more I am convinced that I shall never see a man whom I can really love. I require so much.” Jane Austen, Sense and Sensibility
Marianne Dashwood believes in ‘One True Love.’ When Will Hoffman, [her one true love], turns out to be a dud, she is thrown into a tailspin. Neighbor and friend Brandon Collins comes to her rescue and tries to show her that not all is lost. I love the use of the names from canon in Allenham College and Delaford University. Characters remain true to Austen’s blueprint. We have the romantic Marianne, steadfast Elinor, conflicted Edward, and a Lucy Steele that is not averse to using modern technology to secure her man. This was so cute.
4) Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street: Jennifer Becton: ends at 66% [Rating: Steamy]
“It’s such a happiness when good people get together.” Jane Austen, Emma
Our author did something I’ve not seen before. This story is from the POV [point-of-view] of Harriet who is Emma’s adopted sister. She is Harriet [Addy] Smith Woodhouse, doctor of veterinary medicine. This switch was so cool.
Emma Woodhouse worked at a tiny local TV station [Channel Four] as a nightly news anchor. And like canon was a tiny bit meddlesome... OK… she was a lot meddlesome. She loved to meddle help others be the best they could be. She refuses to think that Martin Roberts [farmer/rancher] is good enough for her sister Addy. And Liam Knightley will help Emma adjust to her mistakes.
Philip Elton, attorney, is running for City Council and is trying to wheedle funds from the wealthy Mr. Woodhouse. August is his campaign manager. Yeah, right. Brick-House Gyms: partnership between Dr. Perry Brickman and Mr. Woodhouse... that was a cool twist. Frank Churchill [his stage name… yeah] works with Jane Fairfax: producer Channel Four… you can see where this is going. Cute story with a HEA that we just knew would happen.
5) Melanie Perceived: A Mansfield Park Story: Rebecca M. Fleming: ends at 79%
“We have all a better guide in ourselves, if we would attend to it, than any other person can be.” Jane Austen, Mansfield Park
College Campus News ‘The Lion’s Den’: Melanie Frances [Frankie] Price, Eddie Bertram: editor-in-chief. We have MaryJo Crawford and Hank Crawford: editor… I enjoyed the college feel to this. However, it didn’t grab me as Mansfield Park does, even though the author tried to remain true to the story line and characterization.
6) The Construction of a Heart: Melissa Buell: ends at 98%
“Vanity and pride are different things, though the words are often used synonymously. A person may be proud without being vain. Pride relates more to our opinion of ourselves, vanity to what we would have others think of us.” Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice
I loved this story because Pride & Prejudice is my favorite Austen story. Meryton Chamber of Commerce calls on local businesses to host the annual All-Town Thanksgiving Feast. This year’s hosts are Bennet Homes and Pemberley Estates… rivals in the construction and renovation business. I loved all our characters even with the slight name changes. I did not think it distracted from the story. Their characteristics remained true to canon and their behavior was consistent with their roles in P&P. I always love seeing how Darcy and Elizabeth get together.
May 7, 2020
A collection of modern JAFF short stories.
The common denominator was thanksgiving, situated in America and the coffee shop Mansfield Perk.
A Persuasive Heart, 5*
I absolutely loved this cleverly adapted, modern take on Persuasion. The alterations made to fit the modern world was spot on. I liked that the author had not just transferred the events from the regency era but made them more plausible in a contemporary world.
The sexual tension lay thick without being explicit, another trait I loved about this story...
North by Northanger 4*
Funny twist to Northanger Abbey. Not the most plausible story I have read but definitely entertaining. Serial killers included...
Second Time's the Charm, 4*
A sweet, romantic and slow-paced story about Marianne and Brandon Collins, although Elinor's and Edward's story was featured as well.
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street, 3*
Harriett Woodhouse's (Smith, she was adopted by the Woodhouses) story in a modern setting, written in 1.person. I was rather disappointed as I adore Emma while my interest doesn't stretch to Hariett, I'm afraid...
Melanie Perceived, 3*
Melanie (Fanny Price) is an eager photographer. Eddie (Edmund) plays on the football team while Melanie takes pictures. They are best friends until MaryJo and Hank Crawford enters the field and things get muddled...
The Construction of a Heart, 3.5*
Bennet's as the owner of a construction company was new but I do believe the interactions between our dear couple too limited to fall in love in a modern setting... The story was intriguing though.
Recommend
The common denominator was thanksgiving, situated in America and the coffee shop Mansfield Perk.
A Persuasive Heart, 5*
I absolutely loved this cleverly adapted, modern take on Persuasion. The alterations made to fit the modern world was spot on. I liked that the author had not just transferred the events from the regency era but made them more plausible in a contemporary world.
The sexual tension lay thick without being explicit, another trait I loved about this story...
North by Northanger 4*
Funny twist to Northanger Abbey. Not the most plausible story I have read but definitely entertaining. Serial killers included...
Second Time's the Charm, 4*
A sweet, romantic and slow-paced story about Marianne and Brandon Collins, although Elinor's and Edward's story was featured as well.
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street, 3*
Harriett Woodhouse's (Smith, she was adopted by the Woodhouses) story in a modern setting, written in 1.person. I was rather disappointed as I adore Emma while my interest doesn't stretch to Hariett, I'm afraid...
Melanie Perceived, 3*
Melanie (Fanny Price) is an eager photographer. Eddie (Edmund) plays on the football team while Melanie takes pictures. They are best friends until MaryJo and Hank Crawford enters the field and things get muddled...
The Construction of a Heart, 3.5*
Bennet's as the owner of a construction company was new but I do believe the interactions between our dear couple too limited to fall in love in a modern setting... The story was intriguing though.
Recommend
June 22, 2017
Lovely, heartwarming, and entertaining. Every story is a retelling of one of Austen's six novels, and they are all cleverly done. My favourite one was a NA story, closely followed by P&P and S&S, but I enjoyed all of them very much. They cheered me up immensely over my very stressful week. The P&P retelling made me laugh out loud several times (which earned me rather concerned looks from my family). I also loved those little details linking the stories together (the cafe!). And now I am only too happy to discover there are more collections in the series. I will probably read them all.
Want to read
November 24, 2017Some stories aren't clean, so vet first.
January 21, 2017
I am reviewing the stories separately and my notes contain spoilers:
A Persuasive Visitor (a "Persuasion" story by Cecilia Gray)
3/5 stars
This take on Persuasion isn't bad, I just felt it didn't bring much new to the table, the time skips between the couple's past and present were confusing at some moments and I felt that the final "getting together" was rushed. While in the original story we get a glimpse of Wentworth's thoughts via his letter, here he simple snogs Anne senseless against the wall. Well, that works as well I guess :).
North by Northanger (a "Northanger Abbey" story by Jessica Grey)
3,5/5 stars
Very cute take on Northager Abbey. I loved the fact that Kate was on softball scholarship and I could relate to her (and Henry's sister Lana's) fascination with serial killers since one of my best friends suffers from the same obsession. I really liked the climax with Henry's politician mom shouting at Kate, her coming home and Henry going after her. While I enjoyed this story, I liked the some of the other ones much better, thus the 3,5 stars rating.
Second Time's the Charm (a "Sense and Sensibility" story by Nancy Kelley)
5/5 stars
This was so perfect! I've never been a big fan of Marianne/Colonel Brandon romance because it felt so forced in the original novel. Like she married him only cause he was always around and she didn't have any other options. In Nancy Kelley's retelling, Marianne is recovering from a heartbreak and discovers that she can, in fact, fall in love again. Brandon, the super nice neighbor, is swoon-worthy here, always bringing Marianne her favorite coffee and writing poetry in his spare time. The other romance (of Elinor and Edward) was nicely translated to modern-times as well and I liked that the author didn't omit the bond between the sisters and included some thougtful conversations between them.
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street (an "Emma" story by Jennifer Becton)
4/5 stars
An "Emma" story retold from Harriet's point of view. It was refreshing change and I liked that Harriet was Emma's adopted sister here which explained Emma's need to "take care" of her all the time. I loved that Harriet – "Addy" – only pretended to be interested in Liam Knightley to get back on Emma for her meddling and to make Emma realize who her true love is. The romance of Addy and Martin was nicely executed as well <3.
Melanie Perceived (a "Mansfield Park" story by Rebecca M. Fleming)
4/5 stars
I am not a big fan of Mansfield Park but Rebecca M. Fleming retold it in quite an original way while staying true to the core of the story. While Frankie and Eddie's romance didn't make my heart beat fast, I appreciate that instead of them getting together right away in the end, they promised to take their time and to get to know each other again, which was more realistic :).
The Construction of a Heart (a "Pride and Prejudice" story by Melissa Buell)
5/5 stars
OMG, I adored this P&P retelling! It was seriously so cute! Elizabeth and Darcy actually had really good chemistry here and I loved their reunion in the end. The only thing I didn't like so well was that Lydia actually married Wickham in Vegas instead of – I don't know – maybe just eloping and Darcy finding them in time. I mean, she is only 18 and he lied to her and used her and yet she is portrayed as the bad one. This is actually a problem in the original novel as well, I maintain that Lydia's story was best handled in The Lizzie Bennet Diaries.
In my opinion, Thankful Hearts is one of the strongest collections from Holidays with Jane series. I especially loved Nancy Kelley's Second Time's the Charm and Melissa Buell's The Construction of a Heart, both of which I will definitely reread in the future.
A Persuasive Visitor (a "Persuasion" story by Cecilia Gray)
3/5 stars
This take on Persuasion isn't bad, I just felt it didn't bring much new to the table, the time skips between the couple's past and present were confusing at some moments and I felt that the final "getting together" was rushed. While in the original story we get a glimpse of Wentworth's thoughts via his letter, here he simple snogs Anne senseless against the wall. Well, that works as well I guess :).
North by Northanger (a "Northanger Abbey" story by Jessica Grey)
3,5/5 stars
Very cute take on Northager Abbey. I loved the fact that Kate was on softball scholarship and I could relate to her (and Henry's sister Lana's) fascination with serial killers since one of my best friends suffers from the same obsession. I really liked the climax with Henry's politician mom shouting at Kate, her coming home and Henry going after her. While I enjoyed this story, I liked the some of the other ones much better, thus the 3,5 stars rating.
Second Time's the Charm (a "Sense and Sensibility" story by Nancy Kelley)
5/5 stars
This was so perfect! I've never been a big fan of Marianne/Colonel Brandon romance because it felt so forced in the original novel. Like she married him only cause he was always around and she didn't have any other options. In Nancy Kelley's retelling, Marianne is recovering from a heartbreak and discovers that she can, in fact, fall in love again. Brandon, the super nice neighbor, is swoon-worthy here, always bringing Marianne her favorite coffee and writing poetry in his spare time. The other romance (of Elinor and Edward) was nicely translated to modern-times as well and I liked that the author didn't omit the bond between the sisters and included some thougtful conversations between them.
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street (an "Emma" story by Jennifer Becton)
4/5 stars
An "Emma" story retold from Harriet's point of view. It was refreshing change and I liked that Harriet was Emma's adopted sister here which explained Emma's need to "take care" of her all the time. I loved that Harriet – "Addy" – only pretended to be interested in Liam Knightley to get back on Emma for her meddling and to make Emma realize who her true love is. The romance of Addy and Martin was nicely executed as well <3.
Melanie Perceived (a "Mansfield Park" story by Rebecca M. Fleming)
4/5 stars
I am not a big fan of Mansfield Park but Rebecca M. Fleming retold it in quite an original way while staying true to the core of the story. While Frankie and Eddie's romance didn't make my heart beat fast, I appreciate that instead of them getting together right away in the end, they promised to take their time and to get to know each other again, which was more realistic :).
The Construction of a Heart (a "Pride and Prejudice" story by Melissa Buell)
5/5 stars
OMG, I adored this P&P retelling! It was seriously so cute! Elizabeth and Darcy actually had really good chemistry here and I loved their reunion in the end. The only thing I didn't like so well was that Lydia actually married Wickham in Vegas instead of – I don't know – maybe just eloping and Darcy finding them in time. I mean, she is only 18 and he lied to her and used her and yet she is portrayed as the bad one. This is actually a problem in the original novel as well, I maintain that Lydia's story was best handled in The Lizzie Bennet Diaries.
In my opinion, Thankful Hearts is one of the strongest collections from Holidays with Jane series. I especially loved Nancy Kelley's Second Time's the Charm and Melissa Buell's The Construction of a Heart, both of which I will definitely reread in the future.
November 8, 2016
I am the proud owner of all the Holidays with Jane collections. This is my favorite so far. From steamy Persuasion adaptations to different viewpoints in an Emma rewrite, all of these stories are fantastic. They make you want to meet the characters and further explore Jane's work and world. As always, I want to visit Mansfield Perk and get one of those cream and lavender cups myself.
September 20, 2017
i heart spending the holidays with jane austen's characters and the indie jane authors' clever takes on her beloved classics. pure. loveliness.
February 24, 2018
Every single story is fabulous, read each one twice!
October 12, 2023
Published by Indie Jane Press as always, this anthology dedicated to Jane Austen and her characters is a delightful gift to open with great joy. Set at Thanksgiving, each of the six stories is inspired by the novels of the famous English writer but with a modern twist.
I love these collections and this time my absolute favourite stories were Second Time’s the Charm by Nancy Kelley and Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street by Jennifer Becton. Both really beautiful!
If you are a Jane Austen fan you can't miss this one! Let the warmth of Thanksgiving wrap you like a comfortable blanket.
I love these collections and this time my absolute favourite stories were Second Time’s the Charm by Nancy Kelley and Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street by Jennifer Becton. Both really beautiful!
If you are a Jane Austen fan you can't miss this one! Let the warmth of Thanksgiving wrap you like a comfortable blanket.
July 25, 2017
Y'all ... I continue to be blown away by the stories that these women write, and am SO honored to be part of their writing project. Also: there are some *exceptionally* swoony heroes in this volume. Ahem.
December 18, 2017
A collection of stories set in the modern day for Jane Austens' characters as they celebrate Thanksgiving in their different ways. An enjoyable set of stories.
November 11, 2020
This is my last Holiday with Jane since I've been reading it out of order, and I have to say it's been fun bingeing my way through the year with these ladies. Thankful Hearts was actually my favorite from the collection, so I guess I somehow managed to save the best for last. I read most of these out of season but imagine they'd feel even more festive if you read them when they're meant to be read. Finishing this book left me feeling a little wistful, but I'm even more disappointed we're living in a world where Mansfield Perk doesn't exist (and I don't even drink coffee.) Can some business-savvy Janeites make it a reality please?
A Persuasive Visitor (Cecilia Gray) 0.5 stars
I was so excited when I started this because, as a pediatric oncologist, Anne Elliot is a woman after my own heart and because Cecilia Gray seemed to remember that the whole theme of Persuasion is actually, you know, the power of persuasion. The rest of the story, though, is a bit of a travesty. Wentworth loses his shirt during his first meeting with Anne and he never really gets it back. Instead of subtly and slow-burn, we get a lot of sexual tension and content that would make Austen's original readers faint. It's no wonder Anne dumped Patrick (Wentworth) for med school when their relationship is portrayed as purely physical. (There's also true love and all that, but that's not what I'm getting from the text.) To add insult to injury, the final scene is a joke. Wentworth pretty much appears, and they start making out. No conversation, no confession. Nothing. There's a brief, blink-and-you'll-miss-it nod to the famous letter at the very end, but instead of half-hope, half-agony, we get a pinch of hope and a whole lot of sex. (Thankfully it mostly happens off the page, but still.)
Okay, sorry, one more mini-rant because that ending was so horrible, but the whole reason Wentworth thinks he has a chance is because he hears she turned down a fancy job?? It makes zero sense to me because Gray actually has him overhear a debate between Anne and Benwick about heartbreak, like why not use that?!
North by Northanger (Jessica Grey) 5 stars
This might be my favorite interpretation of Northanger Abbey. How has nobody thought to make Catherine Morland a fan of serial killer documentaries until now? It's so perfect and totally fits with the theme about the dangers of an overactive imagination. Kate Moore is a tomboy missing her brain-to-mouth filter, and Henry is the Senator's son who gets along with everyone. One day they're single and the next day they're not...maybe? They haven't really defined the relationship, but that's okay, because he takes her home for Thanksgiving. But when his mom's guest resembles a missing murderer from the Investigation Discovery Channel...
Purists might read my rave review and think I'm crazy, but I loved this. I will say it's been a while since I read the original so there are probably a few things that weren't totally in line with canon. Grey's interpretation was so clever. I loved the idea of Lana (Eleanor) as a rebellious teen and Mrs. Taylor (General Tilney) as an appearance-conscious elected official with lofty campaign goals. Henry is so endearing and his interactions with Kate were #goals. (Like I also hate dress shopping, where is my meet cute?) The banter, the exposition on California lingo, even the flashbacks were all spot-on, making this my new favorite Northanger Abbey variation.
Second Time's the Charm (Nancy Kelley) 3 stars
I know I keep complaining there isn't enough Marianne x Brandon stories in this collection, but this one was a bit underwhelming. (I mean, there is a reason third time's the charm...) Marianne takes a page out of Emma's book and throws herself into playing matchmaker for Edward and Elinor in an attempt to distract herself from heartbreak. Brandon, a licensed therapist, gives her space and a listening ear when she needs it...and this all presumably happens around Thanksgiving? It was just a little too slow for me. There's subtly and then there's boring, and this fell into the second category for me.
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street (Jennifer Becton) 4.5 stars
What a refreshing take on Emma! I wasn't sure how I'd feel about reading a story from Harriet's point of view, but Becton pulled it off beautifully. Instead of being Emma's little project, she's an adopted sister who keeps getting roped into set-ups by her well-meaning but misguided sister.
I loved this version of Harriet. She's sharp, sweet and much stronger personality-wise than in the original. She uses a "dumb girl routine" to get rid of unwanted bachelors (i.e. Elton) and reminds us all that adoption can be thicker than blood. It's a pretty bold move to take a supporting character and make her the narrator, but Becton managed to do so in a way that's still faithful to the original story. You still get an intelligent protagonist blind to her own feelings and get to watch Emma's character arc from a different perspective.
I didn't really realize it was a thing, but apparently people hate Emma? I don't think that'll be an issue here because Becton portrays her as well, meddlesome and clueless and downright annoying sometimes, but so well-intentioned you can't help but love her. (But haters should also watch the BBC version and then see if they still feel the same way about Emma.)
Melanie Perceived (Rebecca M. Fleming) 3.5 stars
Fleming ends her acknowledgments by saying, "even though Mansfield Park is officially my least favorite of all her novels, I have a greater appreciation for the story she was telling now, after spending so much time with the characters. I like to think she’d understand, even approve, the change I had to make." I wholeheartedly agree. I've always thought Mansfield Park wasn't Austen's best work, so I was surprised I liked this interpretation of it. I've always thought Fanny was a little boring, and maybe I just haven't read the original in a while, but Frankie felt like a more developed version of Austen's heroine. Plus, it's always bothered me that I'm supposed to believe that Edmund rebounding from Mary to Fanny is romantic and like the fact that Fleming chose more of an opening ending instead. I also just really want a Grampa Jamie to talk to about life and football--apparently he's inspired by a real life person--where can I find one?
The Construction of a Heart (Melissa Buell) 2 stars
This was essentially a whirlwind modern version of P&P. There isn't really a plot to this. The story feels kind of slapped together and a little aimless at times. Elizabeth and Darcy work for rival construction companies that also have to host the annual Thanksgiving because that's how you find love in a small town (at least according to the Hallmark Channel). There isn't any particularly convincing about "The Construction of a Heart," and even the infamous first impressions feels watered down. I have a hard time believing Mr. Bennet would be such a shotgun father to Lizzy and then completely ignore Lydia and Wickham. It's almost as if, by trying to cram Pride and Prejudice in its entirety into this short story, Buell lost the heart of the story, leaving us with a subdued version of the original.
A Persuasive Visitor (Cecilia Gray) 0.5 stars
I was so excited when I started this because, as a pediatric oncologist, Anne Elliot is a woman after my own heart and because Cecilia Gray seemed to remember that the whole theme of Persuasion is actually, you know, the power of persuasion. The rest of the story, though, is a bit of a travesty. Wentworth loses his shirt during his first meeting with Anne and he never really gets it back. Instead of subtly and slow-burn, we get a lot of sexual tension and content that would make Austen's original readers faint. It's no wonder Anne dumped Patrick (Wentworth) for med school when their relationship is portrayed as purely physical. (There's also true love and all that, but that's not what I'm getting from the text.) To add insult to injury, the final scene is a joke. Wentworth pretty much appears, and they start making out. No conversation, no confession. Nothing. There's a brief, blink-and-you'll-miss-it nod to the famous letter at the very end, but instead of half-hope, half-agony, we get a pinch of hope and a whole lot of sex. (Thankfully it mostly happens off the page, but still.)
Okay, sorry, one more mini-rant because that ending was so horrible, but the whole reason Wentworth thinks he has a chance is because he hears she turned down a fancy job?? It makes zero sense to me because Gray actually has him overhear a debate between Anne and Benwick about heartbreak, like why not use that?!
North by Northanger (Jessica Grey) 5 stars
This might be my favorite interpretation of Northanger Abbey. How has nobody thought to make Catherine Morland a fan of serial killer documentaries until now? It's so perfect and totally fits with the theme about the dangers of an overactive imagination. Kate Moore is a tomboy missing her brain-to-mouth filter, and Henry is the Senator's son who gets along with everyone. One day they're single and the next day they're not...maybe? They haven't really defined the relationship, but that's okay, because he takes her home for Thanksgiving. But when his mom's guest resembles a missing murderer from the Investigation Discovery Channel...
Purists might read my rave review and think I'm crazy, but I loved this. I will say it's been a while since I read the original so there are probably a few things that weren't totally in line with canon. Grey's interpretation was so clever. I loved the idea of Lana (Eleanor) as a rebellious teen and Mrs. Taylor (General Tilney) as an appearance-conscious elected official with lofty campaign goals. Henry is so endearing and his interactions with Kate were #goals. (Like I also hate dress shopping, where is my meet cute?) The banter, the exposition on California lingo, even the flashbacks were all spot-on, making this my new favorite Northanger Abbey variation.
Second Time's the Charm (Nancy Kelley) 3 stars
I know I keep complaining there isn't enough Marianne x Brandon stories in this collection, but this one was a bit underwhelming. (I mean, there is a reason third time's the charm...) Marianne takes a page out of Emma's book and throws herself into playing matchmaker for Edward and Elinor in an attempt to distract herself from heartbreak. Brandon, a licensed therapist, gives her space and a listening ear when she needs it...and this all presumably happens around Thanksgiving? It was just a little too slow for me. There's subtly and then there's boring, and this fell into the second category for me.
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street (Jennifer Becton) 4.5 stars
What a refreshing take on Emma! I wasn't sure how I'd feel about reading a story from Harriet's point of view, but Becton pulled it off beautifully. Instead of being Emma's little project, she's an adopted sister who keeps getting roped into set-ups by her well-meaning but misguided sister.
I loved this version of Harriet. She's sharp, sweet and much stronger personality-wise than in the original. She uses a "dumb girl routine" to get rid of unwanted bachelors (i.e. Elton) and reminds us all that adoption can be thicker than blood. It's a pretty bold move to take a supporting character and make her the narrator, but Becton managed to do so in a way that's still faithful to the original story. You still get an intelligent protagonist blind to her own feelings and get to watch Emma's character arc from a different perspective.
I didn't really realize it was a thing, but apparently people hate Emma? I don't think that'll be an issue here because Becton portrays her as well, meddlesome and clueless and downright annoying sometimes, but so well-intentioned you can't help but love her. (But haters should also watch the BBC version and then see if they still feel the same way about Emma.)
Melanie Perceived (Rebecca M. Fleming) 3.5 stars
Fleming ends her acknowledgments by saying, "even though Mansfield Park is officially my least favorite of all her novels, I have a greater appreciation for the story she was telling now, after spending so much time with the characters. I like to think she’d understand, even approve, the change I had to make." I wholeheartedly agree. I've always thought Mansfield Park wasn't Austen's best work, so I was surprised I liked this interpretation of it. I've always thought Fanny was a little boring, and maybe I just haven't read the original in a while, but Frankie felt like a more developed version of Austen's heroine. Plus, it's always bothered me that I'm supposed to believe that Edmund rebounding from Mary to Fanny is romantic and like the fact that Fleming chose more of an opening ending instead. I also just really want a Grampa Jamie to talk to about life and football--apparently he's inspired by a real life person--where can I find one?
The Construction of a Heart (Melissa Buell) 2 stars
This was essentially a whirlwind modern version of P&P. There isn't really a plot to this. The story feels kind of slapped together and a little aimless at times. Elizabeth and Darcy work for rival construction companies that also have to host the annual Thanksgiving because that's how you find love in a small town (at least according to the Hallmark Channel). There isn't any particularly convincing about "The Construction of a Heart," and even the infamous first impressions feels watered down. I have a hard time believing Mr. Bennet would be such a shotgun father to Lizzy and then completely ignore Lydia and Wickham. It's almost as if, by trying to cram Pride and Prejudice in its entirety into this short story, Buell lost the heart of the story, leaving us with a subdued version of the original.
February 6, 2017
Alors, vous connaissez la règle... Je vais vous donner mon avis sur chaque histoire
* A Persuasive Visitor de Cecilia Gray :Thanksgiving with your crazy family is hard enough without your rich and sexy ex-boyfriend, whom you were dumb enough to dump, showing up for the weekend. The only way it could be any worse would be if he started paying attention to another girl... which, of course, is exactly what happens to Anne Elliot. But the good thing about hitting rock bottom is that the only direction to go is up.
Un petit diner de Thanksgiving avec des retrouvailles inattendues entre Anne et Patrick (je n'aime pas trop ce prénom) qui se sont aimés avant la fac de Anne. Bon, Patrick en pompier le fait moyennement et Anne est, comme toujours, médecin. J'ai bien aimé les flashbacks sur leur relation et j'ai été séduite par la réécriture : courte mais efficace. En revanche j'avoue que je n'avais pas compris tout de suite pourquoi Patrick revenait et j'ai été déçue de ne pas avoir la belle déclaration d'amour
Ma note : 6,5/10
* North by Northanger de Jessica Grey : Kate Moore knows a lot about softball and sass...but she's clueless when it comes to guys. Especially smart, cute, worldly guys like Henry Taylor. When Henry invites her home for Thanksgiving, Kate is over the moon. But will her propensity for acting first and thinking later mess up her chances with Henry?
Dans cette histoire, Kate est déjà avec Henry (on est donc sur la seconde partie de NA, celle où Katherine se rend chez les Tilney) et du coup il n'y a pas de couple Isabella (Mercerdes) avec le frère de Kate. Dans cette version, Kate et Lana (la soeur d'Henry) sont fans de faits divers et de crimes non élucidés. L'idée est bonne et j'ai apprécié le fait que pour une fois, le genre du parent encore en vie change (la maman veuve d'Henry est tout aussi impressionnante que le Général). Le tout se suit avec beaucoup de plaisir et il n'y a pas de temps mort dans l'histoire qui reste assez drôle
Ma note : 8/10
* Second Time's the Charm de Nancy Kelley : Marianne Dashwood has always believed in One True Love. But when her love isn’t true, Brandon Collins helps her pick up the pieces. Marianne dismissed her mother’s boring neighbor when they met, but his quiet personality hides depths that call to her as she gets to know him.
Will Marianne’s dedication to the ideal of One True Love leave her alone forever? Or will she find that with Brandon, the second time’s the charm?
Ah j'ai bien aimé cette histoire qui débute avec la rupture de Marianne. La suite est bien respectée (avec un twist pour expliquer la présence de Lucy), des personnages dont les caractères sont ceux des originaux (même si Marianne est un peu moins exaltée) et une jolie fin pour nos deux soeurs (seul bémol, les deux diminutifs dont elles s'affublent... Norrie et Mari c'est pas possible)
Ma note : 7/10
* Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street de Jennifer Becton : When vet student Harriet “Addy” Woodhouse returns home to Highbury, Georgia, for Thanksgiving, she longs to relax and spend time with her father, her sister Emma, and her best friend Martin. But Emma’s incessant meddling causes Addy to hatch her own cunning plan, which not only threatens to ruin the entire Thanksgiving celebration, but reveals the secret loves of both sisters’ hearts.
Déjà, j'admets que j'adore l'idée de faire d'Harriet la soeur adoptive d'Emma et centrer l'histoire sur son point de vue. J'apprécie également la manière dont l'auteure justifie sa brusque sagacité (en fait, en société, elle fait la bécasse pour qu'on évite de lui poser des questions). L'histoire est savoureuse et plutot enjouée tout en respectant les codes d'Emma. Une vraie innovation !
Ma note : 8,5/10
* Melanie Perceived de Rebecca M. Fleming : For as long as she can remember, Melanie Frances Price has loved Eddie. Growing up next door to the wealthy Bertrams, she is used to being his shadow - they are inseparable, the “Eddie & Frankie Show.” With post-college plans on the horizon, she hopes the friendship will (finally) develop into more. But when MaryJo Crawford waltzes onto the scene, changing everything, Melanie must decide what is really worth fighting for.
Ahhh c'est toujours périlleux d'adapter Mansfield Park mais l'auteure s'en sort bien. Le personnage de Melanie est sympa (et s'affirme contrairement à Fanny...) et j'ai aimé ce qu'elle a fait des Crawford (surtout de Mary). Le tout est convaincant et agréable à lire
Ma note : 6,5/10
* The Construction of a Heart de Melissa Buell : Elizabeth Bennet credits the success of Bennet Homes to her close-knit family, however dysfunctional they might be. The Meryton Chamber of Commerce calls on local businesses to host the annual All-Town Thanksgiving Feast. Unfortunately, Elizabeth is paired up with pretentious businessman Will Darcy of Pemberley Estates, her main rival in the construction business. Will Elizabeth be able to fill up her Thankful Jar this year?
Le plan d'Orgueil et Préjugés est parfaitement respecté (même si nous n'avons plus que 3 soeurs) et j'ai beaucoup aimé le déroulé de l'histoire. L'auteure a également su réécrire la proposition de Darcy ainsi que sa lettre de justifications et le tout se laisse lire avec plaisir. Les personnages sont fidèles aux originaux et l'écriture est agréable. Et l'idée de faire s'enfuir Lydia et Wickham à Las Vegas m'a beaucoup fait rire
Ma note : 7,5/10
Pour résumer :
Ce que j'aime : l'inventivité des auteures, de vraiment très bonne versions sur cet opus
Ce que j'aime moins : encore une fois, le format trop court, qui empèche d'approfondir le sujet
En bref : Un excellent cru de la série et des auteures qui savent se renouveler tout en restant fidèles à l'esprit Jane Austen
Ma note
7,5/10
* A Persuasive Visitor de Cecilia Gray :Thanksgiving with your crazy family is hard enough without your rich and sexy ex-boyfriend, whom you were dumb enough to dump, showing up for the weekend. The only way it could be any worse would be if he started paying attention to another girl... which, of course, is exactly what happens to Anne Elliot. But the good thing about hitting rock bottom is that the only direction to go is up.
Un petit diner de Thanksgiving avec des retrouvailles inattendues entre Anne et Patrick (je n'aime pas trop ce prénom) qui se sont aimés avant la fac de Anne. Bon, Patrick en pompier le fait moyennement et Anne est, comme toujours, médecin. J'ai bien aimé les flashbacks sur leur relation et j'ai été séduite par la réécriture : courte mais efficace. En revanche j'avoue que je n'avais pas compris tout de suite pourquoi Patrick revenait et j'ai été déçue de ne pas avoir la belle déclaration d'amour
Ma note : 6,5/10
* North by Northanger de Jessica Grey : Kate Moore knows a lot about softball and sass...but she's clueless when it comes to guys. Especially smart, cute, worldly guys like Henry Taylor. When Henry invites her home for Thanksgiving, Kate is over the moon. But will her propensity for acting first and thinking later mess up her chances with Henry?
Dans cette histoire, Kate est déjà avec Henry (on est donc sur la seconde partie de NA, celle où Katherine se rend chez les Tilney) et du coup il n'y a pas de couple Isabella (Mercerdes) avec le frère de Kate. Dans cette version, Kate et Lana (la soeur d'Henry) sont fans de faits divers et de crimes non élucidés. L'idée est bonne et j'ai apprécié le fait que pour une fois, le genre du parent encore en vie change (la maman veuve d'Henry est tout aussi impressionnante que le Général). Le tout se suit avec beaucoup de plaisir et il n'y a pas de temps mort dans l'histoire qui reste assez drôle
Ma note : 8/10
* Second Time's the Charm de Nancy Kelley : Marianne Dashwood has always believed in One True Love. But when her love isn’t true, Brandon Collins helps her pick up the pieces. Marianne dismissed her mother’s boring neighbor when they met, but his quiet personality hides depths that call to her as she gets to know him.
Will Marianne’s dedication to the ideal of One True Love leave her alone forever? Or will she find that with Brandon, the second time’s the charm?
Ah j'ai bien aimé cette histoire qui débute avec la rupture de Marianne. La suite est bien respectée (avec un twist pour expliquer la présence de Lucy), des personnages dont les caractères sont ceux des originaux (même si Marianne est un peu moins exaltée) et une jolie fin pour nos deux soeurs (seul bémol, les deux diminutifs dont elles s'affublent... Norrie et Mari c'est pas possible)
Ma note : 7/10
* Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street de Jennifer Becton : When vet student Harriet “Addy” Woodhouse returns home to Highbury, Georgia, for Thanksgiving, she longs to relax and spend time with her father, her sister Emma, and her best friend Martin. But Emma’s incessant meddling causes Addy to hatch her own cunning plan, which not only threatens to ruin the entire Thanksgiving celebration, but reveals the secret loves of both sisters’ hearts.
Déjà, j'admets que j'adore l'idée de faire d'Harriet la soeur adoptive d'Emma et centrer l'histoire sur son point de vue. J'apprécie également la manière dont l'auteure justifie sa brusque sagacité (en fait, en société, elle fait la bécasse pour qu'on évite de lui poser des questions). L'histoire est savoureuse et plutot enjouée tout en respectant les codes d'Emma. Une vraie innovation !
Ma note : 8,5/10
* Melanie Perceived de Rebecca M. Fleming : For as long as she can remember, Melanie Frances Price has loved Eddie. Growing up next door to the wealthy Bertrams, she is used to being his shadow - they are inseparable, the “Eddie & Frankie Show.” With post-college plans on the horizon, she hopes the friendship will (finally) develop into more. But when MaryJo Crawford waltzes onto the scene, changing everything, Melanie must decide what is really worth fighting for.
Ahhh c'est toujours périlleux d'adapter Mansfield Park mais l'auteure s'en sort bien. Le personnage de Melanie est sympa (et s'affirme contrairement à Fanny...) et j'ai aimé ce qu'elle a fait des Crawford (surtout de Mary). Le tout est convaincant et agréable à lire
Ma note : 6,5/10
* The Construction of a Heart de Melissa Buell : Elizabeth Bennet credits the success of Bennet Homes to her close-knit family, however dysfunctional they might be. The Meryton Chamber of Commerce calls on local businesses to host the annual All-Town Thanksgiving Feast. Unfortunately, Elizabeth is paired up with pretentious businessman Will Darcy of Pemberley Estates, her main rival in the construction business. Will Elizabeth be able to fill up her Thankful Jar this year?
Le plan d'Orgueil et Préjugés est parfaitement respecté (même si nous n'avons plus que 3 soeurs) et j'ai beaucoup aimé le déroulé de l'histoire. L'auteure a également su réécrire la proposition de Darcy ainsi que sa lettre de justifications et le tout se laisse lire avec plaisir. Les personnages sont fidèles aux originaux et l'écriture est agréable. Et l'idée de faire s'enfuir Lydia et Wickham à Las Vegas m'a beaucoup fait rire
Ma note : 7,5/10
Pour résumer :
Ce que j'aime : l'inventivité des auteures, de vraiment très bonne versions sur cet opus
Ce que j'aime moins : encore une fois, le format trop court, qui empèche d'approfondir le sujet
En bref : Un excellent cru de la série et des auteures qui savent se renouveler tout en restant fidèles à l'esprit Jane Austen
Ma note
7,5/10
December 25, 2018
Enjoyable Austenesque
I do enjoy a good retelling of old favorites, and this collections of short did not disappoint. Putting classic Jane Austen characters in a modern setting and writing each story around a Thanksgiving theme was a great idea.
I do enjoy a good retelling of old favorites, and this collections of short did not disappoint. Putting classic Jane Austen characters in a modern setting and writing each story around a Thanksgiving theme was a great idea.
August 15, 2024
I only came for the Persuasion story: A Persuasive Visitor by Cecilia Gray 4.5* the resolution came a bit quick, but no matter, I still liked it. Who can resist a firefighter?
February 6, 2017
I wrote the short story "The Construction of a Heart" based on PRIDE AND PREJUDICE for this installment of HOLIDAYS WITH JANE. I love the stories that my "book sisters" have written for this collection. <3
Want to read
March 31, 2020A Persuasive Visitor (Persuasion Variation) AKA: Intimacies
North by Northanger (Northanger Abbey Variation)
Second Time's the Charm (Sense & Sensibility Variation)
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street (Emma Variation)
Melanie Perceived (Mansfield Park Variation)
The Construction of a Heart (Pride & Prejudice Variation)
North by Northanger (Northanger Abbey Variation)
Second Time's the Charm (Sense & Sensibility Variation)
Thanksgiving on Hartfield Street (Emma Variation)
Melanie Perceived (Mansfield Park Variation)
The Construction of a Heart (Pride & Prejudice Variation)
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews