In the few books I’ve read on reign of Charles II, The Duke of Monmouth gets a mention here and there. Not much was memorable other than his birth in the Netherlands and his ill-fated rebellion. The image I had was murky and slightly negative. Anna Keay lifts him out of obscurity and her take has him a principled hero.
James, Charles II’s first “natural son”, had a highly unstable childhood. His mother, the beautiful Lucy Walter, disinherited by her own mother, is in constant search for a man to support her. Charles, mourning his beheaded father and other family losses, was dependent on the hospitality of other royal houses.
As Lucy went from man to man with their son, Charles made several kidnapping attempts, finally with success when James was 9. Lucy Walter died shortly after. There was some tutoring, and then with the Restoration a move to England, an opulent life, a ducal title, a wealthy bride and an environment ideal for a playboy youth. As he matured, Keay shows him a brave soldier and military leader and a very able administrator as Master of the Horse and Chancellor of Cambridge University.
From the photos he appears to resemble his father and Charles seems to favor him over all his natural children none of whom seem to have so many positions and titles. There are many instances that show the intimacy of father and son.
Keay shows his uncle James who once, like his father doted on him, change as his namesake matured into a respected member of the court. Uncle James knows that his Catholic faith (and wife) will not make for a smooth succession and begins to see his titled and achieving nephew as a threat. (It appears that all the Duke needs is legitimacy, and he’s a shoe in.) You see the uncle’s scornful acts in and his nephew as naive about the lengths his uncle will go to secure the crown.
We know today that Charles received payments from the French who certainly favored a Catholic succession. Perhaps this is why his son must be sent away. The reasons are not clear to his son and he is stunned and hurt. Charles loves this son, keeps in touch and keeps paying him his pension. At times it seems he might be working behind the scenes on his son’s behalf. There is some unusual correspondence during his second exile, just before his father’s untimely death. A case can be made that with Nephew James out of the country, Uncle James saw an opportunity and took his shot.
The story of the sad rebellion where James fights the army he once led, shows him to be knowledgeable about warfare, considerate of his men but trapped, betrayed. He died making important statements on behalf of Protestant England, but not so much as to jeopardize his wife and surviving children.
John Locke and his treatises have a cameo, since they form the foundation the limitations on monarchs that follow the abdication of (uncle) James II.
I wonder what would have been in store for the Duke had he just bided his time in the Netherlands with his cousins.
Keay bring James to life. It she clearly presents and documents the complex issues that surround the Duke of Monmouth. If you like history through an engrossing story of the players, this is for you.