Kate Shackleton, Mrs. Sugden and Jim Sykes have decided to separate and take some time off for personal vacations. For Kate, this provides the opportunity to visit her old school friend Alma Turner and Alma's daughter Felicity at the seaside. Kate looks forward to catching up with her goddaughter and old friend. She arrives in Whitby, reminiscing about her carefree younger days when she and Gerald first fell in love and became engaged. Her memories lead her to a jeweler's shop where she intends to buy a gift for Felicity but discovers the jeweler lying dead in the back room! She tries to leave the investigating to the local constabulary but when Felicity goes missing with her sweetheart and Alma falls apart, Kate fears the police will suspect Felicity and Brendan of murder! When Kate herself falls under suspicion, she knows she needs reinforcements to help her find Felicity. With whispers of underhanded doings and a mysterious, haunted house, Kate is certain her friend and goddaughter are in trouble.
I absolutely could not put this book down. The plot had a lot of things going on that kept me guessing as to the motive for the murder. There are many red herrings along the way and some things are never fully explained. I was one step ahead of Kate and friends in some respects but mostly perplexed as to who could have done it. Finally, just before Kate and Sykes put the clues together, I knew who did it.
As always, the period descriptions are excellent. I could easily imagine myself in Whitby in the 1920s staying in a lush hotel like the Royal and traveling the streets off the beaten path. The Pepper Pot, Bagley Hall and of course the sea were all very vivid in my mind as I read the book.
I've gotten to know Kate through several books and I like her better than I did at first. When her friends are involved in the mystery, she becomes a little more passionate and emotional in telling the story. She has also had a little romance in her life which softens her a bit. Part of her is still mourning Gerald but most of her seems to like being an independent woman. She is a strong and interesting central character. Mr. Sykes is a complicated man. He sees the world in black and white and has high moral standards, yet I feel like he doesn't honor his matrimonial vows very well. Rosie is very patient and understanding or a woman of her time who doesn't look too closely at what her husband does. Mrs. Sugden provides a little bit of humor with her tough, no-nonsense approach. Inspector Marcus Charles reappears in Kate's life. She may be attracted to him but he is not an appealing man. He comes across as a bit too conceited but he does seem to be good at his job.
The new characters here include Kate's friend Alma. Alma was a hysterical child prone to fainting fits. She was unpopular in school and seems to have sought out popularity by becoming eccentric. Alma is sort of a New Age person- a fortune teller and author of books claiming to predict the future. I liked her at first but as the story progressed, I really disliked her. She is one of those women who needs a man by her side, who only sees their own misfortune and dwells on it. Her backstory is utterly tragic, if I am interpreting her words correctly. She isn't too bright or inquisitive and it gets her into trouble. She always put her trust in the wrong men.
At first Felicity seems like a spoiled brat. She's 16 and has a good job and should be grateful or saving for her future. Instead she steals a boat and runs off to find her absent father. Once I got to know Alma and Felicity better, I understood why Felicity wanted her father. The girl never had any structure in her life and her father actually provided for her once in awhile! Her mother's inability to face facts led Felicity to act rashly. Felicity is young and stupid but she had a good reason for doing what she did.
Mr. Cripplethorpe, who owns half of Alma's house, is a fun character. He's mysterious, almost magical and gothic. Once he revealed his story I liked him very much. His story doesn't have a complete conclusion as to who and why and is just summarized at the end. He is somehow tied into Felicity's father and Jack Philips, the jeweler through a mysterious business which is pretty obvious to Kate. The complete connection though is never fully revealed.
The murder victim, Mr. Philips, does not sound like he was an honorable man but he did not deserve to die. Since he is dead at the beginning of the story, the reader only gets everyone else's opinion of him. The full story shows him to be a little more complicated than everyone believes.
The local people of Whitby make up the rest of the story. Brendan, Felicity's sweetheart, is a foolish young man. I don't see them as a good match. He's young and naive but does have a good head on his shoulders at times of crisis. I would have liked to get to know him better and have a richer conclusion from his point-of-view. His mother, Mrs. Webb, works hard and tries to mind her own business but is drawn into the investigation due to her son's disappearance. I liked her a lot. She had a tough life and knows more than she should but doesn't gossip. She is very typical of a working class woman as depicted in this series. I also liked her daughter Hilda. She is friendly and nice yet she is quick to share secrets with a stranger. Her mother didn't approve but I feel like she did the right thing and admired her for it. Miss Dowzell, he newsagent is a suspicious character. She had the opportunity for murder but did she do it? Her story is very very sad. I did not like Mr. Dowzell from the start. He was a bit rude to Kate in the beginning, nosy and bombastic. He seemed like a self-important man of the type Kate (and I) can't stand. Mr. Garvin, the police sergeant, is way too suspicious and yet way too ignorant of everything that is going on. I found him nearly as chauvinistic as Marcus but not as bad.
I look forward to reading the next book in the series and may go back and read the others I missed.