(I received a copy of "No Dream is Too High" as a Goodreads giveaway.)
I really wanted to like this book, but I found it a difficult read. The title should have been “Egotistical Maniac Aldrin Pretends to be Just Like You”. To be fair, Buzz Aldrin is an outstanding human being who has achieved a great deal in his lifetime, and he has much to be legitimately proud of, but the tone of this book was pretty horrid and unflattering. I am half convinced that Aldrin is using the piece to push for his Mars Cylinder idea, which according to him, would use existing technology to reach Mars right now. Apparently NASA, Congress, and humanity generally simply do not have the will and imagination Aldrin has.
The life lessons presented in “No Dream is Too High” are good enough as they go, but the examples Aldrin uses are terrible. Be bold. That is a good life lesson. The example Aldrin uses is how he saw design flaws in the Space Shuttle design early on, but he broke his life lesson and kept silent. As a result he could have perhaps prevented both the Columbia and Challenger disasters. I find this hard to believe. Out of the thousands of individuals who worked in the Space Shuttle, Aldrin just so happens to catch a fatal design flaw, but says nothing. Be adventurous. That is a good life lesson. The example Aldrin uses is that he went to the Moon, saw the wreck of the Titanic, and took a submarine through the ice at the North Pole. I cannot relate to that.
Be assertive when trying to attain your goals. That is a good life lesson. The example Aldrin uses is how he really wanted to go aboard Obama’s Air Force One (because he had been aboard Kennedy’s and Nixon’s). So he pressures and bombards Obama’s staff until they ultimately concede to let him aboard. I don’t care how motivated I am, I doubt I will ever be able to talk and bluff my way onto the president’s plane. And of course, once Aldrin is aboard Air Force One, he explains to Obama how the rest of the world has been wrong about space exploration and he, Buzz Aldrin, has figured out how to get to Mars using Phobos. So give him some appropriations.
The most extreme story is how Aldrin was taught humility once at the airport. Apparently Aldrin makes a habit of using private lounges in various airports without paying for them. Once he was refused service because even though he walked on the Moon, the attendant was principles enough to say that nobody is granted access to the lounge without paying a membership fee. And Aldrin felt humbled! I never demand services because of who I am. Was Aldrin really so deluded as to think it was okay to demand free service because of his accomplishments? Agreeing to pay money for services rendered is not humility, not a concession of magnanimity, it is normal human interaction. Aldrin was not exercising humility that day, he was put in his proper place by a women who was willing to stand up to his ego.
Speaking of humility, Aldrin claims that he was never interested in making money or having abundance of material possessions. Easy for him to say when you’re the guy who walked on the Moon, came to maturity in the most prosperous period in United States history, and gets spontaneously invited to black tie events on a regular basis. Buzz Aldrin has not lived a normal life. I have no problem with that. His story is an interesting one. Unfortunately Aldrin seems to be entirely ignorant of how unique he is. The reason most people have not been to the North Pole, or testified before congress, or won the Presidential Medal of Freedom, is because those things are not ordinary. Aldrin seems to believe that if we would just stop being narrow-minded we could be just like him. And of course, he has figured out how to reach Mars. If we were not so narrow minded we would have a colony there already. Because Aldrin knows best.
So, “No Dream is Too High” was a rather horrid book. The life lessons are fine, but they are expressed by a man who essentially says “I am an astronaut. You either agree with me, or you are narrow minded and unmotivated. And, if the world was more like me, we would have reached Mars by now.” Even so, there are a few upsides to the book. It is a quick read, and some of the stories about the space program are genuinely interesting, such as how John Houbolt’s innovation saved the program, or how the iodine disinfectant cloths were simply dumped straight into the ocean. By and large though, my appraisal of space exploration was more harmed than helped. What a terrible spokesperson.
The Apollo astronauts have every reason to be proud of their achievements but this does not grant them license to be snobbish egomaniacs.