EVA: The Shojo.
I know, right? It's about the last thing you'd expect and quite possibly the last thing you would want. When I saw this in the catalog, I cringed, and I admit that I even had to take this out of the library a couple times before bringing myself to read it because I was afraid of how much it might suck.
But you know what? It's not bad. A sacrilege? Quite possibly. But it's not bad.
Shinji, Asuka, Rey, and the gang are all here in one form or the other, and at first it's just another normal high school. But then they are subjected to mysterious tests and Shinji starts having strange dreams of terrible monsters. And Rey gets a strong personality! What is lurking beyond the shadows?
Amazingly enough, this one does a pretty good job of keeping the mystery and strangeness of EVA while the usual boy-girl-girl trouble and high school angst of a shojo drive the story. I didn't think that was possible, but it works. However, it's very jarring, and some of the characters feel a bit off (Rey in particular) to fit their molds in a Shojo world. Of course, the Asuka-Shinji banter wasn't all that hard to incorporate, and the writer does a great job with them. I also must admit that even though I know this story like the back of my hand by now, I want to see how the writer gets us there. That's usually a good sign.
All in all, I'd say get past your immediate objection and give this a try, but only if you an EVA fan that also likes Shojo. If you're not into Shojo, don't bother, as you'll come away disappointed. (Libary, 07/08)
Trebby's Take: Better than I expected.