What do you think?
Rate this book
Gaslight Mystery #4
Murder on Washington Square
Turn-of-the-century New York City midwife Sarah Brandt and Detective Sergeant Frank Molloy are thrust into a twisted case of murder—when a seductress falls victim to her own charades.
336 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published April 2, 2002
275 people are currently reading
1744 people want to read
About the author
Victoria Thompson
84 books2,446 followersVictoria Thompson was a beloved authoress of 'standard mystery' novels.
This middle of the road tone is not violent like a 'thriller' but unsanitized (NOT light like a 'cozy mystery'), is unflinchingly adult, serious, and dark.
Humour, romance, family, and compassion balance out the crime part of dear Victoria's unforgettable mysteries.
This middle of the road tone is not violent like a 'thriller' but unsanitized (NOT light like a 'cozy mystery'), is unflinchingly adult, serious, and dark.
Humour, romance, family, and compassion balance out the crime part of dear Victoria's unforgettable mysteries.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 502 reviews
April 8, 2018
Another delightful episode in this excellent series! Notable this time for a sudden jump in the progress of Frank and Sarah's relationship. Even though neither of them is prepared to acknowledge this to the other yet, we know they are falling in love!
Little Brian did not get enough pages in this book - hopefully in the next one and please let him be able to walk. He has so many problems my heart goes out to him!
The murder mystery was well done and although I guessed who dunnit quite early on ( ) there was a trick at the end which I had not guessed. Sometimes I get quite agitated when the two main characters do not communicate all they know but these are the days before cell phones and the internet. The pace was slower then:)
This is a beautifully written series full of well researched historical detail. Love it and I am already looking forward to the next one.
Little Brian did not get enough pages in this book - hopefully in the next one and please let him be able to walk. He has so many problems my heart goes out to him!
The murder mystery was well done and although I guessed who dunnit quite early on ( ) there was a trick at the end which I had not guessed. Sometimes I get quite agitated when the two main characters do not communicate all they know but these are the days before cell phones and the internet. The pace was slower then:)
This is a beautifully written series full of well researched historical detail. Love it and I am already looking forward to the next one.
March 17, 2022
Another terrific book in the Gaslight Mystery series. Others have reviewed it better than I so I will just add this is a series I want to continue. There is character growth, and the side characters add a lot to the story. I am rating it 4.5* as I guessed the end (I don't always do well at that)
April 9, 2018
Sarah Brandt comes to the aid of her neighbor Mrs. Ellsworth’s son, Nelson. He’s become involved with a young woman but after meeting her, Sarah is skeptical of her innocence and motives. Things go haywire soon after their meeting.
The case was really interesting but the developing relationship between Sarah and Detective Sergeant Frank Malloy was what captured my attention. There was an easiness between them in the last book and now that’s gained some heat. It was engaging and the banter was better than ever. His behavior with son Brian is equally heartwarming.
The murder mystery had quite a few bends and turns but I clued in on the probable suspects early on, though that didn’t take away from my enjoyment as the why was important. The journey very much held my interest and the ending was a wonderful teaser. I’m also appreciative of the historical aspects, this time shining light on journalism in that era, which was eye opening. This continues to be one of my favorite series.
The case was really interesting but the developing relationship between Sarah and Detective Sergeant Frank Malloy was what captured my attention. There was an easiness between them in the last book and now that’s gained some heat. It was engaging and the banter was better than ever. His behavior with son Brian is equally heartwarming.
The murder mystery had quite a few bends and turns but I clued in on the probable suspects early on, though that didn’t take away from my enjoyment as the why was important. The journey very much held my interest and the ending was a wonderful teaser. I’m also appreciative of the historical aspects, this time shining light on journalism in that era, which was eye opening. This continues to be one of my favorite series.
January 19, 2019
I enjoy this series mainly for the way Sarah Brandt and Frank Malloy are becoming more important to each other. The mysteries themselves are pretty simple and yet the discovery of the perpetrator seems quite convoluted. Pretty good, but I agree with another reviewer that the Anne Perry books have more depth to them.
April 21, 2019
I've now read three titles in the Gaslight Mystery Cozy Mystery Series. Sarah Brandt is a likeable sleuth as she works as a midwife in New York City. Her ongoing romance with Frank Malloy is fun to see developing as both are reluctant suitors. I like reading about the historical time period. I'll try to return to the series in awhile. I don't want it to grow tiresome or repetitive for me. Now I'm off to read an Agatha Christie title.
February 10, 2017
The most predictable whodunnit of the series thus far, however the details were all a surprise. The author continues to astound me with her atmospheric and detailed accounts of turn of the century New York City. She even mentions in her author's note that she included an actual, factual historical character into this book after doing some research.
The character development continues to be very good and I really like where the two main characters' story is FINALLY headed! The conclusion is a cliffhanger, and I have to admit I'm very happy that I picked up the next 3 books in this series so I can see what happens next...and fast!
The character development continues to be very good and I really like where the two main characters' story is FINALLY headed! The conclusion is a cliffhanger, and I have to admit I'm very happy that I picked up the next 3 books in this series so I can see what happens next...and fast!
February 20, 2025
I instantly loved Victoria Thompson but did not give another volume 5 stars, until “Murder On Washington Square”, this fourth one. Set in 2002, representing 1893, she shows us New York born families amid established immigrants, when the corrupt police were petering out but the subway had not been built. This is one of few historical fiction series that I like! Sarah Brandt fits in with average people to whom readers of today relate. She has no servants and neither does she allow anyone to treat her with inferiority because she is female. She is among the game changers who are pushing the envelope of societal respect. Since I do not read general fiction, the mysteries add an adventurous canvas on which to reflect this historic crossroads.
Very similar to our dear Anne Perry’s heroine, Charlotte Pitt, whose maiden name is Ellsworth interestingly; Sarah’s job earns the respect of the poor and her family keeps her in influential centres. She helps Sergeant Frank Malloy, with whom romance shimmers closer to the surface in this story. It is another compliment that I dislike romantic fiction but love their story! Victoria rewards her fans with growth in her characters and premises. By now, we know this Mrs. Ellsworth well. She has grown from a nosy neighbour, to a good friend. Her son, Nelson, seeks Sarah’s help unravelling what I loosely call a dating scam.
This mystery investigates numerous people, with endearing help from Sarah’s Dad. The dénouement was complex. They seldom impress me. We pinpoint the crime headquarters but I doubt readers ascertained the network of details. Anyone can guess a killer was person A, B, or C. Twists and turns do not make books exciting for me. The winning combination is original adventures, portrayed believably, and characters with whom we empathize.
Very similar to our dear Anne Perry’s heroine, Charlotte Pitt, whose maiden name is Ellsworth interestingly; Sarah’s job earns the respect of the poor and her family keeps her in influential centres. She helps Sergeant Frank Malloy, with whom romance shimmers closer to the surface in this story. It is another compliment that I dislike romantic fiction but love their story! Victoria rewards her fans with growth in her characters and premises. By now, we know this Mrs. Ellsworth well. She has grown from a nosy neighbour, to a good friend. Her son, Nelson, seeks Sarah’s help unravelling what I loosely call a dating scam.
This mystery investigates numerous people, with endearing help from Sarah’s Dad. The dénouement was complex. They seldom impress me. We pinpoint the crime headquarters but I doubt readers ascertained the network of details. Anyone can guess a killer was person A, B, or C. Twists and turns do not make books exciting for me. The winning combination is original adventures, portrayed believably, and characters with whom we empathize.
January 10, 2018
Murder on Washington Square
By: Victoria Thompson
Series: Gaslight Mystery #4
Publisher/Year: Berkley Prime Crime, 2003
Setting: New York, (turn of the century)
Historical Fiction, Mystery, Suspense, Fiction
Adult themes and content
Plus(es): Multiple suspects kept me guessing to the end
Courageous heroine Sarah Brandt is gaining notoriety as being able to solve murders. Therefore, it was no surprise to readers when her dear friend/neighbor (Mrs. Ellsworth) lassoes her into helping clear her son’s (Nelson) name of murdering his girlfriend. Nelson describes the woman as being young and naive. Sarah is skeptical of his “lady friend’s” character and is determined to find out the truth.
Mrs. Brandt and Detective Malloy work feverishly with Nelson’s life and reputation in the balance. With multiple intriguing characters, effective pacing, and plot twists, this book has all the elements of a fantastic read!
*5 stars
By: Victoria Thompson
Series: Gaslight Mystery #4
Publisher/Year: Berkley Prime Crime, 2003
Setting: New York, (turn of the century)
Historical Fiction, Mystery, Suspense, Fiction
Adult themes and content
Plus(es): Multiple suspects kept me guessing to the end
Courageous heroine Sarah Brandt is gaining notoriety as being able to solve murders. Therefore, it was no surprise to readers when her dear friend/neighbor (Mrs. Ellsworth) lassoes her into helping clear her son’s (Nelson) name of murdering his girlfriend. Nelson describes the woman as being young and naive. Sarah is skeptical of his “lady friend’s” character and is determined to find out the truth.
Mrs. Brandt and Detective Malloy work feverishly with Nelson’s life and reputation in the balance. With multiple intriguing characters, effective pacing, and plot twists, this book has all the elements of a fantastic read!
*5 stars
January 13, 2019
After sometime I decided to return to Gaslight mystery series. I have read the first two of the series and few more at random. So I felt I would like to return to the series and read them in order (at least as much as I can find).
This is a good story by Victoria Thompson. Although the murder-mystery is pretty simple and easy to figure out, it was still interesting read. As always I enjoyed the historical touch to the story where it paints a colourful picture of early 20th century New York life. Perhaps this is the foremost reason of my liking the series.
The characters are always diverse and selected from a wide variety. I felt the main two characters of Sarah and Malloy are more developed and mature. And I enjoyed the budding chemistry between the two and the jealous feelings of Malloy against potential suitors of Sarah.
Except for a little repetitive writing I have no other complaints against the book.
This is a good story by Victoria Thompson. Although the murder-mystery is pretty simple and easy to figure out, it was still interesting read. As always I enjoyed the historical touch to the story where it paints a colourful picture of early 20th century New York life. Perhaps this is the foremost reason of my liking the series.
The characters are always diverse and selected from a wide variety. I felt the main two characters of Sarah and Malloy are more developed and mature. And I enjoyed the budding chemistry between the two and the jealous feelings of Malloy against potential suitors of Sarah.
Except for a little repetitive writing I have no other complaints against the book.
January 5, 2021
Oh, I just knew that the delightful Ms. Ellsworth’s son Nelson would have been implicated in something like this! He seemed so upright and naive!!! LOL
Another great mystery!
We gat to see how the relationship between Frank and Sarah is growing and I just know that something will come out of it! ;-)
Also the small moments with Frank and his son Brian are precious! :)
Another great mystery!
We gat to see how the relationship between Frank and Sarah is growing and I just know that something will come out of it! ;-)
Also the small moments with Frank and his son Brian are precious! :)
January 31, 2014
Ahhhh. Some progress on the Mrs. Brant and the Detective Malloy romantic front.
And I'm not sure how Malloy could solve these murders without mid-wife Brant's keen eye and ability to encourage people to open up with critical information.
This cozy mystery series is better than good with a strong storyline and it's relaxing to me by my not having to constantly think about every little tidbit of information.
Also, I do enjoy reading about NYC around 1895 when President Theodore Roosevelt was the police commissioner. Apparently police corruption was rampant during the time.
From Wiki: New York City Police Commissioner
Roosevelt became president of the board of New York City Police Commissioners in 1895. During his two years in this post, Roosevelt radically reformed the police department. The police force was reputed as one of the most corrupt in America. The NYPD's history division records that Roosevelt was "an iron-willed leader of unimpeachable honesty, (who) brought a reforming zeal to the New York City Police Commission in 1895."[40] Roosevelt and his fellow commissioners established new disciplinary rules, created a bicycle squad to enforce New York's traffic laws, and standardized the use of pistols by officers.[41] He selected the Colt New Police Revolver in .32 Colt Caliber as the first standard issue pistol for the NYPD. Roosevelt implemented regular inspections of firearms and annual physical exams, appointed 1,600 recruits based on their physical and mental qualifications and not on political affiliation, established Meritorious Service Medals, and closed corrupt police hostelries. During his tenure, a Municipal Lodging House was established by the Board of Charities, and Roosevelt required officers to register with the Board. He also had telephones installed in station houses.
What are hostelries and Municipal Lodging Houses though? On my list of things to look up.
It appears to me that Thompson did her research on the city before beginning the series which makes reading the books more authentic which I really like.
A fun mystery series and gives me a reprieve from some more heavier reads I've had my nose in recently.
And I'm not sure how Malloy could solve these murders without mid-wife Brant's keen eye and ability to encourage people to open up with critical information.
This cozy mystery series is better than good with a strong storyline and it's relaxing to me by my not having to constantly think about every little tidbit of information.
Also, I do enjoy reading about NYC around 1895 when President Theodore Roosevelt was the police commissioner. Apparently police corruption was rampant during the time.
From Wiki: New York City Police Commissioner
Roosevelt became president of the board of New York City Police Commissioners in 1895. During his two years in this post, Roosevelt radically reformed the police department. The police force was reputed as one of the most corrupt in America. The NYPD's history division records that Roosevelt was "an iron-willed leader of unimpeachable honesty, (who) brought a reforming zeal to the New York City Police Commission in 1895."[40] Roosevelt and his fellow commissioners established new disciplinary rules, created a bicycle squad to enforce New York's traffic laws, and standardized the use of pistols by officers.[41] He selected the Colt New Police Revolver in .32 Colt Caliber as the first standard issue pistol for the NYPD. Roosevelt implemented regular inspections of firearms and annual physical exams, appointed 1,600 recruits based on their physical and mental qualifications and not on political affiliation, established Meritorious Service Medals, and closed corrupt police hostelries. During his tenure, a Municipal Lodging House was established by the Board of Charities, and Roosevelt required officers to register with the Board. He also had telephones installed in station houses.
What are hostelries and Municipal Lodging Houses though? On my list of things to look up.
It appears to me that Thompson did her research on the city before beginning the series which makes reading the books more authentic which I really like.
A fun mystery series and gives me a reprieve from some more heavier reads I've had my nose in recently.
December 31, 2019
Anothe instalment of the Gaslight mystery series I enjoyed reading!
This time the murder hits close to home so Sarah and Malloy have an extra good reason to want this case solved!
The plot of the crime was very interesting and I enjoyed the who dunnit part! Had three suspects in mind and I was greatly surprised when the case was solved and the killer revealed!
Once again the banters between Sarah Brandt and Frank Malloy were great and can I say just...
He cooked for her and I love him even more!!!!
He kissed her!!!!
As for the addition of Frank's rival for the heart of Sarah I would appreciate it more if he wasn't such a dull character and also very unsympathetic at least for my taste!
And now let's see what the next story will bring for my favorite characters!
This time the murder hits close to home so Sarah and Malloy have an extra good reason to want this case solved!
The plot of the crime was very interesting and I enjoyed the who dunnit part! Had three suspects in mind and I was greatly surprised when the case was solved and the killer revealed!
Once again the banters between Sarah Brandt and Frank Malloy were great and can I say just...
He cooked for her and I love him even more!!!!
He kissed her!!!!
As for the addition of Frank's rival for the heart of Sarah I would appreciate it more if he wasn't such a dull character and also very unsympathetic at least for my taste!
And now let's see what the next story will bring for my favorite characters!
March 30, 2018
When midwife Sarah Brandt gets a note form Nelson Ellsworth, her neighbor’s son, she is intrigued. She agrees to their meeting only to learn that Nelson has gotten a woman pregnant, a woman who doesn’t seem to want to marry him. Nelson asks Sarah to examine the woman, but something about their encounter seems off. Sarah doesn’t give it much thought until the woman is murdered and Nelson is arrested for the crime. With the help of NYC detective Frank Malloy, she begins to investigate. What is happening?
I hadn’t realized how much I’ve come to enjoy this series until I picked up the book. I was immediately lost in the world of 1890’s New York City, and Sarah and Frank are outstanding guides. They lead a cast of strong characters, and I love watching them interact and their slow burn romance. I did figure some things out early, but I was still glued to the page as there were twists and complications I didn’t see coming.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
I hadn’t realized how much I’ve come to enjoy this series until I picked up the book. I was immediately lost in the world of 1890’s New York City, and Sarah and Frank are outstanding guides. They lead a cast of strong characters, and I love watching them interact and their slow burn romance. I did figure some things out early, but I was still glued to the page as there were twists and complications I didn’t see coming.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
February 16, 2020
Okay...so I said I would step away and give the gaslight mysteries a rest....but Sarah and Frank are so darned cute, I just had to steal back for more. This time Sarah's neighbour is accused of murder and the unlikely pair of police detective and amateur sleuth midwife leave no stone unturned in their efforts to clear his name, discovering nefarious plots and tripping over a few more dead bodies before book ends.. delicious!
November 28, 2019
Not only do I love the characters, the mystery, and the budding romance between protagonists, I'm really enjoying how the author captures the essence of New York City at the turn of the last century. We get to see the political genre that defined, and still defines, New York City; the contrast of high society to abject poverty, the corruption of the police force, the injustices to immigrants, and even the stench in the city (garbage, horses). New York emerges as its own special character and steals the show. On the surface this is just another cozy mystery, but when you peel back the layers, it is so much more.
I love, love, love this series. I'm off to read #5.
I love, love, love this series. I'm off to read #5.
October 1, 2017
Turn-of-the-century New York City midwife Sarah Brandt and Detective Sergeant Frank Molloy are thrust into a twisted case of murder—when a seductress falls victim to her own charades.
Murder on Washington Square was another enjoyable installment in the Gaslight series. One thing I have noticed is that the mysteries in these books are pretty easy to figure out. I do wish Sarah and Malloy weren't so slow sometimes. Maybe I feel this way because I'm comparing it to Anne Perry's books. I really think her books are a step above most mysteries in their cleverness.
The most enjoyable aspects of this series are the developing relationship between Sarah and Malloy, and Malloy's ongoing investigation into the death of Sarah's husband. I like that there is that one ongoing thread that keeps me coming back for more while also trying to figure out the single mystery to solve in each book. And Frank's grumpiness with Sarah involving herself in his cases always makes me smile.
I enjoy this series a lot so I will keep reading.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
Murder on Washington Square was another enjoyable installment in the Gaslight series. One thing I have noticed is that the mysteries in these books are pretty easy to figure out. I do wish Sarah and Malloy weren't so slow sometimes. Maybe I feel this way because I'm comparing it to Anne Perry's books. I really think her books are a step above most mysteries in their cleverness.
The most enjoyable aspects of this series are the developing relationship between Sarah and Malloy, and Malloy's ongoing investigation into the death of Sarah's husband. I like that there is that one ongoing thread that keeps me coming back for more while also trying to figure out the single mystery to solve in each book. And Frank's grumpiness with Sarah involving herself in his cases always makes me smile.
I enjoy this series a lot so I will keep reading.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
February 19, 2022
Murder mysteries with a slow-burn relationship on the side are my jam.
The mystery in this installment of the Gaslight Mysteries series was really interesting. Sarah reluctantly agrees consult when her next door neighbor gets a girl pregnant (or does he?). This launched her into a home that seems to be a con artist’s boarding house. People start dying, Frank gets involved, sleuthing ensues.
I enjoyed the action in this one and the introduction of three characters, Nelson (Mrs. Ellsworth’s son), Dennis (a love interest), and a reporter (he seems like he could be reoccurring).
Sarah and Frank’s relationship continues to evolve. There are a two big moments, but Sarah may or may not remember one of them. I loved being left to wonder.
The mystery in this installment of the Gaslight Mysteries series was really interesting. Sarah reluctantly agrees consult when her next door neighbor gets a girl pregnant (or does he?). This launched her into a home that seems to be a con artist’s boarding house. People start dying, Frank gets involved, sleuthing ensues.
I enjoyed the action in this one and the introduction of three characters, Nelson (Mrs. Ellsworth’s son), Dennis (a love interest), and a reporter (he seems like he could be reoccurring).
Sarah and Frank’s relationship continues to evolve. There are a two big moments, but Sarah may or may not remember one of them. I loved being left to wonder.
May 9, 2025
╰┈➤ 5★!!
I’m fully aware I said I would be taking a break from this series but ohmy I couldn’t do it 😅. The intricate romance blossoming between Sarah and Frank is the sweetest thing to listen to and I just love getting myself immersed in 1896 New York.
── .✦
In this novel we learn that Mrs. Ellsworth’s son, Nelson has been involved with a young lady who fears she might be pregnant. Discreetly, so as to not upset his mother, Nelson reaches out to Sarah, a midwife and a trained nurse, to help them learn the truth of Anna’s condition. Sarah, forever the icon she is, doesn’t question this request, and meets up with Nelson to check on Anna Blake. Even though their encounter was indeed odd, and Sarah becomes skeptical of Anna’s motives, no one was prepared when she’s found dead the next morning. Nelson instantly becomes a murder suspect and while Sarah thinks it’s absurd that Nelson could have murdered his mistress, the police find it entirely plausible – especially if the woman was indeed carrying Nelson’s child.
── .✦
This case was truly fascinating and I just loved every twist and turn it took. Even though, as I’ve said before, these aren’t really the most complex cases and most often than not I do end up solving them pretty quickly; I truly love how Victoria Thompsson always manages to completely shock me with a plot-twist regarding the case in the end. Something I would never have thought of or guessed myself.
── .✦
On top of that I find the murder-cases themselves still to be a secondary-character and I’m always more present for Sarah’s and Frank’s blossoming relationship & learning more about Brian and how he’s doing – he truly has my heart and I would do everything for him 🥺.
I’m fully aware I said I would be taking a break from this series but ohmy I couldn’t do it 😅. The intricate romance blossoming between Sarah and Frank is the sweetest thing to listen to and I just love getting myself immersed in 1896 New York.
── .✦
In this novel we learn that Mrs. Ellsworth’s son, Nelson has been involved with a young lady who fears she might be pregnant. Discreetly, so as to not upset his mother, Nelson reaches out to Sarah, a midwife and a trained nurse, to help them learn the truth of Anna’s condition. Sarah, forever the icon she is, doesn’t question this request, and meets up with Nelson to check on Anna Blake. Even though their encounter was indeed odd, and Sarah becomes skeptical of Anna’s motives, no one was prepared when she’s found dead the next morning. Nelson instantly becomes a murder suspect and while Sarah thinks it’s absurd that Nelson could have murdered his mistress, the police find it entirely plausible – especially if the woman was indeed carrying Nelson’s child.
── .✦
This case was truly fascinating and I just loved every twist and turn it took. Even though, as I’ve said before, these aren’t really the most complex cases and most often than not I do end up solving them pretty quickly; I truly love how Victoria Thompsson always manages to completely shock me with a plot-twist regarding the case in the end. Something I would never have thought of or guessed myself.
── .✦
On top of that I find the murder-cases themselves still to be a secondary-character and I’m always more present for Sarah’s and Frank’s blossoming relationship & learning more about Brian and how he’s doing – he truly has my heart and I would do everything for him 🥺.
October 4, 2015
This time around Sarah Brandt needed to help her neighbor, Mrs. Ellsworth, when her son got himself innocently involved with a devious woman and blackmail.
And we finally start to see some odd development with the Irish-Catholic widower and father, Detective Sergeant Francis Malloy and Mrs. Brandt, a widow and midwife. Malloy, with his crusty attitude, and Sarah with, most of the times, the patience of a saint, searched for some clues to resolve Nelson Ellsworth's innocence. The camaraderie, chemistry and comebacks add charm to this wonderful historical story of suspense.
And we finally start to see some odd development with the Irish-Catholic widower and father, Detective Sergeant Francis Malloy and Mrs. Brandt, a widow and midwife. Malloy, with his crusty attitude, and Sarah with, most of the times, the patience of a saint, searched for some clues to resolve Nelson Ellsworth's innocence. The camaraderie, chemistry and comebacks add charm to this wonderful historical story of suspense.
August 31, 2016
Murder in Washington Square
4 Stars
When Nelson Ellsworth, the mild-mannered son of her nosy next-door neighbor, is accused of murder, Sarah Brandt enlists the aid of Detective Frank Malloy to help her clear Nelson's name and find the real killer.
As in the previous installments, the mystery is simple and easy to figure out. Nevertheless, the historical background, and growing attraction between Sarah and Frank make this a fun read.
Thompson's research and attention to detail is excellent. The history of the Hanging Tree in Washington Square is very interesting as is the story of Maria Barbella, and the portrayal of yellow journalism at the turn of the century is realistic and believable.
Sarah and Frank's relationship is progressing slowly, but surely as they both come to realize that there is more between them than friendship (although neither is willing to admit it to themselves let alone each other).
All in all, another engaging addition to Thompson's historical cozy mystery series and it looks like the investigation into the death of Sarah's husband is about to heat up.
4 Stars
When Nelson Ellsworth, the mild-mannered son of her nosy next-door neighbor, is accused of murder, Sarah Brandt enlists the aid of Detective Frank Malloy to help her clear Nelson's name and find the real killer.
As in the previous installments, the mystery is simple and easy to figure out. Nevertheless, the historical background, and growing attraction between Sarah and Frank make this a fun read.
Thompson's research and attention to detail is excellent. The history of the Hanging Tree in Washington Square is very interesting as is the story of Maria Barbella, and the portrayal of yellow journalism at the turn of the century is realistic and believable.
Sarah and Frank's relationship is progressing slowly, but surely as they both come to realize that there is more between them than friendship (although neither is willing to admit it to themselves let alone each other).
All in all, another engaging addition to Thompson's historical cozy mystery series and it looks like the investigation into the death of Sarah's husband is about to heat up.
May 18, 2020
A strange case this time, with Sarah’s neighbour Nelson Ellsworth (son of kind, superstitious and frying pan wielding Mrs. Ellsworth) being accused of murdering a young woman with whom he was secretly involved.
Sarah’s dragged into the situation by Nelson himself, and Malloy grabs the case from a fellow policeman to make sure the investigation actually happens.
The case is convoluted with little making sense about the young woman.
I liked this instalment, and like a GR friend find this series addictive, as Sarah and Malloy employ their respective talents to find the killer. And become closer and more important to each other. And enjoy secondary character become more fleshed out and prominent in the lives of the two main characters.
On to book 5.
Sarah’s dragged into the situation by Nelson himself, and Malloy grabs the case from a fellow policeman to make sure the investigation actually happens.
The case is convoluted with little making sense about the young woman.
I liked this instalment, and like a GR friend find this series addictive, as Sarah and Malloy employ their respective talents to find the killer. And become closer and more important to each other. And enjoy secondary character become more fleshed out and prominent in the lives of the two main characters.
On to book 5.
April 22, 2018
Sarah Brandt's neighbor, Nelson Ellsworth, has been accused of murder. Anna Blake was a con artist who seduced Nelson and convinced him that she was pregnant. Now her body has been found under the hanging tree in Washington Square Park. Sarah knows Nelson couldn't have killed Anna. She asks Detective Frank Malloy to help clear her neighbor's name.
Another excellent mystery in the Gaslight Mystery series. Each book in this series is better than the last. Along with the interesting setting, I love the relationship that is developing between Sarah and Frank. My rating: 4.5 Stars.
Another excellent mystery in the Gaslight Mystery series. Each book in this series is better than the last. Along with the interesting setting, I love the relationship that is developing between Sarah and Frank. My rating: 4.5 Stars.
November 6, 2014
The mysteries in this series are always interesting though they are not usually difficult to figure out by at least the half-way mark. That's okay though because it's fun to follow Sarah and Frank through the process of solving the case and there are still usually one or two surprises thrown in. I can't help but think how much faster they could solve the case if they just had cell phones, lol. At this point however, I am definitely reading this series as much for Sarah and Frank's evolving relationship as to see what happens with Brian, and Sarah's cold case. Plus, Mrs. Ellingsworth is always good for a chuckle. I also liked learning about Maria Barberi (Barbella) - and yes, I googled her. Those extra little nods to the time period are like historical easter eggs.
July 28, 2018
Another very good mystery, taking place in New York in the late 1800's. Love the setting and the characters. One of the things I like reading about is the way of life in that era and the different ways people where treated from the beggars all the way to up the line to the ultra rich. How little was know of medicine and the treatment of the sick and injured leaves on with the sense of the hopelessness the people had and their distrust of doctors.
In this story women are blackmailing men after claiming they have been gotten pregnant by them. The women are supposedly helpless and have no jobs but come from good family's but when one is murdered and found not to be with child Sarah and Malloy set out to find out the truth behind the whole scheme. It seems that Molloy is starting to have serious feelings for Sarah and she seems to also. Will be interesting to see how this works out going forward.
In this story women are blackmailing men after claiming they have been gotten pregnant by them. The women are supposedly helpless and have no jobs but come from good family's but when one is murdered and found not to be with child Sarah and Malloy set out to find out the truth behind the whole scheme. It seems that Molloy is starting to have serious feelings for Sarah and she seems to also. Will be interesting to see how this works out going forward.
October 6, 2020
As many other reviewers mentioned, the budding relationship between Frank and Sarah is what keeps this series so captivating, especially set against the backdrop of New York City in the Gilded Age.
Sarah is ask by her neighbor, Nelson Ellsworth, to examine his girlfriend, when she claims to be pregnant. The woman doesn't seem to want anything to do with Sarah, though. When the young lady ends up murdered and Nelson is the prime suspect, Frank and Sarah have to figure out what's going on.
I read this in July, and I'll be honest, I don't remember much of details. I read the first ten books in this series so fast that it's all a blur in my mind. I'm determined to keep up on my reviews so I don't have this problem again!
Sarah is ask by her neighbor, Nelson Ellsworth, to examine his girlfriend, when she claims to be pregnant. The woman doesn't seem to want anything to do with Sarah, though. When the young lady ends up murdered and Nelson is the prime suspect, Frank and Sarah have to figure out what's going on.
I read this in July, and I'll be honest, I don't remember much of details. I read the first ten books in this series so fast that it's all a blur in my mind. I'm determined to keep up on my reviews so I don't have this problem again!
April 18, 2020
Not sure how I managed this, but I started book 4 instead of 3! Not to worry however :0)
The mysteries are kind of straightforward. Well, there are clues that you can put together faster than the characters. Having said this, it doesn’t detract from the reading enjoyment. A big part of this is from witnessing our main protagonists, but also all the secondary cast. I love it how the author turns some of these around into people with more depths than previously expected (the nosy neighbour is turning out to be a force of nature!).
And now, let’s go for book 3 before 5 LOL
The mysteries are kind of straightforward. Well, there are clues that you can put together faster than the characters. Having said this, it doesn’t detract from the reading enjoyment. A big part of this is from witnessing our main protagonists, but also all the secondary cast. I love it how the author turns some of these around into people with more depths than previously expected (the nosy neighbour is turning out to be a force of nature!).
And now, let’s go for book 3 before 5 LOL
May 28, 2018
I don't know where to begin with this. The characters seem to finally be breaking into themselves, no longer just one dimensional. The plot is thickening, and I'm very eager to see where we go from here.
Thompson just keeps getting better and better as the books go on. I didn't see any of this coming. I have to be up for work in four and a half hours, but I'm starting book five tonight.
A more detailed review to come after my morning coffee...
Thompson just keeps getting better and better as the books go on. I didn't see any of this coming. I have to be up for work in four and a half hours, but I'm starting book five tonight.
A more detailed review to come after my morning coffee...
July 13, 2022
4 stars - English Ebook
When midwife Sarah Brandt gets a note form Nelson Ellsworth, her neighbor’s son, she is intrigued. She agrees to their meeting only to learn that Nelson has gotten a woman pregnant, a woman who doesn’t seem to want to marry him.
Nelson asks Sarah to examine the woman, but something about their encounter seems off. Sarah doesn’t give it much thought until the woman is murdered and Nelson is arrested for the crime. With the help of NYC detective Frank Malloy, she begins to investigate. What is happening?
I hadn’t realized how much I’ve come to enjoy this series until I picked up the book.
I was immediately lost in the world of 1890’s New York City, and Sarah and Frank are outstanding guides. They lead a cast of strong characters, and I love watching them interact and their slow burn romance.
I did figure some things out early, but I was still glued to the page as there were twists and complications I didn’t see coming.
When midwife Sarah Brandt gets a note form Nelson Ellsworth, her neighbor’s son, she is intrigued. She agrees to their meeting only to learn that Nelson has gotten a woman pregnant, a woman who doesn’t seem to want to marry him.
Nelson asks Sarah to examine the woman, but something about their encounter seems off. Sarah doesn’t give it much thought until the woman is murdered and Nelson is arrested for the crime. With the help of NYC detective Frank Malloy, she begins to investigate. What is happening?
I hadn’t realized how much I’ve come to enjoy this series until I picked up the book.
I was immediately lost in the world of 1890’s New York City, and Sarah and Frank are outstanding guides. They lead a cast of strong characters, and I love watching them interact and their slow burn romance.
I did figure some things out early, but I was still glued to the page as there were twists and complications I didn’t see coming.
January 8, 2021
In Murder on Washington Square, Sarah Brandt's next door neighbour, Nelson Ellsworth, asks for her help with a woman he's been seeing. Sarah quickly deduces that something is amiss in this relationship. When a murder occurs, she and Detective Frank Malloy have another puzzle to decipher.
I quite enjoy this light mystery series which brings New York in another era to life. My suspicions on who the murderer was were correct, but that didn't detract from my reading pleasure. 3.5 bumped up to 4 because it was great to spend time with Sarah and Malloy again.
I quite enjoy this light mystery series which brings New York in another era to life. My suspicions on who the murderer was were correct, but that didn't detract from my reading pleasure. 3.5 bumped up to 4 because it was great to spend time with Sarah and Malloy again.
March 12, 2017
Murder on Washington Square is the 4th book in the Gaslight mystery series by Victoria Thompson. The series stars New York midwife, Sarah Brandt who finds herself involved in various mysteries over the course of her travels and who partners with, albeit not always voluntarily, with Police Detective, Frank Malloy.
In this 4th book, the son of Sarah's neighbour, Mrs. Ellsworth, is arrested for the murder of a young woman. It seems she has been blackmailing him, after he got her pregnant, and her dead body is discovered in Washington Square. Prior to this event, Mr. Ellsworth has asked for Sarah's help in determining if the woman is in fact pregnant only to have their efforts rebuffed. The woman is found shortly thereafter, hence the suspicion that Mr. Ellsworth is guilty.
Sarah asks her friend Malloy to help in the investigation as she can't believe the young man is capable of murder. This starts an interesting chain of events as the investigation progresses. Malloy's relationship with Sarah becomes somewhat more friendly, Sarah's relationship with her parents is improved; the press hounds Mrs. Ellsworth and her son, and many interesting clues and facts are unearthed, including another attempted murder.
The story moves along very nicely and the characters as always are very enjoyable. The mystery, while not necessarily too complex, keeps you thinking and the whole story and setting, early 1900 NY City, adds to the interest. As well, there are clues dropped for future stories, that will make you want to continue reading. I've found that the stories and character development have improved a bit with each story. I'm looking forward to starting #5. (4 stars)
In this 4th book, the son of Sarah's neighbour, Mrs. Ellsworth, is arrested for the murder of a young woman. It seems she has been blackmailing him, after he got her pregnant, and her dead body is discovered in Washington Square. Prior to this event, Mr. Ellsworth has asked for Sarah's help in determining if the woman is in fact pregnant only to have their efforts rebuffed. The woman is found shortly thereafter, hence the suspicion that Mr. Ellsworth is guilty.
Sarah asks her friend Malloy to help in the investigation as she can't believe the young man is capable of murder. This starts an interesting chain of events as the investigation progresses. Malloy's relationship with Sarah becomes somewhat more friendly, Sarah's relationship with her parents is improved; the press hounds Mrs. Ellsworth and her son, and many interesting clues and facts are unearthed, including another attempted murder.
The story moves along very nicely and the characters as always are very enjoyable. The mystery, while not necessarily too complex, keeps you thinking and the whole story and setting, early 1900 NY City, adds to the interest. As well, there are clues dropped for future stories, that will make you want to continue reading. I've found that the stories and character development have improved a bit with each story. I'm looking forward to starting #5. (4 stars)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 502 reviews