After reading a few encomiums to John M. Ford -- all of which note that his literary estate has only recently become untangled, so get ready to clear out some shelf space for the new editions -- I picked this up at the library.
It's a short book, only ~200 pages, and except for that -- and also it taking place in a Chicago that's 1930s gangster elf-themed -- I kept thinking about Henry James. As a friend once put it in grad school, the experience of reading James is often going "oh no, I don't want to miss this moment when this tension climaxes; oh no, I missed the moment; oh wait, what was that moment?"
Or put another way, this is a book long on innuendo and short on explanation. We meet the 19-year old protag as he runs away to the big city of Chicago, a bordertown between the human world and elfland, through a human landscape that seems on the verge of collapse: the gas station he comes to is crumbling, large parts out of service, and coffee is a scarce commodity. This all gets quasi-explained maybe a hundred pages later, when we learn that, when elves returned, many of them ran amok destroying parts of human culture that they couldn't abide. Which includes TV, which is maybe why the dominant art form is old movies, so even though this book takes place in, I don't know, the 1990s?, everyone dresses and acts like they're in a 1930's gangster movie.
This isn't exactly a case where the style is the genre, though Ford is playing with two genres -- the elf-punk bordertown; the gangster fantasy -- where style is prominent, if not preeminent. (Bordertown is kind of a sleazy, gritty place, where misfits might fit in in a place halfway between two worlds; gangster fantasy is wizards with hats fighting for bootleggers who say, "look, see." Both of those styles are present here.) That is, Ford seems less interested in the accoutrements and more interested in our protag's journey of self-discovery, which...
I'm not sure whether to call what I'm going to say at the end here a spoiler or a guess, because the way people talk to each other in this book is mostly someone saying something oblique and the respondent starting a sentence that they never finish. That's, I guess, part of the fun with a gangster story, where you never quite know where people stand and who might double cross who and for what. But in a speculative fiction story, there's so many unknowns that things that don't get said might simply end up never being known.
Take, for instance, the villain, a bad elf named Whisper Who Dares, who is behind some torture and murder, I guess; a bad dude who is gaining magical power, I think, for some ends which I don't think are ever said; and in the final confrontation the protag walks in to a hostage negotiation and gets a hostage out without really any sense of negotiating, intimidating the big scary guy with something even more terrifying, kinda? It's moments like that -- a big unexplained action climax with no action -- where I felt the lack of the explanation. (As one reviewer put it, the big villain plot is kind of a subplot because it doesn't seem all that important because it's never quite explained.)
It's funny that, in a way, this novel that refuses to talk about what it's about also includes several characters who don't talk about what they talk about, like the columnist whose column is both gossipy and oblique; or, most notably, the human woman who goes by Fay now that she's been cursed by an elf with aphasia, the inability to talk, which grants her also the power of the Voice, that instills emotions in others through, essentially, scat-singing.
That's the sort of thing that makes me think Ford is willfully playing with the power of the unsaid. It works, in a way, especially since this story is from the POV of the new guy in town, the aw-shucks small-town EMT who here is made into the pivotal Doc of the gangster crew without ever really knowing what's going on, and definitely without speaking about it. But at the end of the day, his journey of self-discovery feels both unsaid (because it's literally never articulated) and not worth saying (to me), since his big revelation seems to be that he's into bondage. Maybe this is the sort of thing that time has robbed of its power -- maybe in 2001 this could have been treated like a real revelation and like a character who is concerned with power coming to terms that he can take power without _abusing_ that power.
I mean, I guess I'm glad for the dude that he learned what his kink is, but did it have to take 200 pages of people never finishing their sentences?