The book ends with four long interviews with people identifying as UX strategists. It’s easily the best part of the book, a plaster cast of the field anno 2015.
Unfortunately, there is no escape of the terminological debate on UX design, interaction design, product design, business strategy; not even in this my review. What I see in this book is downplaying “design”, which I’d say is inherently strategic and doesn’t need the label “strategic” slapped on it. In this relatively new field (quicksand) of experience-something we surely try to establish an identity and a personal brand, and we have a whole variety of backgrounds, perspectives and job descriptions to it. This is what this terminological debate often boils down to.
The book left me thinking that UX strategy as described by Levy is synonymous to well-executed product strategy or any kind of “design” including "UX design.” I say well-executed for a reason. You might want to introduce “UX strategy” when you see that your product and business strategies failed to be user-centric, while your user-centric design failed to be strategic.
Geoff Katz, one of the practitioners interviewed for the book, said: "UX strategy is really an essential component of product definition.” — Boom. Put this quote on the book cover, please.
In the words of Jaime Levy: "UX design and UX strategy are two different things. When you are doing design, you are creating something. When you are doing strategy, you are coming up with a game plan before creating something. One way to explain it is to just substitute the word 'product' for 'user experience.’” — Firstly, “UX design” here reads like "interaction design” (and interaction designers would argue that they are much more strategic than that). Secondly, you might as well leave this “product” there instead of “user experience”, and it will fit just fine.
According to Peter Merholz, one of the four interviewees, "There is such a thing as UX strategy because product strategy and business strategy have failed in the prior decades to account for the user needs and awareness. To make sure that the user and the user experience was appropriately beneficial, we had to develop this thing called UX strategy. In an ideal world you wouldn’t need UX strategy, because it would just be a component of your product or business strategy."
I'd agree with this, making one terminological correction: we shouldn’t be talking about “UX strategy" because "UX design", or "experience design”, is inherently strategic — if the job is done well.
This book, as a product, is made quite well. It is clearly structured and illustrated with detailed examples; there are some good stories there. The books describes a fairly typical good UX design process, and it does it well.
I hear reviewers say, the examples are all too detailed sometimes. Indeed, the person interested in the subject of UX strategy does not necessarily want to read a few pages on how to choose a coffee shop suitable for conducting interviews. On the other hand, as there is no standard career path for people who identify as UX designers or strategists, you never know where they are lacking knowledge and experience.