Stolen Midnights

by Katherine Quinn

This magical new YA romantasy from the New York Times bestselling author of To Kill a Shadow will steal your heart. Set in Andalay, a world where the ruling Fates bestow gifts among the favored, a thief must join forces with the palace darling after he unwittingly steals a necklace with the power to change everything.

When Damien, a cold and hardened thief, is hired to steal a gift from the powerful Fates meant for Andalay’s sweetheart, Wren Hayes, he finds himself entangled in a web of secrets.

The gift? A locket containing his own phototroph.

Once the locket is opened, hidden truths unravel, ones that shed light on the ruthless ways of the upper-class society. Yearning for the three Fates and the magical gifts they bestow, the lords of Andalay will go to any length to keep their power—including murder.

Brought together by destiny, and fighting a temptation that neither understand, Wren and Damien navigate a seedy world where the truth can destroy not only their lives, but the city itself.

Genres: Fantasy, Young Adult, Romantasy, Romance, Fantasy Romance, Young Adult Fantasy

464 pages, Hardcover

Expected publication February 3, 2026

About the author

Katherine Quinn is a fantasy romance author and poet. She graduated from the University of Central Florida with a degree in psychology. She resides in Houston, Texas with her husband and children.

Her love for writing began after she read her first fantasy series, Song of the Lioness, by Tamora Pierce. After that, she wanted nothing more than to be a dagger-wielding heroine. Unfortunately, it’s frowned upon to give a child a dagger, so she settled on writing about daring adventures instead.

Coffee is her true love, and she believes anything can be fixed with Starbucks and dark humor.

Reviews

[⋆˚୨ৎ˚⋆ Kim ⋆˚୨ৎ˚⋆]

⋆˙⟡ 𝒫𝓇𝑒-𝓇𝑒𝒶𝒹 (11/6/2025): To my US/Canada NetGalley users: this is currently READ NOW! I'm not sure how long it's going to be Read Now for, so I'll update this again once it's taken off. (Update (11/10/2025): it is no longer Read Now!)

(Also, can we take a moment to appreciate how pretty the edges and the cover art are? This was definitely a moment of "I requested this because of the pretty cover art"😂)

Thank you to NetGalley, Katherine Quinn, and Delacorte Press for this eARC in exchange for an honest review. Stolen Midnights will be officially published on February 3rd, 2026!

[˚୨୧⋆｡˚ ⋆ Val ˚୨୧⋆｡˚ ⋆ · Rating 3 out of 5]

ˏˋ°•*⁀➷ Review ˏˋ°•*⁀➷

Soooo fates and magic and enemies to lovers ? You had me at the word fates. Is it just me who LOVES fate/god romantasies ? They’re always so interesting with really intricate magic systems. In this book, the 4 fates choose people to receive magical gifts that give them abilities, but here’s the catch. The gifts, which are always delivered at midnight on the recipient's 18th birthday, can be stolen. Anddd that's what happens to Wren Hayes. No one in her family has ever not gotten a gift. Until her. She’s the daughter of a rich noble ruling the city, and he’s a thief and an assassin.

Okay but the BANTER in this book ? Omigosh Wren and Damien are SO CUTE, and I always have a soft spot for a GrumpyXsunshine trope (quite literally, he calls her sunshine).


⋆.ೃ࿔*:･ Damien ⋆.ೃ࿔*:･

He’s such a misunderstood character 😔. He’s honestly a really good person, just forced into terrible circumstances 😭. MY MAN DID NOT DESERVE THAT KATHERINE APOLOGISE RIGHT THIS MINUTE. But it is SO FUNNY to see him deny his feelings for Wren when he’s about as subtle as a neon glowing sign 😭. It’s even funnier when he keeps telling himself he’ll get over it because WE ALL KNOW THAT'S NOT HAPPENING.

˚₊· ͟͟͞͞➳❥ “I wish you knew the real m-me,’ he said, his nose grazing mine. ‘But then I…I would dull your shine.” ˚₊· ͟͟͞͞➳❥

SOOOO MY HEART JUST CRACKED CLEAN IN HALF. WAS THIS REALLY NECESSARY KATHERINE ? REALLY ?

ੈ✩‧₊˚ “Damien. Yes sunshine ? Shut up, please.” ੈ✩‧₊˚

HAHAHAHA THEY’RE SO ICONIC. THEIR CHEMISTRY IS OFF THE CHARTS TOO, WHY DON’T I HAVE THIS MUCH CHEMISTRY WITH SOMEONE ? Life is so unfair I do not like real life 😔. I’m so single it’s not even funny 😭

˚୨୧⋆｡˚ ⋆ Wren ˚୨୧⋆｡˚ ⋆

She’s such a sweetheart 🥹 her shitbag of a father DOESN’T deserve her. I can totally understand why Damien thought she was a stuck up, selfish noble, but she’s just been manipulated by her father her whole life. And her mother is so completely USELESS IT PISSES ME OFF SO BAD. PULL YOUR HEAD OUT OF YOUR ASS AND SEE THAT YOUR HUSBAND IS AN EVIL PIECE OF SHIT. WHY IS HER ENTIRE FAMILY HORRIBLE ? I swear, can we get ONE book where the character’s families aren’t dead, dying or evil ? IS IT REALLY THAT NECESSARY FOR CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT ???? So, I thought I’d predicted the ending, I could tell where it was going BUT NO. THE PLOT TWIST ??? THE CLIFF HANGER??? KATHERINE QUINN YOU OWE ME FOR THIS. I’M NOT GOING TO SAY ANYTHING BECAUSE SPOILERS OBVIOUSLY, BUT LETS JUST SAY I WILL BE THROWING HANDS

ੈ✩‧₊˚ Preread ~ Thank you to netgalley and random house children's books for giving me an e-arc for an honest review ! Fates, magic and romance ? Okay you can stop talking now. I'll take it. Also, this cover is actually gorgeous wtf.

[Kara DeLorey · Rating 4 out of 5]

Stolen Midnights really impressed me with its sharp social commentary on wealth, privilege, and the ways society exploits the vulnerable in order to keep the rich in power. . Wren, the snarky and strong FMC, delivers one of the most powerful lines in the book:

“I’m sorry because I allowed myself to be blind when I had the choice to do otherwise. I’m sorry for being a part of a society that uses people when they’re desperate. That forces them to remain desperate. Afraid. Hungry.”

Damien, the MMC, is chaotic and complicated in all the right ways, bringing a messy charm that balances Wren’s strength and makes their dynamic one to smile at. I loved the world building and character development throughout the story as well.

Thank you NetGalley and Delacorte Press for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

[Emily Anne · Rating 3 out of 5]

I'm a little torn about how to review this one, so I'll tell you how it made me feel as I went along. At the very beginning, the concept of her having her gift stolen was a little hard for me to read because it was so awful and sad. So, I read a tiny bit at a time trying to decide if I was going to finish. But once I got to the 40% or so mark suddenly, I got sucked in. I was riveted and started turning pages a lot faster. It's like I had to get over that hump of society doing things that made me sad. Therefore, the portion of me that recommends this book does so because it's very compelling. You start to want to know what happens to these good-chemistry characters. There is a fine balance between having spice and YA. I think this is slightly too much spice for YA but not enough to be new adult. It's in the middle. Unfortunately, without details, as I got to the 90% or so portion of the book, I began to get the sense that not enough was being resolved. Sure enough, cliffhanger city. Don't get me wrong, there is a delicate balance in series books. The author can't tie everything in a bow because there's going to be a book 2. But the readers want a significant portion tied up. Enough ties to feel satisfying. Did this meet the satisfying ending mark? There were twists which were satisfying, but ultimately, I personally come down on cliffhanger side rather than the satisfied side. I noticed one other review calling the ending "brutal" in terms of cliffhanger. So, I took off a star for that. Where did we lose the second star? Realism. I can't believe that I'm going to be the person that says "realism" in a fantasy book review. But I read mostly fantasy and while the rules can be magical and different, they have to be believable. I felt that this had a few too many places where I couldn't suspend disbelief enough. Again, no spoilers, but with sufficient vagueness let's just say that the most major loss of belief was the medical anatomy aspect. These aren't aliens or fae or elves. They're people like us. So, I expect that anatomy to be similar and you can't just wave away a major injury with a superficial patch job without at least waving a magic artifact. End result: I mostly enjoyed reading this and I'm not sorry I picked it up. Therefore 3 stars.

[Mella aka Maron · Rating 3 out of 5]

Thank you to Netgalley and Delacorte for the eARC of this book!

I have now read a few books from Katherine Quinn. Her writing style is mostly very easy. It’s not frilly and also not bland. However, this book was so long-winded. There was so much repetition in the characters’ thoughts that I was skipping huge chunks of them because they’d talk about how they liked the other for two whole pages when they JUST did that the previous pov chapter. 😐 It was excessive! This book could have been cut down easily by dropping a lot of their repetitive thinking.

My other qualm with this book was that not much actually happened. ☠️ I feel like this is another duology and honestly… it feels like it could have just been a singular book had we gotten less repetition and more action. Also the banter was not great - it was also very excessive. I also didn’t really enjoy the scenes where the two just started making out in dire situations. 🤦‍♀️ Keep it in your pants guys.

Add in a bad “I’m keeping this secret from you” plot and some very obvious plot twists… and it just wasn’t a great book. It was not BAD though either. It was one word: Forgettable. It’s very basic, at its core. And if you’ve read any other KQ book…. Sorry this is almost the same thing. 🤷‍♀️ It doesn’t vary much from TKaS at ALL. I can line up scenes/characters that coincide perfectly in these two books.

I do think Quinn is a decent writer and I really enjoyed TKaS… but this one just felt like a let down. I think she’s dropped from an auto-buy author to just one I will read maybe from the library when a new book drops.

I’d only recommend this to readers who want a very basic “two teens from different sides of the economic divide coming together to fight the evil aristocracy” plot with some magic thrown in. The book tries to also have a feminist undertone but honestly it falls very flat because it’s told to the reader (multiple times) instead of shown. Had Quinn focused more heavily on that sexual prejudice, I think the story would have benefitted.

[Samantha Bailey · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for an early copy of this novel!

Y’all, you need this masterpiece in your life. Webs of lies, betrayal, and half truths are woven together in this storyline in such a fantastic way. Plus, the banter is bantering between Wren and Damian. IYKYK. And that ending had me gasping! This isn’t even out yet and I already want the next book!!!

[Nelly]

Please someone tell me this book is as good as the cover its gorgeousssssss <3

[Sierraaa · Rating 5 out of 5]

first off, i would like to thank Katherine Quinn, NetGalley, and Random House Publishing for this advanced reader’s copy!

this book started out with a bang, and did not disappoint me once! the characters were great, the story was intriguing, it was a fast-paced read, and the world building made me feel like i was in Andalay right beside Wren and Damien🫶🏻

this story is about a girl who was meant to receive a gift from the Fates, but on the night of her 18th birthday, that gift is stolen before she ever receives it. in order to get it back, she enlists the help of a charming but dangerous boy who just so happens to be a thief himself. and along the way, they uncover shocking secrets that will leave them different than before… and try not to fall in love while their worlds fall apart.

i absolutely adored Wren’s character from the start; naive she might be, but a pushover she is not! she dresses to please herself instead of society and doesn’t really care what the other nobility thinks of her. she’s headstrong and learns to fight for what she thinks is right; i simply love her💕 and as for Damien, he’s definitely more than the gruff thief who only cares for himself that he appears to be. these two made a great duo, and i absolutely can’t wait for more of them!

also, that ending? my jaw hit the floor more than once!!😱 i definitely didn’t see it coming, and i absolutely need the next book to find out what will happen!!

overall this was a fantastic read, and i’m so greatful to have had the chance to read and review it early! this book releases on February 3rd of 2026, so add it to your tbrs asap!

[Carly K · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5⭐️
Idk what kind of crack was in this book, but I was HOOKED and flipping the pages!

From the epigraphs, to the main characters’ dynamic, to the Fates and magic, and the betrayal and twists…this was exactly what I wanted in a fantasy romance! (minor things that were personal preference that made me not give it a full 5, but so so close!)

There were parts of this story that called out societal issues that could be paralleled to our own world, and I felt them so deeply. The class issues, complicated family dynamics, abuse of power, the patriarchal society, etc. They added layers to this fantasy romance that made you look beyond the love.

My jaw DROPPED at the end because that was NOT what I was theorizing to have happen, and I have no idea how I’m supposed to wait for book 2?! CRIMINAL.

This book will be published 2/3/26! Thank you so much to NetGalley and Random House Books/Delacorte Press for an e-ARC of this book! 🤩💕

[Olivia | SpilltheTBR · Rating 4 out of 5]

3.75 ⭐️ | 🚫🌶️ (yummy tension)

Thank you to Netgalley, Katherine Quinn, and Random House Children’s Books for the opportunity to read this novel as an EArc. As a fan of the author this was definitely a treat for me!

This ending has me 😫😫😫, and I’ll definitely be reading the next book. I have questions and would like some answers. I also would like a HEA. Please and thank you.

Katherine Quinn is a master at writing tension and yearning between two characters. From the moment I picked up this book and was introduced to Wren I knew that what I was about to read was going to be a fun and enjoyable ride. One that was filled with tension and intrigue, but was ultimately an easy read.

Wren, who just turned 18, was supposed to receive a gift from the fates (deities that represent Day, Dawn, and Dusk) that would give her magical abilities. However, her path was thwarted by a handsome thief named Damien. Damien quickly discovers that their paths are more intertwined than just the job he was hired to complete. As they try to uncover the mystery behind their connection a more nefarious plot is revealed. The story goes beyond just uncovering the mystery behind Wren‘s gift, but instead is a commentary on the injustices between the rich and the poor. Sounds intriguing, right? You don’t even know the half of it!

Let’s talk characters and their roles. This is a dual POV so we alternate between Wren and Damien’s perspectives. Which adds to their individual character development as they better get to know one another. This is a slow burn but oh so fun read. The tension between Wren and Damien was electric. I found it to be delicious and their banter was kicking feet worthy. Keep in mind this is a YA fantasy romance. So this means no spice and a lot of closed door scenes but honestly, the tension is written so perfectly. You don’t even really miss the spice.

The overall plot was very interesting, and I found that the world building is easy to digest and understand. I think where I struggled was with some of the predictability of the plot. However, there was just as many things that had me going, “Oh my goodness!”I was frustrated with some of the pacing in the book when it came to our main protagonists having a much needed truth based conversation. I understand that it needed to be extended for the plot, but in my mind, I would’ve been happy if it was addressed much sooner. IYKYK what I’m talking about.

I can’t say I am 100% thrilled with the ending. It does contain one of my least favorite tropes and the big bad feels a bit cheesy for me; like evil mustache twirling evil but with no true motive. Though it did come as a slight surprise! I didn’t expect certain reveals and for that I am impressed. I hope in the next book we get to better unpack character motivations and spend some time with the Fates. Until then I’ll just sit here twiddling my thumbs.

Are you looking for an easy read that still has all of your favorite elements of fantasy then the story is definitely for you. Pick it up. Read it. Enjoy it. It’s like fantasy popcorn, not too dense but fills you up nonetheless.

You’ll enjoy this one if you like…
💕 Enemies to lovers
🤺 Regency era vibes
🪄 Enchanted objects
🥰 Swoon worthy tension

[Celia Posada]

Thank you NetGalley and Random House publishing for this eARC!

4.5⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫

Stolen Midnights by Katherine Quinn is a regency era romantasy that is pretty on the outside all while it is quietly sharpening its knives on the inside.

It is told in dual POV and the story weaves together magical objects, thievery, murder, and sharp social commentary. Beneath the glitz and glamour of high society is a brutally honest examination of wealth, privilege, capitalism, and the ways society exploits its most vulnerable to keep the rich firmly in power. The beginning was difficult to read, not because it’s poorly written, but because it’s very effective. The discomfort it creates feels painfully relevant, and it’s the kind of book that asks you to sit with that unease instead of rushing past it.

Wren absolutely stole my heart. Yes, she’s naive, which is a product of her privileged upbringing, but she’s also headstrong, fiery, brave, and completely unwilling to look away once her eyes are opened. What stood out most to me was her empathy. Her growing awareness of government corruption and social injustice feels raw and real. Watching her reckon with her own privilege while wanting desperately to do something to help was deeply relatable. I see so much of myself in her. The desire to change the world, paired with the feeling of powerlessness, hit close to home.

There’s fantastic banter, a sweet romance with great chemistry, delicious feminine rage, and a strong atmosphere throughout. I loved the symbolism of Wren’s favorite color being pink. Softness and bravery are not opposites here, and the book makes that point beautifully.

I did predict a few twists, but not all of them. And listen. I genuinely thought this was a standalone. That cliffhanger? Cruel. Absolutely cruel.

Overall, I loved this book. It was entertaining as well as thought provoking. Stolen Midnights is a story about stolen power, stolen lives, and what happens when someone finally decides they can no longer look away. 🌸🔥

[Dario Pacheco · Rating 5 out of 5]

First and foremost I’d like thank the amazing folks at NetGalley & Random House publishing for the amazing opportunity of reading this book before its February release date. I am honored and my review is a honest reflection of my feelings towards this book.
This book was a pleasant surprise of a book that winded up being one of my favorite books I’ve read this year. Katherine is an author that I have followed for a while now after I loved her book, To Kill a Shadow.
We meet Wren, a girl who lives in a world that on your 18th birthday you receive a gifted item who’s gifts can range in usability big or small but when her gift doesn’t come she fears she is one of those who is deemed unworthy of one. Unknown to her she had a gift but on its way to her it’s stolen my a thief named Damien. A boy who when he gets her gift, a locket, he is startled to find his picture on inside.
And so sets the stage for a romance between a thief and an upper class girl. Secrets are revealed and the structure of their world is being rewritten. For the good? Nope. This couple is at the core of a power game that will either destroy their love or make it stronger.
I love love loved the banter of Damien and Wren, probably my favorite part outside the gift system that had me intrigued. This book revived a waning interest in YA and I would absolutely recommend this book to lovers of romance, banter and a world that will have you intrigued.

[Mckenna Underwood · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you to Random House Children’s Books, Delacorte Press, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read Stolen Midnights!

Imagine it’s midnight on your 18th birthday, and you’re waiting for the magical gift the Fates grant everyone in your family. Each relative has received something unique and powerful—so of course, you expect yours to arrive too. But when the clock strikes and nothing happens, panic sets in. Your world—and the social order around you—comes crashing down. What would you do?

This story follows Wren as she searches for the truth about why her gift never came. And let me just say—this book was epic! Twists, turns, and jaw-dropping reveals kept me hooked from beginning to end.

I loved how the author wove together magic, mystery, and romance. The tension and banter between Wren and Damien were top tier, making me fly through the pages. This books gave me Powerless vibes with all of the banter and flirting.

And that ending? My jaw was on the floor and my heart was racing. I need book two immediately—I have so many questions and cannot wait for answers!

(Side note: I do not think this should be marketed as a YA novel. Reads more like a NA novel.)

[Serena · Rating 5 out of 5]

OKAY, I need book two asap.

I was intrigued by the description and this book more than delivered. I was immediately swept away into a world with regency vibes, fates, and magical objects. What more could you ask for? Maybe tension so thick you could cut it with a letter opener.

In a society where the privileged receive magical gifts upon their 18th birthday, Wren is shocked to be left empty handed. Little does she know a thief, Damien, stole her gift before it could arrive to her door. Their intertwined story follows Wren as she searches for the truth and Damien deals with the consequences of his actions.

There were a few twists I didn’t expect, especially since I didn’t realize this would be a series! Again, I need book two now. Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Children’s Books for granting me the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

[Tracey · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you NetGalley and Katherine Quinn! Stolen Midnights was a great story that highlighted the complexities of family ( in all forms), economical hierarchies that are not only manipulated but a harsh reality of how societies get caught up in “roles”.

Let’s not forget the electrifying and powerful relationship with Wren and Damien. Both with back stories that make your heart weep and leap. The personal battles within themselves, those they encounter and what Fate has in store for them allow for a page turning experience.

Katherine Quinn challenges the reader to think deeper within her storytelling. My only hiccup was some language use (profanity) that could have been limited. I am excited to get my hard copy.

[Tiffany]

I am beyond excited for this one. Thank you SO much, Random House Children's Books | Delacorte Press, for sending me this ARC. The most beautiful cover and what a fascinating plot!

The expected publication date is 3 February 2026.

As always, all thoughts are my own. 💕💫

[Makayla Brittan · Rating 5 out of 5]

KATHERINE WHAT THE HECK


This book was phenomenal and I will now hide in a cave a refuse to read anything else

[Artemisia · Rating 5 out of 5]

I'm currently wondering what magical fairy dust Katherine Quinn put in this book to have made me hunger for every page like a madwoman.

Stolen Midnights was an unexpected gem for me. I was intrigued by the blurb, but was wholly unprepared by how much the story and characters ended up gripping me. The setting was an instant delight, evidently taking some historical inspiration that gave me regency/victorian vibes, which certainly upped the appeal for me as an avid HF/HR reader. The beginning drew me in at once, from that moment of-- gasp!-- Wren not receiving her gift in such a neat world that was built up early on without once feeling info-dumped.

Yes, I was invested in the plot and storyline. Yes, I really enjoyed the setting. But the two main heroes of the book, Wren and Damien, utterly stole the show for me and were far and away the highlights. I fell in love with them at first introduction, and fell in love with them again at their absolutely peak first meeting with each other in the mud. Their interactions had me laughing out loud and devouring scene after scene just to see what utter nonsense they were going to get up to. Damien was a disaster in the best way possible and is not at all escaping pathetic, sad wet man allegations. I want to study him in a petri dish. I want to know how on earth he survived this long. I want to tell Wren to stab him again but also kiss him, please, because they're disasters together and despite how much of a MESS their interactions and betrayals are, their happiness is in each other's arms! Hello!

It's fair to say the characters elevated the book for me and were the most treasured part. Even with moments where I thought the plot got a little convoluted or slowed, which I did think happened at times, I was unbothered because of how much I was hanging off the sleeves of Damien and Wren.

--Spoilers--
The only part I truly found weak in the book was the last 5% I suppose, and ending. I have come to expect cliffhanger endings from the genre, and know this was the first entry in a duology, but I still felt the conclusion could have been wrapped up a little neater with a few loose ends at least resolved. The lack of the main characters managing to /accomplish/ anything in the plot showed, with me feeling like I had finished a Part 1 instead of a complete book arc that was set up for a second arc that would complete the overarching story. I think I just wanted more out of it, and probably in part felt less satisfied because two tropes I do not consider myself the biggest fan of (hidden family relationships and memory wiping) featured prominently. I didn't feel convinced of the necessity of Damien's relationship with Everett and didn't feel it added much, and though I felt my heart ripped to shreds with Wren's memory fiasco/wasn't jazzed about it happening, the rest of the book was so strong that I am confident Quinn will resolve it in a satisfactory way in Book 2 when it comes. My initial disappointment at the ending was certainly assuaged by that when I sat back and thought about it. No, I don't have the big picture now, but I am hopeful for what's to come and think we're in for quite the Book 2 when it happens.

Ultimately, despite the ending and weaker points I experienced, I truly do want to, and will, give this my 5 stars. I was incredibly entertained and enamored to a rare degree, and for that, I find it deserving.

[Olivia | SpilltheTBR · Rating 4 out of 5]

Book Review: Stolen Midnights by Katherine Quinn

3.75 ⭐️ | 🚫🌶️ (yummy tension)

Thank you to Netgalley, Katherine Quinn, and Random House Children’s Books for the opportunity to read this novel as an EArc. As a fan of the author this was definitely a treat for me!

This ending has me 😫😫😫, and I’ll definitely be reading the next book. I have questions and would like some answers. I also would like a HEA. Please and thank you.

Katherine Quinn is a master at writing tension and yearning between two characters. From the moment I picked up this book and was introduced to Wren I knew that what I was about to read was going to be a fun and enjoyable ride. One that was filled with tension and intrigue, but was ultimately an easy read.

Wren, who just turned 18, was supposed to receive a gift from the fates (deities that represent Day, Dawn, and Dusk) that would give her magical abilities. However, her path was thwarted by a handsome thief named Damien. Damien quickly discovers that their paths are more intertwined than just the job he was hired to complete. As they try to uncover the mystery behind their connection a more nefarious plot is revealed. The story goes beyond just uncovering the mystery behind Wren‘s gift, but instead is a commentary on the injustices between the rich and the poor. Sounds intriguing, right? You don’t even know the half of it!

Let’s talk characters and their roles. This is a dual POV so we alternate between Wren and Damien’s perspectives. Which adds to their individual character development as they better get to know one another. This is a slow burn but oh so fun read. The tension between Wren and Damien was electric. I found it to be delicious and their banter was kicking feet worthy. Keep in mind this is a YA fantasy romance. So this means no spice and a lot of closed door scenes but honestly, the tension is written so perfectly. You don’t even really miss the spice.

The overall plot was very interesting, and I found that the world building is easy to digest and understand. I think where I struggled was with some of the predictability of the plot. However, there was just as many things that had me going, “Oh my goodness!”I was frustrated with some of the pacing in the book when it came to our main protagonists having a much needed truth based conversation. I understand that it needed to be extended for the plot, but in my mind, I would’ve been happy if it was addressed much sooner. IYKYK what I’m talking about.

I can’t say I am 100% thrilled with the ending. It does contain one of my least favorite tropes and the big bad feels a bit cheesy for me; like evil mustache twirling evil but with no true motive. Though it did come as a slight surprise! I didn’t expect certain reveals and for that I am impressed. I hope in the next book we get to better unpack character motivations and spend some time with the Fates. Until then I’ll just sit here twiddling my thumbs.

Are you looking for an easy read that still has all of your favorite elements of fantasy then the story is definitely for you. Pick it up. Read it. Enjoy it. It’s like fantasy popcorn, not too dense but fills you up nonetheless.

You’ll enjoy this one if you like…
💕 Enemies to lovers
🤺 Regency era vibes
🪄 Enchanted objects
🥰Swoon worthy tension

[Erin Arkin · Rating 4 out of 5]

Katherine Quinn’s Stolen Midnights is a compelling blend of imaginative world-building and raw, character-driven emotion. It manages to feel both grand in scale and intimately personal.

The story transports readers to a society where magic is a tangible inheritance. Upon their eighteenth birthday, members of the Aurilian noble families receive a physical "gift" from the Fates—an object that bestows magical power. While the elite are deemed "blessed," those living in the impoverished Void are largely forgotten.

Our protagonist, Wren, is the daughter of Representative Hayes of Ward One. As a devout believer in the Fates, she is certain her gift is coming. She doesn't yet realize that these "divine" blessings aren't based on faith, but on who can pay the highest price to the Fates. Her worldview is shattered when a thief intercepts her delivery, leaving her powerless and questioning everything she thought she knew.

Wren’s character arc is a masterfully executed transition from a sheltered, guarded girl into a daring woman. Stripped of the future she expected, she is forced to confront the systemic cruelty her family represents. Her evolution from a "girl who lost her gift" to a woman determined to save those who cannot save themselves is both empowering and grounded. As she partners with the boy from the wrong neighborhood to reclaim her gift, they uncover something more sinister at play and there is a determination in her to right the wrongs that have been committed.

In the shadows of the Void, she meets Damien, the quintessential "morally gray" hero. Damien’s path to redemption is slow and agonizing as he gradually lowers his defenses. His internal struggle—torn between his goal of escaping to the West and his forbidden attraction to Wren—creates a palpable, electric tension. Their chemistry is built on a shaky foundation of mutual distrust that slowly hardens into a deep, unbreakable connection.

Quinn excels at crafting a magic system that feels integral to the plot rather than just a backdrop. Magic isn't just a set of powers; it is the currency of the social hierarchy. The way these "gifts" influence the political landscape and reinforce class divides adds a layer of sophistication to the narrative that keeps the reader invested in the broader stakes.

One of the novel’s greatest strengths is its ensemble. The secondary characters are essential gears in the story's machinery rather than mere background noise. Callie provides an emotional anchor for Wren, offering warmth and support when her world falls apart. And Ruby serves as Damien’s only real link to humanity. Having grown up in an orphanage and living above a bar, Damien keeps the world at arm's length, but Ruby is the one person he’s let into his sphere...until he lets Wren in. We also have Callie's family and a few other nobles that help move the story along and play important parts.

Stolen Midnights is a stellar series opener that delivers high-stakes fantasy with heart. However, be prepared: the ending is a killer. The final twist will have you wanting to throw your book across the room and it leaves a hole that can only be filled by the sequel. It is the definition of a "must-read" that will have you immediately updating your TBR list.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the copy in exchange for an honest review.

[Heather M Jones-Lancto · Rating 4 out of 5]

Recommendation: 🌕🌕🌕🌕 - (Out of 5 🌕)

Genre: Fantasy, Young Adult, Romantasy, Fantasy Romance

Length: 464 Pages

Pace: Fast

Moods: Romantic, Page Turner, Emotional, Inspiring, Reflective, Great World Building, Action Packed, Romantic

Release Date: February 3, 2026



Stolen Midnights is a story about what happens when someone who is fortunate enough to 'have' realizes there are those in the world who 'have not'. This story was inspirational. Katherine Quinn has written a book that will hopefully make many readers reflect on real world situations in a time when the world is filled with absolute chaos.

The two main characters in this story, Wren and Damien, have their flaws but it is these flaws that make them more human, more relatable. Wren was born into a prestigious and wealthy family. Her advantages do not keep her from realizing she wants different for herself in life and for her future. She wants to be seen as equal to her male counterparts but more than that she wishes to not be treated like chattel, to not be married off to the man who makes the highest offer to her father. Damien grew up with nothing. Abandoned when he was a baby, he was raised in an orphanage and turned out on his own when he came of age. He has learned to use his charms and unique talents to get by.

Synopsis:




Wren has waited for her eighteenth birthday for so long. At midnight she eagerly anticipates receiving her magical token from the Fates. Unfortunately, the gift never comes, and because of this, Wren becomes an outcast in elite society. She had never considered that she would not be chosen by the Fates. Her situation has forced her to open her eyes to things she would have never noticed before. Not only is there an equality between genders, there is a huge gap between the wealthy and the poor as well as a bias against those without magical gifts.

Damien does not understand why he was fortunate to receive a magical gift when he turned eighteen. He was not born into a well to do family, he is considered nothing. But, he has never questioned his luck and has used his token to advance himself. When he was hired by an anonymous client to steal Wren's fated gift he is confused to find a picture of himself in her locket. Once he gets to know and better understand Wren, he realizes can never admit to Wren that he stole her locket. His actions the night of her birthday have brought two together as they attempt to reveal the hidden secrets in their city.

Katherine Quinn has captured my full attention with this first installment of her new series. The story is original, the characters are likable and realistic. I am excited to learn more about the three fates, their origin story, and what they have in store for Wren. I am rarely surprised by a storyline but Quinn has me questioning what Wren and Damien will discover.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Diana · Rating 4 out of 5]

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4/5 STARS

it's been awhile since i've dived into a good fantasy book. i've been in my thriller era. but this makes me want to go into more fantasies again. it's so well written, the world is intricately built, and the story in general is so good. i know it's romantasy, but the societal aspects of the rich getting richer and the poor being poorer resonates so well with the current political climate. and the fact that the Fates have a part in that makes you wonder why... why allow this injustice to happen?

i loved Wren's character from the beginning. despite barely turning 18, she still has that innocence within her. the author doesn't write her character to immediately be adult-like. but more than anything, i loved her ferocity for wanting to be her own person. even though she understood the roles women were expected to play in the world, she still wanted to break the mold. she didn't want to just be blessed by the Fates; she wanted to do good. and she didn't want to be tied to a man to do anything worth doing. bcuz YES!

then there's Damien. he's had a rough life living in "The Void", but he's doing what he can to survive. with that need for survival came skills that led him to cross paths with Wren. he doesn't understand why he's drawn to her or why the Fates led him to her. i was loving the enemies-to-lovers element between them. i'm not really into that insta-love romance, because let's be real... it just doesn't feel believable. while Wren and Damien are at odds with each other, there are moments where their immediate attraction felt forced when Damien is supposed to be angry with the blessed and rich. also, if the Fates were all powerful and magical... how the heck did Damien steal from them?

this honestly was a fun read. i was completely wrapped into the story and loved every second of it. i highly recommend this one for all my romantasy girlies! i have two of Katherine Quinn's books on my shelf which i have yet to read, and after reading this book... i have the push i need to dive into them. so i look forward to those. if they're anything like this one, i have no doubt i'll love it.

thank you to the author and publisher for allowing me the opportunity to read an advanced copy via NetGalley. i leave this review of my own volition. all thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Lauryle · Rating 5 out of 5]

If you loved the uniqueness and magic of Stephanie Garber’s Once Upon a Broken Heart series, I highly recommend diving into Stolen Midnights by Katherine Quinn — the first book in an exciting new duology.

This book was a breath of fresh air in the fantasy genre. From the very first page, I was completely hooked — especially because the story is told from two compelling points of view. It's one of my most memorable 2025 reads so far. I finished it with my jaw on the floor, overwhelmed by emotions, and buzzing with questions (in the best way possible).

Non-Spoiler Book Summary
In Aurilian society, it's tradition for young adults to receive a magical “gift” from the Fates on their 18th birthday — a magical object that grants them unique powers. Wren Hayes comes from a family where everyone has received their gift. But when hers never arrives, she sets off on a journey to discover what happened.

What she doesn't know is that her gift was stolen — by Damien, a mysterious thief raised in Andalay’s orphan system. Hired to take the gift before Wren ever received it, Damien assumes it’s just another job... until curiosity gets the better of him and he opens the locket meant for Wren — only to find his picture inside.

Wren and Damien’s stories intertwine in a way that’s thrilling, romantic, and completely captivating. As the mystery unfolds, readers are drawn deeper into questions surrounding the Fates and why certain families are mysteriously being left without them.

Reviewer's Overall Thoughts:
• I didn’t realize going in that this was the first in a duology, so the ending caught me completely off guard — in the best possible way. It gave me the same heart-pounding, cliffhanger energy of an SJM finale: packed with twists, reveals, and emotion.
• Quinn masterfully balanced the dual POVs. Often in dual narratives, one voice overshadows the other, but here, both Wren and Damien’s perspectives were equally engaging and well-developed.
• I’m desperate for book two! This story has everything I love in a fantasy: mystery, romance, world-building, and complex characters. I’ll absolutely be keeping an eye out for the sequel’s release — and I’m definitely hoping to get my hands on an early copy!

Thank you to Delacorte Press and NetGalley for this advance ready copy and the opportunity to submit a review.

[Alexia shesbetterat40 · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book surprised me! I went in blind, all I knew was it was a YA book. The story started a bit slowly and I really struggled to get into it at the beginning. However, once Wren and Damian’s working relationship started amping up, things got interesting fast. The banter between the two was so fun! The way they honestly thought they hated each other:

“I despised Damien and his smirking face. A face that begged to be smacked.”

And, “Only I could insult Wren Hayes. She was mine to tease and provoke.”

Aside from the witty banter and constant sniping between Wren and Damien, the plot tells a story rooted in patriarchal society and power imbalances between classes.

“The Northerners despised the South, probably because it made them feel better about themselves. Important. How very . . . pathetic.”

Wren and Damien are from different worlds North (rich) and South (poor) but share a connection that neither understands. I enjoyed the slow-burn of their relationship as they navigated their way through their many, many differences. Although this is a YA book, the heat and steam was there. The characters are 18 and 19, and I felt their relationship was age appropriate.

What I wanted more of was the prophecy Wren was given by Dusk. There were times while I read that I thought “oh, that could be part of the prophecy” and it wasn’t mentioned. It was like Wren read the letter, buried it and promptly forgot it existed. I would have like to see it referenced more. I feel like that could have steered the story a bit better.

The side characters in this story are pretty good. I hate her parents and the society at large and love the little band of rebels that comes together throughout the story. The other characters helped to enrich the plot and enhance the mystery to keep you guessing about who is bad and who is good. I don’t think we have seen the last of many of these side characters.

The last 15% of the book moves really fast and ends up on a cliffhanger that made me want to punch a very specific guy. Hopefully we’ll get to see a part two soon. I was so grateful to receive an advance copy of this book and am leaving this review with extreme gratitude and enthusiasm.

[Sarah's Always Reading · Rating 5 out of 5]

THIS.BOOK! THIS. BOOK just took my breath away......

I'm not even sure where to start with this review. This book blew away my expectations. I thought it would be a cute YA novel with a tiny bit of mystery and a kiss at the end. That is NOT what this is! Prepare yourself for an adventure with twists and turns and a love story that will have you tugging at your heart strings.

Wren is the the younger daughter of the Lord who oversees Ward 1, set in a Victorian era period but the upper class are granted gifts from one of the 3 Fates that the people worship. I will admit this concept took me a minute to get into but hang in there. On the night of her 18th birthday Wren's gift never comes- instead it was stolen by the street rat and thief, known as the Ghost our MMC Damien. They should be enemies right? She is the pampered princess now outcasted by her peers without a gift. He is the impoverish thief harden by "the Void." But the Fates are at play and their futures are intertwined. What entails is a beautiful but complex story of betrayal, forgiveness, deceit, and love.

Damien is the book boyfriend we all want. He is a lost and broken soul who will do anything for Wren even when it scares him (if his feelings don't cause him run first). But he is a redemption character in the works. His patience with showing Wren the truth about the Void while also coming to the understanding that she is not the same as the rest of the Upper class. What can I say this man has me!!! Plus all the banter which significantly lighten some of the heavier more depressing parts of the book.

5 Stars
2 Spicy- which was surprising, since this is a YA novel. While the sex scene wasn't explicit I would consider this upper YA.
Excellent plot with a great pace. Ends on a cliff hanger that made my heart stop for poor Damien! I can't wait for book 2!!!!!!!

- Enemies to lovers
- Magical artifacts
- Rich girl/ Street rat
- Betrayal
- Don't touch her

Favorite Quote:
Damien: "Do you always carry a letter opener to balls?"
Wren: "You never know when some prick might get handsy. Or when you might need to catch a thief."

Thank you to NetGalley, Random House Children's and the author Katherine Quinn for the ARC. My life is now on pause waiting for Book 2.

[Sara Hernandez · Rating 4 out of 5]

In Andalay people recieve a gift from the Fated that gives them magical abilities tied to their hearts’s desires. Except Wren Hayes’s gift never arrives. Trying to find out why leads her to stumbling upon an even deeper, and darker secret. To find her missing gift she must work with the reknowned thief Damien, who has a gift of his own, to find out what is really going on. There’s only one problem: Damien is the reason Wren’s gift is missing. He’s the one who stole it.

Wren is a wonderful protagonist. At first she seems sefish and spoiled and shallow, but she quickly comes to realize her privledge and casts off society’s expectations of her. She is headstrong and brave, unfraid to fight (literally!), and doesn’t care what people think of her. She makes friends easily and has a bit of a temper, but she grows and evolves and wants to genuinely help people.

The romance with Damien was just banter at first, flirting at its finest, until he catches feelings. I loved the little detail of them meeting as kids. It didn’t really make sense to me that he was the one to push her away, claim they were a mistake, and then take it back almost immediately when he saw her with another guy, but I guess it built romantic tension since we knew they were going to be endgame. Especially since I have a feeling Grayson is gay and Everett gave major Hans from Frozen vibes.

I do have to admit the twist at the end got me. I never suspected Callie. In fact I suspected it was the mother sneaking around and plotting everything. But it was a pleasant surprise—its not often authors can get the best of me!

There is a cliffhanger ending, during which a lot of secrets are revealed, and an epilogue that sets up book two. I would be interested to see where this goes.

Thank you to Netgalley for an advance copy of the book in exchange for my honest opinion.

[M D · Rating 3 out of 5]

In this thrilling YA fantasy, only the "most worthy" aka wealthiest and most powerful people are gifted magical tokens on their 18th birthday. These tokens given them unique magical powers - and Wren fully expects to receive one. When this goes awry, she is thrown on an eye-opening adventure with the very thief who stole her gift. With complex political turmoil, fierce banter with an enemies-to-lovers vibe, an interesting and fairly unique magic system, and a big plot twist at the end, this book was thrilling and will be an interesting series to continue.

I had a bit of a hard time getting into the story at the start. For the first ~40%, there was really heavy narration from Wren, and a lot of telling rather than showing her feelings as we got to know her and the other characters. The banter was witty, but at times seemed forced/repetitive, and there was a lot of swearing that seemed somewhat counter to the more formalized speech and dress in other scenes (though this may have been intentional to show her growth as she distances from high society). However, I am glad that I stuck with it, because I enjoyed the second half of the book much more.

Once the characters and world were better developed and the plot progression became a stronger focus, I found the story captivating and easy to get lost in. The chemistry in the second half was more natural, and the action was exciting and kept me on my toes. There were some spicy scenes, more than I am used to seeing in a YA novel, but it did stay PG-13. Damien was a well-developed MMC with a mysterious/traumatic background, and it was easy to see how his actions aligned with his sordid past. The dual POV really worked throughout and added significantly to the experience. I look forward to seeing where things progress in book 2.

[Zia · Rating 3 out of 5]

Thank you to NetGalley, Random House Children's Books, and Katherine Quinn for the opportunity to read and review an Advance Reader Copy of this book!

I really wish I had liked this book more. The beginning was strong, and I genuinely enjoyed the setup and the overall plot. Unfortunately, the romance pulled me out of what was otherwise an engaging story.

The book tried to lean into a “we hate each other but can’t stay away” dynamic, but the execution didn’t work for me. Instead, it became a repetitive cycle of “I hate her/him, but I can’t get enough of them,” which took over the narrative. I think if that constant push-and-pull had been toned down, or removed altogether, the romance could have felt much sweeter and more natural.

Plot-wise, I really enjoyed the mystery and fantasy elements. Learning about the powers in this world, how they function, and the role of the Fates was genuinely interesting, and those aspects kept me engaged. I also liked learning about the other characters and the backstory. I think those aspects of the plot were nice to read as well.

That said, the ending felt underdeveloped. While the story hinted at a larger reveal throughout, there wasn’t enough groundwork laid to make it fully believable. We never truly saw who that character was beneath the surface, so the outcome didn’t feel earned. The trope also used at the end is one I usually enjoy, but again, due to the uneven buildup and awkward execution, it didn’t feel natural here.

There were parts of this book that I really liked, but overall the execution felt flat, and that’s what made this book that felt like it could have been a high 4 star book, become a 3.5 star book.

Thank you again to NetGalley, Random House Children's Books, and Katherine Quinn for the opportunity to read and review an Advance Reader Copy of this book!

[Sabrina Marshall · Rating 5 out of 5]

Stolen Midnights quickly became one of my all-time favorite romantasies. I devoured every word and found myself thinking about the story long after I had to put the book down. Now I’m impatiently awaiting the sequel—I need to know what happens next!

The story introduces a fascinating world where, at midnight on their 18th birthday, those of high social standing receive a magical gift from the Fates—Day, Dawn, or Dusk. But when Wren’s birthday arrives, her gift never comes. While not unheard of, it’s considered rare and deeply shameful, leaving Wren and her family devastated.

What Wren doesn’t know is that across the city, a thief named Damian has stolen her gift, adding it to the list of magical items he’s been tasked with stealing. When Wren seeks answers from Dusk and discovers her missing, she sets off on a desperate search to reclaim what was stolen, uncovering a hidden world beneath her polished society—with Damian, of all people, at her side.

The characters are what make this book shine. Wren, Damian, Callie, Everette, and Grayson are so vividly written they feel like real people, each with their own flaws, struggles, and desires. I was initially worried I wouldn’t connect with Wren, but it quickly became clear her fear wasn’t about losing her gift itself—it was about the shame and rejection she’d face in a society that values magic above all else. Watching her grow, fight for others, and fall for Damian—despite knowing he could never be accepted in her world—was one of the most rewarding parts of the story.

Stolen Midnights is an addictive blend of magic, romance, and intrigue that completely swept me away. If you love character-driven romantasy with high stakes and heartfelt connections, this is one you don’t want to miss.

[Eliza · Rating 5 out of 5]

Andalay is starkly divided. The nobles in the north are given gifts with magical powers by the Fates (God-like figures), while the southern Void is home to those with no power, no magic, and many stuck in poverty. When a thief from the south, Damien, steals a magical gift intended for a noble daughter, Wren, he sets off a chain of events which uncovers several dark truths about Andalay and the ruling families, including Wren’s. Wren and Damien find themselves reluctantly drawn together. The end of this book was shocking and the cliffhanger is painfully good. I thought I was piecing everything together, but there was much more happening than I could have guessed. I am anxious to continue this story.

I loved the playful banter Damien and Wren had with each other. While Wren is called “Sunshine,” I would not categorize Damien as a grumpy character. He enjoys pushing her buttons and tries to act carefree or nonchalant even when the situation is troubling him. Wren is a bit naïve, understandably, but her heart is pure, and she is fiercely determined to do the right thing. I found these characters easy to like and root for during the story.

I think fans of Heartless Hunter/Crimson Moth will really enjoy this book. The writing style is similar, and I felt the same kind of energy reading this book. I think the banter and high society parties also contributed to these books having similar vibes. This book is not enemies to lovers though; I’d describe the romantic relationship as reluctant partners.

I think this book is going to be a very popular YA Romantasy book!

Thank you Net Galley, Random House Children’s Books, and Delacorte Press for providing me with an ARC!