What do you think?
Rate this book
The Tales of Dunk and Egg #1-3
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms
Almost a century before A GAME OF THRONES, two unlikely heroes wandered Westeros…
In an age when the Targaryen line still holds the Iron Throne, and recollections of the last dragon have not yet passed from living memory, a naïve but courageous hedge knight, Ser Duncan the Tall, towers above his rivals – in stature if not experience. Tagging along with him is his diminutive squire, a boy called Egg, whose true identity must be kept hidden: for in reality he is Aegon Targaryen, and one day he will be king. Improbable heroes though they be, great destinies lie ahead for Dunk and Egg; as do powerful foes, royal intrigue, and outrageous exploits.
Illustrated throughout by Gary Gianni, one of the finest fantasy artists of our time, A KNIGHT OF THE SEVEN KINGDOMS brings together for the first time the first three official prequel novellas to George R.R. Martin’s ongoing masterwork, A SONG OF ICE AND FIRE.
In an age when the Targaryen line still holds the Iron Throne, and recollections of the last dragon have not yet passed from living memory, a naïve but courageous hedge knight, Ser Duncan the Tall, towers above his rivals – in stature if not experience. Tagging along with him is his diminutive squire, a boy called Egg, whose true identity must be kept hidden: for in reality he is Aegon Targaryen, and one day he will be king. Improbable heroes though they be, great destinies lie ahead for Dunk and Egg; as do powerful foes, royal intrigue, and outrageous exploits.
Illustrated throughout by Gary Gianni, one of the finest fantasy artists of our time, A KNIGHT OF THE SEVEN KINGDOMS brings together for the first time the first three official prequel novellas to George R.R. Martin’s ongoing masterwork, A SONG OF ICE AND FIRE.
355 pages, Hardcover
First published October 6, 2015
9124 people are currently reading
57928 people want to read
About the author
George R.R. Martin
1,506 books118k followersGeorge Raymond Richard "R.R." Martin was born September 20, 1948, in Bayonne, New Jersey. His father was Raymond Collins Martin, a longshoreman, and his mother was Margaret Brady Martin. He has two sisters, Darleen Martin Lapinski and Janet Martin Patten.
Martin attended Mary Jane Donohoe School and Marist High School. He began writing very young, selling monster stories to other neighborhood children for pennies, dramatic readings included. Later he became a comic book fan and collector in high school, and began to write fiction for comic fanzines (amateur fan magazines). Martin's first professional sale was made in 1970 at age 21: The Hero, sold to Galaxy, published in February, 1971 issue. Other sales followed.
In 1970 Martin received a B.S. in Journalism from Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois, graduating summa cum laude. He went on to complete a M.S. in Journalism in 1971, also from Northwestern.
As a conscientious objector, Martin did alternative service 1972-1974 with VISTA, attached to Cook County Legal Assistance Foundation. He also directed chess tournaments for the Continental Chess Association from 1973-1976, and was a Journalism instructor at Clarke College, Dubuque, Iowa, from 1976-1978. He wrote part-time throughout the 1970s while working as a VISTA Volunteer, chess director, and teacher.
In 1975 he married Gale Burnick. They divorced in 1979, with no children. Martin became a full-time writer in 1979. He was writer-in-residence at Clarke College from 1978-79.
Moving on to Hollywood, Martin signed on as a story editor for Twilight Zone at CBS Television in 1986. In 1987 Martin became an Executive Story Consultant for Beauty and the Beast at CBS. In 1988 he became a Producer for Beauty and the Beast, then in 1989 moved up to Co-Supervising Producer. He was Executive Producer for Doorways, a pilot which he wrote for Columbia Pictures Television, which was filmed during 1992-93.
Martin's present home is Santa Fe, New Mexico. He is a member of Science Fiction & Fantasy Writers of America (he was South-Central Regional Director 1977-1979, and Vice President 1996-1998), and of Writers' Guild of America, West.
http://us.macmillan.com/author/george...
Martin attended Mary Jane Donohoe School and Marist High School. He began writing very young, selling monster stories to other neighborhood children for pennies, dramatic readings included. Later he became a comic book fan and collector in high school, and began to write fiction for comic fanzines (amateur fan magazines). Martin's first professional sale was made in 1970 at age 21: The Hero, sold to Galaxy, published in February, 1971 issue. Other sales followed.
In 1970 Martin received a B.S. in Journalism from Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois, graduating summa cum laude. He went on to complete a M.S. in Journalism in 1971, also from Northwestern.
As a conscientious objector, Martin did alternative service 1972-1974 with VISTA, attached to Cook County Legal Assistance Foundation. He also directed chess tournaments for the Continental Chess Association from 1973-1976, and was a Journalism instructor at Clarke College, Dubuque, Iowa, from 1976-1978. He wrote part-time throughout the 1970s while working as a VISTA Volunteer, chess director, and teacher.
In 1975 he married Gale Burnick. They divorced in 1979, with no children. Martin became a full-time writer in 1979. He was writer-in-residence at Clarke College from 1978-79.
Moving on to Hollywood, Martin signed on as a story editor for Twilight Zone at CBS Television in 1986. In 1987 Martin became an Executive Story Consultant for Beauty and the Beast at CBS. In 1988 he became a Producer for Beauty and the Beast, then in 1989 moved up to Co-Supervising Producer. He was Executive Producer for Doorways, a pilot which he wrote for Columbia Pictures Television, which was filmed during 1992-93.
Martin's present home is Santa Fe, New Mexico. He is a member of Science Fiction & Fantasy Writers of America (he was South-Central Regional Director 1977-1979, and Vice President 1996-1998), and of Writers' Guild of America, West.
http://us.macmillan.com/author/george...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 8,603 reviews
March 10, 2024
(A-) 82% | Very Good
Notes: It's about obstinate idealism, social mobility, and how knightly ambition means stumbling into other people's drama.
Notes: It's about obstinate idealism, social mobility, and how knightly ambition means stumbling into other people's drama.
December 22, 2025
(A-) 82% | Very Good
Notes: On pyrrhic wins, quick-cobbled kin (remarriages and strays), royal brawls, disguised cabals, and loves that got away.
*Check out progress updates for detailed commentary:
Notes: On pyrrhic wins, quick-cobbled kin (remarriages and strays), royal brawls, disguised cabals, and loves that got away.
*Check out progress updates for detailed commentary:
February 3, 2019
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a great prequel compilation with superb production value.
I’m currently in the middle of collecting all the books within A Song of Ice and Fire in hardcover format. Honestly speaking, unlike The World of Ice and Fire and Fire and Blood, I didn’t have a lot of interest in reading this book; I treated it as a completionist read or a diversion while I wait for the release for The Winds of Winter. This is also why I'm happy that this book ended up being such a pleasant surprise for me.
Picture: One of the interior illustrations by Gary Gianni.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a compilation of the three prequel novellas in The Tales of Dunk and Egg series by George R. R. Martin. It’s a prequel to A Song of Ice and Fire and the story starts about a century before the events in A Game of Thrones. Ser Duncan the Tall (Dunk) and Egg were simply fascinating to read. Starting from their encounter in The Hedge Knight, each novella continues to develop their characterizations and relationship more. Unlike the main series, the tone of this much more light-hearted. The knights in Westeros are often times asshole, coward, and despicable. This has been proven countless times throughout the main series. Dunk is a different kind of knight; honorable, courageous, naïve, and awkward. The friendship between Dunk and Egg was subtle and I found the unlikely harmony in their interaction to be funny, heartwarming, and highly engaging.
I don’t have really have a lot of things to say regarding this collection because of the short length. This book is 360 pages long and there are more than 160 gorgeous illustrations done by Gary Gianni that filled the pages of this book; they made the book feel shorter but at the same time they totally enhanced my reading experience to be much more atmospheric. I can’t help it, I’m a sucker for a novel with interior illustrations; in my opinion this book has a terrific production value.
Picture: One of the interior illustrations by Gary Gianni.
I enjoyed reading all the three novellas. My rating for thenovellas: 4.5/5 stars for The Hedge Knight, 3.5/5 stars for The Sworn Sword, and 4/5 stars for The Mystery Knight. Overall, I think fans of the main series will have a wonderful time with this book. Martin once again shows that even in a novella format, he’s still a writer with immense talent at characterizations and world-building. A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms offers a glimpse of the rich history behind Westeros through the eyes of the finely written duo: Dunk and Egg. I can’t believe I’m saying this—especially knowing that the main series is in limbo status—but I’m really looking forward to the continuation of the duo's story and how it all eventually connects to the main series.
You can order the book from: Book Depository (Free shipping)
You can find this and the rest of my reviews at Novel Notions
I’m currently in the middle of collecting all the books within A Song of Ice and Fire in hardcover format. Honestly speaking, unlike The World of Ice and Fire and Fire and Blood, I didn’t have a lot of interest in reading this book; I treated it as a completionist read or a diversion while I wait for the release for The Winds of Winter. This is also why I'm happy that this book ended up being such a pleasant surprise for me.
Picture: One of the interior illustrations by Gary Gianni.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a compilation of the three prequel novellas in The Tales of Dunk and Egg series by George R. R. Martin. It’s a prequel to A Song of Ice and Fire and the story starts about a century before the events in A Game of Thrones. Ser Duncan the Tall (Dunk) and Egg were simply fascinating to read. Starting from their encounter in The Hedge Knight, each novella continues to develop their characterizations and relationship more. Unlike the main series, the tone of this much more light-hearted. The knights in Westeros are often times asshole, coward, and despicable. This has been proven countless times throughout the main series. Dunk is a different kind of knight; honorable, courageous, naïve, and awkward. The friendship between Dunk and Egg was subtle and I found the unlikely harmony in their interaction to be funny, heartwarming, and highly engaging.
“A great battle is a terrible thing," the old knight said, "but in the midst of blood and carnage, there is sometimes also beauty, beauty that could break your heart.”
I don’t have really have a lot of things to say regarding this collection because of the short length. This book is 360 pages long and there are more than 160 gorgeous illustrations done by Gary Gianni that filled the pages of this book; they made the book feel shorter but at the same time they totally enhanced my reading experience to be much more atmospheric. I can’t help it, I’m a sucker for a novel with interior illustrations; in my opinion this book has a terrific production value.
Picture: One of the interior illustrations by Gary Gianni.
I enjoyed reading all the three novellas. My rating for thenovellas: 4.5/5 stars for The Hedge Knight, 3.5/5 stars for The Sworn Sword, and 4/5 stars for The Mystery Knight. Overall, I think fans of the main series will have a wonderful time with this book. Martin once again shows that even in a novella format, he’s still a writer with immense talent at characterizations and world-building. A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms offers a glimpse of the rich history behind Westeros through the eyes of the finely written duo: Dunk and Egg. I can’t believe I’m saying this—especially knowing that the main series is in limbo status—but I’m really looking forward to the continuation of the duo's story and how it all eventually connects to the main series.
You can order the book from: Book Depository (Free shipping)
You can find this and the rest of my reviews at Novel Notions
July 8, 2024
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a collection of three novellas that are set a generation or two before the events of A Song and Ice and Fire. In the third person perspective, we follow Dunk or as he tailors himself - Ser Duncan the Tall. The first narrative is named The Hedge Knight and we are presented to our protagonist as he is burying his former mentor for whom he used to squire. It's a touching start, and an interesting introduction to Dunk. He is planning to go to a tourney in Ashford and at a crossroads inn he meets Egg, who he assumes is a stable boy. This boy decides to follow Dunk without permission, wanting to squire for him. Eventually, it transpires that he is of royal blood and would eventually become Aegon V, protector of the realm, etc... He is the brother of Aemon Targaryen who becomes maester of the Night's Watch. At this time Bloodraven is the Hand of the King. This is the gentleman who becomes the three-eyed-raven.
"Dunk the lunk, thick as a castle wall."
At 17 years old, almost 7-foot-tall, strong and with weight and reach in his favour, Dunk is a formidable Hedge Knight. Essentially, he is a Knight who travels throughout the 7 Kingdoms doing jobs he deems true and honourable for coin. Dunk is as true and decent as any Knight you would have read about in A Song of Ice and Fire and there is a fan theory that Brienne is a descendant of his and I can totally believe that. We are presented the tale from his mind and he talks himself down over explaining his stupidity. I never really saw him as being dim. He can't read, he has never kissed a girl and he doesn't really have people skills but some of the supporting cast and villains who can and have done these come across as more vile and horrid when reflected against Dunk's honesty, loyalty and general goodheartedness.
Egg is a pretty amazing character. Even though he has Targaryen purple eyes he shaves his head so his gold/silver hair doesn't make it completely obvious regarding his lineage. And he has a silly straw hat! He is described as being as wise as a maester but still only 10. He knows the history of the majority of the nation's houses and can name who someone is just by seeing the paintwork on their shields. He is also quick of tongue sometimes to his detriment, especially when these 3 novellas often discuss the Targaryan Blackfyre rebellion and hint at seeds that are still spread throughout the land. I read this after I read GRRM's Fire and Blood and the knowledge I gained regarding the Targaryan's there did enhance my experience although it isn't truly necessary to read in that order. I think this could be thoroughly enjoyed by someone who has not yet read the main series. It's not all pretty and it does feature numerous deaths, violence and backstabbing but from Dunk's perspective, these stories present a lot more hope and goodness than we are accustomed to from a typical Westeros tale.
When I read this I had had one of the worst weeks of my life. If I believed in guardian angels I would think that mine made me pick up this book at this time instead of the other 1000 books on my to-be-read list. This story was exactly what I needed. Interesting, funny, about friendship with elements of trust, mystery and excitement. I've always looked down upon reviewers who rate a book 6/5 as I think it makes no sense. After this scenario and how this book has helped me recover then this is the closest I will ever get to giving that rating. It's the best novel I've read this year and I can't wait to read about more Dunk and Egg.
"Dunk the lunk, thick as a castle wall."
At 17 years old, almost 7-foot-tall, strong and with weight and reach in his favour, Dunk is a formidable Hedge Knight. Essentially, he is a Knight who travels throughout the 7 Kingdoms doing jobs he deems true and honourable for coin. Dunk is as true and decent as any Knight you would have read about in A Song of Ice and Fire and there is a fan theory that Brienne is a descendant of his and I can totally believe that. We are presented the tale from his mind and he talks himself down over explaining his stupidity. I never really saw him as being dim. He can't read, he has never kissed a girl and he doesn't really have people skills but some of the supporting cast and villains who can and have done these come across as more vile and horrid when reflected against Dunk's honesty, loyalty and general goodheartedness.
Egg is a pretty amazing character. Even though he has Targaryen purple eyes he shaves his head so his gold/silver hair doesn't make it completely obvious regarding his lineage. And he has a silly straw hat! He is described as being as wise as a maester but still only 10. He knows the history of the majority of the nation's houses and can name who someone is just by seeing the paintwork on their shields. He is also quick of tongue sometimes to his detriment, especially when these 3 novellas often discuss the Targaryan Blackfyre rebellion and hint at seeds that are still spread throughout the land. I read this after I read GRRM's Fire and Blood and the knowledge I gained regarding the Targaryan's there did enhance my experience although it isn't truly necessary to read in that order. I think this could be thoroughly enjoyed by someone who has not yet read the main series. It's not all pretty and it does feature numerous deaths, violence and backstabbing but from Dunk's perspective, these stories present a lot more hope and goodness than we are accustomed to from a typical Westeros tale.
When I read this I had had one of the worst weeks of my life. If I believed in guardian angels I would think that mine made me pick up this book at this time instead of the other 1000 books on my to-be-read list. This story was exactly what I needed. Interesting, funny, about friendship with elements of trust, mystery and excitement. I've always looked down upon reviewers who rate a book 6/5 as I think it makes no sense. After this scenario and how this book has helped me recover then this is the closest I will ever get to giving that rating. It's the best novel I've read this year and I can't wait to read about more Dunk and Egg.
February 22, 2016
Now I’ve of course read these before, but I simply had to get this edition for the illustrations. They did wonders and capturing the story; they almost brought new life to it. So, it was money well spent and, as an added bonus, I had an excuse to read these short stories again!
A memorable friendship
Dunc and Egg make a wonderful pair. Ser Duncan is not only a knight in name, but also one in deed. This is something increasingly rare in the seven kingdoms. There are few true knights and even fewer when the events of A Song of Ice and Fire take place. He is really part of a dying breed in Westeros. So, he is honourable and strong; he is just and kind: he is everything a knight should be. However, he is not at all wise; he’s "Dunk the lunk, thick as a castle wall." I suppose not everybody can have everything. We all have our weaknesses, and this is where the young prince Aegon Targaryen comes in to balance the friendship.
"A hedge knight must hold tight to his pride. Without it, he was no more than a sellsword"
Egg is still a boy, though he has a fully developed mind that even the Maesters shall envy. He tempers Ser Duncan’s wrath, guiding him to choose the best course of action. Indeed he has the mind that Duncan lacks. However, for all his intelligence, he still has a whole world to see and understand; he still needs to develop his wisdom. By being Duncan’s squire, he gets to see honour and decency; he begins to understand how people work, and how best to defeat them; he learns that it can be achieved through words as well as deeds.
The two embark on some interesting adventures. Their first (The Hedge Knight ) is by far my favourite. It depicts the pair’s first meeting, and they discover how important them coming together was. Dunc changes the fate of the Seven Kingdoms. The two only met by chance. Their actions lead to the altercation of who is to be the next King. So, it’s all rather far reaching stuff. The second story ( The Sworn Sword) didn’t quite work for me and felt a little flat in all. The third ( The Mystery Knight) made up for it, though, with its character defining moments.
"Kings rise and fall, Dunk thought, and cows and smallfolk go about their business."
I did have a lot of fun reading these through again, and I think that they really are required reading for fans of the series. In addition to this, the illustration did help a lot to capture the essence of the story. This isn’t the first time I’ve said this in a review now, but I do hope that this book marks the last thing that is (re)published before the release of A Winds of Winter. It’s starting to get a little ridiculous now, and the afterward didn’t help things: ol’ Georgy suggests that there are more tales from the pair to come.
I hope he means after A Song of Ice and Fire! But, that’s beside the point, this was still fun to read.
A memorable friendship
Dunc and Egg make a wonderful pair. Ser Duncan is not only a knight in name, but also one in deed. This is something increasingly rare in the seven kingdoms. There are few true knights and even fewer when the events of A Song of Ice and Fire take place. He is really part of a dying breed in Westeros. So, he is honourable and strong; he is just and kind: he is everything a knight should be. However, he is not at all wise; he’s "Dunk the lunk, thick as a castle wall." I suppose not everybody can have everything. We all have our weaknesses, and this is where the young prince Aegon Targaryen comes in to balance the friendship.
"A hedge knight must hold tight to his pride. Without it, he was no more than a sellsword"
Egg is still a boy, though he has a fully developed mind that even the Maesters shall envy. He tempers Ser Duncan’s wrath, guiding him to choose the best course of action. Indeed he has the mind that Duncan lacks. However, for all his intelligence, he still has a whole world to see and understand; he still needs to develop his wisdom. By being Duncan’s squire, he gets to see honour and decency; he begins to understand how people work, and how best to defeat them; he learns that it can be achieved through words as well as deeds.
The two embark on some interesting adventures. Their first (The Hedge Knight ) is by far my favourite. It depicts the pair’s first meeting, and they discover how important them coming together was. Dunc changes the fate of the Seven Kingdoms. The two only met by chance. Their actions lead to the altercation of who is to be the next King. So, it’s all rather far reaching stuff. The second story ( The Sworn Sword) didn’t quite work for me and felt a little flat in all. The third ( The Mystery Knight) made up for it, though, with its character defining moments.
"Kings rise and fall, Dunk thought, and cows and smallfolk go about their business."
I did have a lot of fun reading these through again, and I think that they really are required reading for fans of the series. In addition to this, the illustration did help a lot to capture the essence of the story. This isn’t the first time I’ve said this in a review now, but I do hope that this book marks the last thing that is (re)published before the release of A Winds of Winter. It’s starting to get a little ridiculous now, and the afterward didn’t help things: ol’ Georgy suggests that there are more tales from the pair to come.
I hope he means after A Song of Ice and Fire! But, that’s beside the point, this was still fun to read.
May 20, 2024
I mean, obviously this is 5 stars. RTC.
• ───────────────── •
“The snail may leave a trail of slime behind him, but a little slime will do a man no harm, while if you dance with dragons, you must expect to burn.”
“A great battle is a terrible thing," the old knight said, "but in the midst of blood and carnage, there is sometimes also beauty, beauty that could break your heart.”
• ───────────────── •
“The snail may leave a trail of slime behind him, but a little slime will do a man no harm, while if you dance with dragons, you must expect to burn.”
“A great battle is a terrible thing," the old knight said, "but in the midst of blood and carnage, there is sometimes also beauty, beauty that could break your heart.”
July 27, 2024
“As the champions trotted into position, Ashford Meadow grew almost still. Then a horn sounded, and stillness turned to tumult in half a heartbeat. Ten pairs of gilded spurs drove into the flanks of ten great warhorses, a thousand voices began to scream and shout, forty ironshod hooves pounded and tore the grass, ten lances dipped and steadied, and the field seemed almost to shake, and champions and challengers came together in a rending crash of wood and steel. In an instant, the riders were beyond each other, wheeling about for another pass. Lord Tully reeled in the saddle but managed to keep his seat. When the commons realized that all ten of the lances had broken, a great roar of approval went up. It was a splendid omen for the success of the tourney, and a testament to the skill of the competitors. Squires handed fresh lances to the jousters to replace the broken ones they cast aside, and once more the spurs dug deep…”
- George R.R. Martin, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms
I am weak. And in my weakness, I finally broke down and purchased George R.R. Martin’s A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. It sat on my shelf for a while, mocking me and my lack of self-control. I meant to continue ignoring it. But then the final episodes of HBO’s Game of Thrones came and went, and the withdrawal set in. It set in bad. I had to crack the cover; I had to stop the shakes.
I didn't want to, you see? Really I didn't.
I don’t like encouraging bad behavior. I did not want to be a part – however infinitesimally small – of goading Martin into further digressions. Like millions of others, I just want him to finish A Song of Ice & Fire, a series that I love and that has – in a very real way – broadened my view of the power of books. Before Martin came along, I never saw myself as the kind of guy who liked dragon stories. Martin made me care. He made me care very, very much.
So I read it. And it underwhelmed me. I will leave it up to you whether that was a preordained result.
***
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a collection of three previously-published novellas concerning Ser Duncan the Tall, a seven-foot knight known as Dunk, and his squire Egg, who is more than he appears. Those novellas are The Hedge Knight, The Sworn Sword, and The Mystery Knight. All three take place roughly a century before the events of A Game of Thrones.
Though all three mini-tales have been published elsewhere, A Knight of the Seven Kingdom repackages them into chronological order, so that they read rather seamlessly as a single work. It has also been marvelously illustrated by Gary Gianni, with pen-and-ink drawings every few pages. Depending on your taste, this might add some real value.
At 355 pages, A Knight of the Seven Kingdom is a very short novel by Martin’s standards. Frankly, everything about this is below Martin’s standards.
***
The three stories are of varying quality. Hewing to generalities, The Hedge Knight is sort of an introduction to Dunk, giving us a bit of his background and character as he attends a tourney at Ashford Meadow. Maybe your mileage will vary, but as I read it, I thought to myself another tourney? After reading about the Tourney of the Hand, and hearing so much about the Great Tourney at Harrenhal, this simply didn't make an impression. This setting has been done, and done much better, elsewhere in the series.
The second novella, The Sworn Sword, is dull. It took me awhile to push through it. Dunk and Egg are in Dorne, and get involved in a minor squabble over water between two houses. If riparian rights are your thing, this story will be right in your wheelhouse. I found nothing inherently interesting about it. There wasn’t any good action, any bad sex, or any funny dialogue. Of course, if you like gleaning bits and pieces of mythology – here, there is a lot of talk of the Blackfyre Rebellion – this might be your cup of Dornish red. I’m looking for more. World building is great, as long as it’s in service of a larger storytelling purpose. Given my limits on consuming information, though, I’m not out to collect trivia on a made-up place.
The final story – The Mystery Knight – is pretty good. It is the one story that broadens the scope, and hints at real stakes. Unsurprisingly, as in many of A Song of Ice & Fire’s best moments, it is set during a wedding. At that, I will say no more.
***
I’m in the minority when it comes to A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. There is no doubt I opened these pages with more than a touch of bitterness at the long – now likely fruitless – wait for the sixth book of A Song of Ice & Fire. Leaving this aside, though, there are still some genuine issues with Dunk and Egg that are worth noting.
To begin, Dunk is an uninspired central character. He is tall, he is strong, and as drawn by Gary Gianni, he looks like Fabio. He is also dumb. Dunk the Lunk is the nickname that Dunk has bestowed upon himself. That’s a problem when we’re dealing with the protagonist, with whom we spend almost every page. He is a dullard, he is slow, he does not say intelligent things, he does not have clear thoughts. He is a plodding bore. That might be fine for a secondary character. But he’s the main attraction, without any opportunities to cut away to other viewpoints. It’s not even worth comparing the complexities and arcs taken by characters like Jaime, Tyrion, Sansa, or Arya to Ser Duncan the Tall, since they are not on the same planet in terms of depth, dimension, and charisma.
***
Next, A Knight of the Seven Kingdom is beset by lazy writing. Martin is a genius, with certain unimpeachable literary skills. A Storm of Swords is one of the best books I’ve ever read. It’s a genre-transcending classic. Bury it in the sand and wait a thousand years, and I’m sure the sentient robots who discover it will anoint it an epic of the ages. That said, when we talk about Martin as a great writer, we are not necessarily saying he is a prose stylist. He is an excellent plotter. He creates rich and layered characters. He knows how to execute an unforgettable set-piece, whether that is an unforeseen twist, an unexpected death, or a cinematic battle. Yet he relies on a lot of writerly crutches, and falls back on patterns, motifs, and phrases. You tend not to focus on these during A Song of Ice & Fire because the expansiveness of his canvas dilutes these tics. Here, in such a short work, they really jumped out. For instance, every other thing Dunk says to Egg is a variation of “I’m going to clout your ear.” Like, get another threat, dude.
**
Finally, the joy of A Song of Ice & Fire is that it is huge. It sprawls. It is like an oil slick, rapidly expanding. There are turns upon twists that are threaded into switchbacks. There are so many details. Details piled atop details. Details all the way down. And the stakes! The stakes are so high. The fate of the world, and all that.
A Song of Ice & Fire is indulgent and immersive. It wraps its arms around you in a bear hug and refuses to let you go until you acknowledge that you are living in this world, and that you can no longer tell if it is fiction. How can it be fake when its history goes back so far? You don’t get that feeling with the novellas. The novellas are trifling things. How can upstream water rights or a middling tourney compare to White Walkers? That’s a rhetorical question. They can’t.
***
At this point, we’ve been waiting so long for The Winds of Winter that it has almost become passe to complain about it. All the argument about what Martin “owes” his readers have been talked to death. Ultimately, he owes us nothing, and we owe him nothing, save the purchase price on his next project.
Furthermore, it’s hard to begrudge Martin his success. If he wants to watch the Jets, blog on LiveJournal, and go to conventions, more power to him. He’s earned a fortune that’s his to spend.
It is a shame, though. A Song of Ice & Fire is Martin’s legacy. It’s the first line on his obituary. It’ll be chiseled on his tombstone. When he is gone, it will be the thing that endures. As Tywin Lannister would tell him, it’s an accomplishment that will last a thousand years, or at least a century or two. If he completes it, that is. If he does not – it will disappear. No one remembers a story without an ending.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is an amuse-bouche, something to chew on while the main course is finished. I found it hard to enjoy, though, when the completion of that main course is so uncertain, and as the actuarial tables start to indicate that it will never be served.
- George R.R. Martin, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms
I am weak. And in my weakness, I finally broke down and purchased George R.R. Martin’s A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. It sat on my shelf for a while, mocking me and my lack of self-control. I meant to continue ignoring it. But then the final episodes of HBO’s Game of Thrones came and went, and the withdrawal set in. It set in bad. I had to crack the cover; I had to stop the shakes.
I didn't want to, you see? Really I didn't.
I don’t like encouraging bad behavior. I did not want to be a part – however infinitesimally small – of goading Martin into further digressions. Like millions of others, I just want him to finish A Song of Ice & Fire, a series that I love and that has – in a very real way – broadened my view of the power of books. Before Martin came along, I never saw myself as the kind of guy who liked dragon stories. Martin made me care. He made me care very, very much.
So I read it. And it underwhelmed me. I will leave it up to you whether that was a preordained result.
***
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a collection of three previously-published novellas concerning Ser Duncan the Tall, a seven-foot knight known as Dunk, and his squire Egg, who is more than he appears. Those novellas are The Hedge Knight, The Sworn Sword, and The Mystery Knight. All three take place roughly a century before the events of A Game of Thrones.
Though all three mini-tales have been published elsewhere, A Knight of the Seven Kingdom repackages them into chronological order, so that they read rather seamlessly as a single work. It has also been marvelously illustrated by Gary Gianni, with pen-and-ink drawings every few pages. Depending on your taste, this might add some real value.
At 355 pages, A Knight of the Seven Kingdom is a very short novel by Martin’s standards. Frankly, everything about this is below Martin’s standards.
***
The three stories are of varying quality. Hewing to generalities, The Hedge Knight is sort of an introduction to Dunk, giving us a bit of his background and character as he attends a tourney at Ashford Meadow. Maybe your mileage will vary, but as I read it, I thought to myself another tourney? After reading about the Tourney of the Hand, and hearing so much about the Great Tourney at Harrenhal, this simply didn't make an impression. This setting has been done, and done much better, elsewhere in the series.
The second novella, The Sworn Sword, is dull. It took me awhile to push through it. Dunk and Egg are in Dorne, and get involved in a minor squabble over water between two houses. If riparian rights are your thing, this story will be right in your wheelhouse. I found nothing inherently interesting about it. There wasn’t any good action, any bad sex, or any funny dialogue. Of course, if you like gleaning bits and pieces of mythology – here, there is a lot of talk of the Blackfyre Rebellion – this might be your cup of Dornish red. I’m looking for more. World building is great, as long as it’s in service of a larger storytelling purpose. Given my limits on consuming information, though, I’m not out to collect trivia on a made-up place.
The final story – The Mystery Knight – is pretty good. It is the one story that broadens the scope, and hints at real stakes. Unsurprisingly, as in many of A Song of Ice & Fire’s best moments, it is set during a wedding. At that, I will say no more.
***
I’m in the minority when it comes to A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. There is no doubt I opened these pages with more than a touch of bitterness at the long – now likely fruitless – wait for the sixth book of A Song of Ice & Fire. Leaving this aside, though, there are still some genuine issues with Dunk and Egg that are worth noting.
To begin, Dunk is an uninspired central character. He is tall, he is strong, and as drawn by Gary Gianni, he looks like Fabio. He is also dumb. Dunk the Lunk is the nickname that Dunk has bestowed upon himself. That’s a problem when we’re dealing with the protagonist, with whom we spend almost every page. He is a dullard, he is slow, he does not say intelligent things, he does not have clear thoughts. He is a plodding bore. That might be fine for a secondary character. But he’s the main attraction, without any opportunities to cut away to other viewpoints. It’s not even worth comparing the complexities and arcs taken by characters like Jaime, Tyrion, Sansa, or Arya to Ser Duncan the Tall, since they are not on the same planet in terms of depth, dimension, and charisma.
***
Next, A Knight of the Seven Kingdom is beset by lazy writing. Martin is a genius, with certain unimpeachable literary skills. A Storm of Swords is one of the best books I’ve ever read. It’s a genre-transcending classic. Bury it in the sand and wait a thousand years, and I’m sure the sentient robots who discover it will anoint it an epic of the ages. That said, when we talk about Martin as a great writer, we are not necessarily saying he is a prose stylist. He is an excellent plotter. He creates rich and layered characters. He knows how to execute an unforgettable set-piece, whether that is an unforeseen twist, an unexpected death, or a cinematic battle. Yet he relies on a lot of writerly crutches, and falls back on patterns, motifs, and phrases. You tend not to focus on these during A Song of Ice & Fire because the expansiveness of his canvas dilutes these tics. Here, in such a short work, they really jumped out. For instance, every other thing Dunk says to Egg is a variation of “I’m going to clout your ear.” Like, get another threat, dude.
**
Finally, the joy of A Song of Ice & Fire is that it is huge. It sprawls. It is like an oil slick, rapidly expanding. There are turns upon twists that are threaded into switchbacks. There are so many details. Details piled atop details. Details all the way down. And the stakes! The stakes are so high. The fate of the world, and all that.
A Song of Ice & Fire is indulgent and immersive. It wraps its arms around you in a bear hug and refuses to let you go until you acknowledge that you are living in this world, and that you can no longer tell if it is fiction. How can it be fake when its history goes back so far? You don’t get that feeling with the novellas. The novellas are trifling things. How can upstream water rights or a middling tourney compare to White Walkers? That’s a rhetorical question. They can’t.
***
At this point, we’ve been waiting so long for The Winds of Winter that it has almost become passe to complain about it. All the argument about what Martin “owes” his readers have been talked to death. Ultimately, he owes us nothing, and we owe him nothing, save the purchase price on his next project.
Furthermore, it’s hard to begrudge Martin his success. If he wants to watch the Jets, blog on LiveJournal, and go to conventions, more power to him. He’s earned a fortune that’s his to spend.
It is a shame, though. A Song of Ice & Fire is Martin’s legacy. It’s the first line on his obituary. It’ll be chiseled on his tombstone. When he is gone, it will be the thing that endures. As Tywin Lannister would tell him, it’s an accomplishment that will last a thousand years, or at least a century or two. If he completes it, that is. If he does not – it will disappear. No one remembers a story without an ending.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is an amuse-bouche, something to chew on while the main course is finished. I found it hard to enjoy, though, when the completion of that main course is so uncertain, and as the actuarial tables start to indicate that it will never be served.
February 22, 2018
“Dunk the lunk, thick as a castle wall.”
I thoroughly enjoyed these three novellas. It was great to return to Westeros, one hundred years before the events of ASoIaF. We follow Dunk, a hedge knight risen up by an old knight with no heirs. He gets himself a squire named Egg, who unbeknownst to him is Prince Aegon - one of the Targaryen Princes.
“Oak and iron guard me well, or else I’m dead and doomed to hell.”
We see Dunk get himself into all kinds of scrapes, including a trial of seven as well as numerous other fights. He is a great hero to follow and I loved recognising the names of houses from A Song of Ice and Fire.
But what really stood out in this book were the illustrations. They were amazing and really brought the stories and characters to life.
“A head’s a head. They all look the same after a few days on a spike.”
With much of the gruesomeness and swearing included in A Song of Ice and Fire; this book helped in my suffering wait for the Winds of Winter. Highly recommend.
The summers have been shorter since the last dragon died, and the winters longer and crueler.”
I thoroughly enjoyed these three novellas. It was great to return to Westeros, one hundred years before the events of ASoIaF. We follow Dunk, a hedge knight risen up by an old knight with no heirs. He gets himself a squire named Egg, who unbeknownst to him is Prince Aegon - one of the Targaryen Princes.
“Oak and iron guard me well, or else I’m dead and doomed to hell.”
We see Dunk get himself into all kinds of scrapes, including a trial of seven as well as numerous other fights. He is a great hero to follow and I loved recognising the names of houses from A Song of Ice and Fire.
But what really stood out in this book were the illustrations. They were amazing and really brought the stories and characters to life.
“A head’s a head. They all look the same after a few days on a spike.”
With much of the gruesomeness and swearing included in A Song of Ice and Fire; this book helped in my suffering wait for the Winds of Winter. Highly recommend.
The summers have been shorter since the last dragon died, and the winters longer and crueler.”
April 15, 2023
Update April 2023
: In which HBO learns no lessons and commissions yet another unfinished GRRM series for a show in which he'll be a writer and producer, and this long-suffering fan lets out a pained sigh.
This isn't a new series of novellas but rather a collection of the three existing books featuring Ser Duncan the Tall, a hugely clumsy and hugely lovable seventeen-year-old hedge knight...
... and his sharp-tongued little squire, nicknamed Egg for obvious reasons (look at his name, and then look at his bald head):
The stories themselves are old favourites in the ASOIAF fandom, no need to describe or review them, and besides we all know everyone bought this edition because of the art by Gary Gianni. It's known!
Mr Gianni, who also did the 2014 A Song of Ice and Fire calendar with a dozen choice scenes from the books, here has produced a grand total of 160 illustrations, all in black and white inking, some quite simple and minimalist and others so detailed and intricate, in a beautiful style that calls to memory the old-school chivalry graphic novel "Prince Valiant" by Hal Foster, which is surely not a coincidence because Gary Gianni undertook the continuation of the franchise after Foster's death, though coloured and not inked as the story used to be in the beginning. And Martin is a fan as well. I am very pleased with this resemblance, because I am a fan of "Prince Valiant" myself, and the tone of that story is quite fitting for Duncan, one of the few true knights that Martin has created and miraculously not killed (. . . yet).
The best illustrations are, unsurprisingly, for the first story, entitled "The Hedge Knight," which is also the one that has the higher number of drawings. It's also my favourite of the novellas, and it was a pleasure to see all the iconic scenes illustrated. Speaking of iconic scenes, Gianni didn't overlook even the naked huntress dream! Fans will remember which one I mean. That book, the second novella "The Sworn Sword" is the one that has the more intimate illustrations, and the third one, "The Mystery Knight," has the next best illustrations after the first novella, in my opinion.
Some of the artist's interpretations were disappointing, which was to be expected because there are some scenes that were different for me in my head, such as the scenes with Dunk and the Fiddler. And other small details were a surprise, such as Ser Duncan's appearance, in particular I found his nose was strangely button-like, that might be a matter of style in truth (and Prince Valiant had the same kind of nose, I seem to recall) and it gives him an air of innocent youth at odds with his big-boned 7-foot tall body. I had a bigger issue with the depiction of Tanselle Too-Tall, who in Gianni's interpretation doesn't seem tall at all, and that was grating because . . . there's a reason for why she has the moniker Too-Tall and her height is plot-relevant.
This is a book for fantasy fans and chivalry-epic lovers to have, both for the stories and for the great art.
This isn't a new series of novellas but rather a collection of the three existing books featuring Ser Duncan the Tall, a hugely clumsy and hugely lovable seventeen-year-old hedge knight...
... and his sharp-tongued little squire, nicknamed Egg for obvious reasons (look at his name, and then look at his bald head):
The stories themselves are old favourites in the ASOIAF fandom, no need to describe or review them, and besides we all know everyone bought this edition because of the art by Gary Gianni. It's known!
Mr Gianni, who also did the 2014 A Song of Ice and Fire calendar with a dozen choice scenes from the books, here has produced a grand total of 160 illustrations, all in black and white inking, some quite simple and minimalist and others so detailed and intricate, in a beautiful style that calls to memory the old-school chivalry graphic novel "Prince Valiant" by Hal Foster, which is surely not a coincidence because Gary Gianni undertook the continuation of the franchise after Foster's death, though coloured and not inked as the story used to be in the beginning. And Martin is a fan as well. I am very pleased with this resemblance, because I am a fan of "Prince Valiant" myself, and the tone of that story is quite fitting for Duncan, one of the few true knights that Martin has created and miraculously not killed (. . . yet).
The best illustrations are, unsurprisingly, for the first story, entitled "The Hedge Knight," which is also the one that has the higher number of drawings. It's also my favourite of the novellas, and it was a pleasure to see all the iconic scenes illustrated. Speaking of iconic scenes, Gianni didn't overlook even the naked huntress dream! Fans will remember which one I mean. That book, the second novella "The Sworn Sword" is the one that has the more intimate illustrations, and the third one, "The Mystery Knight," has the next best illustrations after the first novella, in my opinion.
Some of the artist's interpretations were disappointing, which was to be expected because there are some scenes that were different for me in my head, such as the scenes with Dunk and the Fiddler. And other small details were a surprise, such as Ser Duncan's appearance, in particular I found his nose was strangely button-like, that might be a matter of style in truth (and Prince Valiant had the same kind of nose, I seem to recall) and it gives him an air of innocent youth at odds with his big-boned 7-foot tall body. I had a bigger issue with the depiction of Tanselle Too-Tall, who in Gianni's interpretation doesn't seem tall at all, and that was grating because . . . there's a reason for why she has the moniker Too-Tall and her height is plot-relevant.
This is a book for fantasy fans and chivalry-epic lovers to have, both for the stories and for the great art.
November 7, 2015
I'm not fond of novellas or short stories. I always end up hating them because of the length. It's like someone telling you a summarized version of a detailed story. This one on the other hand is one of the exceptions to the hatred. It's not a shock though that Martin can make me enjoy something that I typically hate.
This book contains 3 novellas about the adventures of Dunk and Egg. A hedge knight and his squire seeking higher status. Martin is known for his tendency to add in a bunch of plot twists, and the 3 novellas proved no different. The ending was great, because it left me wanting for more and wanting to know who did what. I liked how the unexpected turn of events didn't seem like it was written just for the sake of having a plot twist.
The characters were beyond amazing. Dunk and Egg were perfectly written, and developed quite nicely in the end. I can't express how well Martin creates characters. It was most evident in his A Song of Ice and Fire series when I read the first 5 books, but now he proved that he can write amazing new characters. What I enjoyed most about Dunk was that he was a loser. He's not someone who was given everything. He had to work his way to get to the top, and the hardships didn't stop him. I don't hate powerful characters (Like the Starks, for example), but it's refreshing to read about someone who is not of royalty. The journey of a normal boy into a hedge knight was truly entertaining. We all know that being a hedge knight doesn't even result to earning the respect of people. I know that Martin has a few more stories about Dunk and Egg, so hopefully in the future I'd read about Dunk being successful in his journey. Egg was also commendable, but I can't explain how without spoiling. It's better if you find out about the mystery of Egg on your own.
The setting is great, but that's a giveaway already if you've read the ASOIAF series. Westeros is truly unforgiving to the weak. It's great to read more about the fictional world that I've loved since A Game of Thrones. This is a minor detour into the main series, in which the sixth book is still unpublished.
Do I really need to talk about how great the writing is?
4.5/5 stars. If you're unfamiliar with Martin, then you'd better read ASOIAF first. That's just my opinion though, but it did help me enjoy these novellas more.
This book contains 3 novellas about the adventures of Dunk and Egg. A hedge knight and his squire seeking higher status. Martin is known for his tendency to add in a bunch of plot twists, and the 3 novellas proved no different. The ending was great, because it left me wanting for more and wanting to know who did what. I liked how the unexpected turn of events didn't seem like it was written just for the sake of having a plot twist.
The characters were beyond amazing. Dunk and Egg were perfectly written, and developed quite nicely in the end. I can't express how well Martin creates characters. It was most evident in his A Song of Ice and Fire series when I read the first 5 books, but now he proved that he can write amazing new characters. What I enjoyed most about Dunk was that he was a loser. He's not someone who was given everything. He had to work his way to get to the top, and the hardships didn't stop him. I don't hate powerful characters (Like the Starks, for example), but it's refreshing to read about someone who is not of royalty. The journey of a normal boy into a hedge knight was truly entertaining. We all know that being a hedge knight doesn't even result to earning the respect of people. I know that Martin has a few more stories about Dunk and Egg, so hopefully in the future I'd read about Dunk being successful in his journey. Egg was also commendable, but I can't explain how without spoiling. It's better if you find out about the mystery of Egg on your own.
The setting is great, but that's a giveaway already if you've read the ASOIAF series. Westeros is truly unforgiving to the weak. It's great to read more about the fictional world that I've loved since A Game of Thrones. This is a minor detour into the main series, in which the sixth book is still unpublished.
Do I really need to talk about how great the writing is?
4.5/5 stars. If you're unfamiliar with Martin, then you'd better read ASOIAF first. That's just my opinion though, but it did help me enjoy these novellas more.
February 3, 2019
Very entertaining.
George R. R. Martin provides some backstory and depth to his wildly popular Song of Ice and Fire series with this collection of three novellas about Dunc and Egg: a hedge knight and his squire.
The events in the three related and sequential novellas take place a hundred years before A Game of Thrones and there is still a Targaryen on the iron throne and the memory of the last dragon is still alive in and old man’s memory.
First published all together in 2013, with some snazzy illustrations by Gary Gianni, Martin gives us a different glimpse into Westeros than what is provided in GOT as we follow these two on some adventures. A hedge knight is similar to a knight errant in our history, a traveling, non-landed swordsman who hires out his services and participates in jousting tournaments. The hedge knight, though a real knight, is of the lowest order and the term itself is somewhat derogatory.
Our hero, Dunc, naming himself Ser Duncan the Tall – for lack of a better title - was taken from the squalid environs of Fleas Bottom in King’s Landing by a traveling hedge knight and made his squire. Before the old knight dies on the road, he has taught Dunc not just the skills of a squire, but also about chivalry and how to conduct himself as a proper knight should. Dunc’s tutelage seems to have taken hold better than some of the privileged richer classes we meet in the stories. Dunc, maybe not the sharpest tool in the shed, is nonetheless honorable and a very likeable protagonist and for his part trains his squire Egg in the same way.
The beginning scene, where the old knight has died and Dunc is alone, reminded me of the similar scene in the 2001 Heath Ledger film A Knight’s Tale.
Not just for GOT fans, this is an enjoyable read for the fantasy crowd.
George R. R. Martin provides some backstory and depth to his wildly popular Song of Ice and Fire series with this collection of three novellas about Dunc and Egg: a hedge knight and his squire.
The events in the three related and sequential novellas take place a hundred years before A Game of Thrones and there is still a Targaryen on the iron throne and the memory of the last dragon is still alive in and old man’s memory.
First published all together in 2013, with some snazzy illustrations by Gary Gianni, Martin gives us a different glimpse into Westeros than what is provided in GOT as we follow these two on some adventures. A hedge knight is similar to a knight errant in our history, a traveling, non-landed swordsman who hires out his services and participates in jousting tournaments. The hedge knight, though a real knight, is of the lowest order and the term itself is somewhat derogatory.
Our hero, Dunc, naming himself Ser Duncan the Tall – for lack of a better title - was taken from the squalid environs of Fleas Bottom in King’s Landing by a traveling hedge knight and made his squire. Before the old knight dies on the road, he has taught Dunc not just the skills of a squire, but also about chivalry and how to conduct himself as a proper knight should. Dunc’s tutelage seems to have taken hold better than some of the privileged richer classes we meet in the stories. Dunc, maybe not the sharpest tool in the shed, is nonetheless honorable and a very likeable protagonist and for his part trains his squire Egg in the same way.
The beginning scene, where the old knight has died and Dunc is alone, reminded me of the similar scene in the 2001 Heath Ledger film A Knight’s Tale.
Not just for GOT fans, this is an enjoyable read for the fantasy crowd.
October 12, 2025
This was great. It had so much of what made me fall in love with A Song of Ice and Fire.
Yes, there was only one point-of-view. And yes, the characters were not quite as fascinating as Tyrion and Lord Varys and Cersie etc. But they were very good.
The plot was far more of the focused adventure that a single book of modest size can sustain, but it did a great job of feeling as though it were unfolding in that same incredibly rich and complex world we got to know in the more famous series.
We get similar levels of heraldry-porn, along with the trademark focus on clothing, equipment, and food. All of which might bug me coming from a less able author, but that here just made me remember how I adored A Game of Thrones.
So - read it. I sat on this one for ages, and without good cause. In fact, I've had this fine illustrated hardcover for ten years! :o
Entirely by coincidence, there's an HBO series based on the books and coming in January. So read it now!
Join my Patreon
Join my 3-emails-a-year newsletter #prizes
.
Yes, there was only one point-of-view. And yes, the characters were not quite as fascinating as Tyrion and Lord Varys and Cersie etc. But they were very good.
The plot was far more of the focused adventure that a single book of modest size can sustain, but it did a great job of feeling as though it were unfolding in that same incredibly rich and complex world we got to know in the more famous series.
We get similar levels of heraldry-porn, along with the trademark focus on clothing, equipment, and food. All of which might bug me coming from a less able author, but that here just made me remember how I adored A Game of Thrones.
So - read it. I sat on this one for ages, and without good cause. In fact, I've had this fine illustrated hardcover for ten years! :o
Entirely by coincidence, there's an HBO series based on the books and coming in January. So read it now!
Join my Patreon
Join my 3-emails-a-year newsletter #prizes
.
February 6, 2017
Upozorenje:čitanje ove knjige izaziva nostalgiju i čežnju za svetom Vesterosa, te čitanju iste pristupite na sopstvenu odgovornost.
Ocena:4.5*
Sastavni deo ovog prikaza je i House Targaryen family tree :)
November 13, 2025
I reviewed ASOIAF over on my YouTube Channel I read ASOIAF in a month
A fun and enjoyable read. I really liked Dunk and Egg and the depth it added to the world of Westeros. A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms just shows off what wonderful prose GRRM has.
A fun and enjoyable read. I really liked Dunk and Egg and the depth it added to the world of Westeros. A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms just shows off what wonderful prose GRRM has.
October 14, 2025
„Колко очи има Блъдрейвън?“
„Рицарят на Седемте кралства“ е страхотна и може би най-приключенската книга на Джордж Мартин! Действието в нея се развива в познатия ни Вестерос, но близо век преди епичните събития в „Песен за огън и лед“... Тя се състои от три много увлекателни разказа, които описват вълнуващите приключения на странстващ рицар и неговия млад скуайър! Основната разлика с останалите книги от фентъзи поредицата е, че тук имаме силно изявени главни герои, каквито са Дънк и Ег. Авторът чудесно развива тези два персонажа, като между тях се заражда истинско приятелство.
На Железния трон по това време стои Дерон II Добрия, и животът във Вестерос е сравнително спокоен. Обаче настъпва времето на бунтовете на Блекфир и започват да се случват доста опасни събития. Забележителна личност от тази епоха също е загадъчният лорд Блъдрейвън...
Мисля, че „Рицарят на седемте кралства“ е супер подходящо четиво, както за феновете на „Песен за огън и лед“, така и за читателите, които за пръв път ще се докоснат до творчеството на Мартин!
„Рицарят на Седемте кралства“ е страхотна и може би най-приключенската книга на Джордж Мартин! Действието в нея се развива в познатия ни Вестерос, но близо век преди епичните събития в „Песен за огън и лед“... Тя се състои от три много увлекателни разказа, които описват вълнуващите приключения на странстващ рицар и неговия млад скуайър! Основната разлика с останалите книги от фентъзи поредицата е, че тук имаме силно изявени главни герои, каквито са Дънк и Ег. Авторът чудесно развива тези два персонажа, като между тях се заражда истинско приятелство.
На Железния трон по това време стои Дерон II Добрия, и животът във Вестерос е сравнително спокоен. Обаче настъпва времето на бунтовете на Блекфир и започват да се случват доста опасни събития. Забележителна личност от тази епоха също е загадъчният лорд Блъдрейвън...
Мисля, че „Рицарят на седемте кралства“ е супер подходящо четиво, както за феновете на „Песен за огън и лед“, така и за читателите, които за пръв път ще се докоснат до творчеството на Мартин!
August 28, 2024
It's been so long since I read the A Song of Ice and Fire books that I had forgotten what an incredible writer George RR Martin is.
These three novellas are fantastic. I loved each one. And you don't need to be familiar with the long series to enjoy them. The longer series overflows with point of view characters. Here, the writing stays tightly focused on hedge knight Dunk and his squire, and it's so great because of it.
My book even had lovely illustrations! I also tried out the audiobook and found the narrator to be great.
Just a phenomenal book all around, however you get to it. I'll be reading them again and again.
These three novellas are fantastic. I loved each one. And you don't need to be familiar with the long series to enjoy them. The longer series overflows with point of view characters. Here, the writing stays tightly focused on hedge knight Dunk and his squire, and it's so great because of it.
My book even had lovely illustrations! I also tried out the audiobook and found the narrator to be great.
Just a phenomenal book all around, however you get to it. I'll be reading them again and again.
October 20, 2015
www.melissa413readsalot.blogspot.com
I just love Dunk & Egg! I just finished reading the two graphic novels of The Hedge Knight and I had no idea this was the book form with a third story of the duo! I just put it on hold at the library because it's George R.R. Martin :) And a friend from GR told me after the fact what it was!
I know there has to be more to it then the graphic novels, but it seems like the book was the same. I loved the first two stories in this book, and the graphic novels. The third book is awesome! I really hope to see it in graphic novel soon.
This third one is called, The Mystery Knight. Dunk and Egg are just going along minding their own business when they meet some Knights on the road. They try to talk them into going to a royal wedding. They don't seem to be who they are and they don't seem trustworthy. Who is?
Dunk thinks.. well.. maybe he should go and try to win some money for him and Egg so they can be settled nicely for some time. This leads to a big crazy adventure that involves people that are not who they say they are, people getting killed or almost killed, eggs...dragon eggs :) ... more lies and a pretty good ending.
I had no idea how much I was going to fall in love with Dunk and Egg when I bought the first two graphic novels. Now I just want to read more and more. At the end of the book Mr. Martin says to look forward to more Dunk and Egg travels! Yay! Well, he said it better, but I digress.
I do want to add this book to my collection at some time and will eagerly await the graphic novel to the third story in this book and many more. Please... many more.
If you don't like Dunk and Egg, then there is something wrong with you.. so there. Dunk & Egg, sounds like Dunkin Donuts.. I digressed again! Anyhooo.....
I recommend to ALL George R.R. Martin fans, especially those that love the Game of Thrones as this is years before that time. Fin
I just love Dunk & Egg! I just finished reading the two graphic novels of The Hedge Knight and I had no idea this was the book form with a third story of the duo! I just put it on hold at the library because it's George R.R. Martin :) And a friend from GR told me after the fact what it was!
I know there has to be more to it then the graphic novels, but it seems like the book was the same. I loved the first two stories in this book, and the graphic novels. The third book is awesome! I really hope to see it in graphic novel soon.
This third one is called, The Mystery Knight. Dunk and Egg are just going along minding their own business when they meet some Knights on the road. They try to talk them into going to a royal wedding. They don't seem to be who they are and they don't seem trustworthy. Who is?
Dunk thinks.. well.. maybe he should go and try to win some money for him and Egg so they can be settled nicely for some time. This leads to a big crazy adventure that involves people that are not who they say they are, people getting killed or almost killed, eggs...dragon eggs :) ... more lies and a pretty good ending.
I had no idea how much I was going to fall in love with Dunk and Egg when I bought the first two graphic novels. Now I just want to read more and more. At the end of the book Mr. Martin says to look forward to more Dunk and Egg travels! Yay! Well, he said it better, but I digress.
I do want to add this book to my collection at some time and will eagerly await the graphic novel to the third story in this book and many more. Please... many more.
If you don't like Dunk and Egg, then there is something wrong with you.. so there. Dunk & Egg, sounds like Dunkin Donuts.. I digressed again! Anyhooo.....
I recommend to ALL George R.R. Martin fans, especially those that love the Game of Thrones as this is years before that time. Fin
May 6, 2017
"Kings rise and fall, and cows and smallfolk go about their business."
I never really planned to read this until I discovered it at the library a few days ago and picked it up. I told myself why not read something short by GRRM for once.
This book is a collection of three novellas, set in the Seven Kingdoms, a century before A Game of Thrones, while the Targaryens are still the ruling House in Westeros.
Characters:
Dunk, Ser Duncan the Tall, a hedge knight and his squire Egg, Aegon Targaryen (little brother of Aemon Targaryen, who we know from the Wall in ASOIAF) travel the Seven Kingdoms together. Dunk is a pretty plain character apart from his tallness. It's Egg who actually makes those novellas worth reading.
Plot:
A tournament, a trial, weapons. Lords, lordlings and smallfolk. Dragons, Lions and Stags. Love and death and marriage. A fair maid and a lady. Conspiracy, treason and heads on spikes. Another tournament, another trial and more weapons. And lots of plot twists. It will never once get boring.
Writing:
I can't really say anything about GRRMs writing. It may be smart and witty but never made me emotional. At times it get's repetitive and I could be spared the endless paragraphs about food and drinks and names that I will never remember and never be mentioned again.
I'm looking forward to reading more about Dunk and Egg, though I'd prefer to have The Winds of Winter to be honest.
Find more of my books on Instagram
I never really planned to read this until I discovered it at the library a few days ago and picked it up. I told myself why not read something short by GRRM for once.
This book is a collection of three novellas, set in the Seven Kingdoms, a century before A Game of Thrones, while the Targaryens are still the ruling House in Westeros.
Characters:
Dunk, Ser Duncan the Tall, a hedge knight and his squire Egg, Aegon Targaryen (little brother of Aemon Targaryen, who we know from the Wall in ASOIAF) travel the Seven Kingdoms together. Dunk is a pretty plain character apart from his tallness. It's Egg who actually makes those novellas worth reading.
Plot:
A tournament, a trial, weapons. Lords, lordlings and smallfolk. Dragons, Lions and Stags. Love and death and marriage. A fair maid and a lady. Conspiracy, treason and heads on spikes. Another tournament, another trial and more weapons. And lots of plot twists. It will never once get boring.
Writing:
I can't really say anything about GRRMs writing. It may be smart and witty but never made me emotional. At times it get's repetitive and I could be spared the endless paragraphs about food and drinks and names that I will never remember and never be mentioned again.
I'm looking forward to reading more about Dunk and Egg, though I'd prefer to have The Winds of Winter to be honest.
Find more of my books on Instagram
February 10, 2017
This is just what I was looking for! Old timey, good-doer knights and squires doin' good in an old timey setting!
I had picked up a fantasy book a few weeks ago that I hoped would satiate my current reading desires, but alas no. So I turned to George R.R. Martin. He's always a good bet. I like his writing style and I'm familiar with the world he's built. Sure, there's such a small amount of fantasy in his work that, aside from mention of dragons in this particular book, it could almost be called historical fiction for its similarity to the York and Tudor War of the Roses back in the 15th century.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a collection of three lengthy short stories that follow the adventures of a hedge knight and his squire. Any fan of the Song of Fire & Ice series will recognize many of the names dropped herein even though these stories are set about a hundred years prior.
So what you get are some fun action/adventure tales with a helping of Seven Kingdoms history. It's a well-balanced combination. Seldom was I inundated with one or bored with the other.
The stakes are high enough to make you care surprisingly deeply about the two main characters by the end of the book. There's good, solid tension through out. And yet, the stakes aren't "Save the World or Bust!!!" high, which is a nice departure from the epic fantasy of the day.
In summary, this is a very enjoyable distraction that will entertain the dickens out of Martin's fans!
PS: See my videogram book review of this here book by following this here link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ez7U7...
I had picked up a fantasy book a few weeks ago that I hoped would satiate my current reading desires, but alas no. So I turned to George R.R. Martin. He's always a good bet. I like his writing style and I'm familiar with the world he's built. Sure, there's such a small amount of fantasy in his work that, aside from mention of dragons in this particular book, it could almost be called historical fiction for its similarity to the York and Tudor War of the Roses back in the 15th century.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a collection of three lengthy short stories that follow the adventures of a hedge knight and his squire. Any fan of the Song of Fire & Ice series will recognize many of the names dropped herein even though these stories are set about a hundred years prior.
So what you get are some fun action/adventure tales with a helping of Seven Kingdoms history. It's a well-balanced combination. Seldom was I inundated with one or bored with the other.
The stakes are high enough to make you care surprisingly deeply about the two main characters by the end of the book. There's good, solid tension through out. And yet, the stakes aren't "Save the World or Bust!!!" high, which is a nice departure from the epic fantasy of the day.
In summary, this is a very enjoyable distraction that will entertain the dickens out of Martin's fans!
PS: See my videogram book review of this here book by following this here link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ez7U7...
April 15, 2017
This is my Book Of the Month- September 2016, with GR group- Nothing But Reading Challenges- Category: Sci-Fi/Fantasy BOM
"The story offered here takes place about a hundred years prior to the events described in A Game of Thrones"
This was my major concern before picking this up as I have yet to read the Game Of Throne Series (I have watched all the seasons diligently) but still did not want any thing spoiling my enjoyment of reading this series. So you can absolutely pick this up and enjoy the mention of names of all the famous houses that we have come to adore and hate!
This is a collection of 3 short stories involving Ser Dunkard The Tall i.e. Dunk and Egg (who becomes Dunk's squire). One of the strong points of these stories are the extremely likable protagonists.
These stories are available as independent books as well but I would recommend reading these in sequence and together for the maximum enjoyment. This book also has sketches as you read along.
**Mild Spoilers Ahead**
The first story is The Hedge Knight where we are first introduced to Dunk and how he comes to meet Egg. Near to the end of the story the true identity of Egg is revealed
The concept of Hedge Knight was new to me and I was fascinated with the hierarchy between knights of royal blood, Knights sworn to a lord and hedge knights...
I absolutely adored Dunk in this story. He was very unsure and always had doubts regarding himself but this made me adore him even more somehow. Some of his innermologues which are repeated throughout the three stories are-
"Dunk the lunk, thought he could be a knight"
"Dunk the lunk, thick as a castle wall."
There are some very violent moments in this story that made me squirm but by the end of this story I was a True campaigner of Ser Dunkard The Tall.
The second story -The Sworn Sword takes us further into the journey of Dunk and Egg. In this story it is truly confirmed what a Gallant and Noble knight Dunk truly is- "Oak and iron, guard me well, or else I'm dead, and doomed to hell"
We come across the Red and Black fight, the effect on the lords and we are introduced to one of the very interesting characters known as the Red Widow.
The last story- The Mystery Knight is the one filled with most twists. There is a competition and a Dragon Egg to be won but that is not the main focus of this story. This is more filled with political intrigue than any of the other stories
Dunk and Egg are solid together - Lord Cockshaw and the Fiddler had brought grooms to tend their horses, cooks to feed them, squires to clean their armor, guards to defend them. Dunk has Egg
There is also the dreaded Bloodraven who finally makes an appearance
"How many eyes does Lord Bloodraven have? the riddle went. A thousand eyes, and one"
I just wanted to read more about Dunk and Egg and hope there are more stories about them.
"The story offered here takes place about a hundred years prior to the events described in A Game of Thrones"
This was my major concern before picking this up as I have yet to read the Game Of Throne Series (I have watched all the seasons diligently) but still did not want any thing spoiling my enjoyment of reading this series. So you can absolutely pick this up and enjoy the mention of names of all the famous houses that we have come to adore and hate!
This is a collection of 3 short stories involving Ser Dunkard The Tall i.e. Dunk and Egg (who becomes Dunk's squire). One of the strong points of these stories are the extremely likable protagonists.
These stories are available as independent books as well but I would recommend reading these in sequence and together for the maximum enjoyment. This book also has sketches as you read along.
**Mild Spoilers Ahead**
The first story is The Hedge Knight where we are first introduced to Dunk and how he comes to meet Egg. Near to the end of the story the true identity of Egg is revealed
The concept of Hedge Knight was new to me and I was fascinated with the hierarchy between knights of royal blood, Knights sworn to a lord and hedge knights...
I absolutely adored Dunk in this story. He was very unsure and always had doubts regarding himself but this made me adore him even more somehow. Some of his innermologues which are repeated throughout the three stories are-
"Dunk the lunk, thought he could be a knight"
"Dunk the lunk, thick as a castle wall."
There are some very violent moments in this story that made me squirm but by the end of this story I was a True campaigner of Ser Dunkard The Tall.
The second story -The Sworn Sword takes us further into the journey of Dunk and Egg. In this story it is truly confirmed what a Gallant and Noble knight Dunk truly is- "Oak and iron, guard me well, or else I'm dead, and doomed to hell"
We come across the Red and Black fight, the effect on the lords and we are introduced to one of the very interesting characters known as the Red Widow.
The last story- The Mystery Knight is the one filled with most twists. There is a competition and a Dragon Egg to be won but that is not the main focus of this story. This is more filled with political intrigue than any of the other stories
Dunk and Egg are solid together - Lord Cockshaw and the Fiddler had brought grooms to tend their horses, cooks to feed them, squires to clean their armor, guards to defend them. Dunk has Egg
There is also the dreaded Bloodraven who finally makes an appearance
"How many eyes does Lord Bloodraven have? the riddle went. A thousand eyes, and one"
I just wanted to read more about Dunk and Egg and hope there are more stories about them.
October 8, 2021
Tres relatos ambientados un siglo antes de los hechos de Canción de hielo y fuego.
Narran las aventuras de Dunk (Ser Duncan), un reciente caballero errante, y Egg, su escudero.
Son tres relatos con una trama sencilla, personajes con mucho encanto y muy entretenidos.
Narran las aventuras de Dunk (Ser Duncan), un reciente caballero errante, y Egg, su escudero.
Son tres relatos con una trama sencilla, personajes con mucho encanto y muy entretenidos.
September 20, 2023
My favourite part of the ASOIAF world is how well developed the history and world is, and I loved that A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms started to embellish some characters that are reference in the core series.
However, I'm not generally a short story person so while I loved the lore, the story itself wasn't my favourite.
However, I'm not generally a short story person so while I loved the lore, the story itself wasn't my favourite.
February 19, 2018
George R.R. Martin could write a shopping list and publish it and I would still probably give it five stars!
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a collection of three stories set in Westeros, the same fictional lands as featured in A Song of Ice and Fire series, but set over one hundred years previously. This just exemplifies that no-one can world build like Martin can world build! The in-depth knowledge of the land and the familial and ancestral history of the multitude of characters portrayed is just staggering. This book felt like it had an almost political edge to it on times as it relayed the countless wars, feuds and alliances between the horde of great (and not so great) houses. If you have ever read any Martin before you know that he likes his characters! This book is no different.
House Targaryen sits on the throne but we don't view the world from some little lordling's perspective, but from that of a hedge knight. And an admittedly poor one at that. Dunk, or Ser Duncan the Tall, leads us through the world, and it is through his eyes and his experiences that we are introduced to names and places and people that form part of the ancient backstory for A Game of Thrones . That alone was enough to give it five stars, but it was the method used to portray this history that I most liked.
The style of narrative was different to what I expected: the reader is offered the limited perspective of only one character, we are distanced from the great houses and given the perspective from one with a lower social standing, and more is withheld from us, allowing us no further knowledge and understanding than what our protagonist can offer us.
I found myself liking these aspects. It had a different feel to it than that of its renowned predecessor, giving the book its own separate identity. And yet the same myths and tales still permeated the story. The same places are visited and great names spoken of. The same houses still rule and the same houses still serve. This book doesn't feel new; it feels like coming home.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a collection of three stories set in Westeros, the same fictional lands as featured in A Song of Ice and Fire series, but set over one hundred years previously. This just exemplifies that no-one can world build like Martin can world build! The in-depth knowledge of the land and the familial and ancestral history of the multitude of characters portrayed is just staggering. This book felt like it had an almost political edge to it on times as it relayed the countless wars, feuds and alliances between the horde of great (and not so great) houses. If you have ever read any Martin before you know that he likes his characters! This book is no different.
House Targaryen sits on the throne but we don't view the world from some little lordling's perspective, but from that of a hedge knight. And an admittedly poor one at that. Dunk, or Ser Duncan the Tall, leads us through the world, and it is through his eyes and his experiences that we are introduced to names and places and people that form part of the ancient backstory for A Game of Thrones . That alone was enough to give it five stars, but it was the method used to portray this history that I most liked.
The style of narrative was different to what I expected: the reader is offered the limited perspective of only one character, we are distanced from the great houses and given the perspective from one with a lower social standing, and more is withheld from us, allowing us no further knowledge and understanding than what our protagonist can offer us.
I found myself liking these aspects. It had a different feel to it than that of its renowned predecessor, giving the book its own separate identity. And yet the same myths and tales still permeated the story. The same places are visited and great names spoken of. The same houses still rule and the same houses still serve. This book doesn't feel new; it feels like coming home.
September 30, 2025
گوش دادن به صدا و این داستان توی این روزا خیلی برام لذت بخش بود
October 14, 2025
В тази книга са събрани три разказа с главни герои Дънк и неговия скуайър Ег.
Първият разказ в сборника - "Странстващият рицар", е може би най-любимото ми фентъзи произведение, а аз съм прочел доста такива през годините. :) Отлично въведение е в света и интригите на Седемте кралства, които продължават години след това в поредицата "Песен за огън и лед", която все още стои незавършена.
Многократно съм препрочитал първия разказ, винаги с огромно удоволствие!
P.S. Няма да издавам, в кои важни персонaжи за Вестерос на Таргариените ще се превърнат странстващите приключенци, за да има елемент на изненада за четящите ги за първи път.
Първият разказ в сборника - "Странстващият рицар", е може би най-любимото ми фентъзи произведение, а аз съм прочел доста такива през годините. :) Отлично въведение е в света и интригите на Седемте кралства, които продължават години след това в поредицата "Песен за огън и лед", която все още стои незавършена.
Многократно съм препрочитал първия разказ, винаги с огромно удоволствие!
P.S. Няма да издавам, в кои важни персонaжи за Вестерос на Таргариените ще се превърнат странстващите приключенци, за да има елемент на изненада за четящите ги за първи път.
October 17, 2024
4.5 stars 🌟🌟🌟🌟💫!
Dunk and Egg by George R.R. Martin is a delightful dive into a world of knights and quests. The tale tells of Dunk, a tall and true knight, and Egg, his eager squire. Their bond builds as they brave battles and bold deeds.
Martin’s mastery makes the story sing. His words weave a web of wonder, with each scene set in vivid hues. The plot pulses with pace, pulling the reader from one page to the next. Dunk’s deeds and Egg’s growth grip the heart and hold the mind.
The charm of the tale lies in its simple yet strong style. Martin’s knack for names and places paints a rich realm. On the flip side much too many names of knights and the shape and color of their arms was not easy to keep straight. The book brims with brave acts and bright dreams, making it a must-read for fans of fantasy.
Dunk and Egg is a gem, a grand gift from a great writer. It stands as a shining star in the sky of stories.
Dunk and Egg by George R.R. Martin is a delightful dive into a world of knights and quests. The tale tells of Dunk, a tall and true knight, and Egg, his eager squire. Their bond builds as they brave battles and bold deeds.
Martin’s mastery makes the story sing. His words weave a web of wonder, with each scene set in vivid hues. The plot pulses with pace, pulling the reader from one page to the next. Dunk’s deeds and Egg’s growth grip the heart and hold the mind.
The charm of the tale lies in its simple yet strong style. Martin’s knack for names and places paints a rich realm. On the flip side much too many names of knights and the shape and color of their arms was not easy to keep straight. The book brims with brave acts and bright dreams, making it a must-read for fans of fantasy.
Dunk and Egg is a gem, a grand gift from a great writer. It stands as a shining star in the sky of stories.
August 25, 2017
I have read the comic version of this but I ran across a particularly nice illustrated copy and bought it. I am glad I did. This is a very entertaining tale. It is slightly more light hearted in overall tone, but don't let good ol' Dunk and adorable Egg fool you-this is still the world of Game of Thrones. NOTHING is what it seems. There is violence and maiming a plenty.
One Hundred years before the events of the Game of Thrones timeline there was a hedge knight named Ser Duncan. Ser Duncan finds a young bald boy named Egg and makes him his squire. So begins their journey to make a name for themselves. Along the way they run into Lords, Princes and many other famous houses from the GOT story. Just 100 years before. That snot nosed boy being bounced on Lord Frey's lap? Mostly likely the old, dying Lord Frey of the GOT timeline. But you will recognize some of the famous names.
Broken into three short novellas it shows Ser Duncan the Tall and his adventures in a tournament held by Lord Ashford- this is really the origin story of Ser Duncan the Tall. You also find out about Egg.
The second story is a little after those events and it's a very good one. I enjoyed it because it shows the complexity of being a minor noble house in these times. The aspect of honor really is important in this story and it shows what kind of knight Ser Duncan is.
The Third story can really be called the Second Blackfyre Rebellion. If that means nothing to you then good-you'll learn all about the First one in this short story. You will also find out how Ser Duncan and Egg were able to foil a plot to overthrow the King.
All of the stories were written with the GRR Martin flare and are quite enjoyable. The artists Gary Gianni is to be lauded. I loved his artwork. I wish they could have been in color but the black and white illustration are great representations of the events and they are plentiful-I loved that! A great book for any GOT fan. A great book for someone who has no idea what GOT is-this might make you one.
One Hundred years before the events of the Game of Thrones timeline there was a hedge knight named Ser Duncan. Ser Duncan finds a young bald boy named Egg and makes him his squire. So begins their journey to make a name for themselves. Along the way they run into Lords, Princes and many other famous houses from the GOT story. Just 100 years before. That snot nosed boy being bounced on Lord Frey's lap? Mostly likely the old, dying Lord Frey of the GOT timeline. But you will recognize some of the famous names.
Broken into three short novellas it shows Ser Duncan the Tall and his adventures in a tournament held by Lord Ashford- this is really the origin story of Ser Duncan the Tall. You also find out about Egg.
The second story is a little after those events and it's a very good one. I enjoyed it because it shows the complexity of being a minor noble house in these times. The aspect of honor really is important in this story and it shows what kind of knight Ser Duncan is.
The Third story can really be called the Second Blackfyre Rebellion. If that means nothing to you then good-you'll learn all about the First one in this short story. You will also find out how Ser Duncan and Egg were able to foil a plot to overthrow the King.
All of the stories were written with the GRR Martin flare and are quite enjoyable. The artists Gary Gianni is to be lauded. I loved his artwork. I wish they could have been in color but the black and white illustration are great representations of the events and they are plentiful-I loved that! A great book for any GOT fan. A great book for someone who has no idea what GOT is-this might make you one.
September 24, 2017
Final: 4.60
Es el primer libro de George que termino, si todavía me falta un poco de "El Mundo de Hielo y Fuego" pero se les digo, George escribe de maravillas😻👌, su manera de contar historias es increíble, ya me sentía como un pinche caballero weiiiiii!!!! Really, cada parte de la historia es simplemente enlazador, tengo que admitir que el ritmo no fue lo mejor, en algunas partes se tornó un poco lento, pero en general estuvo muy bien👌. Me prometo a mi mismo terminar la enciclopedia de Westeros la otra semana, mejor digo a fin de mes para ser más realistas XD😅😂🤣.
Es el primer libro de George que termino, si todavía me falta un poco de "El Mundo de Hielo y Fuego" pero se les digo, George escribe de maravillas😻👌, su manera de contar historias es increíble, ya me sentía como un pinche caballero weiiiiii!!!! Really, cada parte de la historia es simplemente enlazador, tengo que admitir que el ritmo no fue lo mejor, en algunas partes se tornó un poco lento, pero en general estuvo muy bien👌. Me prometo a mi mismo terminar la enciclopedia de Westeros la otra semana, mejor digo a fin de mes para ser más realistas XD😅😂🤣.
May 20, 2019
I want more.
January 12, 2016
I initially considered holding the fifth star hostage until George R. R. Martin finished The Winds of Winter but I adored these stories so much I just couldn't do it.
These three novellas take place roughly one hundred years before A Game of Thrones. So all the characters we know and love (and love to hate) have yet to be born, the Targaryens still sit on the Iron Throne, and the small folk are exploited by the nobles (so that much isn't different). Instead of seeing Westeros through the eyes of the Haves (sworn knights, great lords, nobles), we get to see it through the Have-Nots, specifically those of a hedge knight, Ser Duncan the Tall. Unlike the sworn knights who serve a lord, hedge knights travel, seeking service where they can and more often sleeping under hedges than under a roof. Of course don't tell them that.
If there is one thing GRRM does well is develop and explain feudal ties and relationships (or maybe he just likes doodling cool house banners). This was very apparent in these stories as Martin does a deft job dropping political developments and themes into the narrative that is ostensibly about the travels of Dunk and Egg. I harbor a suspicion that the entire purpose of the Song of Ice and Fire series is to show how terrible monarchies and aristocracies are.
In this case Dunk and Egg are confronted on several occasions by the fall out from the Blackfyre Rebellion*. The nickel tour is this: The Blackfyre Rebellion was a civil war in Westeros over who should succeed to the Iron Throne (Some old dead king gave a sword to one son instead of another, that was the start of it. And now I'm standing here, and poor Roger's in his grave.). The realm was split, one side (the Blackfyres) lost and several members of that family fled Westeros, looming as a threat to the victorious side. As with all civil wars, one group ends up backing the wrong side and faces the consequences, most notably losing land, titles, holdings, respect of the victors, and being forced to provide hostages to the victor's side. But just because there was a winner doesn't mean the losers were content to just go back to the status quo ante. All that politics aside, even though the rebellion occurred fifteen years prior to the events of these novellas the repercussions still echo throughout the realm.
There is a great balance of fights, character development, narrative progression, and political intrigue. I got a much better view on the lives of the small folk and lesser knights (not surprisingly: just as sucky as I previously assumed) as well as the challenges that the vast majority of Westeros must deal with, small folk and petty noble alike. Heck, one novella revolves around water rights between two nobles of a stream during a drought (and we also see one of the many repercussions of the Blackfyre Rebellion).
But the heart of these books is the relationship between Dunk (Ser Duncan the Tall) and Egg ().
And now for some great passages:
Wisdom even in the real world:
A peasant's pride is a lordling's shame.
~
Kings rise and fall and cows and smallfolk go about their business
~
"Some rebel lord or robber knight, it was. Or maybe a common murderer. A head's a head. they all look the same after a few days on spike."
Maybe GRRM has moonlight as a porn writer: The sun rose hot and hard, implacable.
Egg, master fighting strategists: "Get him, ser," he heard Egg call. "Get him, get him, he's right there."
The only time anyone was glad an Ironborn was nearby: "Count yourself fortunate that I am ironborn. The priests of the Drowned God know how to drown a man and bring him back, and I have made a study of their beliefs and customs."
Even fleas have standards: "We won't have any [money] if we start sleeping in inns. You want to share a bed with some peddler and wake up with his fleas? Not me. I have my own fleas, and they are not fond of strangers. We'll sleep beneath the stars."
*If you want to learn more about the history of Westeros I cannot recommend The World of Ice and Fire enough. Great history and amazing pictures.
These three novellas take place roughly one hundred years before A Game of Thrones. So all the characters we know and love (and love to hate) have yet to be born, the Targaryens still sit on the Iron Throne, and the small folk are exploited by the nobles (so that much isn't different). Instead of seeing Westeros through the eyes of the Haves (sworn knights, great lords, nobles), we get to see it through the Have-Nots, specifically those of a hedge knight, Ser Duncan the Tall. Unlike the sworn knights who serve a lord, hedge knights travel, seeking service where they can and more often sleeping under hedges than under a roof. Of course don't tell them that.
"A hedge knight is the truest kind of knight, Dunk," the old man had told him, a long long time ago. "Other knights serve the lords who keep them, or from whom they hold their lands, but we serve where we will, for men whose causes we believe in. Every knight swears to protect the weak and the innocent, but we keep the vow best I think."I had actually, sort of, already read the first novella, Hedge Knight, in the form of the graphic novel. I liked the graphic novel and liked the novella even better. In fact all of the novellas stood very well on their own, not trying to do too much within their story while still doing a fantastic job of developing the relationship between Egg and Dunk. I really liked their relationship and how it grew over the course of the stories.
If there is one thing GRRM does well is develop and explain feudal ties and relationships (or maybe he just likes doodling cool house banners). This was very apparent in these stories as Martin does a deft job dropping political developments and themes into the narrative that is ostensibly about the travels of Dunk and Egg. I harbor a suspicion that the entire purpose of the Song of Ice and Fire series is to show how terrible monarchies and aristocracies are.
In this case Dunk and Egg are confronted on several occasions by the fall out from the Blackfyre Rebellion*. The nickel tour is this: The Blackfyre Rebellion was a civil war in Westeros over who should succeed to the Iron Throne (Some old dead king gave a sword to one son instead of another, that was the start of it. And now I'm standing here, and poor Roger's in his grave.). The realm was split, one side (the Blackfyres) lost and several members of that family fled Westeros, looming as a threat to the victorious side. As with all civil wars, one group ends up backing the wrong side and faces the consequences, most notably losing land, titles, holdings, respect of the victors, and being forced to provide hostages to the victor's side. But just because there was a winner doesn't mean the losers were content to just go back to the status quo ante. All that politics aside, even though the rebellion occurred fifteen years prior to the events of these novellas the repercussions still echo throughout the realm.
"Treason... is only a word. When two princes fight for a chair where only one may sit, great lords and common man alike must choose. and when the battle's done, the victors will be hailed as loyal men and true, whilst those who were defeated will be known forevermore as rebels and traitors."So as Dunk and Egg (his squire) travel about they are confronted with these consequences: lords who backed the wrong (though not in their mind) side, conspirators to return the Blackfyres, political discontent with the current regime who many believe is being controlled by a sorcerer bastard offspring of the previous king.
There is a great balance of fights, character development, narrative progression, and political intrigue. I got a much better view on the lives of the small folk and lesser knights (not surprisingly: just as sucky as I previously assumed) as well as the challenges that the vast majority of Westeros must deal with, small folk and petty noble alike. Heck, one novella revolves around water rights between two nobles of a stream during a drought (and we also see one of the many repercussions of the Blackfyre Rebellion).
But the heart of these books is the relationship between Dunk (Ser Duncan the Tall) and Egg ().
"Can I have a sword to run them off with?"OK, so they don't start off on the best of terms, but once they settle into the knight-squire relationship they develop respect and admiration for each other.
"No. A knife's enough. And you had best be here when I come back, do you hear me? Rob me and run off, and I'll hunt you down, I swear I will. With dogs."
"You don't have any dogs."
"I'll get some, just for you."
"Pour Ser Duncan a cup of sweet Dornish Red [Egg]. Try not to spill it on him, you've done him sufficient ill already."And while Dunk pretty consistently threatens to clout Egg, it rarely happens, it is more a playful type of threat. Dunk clearly treats Egg with all the respect due a squire without abusing his power over him. Egg is stronger in some matters and instead of resenting Egg for it, Dunk makes use of it. All in all a great relationship that I enjoyed to see blossom. Even though GRRM is way behind on Winds of Winter, I really hope we end up with more Dunk and Egg stories.
"The boy won't spill, Your Grace. He's a good boy. A good squire. And he meant no harm to me, I know."
"One need not intend harm to do it."
~~~
"Well, some knights sing gallant songs to their ladies, or play them tunes upon a lute."
"I have no lute. And that night I drank too much in the Planky Town, you told me I sang like an ox in mud in a mud wallow."
"I had forgotten, ser."
"How could you forget?"
"You told me to forget, ser. You told me I'd get a clout in the ear the next time I mentioned it."
~~~
"Ser? That fat septon said my father sulks in Summerhall."
"Words are wind."
"My father doesn't sulk."
"Well, he might. You sulk."
"I do not. Ser. Do I?"
"Some. Not too often, though. Elsewise I'd clout you in the ear more than I do."
"You clouted me in the ear at the gate."
"That was half a clout at best. If I ever give you a whole clout, you'll know."
And now for some great passages:
Wisdom even in the real world:
A peasant's pride is a lordling's shame.
~
Kings rise and fall and cows and smallfolk go about their business
~
"Some rebel lord or robber knight, it was. Or maybe a common murderer. A head's a head. they all look the same after a few days on spike."
Maybe GRRM has moonlight as a porn writer: The sun rose hot and hard, implacable.
Egg, master fighting strategists: "Get him, ser," he heard Egg call. "Get him, get him, he's right there."
The only time anyone was glad an Ironborn was nearby: "Count yourself fortunate that I am ironborn. The priests of the Drowned God know how to drown a man and bring him back, and I have made a study of their beliefs and customs."
Even fleas have standards: "We won't have any [money] if we start sleeping in inns. You want to share a bed with some peddler and wake up with his fleas? Not me. I have my own fleas, and they are not fond of strangers. We'll sleep beneath the stars."
*If you want to learn more about the history of Westeros I cannot recommend The World of Ice and Fire enough. Great history and amazing pictures.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 8,603 reviews