This is a collection of 11 short stories in a variety of settings such as Venice and Britain. What struck me though was the number of stories set in American east coast suburban and urban settings, the milieu of John Cheever, and how many of the emotions, personality traits , and social commentary also seemed more similar to John Cheever-type stories than the Patricia Highsmith of The Ripliad and Strangers on the Train fame. Some of these stories worked and some didn’t, but several of the ones that didn’t work were at least interesting looks at societal and human tendencies.
1. SOMETHING THE CAT DRAGGED IN
This story is about some British suburban residents - a married couple, their neighbor and his 19 year old-American nurse - whose neighborly Scrabble game is disturbed by what the cat dragged in. This is less suspense and more observation on when neighborly bonds, even tenuous ones, can be stronger than duties to society as a whole. While some of the characters’ reactions and attitudes stretch the plausible, they were at least somewhat plausible and interesting enough to support a decent story. Besides, one of Highsmith’s specialties is to present stories with normal people acting surprisingly when presented with abnormal situations.
I rate it as 3.7 stars
2. NOT ONE OF US
This is a more mild-toned tale of an upper-caste clique of friends and the events that spring as they increasingly decline to tolerate the behavior of one of the group and his new wife, largely because they are … boring. Highsmith deftly captures the passive back-stabbing dialogue among the clique. While some aspects of the story seemed like Highsmith, the overall tone was more in line of a John Cheever approach, which disappointed me, just because of my 'high' Highsmith expectations. I just need to readjust myself to expect a broader scope of Highsmith themes and I will enjoy these stories more.
I rate it as 3.3 stars.
3. THE TERRORS OF BASKET-WEAVING
Diane is a Manhattan PR Officer married to lawyer Reg. Reg and Diane are 38 and childless, happily living in Manhattan and spending weekends at their Massachusetts coastal cottage. One weekend Diane discovers an old-fashioned ‘Moses” basket on the beach and decides to try to repair it. The feelings Diane feels after repairing the basket, as the title suggests, form the story dynamics.
Having accepted the less macabre nature of some of these stories, I ended up liking this one because the concepts and ideas crossing through Diane’s brain were fresh and intriguing ones to me.
I rate it as 4.0 stars.
4. UNDER A DARK ANGEL’S EYE
This story is about a 55-year old bachelor owner of a Chicago antique shop who is paying for his detested mother’s nursing home care, on a trip back to his hometown to sign the papers to sell his family home to help pay for her care. It seems like a nice-set up and then a twist comes in at the ½ way point that adds some Highsmith tension to the story. This tension is increased by some ominous events. While I really enjoyed the shift in tone the story had, the finale still felt a bit anticlimactic. A better written ending would have helped.
I rate it as 4.0 stars.
5. I DESPISE YOUR LIFE
This story involves a free-spirited young man named Ralph living with fellow band members in a sort of hippie arrangement in New York. Ralph had been raised by his parents in Long Island luxury before taking up with these musician friends. His parents had recently divorced with his mom moving back to California after the end of her marriage-breaking affair. Ralph is trying to sponge some rent money from his usually soft-touch and currently morose Dad.
The story is about Ralph’s attitudes and his relations with his roommates, including a female roomie named Cassie, during his attempts to convince his Dad to lend him money. This is a story that’s more of a commentary on lifestyles and parent-adult child relations than the usual Highsmith themes. Somewhat intriguing for that reason.
I rate it as 3.3 stars.
6. THE DREAM OF THEEMMA C
The story involves the interactions of a crew on a fishing boat called the Emma C. mackerel fishing in Cape Cod Bay and their interactions and conflicts after they discover a young woman exhausted and floating in the Bay. This was a different setting and group of characters than I have encountered with Highsmith. While I did appreciate the different-than-usual characters, motivations and themes Highsmith uses in this story, it resulted in an only moderately satisfying story.
I rate it as 3.0 stars.
7. OLD FOLKS AT HOME
This is about an upper-middle class childless couple in Connecticut ‘adopting’ an aged couple from a local nursing home to provide them a home rather than institutional living arrangement. As expected in a Highsmith story, the aged couple soon reveal themselves to be fairly ungracious guests.
The story had some interesting events and tension but, probably due to present day awareness, the whole setup was a bit implausible, and the ending foreseeable.
I rate it as 3.3 stars.
8. WHEN IN ROME
Isabella is the childless wife of Fillipo, an Italian government official constantly dealing with foreign government officials. The couple is based in Rome and Isabella dutifully performs her supporting role at dinner parties and other such functions. Isabella is beset by a Peeping Tom who like to view her showering. Isabella is also beset by a philandering husband. Isabella comes up with a fairly devious plan of how to deal with both of these problems. The story’s tension comes in how well Isabella’s plan is carried out.
I enjoyed the return to a Rome setting - reminding me of the first Ripley - and also in the return to the Highsmith theme of the capacity for evil existing in seemingly ordinary people. I enjoyed the way the story and plan developed but, as with many of these stories, the ending is not a strong one.
I rate it as 4.0 stars.
9. BLOW IT
This was definitely a non-macabre story yet I liked it very much. It is about 35 year old Manhattan attorney/accountant Harry who is contemplating whether to marry one of the two beautiful 23 year old women he has been dating for the past six months; Lesley an upbeat fashion model and Connie, an editor in a publishing house. While Lesley has the easier personality, Connie has the more interesting one. Both women are in love with Harry and interested in marriage. Harry spends the story wavering between the two women and finally comes up with a method of determining who to marry.
The story climax is in the execution of Harry’s method, which of course, does not go smoothly. While not at all a typical Highsmith, I enjoyed Harry’s thoughts about his dilemma. And while the women are underwritten characters, their reactions in the latter part of the story partly redeem Highsmith’s prior underwriting of their characters. I liked it. It felt fresh if not overly realistic.
I rate it as 4.3 stars.
10. THE KITE
Another odd little story about a little boy grieving the death of his little sister and how he chooses to honor her memory. It starts as a basic slice of life story of how grief affects the little girl’s parents and son, coming from the son’s perspective, and then gets both surreal and macabre. I don’t think it all worked but I appreciate the effort in creating something odd.
I rate it as 3.3
11. THE BLACK HOUSE
We end on another story that presents a different type of Highsmith group and setting: male residents of a small upstate New York town that routinely meet in a local bar. They often get to talking about the titled house, an abandoned old house that they all have memories of engaging in youthful sexual and other such exploits in. These memories are variously real, imagined or substantially enhanced but are a source of prideful bar stories. Tim, one of the group decides to enter the Black House to see what it’s all about as he has no such memories or tales to share. Dramatic tension comes from the group of men’s reaction to Tim’s attempt to seek out the story of the Black House.
I rate it as 3.3 stars.
OVERALL
The average rating of the stories is 3.56 stars, which rounds up to 3.6 and 4 stars, but barely so.
My ranking/rating of the Highsmith books I’ve read:
The Tremor of Forgery - 4.5
The Cry of the Owl - 4.4
Deep Water - 4.3
Ripley Under Ground – 4.3
Ripley’s Game – 4.3
The Price of Salt - 4.1
The Boy Who Followed Ripley – 4.0
Strangers on a Train - 4.0
The Talented Mr. Ripley – 4.0
The Two Faces of January – 3.8
Those Who Walk Away – 3.8
Found in the Street – 3.7
The Black House – 3.6
This Sweet Sickness - 3.6
Little Tales of Misogyny - 3.4