Patricia Cornwell took a break for several years from her most popular character and bestselling series to write other books, but her eventual return to Chief Medical Examiner, Scarpetta, started oof rather bumpy with 2021’s “Autopsy” and 2022’s “Livid”. I gave both 2-star ratings, which followed the same formula, lots of time spent on examining dead bodies, and less time on a mystery that suddenly gets resolved in the last 20 pages.
Then Cornwell’s next two Scarpetta novels – 2023’s “Unnatural Death” and 2024s “Identity Unknown” – were much improved 3.5-star ratings that recaptured some of the quality and reputation that she garnered in her earlier Scarpetta books.
And now 2025 brings us “Sharp Force” – Scarpetta’s next serial murder mystery to solve on Christmas eve and day. This time she facing off against the Phantom Slasher, a serial killer who has been violently killing woman in Northern Virginia over the last several months. It appears the Slasher has been using some kind of very sophisticated technology that creates a ghost-like hologram that he uses to invade his victim’s homes and murdering them in their beds. The Slasher has struck again and Scarpetta is summoned to a historic psychiatric hospital located on Mercy Island where two people have been brutally attacked. And one of them is someone that both Scarpetta and her niece, Lucy, knew and had bad relationships with in the past…
The good news is that Cornwell is continuing the positive trend of her last two novels, a solid 3.5 out of 5 stars for me, and well worth checking out. Even though it follows Cornwell’s well-worn formula (that I will explain in the next paragraph), it was compelling, methodically constructed, tightly plotted, and provided a strong mystery that was multi-layered, full of intense atmospheric pacing. Even with her rather weak wrap-up ending that she is known for, the book still held up as a worthy and enjoyable fast-paced read.
Now, for those who have read my previous Kay Scarpetta reviews, a warning that my following comments will be familiar – because Patricia Cornwell sticks to her repetitive formula that sells.
Just like her previous three novels (and more), the plotting of this novel followed the same structure. Everything takes place over a period of 24 - 36 hours (except an epilogue taking place 1 week later). It is all slammed together in a wham-bam-thank-you-reader storytelling experience. I kid you not. Christmas eve covers pages 1- 146, and Christmas day covers pages 147 – 376, followed by the 8-page epilogue.
Cornwell has her formulaic style down pat and delivers it in a smooth grab your attention and keep it all the way through masterful manner. One of her writing strengths is a strong ability to throw in just enough exposition during each and every scene to keep the reader filled in on what’s going on in the investigation and various storylines with the primary characters. This time, Cornwell dealt with several ongoing personal issues with Marino and Dorothy that come to an interesting and somewhat comical flareup. Even the past weaknesses and frustrations come back on Lucy, Kay, and Benton to deal with. Cornwell certainly raises the bar on family relationships and character conflict that I found engaging and yet sad. We can all look back on our lives and reflect on things that we should have done and not done which cause us real pain and hurt. We all have those deep issues that only time can seem to address even if it cannot heal them.
My only real constructive issues with this novel are the lucky to find the killer at the last moment weak ending (subtract half a star) and the unanswered questions left behind (for example – how was the killer using the militaristic technology and where the payments to two of the characters coming from). I can deal with the unanswered questions, but Cornwell has got to work on delivering stronger endings with better climaxes. It’s really hard to have such a solidly strong buildup and then a weak ending. It’s really emotionally draining.
However, even with those issues, this Scarpetta novel still had my interest and attention. What made it even better was that Cornwell did not ruin the plot development, she built on it in a good way. All of the various clues and subplots included throughout the book came together pretty well except for the unanswered questions that I referred to previously. Other than that, most of the elements actually connected well and brought everything together for a cohesive story until the end.
Overall, Cornwell continued to recapture much of the quality and reputation that she garnered in her earlier Scarpetta books. This took me back to the ones that were page turners, capturing your attention visually and emotionally. This had a captivating mystery that was intensely constructed, several connecting subplots that added interconnecting layers of drama, and serious conflict for our Scooby gang of characters that we have come to love and hold dear in our imaginations. Even with the weak ending, it was worth reading.
Overall rating – 3.5 stars.