There are authors who, despite their manifold accomplishments, often tend to get categorised only on the basis of certain ‘types’/kinds of works, which they aspire to “leave behind” and create something (according to them) better, most famous example being Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Although Basil Copper doesn’t have such a fantastically diverse portfolio that may be comparable to Sir Arthur’s, he did write very polished pieces that are worlds apart from the “comte cruel” variety showcased by the Pan Book of Horror Stories, unfortunately many in the genre remembers him only for those stories that had achieved fame & notoriety via publication in that series. This particular novel under question, ever since its 1st publication by Arkham House in 1983, has been trying to rectify that impression. And this particular edition, available from retailers like Cold Tonnage & Realms of Fantasy, should be patronised by any lover of horror simply to appreciate the genius of Basil Copper.
This, is a “werewolf” novel, apart from many other things, namely: a gothic thriller, a study in narrative tautness while describing things in broad strokes of white & black, and a well-researched view of East European wilderness as perceived by fin-de-siècle scholars. The story is well known: a group of scholars, who specialise in folklore associated with the bizarre & the risqué elements, are invited to the Castle Homolky atop the Hungarian type of Lugos. The countryside had been seeing the depredations of a pack of wolves, led by a wolf whose cunning and near-invincibility has already thrown an aura of supernatural around it and the killings. And then, along-with the folklorists, something else enters the castle and starts roaming its dark & haunted corridors for a kill: a werewolf! There are damsels in distress (described gorgeously), blood-drenched history, darkness in the past of the noble family in question, mistrust & misplaced trust, faith & betrayal, terrific suspense. In short: you would hardly notice when the brief chapters have flown by, and you are gasping with the open-ended solution that is offered in the final pages.
Despite all such glory-words, I have certain problems with this novel. Too many issues were left unresolved (or, at least, not exactly resolved to my satisfaction). The antagonist was not dealt with adequately, without punishing the man/wolf for the murders that he had committed (5 and counting!). And despite being a very gothic thriller, and an accomplished horror novel, the mystery was not that difficult to solve. All these factors have compelled me to drop a star. Recommended, but if you wish to read a proper gothic mystery-cum-thriller, try to get hold of Ron Weighell’s “The Shadow of The Wolf” (available from Calabash Press collection of his stories, as well as in “The Werewolf Pack” edited by Mark Valentine): a Sherlock Holmes pastiche that is better than this volume, on each & every count.