Lara and the Moon-Colored Filly, while well-written and consistent with the first book of the series, is probably the weakest of the Hoofbeats quartet, simply because of how little actually happens. However, it’s a quick, easy read that does a great job of emphasizing the bond between Lara and Dannsair, which drives the rest of the series.
Following her capture by Conall, the leader of a horse-breeding enterprise, Lara O’Marchach finds herself as the sole protector of Dannsair, the orphaned silver filly who was born in Lara’s care. Conall has plans to sell Dannsair to the powerful Baron of Athenry, but Lara swears that she will not allow that to happen. In the meantime, Lara befriends Cormac, the son of her father’s sworn enemy, and begins training Dannsair to follow commands. In a race against time, Lara searches for a way to escape Conall’s village with Dannsair without causing another war between her father and his powerful enemies.
I had read Lara and the Gray Mare literally dozens of times before I ever had the chance to read the rest of the series, and I was less impressed with this entry than I was with the first. Kathleen Duey maintains her gentle, logical storytelling style, but her writing struggles without the presence of multiple characters and a steady plot line. The entire book recounts Lara’s day-to-day meanderings with Dannsair as she schemes of a way to escape, occasionally punctuated by the birth of a foal or a conversation with one of the three people she knows. It’s not a particularly riveting story, especially without the rich historical details of the first book.
Nevertheless, the strength of Lara and the Moon-Colored Filly is the relationship between Lara and Dannsair, which grows significantly in this book. Dannsair had only just been born at the end of the first book, so Duey spends a lot of pages building their trust, affection, and dependence on one another. Lara’s fierce devotion to Dannsair brings out the defiant, strong-willed side of her personality that was only hinted at in Lara and the Gray Mare. She spars with Conall, struggles with her opinions of Cormac, and levels out with the contemptuous Fallon at last. The ending of her adventure is abrupt, but it demonstrates how much Lara’s character has grown and what she is willing to do to keep Dannsair safe.
Overall, this is a necessary book in the quartet, but it’s not particularly interesting or exciting, especially after a much-better predecessor and the promise of better things to come.