What do you think?
Rate this book
Belle Meade Plantation #2
To Win Her Favor
A gifted rider in a world where ladies never race, Maggie Linden is determined that her horse will become a champion. But the one man who can help her has vowed to stay away from thoroughbred racing for good.
An Irish-born son far from home, Cullen McGrath left a once prosperous life in England because of a horse racing scandal that nearly ruined him. He’s come to Nashville for a fresh start, hoping to buy land and start a farm, all while determined to stay as far away from thoroughbred racing as possible. But starting over proves harder than he’d wagered, especially when Maggie Linden’s father makes him an offer he shouldn’t accept yet cannot possibly refuse.
Maggie is certain that her mare, Bourbon Belle, can take the top purse in the annual Drayton Stakes at Nashville’s racetrack––the richest race run in America. Maggie only needs the chance to prove it. To give her that chance, and to save Linden Downs from being sold to the highest bidder, Maggie’s father––aging, yet wily as ever––makes a barter. His agreement includes one tiny, troublesome detail––Maggie must marry a man she’s never met. A man she never would have chosen for herself.
Cullen and Maggie need each other in order to achieve their dreams. But their stubborn, wounded hearts––and the escalating violence from a "secret society" responsible for lynchings and midnight raids––may prove too much for even two determined souls.
370 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 12, 2015
365 people are currently reading
3493 people want to read
About the author
Tamera Alexander
36 books3,243 followersTamera Alexander is a USA Today bestselling novelist and one of today's most beloved authors of inspirational historical romance and women’s contemporary fiction. While being Gram Tam is her current favorite role, she’ll never turn down a stroll through an old cemetery or browsing through antique shops.
Her books have been awarded numerous industry-leading honors—among them the Christy Award, the RITA Award, the Carol Award, Library Journal's top honors—and have earned the distinction of Publisher's Weekly Starred Reviews. In 2020 she was inducted into the Christy Award Hall of Fame which recognizes authors for their legacy and contribution to Christian fiction. Her deeply drawn characters and thought-provoking plots have earned her devoted readers worldwide.
Tamera and her husband love living in Nashville, Tennessee, and treasure the time spent with their grown children and grandchildren. They live a short distance from the Southern mansions that serve as the backdrop for many of her critically-acclaimed novels. Tamera views her writing as a way to grow closer to the Lord Jesus Christ—and her deepest desire is that those who read her novels will take steps closer to Him as well.
Her books have been awarded numerous industry-leading honors—among them the Christy Award, the RITA Award, the Carol Award, Library Journal's top honors—and have earned the distinction of Publisher's Weekly Starred Reviews. In 2020 she was inducted into the Christy Award Hall of Fame which recognizes authors for their legacy and contribution to Christian fiction. Her deeply drawn characters and thought-provoking plots have earned her devoted readers worldwide.
Tamera and her husband love living in Nashville, Tennessee, and treasure the time spent with their grown children and grandchildren. They live a short distance from the Southern mansions that serve as the backdrop for many of her critically-acclaimed novels. Tamera views her writing as a way to grow closer to the Lord Jesus Christ—and her deepest desire is that those who read her novels will take steps closer to Him as well.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 520 reviews
May 6, 2015
Reviewed at The Power of Words: http://tinyurl.com/kov96f5
With To Win Her Favor, Tamera Alexander has just elevated herself into my list of top historical romance writers. This story uses the "marriage of convenience" plot that I greatly enjoy, yet raises it to a whole other level than what I'm used to. It has that perfect blend of historical detail, well-drawn characters, captivating storyline, and a love story that touched me with its tenderness, passion, and honesty.
The rich historical detail of Nashville during the year of 1869 provides a fascinating backdrop for this story - from the lush thoroughbred horse farms to racial tensions, prejudice, and KKK violence, evidenced by "need not apply" signs prevalent throughout the area. Former plantation owners had been stripped of wealth, dignity, and all they held dear, while others found themselves judged by skin color and national heritage. Even Maggie, based on what she read in the newspapers, considered the Irish to be "a lazy and violent lot, given to heavy drink and wantonness."
There's a level of realism to Cullen and Maggie that captured my emotions and immediately drew me to them. Together they faced much conflict - financial difficulties, thwarted dreams, personal attacks, prejudice from without and within, guilt from the past. Cullen is a hero I will long remember - a man who, in spite of all the prejudice and personal loss he endured, is a man of compassion, integrity, and tenderness. And Maggie, a young woman with the ability to literally "soar" on her beloved Belle, touched me greatly. This novel has many strengths and their love story is one of them.
One of my favorite characters was Maggie's father, Gilbert Linden, for it is through his character that we see the impact of a Christian legacy. Fully aware of how important both Maggie and Cullen's dreams were to them, and how unlikely it was they could be obtained, he had the wisdom and insight to secure both of their futures in a way neither one would have imagined in their wildest dreams. I loved these words of Gilbert to Cullen as they were talking about prayer: "Let's just say that as I've gotten older, I've learned that there's always a conversation going on. It's just me who's sometimes stubborn of hearing. Either that, or I simply don't like the direction the conversation has taken."
The bond of strong relationships is another strength of this story, seen through Cullen's championing of the downtrodden, as well as Maggie's maturity and spiritual growth. And there are secondary characters who are every bit as endearing as Cullen and Maggie - Ennis, Kizzy, and Savannah Darby, who I believe will be featured in a novella soon. I also have to give praise for the cover, which pictures Maggie in a new riding habit made for her by Savannah, even down to the lace on her collar.
I can't leave with addressing something that I just don't understand; namely, that several reviewers have given this book a one-star rating due to the level of intimacy between Cullen and Maggie. In a time when so many books end at the engagement or wedding ceremony, I find it refreshing to read a story that focuses on the marriage itself. As a Christian wife who has been happily married for over 40 years, I appreciate the realism of both conflict and growing attraction that Tamera conveys so tastefully. And the conversations that take place in the bedroom setting add so much understanding, feeling and emotion that I can't imagine this story without them. There's a difference between intimate and explicit, and Tamera never goes beyond the boundaries into anything that I would find offensive.
I also don't believe all CBA books can be judged by the same standard, as To Win Her Favor is simply a book for adult readers; nowhere, to my knowledge, has it been marketed to the teen or YA audience. However, reading is subjective, and while I appreciate the realistic portrayal of romance in a Christian marriage, I respect that other readers will have a different viewpoint.
To Win Her Favor is an outstanding and memorable novel, happily added to my list of favorites, and one that I look forward to reading again in the future. Highly recommended. 5+ stars
Thank you to Litfuse Publicity for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
With To Win Her Favor, Tamera Alexander has just elevated herself into my list of top historical romance writers. This story uses the "marriage of convenience" plot that I greatly enjoy, yet raises it to a whole other level than what I'm used to. It has that perfect blend of historical detail, well-drawn characters, captivating storyline, and a love story that touched me with its tenderness, passion, and honesty.
The rich historical detail of Nashville during the year of 1869 provides a fascinating backdrop for this story - from the lush thoroughbred horse farms to racial tensions, prejudice, and KKK violence, evidenced by "need not apply" signs prevalent throughout the area. Former plantation owners had been stripped of wealth, dignity, and all they held dear, while others found themselves judged by skin color and national heritage. Even Maggie, based on what she read in the newspapers, considered the Irish to be "a lazy and violent lot, given to heavy drink and wantonness."
There's a level of realism to Cullen and Maggie that captured my emotions and immediately drew me to them. Together they faced much conflict - financial difficulties, thwarted dreams, personal attacks, prejudice from without and within, guilt from the past. Cullen is a hero I will long remember - a man who, in spite of all the prejudice and personal loss he endured, is a man of compassion, integrity, and tenderness. And Maggie, a young woman with the ability to literally "soar" on her beloved Belle, touched me greatly. This novel has many strengths and their love story is one of them.
One of my favorite characters was Maggie's father, Gilbert Linden, for it is through his character that we see the impact of a Christian legacy. Fully aware of how important both Maggie and Cullen's dreams were to them, and how unlikely it was they could be obtained, he had the wisdom and insight to secure both of their futures in a way neither one would have imagined in their wildest dreams. I loved these words of Gilbert to Cullen as they were talking about prayer: "Let's just say that as I've gotten older, I've learned that there's always a conversation going on. It's just me who's sometimes stubborn of hearing. Either that, or I simply don't like the direction the conversation has taken."
The bond of strong relationships is another strength of this story, seen through Cullen's championing of the downtrodden, as well as Maggie's maturity and spiritual growth. And there are secondary characters who are every bit as endearing as Cullen and Maggie - Ennis, Kizzy, and Savannah Darby, who I believe will be featured in a novella soon. I also have to give praise for the cover, which pictures Maggie in a new riding habit made for her by Savannah, even down to the lace on her collar.
I can't leave with addressing something that I just don't understand; namely, that several reviewers have given this book a one-star rating due to the level of intimacy between Cullen and Maggie. In a time when so many books end at the engagement or wedding ceremony, I find it refreshing to read a story that focuses on the marriage itself. As a Christian wife who has been happily married for over 40 years, I appreciate the realism of both conflict and growing attraction that Tamera conveys so tastefully. And the conversations that take place in the bedroom setting add so much understanding, feeling and emotion that I can't imagine this story without them. There's a difference between intimate and explicit, and Tamera never goes beyond the boundaries into anything that I would find offensive.
I also don't believe all CBA books can be judged by the same standard, as To Win Her Favor is simply a book for adult readers; nowhere, to my knowledge, has it been marketed to the teen or YA audience. However, reading is subjective, and while I appreciate the realistic portrayal of romance in a Christian marriage, I respect that other readers will have a different viewpoint.
To Win Her Favor is an outstanding and memorable novel, happily added to my list of favorites, and one that I look forward to reading again in the future. Highly recommended. 5+ stars
Thank you to Litfuse Publicity for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
February 5, 2016
{{TO Those under the age of 15, I recommend you do not read this review or read the actual book as it is filled with marriage thoughts and actions through an arranged marriage. (read: not clean) TO everyone else interested in this book, I don’t recommend this book at all because of all the sexual content, which there is a lot of, this book has bedroom scenes and does not promote Philippians 4:8.}}
About this book:
“A gifted rider in a world where ladies never race, Maggie Linden is determined that her horse will become a champion. But the one man who can help her has vowed to stay away from thoroughbred racing for good.
An Irish-born son far from home, Cullen McGrath left a once prosperous life in England because of a horse racing scandal that nearly ruined him. He’s come to Nashville for a fresh start, hoping to buy land and start a farm, all while determined to stay as far away from thoroughbred racing as possible. But starting over proves harder than he’d wagered, especially when Maggie Linden’s father makes him an offer he shouldn’t accept yet cannot possibly refuse.
Maggie is certain that her mare, Bourbon Belle, can take the top purse in the annual Drayton Stakes at Nashville’s racetrack––the richest race run in America. Maggie only needs the chance to prove it. To give her that chance, and to save Linden Downs from being sold to the highest bidder, Maggie’s father––aging, yet wily as ever––makes a barter. His agreement includes one tiny, troublesome detail––Maggie must marry a man she’s never met. A man she never would have chosen for herself.
Cullen and Maggie need each other in order to achieve their dreams. But their stubborn, wounded hearts––and the escalating violence from a "secret society" responsible for lynchings and midnight raids––may prove too much for even two determined souls.”
Series: Book #2 in the “Belle Meade Plantation” series. {I have read & reviewed Book #1, “To Whisper Her Name”, but it looks like I never posted it! I can tell y’all that I give it 4 Stars for My Personal Rating.}
Spiritual Content- Psalm 61:3 at the beginning; Prayers; Mentions of Heaven; ‘H’s are not capital when referring to God; Scriptures are mentioned & Bible reading; Mentions of those in the Bible; Cullen isn’t a big fan of God and thinks God is cruel.
*Note: a ‘devilish’.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘bloody’ and a ‘dumb’; Curses are cut off (like “you sorry piece of—“); Hateful names are said but not written (though “n*gg*r” is said quite a few times along with “white n*gg*r”); Fist fighting (borderline semi-detailed to detailed); Violence to African American people, hanging them, burning their houses and just plain cruelty to them (semi-detailed); Blood (semi-detailed); Many mentions of slaves, freemen & the Civil War; Mentions of gambling & drinking; Mentions of tobacco; mentions of thrashings & whippings; Dead cows (semi-detailed); a sick horse (semi-detailed).
Sexual Content- Touches & Smelling (semi-detailed and goes to detailed); Noticing, staring, Imagining & checking someone out (semi-detailed up to detailed); Wanting to kiss & touch (semi-detailed to detailed); ; Hand kisses, forehead kisses & tingles; Remembering kisses (semi-detailed); five semi-detailed kisses; a Very-detailed kiss; two very-very-very detailed kisses that lead to unbuttoning clothing and a total of five hinted s*x scenes (lots of unbuttoning (semi-detailed), imagining body parts and making-out; the actual intercourse is not written); a form of ‘wanton’; Mentions of women’s curves; Men’s bare chest; Cullen says he hasn’t been with (read: in bed with) another woman since his wife’s death but there is a mentions of women who would lean over & offer “him a generous view of what was cinched beneath tightly-fitted bodices”; Many, many mentions of consummating a marriage, becoming one, sharing love not wearing clothing & being intimate with someone (Like: “Two of those union—interminable as they were—she could live with under the circumstances. But that of the body? She gulped. She could no more be intimate with this man beside her than she could any stranger on the street. And he’d been married before, which means he knew all about...Well everything. And she knew next to nothing. Then again, his being an Irishmen, he’d likely already known about all of that long before marriage.”); A memory of Maggie learning from her brother about the birds & the bees (“She and Savannah had “accidentally” been snooping in one of her brothers’ bedrooms when they found a stack of pencil drawings. Drawings of scantily-clad women. Why her brothers would ever want such things made no sense. But what stood out in Maggie’s memory most was the frank conversation Oak had with her afterward. ‘Knowing Ma, she’s not likely to ever say any of this to you, and it’s time you knew at least a little.’ Growing up on a farm, Maggie was familiar with how the animals often played with each other. But not until that enlightening conversation with her eldest brother had she begun to understand the full meaning of the word play.”); three mentions of wifely duties; four mentions of a wedding night; nine mentions of sharing a bed (up to semi-detailed); Maggie wearing just a nightgown goes to the kitchen and Cullen walks in on her and comments quite a few times on how she should walk around and twirl for him; Mentions of ladies’ chests (Like: “Why was it men preferred women with larger busts? In the drawings she’d found in her brother’s room, every one of those women had a bosom ample enough to suffocate a small child. Women with waists so tiny and middles corseted so tight everything spilled over the top like bread left too long to rise. Well, if that’s what Cullen Michael McGrath liked in women, then he could just—“) A mention of girls who blossomed and when younger Maggie tried to get boys’ attention by pulling “her long hair forward over her chest, arranging the curls just so, hoping to give the appearance of substance where there was none. But as her brother Abe had told her in that teasing voice, “You can’t hide what you haven’t got, Little Mag.””; a mention of a man who had his female slaves come “visit” him in a home (barely-above-not-detailed); Love, an arranged marriage, falling in love & the emotion (lots and lots and lots!)
*Note: Four mentions of a filly being sired by a stallion.
-Maggie Linden
-Cullen McGrath
P.O.V. switches between Maggie & Cullen
Set in 1869 (Epilogue 1870)
352 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- One Star
My personal Rating- One Star
*sigh* I have never been so disappointed in a book before. Ever. I’ve considered Tamera Alexander one of my favorite authors ever since reading three of her books, all which I really enjoyed. “A Beauty So Rare” being her last release (published by Bethany House) which got five stars from me. Her newest book (this one) is getting one star, as that’s as low as I can go. I am so disappointed. While reading it, I kept looking back at the cover to see if it really was her and not, say, Francine Rivers. Interesting side note: F.R. and T.A. have been going to a lot of writing conferences together, both ladies say they’re very good friends. I was a bit worried when I saw that...as I was not a fan of “Bridge to Haven” by Francine Rivers (Very, very, very sexual) and was hoping that Miss Tamera would influence her; looks like it was the other way around, sadly. Had I known this would be an arranged marriage book, I would have not picked it up. Arranged marriage books always have sexual content that is not needed. What happens in a married couples’ bedroom should stay in that bedroom; meaning being PRIVATE. Why authors think it’s okay to put this intimate stuff in, is beyond me. *sigh* The Civil War era is the hardest historical time for me to read about. I just can’t understand it, the prejudice is awful. And there was a lot of it in this book had me on the verge of tears and throwing up. I’m so disappointed about this book, I now will be cautious with this author’s books.
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Zondervan) for this review.
About this book:
“A gifted rider in a world where ladies never race, Maggie Linden is determined that her horse will become a champion. But the one man who can help her has vowed to stay away from thoroughbred racing for good.
An Irish-born son far from home, Cullen McGrath left a once prosperous life in England because of a horse racing scandal that nearly ruined him. He’s come to Nashville for a fresh start, hoping to buy land and start a farm, all while determined to stay as far away from thoroughbred racing as possible. But starting over proves harder than he’d wagered, especially when Maggie Linden’s father makes him an offer he shouldn’t accept yet cannot possibly refuse.
Maggie is certain that her mare, Bourbon Belle, can take the top purse in the annual Drayton Stakes at Nashville’s racetrack––the richest race run in America. Maggie only needs the chance to prove it. To give her that chance, and to save Linden Downs from being sold to the highest bidder, Maggie’s father––aging, yet wily as ever––makes a barter. His agreement includes one tiny, troublesome detail––Maggie must marry a man she’s never met. A man she never would have chosen for herself.
Cullen and Maggie need each other in order to achieve their dreams. But their stubborn, wounded hearts––and the escalating violence from a "secret society" responsible for lynchings and midnight raids––may prove too much for even two determined souls.”
Series: Book #2 in the “Belle Meade Plantation” series. {I have read & reviewed Book #1, “To Whisper Her Name”, but it looks like I never posted it! I can tell y’all that I give it 4 Stars for My Personal Rating.}
Spiritual Content- Psalm 61:3 at the beginning; Prayers; Mentions of Heaven; ‘H’s are not capital when referring to God; Scriptures are mentioned & Bible reading; Mentions of those in the Bible; Cullen isn’t a big fan of God and thinks God is cruel.
*Note: a ‘devilish’.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘bloody’ and a ‘dumb’; Curses are cut off (like “you sorry piece of—“); Hateful names are said but not written (though “n*gg*r” is said quite a few times along with “white n*gg*r”); Fist fighting (borderline semi-detailed to detailed); Violence to African American people, hanging them, burning their houses and just plain cruelty to them (semi-detailed); Blood (semi-detailed); Many mentions of slaves, freemen & the Civil War; Mentions of gambling & drinking; Mentions of tobacco; mentions of thrashings & whippings; Dead cows (semi-detailed); a sick horse (semi-detailed).
Sexual Content- Touches & Smelling (semi-detailed and goes to detailed); Noticing, staring, Imagining & checking someone out (semi-detailed up to detailed); Wanting to kiss & touch (semi-detailed to detailed); ; Hand kisses, forehead kisses & tingles; Remembering kisses (semi-detailed); five semi-detailed kisses; a Very-detailed kiss; two very-very-very detailed kisses that lead to unbuttoning clothing and a total of five hinted s*x scenes (lots of unbuttoning (semi-detailed), imagining body parts and making-out; the actual intercourse is not written); a form of ‘wanton’; Mentions of women’s curves; Men’s bare chest; Cullen says he hasn’t been with (read: in bed with) another woman since his wife’s death but there is a mentions of women who would lean over & offer “him a generous view of what was cinched beneath tightly-fitted bodices”; Many, many mentions of consummating a marriage, becoming one, sharing love not wearing clothing & being intimate with someone (Like: “Two of those union—interminable as they were—she could live with under the circumstances. But that of the body? She gulped. She could no more be intimate with this man beside her than she could any stranger on the street. And he’d been married before, which means he knew all about...Well everything. And she knew next to nothing. Then again, his being an Irishmen, he’d likely already known about all of that long before marriage.”); A memory of Maggie learning from her brother about the birds & the bees (“She and Savannah had “accidentally” been snooping in one of her brothers’ bedrooms when they found a stack of pencil drawings. Drawings of scantily-clad women. Why her brothers would ever want such things made no sense. But what stood out in Maggie’s memory most was the frank conversation Oak had with her afterward. ‘Knowing Ma, she’s not likely to ever say any of this to you, and it’s time you knew at least a little.’ Growing up on a farm, Maggie was familiar with how the animals often played with each other. But not until that enlightening conversation with her eldest brother had she begun to understand the full meaning of the word play.”); three mentions of wifely duties; four mentions of a wedding night; nine mentions of sharing a bed (up to semi-detailed); Maggie wearing just a nightgown goes to the kitchen and Cullen walks in on her and comments quite a few times on how she should walk around and twirl for him; Mentions of ladies’ chests (Like: “Why was it men preferred women with larger busts? In the drawings she’d found in her brother’s room, every one of those women had a bosom ample enough to suffocate a small child. Women with waists so tiny and middles corseted so tight everything spilled over the top like bread left too long to rise. Well, if that’s what Cullen Michael McGrath liked in women, then he could just—“) A mention of girls who blossomed and when younger Maggie tried to get boys’ attention by pulling “her long hair forward over her chest, arranging the curls just so, hoping to give the appearance of substance where there was none. But as her brother Abe had told her in that teasing voice, “You can’t hide what you haven’t got, Little Mag.””; a mention of a man who had his female slaves come “visit” him in a home (barely-above-not-detailed); Love, an arranged marriage, falling in love & the emotion (lots and lots and lots!)
*Note: Four mentions of a filly being sired by a stallion.
-Maggie Linden
-Cullen McGrath
P.O.V. switches between Maggie & Cullen
Set in 1869 (Epilogue 1870)
352 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- One Star
My personal Rating- One Star
*sigh* I have never been so disappointed in a book before. Ever. I’ve considered Tamera Alexander one of my favorite authors ever since reading three of her books, all which I really enjoyed. “A Beauty So Rare” being her last release (published by Bethany House) which got five stars from me. Her newest book (this one) is getting one star, as that’s as low as I can go. I am so disappointed. While reading it, I kept looking back at the cover to see if it really was her and not, say, Francine Rivers. Interesting side note: F.R. and T.A. have been going to a lot of writing conferences together, both ladies say they’re very good friends. I was a bit worried when I saw that...as I was not a fan of “Bridge to Haven” by Francine Rivers (Very, very, very sexual) and was hoping that Miss Tamera would influence her; looks like it was the other way around, sadly. Had I known this would be an arranged marriage book, I would have not picked it up. Arranged marriage books always have sexual content that is not needed. What happens in a married couples’ bedroom should stay in that bedroom; meaning being PRIVATE. Why authors think it’s okay to put this intimate stuff in, is beyond me. *sigh* The Civil War era is the hardest historical time for me to read about. I just can’t understand it, the prejudice is awful. And there was a lot of it in this book had me on the verge of tears and throwing up. I’m so disappointed about this book, I now will be cautious with this author’s books.
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Zondervan) for this review.
January 1, 2016
Maggie Linden knows she will never race her mare, Bourbon Belle, but she is still determined that her horse will become a champion in the annual Drayton Stakes at Nashville’s racetrack – the richest race run in America. Not only will this prove that Bourbon Belle can take top purse, it will also save Lindon Downs, Maggie’s home, from being sold at auction to the highest bidder. To give her this chance, Maggie’s father, aging and in ill health, yet full of wisdom, makes a deal with Irish-born Cullen McGrath. His agreement includes a singularly troubling stipulation – Maggie and Cullen must marry. After a horse racing scandal nearly ruined him, Cullen comes to Nashville to make a fresh start, hope to buy his own land and develop a thriving farm. He is determined to stay far away from thoroughbred racing, but starting over proves harder than he imagined when Maggie and her love of racing are part of the bargain he knows better than to accept but finds impossible to refuse.
Despite the strange situation that brings them together, Maggie and Cullen realize they need each other, but their stubbornness and past wounds – and even more so the escalating violence from a secret society responsible for lynchings and raids on Linden Downs – work to keep them from achieving their dreams and building a new life together.
There are a handful of authors that I trust completely when it comes to historical romance, and Tamera Alexander quickly became one of them. To Win Her Favor is a gorgeous story; the setting, the characters, the historical detail and the romance are all woven together effortlessly. I typically enjoy marriage of convenience stories, but Tamera brings a richness and depth to this oft-used storyline that makes it fresh and new. The heightened tension in the romantic relationship as well as the plot keeps this from being a run-of-the-mill marriage of convenience story. Tamera’s impeccable grip on creating memorable settings, characters and plot lines made this novel take on a cinematic quality in my mind.
Set during in 1869 Nashville, racial tensions are rife; prominent Nashville families have been destroyed by war, and free blacks, as well as those of other nationalities, must deal with often dangerous prejudices. The racial tensions of the time are so evident; the injustice of it is well-written into the story. I loved the realizations that even Maggie herself comes; somewhat prickly, yet extremely loyal once her “favor” is won, she doesn’t realize how naïve she has been until she meets Cullen. Confronting her prejudices against the Irish in turn makes her confront her ideas about the former slaves that still live at Linden Downs, people that she loves and cares for deeply.
Though at first Maggie seemed to be another “sweet” female lead, I soon found her to be refreshingly honest and realistic. She does not take life quietly, but rather wants her views and opinions to be respected, and even if not followed, at least listened to and valued. I loved interactions between her and Cullen, who proves to be a man of honesty and integrity. Cullen and Maggie are written in such a realistic way that had me turning the pages and unwilling to set the book aside for very long. As a couple they have to face huge challenges – financial strife, personal attacks, destruction of their land and their own personal and spiritual trials. The faith aspect of the story is woven so well within these events and the conversations between the characters that it never once felt out of place and is very uplifting and encouraging.
The romance between Maggie and Cullen is realistic, and while some readers have felt that it pushes the envelope, I found it to be a beautiful, tender depiction of marital love. I think it serves as a reminder that just because a novel is classified as Christian fiction, it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s appropriate for all ages. While not all readers may find it to their liking, the novel is not marketed toward teens or young adults, and, in my opinion, never crosses the line from intimate to explicit. I absolutely loved the tasteful way that Tamera wrote the sweet scenes that depict Maggie and Cullen working through their emotional hurdles to find their way together as a couple.
I also think it worth mentioning that the secondary characters are wonderful and greatly add to the story. Ennis and his family, especially little Kizzy, who quickly captured my heart, bring into harsh light the racial discriminations of the time, as well as provide characters that are full of depth. Gilbert Linden, Maggie’s father, is that dear voice of wisdom; though they didn’t always understand his decisions, they trusted that he had their best interest at heart. Maggie’s best friend Savannah Darby has a story that appears to be just as poignant and captivating as Maggie’s. Their realistic friendship adds yet another layer to the story, and I was happy to find out that Savannah’s full story will be told in a novella to release in July.
At the risk of sounding repetitive, this was a gem of story for me. Though I haven’t read the majority of her novels, thus far, Tamera has never failed to deliver a high quality story. The rich historical details, realistic characterization, tender romance and well-drawn plot make To Win Her Favor my favorite of Tamera’s novels I’ve read so far and a favorite of 2015.
Despite the strange situation that brings them together, Maggie and Cullen realize they need each other, but their stubbornness and past wounds – and even more so the escalating violence from a secret society responsible for lynchings and raids on Linden Downs – work to keep them from achieving their dreams and building a new life together.
There are a handful of authors that I trust completely when it comes to historical romance, and Tamera Alexander quickly became one of them. To Win Her Favor is a gorgeous story; the setting, the characters, the historical detail and the romance are all woven together effortlessly. I typically enjoy marriage of convenience stories, but Tamera brings a richness and depth to this oft-used storyline that makes it fresh and new. The heightened tension in the romantic relationship as well as the plot keeps this from being a run-of-the-mill marriage of convenience story. Tamera’s impeccable grip on creating memorable settings, characters and plot lines made this novel take on a cinematic quality in my mind.
Set during in 1869 Nashville, racial tensions are rife; prominent Nashville families have been destroyed by war, and free blacks, as well as those of other nationalities, must deal with often dangerous prejudices. The racial tensions of the time are so evident; the injustice of it is well-written into the story. I loved the realizations that even Maggie herself comes; somewhat prickly, yet extremely loyal once her “favor” is won, she doesn’t realize how naïve she has been until she meets Cullen. Confronting her prejudices against the Irish in turn makes her confront her ideas about the former slaves that still live at Linden Downs, people that she loves and cares for deeply.
Though at first Maggie seemed to be another “sweet” female lead, I soon found her to be refreshingly honest and realistic. She does not take life quietly, but rather wants her views and opinions to be respected, and even if not followed, at least listened to and valued. I loved interactions between her and Cullen, who proves to be a man of honesty and integrity. Cullen and Maggie are written in such a realistic way that had me turning the pages and unwilling to set the book aside for very long. As a couple they have to face huge challenges – financial strife, personal attacks, destruction of their land and their own personal and spiritual trials. The faith aspect of the story is woven so well within these events and the conversations between the characters that it never once felt out of place and is very uplifting and encouraging.
The romance between Maggie and Cullen is realistic, and while some readers have felt that it pushes the envelope, I found it to be a beautiful, tender depiction of marital love. I think it serves as a reminder that just because a novel is classified as Christian fiction, it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s appropriate for all ages. While not all readers may find it to their liking, the novel is not marketed toward teens or young adults, and, in my opinion, never crosses the line from intimate to explicit. I absolutely loved the tasteful way that Tamera wrote the sweet scenes that depict Maggie and Cullen working through their emotional hurdles to find their way together as a couple.
I also think it worth mentioning that the secondary characters are wonderful and greatly add to the story. Ennis and his family, especially little Kizzy, who quickly captured my heart, bring into harsh light the racial discriminations of the time, as well as provide characters that are full of depth. Gilbert Linden, Maggie’s father, is that dear voice of wisdom; though they didn’t always understand his decisions, they trusted that he had their best interest at heart. Maggie’s best friend Savannah Darby has a story that appears to be just as poignant and captivating as Maggie’s. Their realistic friendship adds yet another layer to the story, and I was happy to find out that Savannah’s full story will be told in a novella to release in July.
At the risk of sounding repetitive, this was a gem of story for me. Though I haven’t read the majority of her novels, thus far, Tamera has never failed to deliver a high quality story. The rich historical details, realistic characterization, tender romance and well-drawn plot make To Win Her Favor my favorite of Tamera’s novels I’ve read so far and a favorite of 2015.
February 5, 2019
.
Tamera Alexander's painstaking research into the people, places and times reveals a high level of realism. I listened to the audio version of 'To Win Her Favor' on Hoopla, which was not as long as the first installment of this series, accessed through the public library system. The narrator was Tavia Gilbert, who sounds different than she did in the first installment. The timbre and tone were so drastically different that I had to double check to make sure that it was not a different narrator. So, it is. But I was disappointed in this rendition. The accents were less pronounced as in the previous book from this series.
This historical fiction based story focuses on the depiction of the struggles and culture set-in the post-civil war, which was a very turbulent time in the South's history, on a plantation called Linden Downs, near Belle Meade Plantation, in Nashville, Tennessee. This inspiring tale addresses overcoming stereotypes, fears, tension, and prejudice. While it also promotes forgiveness, love, trust, and romance. The author is able to bring history alive for the interested reader.
The heroine, Maggie Linden, has always dreamed of racing the thoroughbred she purchased and raised from a foal, Bourbon Belle. However, her father is unable to pay the taxes on their land and may be forced to sell everything at auction, including her most treasured possession, Belle. She exercises Belle daily by racing through the countryside and has benefited financially from racing her locally. Her riding skills are unmatched, but she must have replaced Belle's racing rider before she can enter the horse in the next race.
Along comes the hero, Cullen McGrath, an Irishman, looking for a fresh start. He had previously been involved in a racing scandal with his brother, that nearly ruined him. He, his wife, and daughter came to America to escape the scandal, possible prison and the debt associated with the debacle. Unfortunately, his wife and daughter died from sickness on the ship on their way to America.
Gilbert Linde, Maggie's father, and owner impacted the lives on Linden Downs because his character inspired a Christian legacy. He was well aware of how unlikely Maggie and Cullen's dreams could be attained but had faith that together they could survive anyhow. Some of his words of wisdom about prayer leave a lot to ponder:
"Let's just say that as I've gotten older, I've learned that there's always a conversation going on. It's just me who's sometimes stubborn of hearing. Either that or I simply don't like the direction the conversation has taken."
Mr. Cullen McGrath arrives in town and makes an offer on parcels of land being scheduled for auction, but his attempts had been thwarted. Most southerners displayed pervasive prejudice, having unreasonable feelings about the status of women, considering immigrants as a lower class, treating people in a hostile nature, violent in action or spirit, hell-bent against equality regarding ethnic or racial groups, evidenced the enduring hatred of the now freed slaves and other immigrants. The outcome of the war had not changed their way of flawed thinking at all. The plot is an all-encompassing saga encompassing severe loss, multi-faceted secrets, fierce determination, self-discovery, faith, discrimination, and racial segregation.
Sad how the color of one's skin so defined the path of a person's life, both in freedom for opportunities and in boundaries.
As fate would have it, Cullen McGrath literally bumps into Mr. Linden, Maggie's father, while hoping to make an offer on his land before it goes to auction in two weeks time. Mr. Linden is close to meeting his maker and is worried about his family legacy of land and the future of his only daughter. After careful consideration before the decision, the two strike an unusual bargain, each hiding the personal secrets they are sure would squash the agreement.
In response to scathing reviews, the affectionate scenes portraying a Christian marriage, which is really not explicit, at least not in my opinion. I think it was handled exceedingly well, and that it added the perfect depth and feeling to the story. Readers offended by these tasteful signs of their deep attraction to each other can choose to skim past those few pages and then continue through the rest of the book. Their chemistry was amiable and I enjoyed the progression of Cullen's relationship with Maggie. The unlikely relationship between a southern lady and an Irish man, with a legacy which always invited trouble, was able to bloom beyond all odds. But they were not overly passionate. And the chemistry between them seemed forced at times.
Even though 'To Win Her Favor' captures the drama and tragedy of the post-civil war era and includes cameos from the Belmont Mansion series and the first installment from this series, which brings back happy memories of days gone by, it just was not as captivating as 'To Whisper Her Name', at least in my eyes. As I contemplate how to describe precisely why I am at a loss for an accurate depiction, I tend to feel that maybe the annotation of the narrator didn't bring the characters to life as vividly as they did in the first installment. Or maybe it was the author's change of direction. Also, the day to day activity was skipped over, leaving gaps without explanation. The secrets took too long to be revealed and addressed.
In the end, I was appreciative of the clean (compared to many other romance books) and poignant journey, the complexity, the interesting details, except for the feeling of disconnection I felt. SoI did not hate it, but I did not love either. I was not able to relate to most of the characters, an arranged marriage, or the obstacles of barbaric bigotry and racial discrimination. This was a spotlight interpretation of life in the south after the Civil War ended and I breathed a sigh of relief after finally crossing the finishing line to the conclusion. Just the combined agreement to begin a new life!
Tamera Alexander's painstaking research into the people, places and times reveals a high level of realism. I listened to the audio version of 'To Win Her Favor' on Hoopla, which was not as long as the first installment of this series, accessed through the public library system. The narrator was Tavia Gilbert, who sounds different than she did in the first installment. The timbre and tone were so drastically different that I had to double check to make sure that it was not a different narrator. So, it is. But I was disappointed in this rendition. The accents were less pronounced as in the previous book from this series.
This historical fiction based story focuses on the depiction of the struggles and culture set-in the post-civil war, which was a very turbulent time in the South's history, on a plantation called Linden Downs, near Belle Meade Plantation, in Nashville, Tennessee. This inspiring tale addresses overcoming stereotypes, fears, tension, and prejudice. While it also promotes forgiveness, love, trust, and romance. The author is able to bring history alive for the interested reader.
The heroine, Maggie Linden, has always dreamed of racing the thoroughbred she purchased and raised from a foal, Bourbon Belle. However, her father is unable to pay the taxes on their land and may be forced to sell everything at auction, including her most treasured possession, Belle. She exercises Belle daily by racing through the countryside and has benefited financially from racing her locally. Her riding skills are unmatched, but she must have replaced Belle's racing rider before she can enter the horse in the next race.
Along comes the hero, Cullen McGrath, an Irishman, looking for a fresh start. He had previously been involved in a racing scandal with his brother, that nearly ruined him. He, his wife, and daughter came to America to escape the scandal, possible prison and the debt associated with the debacle. Unfortunately, his wife and daughter died from sickness on the ship on their way to America.
Gilbert Linde, Maggie's father, and owner impacted the lives on Linden Downs because his character inspired a Christian legacy. He was well aware of how unlikely Maggie and Cullen's dreams could be attained but had faith that together they could survive anyhow. Some of his words of wisdom about prayer leave a lot to ponder:
"Let's just say that as I've gotten older, I've learned that there's always a conversation going on. It's just me who's sometimes stubborn of hearing. Either that or I simply don't like the direction the conversation has taken."
Mr. Cullen McGrath arrives in town and makes an offer on parcels of land being scheduled for auction, but his attempts had been thwarted. Most southerners displayed pervasive prejudice, having unreasonable feelings about the status of women, considering immigrants as a lower class, treating people in a hostile nature, violent in action or spirit, hell-bent against equality regarding ethnic or racial groups, evidenced the enduring hatred of the now freed slaves and other immigrants. The outcome of the war had not changed their way of flawed thinking at all. The plot is an all-encompassing saga encompassing severe loss, multi-faceted secrets, fierce determination, self-discovery, faith, discrimination, and racial segregation.
Sad how the color of one's skin so defined the path of a person's life, both in freedom for opportunities and in boundaries.
As fate would have it, Cullen McGrath literally bumps into Mr. Linden, Maggie's father, while hoping to make an offer on his land before it goes to auction in two weeks time. Mr. Linden is close to meeting his maker and is worried about his family legacy of land and the future of his only daughter. After careful consideration before the decision, the two strike an unusual bargain, each hiding the personal secrets they are sure would squash the agreement.
In response to scathing reviews, the affectionate scenes portraying a Christian marriage, which is really not explicit, at least not in my opinion. I think it was handled exceedingly well, and that it added the perfect depth and feeling to the story. Readers offended by these tasteful signs of their deep attraction to each other can choose to skim past those few pages and then continue through the rest of the book. Their chemistry was amiable and I enjoyed the progression of Cullen's relationship with Maggie. The unlikely relationship between a southern lady and an Irish man, with a legacy which always invited trouble, was able to bloom beyond all odds. But they were not overly passionate. And the chemistry between them seemed forced at times.
Even though 'To Win Her Favor' captures the drama and tragedy of the post-civil war era and includes cameos from the Belmont Mansion series and the first installment from this series, which brings back happy memories of days gone by, it just was not as captivating as 'To Whisper Her Name', at least in my eyes. As I contemplate how to describe precisely why I am at a loss for an accurate depiction, I tend to feel that maybe the annotation of the narrator didn't bring the characters to life as vividly as they did in the first installment. Or maybe it was the author's change of direction. Also, the day to day activity was skipped over, leaving gaps without explanation. The secrets took too long to be revealed and addressed.
In the end, I was appreciative of the clean (compared to many other romance books) and poignant journey, the complexity, the interesting details, except for the feeling of disconnection I felt. SoI did not hate it, but I did not love either. I was not able to relate to most of the characters, an arranged marriage, or the obstacles of barbaric bigotry and racial discrimination. This was a spotlight interpretation of life in the south after the Civil War ended and I breathed a sigh of relief after finally crossing the finishing line to the conclusion. Just the combined agreement to begin a new life!
January 4, 2015
To Win Her Favor is a beautiful love story, not to mention a story of faith that shines through in the darkest circumstances. From the very beginning, I lost my heart to Cullen and Maggie and yearned for the moment when they would lose their hearts to each other. Add to everything else a sleek thoroughbred named Bourbon Belle, and this novel quickly galloped its way onto my list of favorite books.
~ Robin Lee Hatcher, best-selling author of Love Without End and Whenever You Come Around
~ Robin Lee Hatcher, best-selling author of Love Without End and Whenever You Come Around
January 28, 2019
1/28/19 update: Fixed a confusing sentence that said the opposite of what I meant!!
I had SO MUCH FUN with this one. I very recently read A Beauty So Rare (Belmont Mansion #2), so I easily spotted cameo appearances. They were integrated so well! Sometimes when I read a standalone book in the middle of a series, I think to myself, “That is OBVIOUSLY a cameo appearance.” And it’s a little bit annoying. Not so in this book. In fact, I recommend reading this book after the previous books, even though this is a standalone novel. The events from A Beauty So Rare clearly occur before this book, and there are some (minor) lasting effects.
The timeline of the Belle Meade Plantation and Belmont Mansion series are intertwined. (They’re very near each other in Nashville.) At the bottom of this review, I’ve listed the six books (and one novella) of the two series in what I believe to be the chronologically correct order. (To Win Her Favor actually ends up being fourth in the sequence of seven stories.)
To Win Her Favor (2015, Zondervan), second in the Belle Meade Plantation series by Tamera Alexander, is a historical Christian romance set in Nashville, Tennessee between 1869 and 1870. I read this book because I snagged a Kindle copy for a low price, and because I read anything and everything by Ms. Alexander!
Rating: 4 1/2 stars
The heroine: Maggie Linden, trains her beloved horse Bourbon Belle for horse races in Nashville. Her father bucks tradition by allowing Maggie to be the thoroughbred’s trainer, even though Mr. Linden is listed as the official trainer. The love Maggie has for her horse is palpable. The two soar together fast. Very fast! Because they’ve been unable to pay their taxes for a while, Maggie and her father are in danger of soon losing Linden Downs, which includes not only their home, but nearly four hundred acres of land, their animals, and the valuable Bourbon Belle.
The hero: Cullen McGrath has had a life full of hurt. When he was fifteen, his family (including an abusive, alcoholic father) moved from Ireland to England after the potato famine. Circumstances later compelled him to move to America, and Cullen then lost his wife and daughter to typhoid on the voyage over. After a year of earning money working on the docks in Brooklyn, he is now searching for land to purchase in the Nashville area so that he might be a farmer. Now he is facing some extreme prejudice. No one will sell to him, even with cash in hand. All is not doom and gloom, though. The reader sees right off that Cullen is very strong, both inside and out. And he has wisdom, likely born of his many hardships.
Christian element: Tamera Alexander’s books tend to be light on preachiness, but she definitely deals in real issues that real people face.
*Cullen remembers his grandfather as saying, “ ‘Tis naught but fools who believe this life is all there be. The world comin’ after ‘tis far greater….” However, Cullen is angry about his bad experiences, and he has turned from God. That’s the place our hero is in at the beginning. “But he was ashamed for having believed, for so many years, in the goodness of the Father God his grandfather had spoken of so many times. Turned out, maybe God the Father was more like his own da.” Fortunately, Cullen meets Maggie’s father, who is wise in the ways of God, as Cullen’s grandfather Ian was. Mr. Linden has experienced just as much hardship as Cullen, “And yet… you still chose to trust, sir.”
What I liked:
*The information about horses and horse racing, in particular, was interesting. In the afterword: “Many current day Kentucky Derby winners (including the famed Secretariat) trace their lineage back to Bonnie Scotland and Belle Meade in the 1870’s.” I also found it very interesting that only black children were used as jockeys due to their light weight.
*The theme of prejudice was definitely present, and the story gives the reader a good sense of how prejudice was perpetuated, and how it impacts the lives of not only those being persecuted, but also of those who did not want to be persecutors.
What I didn’t like: I didn’t find any editing errors or plot holes, and the story, setting, and characters were masterfully crafted. But there was one thing that makes this fall short of a “perfect” story for me: there was too much physical affection between a husband and wife for a Christian novel. This included perhaps three fade-to-black scenes, but before the curtain closes, the reader sees unbuttoning, reaching under, getting on top of, etc. If this were a secular book, I might have given it a five. However, the Christian fiction audience has many very conservative people who believe God does not intend for unmarried people to be dwelling on the physical aspect of love, so I don’t think this was the best choice. This is not to say these scenes were not well done. They were. In fact, I think the scenes seemed very realistic.
--------------------------------------------
I will definitely continue to read more of Ms. Alexander’s stories. I have put the next Belle Meade story, To Mend a Dream (a novella in the Among the Fair Magnolias collection), on my to-read list. I recommend this book to fans of horses, horse racing, Tamera Alexander, and Christian historical romance. I would not recommend this book for younger teens, and I’m on the fence about older teens. For your convenience, see the list below.
A Lasting Impression (Belmont Mansion #1, published 2011)
To Whisper Her Name (Belle Meade Plantation #1, published 2012)
A Beauty So Rare (Belmont Mansion, #2, 2014) (set in 1868)
To Win Her Favor (Belle Meade Plantation #2, published 2015) (set in 1869-1870)
To Mend a Dream (Belle Meade #2.5, published 2015 in Among the Fair Magnolias )
A Note Yet Unsung (Belmont Mansion #3, 2017)
To Wager Her Heart (Belle Meade Plantation #3, 2017)
I had SO MUCH FUN with this one. I very recently read A Beauty So Rare (Belmont Mansion #2), so I easily spotted cameo appearances. They were integrated so well! Sometimes when I read a standalone book in the middle of a series, I think to myself, “That is OBVIOUSLY a cameo appearance.” And it’s a little bit annoying. Not so in this book. In fact, I recommend reading this book after the previous books, even though this is a standalone novel. The events from A Beauty So Rare clearly occur before this book, and there are some (minor) lasting effects.
The timeline of the Belle Meade Plantation and Belmont Mansion series are intertwined. (They’re very near each other in Nashville.) At the bottom of this review, I’ve listed the six books (and one novella) of the two series in what I believe to be the chronologically correct order. (To Win Her Favor actually ends up being fourth in the sequence of seven stories.)
To Win Her Favor (2015, Zondervan), second in the Belle Meade Plantation series by Tamera Alexander, is a historical Christian romance set in Nashville, Tennessee between 1869 and 1870. I read this book because I snagged a Kindle copy for a low price, and because I read anything and everything by Ms. Alexander!
Rating: 4 1/2 stars
The heroine: Maggie Linden, trains her beloved horse Bourbon Belle for horse races in Nashville. Her father bucks tradition by allowing Maggie to be the thoroughbred’s trainer, even though Mr. Linden is listed as the official trainer. The love Maggie has for her horse is palpable. The two soar together fast. Very fast! Because they’ve been unable to pay their taxes for a while, Maggie and her father are in danger of soon losing Linden Downs, which includes not only their home, but nearly four hundred acres of land, their animals, and the valuable Bourbon Belle.
The hero: Cullen McGrath has had a life full of hurt. When he was fifteen, his family (including an abusive, alcoholic father) moved from Ireland to England after the potato famine. Circumstances later compelled him to move to America, and Cullen then lost his wife and daughter to typhoid on the voyage over. After a year of earning money working on the docks in Brooklyn, he is now searching for land to purchase in the Nashville area so that he might be a farmer. Now he is facing some extreme prejudice. No one will sell to him, even with cash in hand. All is not doom and gloom, though. The reader sees right off that Cullen is very strong, both inside and out. And he has wisdom, likely born of his many hardships.
Christian element: Tamera Alexander’s books tend to be light on preachiness, but she definitely deals in real issues that real people face.
*Cullen remembers his grandfather as saying, “ ‘Tis naught but fools who believe this life is all there be. The world comin’ after ‘tis far greater….” However, Cullen is angry about his bad experiences, and he has turned from God. That’s the place our hero is in at the beginning. “But he was ashamed for having believed, for so many years, in the goodness of the Father God his grandfather had spoken of so many times. Turned out, maybe God the Father was more like his own da.” Fortunately, Cullen meets Maggie’s father, who is wise in the ways of God, as Cullen’s grandfather Ian was. Mr. Linden has experienced just as much hardship as Cullen, “And yet… you still chose to trust, sir.”
What I liked:
*The information about horses and horse racing, in particular, was interesting. In the afterword: “Many current day Kentucky Derby winners (including the famed Secretariat) trace their lineage back to Bonnie Scotland and Belle Meade in the 1870’s.” I also found it very interesting that only black children were used as jockeys due to their light weight.
*The theme of prejudice was definitely present, and the story gives the reader a good sense of how prejudice was perpetuated, and how it impacts the lives of not only those being persecuted, but also of those who did not want to be persecutors.
What I didn’t like: I didn’t find any editing errors or plot holes, and the story, setting, and characters were masterfully crafted. But there was one thing that makes this fall short of a “perfect” story for me: there was too much physical affection between a husband and wife for a Christian novel. This included perhaps three fade-to-black scenes, but before the curtain closes, the reader sees unbuttoning, reaching under, getting on top of, etc. If this were a secular book, I might have given it a five. However, the Christian fiction audience has many very conservative people who believe God does not intend for unmarried people to be dwelling on the physical aspect of love, so I don’t think this was the best choice. This is not to say these scenes were not well done. They were. In fact, I think the scenes seemed very realistic.
--------------------------------------------
I will definitely continue to read more of Ms. Alexander’s stories. I have put the next Belle Meade story, To Mend a Dream (a novella in the Among the Fair Magnolias collection), on my to-read list. I recommend this book to fans of horses, horse racing, Tamera Alexander, and Christian historical romance. I would not recommend this book for younger teens, and I’m on the fence about older teens. For your convenience, see the list below.
A Lasting Impression (Belmont Mansion #1, published 2011)
To Whisper Her Name (Belle Meade Plantation #1, published 2012)
A Beauty So Rare (Belmont Mansion, #2, 2014) (set in 1868)
To Win Her Favor (Belle Meade Plantation #2, published 2015) (set in 1869-1870)
To Mend a Dream (Belle Meade #2.5, published 2015 in Among the Fair Magnolias )
A Note Yet Unsung (Belmont Mansion #3, 2017)
To Wager Her Heart (Belle Meade Plantation #3, 2017)
March 9, 2016
This book captivated me from the beginning. The setting is not one I would normally be interested in- post-Civil War South, however the author brings the characters and landscape to life in a way that I can't help but be fascinated. I definitely enjoyed the marriage of convenience theme, and this story is now one of my favorites in that category. Maggie and Cullen are each caught between a rock and a hard place- Maggie because she will lose the family farm to auction, Cullen because nobody will deal with an Irishman. They are both desperate to pursue their dreams, and Maggie's father had enough foresight and faith to offer a solution that would secure the future of both his daughter and their land.
I didn't realize there was such bitter racism against the Irish in the South. It was eye-opening to learn about the attitudes and prejudices that were commonplace. Even Maggie struggled with overcoming her prejudice of Cullen's ancestry but as she grows to respect him for his character she is able to let go of the attitudes passed down by her mother and community. Cullen and Maggie's relationship is fraught with tension; they deal with secrecy and trust issues, feelings of unworthiness, financial difficulties, pressure from society, vandalism and violence from "wolves" (KKK members), and an undeniable attraction and growing love for each other.
I would recommend this book to adult readers since the marital relations between Maggie and Cullen are referred to several times (although tastefully done).
(Thank you to Litfuse Publicity and BookLook Bloggers for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review)
I didn't realize there was such bitter racism against the Irish in the South. It was eye-opening to learn about the attitudes and prejudices that were commonplace. Even Maggie struggled with overcoming her prejudice of Cullen's ancestry but as she grows to respect him for his character she is able to let go of the attitudes passed down by her mother and community. Cullen and Maggie's relationship is fraught with tension; they deal with secrecy and trust issues, feelings of unworthiness, financial difficulties, pressure from society, vandalism and violence from "wolves" (KKK members), and an undeniable attraction and growing love for each other.
I would recommend this book to adult readers since the marital relations between Maggie and Cullen are referred to several times (although tastefully done).
(Thank you to Litfuse Publicity and BookLook Bloggers for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review)
May 28, 2017
If I wasn't so busy caring for my newborn and teaching school, to my other three children, I would have finished this book much sooner! This would make such a great movie. If it was a movie, I don't know what would be my favorite scene to watch though. It would be a toss up between Cullon walloping on Stephen Drake or watching Kizzy soar on that horse! Either way, the book is always better than the movie:)
July 20, 2015
Another fabulous read by the talented Tamera Alexander! I have been a fan of hers since I read her first novel, Rekindled. To Win Her Favor is right up there at the top of my favorite's list. To start off, I really appreciate the "father knows best" aspect in this story. It's refreshing in a day and time where fathers are usually cast as "stupid". I also enjoyed learning more about horse racing. Lots of interesting facts. I don't usually like story's set during or around the Civil War because I find the injustice in the way things were too sad. But Tamera writes so beautifully this time period that I want to soak up every word. Each and every character in this book are so life like that I feel I know them or can relate to them. I love how the heroine is strong willed yet respects her father and her husband. There are tender moments woven throughout the book. I dislike how in a lot of "marriage of convenience" books the couple will have a misunderstanding drag out through the whole story. Not in To Win Her Favor! There is a perfect blend of tension and romance. Little Kizzy is adorable. I wanted to just pluck her out of the story and take her home with me. And then there's Ethan, love those "bad boys"! Will he get his own story? I wanted to match him with Savannah. Maybe in book #3. Surely we will find out more about Savannah. And lastly, without revealing too much, there is a completely PERFECT ending, just beautiful! This is a must read for all Christian fiction readers!
Read
March 27, 2023Reread 2023
I remember loving this book the first time I read it, but skipping past the parts I found to be too much. My thoughts are very mixed-up with this one. There is so much that could be said about the topic I'm addressing below. I'm only touching on the highlights of my thoughts, so just know I'm going to assume whoever is reading this has a healthy view + expectation of marital intimacy.
Disclaimer: This book is for a mature audience. I do not recommend this book for younger readers, but also for those who struggle with content in book. I want to address this first as I believe porn in books is a big struggle for women that doesn't get talked about near enough. Marriage as instituted by God is beautiful, and should be celebrated as such. With the trash being put out into the world today, this book can be a great example of what a healthy marriage could look like. In that regard, I think this was a great book. However, boundaries are so easily blurred when reading books and that's why I think if you struggle with content in books, you might need to stay away from this one. Nothing is explicitly graphic, and we don't get actual sex scenes, but we do get the undressing/leading-up-to-intimacy scenes, the after-scenes, and discussions/thoughts about marital intimacy. In no way am I suggesting this sort of thing is wrong for a married couple, but this is meant to be private, between the married couple. I don't want to feel like I'm in the bedroom with the couple, and that's the feeling I got in this book. This was more content than I prefer, Christian novel or not. I really think content warnings should be a thing in the beginning of books, to warn the readers before they get a surprise.
It should be noted that I don't prefer reading arranged marriage/marriage of convenience books as I find these tropes are used to excuse more intimacy or sensuality that typically found in Christian novels.
Additionally, the main driving force of the plot is the romance, OR desire for romance, OR lack thereof. Cullen and Maggie spend far too much time not talking, being angry/upset with each other, and because of this, they both remain frustrated because they desire closeness and intimacy with the other partner which equates to even more intimate thoughts. They cycled through miscommunication -> argument -> not talking/cold shoulder -> desiring each other -> someone finally has had enough and just gets over the anger -> kiss and make up -> rinse and repeat. I, for one, found it annoying. And the longer I've sat on this review, the less I realize I enjoyed sitting through it.
While Tamera Alexander is an excellent historical novelist, and I do love her books very much, I think (the longer I've thought about it) this one just doesn't sit right with me. I still love the story, but I don't feel like I can recommend it to my friends.
I remember loving this book the first time I read it, but skipping past the parts I found to be too much. My thoughts are very mixed-up with this one. There is so much that could be said about the topic I'm addressing below. I'm only touching on the highlights of my thoughts, so just know I'm going to assume whoever is reading this has a healthy view + expectation of marital intimacy.
Disclaimer: This book is for a mature audience. I do not recommend this book for younger readers, but also for those who struggle with content in book. I want to address this first as I believe porn in books is a big struggle for women that doesn't get talked about near enough. Marriage as instituted by God is beautiful, and should be celebrated as such. With the trash being put out into the world today, this book can be a great example of what a healthy marriage could look like. In that regard, I think this was a great book. However, boundaries are so easily blurred when reading books and that's why I think if you struggle with content in books, you might need to stay away from this one. Nothing is explicitly graphic, and we don't get actual sex scenes, but we do get the undressing/leading-up-to-intimacy scenes, the after-scenes, and discussions/thoughts about marital intimacy. In no way am I suggesting this sort of thing is wrong for a married couple, but this is meant to be private, between the married couple. I don't want to feel like I'm in the bedroom with the couple, and that's the feeling I got in this book. This was more content than I prefer, Christian novel or not. I really think content warnings should be a thing in the beginning of books, to warn the readers before they get a surprise.
It should be noted that I don't prefer reading arranged marriage/marriage of convenience books as I find these tropes are used to excuse more intimacy or sensuality that typically found in Christian novels.
Additionally, the main driving force of the plot is the romance, OR desire for romance, OR lack thereof. Cullen and Maggie spend far too much time not talking, being angry/upset with each other, and because of this, they both remain frustrated because they desire closeness and intimacy with the other partner which equates to even more intimate thoughts. They cycled through miscommunication -> argument -> not talking/cold shoulder -> desiring each other -> someone finally has had enough and just gets over the anger -> kiss and make up -> rinse and repeat. I, for one, found it annoying. And the longer I've sat on this review, the less I realize I enjoyed sitting through it.
While Tamera Alexander is an excellent historical novelist, and I do love her books very much, I think (the longer I've thought about it) this one just doesn't sit right with me. I still love the story, but I don't feel like I can recommend it to my friends.
August 10, 2023
4.5 🌟 TA is such a phenomenal writer. I’d never read a MOC set in this time period before. TA made the MOC believable & made me so invested so fast! Here’s the deal though: while I loved Cullen, I got pretty annoyed with the heroine, Maggie. 1. I’m not a “horse person” (lol) & Maggie’s devotion to racing Belle over everything else (including her relationship with her spouse) bugged me. In short, Maggie seemed immature & selfish & just difficult. In the middle I was like, why does he like her again?? Lol. Cullen had such patience with her.
The whole story is developed well & I could picture it all vividly thanks to TA’s magnificent storytelling. While Maggie did annoy me from time to time it was an excellent read!
P.S. The romance in this book was perhaps the spiciest I’ve read in CF. Definitely for mature readers imho.
The whole story is developed well & I could picture it all vividly thanks to TA’s magnificent storytelling. While Maggie did annoy me from time to time it was an excellent read!
P.S. The romance in this book was perhaps the spiciest I’ve read in CF. Definitely for mature readers imho.
April 6, 2015
The first word that comes to mind when I think of this novel is "passion." This word is displayed throughout the novel, and not just in reference to romantic passion. But let me tell you...Tamera Alexander had the romance sizzling more than ever!
Maggie's passion at the beginning of the novel is for her horse, Bourbon Belle. She and her father have sacrificed so much to be able to keep the well-bred horse, who Maggie is confident will win in the races. But Bourbon Belle is more than just a race horse to Maggie. She raised the horse from a foal and has a connection to the horse like no one else. When she rides her horse, flying across the fields, Maggie's free, untamed spirit shines through. To give up Bourbon Belle would be like losing part of herself. So Maggie is determined to do whatever she can to keep her and the farm that she and her father love.
Cullen McGrath is passion personified. He's passionate about the land, making his way in the world, in his desire to be a good, honest man, and the woman he loves. He's not afraid to back down from a fight or stand up to evil. And he's Irish. So he's basically every girl's dream guy ; ). But he's not perfect. There are a lot of ghosts in his past that he struggles with, and they prevent him from being completely open with Maggie.
And....the sparks were flying between Cullen and Maggie! Both of them are such passionate characters individually, so when they interact the fireworks begin. Sometimes that means the opposite of romance as they both know how to put up a good fight. The fact that they basically had an arranged marriage meant they had to get to know one another under difficult circumstances. At times my stomach would be in knots over the conflict they were dealing with...at other times I couldn't turn the pages fast enough as the romance heated up!
Passion is not the only theme in this novel. Alexander does a fantastic job of addressing the prejudices faced by so many during this time period. As a woman, Maggie wasn't able to manage Belle like she wanted to as a man had to officially own her horse for it to be entered into a race. Everyone was astonished to find out that Maggie actually trained her horse and not a man. When trying to find a jockey, it was assumed that a boy would be chosen, as girls were not seen at that time as being able to do it.
Cullen, as an Irish man, saw the ugly face of prejudice as he tried to buy land, do business at the bank, get a loan for building supplies, and basically find support in his new town. Even Maggie, when she first found out Cullen was Irish, turned her nose up at him. But when she saw beyond her misconceptions, she was able to see the kind of man Cullen really was. It was just another reminder to me how prejudice can show itself in so many ways.
The heaviest display of prejudice was with the African American slaves/free men that played a big part in the story. Cullen treated the men and women with dignity and respect, offering them a better place to live and a fair wage for their work. He protected them as best he could, but he couldn't always prevent the havoc wreaked by evil men. As Maggie saw how Cullen treated everyone equally, she realized her need to change. There were some difficult moments to read in this novel, as it is always hard for me to see evil done to those who don't deserve it. Even harder was knowing that this really took place in our history, and that many suffered the ridicule and pain that was unjustly inflicted upon them. Just as I've felt when reading stories of the Holocaust or other evil periods in our world's history...may we never forget.
I have enjoyed every novel I've read by Tamera Alexander, but this novel stands out in particular. I loved the chemistry between the main characters, I found the bond between Maggie's father and Cullen endearing, and the struggles each character went through, even down to a precious African American child, gave the novel a more than satisfying journey. I would highly recommend it!
**I was given a free copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley for an honest review, which I gave.**
Maggie's passion at the beginning of the novel is for her horse, Bourbon Belle. She and her father have sacrificed so much to be able to keep the well-bred horse, who Maggie is confident will win in the races. But Bourbon Belle is more than just a race horse to Maggie. She raised the horse from a foal and has a connection to the horse like no one else. When she rides her horse, flying across the fields, Maggie's free, untamed spirit shines through. To give up Bourbon Belle would be like losing part of herself. So Maggie is determined to do whatever she can to keep her and the farm that she and her father love.
Cullen McGrath is passion personified. He's passionate about the land, making his way in the world, in his desire to be a good, honest man, and the woman he loves. He's not afraid to back down from a fight or stand up to evil. And he's Irish. So he's basically every girl's dream guy ; ). But he's not perfect. There are a lot of ghosts in his past that he struggles with, and they prevent him from being completely open with Maggie.
And....the sparks were flying between Cullen and Maggie! Both of them are such passionate characters individually, so when they interact the fireworks begin. Sometimes that means the opposite of romance as they both know how to put up a good fight. The fact that they basically had an arranged marriage meant they had to get to know one another under difficult circumstances. At times my stomach would be in knots over the conflict they were dealing with...at other times I couldn't turn the pages fast enough as the romance heated up!
Passion is not the only theme in this novel. Alexander does a fantastic job of addressing the prejudices faced by so many during this time period. As a woman, Maggie wasn't able to manage Belle like she wanted to as a man had to officially own her horse for it to be entered into a race. Everyone was astonished to find out that Maggie actually trained her horse and not a man. When trying to find a jockey, it was assumed that a boy would be chosen, as girls were not seen at that time as being able to do it.
Cullen, as an Irish man, saw the ugly face of prejudice as he tried to buy land, do business at the bank, get a loan for building supplies, and basically find support in his new town. Even Maggie, when she first found out Cullen was Irish, turned her nose up at him. But when she saw beyond her misconceptions, she was able to see the kind of man Cullen really was. It was just another reminder to me how prejudice can show itself in so many ways.
The heaviest display of prejudice was with the African American slaves/free men that played a big part in the story. Cullen treated the men and women with dignity and respect, offering them a better place to live and a fair wage for their work. He protected them as best he could, but he couldn't always prevent the havoc wreaked by evil men. As Maggie saw how Cullen treated everyone equally, she realized her need to change. There were some difficult moments to read in this novel, as it is always hard for me to see evil done to those who don't deserve it. Even harder was knowing that this really took place in our history, and that many suffered the ridicule and pain that was unjustly inflicted upon them. Just as I've felt when reading stories of the Holocaust or other evil periods in our world's history...may we never forget.
I have enjoyed every novel I've read by Tamera Alexander, but this novel stands out in particular. I loved the chemistry between the main characters, I found the bond between Maggie's father and Cullen endearing, and the struggles each character went through, even down to a precious African American child, gave the novel a more than satisfying journey. I would highly recommend it!
**I was given a free copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley for an honest review, which I gave.**
May 19, 2015
To Win Her Favor was everything I was expecting it to be. Even though it wasn’t my favorite, I still really enjoyed this book. The characters married for convenience, and fell in love afterwards. There is just something about a marriage of convenience in novels like these that I find romantic. And To Win Her Favor certainly was that!
The characters for this novel were well developed and not exactly perfect. Though, I do have to say that Cullen—Maggie’s husband—didn’t possess any flaws that I could find. Maggie was prejudiced, which the author did a very good job of showing and not telling. Maggie’s father also had some flaws that the author subtly slips into the book.
To Win Her Favor was a fast read for me. I absolutely loved it! I would not recommend it for younger readers, as Cullen and Maggie do tend to be intimate at times, though the author never goes deeper than she should into that. I really enjoyed the characters. Tamera always paints colorful figures that I can easily picture. The plot was solid and well-thought through.
Tamera Alexander never fails to disappoint. This book was no exception. I will say that sometimes her books tend to sound the same because many of her characters just seem to be really similar. However, she always writes very well and does her research, which I appreciate. I loved To Win her Favor and cannot wait for her next one.
*I received a complimentary kindle copy of this book from the author through Netgalley. The opinions expressed in this review are mine and mine alone.
The characters for this novel were well developed and not exactly perfect. Though, I do have to say that Cullen—Maggie’s husband—didn’t possess any flaws that I could find. Maggie was prejudiced, which the author did a very good job of showing and not telling. Maggie’s father also had some flaws that the author subtly slips into the book.
To Win Her Favor was a fast read for me. I absolutely loved it! I would not recommend it for younger readers, as Cullen and Maggie do tend to be intimate at times, though the author never goes deeper than she should into that. I really enjoyed the characters. Tamera always paints colorful figures that I can easily picture. The plot was solid and well-thought through.
Tamera Alexander never fails to disappoint. This book was no exception. I will say that sometimes her books tend to sound the same because many of her characters just seem to be really similar. However, she always writes very well and does her research, which I appreciate. I loved To Win her Favor and cannot wait for her next one.
*I received a complimentary kindle copy of this book from the author through Netgalley. The opinions expressed in this review are mine and mine alone.
May 9, 2015
In Tamera’s second Belle Meade Plantation novel, we are back to the races! In order to save the farm, an arranged marriage is in order. The question is, can these two find love? Set among the recovering South, after the Civil War, there is MUCH history here!! Racism is at an all time high and the people of the South are not happy when an Irishman decides to take up residence.
I know there has been talk about some of the scenes in this book. While I was surprised by the somewhat graphic nature of a few of the words chosen, I also know that it was how people talked during this time. It certainly wouldn’t be very historically accurate if one changed the vocabulary of the time. I also believe that the words were used within reason, to show the hatred of the times.
As far as the bedroom scenes go, again, while I was surprised to see them in a Christian book, I didn’t feel that they were graphic in any way. I would certainly say that you shouldn’t buy this book if you would be offended at the mention of unbuttoning of clothes and skin touching between married people. I would also caution that you, as a parent, should know what is in the book. I feel that there is an honest look at what is in the book with Lindsey’s review here (http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...). Again, it wasn’t a problem for me, but I didn’t find it graphic while some of you may.
Overall, I thought it excellent writing. I fell in love with the characters and my interest held throughout. I feel comfortable giving it 5 stars because I think that Tamera is an excellent writer, it dealt with some really dark subject matters, the history was wonderful, and the characters were 100% lovable.
Thank you, Litfuse and Netgalley, for a copy of this book! As always, this is my honest opinion. Here’s to many more!
If you would like to see my fun Face-Off with Tamera Alexander, just head on over here (http://atransparentmom.com/2015/05/06...)! She’s giving away a copy of this awesome book!!!
I know there has been talk about some of the scenes in this book. While I was surprised by the somewhat graphic nature of a few of the words chosen, I also know that it was how people talked during this time. It certainly wouldn’t be very historically accurate if one changed the vocabulary of the time. I also believe that the words were used within reason, to show the hatred of the times.
As far as the bedroom scenes go, again, while I was surprised to see them in a Christian book, I didn’t feel that they were graphic in any way. I would certainly say that you shouldn’t buy this book if you would be offended at the mention of unbuttoning of clothes and skin touching between married people. I would also caution that you, as a parent, should know what is in the book. I feel that there is an honest look at what is in the book with Lindsey’s review here (http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...). Again, it wasn’t a problem for me, but I didn’t find it graphic while some of you may.
Overall, I thought it excellent writing. I fell in love with the characters and my interest held throughout. I feel comfortable giving it 5 stars because I think that Tamera is an excellent writer, it dealt with some really dark subject matters, the history was wonderful, and the characters were 100% lovable.
Thank you, Litfuse and Netgalley, for a copy of this book! As always, this is my honest opinion. Here’s to many more!
If you would like to see my fun Face-Off with Tamera Alexander, just head on over here (http://atransparentmom.com/2015/05/06...)! She’s giving away a copy of this awesome book!!!
April 30, 2015
Until now Tamera Alexander has been a christian fiction author that I would recommend to any teen or adult without hesitation. Masterfully written historical fiction that while it contains an element of romance is clean and tasteful. Well. Not so much this book. I am shocked and disappointed by some of the more intimate bed scenes in the book. I know they are married but I do not need to know about ANYTHING that happens when they are NAKED! Give me a break! Occasionally in christian fiction there will be a scene with married people but generally they are left very vague, or it's a conversation. However, this story goes too far on more than one occasion (undressing, hands under covers, one on top of the other). I am married, but I don't need that picture in my mind, and certainly the teens who may pick up this book don't need to read what this is clearly suggesting. Yes, this sort of thing goes on and we all know it but I choose not to read and or to watch sexually intimate content.
I am disappointed in this author, even though it seems to be 'on trend' for a lot of christian fiction out there right now, and I am equally disappointed in the CHRISTIAN publisher who printed it. Maybe if we speak up standards will be upheld and christian fiction will be held to a higher level than what you might find in a secular book. Just because it's true to life doesn't mean it can't be written in a less graphic way.
Please check out any of her previous novels, they are wonderful and so full of history.
I received this book from Litfuse and Zondervan for the purpose of an honest review. My opinion is my own.
I am disappointed in this author, even though it seems to be 'on trend' for a lot of christian fiction out there right now, and I am equally disappointed in the CHRISTIAN publisher who printed it. Maybe if we speak up standards will be upheld and christian fiction will be held to a higher level than what you might find in a secular book. Just because it's true to life doesn't mean it can't be written in a less graphic way.
Please check out any of her previous novels, they are wonderful and so full of history.
I received this book from Litfuse and Zondervan for the purpose of an honest review. My opinion is my own.
October 7, 2015
Tamera Alexander has done it again! To Win Her Favor is peopled with fascinating, richly-drawn characters that drew me into their very hearts and souls. Maggie and Cullen's story captures the drama and tragedy of the post Civil War era, but more importantly, it captures the humanity of those who triumphed after a dark time in our nation's history to rebuild lives marked by joy and anchored by faith.
May 12, 2015
__________________________________________________
*My Thoughts*
Last year, I had to pick 15 top books last year. No. Way. No way that's happening this year. So many fabulous books and 15 just won't cut it...especially since this one could easily take a few spots all on it's own!!
The characters and plot line were AMAZING!! I'm already a sucker for arranged marriages (NO, I don't want one but I love STORIES about them ;). The relationship between Cullen & Maggie grows and changes throughout the book and Tamera did an awesome job!! I loved how gradually Maggie's opinion of Cullen, Irishmen in general, changed. It really angered me, the names that people were called in the aftermath of the war but was really proud at times of Cullen's reaction. His character took it in stride for himself but refused to stand away when someone else was the victim.
Maggie was a little trickier. That's where the emotion steps in. Losing everything that I've known is tough enough and then throw in a complete stranger to marry...wow. Through all of it, she had to learn to keep a tight reign on her emotions, especially regarding Bourbon Belle.
I have to share what Carole Jarvis said in her review for 'To Win Her Favor' on the intimacy side to this book. Her words reflect my thoughts exactly and I didn't want to copy but decided to quote her instead (be sure to check out her review):
"I can't leave with addressing something that I just don't understand; namely, that several reviewers have given this book a one-star rating due to the level of intimacy between Cullen and Maggie. In a time when so many books end at the engagement or wedding ceremony, I find it refreshing to read a story that focuses on the marriage itself. As a Christian wife who has been happily married for over 40 years, I appreciate the realism of both conflict and growing attraction that Tamera conveys so tastefully. And the conversations that take place in the bedroom setting add so much understanding, feeling and emotion that I can't imagine this story without them. There's a difference between intimate and explicit, and Tamera never goes beyond the boundaries into anything that I would find offensive." -Carole Jarvis
Such an awesome aspect to have Maggie's involvement in thoroughbred racing on top of it all. Add a stunning cover and you have pretty much the perfect book. Cannot WAIT for book two!!
____________________________________________________
*My overall thoughts*
To Win Her Favor by Tamera Alexander is a new favorite author. Her perfect blend of challenges and triumphs make it a joy to read while her vivid details keep you aching for more! Where other authors may choose one lead for the main plot: Arranged marriage, first female thoroughbred racers, aftermath of the civil war to name a few, Tamera uses expert writing to weave it all together. 100+ stars!!
__________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give To Win Her Favor by Tamera Alexander...
5 stars!!
http://bookreviewsforchristians.blogs...
*I received this book from Litfuse and the publisher in exchange for an honest review, which I have given. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
*My Thoughts*
Last year, I had to pick 15 top books last year. No. Way. No way that's happening this year. So many fabulous books and 15 just won't cut it...especially since this one could easily take a few spots all on it's own!!
The characters and plot line were AMAZING!! I'm already a sucker for arranged marriages (NO, I don't want one but I love STORIES about them ;). The relationship between Cullen & Maggie grows and changes throughout the book and Tamera did an awesome job!! I loved how gradually Maggie's opinion of Cullen, Irishmen in general, changed. It really angered me, the names that people were called in the aftermath of the war but was really proud at times of Cullen's reaction. His character took it in stride for himself but refused to stand away when someone else was the victim.
Maggie was a little trickier. That's where the emotion steps in. Losing everything that I've known is tough enough and then throw in a complete stranger to marry...wow. Through all of it, she had to learn to keep a tight reign on her emotions, especially regarding Bourbon Belle.
I have to share what Carole Jarvis said in her review for 'To Win Her Favor' on the intimacy side to this book. Her words reflect my thoughts exactly and I didn't want to copy but decided to quote her instead (be sure to check out her review):
"I can't leave with addressing something that I just don't understand; namely, that several reviewers have given this book a one-star rating due to the level of intimacy between Cullen and Maggie. In a time when so many books end at the engagement or wedding ceremony, I find it refreshing to read a story that focuses on the marriage itself. As a Christian wife who has been happily married for over 40 years, I appreciate the realism of both conflict and growing attraction that Tamera conveys so tastefully. And the conversations that take place in the bedroom setting add so much understanding, feeling and emotion that I can't imagine this story without them. There's a difference between intimate and explicit, and Tamera never goes beyond the boundaries into anything that I would find offensive." -Carole Jarvis
Such an awesome aspect to have Maggie's involvement in thoroughbred racing on top of it all. Add a stunning cover and you have pretty much the perfect book. Cannot WAIT for book two!!
____________________________________________________
*My overall thoughts*
To Win Her Favor by Tamera Alexander is a new favorite author. Her perfect blend of challenges and triumphs make it a joy to read while her vivid details keep you aching for more! Where other authors may choose one lead for the main plot: Arranged marriage, first female thoroughbred racers, aftermath of the civil war to name a few, Tamera uses expert writing to weave it all together. 100+ stars!!
__________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give To Win Her Favor by Tamera Alexander...
5 stars!!
http://bookreviewsforchristians.blogs...
*I received this book from Litfuse and the publisher in exchange for an honest review, which I have given. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
March 31, 2015
First of all, I need to state that I didn't finish this book completely. I got 68% through, and I just couldn't bring myself to finish it. Maybe because I started this novel with high expectations because a good friend of mine told me this is her favorite author.
I didn't love the main characters. They were well written and full of personality, but they didn't click with me. I take that back. Maggie's father was great, and I wish he was in more of the novel. Maggie seemed very childish and immature in a lot of her reactions, but it is quite possible that she grew up a lot more after I stopped reading. And while I liked Connor, I have a hard time reading or watching stories where the past wife plays a big role of comparison toward the new wife.
I just really felt that the novel wasn't going anywhere. Like I said, I was more than half way through and I kept wondering when it was going to end. I blame this on reading a lot of novellas lately :)
Probably the biggest reason this book didn't do much for me is because of how...intimate...the book was. There wasn't anything wrong...and they are man and wife, but it seemed like that was a major focus, and it made me uncomfortable with the thoughts, and descriptions, and focus of the intimacies. I wouldn't say it was inappropriate, but I wouldn't classify it as clean either.
*I received a copy from NetGalley in exchange for a review.
I didn't love the main characters. They were well written and full of personality, but they didn't click with me. I take that back. Maggie's father was great, and I wish he was in more of the novel. Maggie seemed very childish and immature in a lot of her reactions, but it is quite possible that she grew up a lot more after I stopped reading. And while I liked Connor, I have a hard time reading or watching stories where the past wife plays a big role of comparison toward the new wife.
I just really felt that the novel wasn't going anywhere. Like I said, I was more than half way through and I kept wondering when it was going to end. I blame this on reading a lot of novellas lately :)
Probably the biggest reason this book didn't do much for me is because of how...intimate...the book was. There wasn't anything wrong...and they are man and wife, but it seemed like that was a major focus, and it made me uncomfortable with the thoughts, and descriptions, and focus of the intimacies. I wouldn't say it was inappropriate, but I wouldn't classify it as clean either.
*I received a copy from NetGalley in exchange for a review.
January 6, 2016
To Win Her Favor may be my favorite book from Tamera Alexander to date. There were so many emotions that were pulled from me as I read this story. This was such a turbulent time in the South's history. The way people were treated... It just galls me. Then there were all these families who had lost so much and just kept on losing even after the war. Maggie and her father were in the middle of it all. Then to have a woman, Maggie, who grew up knowing one world, one life, to be faced with something quite different and a marriage she could have never foreseen... It was a challenge for her to let go of her presumptions and prejudices. I loved how these characters changed. How they learned from each other and to love each other. How some of the town came together.
The story had so many different themes. There was forgiveness that had to take place between Maggie and Cullen, between Cullen and Ethan, Maggie and Ethan, and others. Then there was trust that had to be earned and the struggle that these characters went through to really let go. Then the prejudices and those that had to take a stand, those that chose to open their hearts and to love. It was a beautiful story.
There was plenty going on in this story. There was a lot of romantic tension. Probably the most that I've read from this author, especially since it was between a married couple. There was quite a bit of danger and I felt an underlining suspense through the entire story. There was some terrible violence and some things that happened that were very devastating. But the joy. Oh, the joy! The hope. The love that held this story and these characters together was wonderful and it's what balanced out the bad. Those are the things that always do and make life worth living, even when it's hard.
There were several parts that felt like little jewels of wisdom that influenced these characters. Here are some snippets that stood out to me:
"If there's one thing I've learned, ma'am, and it's a lesson that cost me dearly, it's that one always has a choice."
(Location 1167, Kindle ARC)
"The time is coming, Mr. McGrath, and in fact is already upon us, when a man will have to boldly stand for what he believes, or everything he holds dear will be taken from him."
(Location 722, Kindle ARC)
"There are moments in my life I wish I could go back and do again, but I can't. Because once a moment is past, it's past. There's no gettin' it back. And this is one of those moments for you. As hard as it is right now, as much as I wish we could stop it and start it all over again . . . we can't. If you don't do this now, Kizzy, you may not get another chance."
(Location 4812, Kindle ARC)
Sad, how the color of one's skin so defined the path of a person's life. Both in freedom for opportunities, and in boundaries.
She prayed, especially in light of the recent war, that it wouldn't always be that way.
(Location 4494 of Kindle ARC)
"The best way to beat somebody is to show them who you are, and to succeed by doin' what they say you can't."
(Location 4824 of Kindle ARC)
To Win Her Favor was full of heartbreak, prejudices, and challenges. It was also full of hope, love, and the joy that comes when you forgive and fully love. It was a beautiful story. Inspiring and heartfelt. One of the best from Alexander yet.
Content: There is some violence and some marital intimacy that was well done. I would consider this clean for the genre.
Source: I would like to thank the publisher, Zondervan, and Author Tamera Alexander for my complimentary review copy through NetGalley, which did not affect my review in any way.
The story had so many different themes. There was forgiveness that had to take place between Maggie and Cullen, between Cullen and Ethan, Maggie and Ethan, and others. Then there was trust that had to be earned and the struggle that these characters went through to really let go. Then the prejudices and those that had to take a stand, those that chose to open their hearts and to love. It was a beautiful story.
There was plenty going on in this story. There was a lot of romantic tension. Probably the most that I've read from this author, especially since it was between a married couple. There was quite a bit of danger and I felt an underlining suspense through the entire story. There was some terrible violence and some things that happened that were very devastating. But the joy. Oh, the joy! The hope. The love that held this story and these characters together was wonderful and it's what balanced out the bad. Those are the things that always do and make life worth living, even when it's hard.
There were several parts that felt like little jewels of wisdom that influenced these characters. Here are some snippets that stood out to me:
"If there's one thing I've learned, ma'am, and it's a lesson that cost me dearly, it's that one always has a choice."
(Location 1167, Kindle ARC)
"The time is coming, Mr. McGrath, and in fact is already upon us, when a man will have to boldly stand for what he believes, or everything he holds dear will be taken from him."
(Location 722, Kindle ARC)
"There are moments in my life I wish I could go back and do again, but I can't. Because once a moment is past, it's past. There's no gettin' it back. And this is one of those moments for you. As hard as it is right now, as much as I wish we could stop it and start it all over again . . . we can't. If you don't do this now, Kizzy, you may not get another chance."
(Location 4812, Kindle ARC)
Sad, how the color of one's skin so defined the path of a person's life. Both in freedom for opportunities, and in boundaries.
She prayed, especially in light of the recent war, that it wouldn't always be that way.
(Location 4494 of Kindle ARC)
"The best way to beat somebody is to show them who you are, and to succeed by doin' what they say you can't."
(Location 4824 of Kindle ARC)
To Win Her Favor was full of heartbreak, prejudices, and challenges. It was also full of hope, love, and the joy that comes when you forgive and fully love. It was a beautiful story. Inspiring and heartfelt. One of the best from Alexander yet.
Content: There is some violence and some marital intimacy that was well done. I would consider this clean for the genre.
Source: I would like to thank the publisher, Zondervan, and Author Tamera Alexander for my complimentary review copy through NetGalley, which did not affect my review in any way.
January 17, 2017
UGH!!!!!!! This started out as such a great read and then..... :( Don't you just hate it when an author takes a GREAT book and then throws something in there that ruins the WHOLE THING! :/ This review has been a long time coming and I've prayed and prayed over it. I was LOVING this book! It is amazing to me how a book can change so drastically. I read other's reviews and waited to see how this controversial turn set with others. You see there are graphic sex scenes added. From what I read, married woman had no problems with this because the characters themselves are married. And yes God created the relationship between husband and wife to be a beautiful and special thing. But as a single, unmarried woman I want to be able to pick up my Christian fiction book and know that there are some things that will not be graphically described, married characters or not. I'm a BIG fan of the fade to black! LOL! These scenes left such a bad taste that I still have not finished the book and don't know that I ever will. And because Tamara decided to add these scenes I find it difficult to continue reading her books, because now I can't trust that the content will be clean. :/
Psalm 61:3
~ASC
*I requested and received this book as a member of Litfuse for the purpose of reviewing it. This in no way affected my opinion and the above are my true thoughts and feelings about To Win Her Favor. ~ASC
http://litfusegroup.com/author/talexa...
Psalm 61:3
~ASC
*I requested and received this book as a member of Litfuse for the purpose of reviewing it. This in no way affected my opinion and the above are my true thoughts and feelings about To Win Her Favor. ~ASC
http://litfusegroup.com/author/talexa...
August 23, 2021
This was really, such a beautiful book. I am impressed with Tamera Alexander’s consistent ability to create stories that have such depth and are so unique. So far, every book I’ve read of hers feels like I’m watching a movie. This particular story was so rich and dealt with some heavy topics but I felt were written very tastefully.
Some have mentioned parts of the book being off-putting regarding the scenes involving intimacy between a husband and wife.
As a single person, admittedly, it was a bit TMI for me but I also see that there was a greater message being conveyed beyond just the romance of it all and it wasn’t about lust. I truly understand & appreciate the story Tamera was telling. All the scenes and scenarios that were created were done so with an intent to tell a sweet, meaningful story about two very different people and their lives intersecting. Additionally, I really appreciate how Tamera always weaves such solid, Biblically sound truths throughout her books. I am always moved by the spiritual wisdom that she conveys.
There were so many sweet characters that were endearing and I loved the heart and emotion, loyalty and care that they all had for each other, especially given the time period in history; so much racism and prejudice but so much love was also portrayed. I don’t know if I am adequately expressing how moving this whole book was but it is well worth the read!!
Some have mentioned parts of the book being off-putting regarding the scenes involving intimacy between a husband and wife.
As a single person, admittedly, it was a bit TMI for me but I also see that there was a greater message being conveyed beyond just the romance of it all and it wasn’t about lust. I truly understand & appreciate the story Tamera was telling. All the scenes and scenarios that were created were done so with an intent to tell a sweet, meaningful story about two very different people and their lives intersecting. Additionally, I really appreciate how Tamera always weaves such solid, Biblically sound truths throughout her books. I am always moved by the spiritual wisdom that she conveys.
There were so many sweet characters that were endearing and I loved the heart and emotion, loyalty and care that they all had for each other, especially given the time period in history; so much racism and prejudice but so much love was also portrayed. I don’t know if I am adequately expressing how moving this whole book was but it is well worth the read!!
May 19, 2015
In To Win Her Favor, Maggie Linden finds herself married to Cullen McGarth as the only way to save her family's storied farm and keep her amazing thoroughbred. Cullen has left Ireland and England behind, only to be confronted with intense prejudice in genteel post Civil War Nashville. The two have to choose whether they can make their marriage more than a business arrangement. The thread of prejudice and running from the past while someone else wants to embrace a different past brings a poignant tone to the book. There's also something so compelling about learning to love two characters who have to choose whether to love.
All in all, this book is perfect for those who love a rich, sweeping historical, with equal parts history and romance.
June 8, 2016
Happy sigh. Another delightful read from Tamera Alexander. She speaks my language.
To Win Her Favor is about Cullen and Maggie and the pervasiveness of racism in Tennessee in the late 1800s. The author paints a descriptive picture of the plantations near Nashville as well as the sport of horse racing. I love how she incorporates characters from her other novels into this one.
I look forward to the third book in the series.
To Win Her Favor is about Cullen and Maggie and the pervasiveness of racism in Tennessee in the late 1800s. The author paints a descriptive picture of the plantations near Nashville as well as the sport of horse racing. I love how she incorporates characters from her other novels into this one.
I look forward to the third book in the series.
February 22, 2022
While this is the second book in the Belle Meade Plantation series, it can most certainly stand alone. While some of the minor characters were in the previous book, you don't need any of their histories to read and enjoy this novel. Set in the years following the civil war, this book paints a bleak picture of what life was like in the south. For the Blacks who were trying to eke out a living as free men, but being denied the opportunity for education and worrying about beatings and lynchings. This book also showed how the war had decimated the population to the point where people were losing their land and homes, which played in well to the major plot line of this book. This book follows Cullen McGrath, who has immigrated to the US and finds racism of a different sort once folks notice that he's of Irish descent. Our heroine is Maggie Linden, whose brothers died in the war and she and her father are set to lose their land. A marriage of convenience seems the only response to both of their conundrums. While a marriage of convenience is one of my preferred romance tropes (as the romance follows the commitment), it also makes for a bit more steam as the couple falls in love. While there was no explicit detail included, this one was a bit more romantically intense than others I've read by this author (but I understood the reasoning). This book had a lot of heart-rending moments and much that had me in tears. I was also appalled by some of the elements of history that I'd not known about, having grown up in the north in an all-white area. One thing I appreciate about historical fiction is the education about history that I didn't get in school. I enjoyed this one quite a bit, but the added steam and heaviness of sorrow in this one keep me from giving it a full 5 stars - I'd say it's more like 4.5. One I'd definitely recommend to fans of historical romance who don't mind a little heavier subject matter.
February 23, 2017
Tamera Alexander has done it again - spun history, romance, and characters into a story so rich you might be tempted to stick it in a vault for safekeeping. Except read it first. And then don't stick it in a vault because it's just a book and people might think you're crazy.
Her perspective on the history of the time period is captivating and vivid, at times shocking in its reality, but ever full of reminders that for all the evil and heartbreak present in mankind at any given moment there are always remnants of God's good to shine in the darkness. The romance swirling around this marriage of convenience is at once breathless for both its joys and its sorrows, and the protagonists are as perfectly matched as a wink and a grin. Even if they themselves would argue that point with me a time or two throughout their journey. To Win Her Favor overflows with characters who are too full of life to be held captive to the pages of a story; they weave their way into your heart by the end of the book and feel like dear friends.
To Win Her Favor may be my favorite book yet by Tamera Alexander! Yes, because of all the reasons I already mentioned (history, romance, characters) but all of her books have those elements to perfection. She's such a gifted author that you really can never go wrong with one of her books. What sets To Win Her Favor apart in my opinion is something I'm (happily) starting to see tentatively making its way into the Christian fiction market - reality. The stark truth of what life looked like post-Civil War for blacks and immigrants in the South. The sweet truth of what a marriage can be like when two people love each other, desire each other and love God. In neither of these cases does Ms. Alexander write more than is needed. She tells us just enough about the blatant discrimination and horrific persecution suffered to break our hearts and rile our anger. We see glimpses of Cullen and Maggie as husband and wife but we always zoom away from their bedroom before things get too intimate. Tamera Alexander has redeemed romance from what can be seen explicitly in so many arenas today, and she has done it sweetly and brilliantly - and she has preserved the sanctity of marriage and the purity of our minds in the process.
Another reason To Win Her Favor is my favorite book of Tamera Alexander's is the vivid characters! Especially Kizzie! I can just see her with her hand on her tiny hip, all that sass and spirit set loose in a pint-sized bundle of cute. Mr. Linden stole my heart as well, though the capturing took a bit longer than it did with Kizzy. My heart melted that last little bit over Maggie's father right about the time Cullen started reading the handwritten notes in Mr. Linden's Bible. Speaking of Cullen... *dreamy sigh*. That accent. That wink. That flirtatious mischievous side to him. That soft tender side to him. All-in-all, pretty much everything you could possibly want in a romantic hero. And Maggie - I really identified with Maggie. (Except for the horse thing - I've never really developed a fondness for them, despite living in horse country for all of my adult life to date.) She's a daddy's girl with a fiercely determined nature, firm opinions, and a surprisingly sensitive heart. And while those firm opinions can keep her grounded, they can also do more harm than good at times. This is a lesson I have had to learn as well over time - and it's one of the main reasons I identified so strongly with Maggie's character. As Cullen says to her at one point, "...when the world you're born in is all the world you've ever seen, it's hard to see it for what it really is." I echo his next sentiment - "Believe me, I know."
I also loved seeing old friends from previous books as they made cameos in this one. Nods like this from the author to her long-time readers make me smile deep in my heart! Speaking of deep-hearted smiles, I am thrilled to learn that one of the characters whose story touched me most in To Win Her Favor (Savannah Darby) will have her own story in a novella included in Among the Fair Magnolias. This collection of Southern love stories written by best-selling historical authors Tamera Alexander, Shelley Gray, Dorothy Love, and Elizabeth Musser is due to be released in July.
Finally, To Win Her Favor touched a chord in me because it takes place during a period in American history that isn't pretty, and Ms. Alexander does not hesitate to show the raw reality of life for immigrants and blacks after the Civil War. They were called horrible names, they were beaten, they were driven from their homes, they were refused service - all because of their nationality or the color of their skin. This is particularly close to my heart because of my work with people in my city's international community. Sadly, this kind of treatment toward immigrants still occurs on some levels - and one only has to turn on the news to see that racial unrest is also still alive and well. To Win Her Favor is so timely for our modern lives, despite being written about a period over 100 years in our country's history.
I give To Win Her Favor 5 out of 5 stars and a place on my favorites list!
Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Read more here: https://readingismysuperpower.wordpre...
Her perspective on the history of the time period is captivating and vivid, at times shocking in its reality, but ever full of reminders that for all the evil and heartbreak present in mankind at any given moment there are always remnants of God's good to shine in the darkness. The romance swirling around this marriage of convenience is at once breathless for both its joys and its sorrows, and the protagonists are as perfectly matched as a wink and a grin. Even if they themselves would argue that point with me a time or two throughout their journey. To Win Her Favor overflows with characters who are too full of life to be held captive to the pages of a story; they weave their way into your heart by the end of the book and feel like dear friends.
To Win Her Favor may be my favorite book yet by Tamera Alexander! Yes, because of all the reasons I already mentioned (history, romance, characters) but all of her books have those elements to perfection. She's such a gifted author that you really can never go wrong with one of her books. What sets To Win Her Favor apart in my opinion is something I'm (happily) starting to see tentatively making its way into the Christian fiction market - reality. The stark truth of what life looked like post-Civil War for blacks and immigrants in the South. The sweet truth of what a marriage can be like when two people love each other, desire each other and love God. In neither of these cases does Ms. Alexander write more than is needed. She tells us just enough about the blatant discrimination and horrific persecution suffered to break our hearts and rile our anger. We see glimpses of Cullen and Maggie as husband and wife but we always zoom away from their bedroom before things get too intimate. Tamera Alexander has redeemed romance from what can be seen explicitly in so many arenas today, and she has done it sweetly and brilliantly - and she has preserved the sanctity of marriage and the purity of our minds in the process.
Another reason To Win Her Favor is my favorite book of Tamera Alexander's is the vivid characters! Especially Kizzie! I can just see her with her hand on her tiny hip, all that sass and spirit set loose in a pint-sized bundle of cute. Mr. Linden stole my heart as well, though the capturing took a bit longer than it did with Kizzy. My heart melted that last little bit over Maggie's father right about the time Cullen started reading the handwritten notes in Mr. Linden's Bible. Speaking of Cullen... *dreamy sigh*. That accent. That wink. That flirtatious mischievous side to him. That soft tender side to him. All-in-all, pretty much everything you could possibly want in a romantic hero. And Maggie - I really identified with Maggie. (Except for the horse thing - I've never really developed a fondness for them, despite living in horse country for all of my adult life to date.) She's a daddy's girl with a fiercely determined nature, firm opinions, and a surprisingly sensitive heart. And while those firm opinions can keep her grounded, they can also do more harm than good at times. This is a lesson I have had to learn as well over time - and it's one of the main reasons I identified so strongly with Maggie's character. As Cullen says to her at one point, "...when the world you're born in is all the world you've ever seen, it's hard to see it for what it really is." I echo his next sentiment - "Believe me, I know."
I also loved seeing old friends from previous books as they made cameos in this one. Nods like this from the author to her long-time readers make me smile deep in my heart! Speaking of deep-hearted smiles, I am thrilled to learn that one of the characters whose story touched me most in To Win Her Favor (Savannah Darby) will have her own story in a novella included in Among the Fair Magnolias. This collection of Southern love stories written by best-selling historical authors Tamera Alexander, Shelley Gray, Dorothy Love, and Elizabeth Musser is due to be released in July.
Finally, To Win Her Favor touched a chord in me because it takes place during a period in American history that isn't pretty, and Ms. Alexander does not hesitate to show the raw reality of life for immigrants and blacks after the Civil War. They were called horrible names, they were beaten, they were driven from their homes, they were refused service - all because of their nationality or the color of their skin. This is particularly close to my heart because of my work with people in my city's international community. Sadly, this kind of treatment toward immigrants still occurs on some levels - and one only has to turn on the news to see that racial unrest is also still alive and well. To Win Her Favor is so timely for our modern lives, despite being written about a period over 100 years in our country's history.
I give To Win Her Favor 5 out of 5 stars and a place on my favorites list!
Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Read more here: https://readingismysuperpower.wordpre...
October 10, 2021
It helps to know this book has lead up to sex scenes, so you aren't blindsided. Marriage of convenience with more detail in that regard than most in the genre, but not problematic for the characters, just for us. Enjoyed the history aspect of this one. The faith message was light, but not bad. My first Alexander book and looking forward to reading more.
April 26, 2015
To Win Her Favor by Tamera Alexander is an engrossing Christian historical novel, and I was blessed to receive a copy. It is the second book in the Belle Meade Plantation novel series, but works well as a stand alone. I have not read the first novel, but I intend to.
Maggie Linden is a born rider and it is her dream to enter her horse, Bourbon Belle into a prestigious race. Her father, Gilbert Linden, recognising that he is in ill health, wants to see his daughter married, and secure on the Linden farm. Cullen McGrath, an Irishman, newly arrived in Nashville wants to buy land and settle down. In the South in the 1860's, Cullen finds that no one will sell to an Irishman, no one but Gilbert Linden, and that is on the understanding that Cullen will marry his daughter.
Dreams are a theme of the novel. Maggie's dream of racing Bourbon Belle has been with her for years. She clings to it, and works towards it with determination. Will she pursue it, no matter what the cost? Or will she lay down her dream for those she loves?
A major theme of To Win Her Favor is that of injustice and racial discrimination. It is the deep South, shortly after the civil war, where slaves who are now freemen are not wanted, and neither are the Irish. Prejudices run through the community, and awful crimes are committed by the cowardly white men, hiding behind their white robes and the shadows of the night. Tamera Alexander draws strong Christian characters who refuse to blend in with the crowd, and will stand up to the racial bullies, even at the risk of losing it all.
Tamera Alexander expands the theme of loyalty and family bonds. Family is not just blood relatives, but it is God's family here on earth. It includes people of different races and skin colours. Gilbert Linden lost four sons in the war, and is determined to see his daughter Maggie provided for, before he enters the grave. Maggie trusts her father, and knows his heart for her, but is less than happy at the prospect of an arranged marriage. This can be like us at times, where we have to trust God's plans for our lives, even though we may think that our plans are better.
The bond between Maggie and her horse Bourbon Belle is beautifully portrayed. Bourbon Belle is not just a horse, but a beloved four legged member of the family. Likewise is Bucket, the family dog. I loved the way that Tamera Alexander included the family pets in the story, showing just how loyal our pets can be to us.
Gilbert Linden calls God, his Father. When Cullen arrives in Nashville, he is angry at God. Will the kind and caring Gilbert be able to lead Cullen back to the Father?
Tamera Alexander is masterful at drawing her characters. They are all realistic, and evoke emotions within the reader. I found myself intensely disliking the characters that I was meant to dislike, whilst being drawn to others. Maggie and Cullen are both strong characters who know what they want. It was pure joy to witness their exchanges of dialogue. My heart was totally drawn towards Kizzy, a young Negro girl, who was totally delightful. I loved the chatter between her and Maggie and Cullen. Tamera Alexander drew Kizzy in such a way, that she bought out the protective spirit in me.
To Win Her Favor was the first novel that I had read by Tamera Alexander, and I will definitely be reading more. I found that all chores were put on hold, and I even slept less as I just could not put the book down! For a totally riveting read, pick up or download a copy today.
Maggie Linden is a born rider and it is her dream to enter her horse, Bourbon Belle into a prestigious race. Her father, Gilbert Linden, recognising that he is in ill health, wants to see his daughter married, and secure on the Linden farm. Cullen McGrath, an Irishman, newly arrived in Nashville wants to buy land and settle down. In the South in the 1860's, Cullen finds that no one will sell to an Irishman, no one but Gilbert Linden, and that is on the understanding that Cullen will marry his daughter.
Dreams are a theme of the novel. Maggie's dream of racing Bourbon Belle has been with her for years. She clings to it, and works towards it with determination. Will she pursue it, no matter what the cost? Or will she lay down her dream for those she loves?
A major theme of To Win Her Favor is that of injustice and racial discrimination. It is the deep South, shortly after the civil war, where slaves who are now freemen are not wanted, and neither are the Irish. Prejudices run through the community, and awful crimes are committed by the cowardly white men, hiding behind their white robes and the shadows of the night. Tamera Alexander draws strong Christian characters who refuse to blend in with the crowd, and will stand up to the racial bullies, even at the risk of losing it all.
Tamera Alexander expands the theme of loyalty and family bonds. Family is not just blood relatives, but it is God's family here on earth. It includes people of different races and skin colours. Gilbert Linden lost four sons in the war, and is determined to see his daughter Maggie provided for, before he enters the grave. Maggie trusts her father, and knows his heart for her, but is less than happy at the prospect of an arranged marriage. This can be like us at times, where we have to trust God's plans for our lives, even though we may think that our plans are better.
The bond between Maggie and her horse Bourbon Belle is beautifully portrayed. Bourbon Belle is not just a horse, but a beloved four legged member of the family. Likewise is Bucket, the family dog. I loved the way that Tamera Alexander included the family pets in the story, showing just how loyal our pets can be to us.
Gilbert Linden calls God, his Father. When Cullen arrives in Nashville, he is angry at God. Will the kind and caring Gilbert be able to lead Cullen back to the Father?
Tamera Alexander is masterful at drawing her characters. They are all realistic, and evoke emotions within the reader. I found myself intensely disliking the characters that I was meant to dislike, whilst being drawn to others. Maggie and Cullen are both strong characters who know what they want. It was pure joy to witness their exchanges of dialogue. My heart was totally drawn towards Kizzy, a young Negro girl, who was totally delightful. I loved the chatter between her and Maggie and Cullen. Tamera Alexander drew Kizzy in such a way, that she bought out the protective spirit in me.
To Win Her Favor was the first novel that I had read by Tamera Alexander, and I will definitely be reading more. I found that all chores were put on hold, and I even slept less as I just could not put the book down! For a totally riveting read, pick up or download a copy today.
April 20, 2015
I own every single book Tamera Alexander has ever written. She is, and will remain, one of my favorite authors. Tamera never, in my opinion, sits down and just writes a fluffy little Christian novel. No, she does impeccable research and takes her time, writing a book that resonates with the mercies and grace of God. She creates characters that will remain with the reader long after the book is closed. This one was no exception, either.
I personally feel this is Tamera Alexander's best book EVER!!! I was completely captivated by it. Cullen McGrath was the best male lead she has crafted in her writing career, in my opinion. I especially enjoyed hos he came back to faith in Christ after so many heartaches and losses. He was kind, thoughtful and faithful in all his ways. Of course, the character of Maggie was also wonderful. I had just never identified with a male lead as much as I did Cullen.
There were so many passages in this book that I flagged with sticky notes. Passages that I knew I would want to go back later and read because they resounded so much within my spirit. It's a rare book that causes me to flip back so often and re-read entire passages and paragraphs. And that is exactly what I did! It's like I couldn't get enough of the depth writtein in these pages.
The book contained so much that ministered to me. It's one of those books that cause you to think so much about what you've read and just doesn't leave you for a while after you finish. You find yourself thinking about these characters off and on throughout the days after finishing the book.
Sometimes when I'm reading a book, a passage or sentence will just grab my attention and this book did just that. I will list it here for it does not contain a spoiler. "And here in the darkness before the dawn, the time that had held some of the loneliest moments in her life, hope struggled to find a foothold." You see, I've been there in that place, struggling to find hope when my husband was given a horrible diagnosis. Laying awake at night, wondering if my prayers would be answered. This just grabbed at my heart so hard and brought tears to my eyes. (In fact, I shed many a tear reading this book!) My husband is fine now. But Tamera Alexander has the ability to make the reader FEEL what the characters are feeling. We go with them during their days and activities and feel like we are just walking alongside them as they go through life. It's an amazing ability and one, I'm sure, Alexander was gifted with by God.
I loved this book so much. Do not miss this one. You will not regret the purchase price. I promise you. I seriously promise you that.
*I was given an advanced reading copy of this book by the publisher in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.
I personally feel this is Tamera Alexander's best book EVER!!! I was completely captivated by it. Cullen McGrath was the best male lead she has crafted in her writing career, in my opinion. I especially enjoyed hos he came back to faith in Christ after so many heartaches and losses. He was kind, thoughtful and faithful in all his ways. Of course, the character of Maggie was also wonderful. I had just never identified with a male lead as much as I did Cullen.
There were so many passages in this book that I flagged with sticky notes. Passages that I knew I would want to go back later and read because they resounded so much within my spirit. It's a rare book that causes me to flip back so often and re-read entire passages and paragraphs. And that is exactly what I did! It's like I couldn't get enough of the depth writtein in these pages.
The book contained so much that ministered to me. It's one of those books that cause you to think so much about what you've read and just doesn't leave you for a while after you finish. You find yourself thinking about these characters off and on throughout the days after finishing the book.
Sometimes when I'm reading a book, a passage or sentence will just grab my attention and this book did just that. I will list it here for it does not contain a spoiler. "And here in the darkness before the dawn, the time that had held some of the loneliest moments in her life, hope struggled to find a foothold." You see, I've been there in that place, struggling to find hope when my husband was given a horrible diagnosis. Laying awake at night, wondering if my prayers would be answered. This just grabbed at my heart so hard and brought tears to my eyes. (In fact, I shed many a tear reading this book!) My husband is fine now. But Tamera Alexander has the ability to make the reader FEEL what the characters are feeling. We go with them during their days and activities and feel like we are just walking alongside them as they go through life. It's an amazing ability and one, I'm sure, Alexander was gifted with by God.
I loved this book so much. Do not miss this one. You will not regret the purchase price. I promise you. I seriously promise you that.
*I was given an advanced reading copy of this book by the publisher in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.
December 7, 2017
I loved this book! It is full of complex characters with faults to overcome. The life lessons that Maggie must learn in this story are many, and she grows so much through the whole novel.
The setting of post-civil war Nashville is the perfect place to showcase the disparity between the classes, as well as highlight the ignorance and prejudice against the newly freed slaves and Irish immigrants. The author did a very good job of exposing the danger and trials these people faced, while not allowing the story to become overly dark. And, of course, Maggie’s care and love of her amazing thoroughbred, Bourbon Belle, was fabulous.
The romance and marriage of convenience thread of the story is definitely for mature readers. I think the scenes between man and wife, showcasing the intimacy of their growing relationship was handled beautifully, although best suited to older readers. In my opinion this was truly one of the best marriage of convenience stories I have ever read. I will definitely be reading this book again in the future!
My thanks to Litfuse Publicity and Zondervan for the complimentary copy of this book that I received in exchange for my review.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
The setting of post-civil war Nashville is the perfect place to showcase the disparity between the classes, as well as highlight the ignorance and prejudice against the newly freed slaves and Irish immigrants. The author did a very good job of exposing the danger and trials these people faced, while not allowing the story to become overly dark. And, of course, Maggie’s care and love of her amazing thoroughbred, Bourbon Belle, was fabulous.
The romance and marriage of convenience thread of the story is definitely for mature readers. I think the scenes between man and wife, showcasing the intimacy of their growing relationship was handled beautifully, although best suited to older readers. In my opinion this was truly one of the best marriage of convenience stories I have ever read. I will definitely be reading this book again in the future!
My thanks to Litfuse Publicity and Zondervan for the complimentary copy of this book that I received in exchange for my review.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
May 7, 2015
I was shocked to see a Christian author going the route of writing books that are explicit and not clean. I've read a few of Tamera Alexander's books in the past and they are so awesome and full of history that I would normally recommend..but this book has just gone a bit too far. Just because it's true to life doesn't mean it can't be written in a less graphic way. I am quite disappointed in this book, and if Alexander keeps writing like this, I won't be reading anymore of her books.
*Disclaimer*
I received this book free from litfuse in exchange for my honest review. I am NOT required to write a positive review, and all opinions expressed are 100% my own.
*Disclaimer*
I received this book free from litfuse in exchange for my honest review. I am NOT required to write a positive review, and all opinions expressed are 100% my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 520 reviews