Four stars because it did touch me emotionally; bringing tears to my eyes in certain parts.
I'm all for diversity in books and have read others that did it subtly. This book knocks you over the head with it and the message starting on page one. In the very beginning paragraphs we learn the main character is Latina or Hispanic, in a relatively new school, tall for her age, and bullied. We also find out she loves horses and volunteers at a horse therapy ranch for physically challenged children (I think emotionally and intellectually challenged as well). I was ready to kick this book to the curb due to the author keeping everything so forcefully in the foreground...then in walked Angel.
Angel was a rescue horse picked up for free by the ranch owners at an auction. She did not look like an angel at first, but Jacinda saw a diamond in the rough. And that's where the author hooked me. I had to find out how Angel would turn out with proper care and love and nutrition.
There will be reviewers who will mark this book down a lot because it is too goody-goody. Honestly, the anti-bullying and how to get along messages really stayed right up front and in your face. I'm glad that the team did have arguments to show they were normal; the arguments were diffused a little too easily, but this is a book for middle readers.
[Spoiler Alert]
Overall the story was good. The only obstacles for the main characters were their arguments and tackling their emotions. There were some hitches in Angel's storyline, but even that resolved itself neatly. almost too neatly. Much of the time I was reading along in anticipation of the other shoe to drop. It's a trope authors like - have a nice happy family and, boom, tragedy strikes. Everytime I saw disaster coming it was averted. Even the minor boom at the end was muffled.
That doesn't mean I wasn't touched. This story was really good at tugging at your heartstrings. Angel's transformation, Jacinda opening her mind about Tori and Posh, Emily overcoming physical limitations, Angel kiss recipient reactions, etc. You bet I was misty eyed.
My one peeve is the relationship Jacinda has with her little sister, Tia. I believe Jacinda is 14 and Tia is 6. Jacinda is outright mean to her sister - won't listen to her, puts down her ideas, pushes her away from activities, etc. The behavior is typical enough of sibling behavior, but it bothers me that no one calls her on it.
One thing this somewhat sugary tale does show more subtly is how every single person has it in them to be a bully with their words. With regards to Emily, even reactions and non-violent actions can be extremely hurtful.
In the end, I enjoyed this book. It's the first in a series and you can sign up to get email newsletters from the author about upcoming books. Will I read more in the series? Probably not. There just was not a deep enough connection to the characters to make me have to read what happens next.